10 ms·
Paleontologists Are Trying to Understand Why the Fossil Record Is Mostly Males
- eric4smith 5y agoMisogyny! But seriously. This is common behavior among competitive animals. Male Lions have to seek out a new pride. Don’t even begin to talk about birds who the male or the species need to do all kinds of expensive preening. Male Monkeys commonly get thrown out of the troop. Males (including human males) generally have a completely and substantially different life than females. That’s why I laugh at the common modern trope that we are the same. Animals are just more honest about it.
- CincinnatiMan 5y agoI’m not seeing how this relates to why fossils would more often be males. Can you expand?
- murbard2 5y ago> “They were more likely to do silly things, like die in tar pits,” Gower says.
- dsq 5y agoNature creates superfluous number of males (since one male ususally has most of females, like in a pride of lions, or a sultan's harem). Therefore those unattached males, who are still too young and inexperienced to fight the old ones, wander around 'seeking their fortune', usually leading to their quick demise in all sorts of places.
- danaris 5y ago...Why does it matter whether the demise was quick or slow, with the group or apart from it? They still leave the same number of bones, don't they?
- cninja 5y agoThe environmental conditions that are good for the formation of fossils are not the sort of conditions that are good for living a long and peaceful life. Outcast males are the ones more likely to be wandering around in those sorts of places.
- rapind 5y agoI would imagine because the male bones would then be more scattered, whereas female bones more concentrated, giving you a better chance to come upon a male's bones. Not sure the speed of demise is relevant. If my kids scatter toys all of the living room, I'm much more likely to step on one or more of them, then if they were in a neat pile (speaking from experience).
- PeterisP 5y agoThat does not seem a reasonable exploration - all it means that we'd find female bones more rarely but when we do find them, there would be a whole cluster of them, recovering many specimens at once - it's not like paleontologists stop with "ah, we took one set of bones from here, we'll leave the rest lying around); so the total amount should still be the same.
- rapind 5y agoFair enough. Could be the size of the area, lack of resources, and bad luck until suddenly a jackpot? For all I know, maybe the bones at camp are used to make soup… /shrug
- jmopp 5y agoAn animal dying suddenly in a landslide would be more likely to leave a fossil than one who has been killed and eaten.
- Sharlin 5y agoFossilization is really rare and the conditions that enable fossilization usually involve being quickly buried under something.
- gumby 5y ago> Nature creates superfluous number of males A rather astounding statement. Selective pressure should result a ratio appropriate for a given species of plant or animal. It’s not my field, but I haven’t seen any literature suggesting any such thing, nor do I know of any country full of sultans.
- autosharp 5y agoE.g. most chickens (about 2/3) that come out of their egg are male. But a flock only allows maybe 1 adult male for every 5 females, with the surplus murdered by other chickens. So almost all male chickens are superfluous in that sense. It is still selective pressure which makes chickens have 'too many' males, because apparently those chickens/flocks have created more of themselves. Same for lions, btw, although I don't know about their sex' birthrates.
- rybosworld 5y agoBirth sex ratio of chickens is naturally 1:1. You can do weird things with temperature to affect those birth rates, but the ratio will not reach as high as 2:1 as far as I know.
- gumby 5y ago> Same for lions, btw, although I don't know about their sex' birthrates. If you don't know the rate how can you say it's true? By definition there is some sort of distribution of male/female cubs and there is presumably some sort of distribution of pack sizes. But apart from the victorian-inspired documentaries that talk about juvenile male ronins being chased from the pack I don't really know the dynamics, and I doubt anyone but a specialized community does. Where I live in Palo Alto the distribution of lone mountain lions that show up in town seems, anecdotally, to be predominantly female. Humans are a good example: slightly more males are born but within the range of about 20-50 years of age, the sex ratio is 1:1. Humans have been basically* monogamous throughout recorded history and for whatever reasons that might be it would select for this birth ratio wouldn't it. * Sure, there are plenty (well, a few percent) of kids whose father is not the male in a given hetero "couple" but it's the couple phenomenon itself that matters here.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ekabod 5y agowrong thread
- bantunes 5y agoTo suggest modern human life is governed by the same constraints as a troop of monkeys is ludicrous. Of course we're not the same, but to think we should leave it at that and never try to bridge the gap and fix injustices that might arise from it is weird.
- eric4smith 5y agoWe are governed by the same constraints. We just think we are above all animals in that respect. We are not. Of course no one wants injustices. Duh. But when in the name of curing injustices you deny the biological imperatives — a-la todays modern social justice warriors. This is when the problems and conflicts start.
- bantunes 5y agoPlease expand on one example of constraints that apply to troops of monkeys and modern day humans.
- eadmund 5y ago> Please expand on one example of constraints that apply to troops of monkeys and modern day humans. Both monkeys and humans require oxygen to breathe. That is, as you requested, one example of a constraint which applies to both. Perhaps you'd care to move the goalposts a bit?
- eric4smith 5y agoWhy? You’re not paying me to do so. Instead you would be looking to attack my examples. Instead go and google how monkey troupes operate and look at the analogies in human society. I did it, so surely you can too!
- bantunes 5y agoI see. Many thanks
- gunfighthacksaw 5y ago> That’s why I laugh at the common modern trope that we are the same. The ‘modern trope’ holds true in corporate environments, at least among the engineers, PMs and customer success agents I work with. Obviously your average man has higher bone density and muscle mass and inability to bear children, but this only really affects activities outside of the workplace. That said, aside from drinking more beer and working out more, my lifestyle is pretty much the same as my partner’s.
- rybosworld 5y agoDisagree. Males and females are different and it's important to talk about it. Male competitiveness plays a huge role in the corporate world, and is a reasonable explanation for why the top of the hierarchy is naturally dominated by males. Males and females are interested in different types of work. And if we are being honest, you can find things that the average member of one gender is better at than the other. This also shows it's head in the work place. Generalizations made about females and males are concerning the averages. On average, it's easier for a male to gain muscle mass. On average, women do better socially. Humans are uniquely adaptable so we can become better at things through practice. This does not alter the fact that people have different starting points for any skill set. Ignoring the differences does more harm than good.
- gunfighthacksaw 5y ago> Male competitiveness plays a huge role in the corporate world, and is a reasonable explanation for why the top of the hierarchy is naturally dominated by males Could you foresee this being a problem? Such as the best person for a job being passed over for someone more competitive/in the club? I also refer you to the observed effects of testosterone in financial markets (riskier trades, bubbles) which are typically seen as pathological. Personally I’m not extremely competitive but do suffer from the ‘testosterone-overdose’ fairly regularly which usually involves impulsivity and rashness.
- rybosworld 5y ago> Could you foresee this being a problem? Such as the best person for a job being passed over for someone more competitive/in the club? If we aim for meritocracy, then yes it's definitely an issue. The most competitive males tend to have lots of negative personality traits (e.g. low empathy). That is to say: It's very often not the smartest/most creative people that make it to the top. It's the most cutthroat.
- gumby 5y agoYou appear to be reasoning only using mammals.
- PeterWhittaker 5y agoWhile it isn’t stated in the headline, the article focuses primarily on large North American mammals.
- causi 5y agowhy the fossil record is mostly males Because it can be, that's why. Population bottleneck is female reproduction. You can impregnate X females with X males, or 0.5X males, or 0.25X males. Wiping out males has a much lower effect on the future population of a group than wiping out females, so over time a group that loses a lot of males is better off than a group that loses a lot of females, and has more members to die and become fossils.
- alecst 5y agoWhen has the population of females ever been 4x the population of males?
- paulryanrogers 5y agoPerhaps it has more to do with risk profile and group dynamics?
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoNot even close to 4x but in post-WWII Russia there were 1.21 females for every male.
- unsupp0rted 5y agoAfter war time, this wouldn't be surprising. All the males in a tribe can easily get wiped out in one or two engagements, leaving only females and children. In Russia after WW2 the ratio of female:male was 4:3 Imagine what that ratio would have been after a war in olden times.
- causi 5y agoI'm not saying it has. I'm saying that a small number of males can impregnate a large number of females.
- BurningFrog 5y agoThis can explain why males die younger. It doesn't mean that more males than females die.
- The_rationalist 5y ago
- temptemptemp111 5y ago
- gunapologist99 5y agoThere are so many things we don't know, and the vast expanse of time and limited sample size might cause a real gap in our knowledge here, as well. So, what about the collection method itself; if only 5% of the ancient DNA was usable for this analysis, perhaps it could be because that DNA lies protected within the sex with the largest, strongest, thickest bones?
- atx42 5y agoIt does seem like some sort of survivorship basis, either before death or after (heh - after death sounds like an oxymoron). Females have more fat (?) and might float better in a flood keeping them clear of the burial material longer. Maybe females are just more adept to dig themselves out of the burial material to live another day, or more like you say the physical or material matter somehow is better preserved after burial.
- asciimov 5y agoMy first thought was males tend to have higher bone density.
- darkerside 5y agoSeems most likely to be that males literally die off the beaten path because of their wandering. Females and males who die in heavily trafficked areas will have their carcass picked clean and then their bones ground to dust simply from foot traffic.
- atx42 5y agoDo the females float better, possibly preventing them to be buried quickly?
- jollybean 5y ago"This has less to do with misogyny" WTF? The arbitrary, common and accepted bigotry of women in 2022 is beyond pale. Even arbitrary deaths of animals, must be due to: "Misogyny (/mɪˈsɒdʒɪni/) is hatred of, contempt for, or prejudice against women." Thankfully the author Sabrina Imbler, was able to realize that it wasn't mostly misogyny, but something else. I mean, misogyny being a key component, obviously? Because everything is? I read that as a tongue-in-cheek bit at first but after reading it several times, I don't think it is. How can any academic maintain any kind of credibility with this kind of rubbish? Why would anyone read past the first paragraph where an academic literally used a term denoting 'hatred of women' to be a possible reasoning of animal behaviour? I can't wait for someone to try this on me so I can enjoy early retirement after a nice, giant lawsuit.
- bombcar 5y agoNow I'm imagining a group of misogynistic bison standing around a female telling her that the paleontologists won't even find your bones.
- jollybean 5y agoI don't understand the joke, what does that have to do with the very clear misandry on display by the author?
- seneca 5y agoIn a word, lysenkoism. Academic sciences are so corrupt at this point that if you don't pay tribute to the narrative your career is dead.
- highfrequency 5y agoHistorically, the typical male had 0 offspring while a minority had many (this was not the case for females). When your median evolutionary outcome is atrocious, you will evolve toward high variance behavior like venturing away from the tribe to explore foreign places. This leads to a higher fraction of male fossils because the preservation of remains is a very unlikely event requiring unusual conditions. "These male mammoths—young, reckless, foolhardy—were just more likely to get into some kind of trouble and die, from getting stuck in a pit to running afoul of hunting humans. Luckily for paleontologists, some of these death sites—bogs, crevices, lakes—are pretty good at preserving remains. 'They were more likely to do silly things, like die in tar pits,' Gower says."
- jvanderbot 5y ago"Is there anything good about men?" https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/8765372-is-there-anything-good-about-men https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/8765372-is-there-anythin... Podcast: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YHdl4FXYpU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YHdl4FXYpU Lecture text: https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/Is-There-Anything-Good-About-Men.pdf https://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/Is-There-Any... Therein you'll find this argument applied to humans, as well. It's fairly informative and rigorous (mostly). Good read, even if you disagree with the whole premise. > "I’m certainly not denying that culture has exploited women. But rather than seeing culture as patriarchy, which is to say a conspiracy by men to exploit women, I think it’s more accurate to understand culture (e.g., a country, a religion) as an abstract system that competes against rival systems — and that uses both men and women, often in different ways, to advance its cause."
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoMaybe its a classification error. Most fossiles are fragments of arbitrary bone. Male? Female? It's a reach.
- jjtheblunt 5y agodoesn't osteoporosis hit females harder?
- Maursault 5y agoObviously, the reason is that the female gender is, evolutionarily speaking, a relatively recent development, as anyone can see females are far more evolutionarily advanced than males, more intelligent, better looking, etc. And the population trends predict males will become extinct within a few hundred generations.
- tsol 5y agoCan't tell if this is satire. What a world
- redmen 5y agoDon't males have denser bones? Random thought (probably a stupid one), but maybe they are more likely to last?
- INTPenis 5y agoYeah I was talking about this story with my mom over easter, she's old, she worked as a nurse all her life before retirement and her response was very simple, females get brittle bones with age. They might use more kalcium or whatever is required to make bones strong. So their bones are less likely to last, or less likely to preserve DNA. While males have more of those materials required to make the bones and their DNA last.
- 1MachineElf 5y agoAll creatures die eventually, so it's not like significantly more males than females died due to behavioral differences. As someone with zero experience in these areas, I'd posit that females get osteoporosis, and so their remains deteriorate moreso than males do. Thanks for coming to my TED Talk.
- tuatoru 5y agoFossil bison and mammoths.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThey mention it extends to most mammals later in the article.
- 4x5-Guy 5y agoEasy. "Here, hold my beer"
- pfdietz 5y agoFossilized jackasses.
- Eric_WVGG 5y ago“I’m Johnny Knoxmammoth, and this is Tar Pit Challenge”
- LoveMortuus 5y agoI think we should always have at least one joke thread, if nothing to lighten to mood!
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI think when you here, hold my beer to death, most of those situations are ones where you wouldn't expect fossil preservation of the remains, unless the La Brea Tar Pits are involved.
- jedberg 5y agoIt says only 5% had usable DNA to test. Maybe male DNA just holds up better over that kind of timespan so the bias is in how much of it is usable.
- chrisco255 5y agoWhy would male DNA hold up better when the only difference is the sex chromosomes. They are chemically made from the same material.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoMaybe because they are more likely to die younger—and the younger, stronger body preserves better?
- jedberg 5y agoNo idea, just saying it's a possible explanation along with all their other guesses.
- shalmanese 5y agoI don't get the urge for when a community has been stumped studying something for multiple years and you've just heard about it 5 minutes ago to chime in and ask "I wonder if they've thought of this yet?". Like, how likely do you really think it is that the reason they haven't figured it out is because it simply never occurred to them to investigate your reason?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 5y agoGroup think is real, I have definitely entered consulting gigs in a new topic and asked questions that haven’t been asked before by a group working on something for a long time…
- 5y ago
- chrisco255 5y ago> They figured it was more probable that young male mammoths were much more likely to travel solo, away from the wisdom and protection of matriarchal herds, similar to the way elephant societies function today. Anecdotally, when I went hiking in Yellowstone two years ago down a long nature trail through the woods, I was surprised to see a large male bison trodding alone in the opposite direction down the trail, towards me. I slowly backed up towards the tree line just to give him some space to pass, but I was rather surprised to see a herd animal by himself in such a vast park like Yellowstone with such a big population of bison. I assume that this behavior in males is probably essential. It's risky for a herd animal to travel alone. However if a male is successful in migrating to another herd, and earning his way in, it improves the cross-pollination of dna. Also, males in the animal kingdom regularly push each other out to secure local dominance over local females. Many are therefore forced to leave as well.
- peppustimbus 5y agoLooks like this as male wanders more, increasing the chance of getting into unusual places which provides better preservation conditions. Also, fossils are usually trapped in some place.
- INTPenis 5y agoHere is another hypothesis, maybe humans preferred to hunt males to preserve progeny they can hunt next season. And bones processed and kept by humans might have a higher chance of not being completely destroyed by natural forces.
- sonicggg 5y agoInteresting to see that the whole "Why men die younger?" debate should just be "Why males die younger?" instead. Does the testosterone turn us into reckless idiots?
- ungamedplayer 5y agoNo. Testosterone makes us take risks for breeding opportunity. This chemical value proposition is still in place today and visible in most places where humans gather. It's one of those things that we don't want to talk about but has been and will be true for the immediate future till some other trait better for the species becomes more attractive. Until that time we are stuck with t and risk taking.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe modern attitude that risk taking is by default bad or at least of questionable value is not that old and will probably die out before risk taking behavior does. The latter is common across species and millions of years. The former is a new development and may just be a blip.
- ungamedplayer 5y agoI also believe that risk taking is a valuable behavioural trait. I do think that we (humans) will one day come to accept the biological reality of behaviour and physical traits and not mask them under social delusions.
- The_rationalist 5y ago
- 3pt14159 5y agoLots of possible explanations. My mind initially went to small sample size, etc, but it looks like even assuming a 50% sex ratio (which, isn't quite right for bison, there are slightly fewer males than females) the probability of this result is around 0.26%, which is possible since there are a lot of fossil researchers out there and this is the type of result that would get press over a result that came to a more expected conclusion, but still. It's less likely than I initially would have expected. If I had to guess I would have to assume it's something in the nature of how bison die. Say from male-on-male competition far from predators that may break the bones to digest the bone marrow. Or it's possible that predators prefer preying on females because it's relatively more safe than males. Or it could just be the small sample size, of course.
- jmclnx 5y agoWell, I am about as far from an expert as a 1 year old baby. But if I had to guess, I would say Osteoporosis, since my understanding is, that tends to hit Females worse than Males.
- atx42 5y agoAlso, not an expert, but I'd think that would stop after one is dead? Although some differing (male/female) chemistry at death could come into play.
- jmclnx 5y agoWhat I am thinking is since Female's bones could be a bit less dense, a less percentage survive as long before fossilization occurs.