22 ms·
No, you can’t save £30 per year by switching off your “standby” devices
- cobbaut 5y agoAnd what is the cost of unplugging devices after every use? Not just replacing sockets or cables, but is not true that (electronic) devices have a longer live if they are always plugged in? Are electronic components happy now with the constant power on/off cycles?
- qayxc 5y ago> And what is the cost of unplugging devices after every use? You really think your time is worth so much that taking 10 seconds extra for plugging/unplugging a device is worth even considering? > Not just replacing sockets or cables Never happened to me once in over 3 decades. Both sockets and cables usually have a longer lifespan than any of your appliances. > Are electronic components happy now with the constant power on/off cycles? Depends entirely on the design of the device and the components used. The notion stems from the olden days of analogue devices, which indeed often didn't like being power cycled. Turning appliances on and off twice a day, though, doesn't affect the lifespan in the slightest.
- jansan 5y agoIf you use 5 devices a day and need 30 seconds for plugging and unplugging, this will accumulate to 75 hours per year. If you make 15€ per hour, the cost of opportunity would be 1140€. Ouch!
- sidewndr46 5y agoUnless you're using something with tubes in it, there is basically no penalty to unplugging. I use a power strip with a switch so I have the option to turn off everything when I want to.
- lbriner 5y agoDefinitely annoying when "official" looking stats are not just a bit out of date but sometimes are completely wrong. Then a tonne of the uneducated take these things as gospel and either tout them to their friends or perhaps start breaking switches by turning everything off all the time. How much to replace a broken socket? Probably about £100 by an Electrician! The guy from the energy savings trust also mentions "Even the standby light on your TV takes up energy"! An LED? Seriously? So the crazy advice is switch the TV off at the wall instead. What happens then? Every time you switch it on you have to wait for longer for the PC inside it to boot properly and connect to the network, using much more energy than a tiny LED!
- vrfvr 5y agoWhen your PC doesn't need to boot when not disconnecting it from the grid, it means that there is more than a LED being powered
- sdflhasjd 5y agoThat LED by itself obviously doesn't use a lot of power, but it does imply more usage by other components. Last year I got a thermal camera to help with some insulation in my old house, but it's great for literally seeing this standby usage. The TV, when off, is around 2 degrees above ambient. The author of the article laughs at the mention of the VCR, but doesn't acknowledge that we might be wasting more energy with newer gadgets. Every "IoT" device that runs of mains power seems to have very inefficient power supplies, because they are regularly warm to the touch even when doing nothing: Smart bulbs (by far the worst), Alexa, Fire/Google TV sticks, etc.
- ericpauley 5y ago> Fire/Google TV sticks Are you saying the device itself is warm or the power supply? If it's the device it can't be caused by an inefficient power supply because the supply is external.
- sdflhasjd 5y agoI mention power supplies in both the colloquial sense, but also the power supply circuitry - I know things like the ESP chips themselves don't use much power. As for my Google TV: the PSU is integrated, so I can't tell.
- mordae 5y agoYou have it right. Many cheap always-connected smart devices use Low-dropout regulator (LDO). What does wiki say about these? > The advantages of an LDO regulator over other DC-to-DC voltage regulators include the absence of switching noise (as no switching takes place), smaller device size (as neither large inductors nor transformers are needed), and greater design simplicity (usually consists of a reference, an amplifier, and a pass element). The disadvantage is that, unlike switching regulators, linear DC regulators must dissipate power, and thus heat, across the regulation device in order to regulate the output voltage. See for example: https://templates.blakadder.com/athom_PG01EU16A.html https://templates.blakadder.com/athom_PG01EU16A.html You can clearly see an AMS1117 (a super popular LDO), right next to the ESP board on lower right. Most LDOs have a chunk of metal tinned to the board so that the copper layer can help with heat dissipation. You can quickly identify them by this design. Here is another one on a dev board: https://hallroad.org/images/watermarked/thumbnails/465/465/detailed/24/Espressif_ESP32_WROOM_32D_Development_Board.jpg https://hallroad.org/images/watermarked/thumbnails/465/465/d... More on the topic: https://www.digikey.com/en/articles/use-adjustable-low-leakage-ldos-to-extend-battery-life-in-wearable-designs https://www.digikey.com/en/articles/use-adjustable-low-leaka...
- jason0597 5y agoThe actual sad thing here is that incomes have stagnated so much in the UK and the cost of living has skyrocketed so quickly, that people are desperate to save even £30/year That's approximately equal to 3hrs worth of minimum wage work (£9.50/hr), and people are that desperate? But it makes sense when you realise that the median wage in the UK is ~£24k/yr...
- jahnu 5y agoIf you make say 10 relatively simple adjustments to your life like this then it ( at the risk of being boringly obvious :) ) would be 300 a year which becomes much more significant. So learning about them is important or you can't make any adjustments.
- blitzar 5y agoIf you cut out the take-away coffee and avocado on toast and you will have enough to buy many houses. Apparently going without 24,499 times would mean you have enough to put down a deposit for the average first time buyer in London.
- jacquesm 5y agoIf you made 100 such adjustments it would be 3000! And so on... but really: how many such adjustments can you make? And how much inconvenience will that cause?
- nicoburns 5y agoIf you have a low income, then potentially much less inconvenience than not being able to afford things that you need.
- jahnu 5y agoWell if you want to be silly about it, sure. (I even put in a friendly note to hopefully avoid such comments). But if we remain sensible then there is quite likely room for a dozen or so such adjustments in many lives where the inconvenience is negligible in proportion to the potential gains.
- efitz 5y agoI don’t know if it was the same in the UK, but growing up in the 70s and 80s here in the US it always felt like the future was going to be plentiful - think “The Jetsons”. I always figured that electricity would be cheap and ubiquitous. Weird that didn’t turn out.
- maxerickson 5y agoIt is cheap and ubiquitous, and getting cheaper.
- mnw21cam 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Too_cheap_to_meter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Too_cheap_to_meter
- PolygonSheep 5y agoTo be fair we could generate a lot more power a lot cheaper with circa 1962 (year The Jetsons began) environmental legislation. I mean you would have to compromise on the environment a bit but it's by no means impossible to generate a ton of cheap electricity. It's not some lost art like Greek fire or Damascus steel.
- automatic6131 5y ago>Weird that didn’t turn out. Decades of a green energy policy being developed by what are, apparently, human-shaped ostriches have led us to being partially dependent on an autocratic regime. Other things such as pipeline (US) and fracking (UK) projects being shutdown by a bizzaro left-green lobby mean a real difficulty in substituting the energy input that our entire economy runs on. Bizzaro because the left desperately wants to redistribute the very thing it's attempting to shut down, as they probably haven't considered that energy underpins all the wealth we have. And the greenies - who are nearly universally left wing also - probably will shout loudly when people are shivering in their homes and not getting enough to eat. And never blame themselves. But the real blame for this lies at the feet of politicans, blue and red, who have allowed these loud eejits to dictate energy policy: shutting down nuclear plants, subsidising intermittent energy without (the necessary and) even more significant investments in energy storage. Using green credentailism as a vote winner and nothing more.
- basisword 5y agoMy takeaway from this is that while you may not be able to save £x specific amount, you can make not completely insignificant savings in energy usage. While the claims aren't completely accurate it is probably a good thing for us to be more mindful of our usage.
- vrfvr 5y agoEspecially true since costs such as carbon emissions aren't internalized yet into the electricity cost.
- weego 5y agoThese are completely insignificant savings. The source aligns with a piece published this morning on the BBC which is very obviously a Govt encouraged piece attempting to push the critical failings from them (the Govt) on protecting the most vulnerable families from price gouging and speculation in the energy markets. It's just a replay of the carbon footprint playbook.
- pydry 5y agoThis was my first thought when I saw that too. It's a hamfisted attempt to turn a systemic problem into a "a problem of personal responsibility". Same way that companies that produce a lot of waste are weirdly keen on "everybody doing their bit" with recycling: https://www.treehugger.com/shell-oil-preaches-personal-responsibility-5085792 https://www.treehugger.com/shell-oil-preaches-personal-respo... Or the way that jaywalking was turned into a crime by the motor car companies: https://www.grunge.com/721704/the-truth-about-how-jaywalking-became-a-crime/ https://www.grunge.com/721704/the-truth-about-how-jaywalking... Or the way poverty/homelessness is framed: https://www.marketplace.org/2012/10/05/personal-responsibility-key-ending-poverty/ https://www.marketplace.org/2012/10/05/personal-responsibili...
- Forgeties79 5y agoI do think there is something to be said for creating a culture of sustainability. The values then become reflected in a society’s laws. If we as a people have even just a baseline consideration of our waste and energy consumption, then it stands to reason we’ll apply pressure to the truly responsible parties over time. It also helps remove personal politics from the equation if everyone already sort of agrees we should be mindful as a standard sentiment. The fact that we have folks whose identity is tied to pollution, to the point where we had people at rallies going “drill baby drill!” barely more than a decade ago, says a lot. Remember: the GOP created the EPA. They used to be more openly supportive of conservation. The truly responsible parties love the fact that millions of Americans are going to bat for their “right” to trash and pollute our country.
- mrpopo 5y agoTurning off modem/router for the night saves a bit of energy though (about enough energy to boil the water for my morning tea), with the added benefit of preventing me from compulsive internet browsing on my tablet at night. This obviously won't save the planet or my wallet, but helps me with being mindful at least.
- NullPrefix 5y agoBased on your described power usage, I assume your modem/router is actually a regular x86 PC
- willnonya 5y agoBought in the windows 95 era...
- jusssi 5y ago15W * 8h = 120Wh. For that, you can run a 2000W kettle for 216 seconds, or 3.6 minutes.
- NullPrefix 5y agoOK, I stand corrected. 0.12kWh is a somewhat significant amount, enough to boil a cup of tea.
- tomthe 5y agoYes, you can save more than 30 pound per year by switching of standby devices. I just calculated it for my TV: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=0.01+kwh+*+24+*365*++0.3+%E2%82%AC%2Fkwh https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=0.01+kwh+*+24+*365*++0.... which draws 10 W in standby (which I measured). It results in 25€ per year (I pay ca. 30 cent per kwh). I have lots of other standby devices.
- Jaxan 5y agoI measured almost all appliances in my house. And my TV uses around 9W in standby, so consistent with your finding. We don’t have a switch yet and I’m too lazy to (un)plug every time. So currently that is all wasted energy. Mobile phone chargers really don’t use much energy at all. So these can be left plugged in.
- djhworld 5y ago> And my TV uses around 9W in standby How old is your TV? EU regulations state that devices > 2013 must must not consume more than 0.5 Watts in standby or in off mode 9W is an egregiously high amount, maybe there's some setting or something that's keeping your device awake to be sapping 9W constantly?
- Jaxan 5y agoWe bought it last year. I think it is a model from 2019 or so. Perhaps something is keeping it awake indeed (it is connected to WiFi, and that is also how we use it: it is not connected by any cable). But there is not much to set up, unfortunately.
- ben-schaaf 5y agoThat's a crazy amount of standby power consumption! That's more than my laptop under light usage and way more than a mobile phone even under heavy usage. I really hope this isn't common. As an aside, WA is awesome at units. You can simplify to: 10W years * 0.3 €/kwh.
- ricardo81 5y agoSome advice but not exactly ideal for people on low incomes is replacing old appliances. I have an old TV that consumed ~290 watts. Similar TVs today consume around 70 watts, say 25% for simplicity. Variable rate electricity tariffs are ~30p/kWh at the moment. At ~4 hours of TV a day (I guess more common for older households) 290W * 4 * 365 = 423.4kWh = £127 @ 30p/kWh vs 70W * 4 * 365 = 102.2kWh = £30 @ 30p/kWh So a £400-500 TV pays for itself in 5 years.
- bluedino 5y agoMy 70" OLED draws 130 watts and is probably on 10 hours a day. Thanks streaming!
- natly 5y agoHow come tweets like these aren't tagged as misinformation
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- unreal37 5y agoBecause telling people to turn off their devices when not in use is not harmful. I mean, I can tell you I drank orange juice this morning when in fact I didn't. So it's misinformation. But it's not harming you to believe me.
- blitzar 5y ago> tweets like these A quick way to #saveenergy at home is to turn off tablets, laptops and consoles as soon as you stop using them, and ideally unplug them. This is a big potential #energy saver and could save you up to £30 a year. > aren't tagged as misinformation The only misinformation I see here is up to £30 a year as households would save more than £30 a year by doing this.
- pessimizer 5y agoBecause they aren't considered political. Platforms are mostly only looking for political deviations, something that a politician or lobbying group could complain about. If you tweeted that turning off your Apple devices would save 30£ a year, for example, and other people started picking up on it, Apple would complain and it would become political. Twitter exclusively hunts political deviation; they're not even nipple-hunters like the other platforms. edit: even its search for threats/abuse seems to be modeled on the "Zero Tolerance" policies of suburban schools in the '90s-'00s. Posting finger-guns might get you deleted like it would have gotten a second-grader suspended.
- willnonya 5y agoProbably because it's contradicting asinine advice based on outdated data and flawed assumptions. A better version might be tonhave peoole look at what they have in their home thats using electricity and why.
- fguerraz 5y agoAlso, even if your devices on standby draw the equivalent of £30 of energy per year, and even if you turned them off completely, you would still not save £30 a year if you live in a country where you need heating in the winter. Because apart from light escaping by your windows, almost all that energy is turned into heat, and if it wasn't there, you'd have to heat up your home more.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoAnd if you use air-conditioning for cooling?
- fguerraz 5y agoThen I guess you don't care about neither the environment nor money, so it's kind of a moot point. (I am not talking about using it in reverse / heat-pump ONLY)
- francisofascii 5y agoYep, Your device heat adds to the load on your AC. So if you going to bother with unplugging devices, it is more beneficial on those hot summer days.
- smallpipe 5y agoIIRC, a kWh of electricity is about 3x more expensive than a gas kWh. You’re correct if your heating is electric (resistive) though.
- newaccount74 5y agoYou are right, but your heating system is probably cheaper (unless you have simple electric radiators). If you have a heat pump, it will generate about 3W of heat from 1W of electricity, so it's 3 times more expensive to heat with standby devices that with your heat pump. If you heat with gas, it's much cheaper per kWh than electricity, but I'm not sure what the ratio is.
- yabones 5y agoExactly! Some people look at me with disgust for running an inefficient old AMD PC as my home file/print/backup server, but it's made the coldest room in my house very comfortable during the winter months. There are no central heating vents in this room so I would be using electric heat regardless, it just so happens that my heater is also filling an important technical role as well.
- AndrewThrowaway 5y agoI remember my father powering off TV. It was this old SONY TV with an actual power off switch at the front. The switch that does click/clack and breaks the power. Him saying that he will save some money. Let it be those 30GBP a year. I asked how much will it cost to change the switch when it actually breaks from this constant clicking. He stopped turning off the TV.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoSo you used FUD to convince him to waste electricity. The MTBF of the switch was probably 30k cycles.
- AndrewThrowaway 5y agoI can't remember the exact model of course but it must have been some 2000s SONY WEGA Trinitron. Quick search says it uses 0.3W in standby. 30k cycles / 365 days / ~4 cycles a day (morning news, evening) is ~ 20 years of clicking. Let's say TV is in standby 20h per day. So ~ 146 000h * 0.3W will be ~ 44 000Wh or 44kWh. 44kWh * £0.16 or so equals to ~£10.
- scraft 5y agoI heard this £30 saving stuff on the radio this morning, and it made me shake my head a little. I remember when I got a socket adapter that measures power consumption, and I went around checking all my appliances, eager to find out which are drawing lots of power, excited at the money savings. Started with my old, huge, plasma TV, that is the best part of 15 years old - surely chugging loads of power in standby? Nope, next to nothing. Monitors, same. Network switches, same. Essentially I didn't find anything in my property that was doing anything unexpected. Having hot water (which I get via electricity as my flat doesn't have gas) for a single day will use up more energy than I'd save unplugging all my devices. Similar for heating (again, electricity based) on a colder day in winter would cost more than all the standby devices. I remember a long time ago (25 years?) someone 'invented' a device where you plug your TV into it, and it has an IR receiver to go with it, you program it to respond to your TVs power button (on the remote control), and then when you go to put your TV into standby, the plug then turns off too, and when you switch it on it does the opposite. At the time it was being touted as the money saver, and I got the impression (although never actually tested!) TVs back then did draw a lot in standby, so this 'invention' was a legitimately good one. But it didn't seem to really take off, I am assume because standby was rapidly implemented in a way where there is such minimal electrical draw that it would be pointless.
- farias0 5y agoA good rule of thumb, and I hope someone more knowledgeable can correct me if I'm wrong, is that stuff that generate more heat will consume more power. So hot shower, iron, curling iron, hairdryer, rice cooker, this kind of stuff. Electronics that generate minimal heat will consume minimal power in general.
- Gigachad 5y agoIt's just basic energy physics. Making something hot or cold is real work. Same with moving something or producing light. But light is extremely "cheap" compared to the rest. Computing data or rendering a video game isn't real work and would consume no power if it wasn't for the inefficiency of current flowing through the chip making it hot.
- bencollier49 5y agoThe BBC ran an interesting piece of advice this morning on saving money from "vampire devices": "There are smart plugs you can buy which will let you check everything is turned off from your phone". How much power do the smart plugs use to listen on wifi?
- mordae 5y agoGood ones should manage below 0.1W. But I don't thing many are that efficient. So <1W.
- bencollier49 5y agoIt's interesting - someone looked at their smart plug and it was pulling 1.2W, the cost of which comes to more than some of the devices they might be attached to - assumes saving electricity is your only goal - in that case not necessarily the best bet.
- timrichard 5y agoOut of interest, I just checked my Philips Hue smart switch (Zigbee) using my measuring plug. It reported 0.2W.
- e2le 5y agoI have a Smart Plug flashed with Tasmota firmware, it uses 0.3W continuously (£0.73/year) and 0.7W with the relay activated. I'm sure there's smart plug's which use more efficient power supplies and/or MCU. The esp8266 isn't exactly known for being power efficient. I suspect that it would be more cost effective to worry about the energy consumption of Windows update than to worry about a smart plug.
- piquadrat 5y agoJust yesterday I noticed that a device installed by the cable TV company in my house (a WISI VX 2030 amplifier, according to the sticker) was warm to the touch. Measuring its power consumption, it uses a constant 15 watt, so about 130kwh/year. I don't use cable.
- kwhitefoot 5y agoDid you turn it off?
- piquadrat 5y agoYes, I unplugged it.
- cardiffspaceman 5y agoIt seems like it's part of the cable plant? https://www.wisial.com/product/vx-2030-065/ https://www.wisial.com/product/vx-2030-065/ "The VX 2030 is a location feeding in-house amplifier" Did your service say the same quality after you unplugged it? Did that of other people in your building? It seems weird that they would "install" this in your residence.
- jandrese 5y agoCable Modems are notorious energy hogs. I'm pretty sure some of the ones I've seen run their CPU at 100% all of the time in busywait loops. They are always warm to the touch.
- Havoc 5y agoKinda depends on the device. My desktop is at 5W for sleep state which equals around 10 quid per year if my napkin math isn't failing me (5 * 730 * 12 *0.23 /1000). So 30 for a household doesn't seem impossible Then again that is acceptable to me. Recently realised that leaving it on overnight at 150W idle isn't the best of moves though so now using sleep. Still not quite clear to my why it is idling that high for relatively modern gear.
- AussieWog93 5y agoOne of my old coworkers actually went around with a plug-in power meter and measured what all of his appliances were using. Ended up knocking something like $800/year off of his energy bill. That's not to say that certain modern devices aren't highly efficient in standby, but to call this a fraud just doesn't seem right at face value.
- iSloth 5y agoStrange, I've had a very different experience to the author of this, I've actually got a similar spreadsheet I may clean-up and post to show another view point, however in summary. A couple of months ago I went on a little mission around the house testing the power consumption of devices on standby, as I noticed through my energy monitor that idle power consumption was about 0.4-0.5kW while everyone was sleeping at night, which seemed high to my research of national averages. To my surprise a number of fairly modern devices I found to have utterly terrible standby power consumption, the new buttonless electric hob in my kitchen, the two monitors for my PC on standby, the TV & Blu-ray player and an Aircon unit just to name a few. Since then I used a few Sonoff relays around the house to add these to Alexa, the results were actually quite amazing really, about £10 per week of electricity saved, so £30-£40 per month... So in short, if your similar to me you can actually save £300 a year, I think the key take away here is clamp/monitor your own devices and take a judgement from there, no one house/setup is the same. --- Edit, here's a very quick screenshot of the spreadsheet and data I've got to hand at the moment, in time I'll get something better cleaned up and together. https://imgur.com/a/l4xMwbo https://imgur.com/a/l4xMwbo
- silexia 5y agoThe Keurig is the worst offender... Enormous energy is expended to keep your water hot 24/7.
- iSloth 5y agoVery true - To be honest at the point I knew the house consumption and hadn't yet clamped individual devices I had expected to find a single culprit like that, or even a faulty device with earth leakage that was affectively dumping the current for no real purpose. I should have also pointed out, I really do wish more devices would have more physical power switches where it makes sense - As an example the washing machine has a touch sensitive main power button, yet our tumble dryer (same manufacture & design) has a more physical on/off switch - The former uses a decent amount of standby power, the second uses none, the only real purpose I see is a slightly more "premium" feel to the washing machine.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoMy 'base' load in the house is about 100W.. Containing 3 servers (one 10W-idle Skylake i5 NUC, the other 5W-idle Atom-based, one Raspberry Pi 4), one router, one fibre modem, one 4G backup modem, security system, 5 network switches around the house, 2 Access Points.. Oh and one light (NUC) desktop I run 24/7 but in low-power at night (with most processes suspended). It accumulates to about 100W. All in all that adds up to a lot more than 30 bucks/year, it's about 1 euro per day at current prices. But I need all this stuff. Everything that drains considerable power is already on a switchbox. It's just the way it is, a smart house saves a lot of power but it costs some too. Still, we've come a long way. 100W used to be one lightbulb. Now I can run my whole house on that.
- aulin 5y agoseems underestimated, did you measure it? no fridge? no tv?
- GekkePrutser 5y agoI didn't count the fridge, no. I took the base load from the times the fridge compressor is off. The TV in standby is included though. And yeah it's measured. I have a Shelly EM2 connected to home assistant.
- aulin 5y agoOk, asking because I'm getting around 150W measured base load with way less computing devices but two fridges. I need to start monitoring single appliances to see who's guilty.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoYeah if you have two it's a lot harder to see. I don't have sensors on a lot of individual devices, definitely not the fridge. But on my house power graph it's really clear when the fridge is on because I see a huge spike when the compressor starts up and then about 50W constant load while it cools. Also, I have temperature sensors in both the fridge and freezer compartments so I can see exactly when it's cooling (which coincides with that power draw). But almost all my computing devices are low-power ones and that really helps a lot. Some are in the living room so noise was also a consideration. The only big exception is my game PC - I always shut that down fully and only really use it for gaming because even idle it will take 200W or so. I have an RTX3080Ti in it so it's not power-efficient :)
- t0mas88 5y agoThe author acts as if it's all bullshit, but actual measurements in my house disagree. I have a new (2021) 4k "sky box" from my ISP, a relatively new Android TV (2020), a PS4, a Logitech Harmony hub and a lan switch plugged into one socket. The measurement device shows a total of 35W continuous power usage when they're all in standby. Programmed a rule in my home automation to turn off that whole socket if it's after 11pm and the lights are off, then back on in the morning. It's around 100 kwh per year, which is more than 30 euros at current energy prices over here.
- lmt55 5y agoDoes standby for the sky box, the lan switch and the hub just mean normal operation?
- t0mas88 5y agoYes, with the TV thing set to "off" which really isn't that off.
- pjc50 5y agoHmm. I think I need to do some measurement on my TV setup.
- JshWright 5y agoI use a ZWave light switch in our bedroom that can trigger "scene" commands on a double/triple tap. A double tap at night fires a scene that tells Home Assistant to shut all the things off (and make sure the doors are locked, garage door is closed, HVAC is set correctly, etc). Double tap up in the morning turns stuff back on.
- tomerv 5y agoIt's a good thing if you already have home automation set up. But installing home automation probably costs more than the 30 euros/year you're saving on electricity.
- t0mas88 5y ago
- anonu 5y agoThe solution is to lower the cost of electricity. Why is nobody talking about this?!? I jest... 16 pence / kwh is pricy I think. Thats around $0.2/kwh whereas the US average is around $0.13... so around 50% more expensive in UK vs US.
- qayxc 5y agoWait, so your solution to wasting resources is to make resources cheaper so that more can be wasted? Got it...
- satsuma 5y agoi lived with my mother in law for a short time when i was between apartments. she would occasionally go around the house and unplug all of my devices in the early mornings before I got up. this was originally just the xbox connected to the living room tv, but if I had my laptop plugged in (work or personal) it would get unplugged too. i don't know if it was a petty "power move" (pardon the pun) or if she genuinely thought the standby mode appliances were bleeding her dry, but she's a senior electrical engineer so she should really know better. i was considering confronting her and putting in a kill-a-watt and paying her directly the couple bucks a month my standby devices used in power, but i figured that wasn't worth it.
- onion2k 5y agoEvery article that states you can save a small amount of money by doing something is tacitly saying it's your own fault if you're poor. You ate too many avocadoes, you didn't make your own coffee, you didn't turn your TV off at the wall. It's corporate PR to shift responsibility for the cost of living from billion dollar company profits to individuals who are already struggling. Journalists who write those articles should be banned from being published forever.
- uuyi 5y agoSo much this. Right behind you there.
- gruez 5y ago>Every article that states you can save a small amount of money by doing something is tacitly saying it's your own fault if you're poor. [...] It's corporate PR to shift responsibility for the cost of living from billion dollar company profits That's reading way too much into it, don't you think? >You ate too many avocadoes, you didn't make your own coffee, you didn't turn your TV off at the wall The "article" literally says the savings is £30 a year. Nobody thinks that's the reason they're poor. >Journalists who write those articles should be banned from being published forever. In other words, money saving advice should be banned because they might be spewing "corporate PR to shift responsibility"?
- onion2k 5y agoThat's reading way too much into it, don't you think? I don't think that, no. Or I wouldn't have posted what I posted. Corporations spend an immense amount of money on PR, and a lot of it goes on "perception shifting". As an example, in the early 2000s Shell spent $100m inventing the idea of a "personal carbon footprint" so that people would focus on the environmental impact of you using 20 plastic straws a year instead of Shell burning 400m barrels of oil. It worked brilliantly. The "article" literally says the savings is £30 a year. Nobody thinks that's the reason they're poor. £30 a year on this. £50 a year on something else. £20 a week on a phone. £5 a week on coffee. And suddenly the papers are full of "Poor people can't afford a house because they waste their money on things!" People do believe it. In other words, money saving advice should be banned because they might be spewing "corporate PR to shift responsibility"? Yes. Money saving advice when it's a paltry amount that won't cause a shift in your circumstances is essentially useless, especially if the root cause is some corporation trying to get out of being responsible for their actions. In this case, electricity companies are making record profits and increasing prices far in excess of inflation. The media should focus on that, not whether or not someone is using 20kWh on making LEDs stay on.
- nicgrev103 5y agoI literally read an article on this earlier claiming I can save £147 https://www.telegraph.co.uk/bills-and-utilities/gas-electric/unplug-microwave-tv-save-147-year-british-gas-tells-customers/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/bills-and-utilities/gas-electric... I am now regretting my decision to buy some smart plugs so that I can cut power to appliances overnight.
- cm2187 5y agoWhy would microwave oven clocks, tumble-dryers, dishwashers use a considerable amount of power when not in use? Surely there is a LED light but that should be tiny, and keeping the time should be even tinier.
- qayxc 5y agoThere are considerable losses on the power delivery side. The appliances don't have very efficient power supplies that convert the input voltage (e.g. 230V or 120V) down to the single digit voltages used by the clocks and LEDs. It's simply not a concern for devices that usually consume power in the kW range when operating. The simplest way to save power is to literally just pull the plug after use. It's not even much of an inconvenience either if the plug is reasonably close to the appliance.
- cm2187 5y agoMy oven and microwaves will refuse to function unless you set the clock. It would be an inconvenience in my case.
- qayxc 5y agoSounds like bad design to me. But yeah, if that's the case I agree that's indeed a major inconvenience.
- jihadjihad 5y agoA lot of household appliances like this are hardwired at the breaker panel. I'm having a hard time believing that running to the panel before and after each use of a dishwasher, oven, washer, dryer, etc. is something anyone would actually do.
- qayxc 5y agoMost ovens are hardwired, true. Washers, dryers, and dishwashers, however usually aren't hardwired (at least in countries with 240V AC) - might depend on the country, though. Personally, I've yet to come across a washing machine, dish washer, or dryer that's hardwired. Typical appliances in my region look like this [1], [2], [3], [4]. Note the cords and plugs. [1] dryer: https://elektricks.com/Stromanschluss_022.jpg https://elektricks.com/Stromanschluss_022.jpg [2] washing machine: https://image.architonic.com/img_pro2-4/117/4868/waschgeraete-siphons-2-01-b.jpg https://image.architonic.com/img_pro2-4/117/4868/waschgeraet... [3] dishwasher back: https://www.kuechenjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/Kuechenjournal_4.jpg https://www.kuechenjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/Ku... dishwasher front: https://img.moebelplus.de/xlarge/gaggenau_df251160_szene.jpg https://img.moebelplus.de/xlarge/gaggenau_df251160_szene.jpg [4] dryer: https://image.coolblue.de/840x473/content/5a1961ba7ab2e4818d6c3a32198b7633 https://image.coolblue.de/840x473/content/5a1961ba7ab2e4818d...
- lr4444lr 5y agoEven if you could, would it be worth the aggravation of the on/off wait to do this every time you finished with these devices to earn an extra £2.5 a month?
- traceroute66 5y ago> No, you can’t save £30 per year by switching off your “standby” devices I suspect this is probably true of modern devices with modern power supplies. No doubt if you've got a house full of 10+ year old gadgets then they possibly have more inefficient power supplies. Its likely worth considering modernising old kit because they'll be power-hungry during active use too, which will likely cost you a lot more than the £30 a year you'll save by turning them off overnight !
- CyanDeparture 5y agoWhen I was staying at my parents over the winter holidays, after they'd gone to be at 9pm, my wifi went down and I had to troubleshoot what on earth was up with my laptop. Turns out my dad turns off the router every night to save energy, it was pretty low on my list of things that might be wrong with the wifi.
- egeek 5y agoSo I got into this a bit over the past year, and put a SmartThings socket behind just about everything in the house. Not so much for the cost saving (which will take forever at £29 for each of the SmartThings sockets), but more to understand where the power is being used so that we can run for longer on solar + batteries. There's a range of devices that consume practically nothing when they are in standby mode, these include: - Phone chargers (0 - 1W) - Projectors (0 - 1W) - TVs (0 - 3W for the ones we have) - Laptops (3 - 4W for the ones we have) - AV amps e.g. Denon (2W) - Coffee Machine e.g. Jura (4W) - Printers (0 - 1W) There's a bunch of low powered devices that stay on all the time - Amazon Echo Show (4W) - Presumably the Echos without a screen but I haven't tested them If I turned all of these two groups off in the house when we are not using them then we might save close to the £30/year, but we have a lot of them and it's not worth the effort. There's some devices that you have to keep running, but will cycle, these are typically fridges and freezers. - Pretty much all around 1W sleep - 2 year old full height fridge - peaks at 49W for 7 minutes ever 30 mins or so - 2 year old full height freezer - peaks at 75W for 10 minutes ever 45 mins or so - 1 year old chest freezer - peaks at 76W for 12 minutes every 30 mins or so - 10 year old half height fridge - peaks at 66W for 30 minutes ever 120 mins or so - 2 year old half height wine fridge - load isn't smooth, spikes and goes back down, average of about 100W for 10 minutes every 60 mins or so - 10 year old combined full height fridge and freezer - 110W for 17 mins every 50 mins or so There's not much you can do about these (well I could remove some) but they need to stay on. Then there's some things that can be reduced: - I usually walk away from my laptop and leave it running. The external monitor goes to sleep, but the laptop itself continues to use 33W when left like this. If I put it to sleep instead it would go close to 0. Assuming that I leave it like this for 12 hours each evening, that's 0.033kW \* 0.22p/kWh \* 365days \* 12hours = £31.80 - with this change alone I can hit the headline figures - We have a Virgin Media Box and an XBox One X, I haven't separated their power usage, they both draw in their sleep/standby mode, but together they are using 38W when in standby. Using the formula above, switching them off for 12 hours would save £36.61 - Lights, yes, they are only 0.5W each for the Philips Hue, but we've 32 of them in the kitchen alone. That's 16W in standby, for say an average of 18 hours a day over the year when they aren't being used. £20.56 for the kitchen lights to be "off". Problem with these articles are that some older folk in older houses go round switching off the telly rather than using standby on the remote. That's fine, you might save £1 or £2 over the course of the year, but the house is old, the sockets are close to the floor, the risk of you tripping/falling is much higher. It's never worth it to save £1. Where it does make sense is people who have a few consoles in the house, leaving them in standby mode (particularly the one where it can download updates in the background), or just walking away from their computer and not putting it to sleep properly. Switch it off instead and you'll save the headline figures easily. (edited for formatting)
- Tarsul 5y agoThere are rules in the EU that allow newer devices only 0.5W or 1W standby power, so basically we have to thank the EU that standby devices don't kill us by thousand cuts. I recently bought a device to measure my power consumption and most devices (e.g. monitor, TV, receiver, coffee machine) only use 0 to 0.7W when in standby, so definitely negligible. However, my dvd player uses 3W in standby because it's from the 2000s (before this EU law). btw. next to my washing machine and dishwasher the device that uses the most power over time is my 42" plasma tv (from ~2008) with 150-200W. My 32" monitor only uses 22W. My PC uses 40-60W when browsing or watching movies. 200W when playing Elden Ring. I think it's worthwhile to check your power consumption. If anyone still has not changed their lightbulps to LEDs, please do it yesterday (a change from 40W to 10W is HUGE).
- milgrim 5y agoAnd despite these rules my Sony TV (KD-65XG9505) bought in 2019 uses 20 to 30 watts in standby. Only disabling the internal Wi-Fi and restarting it gets this down to about 1 watt. This seems to be a very common problem with Sony TVs and I have no idea how they don’t get into any kind of trouble with this.
- aequitas 5y agoI have a Sony to, standby is around 1W unless I enable some features like Airplay, then it jumps to 20W. Enabling the feature will show a warning in the UI that "this might increase power consumption". I think this is how they get away with this. They show this warning with a lot of settings. Also a lot of TV's have an energy saver picture profile which is horrible to look at for movies, but it's included to pass the rating I guess.
- milgrim 5y agoTried a lot of settings, but with enabled network I never got the standby power consumption down. It should also be expected that the TV uses the advertised amount of energy in standby mode with the default settings, which was really not the case for me. And don’t get me started on this „might increase power consumption“ message. This might actually not be Sony‘s fault, but the EU‘s, but it really gets annoying when it pops up all the time.
- 8fingerlouie 5y agoIt highly depends on what devices you have. With recent Danish prices fluctuating between €0.5 and €1 per kWh, i have been going through my devices, and there were a few of them that surprised me. I have a couple of Sonos speakers, and apparently every Sonos speaker draws 3-6W while idle/standby (https://support.sonos.com/s/article/256?language=en_US https://support.sonos.com/s/article/256?language=en_US). Having 4 speakers means about 20W idle power consumption, which amounts to 175 kWh/year (14.5 kWh/month), and even at €0.5/kWh, that's €7 per month just keeping speakers on standby. Another "hidden source" of power draw is a PlayStation. While it's fairly cheap keeping it on "standby" (6-8W), streaming media from it takes about 90W. For comparison an Apple TV uses between 3 and 7W (https://www.apple.com/environment/pdf/products/appletv/Apple_TV_4K_PER_sept2017.pdf https://www.apple.com/environment/pdf/products/appletv/Apple...) for the same.
- 8fingerlouie 5y agoHue lightbulbs use about 0.5W in their powered off state. So 10 of those is another 87 kWh per year in idle consumption alone.
- maccolgan 5y ago€1 per kWh? Is that a typo?
- 8fingerlouie 5y agoSadly no. Normal prices are around €0.35/kWh, but since the Danish electricity grid is based on renewables, with backup power being generated mainly by natural gas, that means when natural gas prices go up, so does electricity prices. Combined with freak occurences of low rainfall in Sweden and Norway during 2021, meaning less hydroelectric power, as well as an unusual period of very little wind along the Danish west coast in august/september, meant that most of the winter has been using a lot more "backup power" than usual. Solar is of course an option, but considering that the southern parts of Scandinavia is about as high up north as Canada, the sun usually doesn't shine when we need it (the sun rises around 9:00am and sets around 4pm during winter, with an impressive 19 hours of sunshine during all of December) As i'm typing this, 57% of our power is being generated by renewables, and the current price is €0.46/kWh. The highest price in April has been €0.63/kWh, but on March 23rd it was €0,71/kWh, on March 14th €0.79/kWh, on March 9th it was €1.00/kwH, and on March 8th it was €1.12/kWh. It was even higher in february. All of the above prices are "hourly spot prices" from 18:00 - 19:00, so the average 24 hour price will be lower, usually around the €0.5/kWh mark, though in february that was closer to €0.7/kWh.
- midislack 5y agoI switch them off to prevent large corporations from spying on me.
- noTooMooch 5y agoHa; I’ve always found these nickel and dime savings efforts, as if the waste creation at scale is offset by shaving a few dollars, laughable Nah; while the species as a whole is fine to grind forward without a care, I’m all in full speed ahead. Leaving my lights on in empty rooms, generating all the one time use waste; front row seats to the apocalypse sounds metal af.
- jansan 5y agoAs a rule of thumb one Watt standby equals 9KWh per year. If you have expensive electricity like we do in Germany with 35 Cent per kWh, this is roughly 3 Euro per year. 10 Watt standby does not sound unplausible I found that my subwoofer of a very well known brand consumes about 6 Watts in standby, and our old Roomba is very hungry when on standby, too. Get a device to measure power consumtion for a 15 Euros/Dollars, find the energy hogs, and give the device to friends and relatives. This will not save the world, but you WILL find some pontential for saving energy.
- usrusr 5y agoLong lived hifi equipment can be a huge offender, plenty of stuff still around from the decades between broad introduction of remote controls (before that, they were usually hard off) and broad introduction of switching PSU which aren't quite as bad as transformers (but early and/or cheap can certainly be bad as well) But I think "everyone" already knows that standby devices are a convenience that one should strive to avoid, the current fight is between people who insist on unplugging the USB charger vs those who refuse to do so. On this battleground, I think I see a strong case of perfect as enemy of the good: "refusers" are likely to react to pressure by ignoring the issue completely and might easily miss out on meaningful low hanging fruit.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 5y agoStandby power use varies widely by device. Of 100 devices around your house, there might be only two with unreasonable standby power. But those two will be costing you significant amounts of money. For example, I found my oven clock was using 15 watts. The oven is 20 years old, so over those 20 years, the clock (which I never use anyway) has cost £762 (at today's electricity prices). For that I could have bought a new oven! Other surprising high usage devices: * Audio Amp (on, but silent - 45 watts). * A power strip - 10 watts. Nearly all other appliances were < 1 watt on standby/idle, as is required of many new devices by European law.
- jandrese 5y agoWhat the hell is a power strip doing that needs 10w!?!? Did they find some outrageously inefficient bulb to put behind the switch?
- londons_explore 5y agoPower strips often have 'power surge protection' built in... That usually consists of a metal oxide varistor. When they have taken a few lightning strikes at the other end of the street, they start leaking power and getting warm. A few more strikes and it'll be drawing 100 watts and catching fire...
- Stevvo 5y agoOLED TVs runs pixel refresh compensation cycles whilst in standby. These cycles are essential for preventing burn in. So don't turn off your OLED when you find it using some power in standby.
- mdb31 5y agoYeah, this particular myth is common in many EU countries as well. Apart from the minimal amount reportedly saved (30 GBP per annum in real currency is 37 EUR/USD per year, less than 10 cents a day), it does not seem to be particularly true. I measured this (at the wall socket) over the years, and my findings are below. For battery-powered devices, disconnecting the charger once the battery is full does nothing, other than to cause the battery to be discharged more rapidly than it would be otherwise. For battery health, it's best (if possible) to set a 'start recharging' threshold at 90% or so, but that's mostly a device-lifetime issue, not a power consumption issue. For 'mains-powered' devices with a 'soft power-off', like many modern coffee machines, microwaves, etc. etc., the power draw in 'idle' mode is truly insignificant. You may have an atypical (broken?) device, but other than avoiding some transistor whine, you truly don't gain anything by powering these off. For devices like printers, monitors and TVs, I've never seen any 'idle' power consumption that was even noticeable. Some 'always-on' devices do have significant power requirements. Like: your set-top box (since it needs to records the programs you scheduled), your modem and/or media converter, and your fridge. With these: it's always measure, inquire and replace as needed/possible. For me, my fridge is as efficient as it gets, the fiber-to-Ethernet box from my ISP draws minimal power anyway and my Mikrotik router and APs are pretty power-efficient as well (like, 4 hours runtime on a tiny UPS). The rest goes mostly to my heat pump (which also powers my boiler), and in the summer months, this always offset by my solar panels, unless cooling requirements get way out of hand.
- ngcc_hk 5y agoJust today the bbc said you can say 100 pound plus. Sigh. Any executive summary of which is fake.
- Hamuko 5y agoMy one-occupant apartment is currently averaging about 0.15 kWh for the hours when I'm asleep. With my current electricity price, 0.1043 €/kWh, I could perhaps save 11.30 € in a month by completely eliminating that 0.15 kWh draw. Obviously, that's not realistic since I want my fridge to stay cool, I want my Wi-Fi beaming across the apartment, I want my NAS running services and I want my air purifier circulating air, even if I'm concious or even in the apartment. I think I'm currently on pace to save about 2 kWh/day with my new computer though, so that's something at least.
- PaulHoule 5y agoI think it's hilarious that the cable box (or satellite box) is worse than the others, in fact most of the others put together. The cable box uses more power when idle than a smartphone uses peak, and that doesn't include the display! As important as they frame the DVR I don't think I've known anybody who has cable who really uses the DVR.
- PaulHoule 5y agoPeople like Amory Lovins have long identified cases where it seems that you could spend $A today and then save $B a month later and after n months $nB >> $A. There are a long list of these where it seems there is a business case to invest $A in energy conservation yet people don't act. One trouble is that energy consumption is noisy. I remember replacing all the incandescent bulbs in my house (circa 2002) with compact fluorescent bulbs, expecting a few dollars a month savings, but given the fluctuations of the bill those savings were invisible. A few years later I was involved a project that involved evaluating the effectiveness of improvements in building energy efficiency at a large university and that turned out to be pretty difficult. We tried modelling the energy consumption of buildings based on the weather and found there was still a large residual of what seemed like random variation that typically dwarfed the effects of energy improvement upgrades. It could be that our model wasn't a good model, but it turns out to be very hard to prove that the energy and money savings advocated by the likes of Amory Lovins are real, so that's one reason why people don't invest in them.
- Helmut10001 5y agoI have a Shelly Plug S connected to my PC Speakers, which connects to my InfluxDB 2.0 via MQTT. The speakers use 11 Watt on average, even if turned off, which amounts to 96.10 kWh per year. In Germany, that would be 37.48 € (39 cent/kWh), or 31.51£ - only one device turned off. Now, I still leave it on, because turning a power adapter on and off 365 times a year may also render it useless after a while. I was actually thining about this recently, and whether I should use the Shelly to turn it off automatically, but did not reach a conclusion so far.
- aequitas 5y agoIf you live in the Netherlands (or Belgium/Luxemburg/Sweden) and have a smart meter it is fitted with a P1 port according to the DSMR (Dutch Smart Meter Requirements). If you connect it to a RS232 port (and pull some pin high depending on the version) it will dump a ASCII "telegram" every 1 or 10 seconds (depending on version) with all meter readings, current usage/delivery, gas meter readings and some other stats like frequency and phase voltage. It's very useful in determining your current power usage and "debugging" vampire drain. A good starting point is the HA DSMR component page[0]. I personally log the metrics to Prometheus so I can graph them over time with Grafana. For groups/devices that don't have a dedicated power meter attached I sometimes do a run where I switch off all the breakers and then turn them on one by one. The live power usage output is really useful to quickly determine how much easy group is using. [0] https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/dsmr/ https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/dsmr/
- djhworld 5y agoI'm doing something similar although I don't think smart meters in the UK come with a debug port sadly - so I'm scraping a third party API instead. Wrote a small script to regularly ingest the data into SQLite, then use Grafana to plot the results :)
- aequitas 5y agoCheck your meter to see if it has a blinking LED. Most meters have a pulse LED which blinks X times per kWh consumes. Before smart meters where a thing I used to have a light sensitive transistor taped to my meter and just count the pulses. Even older models might have a digit replaced with a mirror on the last indicator dial. Which can also easily be read. Another one is magnetic pulse output, which can be read with a HAL sensor, but those are mostly found on water meters. Don't be satisfied with aggregated low resolution scraped metrics is what i'm saying. Per second real-time power measuring is the thing you want :).
- djhworld 5y agoHahah that's amazing. My meter is one of the blinking ones yeah. I'm not sure if I have the patience to add sensors though. One interesting aspect of the meters is I think they talk over zigbee protocol, but I'm not sure how to tap into that. I think the in-home display uses it though to display "real time usage". The API I use gives 30m resolution which seems ok enough.
- sandworm101 5y agoBe very careful about some of these articles. The general ideas are basically correct, but exact numbers are subject to huge error bars. Your typical clam-type meter will easily be off by 5-10%, possibly much more at very low amperages in a household environment. So articles written by well-meaning tech writers measuring their computer with a 50$ clamp meter should be taken with a grain of salt. They are really not designed to properly measure anything less than a few amps.
- e2le 5y agoLet's not focus solely on standby devices. How much energy could be saved by simply disabling Windows update or discontinuing use of other CPU inefficient software? I suspect that across the entire population, it would add up to be a non-significant number.
- nullc 5y agoI had a single AV receiver that was using over 100w in its "off" state, one device alone easily blowing past that £30 figure.
- lokimedes 5y agoAs someone living in an electrically heated and well insulated house, all that vampire power is heat+convenience. My heat pump is surely 4x more efficient, but that 50W of standby power is not really wasted.
- cwkoss 5y agoUnfortunate shortened url in that tweet: "Find out more here: http://ensvgtr.uk/pS1ut http://ensvgtr.uk/pS1ut"
- herpderperator 5y agoImagine how much global power would be saved if NOBODY ran standby devices overnight. Not practical, but an interesting thought.
- abridgett 5y agoI did this in two different houses and it does depend on if you have bad culprits. By far the worst for me was a Zanussi washer/dryer with an on/off that went "clunk/click" and popped in/out - but would still use 10W (about £10/year back then). I just ignored that switch and used the wall socket switch instead. A few timers on other devices to turn off bluetooth speakers overnight. Over the ten years I lived there it was a decent saving.
- synicalx 5y agoI will happily pay my local equivalent of £30 each year to not have to wait for every device I use to start from a cold boot every time I want to use it. My TV takes ~2 minutes to be usable after booting, I use that every single day more or less - if I wait for a cold boot each time that's HOURS of time lost every year. Not to mention things like games consoles which update themselves and their installed software while in standby mode - that's more hours of time saved. All for the low low price of £30pa. Realistically I could buy smart plugs or ones with a timer, but that's more cost (probably more than £30), more complexity, and they'll probably cause at least one ungraceful shutdown which I'd rather not have to deal with. And the last thing I want is more discount IoT garbage using my internet to participate in a DDoS because the now bankrupt manufacturer left telnet on and forgot to change the password from "admin/admin".