23 ms·
Wireless is a trap (2020)
- cjohnson318 5y agoThere's a tradeoff with wired headphones. Sometimes they act like their own antenna, and if you live in an area with very poor reception, then that becomes a huge problem. In that scenario, bluetooth earbuds are actually preferable, until they run out of battery mid-call.
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoNot saying this is impossible, but it doesn't make sense to me. The phone antenna isn't a straight piece of wire entwined with your cable (probably not even parallel with it), and your cable isn't connected to the antenna port. How would the cable block the signal?
- cyral 5y agoMaybe they mean the noise you can hear from the phone as it communicates. I wonder if it is more pronounced when reception is bad as it searches for other towers? I had wired headphones + mic with an amplifier for a while and if I put my phone anywhere near it you'd hear the classic GSM buzz.
- betwixthewires 5y agoSo they do share ground, which is where the interference comes from. You might find sometimes even stereo sound speakers pick up a ticking noise right when you receive a phone call. This is pretty common with speaker systems, wired headphones being a type of speaker system. Also, a lot of SoCs with FM antennas use the 3.5mm ground as the antenna, so they are wired into the SoC in such a way that they can receive undesired interference.
- salawat 5y agoThat would be a problem... Why? You're wired.
- doommius 5y agoYup. Also just mostly wireless equipment is super low quality. It's easy to see this when living downtown in any larger city. You'll easily be competing with 100s of other APs for the 2.4 ghz wireless band. With tbr 5 and 6 ghz this is getting better but there still isn't nearly enough channels.
- modeless 5y agoUSB-C hubs or monitors with power delivery make this really easy these days. One cable gets you everything. Power, display(s), mouse/keyboard, Ethernet, and any other peripherals you need. It's absolutely worth getting a USB Ethernet adapter. They work way better than WiFi. A wireless mouse is still worth it though. Logitech G305 is essentially perfect IMO. Extremely reliable, extremely low latency, months of battery life, reasonable price.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoI have a wireless gaming mouse. It's never been anything but completely reliable. The dongle is integrated into the charging dock, which sits about two feet from the mouse. I've never heard a single person complain about a wireless mouse. The author is just a crank. I would advise people to not get a Logitech mouse, however. Their button switches are poorly made and fail much sooner than any other manufacturer.
- betwixthewires 5y agoWhat makes a wireless mouse worth it? Also from what I've read, usb-c has a lot of interoperability problems because the connector is a different standard than all the different communications standards that it can be used with.
- smilekzs 5y agoMy biggest gripe with wired mice is that the wire never seem to cooperate --- it would drag on the table, be too stiff, tangle, etc. Plus, latency for at least the dongled mice (not the bluetooth ones) is low enough for me to notice.
- davidelettieri 5y agoI have MX Keys and MX Master 3 and couldn't be happier. Bluetooth works with dongle and with integrated usb.
- adamch 5y agoThis is really noticeable with video chat. I never use Bluetooth when talking with my family... between the Texas - Australia lag and the Bluetooth headphones - Android phone lag, it's enough to impair conversation. Now the problem is just how to manage all the cables that come from having a gaming PC and work laptop that use the same keyboard and monitor. I have a KVM switch but I can't hide it under the desk if I want to press it.
- hug 5y agoMost KVMs have a keyboard shortcut that will let you switch, commonly double-tapping scroll-lock and then hitting 1 or 2 for the first or second input.
- formerly_proven 5y ago> I have a KVM switch but I can't hide it under the desk if I want to press it. Why not? I bolted mine to the underside of the table roughly 20 cm (about 13/20 ft) back from the edge, it's both invisible and the button is trivial to find without fumbling.
- nerdbaggy 5y agoAX has BSSID Coloring which really helps improve performance when multiple APs are on the same channel. Still have the saturated channel limitation but that rarely happens on 5Ghz https://www.extremenetworks.com/extreme-networks-blog/how-does-bss-coloring-work-in-802-11ax/ https://www.extremenetworks.com/extreme-networks-blog/how-do...
- Avamander 5y agoAnecdotal personal experience, but I don't think it would take 802.11ax to improve available bandwidth, just better AP hardware. I replaced a high-performance n/ac router with years old leftover enterprise AP. Price-wise the enterprise AP would've cost as much 2nd hand. It improved the situation in a very very crowded airspace in every measurable metric (~10-50%). Better latency, average, minimum and maximum speeds, connection stability, packet loss and even security (PMF support). All that on the same standards and other conditions. My suspicion is that consumers are being sold bottom of the barrel hardware and new protocols just rise the bar on what s*t they can get working.
- areoform 5y agoI bought a Homepod Mini on sale some time ago, and it's one of the worst experiences I've ever had. It continuously stutters. It stops working. I realize just how magical it is that it works at all. But the realization that it needs WiFi to stream music to, despite having bluetooth, has been quite depressing. I don't think the product will ever work without jitter given the amount of overlapping WiFi signals in my area. It's a bit like the butterfly keyboard of speakers. A wonderful idea in theory. But it makes you wonder if anyone at Apple has ever tried using it an apartment building, a dusty environment, or some place that isn't a pristine lab or upper middle class suburbia
- lstamour 5y agoI set up a second wifi hotspot in the same room as the HomePods and they still struggle to connect to wifi. At this point I’ve given up and assume it’s like the Apple Watch - the wifi works when it wants to. It’s annoying that Apple makes both products that work great with wifi and products that don’t work great - and the ones that don’t work great with wifi often lack Ethernet connectivity options or I would use that instead. At least my watch can connect to cellular. It’s disappointing when you find yourself wanting 5G home speakers to ensure proper internet connectivity…
- turtlebits 5y agoI have a stereo pair of Homepods and they work perfectly. Maybe the wifi channel of your AP is congested? Surprisingly, the Homepod also works when there is no wifi available. It still boggles the mind why there is no wired input though.
- bob-44 5y agoOn my home network, the HomePod Mini's demand to use both IPv4 and IPv6 is what I'm thinking is contributing to the unreliability of my stereo pair. My ISP doesn't provide me an IPv6 address, so my home router and pihole both seem to struggle with the HomePod Minis. My original HomePod doesn't have this issue. What I'd really love is if my HomePod Minis stopped assuming the primary HomeKit Hub role and instead let my Apple TV connected via Ethernet handle all of the requests. There's no way to select a device to be the primary hub as far as I can tell.
- qq66 5y agoI wanted wired Ethernet in my office but didn't want to punch holes in the wall. Luckily I have an old "central vacuum system" that as far as I can tell has never been even powered on, many years before I bought the house. I tied a ping pong ball to a piece of string and used a vacuum cleaner to suck it through the pipes, then used the string to pull a stronger rope and then the Ethernet cable. So now my Ethernet goes from my office to the wireless router via the vacuum ducting.
- robotnikman 5y agoOther alternatives I've found to work are Ethernet over power (varies depending on how well your house is wired though) and ethernet over coax using MoCA adapters (if your house was previously wired with coax for cable TV these work great)
- bin_bash 5y agoMoCA adapters are crazy expensive though
- mason55 5y agoIt's true but you might not need that many. Our house was built in 2000 and every room is wired with coax but no ethernet. With some strategic placement I was able to get a hardwired switch in my office + two hardwired wifi APs with just two MoCA adapters - $300 well spent. It would be pretty expensive to turn every coax run in my house into a hardwired ethernet switch but well placed hardwired APs obviates the need to do that.
- chrisweekly 5y agoYeah; I'm about to upgrade the backhaul on my Orbi mesh system to be wired, via extant coax nodes in good locations.
- themitigating 5y agoA gocoax 1gbit is $60
- alexvoda 5y agoIt's too late now. We are already entering the age of laptops without headphone jacks. If only people listened earlier.
- amelius 5y agoWired would be so much better if it were just a replacement for wireless, where you just plug a wire between two points, and they start communicating without any configuration necessary if the two points already had a wireless communication going.
- falcolas 5y agoIt... usually does? For example, I can plug in an ethernet cable to my router and computer, and it works perfectly fine. And if I unplug, it's still connected, just by wifi.
- timando 5y agoNow try with an SSH session open
- tedunangst 5y agoI blame the wifi. I can ssh from one wired machine to another just fine, but when I unplug the cable the wifi doesn't seamlessly take over. This is clearly the fault of the wireless.
- the_third_wave 5y agoIf you configure things so that the wifi adapter gets the same IP address as the wired connection you should be able to continue communicating with those machines. SSH uses TCP which is connection-oriented so as long as the connection can be made it should work (bar problems with MTU etc.). You might experience a stall before the connection becomes alive again but it should work.
- ChadNauseam 5y agoI think it's a problem with the TCP/IP stack somehow. If I try the same thing when downloading something from chrome, the download fails. If I'm loading a website I get a "connection interrupted" error. Really there's no reason that my device shouldn't have its own IP and treat wifi and ethernet as two different routes to my device. Remember "IP routes around damage"?
- layer8 5y agoTIL why Bluetooth is called Bluetooth: > It was the epithet of King Harald Bluetooth, who united the disparate Danish tribes into a single kingdom; Kardach chose the name to imply that Bluetooth similarly unites communication protocols. [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bluetooth#Name_and_logo https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bluetooth#Name_and_logo] Another thing, not mentioned in the article, is that microwave ovens tend to interfere with Bluetooth in my experience.
- JonathonW 5y agoAnd WiFi. And anything else that might happen to operate in the 2.4 GHz ISM band (like some cordless phones, back in the day).
- falcolas 5y agoIt absolutely does. Especially if folks are in the habit of opening the door before the microwave shuts itself down.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoTom Scott had one of his usual informative videos on this https://youtu.be/VdmQp9M9jUo https://youtu.be/VdmQp9M9jUo
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y agoNot just your experience. I worked for a company that made a lot of wireless devices. We had a pretty open-plan office and learned not to test anything around lunchtime. Seriously. There were many times that I was working on something that suddenly had a spike in the receive failure rate and I'd look at the time and realize that somebody was heating up their lunch in the microwave.
- wwweston 5y agoThis is one reason why I'm still down on Apple's decision to remove 1/8" audio jacks from iPhones: they took away a decades old "just works" standard that wasn't subject to interference or battery or latency issues and replaced it with something that fundamentally is. Their efforts at filing down the sharp edges here with the airpods (and they have done as well as anyone could expect and more) don't change the fundamentals. "Get a dongle" -- maybe I will when I finally give up my original iPhone SE, but I'm not going to be cheerful about paying an extra $30 for the privilege along with the overhead of keeping track of an additional thing.
- turtlebits 5y agoIf you need to move around, wired headphones suck. IME, interference and latency are non issues with BT. Otherwise, the lighting to 3.5mm dongle works perfectly. At my desk, i do have wired headphones, but they are plugged into my TB dock.
- Sebb767 5y ago> IME, interference and latency are non issues with BT. Depends on your usecase. Music and Zoom is fine, but for competitive gaming I'd always go wired.
- recursive 5y agoMusic might be fine for listening, but it is emphatically not fine for playing. It's completely unusable. It's like trying to talk while listening yourself 100ms delayed. Probably fine for competitive gaming if you're just spectating too.
- vonseel 5y agoWhile off-topic, somehow Apple has screwed this up in the M1 MacBook Air built-in audio hardware too. I wanted some monitoring while playing acoustic the other day so I opened logic and rather than connect my expensive audio interface, I just wanted to use the built-in mic and headphone output to monitor myself playing and singing in real time. For some reason there was still an audible delay even though I wasn’t using plugins and had the buffer set very low. I’m pretty sure it was in low latency mode… you shouldn’t have to use an external audio interface just to do real time monitoring like that such a simple use case.
- nl 5y agoThis "managed cables on my desk" is reason enough to stick with wireless.
- kazinator 5y ago> Most Bluetooth headsets introduce around 150-300ms of latency (the time between my computer receiving the audio from the Internet, and the sound coming out of the headphones) I must have an incredible $10 BT speaker (used for quiet TV listening at night). I don't see any delay versus the regular audio (plan old 1/8" audio jack out of Android box, to stereo). You would notice 150-300 ms as serious lip synch issue.
- lxgr 5y agoModern Bluetooth devices can communicate their internal latency, and modern AV stacks use that figure plus known physical layer latencies to delay the video just enough to compensate for that. For interactive audio like games or video conferencing, this doesn‘t work of course.
- can16358p 5y agoAnd recording music. Working on Logic (just hobbyist here) and gaming are the only two activities that I connect my wireless headset via USB C. The latency (because of Bluetooth protocol itself) is too much. For Zoom calls it doesn't affect me much.
- boolemancer 5y agoIf you're watching non-interactive content, the device can just play the audio a little ahead of the video to keep things synchronized. I've noticed this with YouTube where sometimes the audio gets out of sync when listening on bluetooth headphones and I have to pause and re-play to force it to sync again.
- timando 5y agoIt might be that your device is also delaying the video by 150-300ms so it matches with the delayed BT audio.
- nonrandomstring 5y agoThree notable things in this article are: 1) wireless degrades by degree and is hard to debug 2) it fails silently or just in non-obvious ways 3) people generally have no idea how good it is supposed to work, until they experience it working properly I think there are many things, in life generally, but especially in tech, where these qualities conspire to give people a rotten time. People will complain when things fail, or take action. "Graceful degradation" seems like a feature, but it can keep you on a slippery slope of increasing tolerance toward ever worse performance. The complexity, and fuzzy "connection to everything" means that no one has to take responsibility. Maybe it's your neighbour? Or the trees? Or the alignment of Venus and swamp gas on a full moon? Unless you have a full spectrum RF field meter and other very expensive test gear microwaves are "black magic" to even great engineers. I'm sure when Apple met to discuss remotely degrading iPhone performance the words "They'll never notice" were spoken. Companies that sell complex services and oversell resources love this combo of fuzzy, hard to measure, diffuse, naturally erratic behaviour, broad tolerance, mixed with vague customer expectations. They prevent you from knowing, and comparing, what you should be getting, and what you are getting. Many recent development directions, 5G, secure enclaves, encrypted updates and exfiltration (telemetry), are set to increase the "random magic factor" and make gear even more precarious and mysterious to the end user.
- mypalmike 5y ago"I'm sure when Apple met to discuss remotely degrading iPhone performance the words "They'll never notice" were spoken. Companies that sell complex services and oversell resources love this combo of fuzzy, hard to measure, diffuse, naturally erratic behaviour, broad tolerance, mixed with vague customer expectations." I suspect Apple would prefer their products to be reliable rather than erratic.
- nonrandomstring 5y agoThey quite deliberately decided to make them degraded (to prolong battery life). And they were fined for it [1]. Nobody mentioned erratic in that case. [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-51413724 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-51413724
- Duologic 5y agoI can really recommend cable sleeves/tubes, I use these on my desk: https://www.amazon.com/Alex-Tech-10ft-Protector-Sleeving/dp/B07FW3GTXB/ https://www.amazon.com/Alex-Tech-10ft-Protector-Sleeving/dp/...
- cjohnson318 5y agoGreat suggestion. Q: Do these vacuum well? Or should I just replace them every couple of years?
- Duologic 5y agoI've bought them 2 years ago including a few spares, haven't replaced them since (not sure what 'vacuum' means in this context).
- jrockway 5y agoYeah, I've never really seen the appeal. Wires are just so reliable. I am always in meetings with "sorry, my headphones died, can you repeat that" or people mysteriously vanishing because their laptop can't charge as fast as Zoom draws power and their computer just dies. I have a wired mic, headphones, and power, and it just never breaks. Wireless is just temporary, if you have wireless headphones, you have to plug in a wire to charge them. If your computer has a battery built in, you have to plug it in every day to charge. So it's just an extra chore that makes your life worse. Not that exciting. Maybe everyone fantasizes about being a digital nomad. I do not. I have a great desk, chair, keyboard, and 3 monitors. I couldn't work without them. If I want to see the world, I'll go do that without bringing my computer. A vacation with your computer is just work. A question I'm asked is "what if there's a power outage" but we have had about 10 total minutes of power outage here in Brooklyn in the 10 years I've lived here (during Hurricane Sandy). My thought is I just won't do any work if there isn't any power. We waste an hour a day dealing with wireless not working, 10 minutes every 10 years is no big deal. ("But what if it's the big one!?" Then my ISP's backup batteries will also be drained and I still can't work.)
- recursive 5y agoFor me the appeal is that I don't need to figure out how to run wires all over my house, or have them stapled to the walls or something. Wifi works well enough that I would never get to a net positive after considering the ethernet wrangling project inconvenience.
- Gigachad 5y agoWireless makes cleaning and vacuuming so much easier. Also means I can walk around while in calls. And it just works well enough that the times it doesn't are more than made up for the times it does work.
- vonseel 5y agoWiFi is fine for most consumers, it’s only really a problem if you have a big enough of a house to need multiple APs with wired backhaul, but the cabling isn’t there so you go with wireless backhaul / meshing. Wired backhaul always works better in my experience.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ryukoposting 5y agoI yearn for the day that I will get to work at a company that gives me a wired connection at my desk.
- tablespoon 5y ago> I yearn for the day that I will get to work at a company that gives me a wired connection at my desk. It boggles my mind that any company wouldn't do that. Wifi sucks so bad and offices are so dense with people. The cube at my office have several network drops each, across many different cubicle systems. I figured they were standard equipment.
- ryukoposting 5y agoStartups.
- can16358p 5y agoWireless (and LTE hotspots) gives me freedom to get my laptop and work with wherever I like with my laptop. I don't need cabled connections of any kind 99.9% of the time, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth headset, and my laptop "just work". Any stability and performance gain from using a wired setup is negligible in daily life (apart from very specific tasks) and convenience of wireless is far outweighing any gains of wires. Been this way for many years with zero issues. So yeah, I like this "trap".
- anonu 5y agoYet were moving quickly to millimeter wave 5G tech... which apparently doesn't have the same congestion issues that WiFi or other older cell technologies do.
- zw123456 5y agoI would not call it a trap, I would call it a trade off. But I am quibbling over semantics. I would reference Shannon here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon%E2%80%93Hartley_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon%E2%80%93Hartley_theore... which essentially says the following: C ~= B * SINR ( see the link for exactness ) C is the capacity of the link (think bps) B is the amount of spectrum ( how many Mhz can I get across the medium ) and SINR is Signal to Interference and Noise Ratio If you think about this, of course, wireless will be limited spectrum, there are only so many Mhz that is made available for whatever wireless standard you are thinking about, Wifi, 4G, 5G, Bluetooth, whatever. And, obviously, wireless will struggle with Noise and Interference. Wired solutions, whether shielded twisted pair (e.g. CAT6) or Coax, or Fiber or Waveguide, whatever, will do much better on SINR, you have thermal noise sure, but generally, it would be a much quieter medium. Also, you would not have the FCC saying you only get X Mhz, whatever you can get across that medium you get to use. Thinking about all of these factors then of course, Wired will generally win out, all things being equal. The Trade off, is that wireless is more convenient.
- xeyownt 5y agoIt is more convenient on the short term. On the long term, if you look for reliability and hassle-free setup, you lose the benefit of convenience.
- kuschku 5y agoWhen you’re using 100% of the spectrum on your wires, you can just put down a second shielded cable. When you’re using 100% of the spectrum of the air, that’s it.
- richardfey 5y agoThe further problem with the Logitech device can be explained by driver or firmware updates: the driver may upload a firmware blob when device is powered up and if the combination of the two is not well tested you might get some unwelcome surprise. Another more mundane reason for jankyness could be related to I/O saturation: your mouse will not necessarily be prioritised when a variety of workloads are being handled by your OS.
- Pxtl 5y agoThis. I love Logitech hardware but G hub is software cancer.
- tempnow987 5y agoI love wired connectections. The LATENCY is noticeably better. If you are on a zoom call with both parties on headsets and on wired connections (so no echo cancellation needed) or other audio connections I find it noticeably better (less stepping on each other etc). I have AT&T's fiber product (2 Gbps) and the office has their biz product (300 Mbps) and latency between is good and to google et al is great (< 10 ms in almost all situations).
- nomel 5y agoAt home, my WiFi vs Ethernet ping is just a few ms different. For data, my WiFi 6 devices (most of them now) are faster over WiFi. But, at work, there's hundreds of ms difference between ethernet and WiFi. I assume it because most offices use mesh networks now, and none here are WiFi 6. So, network setup and router quality definitely play a part. My AP was ~$200, used for streaming VR.
- nezgar 5y agoWired ethernet resolves most of my own teams/zoom/webex etc anxiety that any glitches in anyones meeting video or audio are probably NOT caused by my own connection....
- jchw 5y agoA little pro-tip for those about to run wires through your walls: use shielded cables. Also, probably don’t run them anywhere near AC wire. Some people recommend a full stud between them, whereas the NEC allows them to be run next to eachother as long as there is at least 50mm of clearance. I think this is usually recommended for safety reasons, to prevent mistakes from causing high voltage to get into your low voltage runs and become a shock hazard or potentially start a fire. But, I have noticed empirically that running a bit too close with the wrong cable does absolutely result in some serious interference issues. So… your wired connections are not free of signal issues either, especially if you want to neatly run them in-wall. edit: also, worth noting that this is a highly U.S. centric piece of advice. I mean I’m sure it applies elsewhere, but both electrical systems and construction differences probably make some of the details very different, and I’m not cultured enough to know exactly which and how.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fulafel 5y agoEthernet on copper cabling doesn't seem to be keeping up, shielded or not, previous and current gen ethernet (10g/100g) over copper is really power hungry or nonexistent.
- jchw 5y agoConsumer devices hardly even have 10Gbit, and often don’t even have WiFi 6. Even if they did, my NAS running on spinning rust is not bottlenecked on network bandwidth even slightly, and affording the amount of switching fabric necessary to sustain 10Gbit across all my devices is not economical right now. I mean, this might be different for fiber in some regards, but I doubt that is terribly economical either.
- fulafel 5y agoConsumer NAS and laptops[1] do have it and with SSDs the story is different. [1] Or more accurately, as laptops dropped builtin ethernet ports, the kind of ethernet you use got decoupled from the laptop model.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- musicale 5y ago> Qt included a component which would poll for networks every 30 seconds whenever a “network access manager” was instantiated, causing pretty much any Qt app using the network to degrade your wifi for ~5 out of every 30 seconds. This intrigues me and makes me wonder: 1. Why should it need to do this? 2. Why should this degrade the wireless network performance? (I don't recall the details of wi-fi but shouldn't it be able to do this passively without disrupting anything?)
- foobarian 5y ago2. if it needs to send/receive at the lowest bitrate (used for discovery/broadcasting) that takes up a ton of wall clock time, which is equivalent to a lot of bandwidth at the highest bitrate.
- hedgehog 5y ago1. If you want the machine to switch to stronger / more preferred networks when available it needs to know about them somehow. 2. The radio in most (all?) WiFi radios can only tune to one channel at a time, scanning all channels requires retuning to each one, which takes a little time.
- ogoffart 5y ago> 1. Why should it need to do this? I vaguely remember from the time (~10 years ago) is that this was a requirement for phones (eg, when Qt is used on a Nokia phone) that the network request go to the interface preferred by the user (so not to use the cell network when wifi is available). Anyway, the whole thing was implemented in a "bearer manager" plugin, and that thing was quite buggy. https://doc.qt.io/qt-5/bearer-management.html https://doc.qt.io/qt-5/bearer-management.html I think apart from people running Qt on phone, this had virtually no use. And yet this was enabled by default on all platform, and causing lots of troubles. What we ended up doing for the application we were shipping was to make sure that this plugin was not included in the final package.
- walnutclosefarm 5y agoMy broadband access has been wireless ethernet, over a roughly 5 mile hop from the nearest tower, for roughly 20 years. I'd still be using 14.4kpbs modems over copper telephone wire without it. From the post in the South pasture where we pick that up, it's wired to the two dwellings on the place, and pure wireless after that, including extension APs in two more outbuildings, and a LR outdoor AP. Rarely have any trouble with any of it. Of course, I don't have to worry about my neighbor's router causing interference - the nearest neighbor with broadband is half a mile away, most of which, from a line of site point of view, is through dirt. Before I retired, I was CTO for a hospital where we ran 14,000+ APs on roughly 100 sites, serving 100,000 or so employees, patients and visitors daily. I regularly used it at a restaurant across the street from one of our buildings. The service was highly reliable and available nearly everywhere. (And, believe me, if you took away a surgeon's wifi that she or he used to do quick email and other updates between surgeries, you'd know it in short order. So, yeah, wifi can require some management, but the thought of running all those laptops, phones (you couldn't rely on cell service - which of course is another form of wireless - inside most of the buildings - worked some places, not others), and portable medical devices only on wired ethernet is a non starter. As for other forms of wireless - Bluetooth and BLE have their issues, but you get an awful lot in return.
- franklyemphatic 5y agoIf you mess with a doctor's icon placement you hear about it. If a computer they use looks old I hear about it. So, yeah. Don't mess with wifi.
- keithnz 5y agoI have everything wired except my headset (Technics EAH-A800), which works well, I haven't had any problems with it. Network cable vs Wifi is a REALLY different experience in terms of performance and ping, which I care more about for gaming than for work.
- chrismcb 5y agoI dunno my wireless just works. Two people in the house running meetings on wireless. TV is on wireless. Everything seems fine. My wireless keyboard acts up sometimes, but I blame the keyboard not wireless. I do run wires when I can, but that is mostly just the equipment near the modem Perhaps it's because we are in the suburbs and the house is fairly open. Or maybe I just have my wireless setup properly.
- sgtnoodle 5y agoI ventured under my 120 year old house to make a couple Ethernet runs. It took a lot of meditation on my part to bear doing it. On one run, I needed my wife to pull on a fish line from above, but then she had to feed the baby, and so I watched an episode of star trek on my phone for half an hour while wedged between wood stilts. 6 months later, I got a notice that the cable I used was recalled for a bad UL rating. Monoprice had to pay a contractor had to come out and replace it. When coordinating the work, I warned the company that it was a very dirty job that would require two people. They sent an older guy out all alone, and he poked around for half an hour then left, saying he would come back with PPE and a helper. A couple weeks later the same guy came back alone and unprepared again. Finally the third time he came back with a much younger guy and bunny suits, and they redid the runs. I had stapled the cables up every couple meters, and followed a Manhattan path based on where I could crawl to. they just fished it in a straight line, and left it resting in the dirt. They presumably billed Monoprice several thousand dollars...
- humpday69 5y agoWhat is a "bunny suit" in this context? The web results make me wonder if there was miscommunication about hiring plumbers for a "very dirty job" if you know what I mean.
- sgtnoodle 5y agoOh, and they left the box of recalled cable that I hadn't installed yet, so I have like 400ft of free but uninstallable CAT6.
- ggm 5y agoI convinced my 8yo offspring that crawling like an alcatraz escapee over the under-house dust, asbestos, DDT, and probably decaying possum was "fun" and we did it together. OTOH he got the most fun using the power tools drilling the holes.
- vvanders 5y agoI often joke that I have an amateur radio license and only use wired earbuds for conference calls. The 2.4ghz ISM bands are just noisy, sometimes all it takes is a poorly shielded microwave to take out everything in a 50 yard radius.
- panny 5y ago>June 2020 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23589798 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23589798
- Pxtl 5y agoYeah, I still use a desktop with wired everything except headset. I need my wireless headset, I pace in long meetings.
- causality0 5y agoI ran a sixty foot HDMI cable and a powered USB extension cable through my crawlspace from my office desktop to my living room television. Relaxing on the couch is so much better than sitting at a desk.
- shmerl 5y agoNo question about it. WiFi can't come even close to wired connection, especially in latency.
- chazeon 5y agoI agree very much with what Ben have said. In my experience, I elect to use my once Bluetooth noice-cancelling overhead phone with a 3.5mm cable plugged, and voice from webcam. Life with Zoom are much improved than using it as wireless headset.
- chaostheory 5y agoOne con for Bluetooth that wasn’t mentioned is security. It’s an issue if you have this setup in a people dense space.
- jhugo 5y ago> For instance: most people, when their video call stutters, blame their Internet service provider. That’s understandable, since most ISPs are overpriced oligopolists with barely-usable software and horrible customer service. However, every time I can remember helping someone track down the source of their connection problems, the culprit has turned out to be their wifi. Can confirm. I work on videoconferencing infrastructure, and easily 90+% of the end-user quality problems we investigate are caused by the end-user's WiFi. It's very difficult from a customer support perspective too, because it's common for WiFi to have latency and loss problems that are severe for real-time video or audio but not so noticeable for bulk TCP transfers (like most speed tests) or web browsing. So communicating the issue to users is hard.
- crackercrews 5y agoOpposite experience here. It's always the provider, and when the provider fiddles with settings on their end it fixes the issue.
- DeathArrow 5y agoI like speed on my desktop and there's no way I can have 10Gbps link with wireless.
- 1ncorrect 5y agoWireless network links should be exclusively the domain of nomadic, temporary or sacrificial endpoints. If the device is expected to be used in a fixed spacial or temporal manner, or you care about the data conveyed across the link, constrain its path as much as possible with a waveguide.
- walterbell 5y agoYes, even WPA3 remains vulnerable to various attacks.
- 2143 5y ago> For instance, on my Mac’s built-in bluetooth, my mouse (a Logitech MX Master) displayed noticeable jank—stopping, then jumping, instead of moving smoothly. Anecdata. On my Mac the MX Master 3 works flawlessly via Bluetooth. However, it has janks when I use it on my recently purchased ThinkPad running Linux. > Similarly, when connected to Mac bluetooth, my Jabra Evolve 75 headset would frequently have the mic or sound drop. It (mostly) worked fine on its own dongle. Again, all my bluetooth headphones work fine on my Mac, but on some (not all) of my Linux computers it sometimes work and sometimes doesn't. I don't know if it's Linux or the hardware. Also, on the aforementioned ThinkPad, when I connect a new device via bluetooth the wifi disconnects and immediately reconnects 40% of the time. Don't know what's up with that. I've been using Linux long enough to take things like these in its stride :) (Btw, it was after I was issued a Mac by my employer that I started using Bluetooth devices regularly; before that in Linux it was mouse via IR-usb-thing, wired headphones etc.) I agree with the general sentiment that wired devices are inherently more reliable. But I don't know if we should collectively move towards wired, or improve the reliability of wireless.
- notfed 5y ago> Again, all my bluetooth headphones work fine on my Mac, but on some (not all) of my Linux computers it sometimes work and sometimes doesn't. The issue I'm currently dealing with is that my Bluetooth ZMK keyboard works flawlessly on Linux but won't pair with a Mac. I guess devices are nuanced.
- renox 5y agoYes! On my part of the bed video streaming with an IPad works OK but often this isn't the case for my wife! How am I supposed to fix this???
- mro_name 5y agoalso having a dedicated place for work is a bliss. Nearby the outlet.
- grujicd 5y agoI have another problem with bluetooth - sharing. With a cable you always know the device is connected to you and you only. With bt, another person's device can overtake your audio even if they don't mean to. They were paired once and now simple notification sound can take over your bluetooth speaker. These invisible connections from multiple devices are hard to track and often cause problems.
- theshrike79 5y agoThis is 99% a UI/UX problem, not a bluetooth or wireless issue.
- HWR_14 5y agoI find bluetooth sharing to be a feature. I can make my headphones enumerate which devices they are connected to. They can also connect to both my computer and my phone simultaneously, so I can be using the computer audio mostly and have my phone override the audio input/output when a call comes in.
- bmicraft 5y agoI don't know what kind of headphones you have but none of mine can be "taken over" while music is playing. Most don't do that.
- grujicd 5y agoMost of my problems are with JBL Charge 4, which I often share with friends. Multiple phones get paired and connected during a day. Notifications definitely can stop currently played music from another phone in this case.
- bowsamic 5y agoI’ve never had any of these issues, except for Bluetooth latency
- wodenokoto 5y ago> Any program on your computer can ask your wireless card to enumerate the nearby networks. This causes it to go into “polling mode,” where it spends less time transmitting data and more time listening for routers advertising their network info Except for the Wi-Fi widget I click on when I want to choose Wi-Fi network, what software needs this access? I can think of two use cases: - A Wi-fi diagnostics application. - Data collection to co-relate Wi-Fi networks and locations. I don't see why the OS doesn't simply refuse going into to polling except for white listed applications, because out of the box there is only one application that needs to ask for polling (my wi-fi widget) and I don't care if Google Maps wants to geo-tag the wifi in my surroundings, so just give it the list from the last whitelisted poll. And if I need a Wi-Fi diagnostic tool, then I am an advanced enough user to figure out how to white list it.
- mod 5y agoA lot of smart devices create their own local wireless network for setup, and manage the process of switching between them. Pretty valid use case IMO.
- a-dub 5y agolol. been saying this since 2007. although wifi works pretty well in professional installs these days and bluetooth earbuds were a godsend with masks. bluetooth connections are still unacceptably flakey though... even with top shelf name brand gear.
- aheilbut 5y agoI just have a 50ft ethernet cable running across the floor.. 3 years and I haven't yet tripped.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eafkuor 5y ago> That means that if I’m chatting with a friend in New York, the audio data will take about 50ms to get from them to my computer, and, say, 200ms—4x as long—to get from my computer to my ears. Since high latency ruins the natural flow of conversations, I’d like to eliminate as much of it as I can. For whatever reason this isn't a problem for me. I work with a laptop connected to my WiFi, use bluetooth headphones, and have 2-3h of meetings per day. Not a problem whatsoever.
- zerd 5y agoMaybe because you just talk, or just listen. Having a conversation where you go back and forth is when it's the worst, especially with multiple people.
- FooHentai 5y agoGood wireless is expensive, and not maintenance free. This is at least true in any business setting. At home, wireless is simply fantastic for mobile devices, but wiring in fixed items (PC, consoles, TVs) is 100% the way to go. Also, being conscious of what's in the air space is as crucial as the quality of your wireless equipment. It's all for nought if your microwave, AV sender, bluetooth headset or crappy 2.4Ghz wireless mouse is shitting into the same airspace as your network connection. I say all of this as someone that pushed HARD to switch our office from wired to wireless when we moved. Aside from the direct cost saving (~200k in wiring alone) the side benefits of things like not having to use a crappy 'presentation PC' in each meeting room was a complete revolution. You just bring your laptop, and it's not even going to shit itself roaming from wired to wireless because boom, you were on wireles the entire time anyway. Same principle about wiring in fixed items applied though, we put fancy ipad meeting room control stuff in, and dropped extra on ethernet adapters for them because they're fixed devices, wireless is not a good choice for that despite ipads being wireless devices primarily. Lack of visibility is probably the biggest shortcoming for enthusiast-level home wireless. I've had good outcomes buying ex-business Aruba gear and repurposing it for home use, but it's power hungry and you need to know what you're doing to get it off the ground. But being able to actually see what's sitting in the spectrum and watch the impact of things like turning on the microwave for ten seconds is a game changer.
- magic_hamster 5y agoWireless is an added bonus to my router which we mostly use wired. It's nice to have for guests and mobile devices.
- leokennis 5y agoCounter point: - I can move houses and just put all my WiFi mesh nodes anywhere and I’m online again. - I can play music from my phone while cooking, and use the phone besides my stove to view the recipe simultaneously - I can browse photos and create a photo book online sitting next to my wife on the couch, instead of sitting at an uninspiring desk in the working from home room
- alkonaut 5y agoWi-Fi used to be bad around the 802.11b era. After 802.11n I barely even see a need to upgrade. A cheap consumer router easily covers my 2-floor house with a half dozen clients without any dead spots. I imagine concrete houses or congestion might be different but I can’t even find a reason to get a mesh system in my house. Wireless mice and keyboards also work great. I use them even for gaming where many swear by wired. You can’t hide a mouse cable thing like you can hide an internet cable. It’s literally on your desk no matter what you do, so the upside of wireless there beats the downside. Same with wired internet to a smartphone… I still don’t trust BT audio though.
- swah 5y agoI haven't had problems with Bluetooth in a while - love my TWS earbuds, RF mouse, BT mouse and BT/RF keyboard. Those devices last for months/years on two AA batteries (other than the headphones of course). I will concede that the audio delay degrades the call experience a bit. Wifi on the other hand... I have no idea if its interference or the modem. It worked fine for months, then all of sudden my connection went to 2Mbps. And my Chromecast can no longer connect to it, etc..
- SkeuomorphicBee 5y agoI tried Bluetooth headphones a decade or two ago and at the time it was unusable. Then recently I thought to myself: it has been almost two decades, wireless audio is probably a "solved problem" by now, especially with its newfound notoriety after apple ditched audio cables. So I just bought some new Bluetooth headphones, and I'm thoroughly underwhelmed, it is nearly as bad now as it was then, high latency, audio drops (even some failures to connect at all, with no way to debug). Bluetooth headphones are the new printers, they fail (partially or completely) at their job half of the time and yet people just accept that as a fact of life and go with their days.
- pvillano 5y agomy use case for Bluetooth headphones is noise cancellation on public transport/airplanes. for listening to music latency doesn't matter, although for me it's enough that I can't use wireless headphones to play games on my Switch
- thfuran 5y agoThey also often only support shitty audio.
- lproven 5y agoObligatory XKCD: https://xkcd.com/2055/ https://xkcd.com/2055/
- rkangel 5y agoI work the "Wireless and Digital Systems" division of my company. Nobody distrusts wireless products like wireless engineers. That said, I adore wireless headphones and would never go back. Whether it's my earbuds to listen to podcasts while doing the washing up, or my BT headset that I use during the day for work. My BT headset (a Bose noise cancelling one) is definitely the most frequent cause of call issues (now that I've fixed a motherboard problem causing wifi dropouts), but it's still worth it to be able to move around, still hear what's going on in the call while I get a drink etc.again).
- test6554 5y agoWireless is great enhancement as long as you can fall back to a wired connection
- mc4ndr3 5y agoSo use a landline phone. Work at a desktop computer. Listen to CD's, not broadcast radio. Never use GPS. Never use WiFi. Never use RFID. Never use Find my iPhone to recover devices. Never use automotive remotes. Never use TV remotes. Never explore outer space. Never explore underwater. All must be wires. Because wireless is a trap.
- test6554 5y agoShould I tether myself to he house when I go out to check the mail or just never go outside.
- pkulak 5y agoMy covid project was wiring my house with Cat-6. Getting wires through existing walls is an art form, and pretty rewarding when you get a run working! I'm by no means a pro now, but I do own a 6-foot drill bit.
- test6554 5y agoHello ladies!
- test6554 5y agoI built my house with this guy's new mindset. There's 2 Ethernet jacks in every room. Even the closets, bathrooms, and garage. I have 3 wifi routers with matching SSIDs as well, because we're not animals... but everything can be wired if I want it to be. Also, this guy's "cable management", haha.
- archi42 5y agoThis is a true techy topic :) But the author proably mostly has expierence with bad environments (like apartment buildings with lots of competing WiFis) and/or cheap wireless devices or those which have to do severe compromises (e.g. style or size or battery runtime over RF performance). These were the issues I had: 1. SO's cheap wireless mouse produced WiFi interference -> massive packet loss 2. Small 2.4Ghz USB dongles plugged into USB 3.0 port (e.g. Logitech's wireless dongle or USB WiFi for RPi) -> USB 3.0 interference render the dongle unusable 3. The HTC 10 has a metal casing -> incredibly poor BT RF performance, causing massive drop outs (especially bad with my FiiO Q5 DAC/headphone amp, which has a massive aluminum case) 4. Client stays on AP with very poor signal (barely in range) instead of jumping to different AP -> retransmissions cause massive degredation for all other clients 5. Lots of APs running at full power in an apartment complex, paired with a router/AP that had low WiFi performance anyway -> bad everything All but the last can be solved relatively easy (okay, I didn't swap the HTC10 due to BT, though that really annoyed me; it's time eventually came when the battery lasted half a workday without using the phone for anything). Especially coordinated WiFi APs (like Unifi) are great. And even the last point was a non-issue both in our last apt (one well placed UAP for testing) and our new old house (four UAPs).
- roeles 5y ago> You might think this could be solved by having routers automatically figure out the least interference-prone channel to use, but many of them seem to be quite bad at this. Partly because of the physics involved. The AP can't magically sense the best channel for the clients, since it can't sense the spectrum at the client's.
- Night_Thastus 5y agoI feel the exact opposite. When I was younger, I thought wireless anything was terrible. Slow, inefficient, finicky, requiring constant charging. But since then I've realized things have changed. It's incredible how much wireless and battery technology have improved in the last 10+ years. If you want to perform at the top level in most games, you need a wireless mouse. It allows for significantly easier and freer movement than a wired mouse, even with a bungee. Charges can last for weeks, and due to faster charging can charge in an hour or two. And as my list of equipment and peripherals grows, I find myself wishing more of them were wireless so I don't need to deal with them getting tangled, needing to re-route them, them being too short if I raise a desk up, etc. However, there are some exceptions: * Internet. The reliability problem has largely been solved if you have decent quality equipment. (I have a Ubiquity Wifi 6 lite, and it works great) However, the delays are still there, and some houses/apartment layouts and materials just aren't workable. I think people overall underestimate WiFi though, as most setups are very poorly done. The crappy WAP in your comcast router/modem/switch/wap combo box is terrible and will never perform well no matter what. But a good dedicated setup with WAPs spread and placed properly will do amazing. * IEMs. There are no standards for transferring high-resolution uncompressed audio wirelessly right now (BlueTooth cannot do it), so the only way to get the best experience is a wired IEM. This isn't true for all digital audio transfer, like streaming. That can be done wirelessly just fine over wifi. (IE, wirelessly sending audio to a Raspberry Pi, when then sends it to a DAC, etc) The moment such a standard exists for IEMs, I will gladly swap over. The wires constantly get tangled, are too short, get damaged, or rub against things while moving leading to undesirable sound coming into the ear.
- zzo38computer 5y agoI prefer all wired connections. Many things are wireless but I use wired as much as possible. I have a wired internet connection, keyboard, mouse, display, telephone, etc. We can clearly know what it is connected to without needing configuration, there is less wireless interference, spying, etc. The radio is wireless, but that is public broadcast and is not a connection to a specific device. Sometimes it is unreliable, but that is not much of a problem in this case.
- paradox242 5y agoSince the migration of most employees to working from home I've run into this on a nearly weekly basis in IT where wireless works until it doesn't. Corporate networks can be challenging enough to tune in an environment where you have a lot more access and control than someone at their home. Often this is in a dense urban setting where their setup consists of connecting to the cheapest wireless equipment their ISP could buy. Once the usual quick checklist items are exhausted,suggesting that maybe we ought to just run a cable before getting into troubleshooting buggy wireless drivers, old hardware that doesn't support modern 802.11 amendments, or conducting a full spectrum analysis are often dismissed, or even if they are open to it, no one seems to own an Ethernet cable these days or their gateway is in a closet, basement or some other inconvenient location. Someday I hope that installing Ethernet jacks throughout the house becomes as commonplace as it once was to do the same for phone lines, but to many it is an afterthought as they are used to their crappy wireless.
- fabioyy 5y agoanyone have tried to use fiber? is there a fiber to ethernet conversor? ( to connect the playstation for example )
- meristohm 5y agoWhat's a rough ratio of power consumption by wifi compared to cable? I'm guessing the wifi transmitters are like radio towers but shorter, emitting radiation radially from the "tower", unless orientation doesn't matter and there are two other wires so coverage is spherical? Our mesh network units each have an obvious base, though I haven't looked inside yet. I don't care much about heat from electronics when I'm trying to warm the space anyway, but I'd rather minimize it in the summertime.
- FunnyBadger 5y agoThe other issue: security. I got my paranoia from working with military SIGINT - the things we routinely harvested from radio and telephone of the USSR was a major wake-up call.
- sally1620 5y agoI always use Ethernet at the office because Wi-Fi sucks when everyone is connected to it at the same time. Even though they use commercial grade routers. At home switching to Wi-Fi 6 has solved some f dead zone problems. I notice a stark contrast between performance of Wi-Fi 5 and Wi-Fi 6 devices.