25 ms·
Food security and the coming storm
- h2odragon 4y agoAnother: https://jeffreycarter.substack.com/p/no-one-is-talking-about-this?s=w https://jeffreycarter.substack.com/p/no-one-is-talking-about... Few seem to want to talk about this, they want to talk about how coming shortages will best be solved by giving them power or at the least listening to their advice. For all the "Baby formula shortage" media coverage, how many stories have included a recipe for alternatives to commercial formula? Mostly I've seen admonitions to not try making baby food at home, which is incredibly useless for people trying to feed kids. I'm seeing fields choked with weeds, because the Crop Production company that leases the land decided they're doing half a "no till" planting this year without herbicide; because that'll get them their crop failure insurance payment. I suspect they will bail on some of next year's leases or at least lower rates because of reduced fertility, too. "Fertilizer export restrictions" started happening last fall; this was all visible writing on the wall well before Ukraine got invaded. It sounds "conspiracy theorist" to say there's a plan in operation; but it's hard to say that there is not.
- gatlin 4y agoI would be interested in reading more of what you are reading.
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoThe fertilizer problems started with sanctions on Belarus which is 20% of the worlds potash as in potassium market, and got dire due to China, the US and Europe all messing up their natural gas markets. That's used to supply hydrogen atoms for the first step of nitrogen fertilizer, the most used by weight, in the Haber process which makes ammonia (NH3) using nitrogen from the air. A lot of entities, not just "Crop Production companies" are doing suboptimal things for the food supply due to the fertilizer crisis. As for stores not providing baby formula recipes, I'd imagine they're worried about liability, and there are of course many other sources for them. Really, due to the Federal government's WIC program which is half the market, its import restrictions, and messed up FDA regulation it should be on them. I say messed up because the FDA demonstrably wasn't serious about dealing with the Abbott Labs plant problem or getting it fixed quickly based on the timeline starting with the whistle blower, while they make it very hard to get into the business. Or the USDA's problem due to their policy of forcing states to grant a WIC monopoly to one formula manufacturer resulted in three companies having almost all the total US market with Abbott having the largest share, at the same time US prices being double those of Europe. Which isn't as strict about food safety but still seems to do OK. A serious country would have done something to mitigate the shortage after they closed down Abbot's huge factory before there were bare shelves for months and it became a political problem in an election year.
- bombcar 4y agoMuch of the regulations in the USA are mainly now used to keep the main businesses in those markets safe from competitors.
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoI'd strip the "now" from your statement, this goes back at least to the 1887 Interstate Commerce Commission and many subsidy attempts which generally didn't produce economically viable railways or steamship lines. Regulatory capture is a universal problem as long as a government is involved in an economy, and it has to be if for no other reason than to collect taxes.
- cpursley 4y agoThere's a term for this: Crony Capitalism
- toiletfuneral 4y ago[dead]
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoAnd before that, fascism Italian style, or national syndicalism as I see Wikipedia calls it. Hard to say we in the US aren't already there in many sectors where big companies work hand in glove with the Federal government such as much of the "surveillance state." Which the companies don't have much choice in acquiescing to unless their leaders want to end up in Federal prison like Qwest's Joseph Nacchio. Going back to farming, the Federal government assumed near total control over a great of it in the New Deal, down to how much you could charge for selling a kosher chicken (A.L.A. Schechter Poultry Corp. v. United States "the surname Schechter means "slaughter" in Yiddish, and specifically refers to a ritual slaughterer") and the two have been inextricably linked since then. And until about now things have been a lot better, for before WWII at the same time food production was limited by diktat and there were newsreels of it being destroyed, the USDA also believed about a quarter of the nation was malnourished which was confirmed in the WWII draft. Which I've read was major factor in establishing the school lunch program.
- 0daystock 4y ago> There are rumors of diesel shortages and urea shortages. In order to operate a diesel engine on the road you have to use DEF fluid which is urea. This isn't strictly true, you can remove the DEF emissions control system from most trucks for a small price and this even yields a small performance gain. In my state, this is quite common as there is no emissions testing. The emphasis on diesel/DEF shortages is greatly exaggerated and somewhat misguided, I think.
- SoftTalker 4y agoYou can do a "DEF delete," but if you are caught you will be paying some major fines for EPA violations that will quickly exceed the value of the truck. Do the DOT inspections at weigh stations not check for this? I know that older trucks are grandfathered as they never had it; generally vehicles are required to have all the original emissions controls intact. You also will need to know how to reflash the engine computers, which will not be happy if expected emissions equipment is simply removed.
- josephcsible 4y agoI think the point is that if there's a urea shortage, good governments would waive the DEF requirement until it ends, rather than effectively saying "sorry, it's illegal for you to drive that truck at any price".
- SV_BubbleTime 4y ago> I think the point is that if there's a urea shortage, good governments would waive the DEF requirement until it ends, Automotive EE here, this will ABSOLUTELY NOT happen.
- josephcsible 4y agoOh, I have no delusions that it will happen. I also have no delusions that our government is good.
- 4y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> For all the "Baby formula shortage" media coverage, how many stories have included a recipe for alternatives to commercial formula? Mostly I've seen admonitions to not try making baby food at home, which is incredibly useless for people trying to feed kids. Thanks for pointing this out. It's like we've forgotten how to function as humans in some respect. Baby formula isn't some magical combination of ingredients. And I get it, authorities are wary to recommend recipes because of the risk of people fucking it up. But when people are out of options they'll likely make worse decisions, like watering down formula.
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoBaby formula isn't some magical combination of ingredients. Some of it is for those with metabolic problems. Abbott makes one type which very recently the government has taken action about, but each recipient has be vetted to get it, I believe it's from non-FDA regulated production in Europe.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI mean, that's fine, but how many babies need that kind of formula? And parents with babies that do need that kind of formula are probably well aware of that. If you Google "how to make homemade baby formula", basically every article is how experts strongly recommend against it. And there are articles like "Why following TikTok influencers' baby formula recipes is a terrible idea." No shit following TikTok baby formula recipes is a horrible idea. But if a detailed recipe for age-appropriate "standard" baby formula were published by experts, my guess is that it wouldn't contain fairy dust. I can commiserate somewhat with these "experts", though, because this is a fairly common case where what is good advice for an individual can be bad advice for the masses. That is, if you're a reasonably intelligent person, it's probably not that hard to make your own baby formula. But if, say, at least 20% of people are not reasonably intelligent, experts will err on the side of "lowest common denominator" advice.
- IncRnd 4y agoExactly, babies have been eating for an extremely long time, far longer than boxes and bottles have been around and filled with the "only way to feed the babies".
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoIt's hard to take any food shortage articles seriously when we feed >40% of the calories we grow to cattle alone. Sure, more people might go hungry because we do not allocate food well. But we are so far from actually running out of calories that the idea is ridiculous.
- dsrees 4y ago40% of corn grown goes to produce ethanol. [1] The silage by product is then sent to feed cattle. [1] https://civileats.com/2022/02/14/how-corn-ethanol-for-biofuel-fueled-climate-change/ https://civileats.com/2022/02/14/how-corn-ethanol-for-biofue...
- redisman 4y agoSure but thinking that the American people don’t implode if the stores are empty and you’re sent a bag of corn every month for your calories is also not realistic.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoYou can grow other calories on the land you're growing corn for ethenol and livestock feed.
- pixl97 4y agoWith the massive efficiency of corn its actually kinda hard to do that to the level you expect. Corn is very effective at turning space into starch.
- imtringued 4y agoWhat massive efficiency? You're feeding it to animals. 80% of the calories are immediately pooped out.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y ago
- SkyPuncher 4y ago> For all the "Baby formula shortage" media coverage, how many stories have included a recipe for alternatives to commercial formula? Well, the reality is there isn't a good one. If there was, this issues wouldn't be so serious. Infant formula is truly a modern marvel - an accurate enough representation of breast milk. It lacks certain things (like antibodies), but can absolutely provide an infant correct nutrition. Too put things in perspective, toddler formula - which is very, very similar is considered a dangerous substitute since it does not contain the exact correct ratios and can lead to health issues. To answer you question, the media does not have a recommendation because there simply isn't a good, safe recommendation.
- sdoering 4y agoI recently had a conversation with an organic farmer. While he is able to pass on at least some of his increased costs for energy and fuel through direct sales and cooperatively organized distribution channels, his conventionally farmed colleagues have a bigger problem. They have long-term purchase contracts that fix the prices for milk, meat or vegetables. In the case of milk and meat in particular, production costs, including purchased feed for the animals, now exceed the agreed purchase prices. At the same time, however, prices for the end consumer are rising because, on the one hand, the processing companies themselves have higher energy costs, but on the other hand (without passing them on to the producers) the current climate allows price increases and thus an increase in margins. So the consumer and the farmer lose out. Only the processor, its shareholders and retailers benefit (at least in the short term). And the speculators who bet on rising prices. Many conventional farmers see their livelihoods threatened. Which further endangers food security in the long term.
- bombcar 4y agoOne should never make long term contracts for delivery without long term contracts for supply, or at least something to hedge against supply costs.
- davio 4y ago“The farmer is the only man in our economy who buys everything at retail, sells everything at wholesale, and pays the freight both ways.” — John F. Kennedy.
- usrn 4y agoHe might be our most underrated president.
- eatonphil 4y agoI don't think he was, at least based on what he actually did in life. He only barely beat Nixon in 1960, caused Cuban crisis through his own making by bad defense policy in the middle east, gridlocked congress. His people turned him into a legend after he was killed. LBJ did the real work in implementing the ideas JFK wanted (but couldn't implement). Yes JFK's death may have made some of this more possible but how much can you credit someone for dying when it wasn't even for a particular cause (other than anticommunism maybe). You may be able to tell I've read too much Robert Caro. https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/06/jfk-accomplished-little-but-his-historic-myth-endures.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/06/jfk-accomplished-lit...
- dontbenebby 4y agoDoesn't seem to factor in that cheap solar will make desalination much cheaper, but an interesting article for sure.
- gadflyinyoureye 4y agoA large issue is where do you put the brackish or super-salted water? Desalination is great as long as you have the waste impacts managed.
- eropple 4y agoExtremely not an expert, but I wonder if dehydrating it out doesn’t make sense? Solid-form salts are easier to dispose of.
- m0llusk 4y agoThe process can also be used to generate construction materials.
- codenesium 4y agoYou pump it back out into the ocean.
- stevenjgarner 4y agoProbably fine for small-scale use, but on a planetary scale increased salinity could dramatically influence marine biodiversity, not to mention climate from thermohaline circulation disruption [1] https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/education/tutorial_currents/05conveyor1.html https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/education/tutorial_currents/05...
- thriftwy 4y agoIt's not possible to change ocean salinity by any measurable amount by desalination. Except maybe for some very closed off seas, which are already less saline than the ocean.
- lotusmars 4y agoPutin already hinted that in exchange of lifting sanctions he will ship grain from occupied Ukraine. I'm pretty sure that Western politicans will scream "no way" initially but will quietly give in later. Just they way they gave in to Putin's demands to pay for gas in rubles. Whole rush on occopying south Ukraine (and levelling cities like Mariupol) was for Putin to have grains shortage as yet another leverage on European politicians. Not to mention that sanctions hadn't made any significant dent anyway. Russian economy is booming unfortunately. Yes import is limited, but local prices cratered due to strong ruble. It's around 60-70 RUB per USD both in banks and on the street compared to 78 pre-war. These sanctions are a shame while Germans are sponsoring war by pumping billions into Russian economy and drag their feet on promised weapons to Ukraine. So much blood on Germans once again. Only last time they were explicit about it.
- ImHereToVote 4y agoI dunno. Mariupol doesn't look that flattened to me. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i1I8SZeXGFo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i1I8SZeXGFo
- lotusmars 4y agoPlese don't spread Russian propaganda. Graham Philips worked a token "pro-Putin Westerner" on RT and Zvezda, which is literally Russian army's TV channel. He's as shilly as it gets.
- ImHereToVote 4y agoYeah, I guess all those ethnic Russians that live in Mariupol are all payed actors. And those concrete buildings that are all in actuality flattened. Elaborate actors, the whole lot.
- lotusmars 4y agoYep, saying this as a Russian, Russian media will show you a small part of the city with a staged crowd carrying Russian flags and tell you it's the whole city. They've done it for years. It's a shame some people in the West are fooled by these cynical lies. For others reading it, just google areal videos of Mariupol from The Guardian or BBC. It's shocking how West allowed this to happen in 21st century.
- atq2119 4y agoThis is why, in normal times, food waste is a good thing. It means there's some slack in the system for when times get worse. Not that that helps people in poorer countries, unfortunately.
- usrn 4y agoSoon we might face the choice of stopping aid or starving ourselves which doesn't help them either.
- joenathanone 4y agoSuch a short sighted comment, no, it would be best to have an efficient system where excess food could either be stored or delivered to those with food insecurities.
- tomp 4y agoNo, your comment is short-sighted. Ideally, you'd have a system that would massively over-produce food (and feed everybody and store some) so that localised disruptions / crop failures wouldn't bring the whole system down.
- guerrilla 4y agoI'm pretty sure that's what they meant.
- ziml77 4y agoPerfect efficiency is how you end up with small disruptions turning into big problems. Compensating for lost production in one place by ramping it up elsewhere is not as quick as flipping a switch. Especially when your food needs a season to grow.
- atq2119 4y agoExcess food is being stored, but it can't be stored indefinitely. Others have explained again why excess food is a good thing. One thing in favor of your point is that we can still improve the system: avoid excess production of processed food, and find optimal uses for excess food that isn't eaten (compost, biofuels, etc.).
- photochemsyn 4y agoInteresting quote: Amid the mounting signs of distress, a series of policies could help to minimize human suffering. However, most would require a considerable degree of international cooperation, which might be difficult to achieve in the current environment. I'm really wondering if Orwell's prediction from almost a century ago, that the world would devolve into three major blocks continually at war with each other, each exercising authoritarian control over their domestic populations, isn't on the verge of becoming a reality. It appears that both Russian and American political leaders view the conflict in Ukraine as beneficial to their own domestic political interests, for example - and China is not yet involved, but what if there's a war in Asia, i.e. Taiwan? The global South sits outside this picture, so maybe there's some hope there. As far as practical matters, there are a lot of approaches to ensuring local food supplies. Victory gardens were a thing in WWII for example. Also, there are several known vegetarian mixtures that give full amino acid profiles, such as the corn-beans-squash mix of pre-Colombian agriculture in NAmerica, or rice-bean bases of SAsia, etc. Recycling nutrients via effective composting also reduces the need for fertilizer imports. Avoiding reliance on global supply chains is going to become very important if current trends continue, in any case.
- radford-neal 4y agoNo mention of the amount of food diverted to biofuels, such as corn being converted to ethanol. Stopping doing that would be the easiest way to increase food production. Maybe this omission has something to do with their ritual invocation (on no evidence) of climate change as a cause of the food shortfall. Not mentioning biofuels may be a matter of solidarity with other climate alarmists. Even though biofuels are a total scam, that damage the environment rather than help, pointing that out might lead people to ask whether other aspects of the climate agenda are also dubious.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoCarbohydrates are the real feed stock in corn (maize) used to make ethanol. Left over are "distillers grains" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distillers_grains https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distillers_grains as in "protein, fibre, fat" which is used as animal fodder, especially for ruminants who can digest the fiber. The real total loss is in biodiesel made from vegetable fats. I can't remember the numbers now, but I read the German use of them is a substantial fraction of the sunflower oil that's no longer available from the Ukraine.
- radford-neal 4y agoPeople need calories. The carbohydrates going to make ethanol could have provided those needed calories. I hope the Germans are just giving up on biodiesel if they can't get sunflower oil from Ukraine, rather than buying up other food oils...
- code123456789 4y agoLOL. The article says that to fix the issue we need some international efforts and blah blah blah. Bullshit. All we need is to sink down russian ships in Black sea. Even better will be to help with the liberation of both Kherson and Crimea regions. Zaporizhzhya and Donbas can be liberated later, but Bastion rockets in Crimea endanger ports in Odesa and Yuzhne. This is the easiest way to provide food to emerging markets. By the way, there are chemical (fertilizer) plants in Ukraine. Today they are not working or occupied. One in Yuzhne is intact, but shut down temporarily. There's also Sumykhimprom plant in Sumy, that's right on the border with russia. The plant is intact, but I think it's not working as well due to war. If we chase russians off from Ukraine, food prices will return to normal.
- guerrilla 4y ago> All we need is to sink down russian ships in Black sea. Yeah, I'm sure nuclear war will be good for food pirces.
- tomjen3 4y ago
- guerrilla 4y ago
- fractallyte 4y agoNato could have marched in at the beginning, with the justification that Russian aggression in Ukraine was a security threat to Europe. Russians only respect strength. The situation could have been escalated much further without tipping over into nuclear exchange. Nato failed, and now we have a multitude of security issues.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoNATO is a defense pact. It only acts when its members are attacked.
- pphysch 4y ago> Over the last three months, Russia's invasion of Ukraine has shocked agricultural markets Did Washington's illegal invasions of Iraq, Libya, or Syria shock global energy and food markets, leading to global crises? No, because a large part of the global economy did not attempt to cut off USA from the global economy following those blatant violations of sovereignty. This real lede is buried deep in the article. The fact is that the current economic crisis could be partially mitigated by the West undoing its economic punitive measures intended to destabilize Russia and force regime change. While Russia is arguably engaging in a military crisis of choice, Washington (and Brussels) are engaging the world in an economic crisis of choice; primarily because a unaccountable cabal of aging Cold War neocons are fixated on overthrowing Vladimir Putin "at any cost". Anyways, most of the analysis is correct and useful, but it always bugs me when the causality is obfuscated in the name of pushing a political agenda.
- enraged_camel 4y ago>> Did Washington's illegal invasions of Iraq, Libya, or Syria shock global energy and food markets, leading to global crises? Not a good comparison in terms of food. Ukraine produces 6% of the world's wheat. Russia produces 17%. The former is unable to export its stockpiles due to the Black Sea blockade by the latter, and the latter is not going to be exporting what it produces because they recognize that they can use it as leverage.
- thriftwy 4y agoRussia and Ukraine got very little from being major food exporters. For Russia it meant that wheat profits are just a dent of oil&gas profits, and for Ukraine it meant perennial poverty and international aid seeking. Both were getting scolded for slacking economically. If both countries were to be compensated 'fairly' for the wheat, maybe there would be no war right now. Food prices may never 'recover' to those unsustainable levels.
- lotusmars 4y ago> If both countries were to be compensated 'fairly' for the wheat, maybe there would be no war right now. Wow. Now this is the Putin apologist take I've never heard before, and I've heard a lot of them watching Russian TV.
- DeathArrow 4y agoThis might mean new waves of immigration from Middle East and Africa to Europe. The last ones caused some stirring. I expect a new wave will cause, too. So we can see some pressure from European governments for finding solutions to end the war.
- tomp 4y agoIn the last wave, only one country (Hungary) handled the problem sensible (building a wall, encouraging locals having more kids). The rest of the governments mostly pretended the problem doesn't exist. I expect this to change with any future waves. It's hard to be a trendsetter, but easy to be a follower.
- guerrilla 4y ago> In the last wave, only one country (Hungary) handled the problem sensible (building a wall, encouraging locals having more kids). You left out the part about turning to fascism. Anyway, none of what you mentioned helped immigrants nor resolved the reason for their immigration, so it seems more like the least sensible being that it was a complete failure. > The rest of the governments mostly pretended the problem doesn't exist. Excuse me? This isn't remotely true. It was the main topic for half a decade. We housed, clothed, fed and educated millions of people in need of our help and it was an amazing success!
- Throwawayaerlei 4y ago"You left out the part about turning to fascism." Why do you think people "turn to fascism" in the first place??
- guerrilla 4y agoBecause they are racist natioanlist authoritarians and they perceive it as benefiting them.
- 4y ago
- tomjen3 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- droopyEyelids 4y agoI keep seeing articles referencing that Russia is blockading Ukraine's ports. As far as I can tell, that is completely untrue. Russia still allows shipping in the Black Sea in what they call a humanitarian corridor which is "a safe lane south-west of Ukraine's territorial sea, 80 nautical miles long and 3 nautical miles wide, from 08:00 to 19:00" The reason ships can not dock at Ukrainian ports is "Ukraine’s ports are at MARSEC (maritime security) level 3 and remain closed for entry and exit. Sea mines have been laid in port approaches and some port exits are blocked by sunken barges and cranes." This comes from the The International Maritime Organization (IMO) https://www.imo.org/en/MediaCentre/HotTopics/Pages/MaritimeSecurityandSafetyintheBlackSeaandSeaofAzov.aspx https://www.imo.org/en/MediaCentre/HotTopics/Pages/MaritimeS... Russia is doing enough evil that we don't have a shortage of stuff to denounce it for. And while misinformation has its place in war, I don't like it here and think it could make the food crisis worse.
- lotusmars 4y ago> "Ukraine’s ports are at MARSEC (maritime security) level 3 and remain closed for entry and exit. Sea mines have been laid in port approaches and some port exits are blocked by sunken barges and cranes." So yeah, this quote literally says that ports are blocked because of war Putin wages on Ukraine. Putin just loves this logic. "I'm not blockading anyone! Feel free to pass to a war-ravaged occupied region with active warfare going on. Everyone who is saying otherwise is a gay Nazi and should look at both sides".