27 ms·
How to Quiet Your Mind Chatter (2021)
- krono 5y ago> The human mind didn’t evolve to always be in the moment. Unless you're blessed with ADHD, in which case you're sometimes processing multiple moments simultaneously!
- PartiallyTyped 5y agoThe things I'd do to stop processing certain stuff. The worst of all is sound tbh. As much as I love music, I think I'd give up hearing for some silence.
- darkteflon 5y agoOh man, have you heard of misophonia? I didn’t learn about it until my mid-30s but the knowledge helped me re-frame a lot of previously very puzzling bullshit.
- PartiallyTyped 5y agoIt seems to be hyperacusis as the sounds are mostly environmental. Afaik I know it relates to difficulty modulating stimuli which checks out with my other experiences.
- amai 5y agoEasy: do some exhaustive sports. Go running as far as you can. Or do some push-ups or pull-ups until exhaustion and beyond. Do burpees. Or simply do a hand stand as long as you can. Because "if your body is in pain, it simply stops your brain".
- taeric 5y agoThis... doesn't really work for me. I do enjoy long bike rides, but unless I specifically take steps to focus my thoughts, I will have just as chatty of a mind during exercise as I will at any other time. Probably more so, if my mind is not otherwise needed to make choices. (And, "keep going" isn't really an active choice that bothers my mind.)
- LesZedCB 5y agoi mountain bike, and the climb, i have an internal monologue as much as normal. i try to focus on the woods instead but doesn't work. on the downhill though, silence. while skiing (downhill), silence. rock climbing same deal. those moments are bliss in many ways.
- doliveira 5y agoMaybe bike riding isn't really exhausting for you anymore? I used to cycle to work in the pre-2020 era, but during the first few months I remember how everything in my mind was about the bicycle and the road and forcing myself not to stop. After this first period the body adapted and the usual train of thoughts returned. When I noticed I was thinking of mundane things during the ride was when I considered that my body had adapted
- ehnto 5y agoI can still lose my train of thought while mid maximum effort deadlift, or pinned on a chunky downhill MTB section. I think it's less about the effort and more about the familiarity. I tend to have a clear mind when I am taking in new information, like during a ride in new place.
- taeric 5y agoApologies for the slow response. It isn't the hard or the easy parts, to me. Seems it is more the repetitive versus quickly done parts. A long climb up a hill? I'll be chatting in my head rather quickly. A series of up and down? A hill that varies? I could see those keeping me occupied.
- taeric 5y agoJust to follow up on if it is exhausting nine miles and eight hundred feet is definitely tiring for me, still. :) Probably different back when I did this daily. But right now... Dead.
- fattless 5y agoOh man, i know how that is. I’m getting back into mountain biking after my surgery, and after an hour or two into my latest ride, if found myself spacing out a lot and letting that chatter take over. Not paying attention during a slow, straight ride I caught my wheel on a root and fell forward over the bike, not fun. I found it much easier to slip into that state while I was exhausted though. I feel exactly the same as you describe, unless im trying to stay focused, taking in something new every once in a while or making choices, I tend to space out completely.
- marcyb5st 5y agoAgreed. Other things to do to complement that: 1. Avoid excessive multi-tasking 2. Minimize activities that bring immediate reward signals to your brain like opening social networks 100s time/day. Taken to the extreme do a "dopamine detox" period 3. Try to set a routine for yourself in small steps
- pfrench42 5y agoWorks for me. So far rock climbing and fly fishing require 100% of my concentration and voice chatter disappears completely. For me they are my meditation.
- nicbou 5y agoA walk, bicycle or motorcycle ride works wonders for me. It keeps me just busy enough to consider my thoughts one by one. When I go on long motorcycle trips, I come back with this incredible feeling of clarity and inner peace.
- b__d 5y agoMotorcycling is also my go to activity to disconnect my brain from almost all "chatter". It's just the road, the bike and you. As soon as you are an somewhat experienced driver and you can drive "fairly" safe in sailing/flow/cruise mode it's pretty incredible. It's just engaging enough that it feeds the brain with mental work, but does not leave any more room for unimportant "garbage". Took me around three years (around 30.000km) to get to this point.
- cromulent 5y ago> just the little voice we all have No, we don't, as Reddit famously made clear. https://www.reddit.com/r/NoStupidQuestions/comments/exan65/today_i_told_my_mom_that_i_have_no_internal/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NoStupidQuestions/comments/exan65/t...
- WJW 5y agoIt wasn't until I was ~25 years old when I realized that some people really do have a "voice in their head" and it's not just a movie thing that they use for lazy storytelling. My own train of thought is more like a graph of concepts/shapes/colors that does not necessarily have words attached. I can consciously "talk to myself in my mind", but there is not anything like a subconscious voice.
- mypastself 5y agoYeah, I remember being annoyed by comic books as a kid when I’d see a person thinking in full sentences. I’m still not convinced verbalization is the default mode: how slow would a person’s thought processes have to be if they had to spell everything out in internal monologues?
- jiggawatts 5y agoI don’t know about other people, but I don’t “have to”. I can and do think in both verbal and nonverbal modes. Verbal is usually when mulling over options, like what to get for dinner.
- mypastself 5y agoWell, I guess we all verbalize internally in certain situations (I definitely do when I’m writing comments or deliberately organizing my thoughts). In that case, it seems the original Reddit thread is based on a misunderstanding of the definition and scope of “internal monologue”. It’s certainly nothing like aphantasia, which seems like a genuine condition.
- 5y ago
- tigerlily 5y agoI don’t have any mind chatter, but I have strong phantasia. To emulate an inner voice, I actually have to talk out loud, to myself. I’ve quite enjoyed this ever since I was a kid. Anyone else do anything similar?
- anon2020dot00 5y agoSame in terms of not having a strong inner voice and using Otter.AI or writing down on paper to emulate an inner voice; phantasia doesn't seem to show much in Google so maybe there is a different term
- tigerlily 5y agoYeah I was using “phantasia” as an antonym for aphantasia, so just a placeholder term. I guess I mean I readily conjure images in my mind.
- SemanticStrengh 5y agoTalking out loud or writing significantly potentiate my otherwise weak inner voice. The question is: yes talking out loud is a very potent increase in inner voice quality of the thought and velocity. But how universal is that? Does everyone actually has a weak inner voice that has a hard time forming rich thought associations and rich sentences? Because it makes sense that talking out loud or writing leverage more neurons and therefore has more bandwidth. It even has some proof of universality for neurotypicals, see e.g rubber duck debugging.
- nicoburns 5y agoThis seems common in children when learning to read. Most can initially only read out loud and have to later to learn to do so in their head.
- tigerlily 5y agoI think it has reasonably high bandwidth, but it depends on the mode. A lot of the time I’m speaking to an acquaintance who is not present, and it’s a little like rubber duck debugging what I am going to say when I next meet them. Sometimes I sound completely over the top, or too fantastical, so it’s a good way for me to check my state of mind. The bandwidth starts to roll off once topics become circular, or there are too many repeats. Then I either just shut up or move onto another topic. Man I’m making myself sound insane. I hope I don’t accidentally dox myself one day. I liked your mention of rubber duck debugging, I think it’s the closest way to describe it :)
- joeberon 5y ago
- rvieira 5y ago(Slightly OT) but I feel this Nomeansno classic is an accurate description of mind chatter. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eIbZLOmGQSA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eIbZLOmGQSA (Potentially NSFW album cover)
- lemiffe 5y agoWhenever I'm anxious it is not just one voice but almost an internal cacophony. I found that if I shout "STOOOP" at myself (internally), while clenching my fists, it almost always quietens the whole chorus down.
- 867-5309 5y agoI have been increasingly tormented by repetitive music, whether it's something I heard recently or something my mind made up. it's got to the stage where it's practically incessant at every moment of every day. I also grind my teeth to the beat which dentists have commented on. on one hand I feel blessed that it's not voices but on the other I wish there was a pause button
- kinghtown 5y agoA musician buddy told me it’s because your mind craves the pattern and to see the song through to the end to find out how the tonics and keys play out. Also, modern pop songs are designed to be catchy. It’s not common to be able to hear music in your head, just like some people can’t visualize. So be happy you got a talent most don’t have. Thinking of these two ideas really mellowed songs playing in my head.
- ehnto 5y ago> It’s not common to be able to hear music in your head I did not know this, do you have any sources for somewhere to read about it? Not that I don't believe you, I'm just curious about just how unlikely it is to be able to do that. In music we call the above ability "audiation", and people who can't audiate are often not good at improvisation. It's more intuitive for people who can audiate, and more systematic for people who can't (ie instead of imagining new music, they are generating it from rules). I can recall and recite full pieces that I've only heard one or two times. I really struggle with remembering lyrics, but I will remember the full suite of instruments and what they played. I can also synthesize/imagine new songs in my head with those same instruments and voices, with totally new melodies and chords, I can do that for voices to. I can make anyone say anything in my head. I figured everyone could do some variant of that. Though remembering every note is probably a bit extra-curricular I wouldn't have expected it to be that unique. It's also possible that I don't remember as perfectly as I think I do, but because I can synthesize so well and have a fairly large musical exposure, I fill in the background instruments closely enough that it's the same vibe.
- 5y ago
- sph 5y agoI quiet my mind chatter by taking my dexamphetamine for ADHD. It's like there's so much space to think now, and it's lessened the ever present musical earworms that were infesting my mind. I recently had a fever, and the constant rumination reminded me of my worst ADHD days when there's never a moment of silence.
- darkteflon 5y agoSo I’m 42, and my 4 year-old son has recently received an ADHD diagnosis. We have a process in place and are working to ensure he gets support. But it has also made me look back over the particular challenges I faced - especially in my studies and my career - with fresh eyes. Would you be willing to share a bit about how you got to a diagnosis? Did you suspect beforehand?
- bloqs 5y agoA 4 year old cannot be diagnosed with ADHD. His personality hasnt finished developing yet (that comes at around the age of 6)
- tinsmith 5y agoGive or take a few years. There are a number of subtle developmental differences between individuals. Not saying the doc is correct on diagnosing a 4 year old with ADHD, as some docs still like to jump the gun on that. However, so long as the diagnosis results in evidence-based treatments that do not involve drugs, it may still be beneficial. I say this as a 44 year old who was not diagnosed until 41, and that was after almost 10 years of trying to explain to docs what was happening to me, and the hell that it made my life. From my perspective, it becomes a question of which is worse; diagnosing and treating too early (sans drugs) or trying to fix a broken adult set in their ways?
- DoreenMichele 5y agoFWIW, 4 does sound a tad young to me. ADHD is supposed to be a diagnosis of last resort after all other possible explanations have been eliminated. Sometimes bright children are mistaken for having "attention" issues because they are underchallenged and bored. Unidentified health issues can look like "ants in the pants" and be mistaken for attention issues. Sadly, drugs are all too often advocated for as a convenience for adults dealing with the child. This can cause permanent impairment because they impact the still developing brain.
- sheinsheish 5y agoI do it to a degree while meditating. Also, when improvising or practicing piano.
- khofstadter 5y agoThe best thing that stills my mind is concentrating on work (which could be linked to Csíkszentmihályi's flow state) or doing meditation. There are many different states of mind meditation can help induce and maintain. I think the basic categorisation splits meditation into two types: (a) concentrative/active and (b) receptive/passive. The fastest and most efficient technique I found is the Wim Hof breathing technique: https://youtu.be/tybOi4hjZFQ https://youtu.be/tybOi4hjZFQ
- rpastuszak 5y agoAny meditative activities, including sports, drawing or writing help me quite a lot: https://sonnet.io/posts/ulysses/ https://sonnet.io/posts/ulysses/
- davidhs 5y agoI do concentration meditation. After about 15 minutes most of my mind chatter has dissipated.
- denton-scratch 5y agoI used to do "proper" mindfulness sitting practice in a Buddhist tradition (I'm no longer a Buddhist). What I found striking about that kind of practice was that it doesn't stop the internal chatter; it's not supposed to. It renders it visible (and the speed of the stream of thoughts is startling). Commercial "mindfulness" training is sold as a way of calming the mind. I think it's unwise to approach mindfulness with that expectation. It can have the opposite effect; things can get stirred up, especially if you do longish sessions. Commercial mindfulness is also pitched as being completely safe for everyone. It's not, it can cause trouble, and it's advisable to have a good instructor on hand.
- davidhs 5y agoTo give a better context for my comment to OP, I began (again) practicing meditation early January this year by following the book The Mind Illuminated. I am now mostly working on stages 3 and 4 of the book. I noticed, in my mind, when I was using the technique Follow the Breath my mind chattering would mostly cease, not that I intentionally tried to suppress it. I still experience a kind of narration of what is happening in the moment.
- kgbcia 5y agofasting
- bigbillheck 5y agoThe interviewee suggests referring to oneself in the internal monologue as 'you' or by name, but to this it turns out that I am, as they say, Pagliacci. (Alcohol and benzos can sometimes quiet things, but of course that's not sustainable)
- the-smug-one 5y agoSometimes I get stuck in loops of thought about "what I need to do", such as "I need to buy X, pick up Y, return Z". Writing this list down breaks the loop. I think that counts as mind chatter :-).
- LB232323 5y agoPrayer is a meditative activity. He will quiet the storm in your soul and give you peace eternal.
- bigbluedots 5y agoIt is, but better to focus on your breathing. There's no question that it exists.
- specialist 5y agoPrayer is a form of rubber ducking for me.
- Zababa 5y ago> In Chatter you talk about how you halted a particularly bad spiral by calling yourself by name. That’s fascinating to me, the idea that what we call ourselves in the privacy of our own head has real discernible effects. I've found that it's very effective when trying to break negative self talk, for example when I'm getting anxious. Hearing my name always makes me stop for a small instant, and this also stops my thoughts. So when I'm starting to think that everything is terrible and things won't go well, just calling myself by my name stops that for a small moment, and I can try to get back to normal self talk.
- AccountAccount1 5y agoThere are a lot of people doing "Carnivore Diets" right now, that is, to eat only meat and just meat all throughout the day. I think this is a very important idea, it's not that these people can only eat meat, but in other diets there's a particular food that is triggering an auto-immune response in their bodies and they just cannot pinpoint exactly which one is it. So if some food triggers an autoimmune response -- the solution is just to stop eating (well kind-of.) This idea is augmented and explored much more in oligoantigenic diets where you go about removing different specific food (e.g. bananas one week, eggs in another) from your diet each week until you can tell which one was causing side-effects. There is a mental health analogue for this: meditation. You remove everything, you sit completely still and you focus on nothing. This would be the carnivore diet, but you can also go the oligoantogenic route, go about removing bad habits that are causing side-effects maybe video-games, Tiktok, instagram, or what-have-you that is just too much too fast.
- Buttons840 5y agoA gastroenterologist recently told me that I may not see improvements until I've eliminated all gluten for 4 months, I wish one week was enough (recently diagnosed celiac).
- AccountAccount1 5y agoHey, that's really promising. I think that it's always a net positive to try different diets and see how different you perform with each one. (make sure to keep your macros at the same level.) I wish that you can stick with it through that period & that it brings you positive benefits.
- LesZedCB 5y agoelimination diets are productive and useful, if you do them with a dietician or other licensed doctor (though ones with a diet specialty tend to be better). eliminating everything but meat is a genuinely dumb tik tok trend.
- photochemsyn 5y agoMy mind chatter is almost all symbols and images, and any time 'inner voices' pop up I just deliberately silence them. There are some useful little tricks for people who are always beating themselves up, though. For example, rather than saying to yourself "you really screwed that up, you idiot" just say "well, let's not do that again", or "next time, let's do a better job of it." Even so, schizophrenia is characterized by out-of-control inner voices, it's really not very healthy to wallow in that kind of thing. I read a little about schizophrenia; it seems rather like a case where you have a kind of mental fragmentation, like a bunch of people (i.e. divergent egos) in a maze (i.e. a single mind) who can only communicate with each other by shouting over the walls of the maze. In my area there it's not all that uncommon to encounter homeless people with this condition, they're often doing things like screaming 'shut the f*ck up' to noone in particular but I assume they're responding to the out-of-control voices in their head. It's too bad there aren't more tools available to help people with these conditions. I assume a lot of it is due to things like childhood trauma - people end up with very fragmented minds. Some kind of re-integration process seems necessary. Maybe psychedelic therapy? Feeding people tranquilizers just seems to mask the condition, and when they 'go off their meds' nothing has changed.
- artificialLimbs 5y ago>> The goal is not to stop talking to ourselves. That would be a bad thing. This... has not been my experience at all. When the mind is able to be quiet, this is when inspiration and insight is most likely to occur. I have best been able to cultivate the environment for a quiet mind (still a daily practice...) by focusing all attention on one spot in the body, over and over again, as much as possible through the day during any activity.
- mekoka 5y agoI found that quote strange, as well. Considering that so many of our problems can be traced directly to the constant inner dialogue (in one form or another), and considering how difficult it is to reach a state where you lose the habit, let alone the ability, I also think it was unnecessary. The most habitual meditators still have to work at quieting their minds. If you find yourself in the midst of a rainy storm and are looking for shelter, it'd be strange to first acknowledge the usefulness of water.
- jerry1979 5y agoI found that fasting decreases my mental chatter.
- dav_Oz 5y agoI wonder how "mind chatters" manifest in different people. There seem to be some who really experience an inner voice talking in full-fledged sentences and others with no inner monologue at all. My "mind chatter" as I am writing this down resides somewhere in the middle and mostly fragmented: I kind of "autocomplete" on various levels (grammar, semamtics, form ...) and writing/talking just initiates the process to tie up those loose ends into a (forced) linear fashion. So, when I'm finished with a sentence I see/hear it also for the first time; sometimes in amazement (good and bad). I find the evolution of human consciousness quite fascinating and the residues of that process still can be seen and infered from individual differences which can differ quite significantly/unexpectedly e.g. ranging from aphantasia to hyperphantasia. The famous/controversial concept of Jayens' bicameral mentality[0] in which "hearing voices"/"hearing commands" is meant quite literally and only later gets consolidated (through e.g. reinfored cultural practices) to an own inner voice. In a similar vein it is conceivable that there exists a common (not pathological) spectrum between forms of clearly heard (inner) voices to faint unstructured (inner) monologue to no voice/monologue at all. [Of course to a degree open to modulation through different states of consciousness.] [0]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicameral_mentality https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicameral_mentality
- Melatonic 5y agoApparently there are some people who do not think at all using language which is extremely bizarre to me. Also makes me wonder what mind chatter for a dog looks like. In terms of personal introspection I find it really interesting how ones "mind chatter" shifts when one is super tired or out of it or similar.
- pmoriarty 5y ago"Apparently there are some people who do not think at all using language" Oliver Sacks wrote a great book about this: Seeing Voices[1] In it he writes about all sorts of people who either never learned language or learned it late in life, and about what that transformation from a non-linguistic world to a linguistic world is like. Highly recommended. [1] - https://www.amazon.com/Seeing-Voices-Oliver-Sacks/dp/0375704078 https://www.amazon.com/Seeing-Voices-Oliver-Sacks/dp/0375704...
- purplepatrick 5y agoI don’t have an inner voice, and it’s a bit puzzling to me to read about journalists and/or scientists who seem not to be aware of that. It’s not that uncommon either: just ask ten people at a party or at work, and you’ll probably find at least one person who doesn’t have an inner voice… PS: I speak a couple of languages fluently (e.g. English is not my native tongue) and have never experienced any effects between being immersed in one language and “thinking”, except of course when I’m trying to formulate language consciously, for example when writing.