13 ms·
Seen this kind of thing several times. "Assistance" programs meant to prop people up with so many reporting requirements and perverse incentives that punish yo
by colechristensen 4y ago
Seen this kind of thing several times.
"Assistance" programs meant to prop people up with so many reporting requirements and perverse incentives that punish you for improving your situation to the extent that the best path is to not even try to improve your situation and be entirely dependent on the program because when you do start earning income or saving anything, they take so much away from you that there is a significant cost to any amount of improvement until well after you'd be self-sufficient. i.e. it is more expensive to earn any income than it is to earn none, and the constant threat of losing support of the program (explicit threats) is much more anxiety inducing for the most vulnerable populations often than the situation they were trying to exit.
Being homeless, getting into a program to help the homeless, and then constantly being threatened with a return to homelessness if somebody doesn't do the paperwork exactly right is just crazy, but I've seen it first hand.
- jakub_g 4y agoWhen I was a student and wanted to get a small job to get some pocket money, I couldn't, because after reporting it, my mom would lose some family benefits and we'd be worse off at the end of the day. This was a recurring theme until I graduated and went on my own.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- daenz 4y agoIt's amazing how many people see this happening, acknowledge it is wrong and severely dysfunctional, and then turn around and claim that everything will be better when the government runs everything in the economy.
- mordae 4y agoIt's happening mostly because the politicians advocating for these dysfunctional policies are ignorants corrupted by their business friends who really don't want people to feel safe enough to ask for more money. At least here in Europe. Speaking from experience. We have several people directly profiting from several ineffective policies targeting disadvantaged in the local Parliament.
- bitwize 4y ago
- xmprt 4y agoHow would you solve this without the government? I can't see why private companies would be incentivized to do this. And the reason this is dysfunctional is because the government doesn't go far enough in extending benefits. If there was more budget allocated to these benefits then we wouldn't have this problem.
- tragictrash 4y agoI don't think people are arguing for no government assistance program, they're observing that it's incentivizing staying in the program rather than the assumed intended use, helping someone get on their feet again
- mordae 4y agoSometimes it's not even about budget. I've seen clerks actively discourage people from asking for the benefits even before the official evaluation.
- daenz 4y ago>And the reason this is dysfunctional is because the government doesn't go far enough in extending benefits. If there was more budget allocated to these benefits then we wouldn't have this problem. This pov is exactly what I was describing. It's always "more money will fix it." More control, more money, and then things will be better. I promise. Compulsive gamblers have a term for this: "chasing losses" >How would you solve this without the government? The problem of people with disabilities needing help? Do you believe people never received help before the government came along? They were helped at a local level by charitable people who cared about each other and knew that taking care of each other was part of a healthy society. Neither business nor government replaces that.
- taurath 4y ago> Do you believe people never received help before the government came along? I do. Especially when people who need the help are from poor communities who can’t spare much - much less provide things like in home care, transportation, etc. If you say gov doesn’t need to be involved then please show me who is gonna help. The only ones I know of are the same that throw queer kids or male domestic abuse victims out on the street. People are more charitable when they’re rich (or more accurately, on rising incomes), but they only help out people close to them. Poor people are dehumanized. That’s why we need the gov. Or did you not like see the lines of cars 20 miles long during covid for food assistance?
- jjoonathan 4y agoThis is the one-two punch that Republicans use to kill social programs. 1. Drag their feet until Democrats reluctantly agree to include something guaranteed to cause dysfunction (uneconomic means testing, perverse incentive cliffs, adverse selection, etc). 2. Point at the dysfunction they created as a reason to kill the program. I'd be a lot more sympathetic to #2 if I didn't see so much #1.
- myfavoritedog 4y agoAnd yet, when the Democrats control Congress and the presidency (like they do now, like they did in 2010), they do absolutely nothing to show us how wonderful their programs could be -- if only they had control! Government programs don't need Republicans to add the dysfunction.
- praxulus 4y agoThey don't actually have the ability to pass general bills without Republican support though. Outside of budget reconciliation, neither party has had the power to pass legislation without at least some bipartisan support since Ted Kennedy was replaced in 2010.
- leereeves 4y agoThey do have the ability to pass general bills without Republican support, actually. They can pass a separate bill to suspend the filibuster on another bill, and suspending the filibuster only requires the 50 Democrat Senators and the VP. They tried to do so in January but Manchin and Sinema voted against it.
- klyrs 4y agoSo, they don't have the ability to pass general bills without Republican support. They'd need to change the rules to have that ability.
- 4y ago
- micromacrofoot 4y agoThese kind of labyrinthine policies happen because they're attempts to appease people who don't want these programs to exist at all.
- UncleMeat 4y agoYup. People complain about freeloaders taking advantage of these systems so they demand policies like this.
- olyjohn 4y agoYep. Shut down the whole system because there are some people who might cheat on it. It's like if we shut down Home Depot because there's people stealing merchandise. Welp, buncha fuckin freeloaders stealing tools again! Better get rid of all the Home Depots so nobody can steal.
- UncleMeat 4y agoAnd even if people aren't cheating it, just make up stories about people doing to so to justify shutting it down! The "welfare queen" archetype is so strong in the minds of people in this country that it prevents all sorts of useful policy.
- Swenrekcah 4y agoWell, it is the government that’s providing the help in the first place. They just need to fix the qualifications at the margin, but that is often met with hostility from other voters for the misguided reason that people are just leeching off these programs, when the reality is exactly what is described, that the paperwork and punishment for extra earning is exactly what makes that happen, to the extents that it does. For the record I absolutely don’t want the government handling everything, I’m just tired of hearing that everything the government does is disfunctional and everything private enterprise does is great and noble, cause it’s not true.
- dwallin 4y agoIt’s amazing how people could see this happening, acknowledge it is wrong and severely dysfunctional, then go around insisting we add more means testing to benefits because it would be horrible if people got help who “didn’t deserve it”. Just a hint, the people causing this dysfunctional state of affairs are probably not the ones who are trying to expand government benefits to cover as many people as possible.
- mcavoybn 4y agoVery snarky response. I think the poster you replied to was trying to point out that the reason this happens is because the government prints money and if they don't take the money out of circulation via taxes then inflation becomes an issue.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- guelo 4y agoIt's the politicians with your antigovernment attitude that make these programs so awful. Then they turn around and point at the mess they helped create as the reason they're antigovernment.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIt’s easy to pass blame; harder to realize that we are the people who are supposed to fix it.
- tshaddox 4y ago“For decades most airplane crashes have been caused by trained pilots and yet we continue to put trained pilots in the cockpit.” This form of argument almost looks compelling until you realize that it is predicated on some unspoken belief that there is a clear better alternative.
- excitom 4y agoIt's not the fault of government per se, but puritanical conservatives in government who think any assistance to disadvantaged people is coddling lazy slackers. See for example, drug testing of assistance recipients. It turns out, as the testing has proven, that most of the people who get a little bit of cash are most likely to use it on food and essentials. Oh, and the people who run the for-profit drug testing happen to be cronies of the politicians who advocated for the testing - such a surprise. Another example: Don't let people withdraw all their money at once or they will waste it. Instead give them debit cards with a small withdrawal limit. Oh, and there's a withdrawal fee that eats into the meager cash ... and cronies of the politicians who advocated for the policy own the ATMs in the stores which collect those fees.
- montjoy 4y agoAs I get older I see more and more of “reducing gov’t waste” as a means to funnel money into private individuals’ pockets. See also for-profit prisons, charter schools, bussing, medical care, etc etc.
- UncleMeat 4y agoThe alternative is worse. My aunt is on disability. Yes, systems suck and if she could hold a temp job she'd be discouraged from doing so. She'd be dead in the ground if conservative policies ran everything.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoSounds like you are pro-immortality!
- amelius 4y agoDo economists and politologist not acknowledge the problem?
- philistine 4y agoWe want to help people who don’t make a lot of money. Governments are imperfect institutions yes, but what alternative is there to send money to people who need it ?
- mcculley 4y agoAnd yet, some countries and cultures have safety nets that work. It is not surprising that the government functions like the people that elected it. If your community is comprised of assholes, you get cruel policies.
- masklinn 4y ago> And yet, some countries and cultures have safety nets that work. Welfare traps are definitely a thing in countries and cultures with “safety nets that works”, fwiw.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoAren't most of these absurd rules the result of elected legislators putting on a show for their voters rather than the result of professional beurocrats making arbitrary rules because they felt like it?
- justin_oaks 4y agoIf we want to help people, I think the first step is to assign each person/family an advocate. Someone who looks out for the person in need and reaches out to them. That person could help navigate the bureaucracy, explain to people their options, etc. Sadly, most people have to advocate for themselves. They have to research what they need to do to get benefits, try to figure out how to navigate the poorly designed system, make calls, fill out paperwork, submit documents, etc. Poor people may not have the mental/emotional energy to go through all this. I know, I know. Sometimes this is the system behaving as designed. The government makes it hard for people to get benefits so it doesn't have to pay as much. Such design is despicable.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> If we want to help people, I think the first step is to assign each person/family an advocate. The first and last step is to just give them cash. Give everyone cash indiscriminately. If we want to help people. To ensure the the wealth is not being transferred from poor to wealthy, you have marginal income/wealth or marginal sales tax rates.
- dsr_ 4y agoYou mean progressive rather than marginal, but yes. You can give people cash. You also have to kill a lot of restrictive zoning laws, because new housing can't be built until they go away. You need to require new housing to pay for new infrastructure to support itself, and then you need to require old housing to pay for maintaining their infrastructure, too. You need to kill off local funding of education in favor of universal funding of education, because otherwise the poor kids get substandard schools and teachers. You need to fund public transit, and it needs to be aimed at getting people not just from their homes to work and back, but also to schools and stores and entertainment. Everything has to be automatically indexed to inflation, or else you get the same problem ten to twenty years later.
- Spivak 4y agoYeah, but it won't ever happen because it lays bare the function of taxation as (mostly -- sin taxes and virtue credits being the exception) the vehicle for a wealth transfer from rich to poor. And if we actually admit that then we have to deal with the awkwardness that is why even bother taxing people below the breakeven point?
- ipaddr 4y agoThis is what many low income buildings become. They take 30% of your gross income so any small raise get's immediately reduced by half and sucked into the machine. Unless you can get a huge salary increase above the average wage you can never save enough to move into a property outside of the system even after your rent reaches parity with average rent prices. The only thing one can do is to quit working legally which reduces the rent and frees you up to find cash work.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agothis is way worse. medical expenses for disabled people are high enough that this takes over 100% for a lot of jobs
- Dylan16807 4y agoThat's way less of a problem. It's not great when half a raise goes to rent and half goes into your pocket, but it doesn't hold a candle to policies where the entire raise disappears or you actually end up with less money. And a situation like that definitely won't stop you from saving money. It doesn't trap you. If a wage increase takes your payment from significantly below market rent up to market rent, you'll be able to save up a security deposit and moving expenses pretty quickly. Lower the percentage some or make it a third of net income and it sounds like a pretty great system.
- michaelmrose 4y agoAs a resident this is absolutely the least of the difficulties in such buildings.
- WalterBright 4y agoWe also have a crazy system where a graduate is a fool to pay back the education loans.
- throwaway894345 4y agoYou mean pay them at all or pay more than minimum payments? I believe the latter but I don’t understand the former (maybe you’re talking about the covid deferments?).
- tehwebguy 4y agoWhat do you mean? People who don’t pay their student loans face all kinds of negative consequences from being unable to buy a home / car due to credit dings, tax refund garnishment & wage garnishment on top of fees & interest
- WalterBright 4y agohttps://www.forbes.com/sites/adamminsky/2022/05/19/if-biden-enacts-broad-student-loan-forgiveness-it-may-look-like-this/?sh=5368f4a76bc7 https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamminsky/2022/05/19/if-biden-...
- shakes_mcjunkie 4y agoWhy would someone be a fool to pay? Biden was previously advocating for only $10k which doesn't cover the median federal student loan amount. $50k may not even happen. Right now you can pay down some of the principle at 0% interest in case your loans aren't forgiven. https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/loans/student-loans/you-can-pause-two-student-loan-payments-but-should-you https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/loans/student-loans/you-c... It's much more complicated than calling people "fools" for paying. TBH the program is a disaster and it's really, really disappointing that the loans won't just simply be forgiven. I personally know many people held back from economic participation because of federal student loans. Even if you want to be all bs moralistic about the responsibility of paying debts back, from an economic perspective the loans should be forgiven.
- gwright 4y agoI most recently saw that with some criticisms of Section 8 housing. I'm paraphrasing but basically to be eligible for Section 8 housing you can't have too many assets. Good financial planning would say to scrimp and save so that you can get make a downpayment to get a mortgage but you'll be kicked out of the section 8 housing long before you've saved enough to get out yourself. Catch-22
- stjohnswarts 4y agoThe only way is to put savings under your mattress and that is extremely likely to get stolen (usually by relatives or "friends"). It's an awful catch 22.
- 19870213 4y agoOr when you need to use that money by the police as part of Civil Asset Forfeiture during a random stop/search.
- bqmjjx0kac 4y agoOr NFTs ;)
- adrr 4y agoGet a safety deposit box for $80 a year and store your cash in it.
- jdeibele 4y agoThey're not easy to find. I got a notice last month from my credit union that I need to plan move my stuff out of my deposit box. The Credit Union "relies on a vendor for the software that is used to open, close, and maintain Safe Deposit Boxes. Over time, the vendor stopped consistently upgrading this software and we have now learned that it is being phased out altogether. Replacing this type of system would mean a significant cost to our membership." A few years ago they replaced the double key system (bank employee has a key, you have a key) with a handprint system to let one customer at a time into the vault. They removed the bank key. I always have to remember which set is where my box is: they have 3 or 4 boxes labeled 131 because they acquired them from other banks or credit unions who got out of the business. I had to settle my aunt's estate in Huntington Beach a few years ago. The Chase branch there limited people to one box per branch because they are relatively popular. But safe deposit boxes definitely skew towards grey hair. I opened an account with my credit union because they were one of the few options for safe deposit boxes but the branch with the boxes is miles away from my local branch so I don't use it often. I would have liked to store backups there but in the end I use BackBlaze.
- tablespoon 4y ago> "Assistance" programs meant to prop people up with so many reporting requirements and perverse incentives that punish you for improving your situation... It's a legitimately difficult problem, though. The interests and perspectives of the people who depend on these programs and the people who pay for them are often badly misaligned. On the one hand, you want to make it easy for the people who depend on these programs to improve their lot and achieve independence. On the other hand, the people who pay may be legitimately resentful when their money is going to strangers who don't in fact need it. It's a fine line to walk between those things, and the likely outcome is something that's biased towards one side or the other.
- lostcolony 4y agoIt's actually super easy to do. See, you just...make sure that rather than cliffs, you have percentage based reduction of benefits. I.e., you lose $1 of benefit for every $2 you make, or whatever. And something similar with assets (though admittedly the details would be trickier to avoid it being gamed). Neither the group that needs help (and their supporters), nor the group that doesn't want to give hands out to people who refuse to work but could, have reason to object to something like that. The actual problem is the red meat that welfare/socialism is to our political bases in the US, and the incentives of politicians, on both sides of the aisle, to ensure it persists. If you do the obvious thing to actually address the problem, neither side can use it any longer to stir up the base. So the incentive is to not actually fix it.
- paulmd 4y agoAs discussed elsewhere in the comments here, and as discussed in the article, there is indeed a phaseout for income. Every $1 you make above $85 reduces your benefits by $0.50, so they are doing exactly what you suggest. The $2000 number is a cap for wealth, not income. The problem isn’t having a phaseout or not anyway - we could set a wealth cliff of $50k and that would be perfectly fine. It’s the numbers that matter, where the phaseout or cliff is placed and how steep a phaseout. $85 a month is a redonkulous place to put the phaseout even if phaseouts are “better” - that is a worse policy than a 50k a month cliff! And you’re right, the reasons the number hasn’t been adjusted since 1935 (in 1989 the number was inherited from a prior program, it wasn’t adjusted at that time) is because of political will. Social spending on anyone other than the elderly is extremely unpopular in the US.
- cryptonector 4y agoIt's almost like it's done on purpose.
- namibj 4y agoIf you consider the (conditional) basic income in Germany ("Grundsicherung") as given, and it's partial reduction in the face of more than 100€/month income as income tax, one reaches the asymptotic effective (average, not marginal) tax rate of the super-rich at about 180~200€/month. It's progressive until around 1500€/month of income (if it was salary), after which it's regressive. UBI would fix those perverse incentives (80% marginal "tax rate" for the next few hundred after the first 100 (per month), then an about 300~500€/month wide band with 90% marginal tax rate, followed by iirc another couple hundred at 0% marginal, and then hitting around 20% marginal (going up in piecewise-linear progression)).
- guerrilla 4y agoI always have to ask: How does UBI not just result in inflation and we end up in the exact same situation as we are in now but with extra steps?
- chii 4y agoIf UBI is paid out through printing extra currency, it will induce inflation. But if UBI is paid out via extra taxation, then it will not induce inflation (or at least, not overall - it might induce some inflation in goods/services which wouldn't have been in demand but for the UBI, such as low cost labour). The higher taxes taken from the higher income people will reduce their demand, and thus balance out.
- guerrilla 4y agoThanks. That makes sense.
- crooked-v 4y agoUBI is a pretty small money faucet compared to the endless spending on foreign wars that the US political establishment regularly undertakes. Just give out the same amount of money to poor people instead of using it as a middle-class jobs program that kills foreigners.
- savanaly 4y agoIt doesn't even have to be the case that, as you say, "it is more expensive to earn any income than it is to earn none". That describes an implicit tax rate of >100% which would certainly discourage work, but even if it were, say, 75%, I don't think you have to be a hard-core republican to believe that that might disincentivize work and be on the far side of the Laffer curve.
- Forgeties79 4y agoI filed for unemployment for a few months during the pandemic (film industry. Literally no work available). The most insane revelation, as this was my first time filing, was that I had to file every single week. All for a paltry $247/wk (without the federal addition during Covid). The process to get started was so opaque that the local 600 (camera union, I’m not even a member but they didn’t care) held a live zoom session where they screen shared with us and had us all follow their exact instructions on what boxes to check, what to fill out, etc. Folks still had trouble. Again, it was quite the revelation.
- Farfignoggen 4y agoJust think of the folks in your local Theater/Trade Show Union branch and the Broadway season ends and the slow summer months begins where at the same time the Trade Show season is at its low point(Summer Months), And UI insurance is sometimes the only way to make it through the Summer Months In the Big Easy and for Union members that are not high up on the Seniority roster. You are Studio Mechanics/Related Local folks and if you can get some Movie/TV production work over the summer you have it good there as after summer is over you can go over to the Theater/Trade Show local in the non summer months and get some extra work there. That weekly job search/reporting requirement is not so hard for anyone working out of a union Hiring Hall as one needs to just go to their local and get the Union Rep to sign their weekly job search booklet and they have that over the phone reporting maybe but I used to go weekly to my UI office as I lived only a few blocks away from the office but that was a few decades back and not over any pandemic where the UI Offices where closed.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoGetting people who are on your program off your program is not how the bureaucrats in charge of these things grow their budgets, get more reports and advance their careers. Show me the incentives...
- jnovek 4y agoI am in the process of applying for SSDI right now. AMAA, I suppose. One of the first pieces of advice that I received in this process — and boy is it a process! — was, “don’t ever say anything that implies that you might want to or be able to go back to work someday.” I mean, of course I want to go back to work someday! I don’t want to spend the rest of my life sick and below the poverty line, not to mention being sick is incredibly boring. I really want to be well and working and I feel like the vast majority of people in SSDI must be in the same boat. Criteria for SSDI (paraphrasing) are that you must be disabled such that you can no longer do your job, are unable to do another job with your skills and level of ability and you’ll be in this situation for at least a year. Even so, expressing even the desire to return to work someday beyond a year from now is apparently a sign that you can work right now to some examiners. The entire process is wrapped in layers of fraud paranoia, even though the fraud rate is absolutely minuscule.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y ago>The entire process is wrapped in layers of fraud paranoia, even though the fraud rate is absolutely minuscule. ... or possibly "due to the layers of fraud paranoia, the fraud rate is absolutely minuscule". Difficult to know, I would think?
- jessaustin 4y agoIt would be possible to change policies slightly and observe the results. The slope toward vastly less punitive benefits regimes might be slippery...
- jnovek 4y agoOf course; I’m sure that, if it were easy enough, people would commit social security fraud. I know this is a subjective statement, but as I go through this process it just feels way, way, way over the top. We could probably do with a lot less. We could probably make the process kinder. The experience is so humiliating and we do it to people who are already suffering. Edit: Imagine, hypothetically, that the process were twice as kind but bumped the fraud rate to 1.5%. I would be totally OK with that. Maybe it’s worth spending a little extra public money to treat people with dignity.
- guerrilla 4y agoYou're talking about the welfare trap. That's not what the article is about. The article is about disabled people who are unable to work being kept poor. Many people will never work because they can't and this punishes all of them.
- Fezzik 4y agoYup, the same thing happens with independent minors in the care of the State - they get a benefit from the state every month but if they have above [a tiny number saved] or earn above [a tiny paycheck every month] the subsidy is reduced, dollar for dollar. It’s an awful system.
- crossroadsguy 4y agoWhen I went to Europe backpacking the rude shocker was waking up in the middle of the night because that seat was not reserved. I thought that train only had unreserved seats. From next day I started adding reservation with that extra cost every time I had to reserve seats or berths and then seeing a lot of Europe essentially had just buses as public transports and not trains (esp. when I moved towards Eastern Europe -- also in Sarajevo I believe the pass didn't work, I had bought that in AMS). Maybe next time I will manage it better. Is there a pass that doesn't require you to pay extra every time you want to reserve a seat/berth on the train if you already have a pass?
- pyuser583 4y agoSSDI is basically a “disability pension.” The idea is that you are permanently disabled and will never work again. It really sucks that there’s a huge gap between, short-term disability and permanent disability. One you are on your for, the other the state covers 100%. We need a comprehensive social safety net.