9 ms·
Every company I know of that did a poison pill to prevent a takeover wound up tanking within a year or two and the shareholders wound up with sand. As a Twitte
by WalterBright 5y ago
Every company I know of that did a poison pill to prevent a takeover wound up tanking within a year or two and the shareholders wound up with sand.
As a Twitter shareholder myself, the board is making a big mistake.
As a legal matter, I don't understand how a board could sell shares to other shareholders at a lower price than to the entity wanting to buy shares to gain control.
- xyzzy21 5y ago
- tuckerman 5y agoThe idea that the board's fiduciary means they must maximize profits at the expense of all else is a bit of a myth. Yes, they need to look out for their shareholders but they also need to do right by the company, and companies can be formed for any legal purpose and everyone (the company and the shareholders) values things differently. It's generally been upheld that the board has a lot of autonomy and, outside of gross negligence, is generally protected by the business judgement rule.
- tsimionescu 5y ago> Yes, they need to look out for their shareholders but they also need to do right by the company, and companies can be formed for any legal purpose and everyone (the company and the shareholders) values things differently The board has a lot of leeway into how they achieve profit for the shareholders, but all decisions they make must be nominally in the interest of that goal (assuming we're discussing a for-profit company such as Twitter). They can basically claim anything they do is done in the interest of shareholder value and be safe, but if they said "we know the company will lose money on this, but we really like X so we'll spend company money on it", they would pretty clearly be in breach of their fiduciary duty.
- philistine 5y agoYou gave a very clear example of a breach. To add to your point, Elon's offer is both conditional on financing and too low, so we will implement a poison pill would never be seen as a breach.
- tuckerman 5y agoAt least in Delaware law, a board's fiduciary duty involves a duty of care, loyalty, and good faith. While acting to maximize their personal interests or egregiously working against profits could be considered a breach, not trying to maximally make profits probably wouldn't be. All of this would need to be litigated on a case-by-case basis, but many modern cases have found that companies can freely act to maximize the wages of their employees at the expense of dividends or act charitably even when there aren't tax breaks. That said, I'm not sure this really even applies in the case of Twitter---I think its not unreasonable to argue that the innate value of Twitter is so much higher than what Musk is offering that its better for the shareholders to wait even thinking purely in terms of profits (I would probably personally disagree with that, but I don't think its any more unreasonable than plenty of other valuations I see)
- tsimionescu 5y agoYes, they don't have to maximize profits, but they also can't ignore profit to the benefit of other values they deem more important, per the very old but still in force Dodge v Ford. As long as they are not egregiously and obviously acting against that goal, or taking decisions without deliberation, the law would favor them in any trial that only hinged on whether the price offered by Musk was better than the market. Basically the burden of proof to show that it could not have been a good business decision would lie with the plaintiff, and I very much doubt that you could build a solid case of that.
- tuckerman 5y agoI don't think Dodge v. Ford isn't a great case to cite here for two reasons: 1) I think the trend of accepting that corporations can exist for reasons other than to generate profit is a post-ww2 phenomenon and this case is from 1919 2) Perhaps more importantly, Dodge v. Ford was a case before the Michigan Supreme Court and, to my knowledge, has never been used in a case in Delaware.
- friesfreeze 5y agoUnder DE law, my understanding is that you are slightly off on this. Boards do have a duty to maximize shareholder value. THAT SAID, the business judgement rule provides that judges will not second guess the board absent evidence of gross negligence or total disregard of duty. This is because the Delaware court has decided that judges are not better than boards at evaluating business decisions. BUT! Overcoming the BJR is very difficult unless management stupidly says the quiet part out loud. Dodge v. Ford is a celebrated case in this regard because Ford basically said at trial "Yeah my main consideration in taking [specific action] is not maximizing shareholder value" and the judge was like "Haha no, that's not how any of this works - you can't do [specific thing] now." But if Ford was like "Yeah [specific thing] would be GREAT for shareholders" under the BJR the judge would have been like "Okay, great, keep doing what you are doing. How could I possibly know better than you?" Also there is no "need to do right by the company" - squeezing value out of the company and all of its stakeholders is completely consistent with the duties of the board members. How else would the private equity industry exist? (jk!)
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> have a duty to maximize shareholder value Not to maximize profits. Courts give companies a wide berth in defining shareholder value.
- friesfreeze 5y agoRight, though I don't think it is so vague as to be meaningless. The stakeholder / shareholder value debates in corporate governance play on the extremities of this distinction a lot, with the current koan being that what is good for stakeholders is good for shareholders.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> don't think it is so vague as to be meaningless It's not, particularly in the context of takeover defenses. There were cases in the 80s where Delaware ruled that only shareholder interests--not all stakeholders'--can be considered when a Board uses its "business judgment" to deploy a poison pill. But shareholders can have aims other than maximizing profit, and companies are free to respond to them.
- rileymat2 5y agoNot sure this is true, if they believe the long term outlook is higher than the hostile price, they are being good fiduciaries.
- sbelskie 5y agoAre you claiming that this common kind of poison pill provision is illegal?
- memish 5y agoAs a shareholder and end user of the product, I agree.
- alphabetting 5y agoyou want to cash out with a 20% bump and be out of the stock during a huge tech equity downturn when the stock was over 60% higher last year?
- hajile 5y agoThe big reason it tanked was privacy regulations from Apple/Android. That's not changing to favor Twitter and effectively took away one of their biggest revenue streams. That's a big deal for a perennially non-profitable company.
- loceng 5y agoElon said he'd keep as many shareholders as he's legally allowed to.
- hackernewds 5y ago"Elon said" is not a stamp of trust anymore. Elon also said TSLA would accept Dogecoin, which he had accumulated prior to communicating it. Then he sold it off. History should be a lesson here, it's almost Deja Vu with Twitter
- mcintyre1994 5y agoI think the most famous counter-example would be Netflix in 2012 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-20214401 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-20214401
- fortran77 5y agoAnd Disney, twice. https://www.upi.com/amp/Archives/1984/06/11/Walt-Disney-Productions-ended-financier-Saul-Steinbergs-takeover-attempt/1284455774400/ https://www.upi.com/amp/Archives/1984/06/11/Walt-Disney-Prod...
- scythe 5y agoIcahn was claiming that Netflix was undervalued. To be fair, he was also angling for an acquisition. But a bid like that usually has a half-life; the market trends to a good price — and indeed, Netflix doubled in value by mid-2013. Elon is arguing that Twitter is mismanaged. He already probably pushed them on the edit button, even though they claimed he didn't. If he's right — and Goldman Sachs seems to agree — he could have an easier go of it next year.
- wwweston 5y ago> Elon is arguing that Twitter is mismanaged. Anyone who thinks this is manifestly true should read this take from an ex-CEO of Reddit: https://twitter.com/yishan/status/1514938507407421440 https://twitter.com/yishan/status/1514938507407421440 tl;dr: managing human interaction in any environment with limited accountability is a lot harder than it looks Also, there's the question of by what metrics one would argue it's mismanaged. Revenue and engagement trends? Profitability trends?
- anonymouse008 5y agoRead some Matt Levine, he's way more articulate and makes finance quite fun. But if I were to take a stab at it: The market has been so weird recently that stock splits - which according to previous theoretical belief do not create shareholder value - have in fact increased the share price for extended periods. So issuing stock for whatever reason (high price, poison pill) could be seen as shareholder maximizing. One could say diluting the stock so that a particular personality cannot buy the whole company could be shareholder maximizing as it would entrench ESG held values -- emboldening new shareholders to purchase the stock (saving the stock price). And point of information, by diluting rather than selling already owned shares, control is not ceded to the potential acquirer -- unless the potential acquirer doesn't care about the poison pill and will pay the premium for the new issue as well. This is quite fun to watch.
- atmosx 5y agoMatt is awesome. Super-smart guy, I love his perspective although I must admit I rarely read his newsletter nowadays.
- eqmvii 5y agoIMO, Matt Levine is mostly writing with his tongue firmly in his cheek when he suggests stock splits and meme stock antics are Rational Things Boards Should Do For Value. Excellent source for financial news though, I agree!
- and-not-drew 5y ago> The market has been so weird recently that stock splits - which according to previous theoretical belief do not create shareholder value - have in fact increased the share price for extended periods You're right that theoretically, they shouldn't create value, but I think even back to the 80s and 90s it's been shown that companies that go through a split tend to out perform the market for years after the split. The main reason isn't that the split creates value, but rather that companies who go though a stock split are usually successful and already on a trajectory to beat the market, split or not.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cwkoss 5y agoAre you going to sell? If not, why not?
- WalterBright 5y agoI'm considering selling.
- lr4444lr 5y agoI'm not. Though I wouldn't have been too upset to pocket a 20+% gain, I bought at the start of 2022, bolstered by Jack's ouster. They need to figure out a paid tier for celebrity accounts, cut the fat from the staff (it's really not that complex a piece of software relatively speaking), and get profitable. Scott Galloway saw the potential well before Musk got involved.
- senthil_rajasek 5y agoCan you give some examples? I know one company that had the poison pill provision and did well.
- WalterBright 5y agoTwo companies I'd invested in and lost my shirt on after the pp. It left a lingering sour taste. I'd rather not name them, I'm still sore about it.
- senthil_rajasek 5y agoThat's fair. I am not sure if "poison pill" is the cause of companies going belly up though. Surely, we have contradicting examples.
- sangnoir 5y agoIsn't your sample biased? Distressed companies are more likely to attract takeover attempts (hostile or not) compared to healthy ones; and they are also more likely to tank. As far as I can tell, Twitter is not in financial distress.
- onelovetwo 5y agofrom my understanding they've been going downhill for quite some time.
- guyzero 5y ago"I don't like it" != financial distress. From Twitter's 2021 10K: "FY 2021 Highlights Total revenue was $5.08 billion, an increase of 37%, compared to 2020." 2021 net losses were $221M, which is a big improvement on $1.135B in 2020. Honestly seems like things are really shaping up @ Twitter.
- Kye 5y agoI'm curious to see how this holds up without the events of January 6th driving so many ad impressions.
- onelovetwo 5y agohttps://twitter.com/cameron/status/1514977953079209985 https://twitter.com/cameron/status/1514977953079209985
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fullshark 5y agoI’m actually a bit amazed they aren’t profitable yet. Hasn’t their user base been stagnant/shrinking for years? What are they investing in?
- guyzero 5y ago
- yalogin 5y agoNot really, as a counter argument, there is every reason to believe that Musk will make a mockery of twitter and run it into the ground. A social media platform with a lot of responsibility is not for someone as egotistical as Musk. If Zuckerberg is bad, Musk could be catastrophic.
- whatshisface 5y agoThe shareholders no longer care what happens to Twitter once they are shareholders no longer. (Except insofar as they are Twitter users.)
- yalogin 5y agoThat need not be what the board wants and long term shareholders want. This pressure to accept an offer is for institutional (hedge funds) and short term investors. This thought process is similar to when the company decides to invest in the business at the expense of stock buy backs for example, the way Bezos ran Amazon for a long time.
- axlee 5y agoTell that to all the employee with shares or options.
- hamiltonians 5y agoelon is very popular. how would he run it into the ground
- legalcorrection 5y ago"Mockery" i.e. not censor people who say things you don't like.
- avs733 5y agoIt’s a completely ridiculous narrative to think that musk is interested in anyones free speech but his own. We should all be more aware of when the narratives billionaires pitch about themselves become perceived to be objective reality.
- ChicagoDave 5y ago90% of Twitter stock is held by institutional investors. Feel free to sell your shares. No one will notice.
- WalterBright 5y agoDid I give the impression anyone would? I pointed out that I have a financial stake in Twitter in order to show that I have skin in the game that contributes to my pontifications on the topic. I'm not merely a disinterested observer.
- salawat 5y agoThis POV needs to shove it, because even those institutions can have their resources revoked by people waking up and accepting capital allocation is their responsibility. This is the toxicity that has younger people rightfully angry at how the system works, and how it is "rigged". People just haven't had the info bandwidth previously to even contemplate these problems. So no. WalterBright should absolutely do with his shares as he wilt, as should everyone else. Frankly, I wish institutional investment was deconstructed to at least get people coordinating with each other from the ground up to accept what it is their institution's manager was actually perpetuating.
- ChicagoDave 5y agoInstitutional investors are the backbone of municipal bonds that help small towns borrow and build. They back all of the retirement vehicles in the U.S. They give a financial stability to places that need them. One of the reasons Twitter is stable is because of those types of investors and is not subject to the whims of individual shareholders. No corporate leadership wants to be subject to the whims of the stock market if they can avoid it. Twitters board and its institutional investors the firewall against such things.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- runeks 5y ago> Every company I know of that did a poison pill to prevent a takeover wound up tanking within a year or two and the shareholders wound up with sand. Which companies are these?