17 ms·
Have an old iPad lying around? You might be able to make it run Linux soon
- rbanffy 4y agoCan’t wait. Seriously. Now we need Tektronix, ReGIS, and Sixel graphics on the Linux graphical console.
- samstave 4y agoPlease ELI5 Why?
- sirius93 4y agoThis is cool.
- masswerk 4y agoIs there anything like this for 32-bit iPads? (I've a pristine example, which has been reduced to an alarm clock, since most websites don't support its browser anymore. Most of the apps have also lost their backend. Certificates are also an issue. The battery is still fine and a charge lasts for more than a month, as it is decoupled from the Internet for the moment. Would be a pity to have to throw it away…)
- ck45 4y agoI'm using my old iPad mini as an ebook reader for tech books. For fictional books, I'm still a happy Kindle user, but I never liked reading technical books esp. with tables or images. Before finding that usecase, it almost ended up as a digital picture frame, which feels like a waste.
- asdefghyk 4y agoIn my "limited understanding " of "web tech"? I thought it may be possible to use some kind of manipulative? and/or filtering? proxy to allow old ipads to use modern websites. This proxy could be remote like on a amazon or some other server somewhere OR as a embedded device that just operated on wifi. My background is as a electronics engineer who worked in embedded software dev ( few years) and then as a software test analysist (many years) . I have several "old" ipads ...
- s800 4y agoYou could use a squid proxy elsewhere to uplift the crypto/cipher/PKI, which would get you browsing the full web again- however, you'd potentially fall victim to an unpatched Safari based exploit. http://www.squid-cache.org http://www.squid-cache.org
- ireflect 4y agoThis is basically what is done in the vintage computer world… https://github.com/tenox7/wrp https://github.com/tenox7/wrp
- e1ghtSpace 4y agoYou might have luck with Qmole. It works on 32 bit devices. https://github.com/chriskmanx/qmole https://github.com/chriskmanx/qmole I think theres a cydia repo somewhere.
- cyberpunk 4y agoMoxie’s sslstrip still works…
- hkgjjgjfjfjfjf 4y ago
- jonnycomputer 4y agoWould be cool if I could install some kind of linux on that old ipad 1 i still got laying around.
- omginternets 4y agoI had the same thought! I don’t know what I’d actually want to do with it, but the tablet form-factor is just begging for some creative attention.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoIt's always fun but then afterward I'm left with a nuked iPad running elinks.
- quag 4y agoThe best use I could find for my iPad 1 is to use it as a clock. It’s a real shame I can’t use it for anything else.
- digisign 4y agoHave a ipad 2 here not turned on in ~five years. It could no longer handle any websites, not enough RAM. Would be great to use it for something, but it has an A5, not A7 or 8, according to Wikipedia.
- sto_hristo 4y agoLatest tablets rock some pretty spectacular hardware. It's so sad that the horrible OSes completely waste all that potential. Why is it so much to ask for a tables with an open OS?
- bitL 4y agoGet a Lenovo M10 X605 and enjoy accelerated video on Ubuntu touch: https://devices.ubuntu-touch.io/device/x605/ https://devices.ubuntu-touch.io/device/x605/ IMO the only tablet that works well on Linux.
- ngcc_hk 4y agoThat sound interesting. Seems quite low on memory and the 3rd generation is 3+128… is only 605 workable. I may give it a trial as it is very cheap experiment. The article mentioned iSH. It is sad that iSH and a-shell both are working but cannot run sbcl … And ecl run but cannot load quicklisp. Hard to be used.
- bitL 4y agoThere is some YouTube video of X606F running on Ubuntu Touch as well but I can't tell what exactly works on that one.
- rollcat 4y agoI don't know if it's wasted. Depends on what you expect out of your computing device. My partner is very happy sketching in ProCreate every day, but she'd find a hackable Linux device much less useful. I'm pretty much the other way around.
- pessimizer 4y ago> she'd find a hackable Linux device much less useful. No she wouldn't. You're not forced to install linux on a linux-capable device.
- sto_hristo 4y ago
- margarina72 4y agoLooks great, I cannot wait for when they will have a working version at least basic so I can give life to a bunch of dead ipad that are otherwise perfectly functional if it wasn't for ios on it...
- judge2020 4y agoI wonder if we could also force the manufacturers of mixing boards and synthesizers to allow us to flash our own linux installations. I bought it but I want to use it for a different use case than what they design and support.
- the_cat_kittles 4y agomaybe my hoarding of old ipads will finally pay off? i have about 40 of them if anyone needs em
- sitzkrieg 4y agohow the heck did you end up with that many
- tylergetsay 4y agomy guess is they make iPad apps
- sitzkrieg 4y agome too but four zero? imagine the rats nest of chargers lol
- munchenphile 4y agoNot the same game, but I used to work as an Android dev for an imaging company. We had to physically test our apps in meatspace with the real device camera and we had to support hundreds of devices. I had hundreds of Android devices hooked to a dozen or so dev machines in a test farm. A test script would run. The active device’s screen would turn green. Then a QA engineer would have to physically scan a bunch of different things. Then the next active device would turn green and they’d do it again. And again. And again. I probably could have automated more with a moving conveyor belt and a custom lighting system, but I would’ve put a lot of QA people out of work… This was during the “bridge” period between android.hardware.camera and android.hardware.camera2, so I had to write a wrapper library bridging the two APIs. About half of our users were on the old API, half on the new. It was a mess. There was no CameraX provided by Google at the time. Obviously Android has way more device diversity, but I can easily see 40 iPads getting accumulated by even a small iOS shop that’s taking their user experience seriously. The company that I worked for was actually quite small, yet we amassed dozens of iDevices and hundreds of Android devices. The CTO would require every camera crash to be fixed, even if it were on a random developing market junk phone. We had so many single-device workaround in the camera wrapper lib it was insane…
- zakki 4y agoOriginal tweet: https://mobile.twitter.com/konradybcio/status/1531963130934329344 https://mobile.twitter.com/konradybcio/status/15319631309343...
- clarge1120 4y agoApple has gotten pretty good at protecting the idevice class from Linux. There are millions of these old devices sitting on shelves unused, still in working condition, and useless. It should not take so much effort to make our devices useful after Apple has moved on from them. There are tons of uses for a capable device after the manufacturer has abandoned the customer. We need Right to Repair now.
- boplicity 4y agoYou may technically own Apple hardware, but its not yours in actuality. You have a "license" to use the software on it, bif of you can't change the software, you don't have control over it. It's not yours. This is how Apple steals from us: They let you buy beautiful, high tech hardware that requires their software. Eventually, they stop supporting that software, so the hardware (mostly) stops working. This is theft. Sure, it may be legal, but morally, it is wrong. So many old iPhones and iPads are languishing, when they could be used as Raspberry Pis (or old laptops) are often used: home servers, learning tools, linux devices etc.
- oneplane 4y agoIt depends on how you see those devices. On one hand it's a block of hardware (like an appliance) on the other hand it's a CPU and RAM and storage etc. This is a weird gradient where the same could be said for routers (and we kind-of do that), but also for Smart TV's (which are left out in the cold, generally), and other devices with smarts in them (or: a CPU, memory and storage). The general problem lies with the utility for mass-market products, even if you re-purpose it, how widely spread can you do that? How feasible are most ideas on what to do with products that are end-of-life? A lot of existing things are just dumped and forgotten about like thin clients, settopboxes (same hardware as Raspberry Pis) and entertainment systems in cars. We like to point at manufacturers and products from well known brands but in reality it applies on a much larger scale, yet the infeasibility scales with it all the same. Some of it might be due to legitimate PKI-based lockouts, while other reasons might simply be the lack of broad interest and governmental policy. In an ideal world the specifications on how the devices work and end-of-life disablement of lockouts would be a reasonable bar to set; it'd be hard to argue that it's bad for commerce, and implementation-wise even PKI-based systems have easy ways to facilitate this. The cost would be enablement from the manufacturer's side and for some brands the connection between their brand name and a device they cannot control the presentation of. I don't know how to solve that but it's definitely a much larger problem than people in tech might think of.
- simonmales 4y agoNot an Apple person but would consider getting an old iDevice if Linux could run realibly.
- neilv 4y agoOne reason it's good for PostmarketOS to support lots of old models of devices well (rather than, say, just new Pine and maybe Purism) is that it avoids the risk of mobile open source Linux failing altogether, should 1-2 device vendors somehow drop the ball. This has happened multiple times before.
- alexklarjr 4y agoI heard that like 2 years ago. Still “soon”. Knowing linux community they will spend another 2 making different “organisations” and then claim “success linux run on ipad!” when it boots with zero devices supported and 90% loss of performance and battery life. Then it will die.
- rvz 4y agoHe's right you know; and it's true. This happened when checkra1n was out and we saw a tech demo with 'Linux' on an iPhone 7 [0]. Then we have it running a Ubuntu GUI on an iPhone 7 a year later. [1] However, want to do this yourself? [2] Follow these straightforward and simple 'prerequisites': First get a cross-compiler, git clone, patch, patch, kernel setup, CONFIG_ABCD=XYZ, make build, DFU blah blah blah and after days of trying to duck tape everything, it still crashes as it only works on an iPhone 7. Nothing has materialised in a straightforward 1 click multi-device install like checkra1n has but for 'Installing Linux' on it. Even 'checkra1n' was supposed to be 'open-source' and that still hasn't happened since. If anything goes wrong or a bug happens then restore everything and start all over again. > Knowing linux community they will spend another 2 making different “organisations” and then claim “success linux run on ipad!” when it boots with zero devices supported and 90% loss of performance and battery life. This is the likely case on what is going to happen. It is still "coMiNg vEry vErY SoOn". [0] https://blog.project-insanity.org/2020/04/22/linux-with-wayland-is-now-running-on-iphone-7/ https://blog.project-insanity.org/2020/04/22/linux-with-wayl... [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/kvmsfd/success_iphone_7_booting_ubuntu_2004_to_full/ https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/kvmsfd/success_iphon... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/kux9xx/success_iphone_7_with_dead_nand_netbooting/ https://www.reddit.com/r/linux/comments/kux9xx/success_iphon...
- reaperducer 4y agoWhile most apps no longer work on the really really old iPads, e-mail still does! I have an old launch day iPad (that makes it over 12 years old) that does just fine for checking e-mail on the couch.
- Syonyk 4y agoWe should be pushing some of the "repair" legislation to include clauses about, "If you're no longer going to provide OS updates for a device, you must provide a way to install alternate firmware on it." We'd either get continued updates for devices, or a way to install something else. Either way is a win.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThis times 1 million
- heavyset_go 4y ago> you must provide a way to install alternate firmware on it. Seems like a common sense measure that shouldn't be conditional on whether or not OS updates stop. PCs have worked this way for decades, and some phones and tablets, as well. It's a shame that competition is limited like this.
- pjmlp 4y agoBy accident, as IBM failed to prevent Compaq's reverse engineering in court.
- Syonyk 4y agoI would certainly prefer that this be the case, but I also don't think it's particularly likely to pass as legislation - because there are plenty of devices that are sold at a loss, expecting to make it up on other later software sales. I believe almost all modern game consoles live in this space, I would expect Amazon's Kindle devices are in this category, etc. And while I don't like this model and won't participate in such ecosystems, neither can I deny that such things are fairly common and popular. Forcing open firmware on those would likely generate a much larger, and, frankly, better funded response to being able to maintain a locked down firmware for the useful life of the system. Picking specifically on the "no longer receiving firmware updates" category makes it much harder for those companies to argue that having to do this will hurt their profits or hinder their ability to recover losses on subsidized hardware - they literally don't care enough to bother updating them at this point, so it would be much harder for them to make these claims. You abandon a device once you're done earning your money back on it. I doubt Sony, for instance, still expects much return on deployed Playstation 3s. And it's exceedingly hard for Apple to argue that they're making any money on an iPhone 3GS or something, because it doesn't even run modern app store packages. So my logic here is that "you must unlock abandoned devices for those who care" is likely to be winnable, whereas "All devices must be unlockable from day 1" isn't.
- olliej 4y agoThere example hardware includes a 2014 era iPad 2 air which per wikipedia is still getting updates? Honestly I find the Asahi linux folk much more interesting, although of course the hardware is actually explicitly open so step 1 for them isn't "get around the device security"
- prvc 4y ago>Linux support could give some of these devices a second life as retro game consoles, simple home servers, or other things that low-power Arm hardware is good for. An iPhone running Linux bare metal with (hopefully) working drivers for its i/o components would have so many possible uses it's not even funny. I guess "other things" is pretty comprehensive, but its using an Arm instruction set is very much besides the point.
- cfontes 4y agoits like a super raspberry pi, I would love to get 3 new pi's out of the blue, with camera, mic, accelerometer, etc...
- pabs3 4y agoNote that this relies on the checkm8 bootrom vulnerabilities, which cannot be fixed on existing devices as the bootrom is physically read-only. AFAIK, there isn't currently an open source exploit for the vulnerabilities. The closest is checkra1n: https://checkra.in/ https://checkra.in/
- earthboundkid 4y agoThey should pass a law that you’re required to support an internet connected device for at least two years, then there’s a three year period where you don’t necessarily have to support the device, but if you don’t, you’re required to release a jailbreak for it. Then after the five years, if you haven’t released a jailbreak, you can’t still sue anyone else who does it.
- robbintt 4y agoI am not sure where the boundary is, but it should be required to not encryption lock your devices from custom firmware/data.
- Gigachad 4y agoThere is some user benefit to this. There is an old saying that when the attacker has physical access, its game over. But modern products are making that less true. Sure if the government has your device you might still be screwed, but the average person can't do anything with a locked iphone like they could a locked Win 7 era laptop. It would be fair to have a locked / unmodifiable initial boot step which shows a visible "unsecured" indication on every boot. If you installed a custom OS you can ignore this, if you didn't, you can worry.
- Gigachad 4y agoApple is at least on the leading edge here by supporting their iPads for 7+ years.
- olliej 4y agoOk, I'm feeling cynical here based on many complaints about support length. People are asking for legislation to allow firmware replacement after X years Why is no one asking for the more basic and obvious one, of just supporting the device for more than 12 months? Like you're never going to get anything meaningful from fly-by-night budget companies that don't even exist for a year, but I was just looking at the big non-apple tablet companies and they all seem to max out at like one year of major updates?
- dredmorbius 4y agoCredit to Apple, their devices do seem to be supported for a long time (5--8 years). Contrast Android, where all but one device I've ever owned was abandoned by the vendor from purchase. The exception is the Onyx BOOX. I've had four updates to that in a year, including one addressing issues I'd reported personally. (Earlier devices were HTC and Samsung. HTC was annoying, Samsung are pathological, and I refuse to touch any of their products ever.)
- sva_ 4y ago> The EU might require OEMs to provide 7 years of updates and spare parts for its phones https://www.gsmarena.com/the_eu_might_require_oems_to_provide_7_years_of_updates_and_spare_parts_for_its_phones-news-50824.php https://www.gsmarena.com/the_eu_might_require_oems_to_provid... I feel like maybe there should be rule such as, either provide x years of software support, or open source it. The best of two worlds.
- Gigachad 4y agoBecause the iPad Air 2 is still getting updated and its almost 8 years old now. There is no need for ipads to be updated any longer than they already are. The non Apple market is just not worth buying. It's cheap junk.
- behnamoh 4y agoI just installed an old clock app and use my ipad 4 as a wall clock!
- abdouls 4y agoThis sounds very cool - I have three iPads with one not being used, would be very interested in doing something like this! Not exactly related to Apple or iPads but this reminds me of running a webserver on an old Android phone of mine. Created a port forward on my modem and used Cloudflare to set a DNS, it wasn't the fastest thing but pretty cool weekend project.
- NKosmatos 4y agoLOL, my only tablet is an iPad Air 2 and still gets some updates, runs most apps and is in a very good condition. Battery isn’t what it used to be, but I can’t complain keeping in mind that my trusty iPad has served me well all this years and has paid off its investment. Nowadays Apple is not making hardware like it used to.
- init-as 4y agoApple is making better hardware than ever. Like your iPad, devices get at least 5 years of updates and will generally run faster every year. Like you said the biggest noticeable difference is in the battery, but this is obviously a much harder problem to solve.
- cube00 4y agoIt will be interesting to see if there's legislation in the future to encourage companies to open up unsupported devices instead of relying on the efforts of enthusiasts to keep them out of e-waste streams.
- eastbound 4y agoSimilarly, software should automatically be open-source after 30 years. The more I grow old, the more I consider that OSS is the 8th marvel of the world. Millions of humans worked independently and created the hugest building of our civilization: Linux/Postgres/MySQL/Wordpress/Audacity/OBS/drivers/Nginx/Owasp/NPM/React/Angular, a stepping stone that powers everything and has even already taken off from Mars (Perseverance’s helicopter).
- scoopertrooper 4y agoI'm now trying to imagine a Mars helicopter solution that encompassed all those technologies in the stack. I could imagine the company I work for coming up with such a solution.
- wrycoder 4y agoLisp, gcc, gdb, pearl, python, apache, mozilla, git, etc.
- tyingq 4y ago>Similarly, software should automatically be open-source after 30 years. I'm not sure how well this might work. It's currently easier for me to resurrect an old Z80 ASM program than to get a node.js V6 program working. Our complicated dependency chains will make future-retro hard.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoI had a similar experience trying to resurrect an old RoR project from the early 2010s. Maybe technically possible, but not the least bit practical… it’d be better to just start from scratch. Meanwhile, I was able to get an early 2000s mac Cocoa project building and running again in just a few hours, with the bulk of the work going into fixing deprecations. The main difference between the two was the number of third party dependencies… the Cocoa app had almost none while the RoR project had several tens when counting sub-dependencies.
- midislack 4y agoIs this just a tech demo or can we download the code?
- tiahura 4y agoThe article suggests the Air 2 doesn’t receive updates. The Air 2 runs iPadOS 15 just fine.
- Mister_Snuggles 4y agoI was just about to say that the Air 2 isn't all that old. According to Wikipedia, it's almost 8 years old. There are two of these in my house. Both are still perfectly usable, the batteries are fine, and it still receives software updates.
- rockyj 4y agoThis is so good. I have a old iPad and a PS3, they work well but I cannot do anything on them. Companies should just let you install Linux on hardware they do not want to support.
- balls187 4y agoYou may recall, the original launch PS3's could run Linux natively. Sony eventually disabled support for it.
- hda2 4y ago> Sony eventually disabled support for it. and got sued for it in the US. People not living in the US got screwed though. We paid for a feature that sony took back. Never bought a sony product since.
- balls187 4y agoAhh yeah, that's right. And I got ~$50 as part of the settlement. I did run Linux on it, but was disappointed when OtherOS did not have access to the RSX chip.
- hda2 4y agoMy siblings and I used the PS3 to play old dos games on the TV via linux/dosbox. We used to play more or less daily until Sony took it away. I still remember my brother being very disappointed.
- GhettoComputers 4y agoDoes anyone turn these old devices into a project and install cool software on it only to never use it again? I stop using multiple devices because having several iPads is as useful as having several phones. I install stuff to “give it a longer life” but without purpose I don’t actually use it.
- Mister_Snuggles 4y agoA number of people in the Home Assistant community use cheap and/or older tablets as wall-mounted control panels. Android tablets are well-represented, including many Amazon Fire tablets, but there are iPads in the mix too.
- Gigachad 4y agoI do suspect its much like Raspberry Pis where people buy them on the thought of doing something with but don't ever get around to it. Still very nice to have the option and if you do actually have a use, you can buy these devices very cheaply second hand. Much cheaper than a pi + touchscreen + battery would be.
- mark_l_watson 4y agoI love it that people have hobbies and interests to do stuff like this. As someone else here said: Apple is pretty good at supporting old hardware. Off topic (sorry): my iPad Pro with the Apple case keyboard and SSH and Mosh clients makes a good enough client for running Linux VPSs. For someone who wants to program on the run with an iPad this solution might cause fewer frustrations.
- highwaylights 4y agoI don’t like saying this, but the way solutions like this are presented makes me really uneasy. I think it’s a laudable effort, and it’s noble that the authors want to reduce e-waste, but I feel like they should make really clear right at the outset that at least some of the features they take for granted are negated by this. I’m thinking most specifically about the integrity and security guarantees around enclaves and official vendor patch support (i.e. the things most users wouldn’t realise were missing and could endanger them). I would assume once this ships it’ll be able to update same as any other linux device (with security and feature patches), but the average user may not realise how much those updates were protecting them. There’s also likely to be a very vulnerable gap between Linux and the hardware elements that will need to remain open because that’s what the exploit relied on in the first place (in this case, checkra1n, if I’m reading it correctly).
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoCan you provide any case studies where enthusiast ports of embedded devices were exploited en masse in the way you seem concerned about?
- highwaylights 4y agoI feel like this is a bad faith argument. Enthusiast ports are already niche, and therefore not lucrative targets. This project has stated that a long term goal is keeping the many iPads that have fallen out of support in service. If they’re successful in that goal, it’s no longer niche, and therefore is more worthy of a target for attacking.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoDo you believe this would ever become mainstream enough for that to happen? Malware on macOS is fairly rare despite a significant market share.
- trasz 4y agoAren't security enclaves used mostly for things like banking apps, instead of the parts of security that actually matter to end users?
- louwrentius 4y agoI have an old iPad 3 - first retina model - and although unsupported for many years, still works fine. It feels like such a waste to dispose of it, especially because of the screen. But running Linux on it is not going to make it live longer, what kind of usability would we have? What remains is repurposing it as some kind of monitor / Dashboard device maybe. Or just return it to apple for recycling.
- johnklos 4y agoOnce Linux is running on these, the BSDs won't be far behind. While there are Linux projects for every conceivable device, they often lose momentum and die off. The BSDs, on the other hand, don't. A NetBSD port for an iPad will stay as up-to-date as for a Raspberry Pi 4, eventually 5, et cetera. Can't wait! A portable ARM device with a good screen and excellent battery life will be quite useful.
- SwampertX 4y agoYou probably meant a portable ARM Linux device; I think it is just difficult to get a team of Linux developers committed to fine-tuning the battery efficiency of the Linux (maybe a specific distro) for the tablet, so I am not hopeful about having an excellent battery life, as much as I would want it to happen.
- emilfihlman 4y agoWhat makes the difference?
- trasz 4y agoMy guess is the approach to development: things that can be fixed get fixed, not replaced. In FreeBSD, for example, rather fundamental changes get introduced when necessary - compare FreeBSD devfs with a... somewhat 1970's approach used in Linux - but they don't happen "just because".
- bbbobbb 4y agoUnfortunate that only 'old' iPads. I would like that fir my 2020 one. The OS is complete trash in my opinion and it is the first and last Apple device I have bought.