12 ms·
The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free (2009)
- falcolas 4y agoA small, mildly entertaining, anecdote about soda: When Oracle acquired the company I was working for, they made the soda free. That is, Oracle made the soda dispensing machines simply dispense soda when you pressed a button. The same company that had a self-service "I Quit" page. Free soda is an indicator about how a company treats its employees, but perhaps not the best.
- wolverine876 4y agoI had a client that stocked kitchen fridges with free basic foods - drinks, meats, breads, etc. - and quality, healthy stuff too. That always impressed me, sending a simple, strong message that they cared about their employees and people like me, and it had a positive impact on me when I ate my share (and didn't have to worry about taking time to get lunch). At one point they brought in a relatively large team of contractors to work day and night on a critical, time-sensitive project. A week after the team started I was there, talking casually to the manager. They told me that there were complaints that they were running low on food in the fridge because the contractors were eating it too. What would they do? Ban the contractors, with only arms-length loyalty to the business, working day and night, and on whom the business's fortunes depended, from the kitchens.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y ago> At one point they brought in a relatively large team of contractors to work day and night on a critical, time-sensitive project. To me that is a huge red sign that something is seriously wrong with the company. Bringing in a bunch of new people and having them work long hours does not seem conducive to good code.
- mlyle 4y agoNot everything is permanent code that has to be maintained forever. Sometimes you have a migration, or a bunch of data to suck in one time from a vendor or acquisition, or whatever. You can run appropriate quality checks to bound the error rate.
- ReactiveJelly 4y agoBut sometimes the most permanent code is the "just once" code.
- wolverine876 4y agoIt wasn't an IT company.
- ls15 4y ago"Be my guest, but don't touch the food!"
- philwelch 4y agoThere's a lot of talk on Twitter the last couple of days about how this is apparently a cultural norm for house guests in Nordic countries!
- na85 4y agoI mean if an electrician or whatever came into my house to do a job, and ate my food without being offered it, I'd consider that extremely rude.
- Nextgrid 4y agoScale and context matters. The loss of a single food item in your own house has a much larger impact than the loss of a single food item in a kitchen stocked to feed dozens of employees - in the former case, your lunch disappeared but in the latter case there's just one less pack of crisps in a box of 100 that nobody will even notice and the positive impact of that (in terms of morale, especially for regular contractors) outweighs the 50c the pack of crisps costs.
- cgriswald 4y agoFor the curious, here is the reddit thread and comment that seems to have started it: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/uxz68j/what_is_the_weirdest_thing_you_had_to_do_at/ia1ji6z/?context=3 https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/uxz68j/what_is_t... > @Wowimatard > I remember going to my swedish friends house. > And while we were playing in his room, his mom yelled that dinner was ready. And check this. He told me to WAIT in his room while they ate. > That shit was fucking wild.
- klipt 4y agoSo what do Swedish guests do - bring their own food to others' houses, or just always leave before mealtime?
- tomrod 4y agoAccounting/PeopleOps meets the Real World! Great anecdote. The free meals are a perk paid for by the people creating the revenue. I suspect that perk probably wasn't budgeted for addition to the Contractor work. An oversight, perhaps? Hopefully folks working got fed.
- voidfunc 4y agoIs Oracle all that bad of a place to work? Everyone _hates_ Oracle for product reasons but I've never met any engineers that said it was a terrible place to work or particularly worse than any other big tech b2b companies (e.g. ibm, microsoft, etc).
- arebop 4y agoEvery ex-Oracle engineer I've met says it was a terrible place to work compared to the big tech company where I work now. I also don't know anyone who went to work for Oracle after leaving my current company, fwiw.
- volkadav 4y agoit strongly depends on which org you're in, with an average of "boring, with a big steaming pile of bureaucracy" based on my observations spending five years at the seattle-based cloud org. if you had a good manager and skip-level stuff could be pretty alright, if you didn't god help you.
- falcolas 4y agoThis. If you have a good manager, and your project doesn't span across orgs, you have a ton of freedom. Crossing orgs creates red tape you wouldn't believe, since such requests "must go through Larry's office". They also have an absolutely stellar health plan - I know of one (US) employee whose spouse got cancer, and they didn't pay one penny out of pocket for the entire treatment.
- thebean11 4y agoI don't think that's out of the ordinary. With most big tech health plans you'd probably pay little or nothing if you stayed in network.
- rst 4y agoImmediately after the Oracle/Sun acquisition, there was a huge exodus of senior engineering talent (e.g., most of the core Solaris kernel development team). This writeup of why James Gosling left has some of the obvious reasons (e.g., he was asked to take a significant pay cut), but also this anecdote, showing Oracle managements' general attitude toward the talent: https://www.eweek.com/development/java-creator-james-gosling-why-i-quit-oracle/ https://www.eweek.com/development/java-creator-james-gosling... [quoted]: Making his point about the “creepiness,” not only with Ellison but with Oracle’s power structure, Gosling said he sparked a notion to try to improve morale amongst the Sun faithful who endured the Oracle acquisition. He said the company decided to rent out the Great America amusement park in Santa Clara, Calif., and allow the Sun folks to have a day of fun. Scott McNealy and Sun CEO Jonathan Schwartz signed off on the project that came in well under budget and all systems were go, Gosling said. Except a few days before the event was to occur, Oracle Co-President Safra Catz got wind of it and put the kibosh on the thing. “Safra found out and had a fit,” Gosling said. “The word came down that Oracle does not do employee appreciation events. So she forced the thing to be cancelled. But they didn’t save any money because the money had been spent – so we ended up giving the tickets to charities. We were forced to give it up because it wasn’t the -Oracle Way.’ On the other hand, Oracle sponsors this sailboat for about $200 million.”
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cptnapalm 4y agoSelf-service "I Quit" page... that's... wow...
- mberning 4y agoIt’s not that rare. Many large companies have an HR portal and one of the many options is usually to “end your employment”.
- throwaway284534 4y agoI assume the form has some dissuading text along the lines of, “Upon submitting, a goon squad will be sent for your immediate removal from the premises.” Or maybe they just send spiders through the ethernet. It’s a big company.
- falcolas 4y agoWith 200,000 employees (at my time of employment), they couldn't care less about turnover. Acqui-hires and people wanting a working retirement keep Oracle afloat in the tech department. Realistically, if you weren't on the Oracle DB development team and didn't draw too much attention to yourself (for example, via daily reimbursed meals at elite restaurants accompanied by the best wines for years on end), you didn't really matter.
- falcolas 4y agoSomewhat ironically, it was the only way to do it. If you tried to talk to your manager, they would direct you to the self-help page. There were just too many scripts tied to it - from disabling your access to notifying your manager to setting an end date in their payroll system. There were legends of folks who failed to press the button, and were being paid for years thereafter. While I imagine a kernel of truth is here, I can only shake my head at the thought of Oracle's lawyers getting ahold of the ex-employee in question.
- RajT88 4y agoI worked for a post-startup company early in my career. The Christmas parties were awesome, my first few years there included parties at the Shedd Aquarium and the Field Museum. There were subsidized vending machines as well. I knew engineers who would spend a dollar on the vending machine and get a few bags of chips for lunch. Subsidized vending machines were the first to go. Then the Christmas parties. Then a bunch of other changes which showed derision for customers and employees both.
- dang 4y agoRelated: The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30173379 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30173379 - Feb 2022 (1 comment) The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27445943 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27445943 - June 2021 (3 comments) The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free (2009) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19690250 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19690250 - April 2019 (2 comments) The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16801710 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16801710 - April 2018 (2 comments) The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free (2009) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13134712 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13134712 - Dec 2016 (69 comments) The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free (2009) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5751329 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5751329 - May 2013 (390 comments) The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1007750 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1007750 - Dec 2009 (226 comments)
- raccer 4y agoHoly moly, first thread summary I've seen, very cool! Is this an automatic thing now? (assuming url match I suppose)
- ColinWright 4y agoI used to do this a lot, but I've given up. I used to run a 'bot to do it, but I got a lot of pushback and discontinued. Dang is a moderator, and he does it when he thinks it's useful. I suspect he does it "by hand" but, like me, has written scripts to help. Given that your account was created 12 years ago I'm a little surprised that this is the first thread summary you've seen.
- dang 4y agoYes - I wrote software that makes it fast to do by hand. You'd certainly be welcome to resume! I think including the date + number of comments is the important bit, plus not pointing to threads with zero comments - but IIRC you had both of those features. Edit: one fun fact – it's surprisingly difficult to post links to past threads without coming off as somehow reproaching the latest submitter for posting a duplicate. In reality, HN allows reposts after about a year (and this is in https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html), but many people don't know that and interpret the list of past threads as an implicit criticism, which is a shame. I've tried out a bunch of different wordings trying to minimize that misunderstanding. The simplest one seems to be the most effective - I just say "Related". Somehow the word "related" sounds less like a criticism. It also has the nice property of being inclusive, so for example it's fine to include other articles on the same topic. One of these years, I still want to build software support for collecting related URLs and related past threads into HN's official UI. Then we can all build up sets of related things collaboratively. That will hopefully make HN more interesting.
- incanus77 4y ago> All these engineers were still heads-down, working their tails off, just as they had been doing since the first few months of the company. Too busy working, most were oblivious to the changes that success and growth had brought to the company. This gets at the vague steps that the author mentions at the end about supporting transitions of _people_, but I was waiting for them to get concrete about how the engineers should have _positively_ been made aware of the success and growth. Pay raises to market rate? A bonus? I’m guessing that in actuality, it was little more than verbal pats on the back. I guess it’s different for each company culture, but this makes it sound like the engineers worked hard, the company got solid, things were taken away, and then the superstars started to leave. I’ve seen similar patterns a few times. What are some positive ways that people have seen these patterns fought?
- ftlio 4y agoBased on how I've seen it mismanaged, the only way I see it working is hiring "provisional VPs". In the same way that you might have hired slow and fired fast in the beginning for competent ICs, you need to do the same with the now executive management skillset that's required to break off and scale whole divisions of the working organization. The other side of that is you need to equip them with the actual subset of the talent they need, and not hold back some employees who were there in the beginning for special considerations. The ICs have been there for years, knife fighting with the market and the competition, and then someone comes in from some adjacent market or some other vertical entirely, and the expectation is that all the work done to go from zero to one needs to be fit to their agenda, and not the other way around. Everyone who has lived it knows its backwards, and yet I've seen the trigger get pulled on this so slow that it had a measurable effect on the exit.
- dzdt 4y agoI wonder about the "unintended consequences" takeaway here. Correlation is not causation. It seems to me that the talented startup engineers leaving and the decision to discontinue free soda don't likely have a causal relationship between them. Just both are things that happened along the growth path from startup to established company. More of a common cause explanation. If they had kept giving free soda would it have really kept the engineers from leaving? I have doubts.
- wolverine876 4y agoHmmm ... anything is possible. You don't offer any evidence for your hypothesis and by that standard, anything is possible. The OP was there, at the company, saw what happened, and has observed several other similar circumstances.
- thayne 4y ago> The sodas were just the wake-up call. It probably wasn't just the sodas, it was probably a culmination of a lot of changes, and the sodas were the straw that broke the camel's back.
- ajuc 4y agoIt's a combination of things - if company takes away benefits and provides no new benefits - you as an engineer lose money. Meanwhile in current market just changing the company means a rise. Why settle for an effective salary cut when you can trivially get a rise instead? The difference between no rise and cut is huge mentally. Additionally if the company saves money on such a small scale it sends the signal things are BAD.
- freetime2 4y agoI could see myself being really upset by this change. It’s not just about the cost of the soda - it’s also about convenience. Now if I want to have a soda at work I need to remember to keep change or small value bills in my wallet. And if one day I forget then I need to leave the building in search of a treat, or else just go without - in either case I’m annoyed. And more than that it’s about feeling valued and respected. It can be really upsetting when something you’ve gotten used to is taken from you. Especially when you know the cost to the company is just a tiny fraction of the overall operating budget, and unlikely to make any significant difference to the bottom line. Interestingly at my first job that I worked at, sodas weren’t free, and it never really bothered me. But if they had been free, and one day stopped being free, that would annoy me. I think there is an asymmetry between the satisfaction people get when they use a perk, and they dissatisfaction they get if you take it away.
- CWuestefeld 4y agoI wonder how we got a cultural thing where coffee is usually expected to be provided free, but other beverages fall into a different class. I assume that if it was provided from dispensers like at McD's, it would be similar in expense to coffee.
- gwbas1c 4y agoWhen I worked for Intel, the coffee was absolutely not free. The only freebies were filtered water and toilet paper. It never bothered me that much, but when I joined a company with freebies, it was like a breath of fresh air.
- ajross 4y agoCoffee is free at Intel. Or was, back when people worked in offices.
- selimthegrim 4y agoNot if you're a green badge it isn't.
- ajross 4y agoContractors don't get perks like that anywhere, thanks to Vizcaino v. Microsoft. Withholding resources afforded to permanent employees is weird and counterintuitive, but it's how employers demonstrate compliance.
- gwbas1c 4y agoI think a lot of that changed after I left. (In 2005-2007) It just felt petty to have to use a coffee vending machine.
- NtGuy25 4y agoRecently joined a company with legit soda machines(the fancy ones with exotic stuff like cream sodas), slim jims, ice cream, cookies, cakes and which buys lunch for the engineers every weekend. It's amazing. I came from a place where you had to pay 2 $ for a soda! It's definitely one of the things that you don't realize when you don't have it, but when you do it's like heaven. It's really helped me get more work done since I can snack away and it encourages me to get up for walks around the office.
- cbsmith 4y agoI don't see it as unintended consequences of Soda Not Being Free. It's an attribution mistake, not entirely different from how SEM tends to get attribution for conversions it didn't really earn. The Elves leaving is unintended consequences of the company getting larger, and not finding a way to manage it in a way that retained top talent. The soda exposed it, but it was going to get exposed one way or another.
- marcosdumay 4y agoIt's not attribution mistake, it's a proxy variable. Nobody ever though people left because of the soda.
- dsr_ 4y agoOr, if you prefer, it's one piece of evidence that is easy to measure.
- cbsmith 4y agoRight... and so consequently what is gained by hiding the evidence?
- cbsmith 4y agoAs a proxy variable, it's a proxy for things that were already true, they just hadn't realized it yet. It's like how there's a lot of turnover after bonus season. The bonuses aren't the reason they're coming/going (though they're often shaped significantly by the real underlying reasons they're coming/going), but they do effect the timing of their coming and going... because that's the point where it becomes impossible to ignore the underlying reasons for the turnover.
- rodgerd 4y agoIt's a general problem of being, as the Brits put it, "penny wise, pound foolish". Some bod in accounts can show an obvious change in the bottom line by cutting a cheap perk. The problems in retention, hiring, delivery are all someone else's problem and much harder to quantify.
- Animats 4y agoIt's worth watching the little stuff. When you see a retail establishment with a partly burned out sign, and it doesn't get fixed quickly, you know they're in trouble.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoThere are plenty of shitbox stores making tons of money though.
- rootusrootus 4y agoMaybe it pays to have an image of not wasting money looking pretty.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoI have wondered similar. Tradies need clean and tidy vehicles to present an image of competence, organisational skill and attention to detail. But if they were to start turning up in a Porsche Cayenne it might signal they cost too much. Fine line in image management.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoCertain businesses and situations allow for the owner to squeeze as much money out as possible. Image doesn't really play into it or is unnecessary. Captive markets, knowing an eventual sale of the land will be a windfall, etc.
- moate 4y agoI'll mention that to the bodega owner in town who's been in business longer than I've lived here. I'm sure it will get a chuckle.
- justin66 4y agoIt's the deviation from the norm that's a potential warning sign. You'd know the cool bodega might be in trouble, with a lame new owner or something, if the sign got fixed or a bunch of painting was done...
- gwbas1c 4y agoI remembered once working at a large corporation with deep pockets, and lots of people with (cough) questionable value to the company. As soon as we hit a recession there were cries to cut back on the free food and sodas. It sent a very wrong message to me, as many of the people I interacted with on a daily basis were horrible in their jobs. It seemed that pausing hiring recs and a few well-targeted severance packages would have saved more money than cutting back a few freebies.
- gowld 4y agoWell-targeting severance is hard to do.
- mwigdahl 4y agoSimilar story -- back when I worked at a physical engineering company, one of their cost-cutting methods when things got tight was to cut down the amount of time they ran the A/C during the day. This applied to all floors of the building except the one where the partners' offices were. This led to a number of people routinely using their breaks to take the elevator up to the "partners' floor" and cooling off / airing their sweaty BO for the bosses' benefit.
- gav 4y agoI think that these cost-cutting schemes never really work out, they either cause the best people to leave or trade money for work-done. I worked for a bank where they had terrible coffee on our floor. We used to joke about how bad it was until one day these fancy automatic machines showed up that ground the coffee for each cup, they even had milk! Times were good, we'd walk over to somebody's desk--"I'm running a build, do you want to grab a coffee?"--and we'd chat in the break room about how great these new machines were. Then we had a couple of quarters in a row with bad numbers, cutbacks were being made, if we do this then we don't have to have layoffs, etc. We lost our fancy machines. The impact to morale was huge, we only had had them for a couple of months, taking them away once we got used to them was a huge deal. But more importantly, most people on our floor were now used to drinking partly-decent coffee. A couple times a day we'd go to the nearest coffee shop and buy our own, which involved walking to the elevator, waiting, going 23 floors to the lobby, badging out, walking across the street, getting coffee, walking back, badging in, waiting for the elevator, going up 23 floors, then finally back to your desk. This had to waste at least 20 minutes, more if the elevators were busy.
- lordnacho 4y agoMy reading of it is that it isn't the soda, it's having the bean counter become an authority that can make decisions. If you work day and night to get a product out, and then a CFO slides in above everyone on the team, and on top of that they're a cheapskate, that sends a signal.
- the_af 4y agoWell, the article spells out that it wasn't really about the sodas: > The engineers focused on building product never noticed when the company had grown into something different than what they first joined. > The sodas were just the wake-up call.
- hinkley 4y agoThere is a large cage here. The weathering suggests that it may have been here for a long time. There is a large sign next to the cage. There is a stick on the ground. > read sign The sign says, DO NOT POKE THE BEAR > get stick You pick up the stick. > poke bear with stick Despite your better judgement, you poke the bear with the stick. The bear rouses from its sleep. > poke bear with stick With a terrible roar, the bear turns on you. Reaching through the bars, it tears your arm off. There is an arm laying here, holding a stick.
- Fnoord 4y agoAlthough Luke did not lose his arm in wampa cave on Hoth (he lost it at Cloud City) he could've gotten a new one at the Redemption which was stationed at Hoth at that time. Ontopic: I wouldn't give a shit about soda or free soda, but coffee and tea is always free here for employees in my country (quality may differ!). I simply would not work for a company which wouldn't feat this. So the social norm defines it and keeps its own behavior status quo. That's also a reason why its difficult to get rid of smoking/smokers tobacco in society
- the_af 4y agoI'm not entirely sure what you're trying to say here (who is the bear, the employees or the company?) but anything related to text adventures / interactive fiction has my immediate upvote!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- givemeethekeys 4y agoYou get what you pay for. Hire an accountant? They'll ask questions, refer to the team etc. Hire a CFO? They've been hired to make an impact. Few companies are good at promoting from within.
- HollywoodZero 4y agoI used to be in a management role a number of years back and faced this same issue. Thankfully I was able to convince executive management that for our several hundred employee company, running a Coke soda machine was basically the cost of 1 Tech Support headcount. That's it. One of the most popular in-office perks, the Coke freestyle machine was 1 tech support headcount. That was years ago. And we still have that machine.
- wolverine876 4y agoYes, it's a cheap employee morale device. How much do the alternatives cost? > for our several hundred employee company, running a Coke soda machine was basically the cost of 1 Tech Support headcount It cost you $50-100K/yr to run a Coke machine? Maybe I'm misunderstanding something!
- Tade0 4y ago$100k divided by several hundred employees and a year's worth of workdays equals a few bucks per person per day at maximum. Last time I had this perk I was downing at least four sodas a day - same ballpark.
- titanomachy 4y agoJesus. That can't be good for you.
- Tade0 4y agoIt wasn't! Additional weight and cavities followed shortly.
- astrange 4y agoIt might also cost you in dental benefits.
- devchix 4y agoTo present an alternate point of view, I never grokked this idea of free soda, free food, catered lunches, sleeping pods, dry-cleaning, massages, ping-pong table as a way to attract talents. If I took a risk to work for a startup, I want a lean machine that pays me in ridiculous cash or ridiculous options, and obscene milestone bonuses. The only thing I think I'd really care about is "bring your dog to work" and "onsite/nearby child-care", there's no substitute or purchasing-equiv to that. A startup is an intense high-stress environment where focused work and time is invaluable; none of those "perks" directly drive the goals, if anything they seem hedonistic distractions from the goal.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoI think the point of supplying food and drink on-premises is exactly that, to foster "focused work and time " The objection isn't so much the price then put on the food and drink. It's the conversion of 'valued employee' to 'hourly crank-turner'. No longer a valued critical member of a team, now the corporation regards you as a 'resource'. E.g. did the executive perks disappear too? No? Now you know what pigeonhole you've been placed in (demoted to).
- probably_wrong 4y agoI like the explanation from this article [1] titled "Why perks matter": because perks like that avoid context switches and remove "distractions and other things which could disrupt [my] flow". As a human being who regularly needs to eat, not having to worry about having the right amount of snacks and/or change at hand can make or break my day. Trying to code while hungry is a waste of everybody's time and money, which is how free food pays for itself. And don't get me started on trying to code when all you really want is a nap... [1] https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2012/11/16/context/ https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2012/11/16/context/
- rootusrootus 4y agoI thought I remembered reading somewhere that Google (or some company in a similar position) had worked out the math and figured that the free meals more than paid for themselves in increased productivity (or at least seat time) because employees weren't getting up to go off-site to find lunch. As often as not they'd be quickly back at their desk coding away.
- rootusrootus 4y agoWe had something akin to this happen at my company. For context, this is a well established mid-sized company with around 5000 employees. Some beancounter decided that they could no longer afford to subsidize the plastic spoons in the break rooms. So they announced that when the current stock ran out, they would not be replacing it. The backlash was pretty strong. Not because engineers can't afford plastic spoons of their own, or some other alternative, but because it was such a petty thing. These spoons come in cases of 1000 for under 10 bucks, so nobody can argue with a straight face that it was about the cost. I don't know that anyone actually quit over it, but it leaves a sour taste in your mouth.
- conradfr 4y agoThey should have said it was to save the planet.
- jmharvey 4y agoThis reminds me of a startup CFO I worked with, who could see the big picture. In the early days of the company, they worked in an office that shared a bathroom with a half dozen other companies. And the toilet paper in said bathroom was terrible. Like, not just standard-office-building terrible. Really, really bad. So CFO takes it upon himself to rectify the situation. He orders a couple dozen rolls of standard-issue "premium" office toilet paper (still not that great relative to home-use TP, but good by office standards) and leaves it in the bathroom. Two days later, it's gone: someone (not clear whether it was someone at the startup or one of the neighboring companies) decided to take it home with them. Everyone in the office starts grumbling about the state of the TP situation again. Not to be outdone, CFO places another order; several cases this time. And it takes a few more days, but sure enough, it all disappears. At this point, CFO is fed up. He orders two full pallets of TP. After lunch one day, several volunteers unload the toilet paper. Multiple stacks, floor to ceiling, in the bathroom. More stacks in the supply closet. Stacks in the hallway. Stacks in the lobby. Everywhere you look, there's toilet paper. And if people were stealing TP after that, it wasn't at a rate that anyone could notice. Including the ongoing costs for the subsequent 18 months until they moved out of that building, the "unlimited TP" policy might have cost the company $10k. But it bought a lot more than that in terms of employee goodwill. Knowing that the bean counters are focusing on "our employees are producing a product worth $x; let's figure out how to have them do more of that" makes a big difference.
- analog31 4y agoThe cynic in me wonders if management and the soda industry colluded to make free soda a symbol of something deeper, namely, management pretending to care about their workers. Come for the free soda, and stay for the open plan offices and Agile Scrum meetings. I once read an article, I think in the Wall Street Journal, about Levi-Strauss sending out promotional materials to HR departments about how to set up "Casual Friday" at the workplace. It was a promotion for their Dockers brand.
- snapetom 4y agoMy favorite story of "unintended consequences" of belt-tightening like this was when I worked at a startup about a dozen years ago. We did well for a few years, but it was clear to people we were reaching a point of market saturation. Nevertheless, the CEO kept agreeing to doubling of sales revenue year after year. Well, no surprise, the last year before big layoffs, we were way off on sales goals. The CEO announces we have to "put our heads down." Pretty much the main change enacted was no more ping pong. The problem is that were really only two guys constantly in the ping pong room. Those two guys just happened to be the two most senior sales guys, and the only two that were meeting quota. They both left about a month after this and not-so-slyly told the CEO he was an idiot.
- throwaway123x2 4y agoMan how out of touch do you have to be to do that.
- anitil 4y agoI've seen companies reduce top-performing sales people's commission because it was "costing too much money". So the good sales people left and the company didn't have that problem (of making lots of money) anymore.
- g5095 4y ago2008 GFC, startup of 25 (15 dev), everyone drops to 4 days a week, the newly hired 'CEO' drops 5k on a top of the line laptop for himself to basically run Outlook and Solitaire after telling everyone they were cancelling 'birthday cakes' (which the staff mostly pitched in for anyway). RIP entire company.
- Tade0 4y agoIt never actually bothered me that we had a CFO in any of the organisations I worked at. I like having a clear situation regarding who's financing what - especially when it comes to business trips. A HR manager where there was none previously is a whole other story though.
- DancesWTurtles 4y ago> No one on the board or the executive staff was trying to be stupid. But to save $10,000 or so, they unintentionally launched an exodus of their best engineers. Maybe the insight here is "keep your engineers happy, it's important". But I believe there is more to it on this story. The engineers heard "we could give you soda when we were small, now we're big, we cannot give you soda" and, to the rational mind, that makes no sense. Maybe they left because they were sitting on a precarious equilibrium and the free sodas tilted the balances. But I think it was also that the engineers saw the sign on the wall, and thought "this guys have lost their collective corporate mind, let's bail before they have any more bright ideas".
- stonogo 4y agoWhat part of "free soda doesn't scale" is irrational? I get that it signals a change in management priority -- specifically a change away from prioritizing staff and toward prioritizing money -- and I'd probably leave too. But I don't see how you have to lose your mind to achieve that perspective.
- drewcoo 4y ago> What part of "free soda doesn't scale" is irrational? All of it. Free soda for 10 people is hard. They have different tastes. There are too many things to keep enough refrigerated at the same time to make sure you hit soda rush times of the day. And you're probably running to a local grocery store, at least sometimes, to make sure you don't run out. With 100 people, you've probably settled into something more standardized, no more special Puerto Rican pineapple soda for that one person with the interesting tastes. Everything can be delivered by the same one or two vendors. You know roughly how much you need and when - much more predictable. And you have more fridges now, constantly stocked with more soda. Moreover, the free soda now costs less per person. Etc.
- simmerup 4y agoThe only problem with free soda for a big corp is that people are more likely to take the mick and take more than their fair share, as they’re less likely to feel obligated to the company to be reasonable.
- phendrenad2 4y agoIf you study this story carefully, you'll notice that it wasn't a case of "new CFO was an idiot". The ENTIRE BOARD, including some experienced VCs, agreed that they were "too big for that now". My analysis: What does "too big for that now" mean? Does it mean that they can't afford it? I doubt it. They were still going to sell the soda "cheap" (presumably 25-50% of the normal soda cost). So what was it? My theory is "big" ISN'T a synonym for "large-scale" here, but instead is a synonym for "professional". Why is free soda a negative indicator of professionalism? And to whom? I think that once you reach a certain level (non-startup or series-Z-startup), investors expect you to be extremely bean-countery. So the ultimate source of this problem is mega-scale investors which want to see a tight ship. The board was likely feeling pressure from them before the CFO was ever hired.
- cbanek 4y agoThis reminds me of when Microsoft stopped offering the free towel service. In the buildings with large bike racks, there were locker rooms with showers. Normally they would have a free towel service so you didn't have to bring your own, like a gym. But then one year they said that they were spending too much money on it compared to the number of people using it. There was a huge uproar. Then again, if it had been the free sodas, it would have been a mutiny. I remember when they got rid of the spicy v8 and a mutiny was considered, but declined.
- kcplate 4y agoMy hackles would always raise when the company started buying the cheapest coffee available for the break room. Usually meant a buyout was coming.
- dennis_jeeves1 4y agoMoral of the story: (senior) engineers should have power to overrules the bean counters if needed.
- morelisp 4y agoI've been around long enough to see this cycle through twice before, but it still rankles how stupidly myopic it is every time. Beginning this year we're no longer allowed to have the company pay for an in-office team lunch without pre-approval of each individual time from a 3-skip manager, who's in a department that might as well be a different company. At the same time they want to mandate 60% return-to-in-office time. The actual leads had all ability to incentivize people to come back cut off, and know reactions are going to range from work-to-rule through quit.
- timwaagh 4y agoThis myth about the free drinks has been repeated so many times... I don't know if it's actually a myth but it's really getting old.
- tushar-r 4y agoThe 2008 recession was especially fun because of bean counters. Some of the big Indian outsourcers used this to remove all sorts of things from the office stating "we can save money with these things and avoid layoffs." Among things that were removed at the outsources I worked at? Paper towels in the bathroom were removed in favour of the hand drying machines.