16 ms·
TSMC head says drive to onshore chip supply chain is 'unrealistic'
- api 5y agoTSMC is in part a Taiwanese defense asset. They don't want anything moved because right now having so much supply chain in Taiwan chains the rest of the world to Taiwan's security against the PRC.
- bombcar 5y agoAnd he's saying it wouldn't be "profitable" because they'd have overcapacity. But countries wanting to bring it in-house may not care about that, or be willing to pay for that. Ignoring shortages, Russia would be much happier right now to be oversupplied with the chips they need than having to get them through China. And lots of other countries are now re-evaluating what risks may be inherent in their supply chains.
- ltbarcly3 5y agoSo TMSC would also stop being profitable by that logic I think, unless there is some structural advantage they have?
- bombcar 5y agoThat's likely why they're trying to dissuade people from doing it; also if you DO bring something in-house you're likely to bring in the highest margin chips, which of course affects TMSC's bottom line.
- pphysch 5y agoThis is an oft-repeated meme that doesn't align with the historical facts. TSMC is a distant secondary factor in the geopolitical competition over Taiwan, which is a continuation of the Chinese civil war that started in 1927 and has never officially ended. If TSMC didn't exist, or was located in e.g. Vietnam, Taiwan would still be a vital strategic asset in Washington's stated policy to contain Communist China (as part of the "first island chain" [1]). There would still be a geopolitical competition without TSMC. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_island_chain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_island_chain
- flyinglizard 5y agoVague geopolitical considerations are very secondary and policy dependent compared to the real and abrupt chaos which will ensue if TSMC is taken out.
- jaywalk 5y agoThis is exactly correct. If China took out TSMC, we would have an unimaginable global catastrophe on our hands that would make Covid look like nothing. There are far too many eggs in that basket.
- hackernewds 5y agoThis seems like an exaggeration. What are the resulting catastrophe?
- samus 5y agoThe semiconductor industry would be set back a few decades because the main production facilities for the current node and many previous nodes would be gone. It's not just the equipment, but also the institutional knowledge about how to operate it best.
- WillPostForFood 5y agoIf China invaded Taiwan, and the world response was something like the response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine (economic isolation), it would mean losing 500 billion dollars of imported products, and an uncountable loss of products that are dependent of that 500 billion. Look at what a small kink in chip supply is doing to car pricing and supply. Imagine instead of a kink in the supply chain, the supply goes to zero for several years. Now imagine that affecting thousands of products that are either wholly manufactured in China and Taiwan, or dependent on components made in China and Taiwan.
- jaywalk 5y agoThe number of chips within a five foot radius of you at this very moment that were manufactured by TSMC could easily be in the double digits. So imagine that all of the devices containing those chips are no longer able to be produced because nobody else can make the necessary chips.
- outside1234 5y agoAfter the German debacle over having to kowtow to Russia to receive oil and gas and essentially in doing so fund the killing of Ukrainians, everyone has to be rethinking who they are reliant on and making sure they are strategically diverse. China is the obvious example of this where we need to break out the supply chain across more countries. I fully expect this to happen through a combination of corporations and countries realizing their exposure to "China doing something nuts" and acting accordingly. You already see Apple doing this, for example, with India.
- jmoak3 5y agoApple is also attempting to mobilize Indian workers before China's working population declines enough to be noticeable. The cost of business in China (regardless of international policy) is guaranteed to rise as the number of available hands decreases from mass aging.
- vkou 5y agoNo, the cost of business in China isn't rising because of demographics, it's rising because China is no longer an impoverished country. Wages in it have grown massively.
- jmoak3 5y agoI was referring to the future, the demographic situation is guaranteed to raise costs. I'm sure the extra leverage China's citizens have from their earned wealth will play/is playing a part as well.
- gnulinux 5y agoWell, of course, TSMC doesn't want chip supplies to be onshored. It's everyone other than TSMC and Taiwan willing to do so. West wants to have reliable access to chips without potential war with China. In addition to geopolitics, wouldn't overproduction of chips be beneficial to consumers in the form of cheaper chips and greater variety?
- core-utility 5y ago> In addition to geopolitics, wouldn't overproduction of chips be beneficial to consumers in the form of cheaper chips and greater variety? Another reason why TSMC would be against this
- hwillis 5y agogreater variety is not a thing that would happen (and incidentally, as an electrical engineer, there's plenty of variety already). The hardware used in semiconductor foundries is all made by the same few companies, which is a major reason everyone gets similar advances at the same time- they're all working with the same tools. The vast majority of variety in product lines comes from who is ordering the chips, not the foundries where they are made. Adding more foundries will not introduce any more different chips, just chips that have subtly different performance or reliability, which is already a nightmare engineers deal with continuously. China sells the cheapest chips, and companies only buy the cheapest chips. Making more foundries in the EU and Europe will not change that fact. China will have the huge majority of demand. If anything, a reduction in demand will give more power to counterfeiters and raise the floor price you have to pay to avoid them. It won't really impact prices at all (counterfeit chips are almost nonexistent for anything costing more than a couple cents) but it will make life significantly more irritating for people like me.
- kennywinker 5y agoWhen I read greater variety I was thinking of a greater variety of functions not a greater variety of fabrication techniques. Like if you’re shopping for a regulator there are dozens of manufacturers with dozens of options. If you’re shopping for something strange… say a 16x16 switch matrix? I think there’s a single chip? Excess capacity because of a proliferation of fabs could lead to a lot of cool chips being made for a low cost. Which in turn enables new technology in that “these are cheap, what can i make with them?” way.
- foolfoolz 5y agothe pandemic and its effects showed that the cost benefits of globalization are beaten by the national security benefits of onshoring. i think we will see more critical manufacturing, even at great expense, move back to the u. s.
- alooPotato 5y agoOne thing I'm curious about is how you define "critical manufacturing"? Manufacturing seems like a directed graph where each node is a product or material and the edges are dependencies or inputs to that product. So if you want to onshore manufacturing of a particular product, you need to also onshore all of its dependencies. My contention is that the graph is so densely connected that you end up having to bring entire supply chains onshore and this effectively means every country needs to manufacture everything.
- jl6 5y ago> One thing I'm curious about is how you define "critical manufacturing"? It’s a good question. For me, critical means you can’t walk away from a deal because you need the product, meaning you end up being extorted. Food and energy meet this criteria. Do chips? Maybe. And if so, then yes, you’re absolutely right that you would need to secure the supply chain/graph too. Maybe not the whole graph if you work back to the point where there is a diversity of competitive sources.
- sigstoat 5y ago> this effectively means every country needs to manufacture everything. depending on your exact goals, it could be worthwhile to bring a little bit of every node on the graph onshore. you retain critical experience, and have at least some hope of ramping up. getting a bunch of functioning, complicated businesses to expand is way easier than creating them from scratch.
- alooPotato 5y agooh that's interesting. You maintain a skeleton crew of an industry as a hedge in case you need to ramp it up....
- topspin 5y agoAt some point in the next 10 years Taiwan will be surrounded by half a dozen Chinese aircraft carriers[1]. The rest of the world knows that continuing to rely so heavily on Taiwan for crucial components is not viable. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2021/11/09/china/china-aircraft-carrier-type-003-launch-satellite-imagery-intl-hnk/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/11/09/china/china-aircraft-carrier-...
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Taiwan will be surrounded by half a dozen Chinese aircraft carriers Every time U.S. aircraft carriers enter a discussion, the reams of developments in anti-ship missile and swarming tactics with aerial or maritime drones (or fast boats) comes up.
- dragontamer 5y agoThat's because China can launch anti-ship missiles from any Chinese highway to threaten US Carriers. In contrast, the weapon-platforms of Taiwan / US Navy are simply more constrained. Sure, US Destroyers / Cruisers are good missile platforms and US Aircraft Carriers / F35 fighters are also good delivery mechanisms for anti-ship missiles... But China has the advantage of land-based missiles, land-based air force, AND sea-based naval forces to triple-team up against the US Navy. ------- Chinese Carriers hanging around the Straight of Taiwan and hugging their coastline (under protective cover of Chinese missile-forces / Chinese air-forces) is the expectation. We're not concerned about Chinese Carriers trying to say, attack Hawaii (which would be the opposite situation: US Air Force supporting US Navy in defense). The near-term threat is the gross geographical advantages of the China-Taiwan fight. There's a mild expectation that if a Chinese / Taiwan fight were to occur, US Marines might be forced to make landings in the Chinese mainland to destroy Chinese land-based missile forces and even the odds.
- jacobolus 5y agoHow useful are anti-ship missiles in Ishigaki Island (Japan), Batanes (Philippines), etc.? If Taiwan is loaded with anti-ship missiles, cruise missiles, naval mines, loitering munitions, artillery, modern fighter jets, etc., any Chinese invasion is at the very least going to come at very steep cost in life/military hardware. And then the economic costs (to everyone in the world) are going to be extreme.
- trentnix 5y agoHe wouldn't be commenting if it was really unrealistic.
- kadoban 5y ago
- vondur 5y agoWell, if the Chinese do invade and take over Taiwan, it will be lesson learned too late.
- rektide 5y agoMorris Chang (founder of TSMC)'s speech a year ago touched on 3 huge advantages Taiwan uniquely has. Having a whole, well-knit-together country with such intense knowledge & specilaization in making chips is something that would be extremely hard to recreate anywhere else. A community of practitioners is key. https://interconnected.blog/morris-chang-global-semiconductor-competition-make-making-stuff-cool/ https://interconnected.blog/morris-chang-global-semiconducto... The United States had extreme success growing really good chip designing talent with the digital foundry model. We simply gave college students & others access to the means of production. Something we see eFanless/Google/Skywatdr kind of doing these days, with free chipmaking (at 130nm). But how we get good at making the foundries, create a body of expertise in not chip design but chipmaking, at any level of density... hard problem.
- duped 5y agoThe first two points are at best opinion and and worst nationalism, neither are facts.
- VWWHFSfQ 5y agoChang is very well known for making these kinds of statements that make no sense.
- TrevorJ 5y agoIt isn't that his point isn't true, it's just that it is tautological. It's sort of like saying cars are more useful in country X than country Y because country x has roads. On the one hand: yes. On the other hand: it used to be that no country had roads, so obviously this is a problem with a solution. The country has roads, because it has cars.
- hahaxdxd123 5y agoWhat? I am reading the English translation and it seems based in truth to me. 1. The US of course has technical talent. However the vast majority would rather work in in the higher margin software industry, not hardware. If I am intelligent/hard-working enough in America to understand the physics behind semi-conductors, I would rather apply that to prop trading than Intel. 2. Manager-employee customs are vastly different across cultures. What is institutionalized in Japan is harassment in America. If he says Taiwan has a sufficiently different culture, I believe him.
- ed25519FUUU 5y agoWho cares if it’s not profitable? Who’s trying to onshore chips because it’s cheaper? We’re bringing chips back home for security and resiliency reasons.
- ElectricalUnion 5y ago> Who cares if it’s not profitable? Who’s trying to onshore chips because it’s cheaper? "Capitalism" enters the chat. > We’re bringing chips back home for security and resiliency reasons. The chips will close down by themselves if they're insanely non-profitable and a resource sink.
- civilized 5y ago> It makes sense that all the major economies hope to bring the chips for infrastructure or defense uses onshore, but to bring a full supply chain back and try to be fully self-reliant is totally not efficient Unfortunately, sometimes you've got to trade efficiency for robustness. Taiwan has China dangling over its head like the Sword of Damocles.
- dwighttk 5y agoWolf says shepherds should leave sheep alone
- amelius 5y agoAnd I thought having less salty air makes it easier to build a fab ...
- iamleppert 5y agoBecause we all know how great it’s been being out of stock of everything for months now. The current system is working so well! /s
- cjsplat 5y agoAs Moore's law slows down, fabs will have longer life near the leading edge. So, for example, 45 nm rolled out in 2007. If in 2005 you were crazy enough to try to bootstrap a 32 nm fab, you might have hoped to have the line completed a year behind the industry if you were lucky. (You have to get it working, get the customers,and get them shipping in volume to get the business healthy.) So Joe's Tool and Die startup fab rolls out their 32->36 nm process in 2010. And they luck out because the 22->28 happens in 2012 (a 3 yr gap vs the typical 2 yr at that time.) But 22->28 rolls out and JT&D is playing catch up again. If the same cycle stretches to 5 years, the technology ramp becomes much more manageable.
- powerslacker 5y ago> to bring a full supply chain back and try to be fully self-reliant is totally not efficient. ... At the end of the day, that additional capacity could become non-profitable capacity." It doesn't matter if it isn't profitable, because if cars, trains, and computers go offline because of chip production supply chain issues then a huge portion of the workforce can't participate. If regional war blocks trade from Taiwan we will be hosed within a matter of years.
- erdos4d 5y agoHonest question, what would be the outcome in terms of chip manufacturing ability if China didn't invade Taiwan, but just decided to level the whole island with an eye towards repopulating later with Chinese nationals? Have Chinese fabs come along enough to allow them to just destroy Taiwan instead of mounting a costly invasion?
- MR4D 5y ago> the rush by major economies to onshore semiconductor production is "unrealistic" and that expanding capacity would not help alleviate the global chip shortage. OR, maybe the countries are just using that as pretense because they think the CCP will make a move on Taiwan, and it’s easier to say this than say that out loud.
- danans 5y agoI'm curious to see if the chip supply constraints will result in device designs that make more efficient use of them. I think some auto manufacturers are already doing exactly that.
- trrb 5y ago
- adamsmith143 5y agoHead of Monopoly says attempts to break monopoly are pointless. In other news water is wet.
- jscipione 5y agoI’m all due respect to TSMC, Taiwan may be ‘unrealistic’ pretty soon.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- skeeter2020 5y ago[totally not efficient, non-profitable capacity] !== 'unrealistic'
- dirtyid 5y agoA more recent piece with Morris including link to his talk at Brookings from a few days ago. https://www.theregister.com/2022/04/20/us_chips_tsmc/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/04/20/us_chips_tsmc/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwCWYcag5RE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NwCWYcag5RE Choice quotes: > Chang said that costs for manufacturing in the US are simply prohibitive, and TSMC has the data to prove it thanks to 25 years of manufacturing at its plant in Oregon. Chang said the plant is profitable, but expansion plans have all but been abandoned. >"We were extremely naive," Chang said, "in expecting comparable costs, but manufacturing chips in the US is 50 percent more expensive than in Taiwan." ... >It's perhaps hard to square Chang's position with TSMC's $12 billion investment in an Arizona fab, and news that it raised an additional $3.5 billion in bonds for the factory. Then again, he did leave in 2018 and said that the decision to build the new US fabs wasn't his. >"We did it at the urging of the US government, and TSMC felt we should do it," Chang said. Still, he believes that all the billions of subsidies being ring-fenced by the US for increased domestic semiconductor assembly will still fall far short of the necessary amount needed to boost homegrown chip manufacturers.
- parkingrift 5y agoWhat we’ve learned the last 18 months is that chip production is vital to the economy, not just national defense. It doesn’t matter if it is profitable. If American businesses can’t run chip production on American soil at a profit then we’ll have to subsidize it. Either way we absolutely can’t continue with such an absurd reliance on Taiwan and China.