18 ms·
This is an important read, especially this part. > This highly educated and affluent person prioritized stability for her own children. But refused to publicly
by rayiner 5y ago
This is an important read, especially this part.
> This highly educated and affluent person prioritized stability for her own children. But refused to publicly endorse this value so that less fortunate children could also benefit from family stability.
I’m from a rigidly socially conservative immigrant family that professes fashionably liberal values in public—imposing a double standard between “us” and “Americans.” Meanwhile my wife’s family is from a working class part of the Oregon coast. Watching and hearing about the family instability in these communities is heartbreaking. Half or more of everyone’s parents are divorced. The kids float around seeking stability and the adults can’t provide it.
The article is right on the mark talking about the importance of social expectations for men. My family’s rigid expectations have been such a blessing. It made a difference that the way to earn their respect was to get an education and a good job and support my family, and knowing that I would lose that respect if I did anything selfish to destabilize my kids’ lives. The contrast made me realize that professing liberal social values that one doesn’t live by harms society. It matters what we say about what’s good and what’s bad, what works and what doesn’t. Creating a culture where men can attain dignity and social respect by providing for their family and staying with the mother of their kids matters. And creating a culture where men are told it’s okay not to do those things creates harm.
This isn’t really a political point though it sounds like one. Social change has swept through America so thoroughly that the head of the “conservative” party is a three-times-divorced man of little character. The social and cultural guard rails have been removed from the whole country. But the impact is obviously felt most damagingly in parts of the country where men need to find dignity in working at the animal feed plant are harder hit by that cultural change than parts of the country where men can find dignity earning half a million dollars a year doing interesting knowledge work.
- sandworm101 5y agoMaybe for those men lucky enough to have families. A growing issue is the large percentage of men who do not and will likely never have families to ever take care of. If we think deadbeat dads unstable, the incel community is a madhouse.
- fartcannon 5y ago
- PaulHoule 5y agoSome of them call themselves that.
- fartcannon 5y agoWho cares what they call themselves? That's theres to decide. Do you want them in or out? If you want them out, call them incels, if you want them in, give them the dignity of any other human and call them men.
- hardrcafe 5y ago
- sandworm101 5y agoIncels are a part, not all of that group. But they are a percentage. A greater number of perpetually single men, those who do in fact want a family as opposed to thise who chose not to have one, does mean a greater number of radical incels. Even without going full radical incel, a great many single males lose hope and lose thier drive to achieve. I work with some. They just dont care about work/money/stability/future in the same was as people with dependant families.
- fartcannon 5y ago
- recuter 5y agoI'm curios if there is a female equivalent of a radical incel?
- blueflow 5y ago
- Helitioo 5y agoWe need to find a better reason why this happens. I don't believe it's liberal social values which are not lived by. First of I would believe it's an educational problem and second it's a 'who cares' problem. There are plenty of areas/ghettos of low income and low education around. The blog also contains the following: "The people with the most money and education—the class most responsible for shaping culture and customs—ensure that their children are raised in stable homes. But actively undermine the norm for everyone else" How do they undermine the norm? They don't do this on purpose they are also just humans.
- aga98mtl 5y ago> How do they undermine the norm? Richer people have kids in their thirties, so the media is full of people in their twenties living it up. Poorer men have kids in their twenties and then they feel like losers for living the boring lifestyle of a responsible breadwinner. They want to copy the carefree lifestyle shown as "normal" by our culture.
- kevinventullo 5y agoThat’s an interesting point, one I wish the article had made explicitly.
- sokoloff 5y agoPerhaps the best way to copy that lifestyle would be to, well, copy the choice to not have kids in their twenties (or teens). It’s hard to see how the choice by some to delay kids is somehow undermining others. Conversely, the choice to have kids earlier brings its own set of benefits (having more physical energy is one that I wished for somewhat often and I think there’s evidence of earlier pregnancies being lower risk).
- nkrisc 5y agoIt’s sort of funny: they make the same mistake the “red pill” crowd makes. First they want to emulate a false reality that doesn’t exist, then some of them end up rejecting that same false reality that never existed (the red pill crowd) and end up tilting against windmills. Both groups have deluded themselves by choosing keep their eyes closed to the actual reality they exist in which is far more mundane.
- what-the-grump 5y agoYay the patriarchy! :)
- hardrcafe 5y agoAt least it has a track record of creating coherent, functioning civilization the world over since time immemorial. Can’t say whatever we have today looks all that compelling, and I say this as a “winner” with a high salary, owned home, wife, and children. I think of a future beyond my ability to retire to Margaritaville. What future lies for my daughters and sons? A hedonist utopia that denigrates and denies the most basic human imperatives? To build a family? Why would I want that for them?
- notpachet 5y agoI think too much attachment to humanity, in its historical incarnation, is misplaced. Those periods of coherent, functioning civilization may end up just being the gentler slope of the asymptote before things started going nuclear. The same underlying tendencies have always been present in us, they just weren't manifesting at the same scale. "Coherent and functioning" sounds great, but in practice that coherence was usually bought on credit, by pushing negative social externalities somewhere out of sight. Those externalities are more easily ignorable when the boundaries of the world are smaller. Just push the trash into the river; just tie the witch up in the forest. Just shut up and marry, girl.
- UncleMeat 5y ago"Functioning" is a word for it, I guess. I really don't think I'd describe a system where 50% of the population has basically zero rights to be "functioning."
- wpietri 5y agoA surprising number of people in the 50% who get extra privileges seem fine with it.
- civilized 5y ago
- bilbo0s 5y agoI hate to be "that guy", but you guys have this whole thing backwards. What men do is based on what men want. What men want is sex. If sex is free then you can have all the liberal or conservative values you want, but it won't cause those men to work harder. Why? Because sex is free. Full stop. If sex costs more than most men will ever have, then you can have all the liberal or conservative values you want, most men will still opt out. Since they know their chances are nil. Why? Because they'll never get sex, it costs more than they have. Full stop. No amount of ideology is going to change these facts. No matter what the ideology is. (Of course, now I think about it, you could probably change it at the barrel of a gun. That is, the government could make blunt force laws that would force women to lower their prices for sex and companionship, or force men to work hard even in environments where sex is free. Or both I suppose? But that's not ideology moving men and women, but fear of the government's guns.) And that's it. There is no grand philosophy behind it all. It's just a bunch of guys out trying to get off. And women out trying to get the best deal for what they offer. This is the kind of issue where liberals and conservatives generally go off the rails. They usually never account for base, vulgar human nature in their grand philosophies.
- BlargMcLarg 5y ago>What men do is based on what men want. What men want is sex. Too simple, though what you say captures the essence. People have breakpoints for how hard they are willing to work for various things. Some of them are progressive (relationship -> kids -> family). Some are lateral (relationship, starting a business). For a lot of men, they see getting a relationship is more difficult than just having low effort sex. So they get exactly that and continue on with their lives otherwise. Next step, families and children. Have a relationship? Cool, now look at how much effort it takes to start a family and raise kids. Look at the risks involved. Look at the demands it takes. Loads of guys go "nope, too much, too risky, too little reward" and check out. Society has been pushing to make it much easier to have sex risk-free. They have made it much harder to start a relationship, let alone start a family, by introducing all these risks and incentives not to. Plenty of men still want a family more than or on top of sex. They just don't want the current deal given to them. Cherry on top, almost every time the debate opens as to why men in particular don't want this deal (as opposed to "why do people / women not want this deal"), the discussion turns into shaming men into taking the deal rather than evaluating things and working together. No civil conversation, just a bunch of monkeys flinging poo. And people are surprised men are ghosting society, when you won't even pretend to listen?
- idontknowifican 5y agowhen you have kids for no reason, they know they’re here for no reason, and it’s a formula for a disaffected person. i don’t know if expectations being set because of being a man makes any sense, but i firmly believe you must have goals and morals. i think we spend a lot of time struggling with the roles we’re assigned. no for any deep reason, it’s just work and people tend to hate it. i think it comes down to the intent of the parent in having a child. to a point of course, if you’re in your thirties and refuse to grow up. it’s hard to grow up when you were raised poorly by a sibling because your parents weren’t interested.
- ekianjo 5y ago> when you have kids for no reason, they know they’re here for no reason, and it’s a formula for a disaffected person. That does not make any sense. Most older generations did not choose to have children (certainly not as much as we do) and it did not result in generations being "disaffected". If anything that's exactly the opposite - we are the generation when we have full control of who gets born and there's never been more unhappy families in History than now.
- huffmsa 5y ago> Most older generations did not choose to have children Birth control and family planning aren't a new invention.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agowell they're newer than Television if you're talking about effective birth control and family planning. And I mean effectiveness has risen since the first invention of the pill to where you really can control and plan things pretty well.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoAnd Family Planning is as old as old as the Hills if you're talking about marriage as a technology to provide a stable household for children
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoSociety would be a hell of a lot better off if more people practiced what they preached. I really respect the hardliner commies and theocrats on their respective ends of the spectrum for consistently doing this and for consistently acknowledging and not liking when they are forced to do things not consistent with their beliefs. As a side note with regard to familial stability in general, look how dis-incentivizing familial stability and fostering government dependency worked out for the communities it was done to in the 1960s and who benefited and who is still befitting. That's why it's being pushed, because the people who benefited want to go around again but with different/more demographics.
- bo1024 5y agoIt sounds more like the author wants "elites" to preach what they practice.
- throwaway6734 5y agoThey largely do? Divorce rates are much higher among people with lower educational attainment
- sokoloff 5y agoI think “preach what they practice” would mean publicly speaking (more?) in an effort to nudge behavior more towards how they act (in your example, to speak out in favor of sticking out and improving marriages).
- hotpotamus 5y agoRecently I've noticed that divorce rates amongst the richest are actually quite high too. Gates, Bezos, and Musk are all divorcees and Buffet has had an open marriage situation for something like decades I believe. Just something I found interesting.
- Der_Einzige 5y agoThey call it "new wife money" for a reason when you get rich...
- ss108 5y ago"This highly educated and affluent person prioritized stability for her own children. But refused to publicly endorse this value so that less fortunate children could also benefit from family stability." As someone both from a somewhat conservative immigrant background who is basically a coastal elite type myself, I think that statement is not particularly accurate or insightful. My main point of contention is that low-income whites tend not to care for what the highly-educated and affluent think anyways. Absurd to blame the "educated and affluent" for lower-class abandonment of their own cultural values. "Social change has swept through America so thoroughly that the head of the “conservative” party is a three-times-divorced man of little character. But that illustrates my point." I think that has more to do with hypocrisy and is symptomatic of deeper cultural and moral problems erupting among "conservatives" both rich and poor. "It’s the rest of America that most needs a supportive culture that tells men that by getting a job, any job, and supporting their family, they can attain a measure of that same dignity." These cultural groups can have that with or without the help of "elites". Again, they don't like elites. The article cites some anecdote about a UN meeting--these people tend to not even want the UN to exist. They don't know about the UN does, nor do they really care. No outcome of that meeting would sway their behavior. Ultimately, the issue isn't that somehow the culture of "[t]hose who sit at or near the apex of the social ladder" is failing these people. These people have failed themselves, some might argue in part precisely because they would rather NOT mimic what the people are the apex of the social ladder do. These people of course love to place the blame elsewhere, particularly on immigrants, but ultimately their culture has become degraded and their moral fabric destroyed from the inside.
- ibejoeb 5y ago> Absurd to blame the "educated and affluent" for lower-class abandonment of their own cultural values. The author isn't blaming the elite for the trend. In fact, he acknowledges that it has impacted all strata, even though the impact is greater at the lower end. What he's saying is that family stability is no longer a universal value. The thesis is that the elite set the fashion. He writes: "Those who sit at or near the apex of the social ladder (who decide what behaviors are prestigious) have decided that family stability is unimportant." When you say that "low-income whites tend not to care for what the highly-educated and affluent think," there may be something to that at some level, but I think these are trivial levels. The elite make the laws and rules and systems, and we all live with those. I think that is beside the point, though. It's not that the elites are saying, "Start a family and stick with it," and therefor everyone else is acting out in protest; it's that the elites are not saying it.
- stevespang 5y ago[dead]
- throwaway6734 5y ago>The contrast made me realize that professing liberal social values that one doesn’t live by harms society. It matters what we say about what’s good and what’s bad, what works and what doesn’t. Creating a culture where men can attain dignity and social respect by providing for their family and staying with the mother of their kids matters. Liberal social values includes committing and providing for your family
- meken 5y agoIt’s weird. Society has tried to influence me that money, wealth, status, career are beneficial. I was raised middle class. But I’ve never quite seen the point in all of it. All it’s really led to is a lifetime of beating myself up and asking what’s “wrong” with me. So I’m not sure more expectations and guilt is the answer. It’s hard to see how that would have done anything more for me.
- lolinder 5y agoOP isn't talking about creating expectations of money, wealth, status for their own sake. The biggest thing he says his family expected of him was to provide a stable foundation for his own children. This is something which some amount of money is necessary for, but if you focus entirely on the money you've destroyed that foundation just as thoroughly as if you failed to provide for them at all.
- 88913527 5y agoIt seems like a bit of a nothing-burger considering how low OECD birth rates are. More men than ever are simply not having kids. So if the objective is to create a stable foundation for the next generation -- and there is none -- mission accomplished. I have no purpose. It's the same conclusion, though a different path towards it.
- lettergram 5y ago> America so thoroughly that the head of the “conservative” party is a three-times-divorced man of little character. I think that’s an interesting point. The political window has shifted further and further left in recent years. The fact is he’s not the head of the conservative moment, he’s the head of the Republican Party. There are differing factions and he promised something most in the party could support. For example, he supported states rights during the pandemic and didn’t use force. Similarly, the focus was domestic production and an improved foreign policy. Finally, there was a decent support of policies for the working class. I’m not personally for the man, but I can see why there was support. It’s the most conservative president in decades by most measurements, though not personal life.
- throwaway6734 5y agoSupport for states rights was wildly inconsistent and dependent on the issue. The focus on domestic production was largely via anti free-trade protectionist policies. The foreign policy was largely unipolar and anti-nato. Trump is absolutely not a small-c conservative. He's more like a European right wing populist than Reagan or Bush sr.
- Ensorceled 5y ago> The political window has shifted further and further left in recent years. As an outside observer, I'm Canadian, this viewpoint of many Americans that their politics has shifted "left" is flabbergasting. The SC has definitely shifted hard right and Roe v. Wade is essentially overturned, or being, overturned in many states. "Don't say gay" and other anti LGBQT+ laws are being passed. I feel you are using a very "true Scotsman" definition of Conservative in your world view in order to paint Republicans as "left".
- fnqra 5y ago
- FridgeSeal 5y ago> it reverts to the centrist opinion of the 1990s/2000s I don’t know, sort of feels like we’ve largely moved on from the centrist opinions of the turn of the millennium. You’d get the half-shame branding of “metrosexual” for dressing better than average or liking things marginally off the mainline of masculinity, wasn’t exactly a particularly supportive attitude back then. > Brigaded in less than a minute. Well done, LGBTQIA+ KGB. Not exactly doing yourself any favours here. Behaving like this makes your point get lost in the emotional hysteria of your reaction.
- bannedbybros 5y ago
- giantg2 5y ago"The article is right on the mark talking about the importance of social expectations for men." Those only really work if the opportunities are there for the person to succeed. If you have no hope of success, then people just give up.
- lolinder 5y agoTrue. But people also just give up if they're constantly told that all the opportunities are gone, whether or not it's true. If you combine "there are no opportunities for me" with "there are no expectations for me", you get "I'll do nothing".
- mountainriver 5y agoYes, opportunity is a belief, in reality there are plenty of opportunities, it takes imagination and hope
- DeathArrow 5y agoIt takes imagination and determination. Finding the windows when the doors are closed. Not giving up on failures.
- giantg2 5y agoUnless you're locked in a room with no doors or windows.
- giantg2 5y agoIt depends if they're realistic or not. Without that, the hope portion disappears. Then one has to weigh if the job is worth it. With the high cost of modern living (shelter, taxes, healthcare) one might decide it's better not to work and just rely on assistance programs (I know someone like that).
- giantg2 5y agoEven if you have expectations, many opportunities may be gone. Just look at the lack of non-college work in the US that pays a living wage. Now try to get one of those jobs if you're competing against others who have no criminal history if you have a minor one. I have a job as a dev and even I'm tired of this treadmill. Taxes, COL, healthcare, etc. No time/money to do the things I want. No real career, just a job. Lies and discrimination at work. I don't blame others for giving up when their circumstances might mean that's the best option for them.
- unix_fan 5y agoI’m from a middle class, conservative family in a poor country. Compared to my richer, status seeking classmates, I can handle myself a lot better socially and emotionally. I’m also disabled, that means the social divide is a lot tougher to crack. In fact, I get shot dirty looks by the same classmates. It’s not because They don’t like the fact I participate in my classes, it’s just that they don’t like the fact that someone who doesn’t have the same status can equal them in a lot of ways.
- mountainriver 5y agoGood for you! Our struggles are often gifts in disguise!
- lkey 5y ago> Watching and hearing about the family instability in these communities is heartbreaking. Half or more of everyone’s parents are divorced. The kids float around seeking stability and the adults can’t provide it. You seem to be attributing the cause of this to 'Telling men and boys it's cool and fine to divorce' and not attributing to say... declining material and social capitol in the lower four quintiles of wealth that have created pressure that exacerbates marriage instability and numerous other social ills. Also, divorce sucks when kids are involved, I don't think anyone on earth, left or right, would dispute that. > Creating a culture where men can attain dignity and social respect ** We do in fact need a culture where it is possible for people to attain human dignity. I don't think that the path to gaining this needs to be a rigid and proscriptive 'return to tradition'. For example, with the advent of no-fault divorce, divorces went up, but female suicide rates dropped by 20%. It wasn't all streamers and light when the 'guard rails' were on. And speaking of America specifically, dignity and respect were not equi-distributed if you were a simply a 'married man' in decades past. It was quite a bit stricter: white, middle class or higher, married men were the ones afforded government support and social protection. > My family’s rigid expectations have been such a blessing. I won't dwell on this, but not every (or even most) children benefit from this approach to parenting. Extreme rigidity, in fact, is more associated with negative long-term outcomes. Finally, historically speaking, decrying the next generation as depraved, lost, and needing traditional discipline has been something the older generations have done since at least the invention of writing (across all cultures too!). Yet I'm still continually shocked that this argument continues to be unironically employed century after century.
- captainredbeard 5y ago> but female suicide rates dropped by 20% ...hmm, male suicide rates are going up...
- photochemsyn 5y agoYou might want to age-control that: https://www.webmd.com/depression/news/20200911/suicide-rate-keeps-rising-among-young-americans https://www.webmd.com/depression/news/20200911/suicide-rate-... > "Suicides among children and young people aged 10 to 24 rose 57% from 2007 to 2018, according to a new report from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention... In actual numbers, the suicide rate among 10- to 24-year-olds jumped from about 7 per 100,000 in 2007 to nearly 11 per 100,000 in 2018, according to the National Vital Statistics Report published Sept. 11." That's called massive societal failure any way you look at it. Oh well, I guess there's the upside that wealthy boomers can ride off into their cruise ship futures on the backs of 401K retirement plans financed by investments in student loan debt, fossil-fueled global warming, price-hiked pharmaceuticals and the war machine. What a wonderful picture, really shows the mentality here. Jim Morrison was speaking for that class when he said, "I don't know what's gonna happen, man, but I'm gonna get my kicks in before this whole shithouse goes up in flames."
- galfarragem 5y agoGreat comment. I would just make a minor but relevant change, everybody is responsible here. "And creating a culture where men and women are told it’s okay not to do those things creates harm."
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoThe article is specifically about men having children with women, then leaving the family by one means or another. While your inclusivity works in many places, the problem here is well defined as young men not striving for family stability.
- chasd00 5y agoWell why should they? All the hear every day is how they’re all monsters and the root of every social injustice.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoYour implication is that women are not part of the dynamic of the relationship Thats just nuts
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoYour interpretation of my implication is incorrect, and it's not my implication anyway - that belongs to the author of the article. Even still, this article is examining one aspect of a problem, not the whole problem. It's okay to look at problems in parts without addressing the whole.
- FabHK 5y ago> The article is right on the mark talking about the importance of social expectations for men. My family’s rigid expectations have been such a blessing. Émile Durkheim basically introduced the discipline of sociology with his study of suicide. He found that the ratio of suicide was higher among protestants than among catholics, and concluded that it was because they were less embedded in strict norms, and freer to do whatever they pleased, compared to the stronger social control among catholics. So, freedom turned out to be not necessarily a good thing. (He also found that suicide is higher in times of peace than in war.) Not sure how the theory held up, and what modern sociologists say about it. But that result stuck in my head, and it aligns with your experience and the article. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_(Durkheim_book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_(Durkheim_book)
- croes 5y agoFrom your link "Durkheim explores the differing suicide rates among Protestants and Catholics, arguing that stronger social control among Catholics results in lower suicide rates. According to Durkheim, Catholic society has normal levels of integration while Protestant society has low levels. This interpretation has been contested. Durkheim may have over-generalized. He took most of his data from earlier researchers, notably Adolph Wagner and Henry Morselli, but they had been more careful in generalizing from their data. Indeed, later researchers found that the Protestant–Catholic differences in suicide seemed to be limited to German-speaking Europe, thus suggesting a need to account for other contributing factors."
- DeathArrow 5y ago>they were less embedded in strict norms, and freer to do whatever they pleased, I would argue that strict norms - if they don't come into contradiction with what is natural and proven in time as beneficial - might imply more freedom than some kinds of "freedoms" or "rights" imposed by force if those "freedoms" or "rights" come into contradiction with the natural way societies and civilizations evolved.
- burntoutfire 5y ago> He found that the ratio of suicide was higher among protestants than among catholics, and concluded that it was because they were less embedded in strict norms, and freer to do whatever they pleased, compared to the stronger social control among catholics. So, freedom turned out to be not necessarily a good thing. Interesting, I'm from a catholic country and my characterisation of those two religions is basically opposite. Chill and rules-skirting catholics (Poles, Italians) vs uptight and law-abiding protestants (Englishmen, Scandinavians etc.).
- ipaddr 5y agoThose pressures forces you down a narrow path. Steve Jobs from an immigrant background would have never become what he did if he was forced into your situation. Freedom means you get to choose. Many choose unwisely. Without that choice you are limited to established career paths that can be easily communicated.
- Longlius 5y agoIt's not merely expectations but intergenerational poverty. I get that you think that you came from a less privileged background than your in-laws and in some respects that's true, but even being able to immigrate to the US indicates a degree of social mobility that simply isn't available to the intergenerationally poor in rural America. These are people who grew up in places without anything to do, no training for higher-paid professions available, and who pay first-world expenses simply to exist. How does one get ahead with 4 children and maybe $2000 of household income per month when rents eat half of that. This isn't simply a problem of moral failing on the individual level but of failings at the societal level to provide a means for these people to escape poverty.
- temp3444 5y ago
- Longlius 5y agoDepends on the immigrant family. The ones from Mexico and Central American certainly don't have much, but those coming from East and South Asia who immediately start businesses on arrival have access to more wealth (either personally or via social connections) than many native-born Americans will have access to in their entire lives.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y ago> Simple, don't have 4 children. Okay, but some people do, so what then? Fuck them and their 4 kids who did nothing wrong but be born?
- temp3444 5y agoWe need to seriously stop treating having kids as some kind of accident that just happens. It's extremely simple to not have children. American society is free, which means you are free to fail and fuck things up. If someone has 4 children the only person to blame is the parents. If you can't control yourself, get yourself sterilized. We don't need more of your insane lineage that can't prevent themselves from having 4 children on this planet.
- UncleMeat 5y agoPros and cons. A big challenge with rigid social expectations is identifying the beneficial ones and removing the harmful ones. In practice, there tends to be little introspection about which traditional expectations help and which ones hurt. Instead, people appeal to tradition itself as evidence that an expectation is helpful. If we could more effectively iterate on these social expectations then we'd be able to more effectively optimize. But efforts to do this (e.g., discussion of topics like "toxic masculinity") are by-and-large rejected out of hand by traditionalists. Another challenge is that social expectations may help on average but they may completely fail in individual cases. For example, having both parents raise a child will, on average, lead to improved outcomes. But if we codify this as a rigid rule, then people are unable to escape abusive relationships where the presence of both parents is a negative. Social expectations are necessarily generalizations and people need the freedom to identify when they are not helpful for their particular situation and adjust accordingly.
- DeathArrow 5y agoThe tentatives to artificially engineer the society to be more just, fair and inclusive only resulted in a less just, less fair and less inclusive society. The society should be left to evolve on its own, in a natural way. If we don't want to replace small disasters with big disasters.
- UncleMeat 5y agoCivil rights for gay people and black people were criticized "artificially engineering society". As were voting rights for women or access to birth control. Subservient roles for women and labor roles for black people were seen as "natural." I think you'd be absolutely crazy to consider rights for these populations to have led to a "less just and less fair society." There is no such thing as natural society. Society is constructed by humans.
- dc-programmer 5y agoI think the crux of the current debate is the tension between cultural liberalism and cultural socialism. The philosophy of the cultural liberals is to remove restrictions that inhibit people from living the social lives they want. The cultural socialists want to use the power of institutions to distribute a culture across the population. They believe their culture is societally optimal so reducing liberties to propagate it is morally justified. I’m sure most peoples beliefs lie somewhere in between the two. But the cultural socialism maximalists in the west have been getting louder and louder and it’s beginning to terrify me. I predict in the next 5 years, womens’ voting rights will be an actual political topic. It will start with “ironic” jokes and “rational” thinking but will get increasingly normalized in discourse.
- softcactus 5y agoMy problem with takes like this is that they are based off of a really sanitized historical worldview, and they don't take into account any materialist factors. To say that Trump is a canary of our social change ignores all of the equally debaucherous presidents we had throughout the 20th century. In my opinion, the biggest change has been the lack of financial reward for the average person. The bar for achieving financial stability is much higher than it was say 40 years ago. It was much easier to raise a family on a blue collar income.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xwolfi 5y agoI think you're wrong. I'm French so my "social conservative christian" parents still taught me to roll cigarets, that abortions saved young girls' future and that you shouldn't beat your wife if she wants a divorce, which is for me american "social liberalism". The way I see rigidity is to associate set roles to women, beating the gayness out of gays or shunning you for marrying out of your parents' religion. What you describe is complete laxism, maybe not telling men that they do have to own up their decisions, especially raising children that even someone like my dad did, despite being more flexible maybe than your parents ? And I'm socially liberal in the sense I married a Chinese and raise my daughter telling her mariage is not the only goal in life, that if she's gay it won't matter, and that religion is BS, but I still expect her to raise her kids properly if she has some... so I'm not sure your parents raised you well because they were rigid or simply because they were good honest people... which even the liberals you dislike could also be !
- gwbas1c 5y ago> I’m from a rigidly socially conservative immigrant family that professes fashionably liberal values in public I don't consider believing in matrimony, fidelity, and prioritizing ones' children as socially conservative. It's just normal. Just spend some time watching Tiger King to pick up on their lifestyles and politics: They might appear liberal because Joe Exotic is a freewheeling, open homosexual with multiple partners. But on closer inspection, they love Trump and hate Nancy Pelosi.
- camgunz 5y agoI think the post fails to make the case that male behavior (or the culture that induces male behavior) is the root cause of divorce rates. - The rise in imprisonment is basically entirely a result of the War on Drugs, aka carceral slavery. - The problems with employment are that unions have disappeared, jobs are hyperexploitative (a better measure than the unemployment rate here is the Social Security Disability rate), and real wages have stagnated. - Middle-class divorce rates (different than what the author references, which is not-getting-married rates) have only started to decline over the last decade or so. The link between middle-class families--where the author writes "Poor and working-class people follow suit"--is totally unsubstantiated by his sources. - I've not read this book, but looking at a synopsis [0], it's unclear to me how you could take a book clearly about women (162 of them!) and walk away with the conclusion that the root problem is no one expects men to stick around. It feels to me like more of a character study of broken systems (again War on Drugs, income inequality, etc.) - The paper referenced at the end [1] is junk? Contains a lot of self-cites and no original research? I can't dig into the secondary sources, but the amount of editorializing makes me skeptical of the foundations here. It also seems at odds with the rest of the post: if men will do whatever it takes for sex, it seems like they should be working hard to stay out of prison? Or to hold down a job? Is the argument that women should be more discerning? I'll also say I keep seeing this weird line from conservative or conservative-ish posts about people on the left not speaking up for marriage. I'm super left and that's not my experience or anyone else's I know? I mean, we're very in favor of gay marriage, and everyone I know acknowledges the research is pretty unequivocal in favor of two-parent households, so I think there's some nuance missing from this conversation. --- Broadly though, I do 100% agree our society is busted, and not just for systemic reasons (though those are big pieces). Many of us have lost a sense of community and place we once had. I don't know what about our culture has done this, but it's bad. [0]: https://searchworks.stanford.edu/view/13738165 https://searchworks.stanford.edu/view/13738165 [1]: https://carlsonschool.umn.edu/sites/carlsonschool.umn.edu/files/2019-04/baumeister_vohs_society_2012_0.pdf https://carlsonschool.umn.edu/sites/carlsonschool.umn.edu/fi...
- nitrogen 5y agoMany of us have lost a sense of community and place we once had. I don't know what about our culture has done this, but it's bad. The marketing, political, religious, and cultural industries that divide and conquer us into ever finer slices of demographic identities to sell us things have convinced everyone that they can only be themselves by emphasizing their irreconcilable differences with others. In doing so they have robbed us of any sense of common identity. It's no longer acceptable to be thought of as part of broad category A where everyone has different interests and affinities. Instead now, we have to be exclusively XYZ and W, and nobody else could possibly understand the XYZW perspective.
- 127 5y agoWe have been riding four positive tidal waves in the west: (momentary) end of war, positive population pyramid, rapidly improving technology, extremely cheap resources. Now that all of those trends are reversing or at least stagnating, we are in for a really rough landing, as our values and systems have eroded as a consequence of those easy times.
- tristor 5y ago“Hard times create strong men, strong men create good times, good times create weak men, and weak men create hard times.”
- akomtu 5y agoNever seen this saying, but it accurately describes the 4 ugas, or periods, in 4:3:2:1 proportion, in Indian occultism. Golden age where strong and good souls rule, they create prosperity. Silver age where good and weak ride the wave and maintain the traditions. Bronze age where bad and weak start abusing the system for personal profit. Iron age, the era of dark cults, where strong and evil rule freely. We are in a small bronze age right now.
- m0llusk 5y agoThis seems like a lot of misplaced and irrelevant moralizing. Even in this article it is reported that men find little opportunity in labor markets that leave them with low pay and low respect. If low end jobs paid enough to support a family and might lead to higher pay over time then the situation would be different. Blaming this situation on expectations doesn't make sense when the labor market is clearly both critical and broken. Working class pay has steadily fallen for decades and economic mobility is near zero. In such an environment expectations and the attitudes of the upper classes have no bearing.
- defterGoose 5y agoRight. If there is, in general, little to no chance for advancement in a profession, then there is little to no reason for a person (male in this case) to work hard to excel at it.
- dumpsterlid 5y ago> Working class pay has steadily fallen for decades and economic mobility is near zero. Exactly, so long as this is true, every other discussion about the economics of the working class is a distraction from this
- sunjester 5y agoGiving birth to a baby without being married is a religious point of view. I am supposed to believe that a "sociology professor at Princeton, and Kefalas, a sociology professor at St. Joseph’s University" can somehow convince me that he knows what a "low-income woman" thinks or does in her life. I've lived around "low-income women" my whole life and I haven't figured it out. "The conventional view is that a lack of money leads to out-of-wedlock births." Whose conventional view? This is not the view of poor people. "Today, one in six American men between the ages of 25 and 54 are unemployed or out of the workforce altogether: about 10 million men.", the book this came from was written by a conservative scientist from Iowa. I tried to check some of the stats and every one of them seem to be wrong. This link outright proves there are not 10 million men unemployed in America. https://www.statista.com/statistics/193244/unemployment-level-of-men-in-the-us-since-1990/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/193244/unemployment-leve... So who's statistics are right? This is a horrible article that seems to do nothing by try and place blame rather than provide a solution to a problem that does not exist. I will go as far as to say this article is quite racist. The article says "American" men but then only targets white American men in their statistics. Which is it, American men or white American men? He says at the beginning of the article he was one of America's "lost boys" which already tells me he has no idea what it means to actually be lost or poor. His other blog posts reveal his religious rhetoric. Remember when Cambridge produced leaders and not followers? This is a poorly written article based on personal views and statistics that don't even target the proper demographics of the content of the article. Unbelievable.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y ago> This link outright proves there are not 10 million men unemployed in America. https://www.statista.com/statistics/193244/unemployment-leve https://www.statista.com/statistics/193244/unemployment-leve... So who's statistics are right? Both of them are right, this is a common confusion in unemployment statistics. Unemployment as a technical term refers to people who both don't have a job and are "in the workforce", meaning they gave the right answers for the survey taker to conclude they're looking for a job. People who aren't trying to find a job are "out of the workforce" but not "unemployed".
- tootie 5y agoIt's also complete hearsay. Idk why these random opinion blogs are getting so much traction on HN. Actual science exists.
- CalRobert 5y agoI dunno, my own childhood improved massively when my parents bad marriage ended, and my relationship with both of my parents improved. You can be a responsible parent while not staying in an unhappy marriage.
- antiterra 5y agoSometimes it’s not a contradiction, but our old friend nuance. eg Ideally, everyone should learn to take a literal or figurative punch to the face, shrug it off and refocus. However, that doesn’t mean that someone can’t be severely traumatized or injured by a single punch to the face. The context matters. So the ideal of ‘just learn to take it and toughen up’ is flawed because of the very real effects of trauma. And the ideal of ‘no one should ever get punched in the face’ is flawed if we never train ourselves for hardship. It can be really unintuitive to figure out the middle path between the two. Sometimes it should be obvious. Stuff like, kids should be made active enough to occasionally scrape their knee, but sanding a scrape into your kids knee is horrible abuse.
- danans 5y ago> Creating a culture where men can attain dignity and social respect by providing for their family and staying with the mother of their kids matters. And creating a culture where men are told it’s okay not to do those things creates harm Teaching people how to pull together and get through tough times as a family together is a great thing to promote, but re-stigmatizing divorce to the extent it once was is not a way to achieve that.
- otikik 5y agoThe implication of "liberal values = high divorce. Conservative values = low divorce" might make sense intuitively (as one group claims to put more shame on it than the other), but until it is backed with data it is just "an impression". Here's my 2 minutes attempt: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/marriage-divorce.htm#state_tables https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/marriage-divorce.htm#state_tab... I have sorted that list several ways (rate of divorce in 2000, in 1990 and average). Of the top five (Nevada, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Wyoming, Idaho) only Wyoming voted Democrat in 2020. The lowest five (Pennsylvania, Iowa, Illinois, Louisiana, Massachusets) Iowa and Louisiana voted Republican, the rest voted Democrat. That seems to go against the "intuition" that divorce is less prevalent amongst conservatives. The list also seems to show a steady general decline across all of the states in divorce rates between 1990 and now.
- lolinder 5y agoComparing divorce rates like that is very hard because where divorce is culturally stigmatized, cohabitation is also stigmatized. The result is you get a bunch of people who get married, have kids, find out they're incompatible, and get divorced. In other states with different cultures, that exact pattern (including the kids) can play out but never end up in the divorce stats because instead of getting married the couple just lives together for a while. Once kids are involved the negative effects are much the same as in a divorce (minus the legal bills), it just doesn't show up in the stats.
- sanderjd 5y agoI think the problem with the whole argument being made in this article is exhibited in your pull quote as well: working class people don't know or care what that "highly educated and affluent person" thinks about anything. It is not then clear to me how that person's stance on this - which I don't share - could possibly be the cause of the problems of people who don't care what that person thinks.
- lolinder 5y agoIt's not the opinions of any one person that matter, it's the expressed opinion of society as a whole, which is made up of the expressed opinions of every individual. It has to start with someone, but I don't think anyone here is under the illusion that one person speaking out is sufficient to alter the culture.
- sanderjd 5y agoThere is no "opinion of society as a whole". There are myriad different cultures within the society, each with their own opinion.
- lolinder 5y agoFair, that was an oversimplification. I don't believe that that substantially alters my point, though: no one is saying that if only wealthy person X would speak up everything would be better. People are arguing that we need a surge of people speaking up in defense of the choices they made that contributed to their success.
- sanderjd 5y agoI think the article significantly overplays the extent to which that doesn't happen. I don't actually think there is any shortage of affluent / professional class / cosmopolitan people who are outspokenly proud of their stable families. But I don't think they have any influence whatsoever over the working class culture exhibiting the problems highlighted. They're two different cultures without much overlap or influence over one another.
- itronitron 5y agoIt's important to keep in mind that there have been significant policy decisions that diminish the positive impact of social programs by taking into account the marital status of those receiving them. The documentary 'The Pruitt-Igoe Myth' provides a nice case study on the societal impact of otherwise banal policy and funding decisions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pruitt-Igoe_Myth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pruitt-Igoe_Myth
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]