29 ms·
Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will'
- Hnrobert42 5y agoI don’t advocate being anti-racist on Twitter. I don’t post #blm stories on Instagram. However, I do use cash in person and refuse to patronize establishments that don’t accept it. I do this specifically to support the underbanked. It’s not much, but it is my way of combatting systemic racism.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vertis 5y ago> Around 10 million people, or one in five adults, would struggle to manage in a society without cash, a report from the Royal Society of Arts commissioned by cash machine network Link found. At least they didn't bury who was paying for the study. Going completely cashless is troubling for many reasons. I almost never have cash that I can give to beggers and buskers now (the later sometimes have little tap to pay machines). Given that there are plenty of people that are unbanked, it's going to be problematic to be 100%. These are not insurmountable problems, but you have to bake in solutions. Rights to have accounts even if you don't have a fixed address (etc).
- yur3i__ 5y ago> the later sometimes have little tap to pay machines Its interesting how these have started to crop up more and more recently as cash has declined, for instance my local Gurdwara (Sikh temple) which traditionally takes donations in cash has a little card machine you tap on as you go in. I wonder if when we get to a point where homeless people get them too, if people will trust them enough to do carded donations.
- nivenkos 5y agoIn Sweden they sometimes do it with a phone, as you can Swish to pay directly to phone numbers. I'm not sure how they register with a bank and their ID though, maybe it's not theirs or they share it. Nevertheless, they really shouldn't exist. There should be enough housing and emergency provision to help people in emergencies, and they need to crack down hard on the foreigners that come and use it as a way of sending money back - e.g. https://metro.co.uk/2017/02/20/gang-of-beggars-pictured-getting-out-of-romanian-registered-car-in-cambridge-6459992/ https://metro.co.uk/2017/02/20/gang-of-beggars-pictured-gett...
- omegaanon 5y agoIf you go into London now, so many homeless people have those card readers as people are just using their cards or mobile pay. Definitely see the change after the pandemic where they advertised cash in supermarkets to be the spreader of the virus.
- ojosilva 5y agoIn Brazil, with a huge informal economy, you can now find all sorts of small street vendors with a card reader. Also the government has successfully rolled out Pix less than 2yrs ago, with now 50% of the population as registered users. Pix is the smartphone payment protocol which has basically nuked cash transactions countrywide, or at least where mobile networks work. So, at least in Brazil, card readers are already on the way out for informal workers, and even some SMBs, and Pix with its QR codes and phone numbers are in.
- Vivtek 5y agoThis process has started in Puerto Rico, too. People still mostly use cash, but almost every vendor these days has ATH-Movil, a phone-based payment system through your bank.
- aufhebung 5y agoI've heard the same with China and WeChat Pay even pre pandemic. This is just from second hand anecdotes though so take it with a grain of salt.
- _hao 5y agoCan confirm. Beggars and small street paddlers in China all just have their WeChat Pay QR code printed and laminated or you can scan their phone. Hell, summer of 2018 when I was in Hong Kong there was an American tourist(? granted, he did look like one) that was begging with his QR code printed so he could "fly back home".
- nivenkos 5y ago
- vertis 5y agoCitation needed. Having worked with various homeless charities over the years this comment is not just wrong, it's insultingly wrong. Homelessness is a real problem[0] with various manifestations. The whole welfare cheat problem is statistically insignificant[1] compared to real problems that cause homelessness like domestic violence. This attitude that they're faking it and sending money to Romania is just not helpful. Note: I apologize for the Australian links but most of my experience comes from Australia [0]: https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/australias-welfare/homelessness-and-homelessness-services https://www.aihw.gov.au/reports/australias-welfare/homelessn... [1]: https://www.aic.gov.au/publications/tandi/tandi421 https://www.aic.gov.au/publications/tandi/tandi421
- native_samples 5y agoWhy do you think experience of Romanian immigrants in Australia would be relevant to the experience of people with Romanian beggars in the UK? The UK for years was a part of the EU and thus allowed unlimited, no-questions-asked immigration from Romania: the literal opposite of immigration policy in Australia.
- vertis 5y agoI said nothing about Romanian immigrants, rather that homelessness was a real problem. The parent comment was choosing to suggest that all beggars were fake and that you "shouldn't encourage them". They were using a rather poor metro.co.uk article as the only justification for that statement. Homelessness is a real problem everywhere. That most of my experience comes from Australia does not make it less relevant. I've spent enough time in the UK to know if anything Australia is better about homelessness. My citations spoke to the percentage of people that were abusing the welfare system. Something closely related to the perception that people are bad actors. It happens but it's a tiny percentage. If you have a study about the number of Romanian gangs that are begging, then by all means share.
- Apofis 5y agoI really wish more would have a scannable QR code for Venmo/Paypal. More outreach needs to be done in this regard to educate. Both issue debit cards.
- PeterisP 5y agoI'm not sure how/if Brexit has changed that in UK, but in EU there is indeed a legal right to have a basic bank account for everyone - a bank can't refuse opening a basic bank account just because they're e.g. homeless or a convict or whatever - and there has been a push for quite some time to reduce the number of "unbanked" people. From what I see locally, the very very poor people such as permanently unemployed rural alcoholics "living off the land" all do have bank accounts as that's the way they're getting state support payments.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoThe same thing still exists in the UK, the banks have to offer a basic account to anybody.
- jlokier 5y agoIt's actually the opposite in the UK. Banks are required to deny bank accounts to people who are disqualified from banking, and also deny them from being added as signatories on shared accounts. This is why cashless in the UK would be more harmful than in countries where everyone is allowed banking as a right. In the UK, access to banking is a government-controlled privilege, even though most people take it for granted and think that everyone can have it. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/home-office-immigration-checks-bank-accounts-mps-campaign-groups-urge-stop-caroline-lucas-david-lammy-a8118251.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/home-office-...
- Symbiote 5y agoSimilar checks are already normal in the EU; national identity card systems, a population registry etc already prevent non-residents from opening bank accounts. Just search "open bank account Germany" or similar, and you'll see you need proof of residence. The checks tend to be done once by the government, rather than 10 times by 10 private businesses.
- PeterisP 5y ago
- bloqs 5y agoCommissioned by an ATM provider... Additionally, I would say this is actually fairly low opposition compared to the popular buy-in in Britian for any other sort of change. People fear everything new, all of the time.
- matthewmacleod 5y agoNot only is the study commissioned by the ATM network, it’s also published by the Telegraph - so be wary. This paper runs an explicit campaign called the “Keep Cash Campaign”, so you shouldn’t expect to see anything that examines this issue seriously (if that wasn’t already clear from the headline). That said, paying attention to the needs of unbanked or at-risk people is important and can be overlooked too often.
- dTal 5y agoHmmm, so given the close affiliation between the Telegraph and the Tory party - do we know why the Telegraph is so pro-cash? What's the political angle on it? We can be certain it's not because of its importance to the disadvantaged. I'm pro-cash but now I must wonder.
- thinkingemote 5y agoLow c conservative, not too fond of new technologies or rapid change. Also classic upper l Liberal tendency towards freedom from tracking, Id cards etc. In terms of money, limiting cash affects small businesses whose owners tend to vote conservative. In recent years the Tory party has a larger share of "working people" lower middle class, who also prefer cash, (cash in hand etc) but who won't read the Telegraph. Basically it's about their voter base. ---- For me, I tend to use cash often for small things from smaller places but in larger amounts for street taxis (good, fast and very easy to get), for street / box charity and church service donations.
- matthewmacleod 5y agoAt the risk of being reductive, basically “Aging Tory readership thinks all change is bad” and the Telegraph will capitalise on that. That doesn’t mean there can’t be good reasons, only that the source is something to be skeptical of. It’s similar to their “we should switch back to imperial measurements” campaigning - a sop to a particular kind of conservative UK reader.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoI can't imagine the plight of the unbanked is very high on the list of the Telegraph's concerns.
- davidhbolton 5y agoOther reasons to keep cash. 1. Self discipline. Plastic (debit or credit) lets you spend more than you should. Cash doesn't. 2. Privacy. Do you really want every transaction to be observed by the Government? "We think you are spending too much on alcohol. Reduce it and increase spending on greens by at least £5 a week". Don't think it will happen? Remember Nudgers gotta nudge. Also I wonder just how big the black economy is. 3. Where do you keep the rainy day fund? I don't think anyone is developing an electronic mattress.
- erincandescent 5y ago> Plastic (debit or credit) lets you spend more than you should. I think this differs from person to person. Cash for me requires more self-discipline, because I don't automatically get a log of where the money has gone and so in some ways it just disappears without me having an idea where (Sure, my bank statement can't tell me what I bought at a given shop, but knowing I spent €X at a shop is a good memory jog)
- dTal 5y agoOdd example - Britain has a huge alcohol abuse problem and staging interventions on alcoholics who are spiraling the plughole is probably the most politically acceptable application of financial surveillance one could think of.
- xdfgh1112 5y agoWe already have the ability to block gambling transactions, it's not a huge jump to block alcohol ones if the card owner desires it.
- g_p 5y agoOne issue with doing this is that blocking gambling is usually done by the merchant classification. Betting shops are easy to categorise and identify from their merchant category. Alcohol can be bought from a supermarket, or corner shop, or off-licence. Other than dedicated off-licences, the merchant classification wouldn't be enough to let you block gambling transactions. To do this effectively, you'd need support in the EMV spec to allow the card to tell the terminal it is unable to pay for goods in a given "category", and have a standardized list of goods categories, and let the POS system send a list of categories to the card before it tries to authorize the transaction. Otherwise I don't see how you could "delve into" the purchase deeper than seeing it's in a supermarket, and not knowing if it's for alcohol or other items.
- nivenkos 5y agoCashless is great, I moved from the UK to Sweden. Haven't used cash in years. Also helps to stop drug dealers and tax evasion.
- sneak 5y agoStopping drug dealers has the side effect of stopping drug purchasers who are trying to self-medicate in the best way they know how. In my view that is a human rights violation.
- mjbeswick 5y agoPeople don't sell drugs to help people, they sell them to make easy money. That wouldn't be such a bad thing if drugs didn't destroy the live of so many people, and the lives of those around them. Not all drugs are so bad, and that is reflected in their classification under the Dangerous Drugs Act. I can only assume that you or anyone you care about hasn't died or destroyed their life due to drug addition?
- syshum 5y agoThe war on drugs and prohibition has destroyed more lives than the drugs themselves. Prohibition and criminalization of drug use is not the way to solve a medical problem of drug addiction and abuse
- mjbeswick 5y agoAbsolutely. Possession shouldn't be a crime; just the intent to supply. The best way to help addicts is to supply them with safe places to go to administer drugs, and provide registered addicts with safe drugs and support for free. It's expensive, but less expensive than wasting resources treating people that are essentially victims, as criminals. It's important to note that "the war on drugs" is an American concept; not how things are done in the rest of the world. It's almost like they learned nothing from the prohibition!
- livueta 5y ago
- Traster 5y agoLaying aside the questionable sources of these claims, I did try and pay for a meal in cash at the weekend and the pub I was in said "Oh no, we don't take cash" and frankly I think that's just unacceptable. Fine yes, 99% of the time I have a card, but on the occasions where I do want to pay in cash I should be able to and it's just crappy service to refuse. It's not like they don't have tills, they just decided it was easier for them not to bother.
- France_is_bacon 5y ago
- matthewmacleod 5y agoLike taking cards, taking cash isn’t free for a business - between the cost to deposit, the need to physically take the cash to the bank, and the need to keep a float. So there’s going to be a business decision to be made - is it worth the time and effort to take cash if basically nobody wants to use it? It’s easy to see why a business might just not be interested, in the same way they wouldn’t be interested in taking a personal cheque. Given the general spending patterns in the UK it feels like the only way businesses will continue accepting cash payments in the long term will be if is legally required. There are some decent arguments in favour of doing that, but without a firm requirement to do so it doesn’t seem unacceptable for a business to refuse a payment method that’s pretty unpopular.
- presentation 5y agoAlso the labor cost to have staff count the money in registers at closing time.
- bell-cot 5y agoBut, at least here in Michigan, the cost of taking non-cash payment is enough higher (vs. cash) that many gas stations offer a small discount for paying (for low-margin gasoline) with cash.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoNot a Brit, but I would be against going fully cashless in my country if that means that foreign entities like Visa or Mastercard would tax every transaction done.
- dijonman2 5y agoI’m against going cashless for anonymity. Hypothetically let’s say I buy some weed and it’s not yet legal. I don’t want to incriminate myself or provide data for parallel construction
- KptMarchewa 5y agoI don't think "I don't want to go cashless because I want to conduct criminal activity anonymously" is very convincing.
- sneak 5y agoThe definition of "criminal activity" is constantly changing arbitrarily as governments seize more power and control than ever before.
- KerrAvon 5y agoThe answer to this is to band together and fix the governments. I understand that this is not libertarian orthodoxy, but libertarian orthodoxy got us into this mess.
- djohnston 5y agoNeo liberalism brought us here on bright smiles and charming promises.
- syshum 5y ago> libertarian orthodoxy got us into this mess. What? What@@!@ Hardly, people not listening to the warning of libertarians got us into this mess. Libertarians have been very accurate to the consequences of government largess, and at every turn people ignore the results of government programs doubling down claiming that not enough money was spent, or not enough power was ceased, or a loop hole was really the problem No libertarianism did not cause this mess, far far far from it
- throwaway22032 5y agoI pay with cash wherever possible and if somewhere refuses me, I tell them I'll pay this time by card but I'm not coming back. The whole thing reminds me of the Google tracking article posted on here earlier. I don't want you to know my name, and I don't want anyone other than us to know about this interaction. Simply - no. No further reason required.
- sneak 5y ago> I pay with cash wherever possible and if somewhere refuses me, I tell them I'll pay this time by card but I'm not coming back. Leave all your cards at home. Make it their problem. This is what I do.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoOpposite. Wish Google had search that shows places without PayWave. Handling cash is disgusting and so inconvenient.
- walterbell 5y agoIn some U.S. cities, there's a legal requirement for every business to accept cash. One fast food place said they were only accepting cards because the manager had left and taken the cash drawer with them (not trusting the employees to handle cash?). After being reminded of the local law, which they knew, they found a couple of workarounds.
- galdosdi 5y agoIn the entire US there is also the (sometimes misunderstood) "legal tender" doctrine. By law US currency is "legal tender" for settling any debt. This means cash cannot be refused for a service/product that has already been provided. Businesses are still free to be picky (eg, no cash, or no coins, or no $100 bills, etc) if they haven't actually provided the service yet. So for example at a cashless counter serve restaurant that requires me to pay before getting my food, they can indeed refuse to take cash. But at a place that gives you your food first and then the bill, they have to accept cash. They have no legal recourse if you give them cash and they don't want it.
- mhh__ 5y agoI bought a kebab with some change then gave a few quid to a homeless guy. I think that's it for the last 3 years for me when it comes to cash.
- bradhe 5y ago> Around 10 million people, or one in five adults, would struggle to manage in a society without cash, a report from the Royal Society of Arts commissioned by cash machine network Link found. Great source you got there, Telegraph.
- LinuxBender 5y agoWhile I do not foresee this being adopted in the US I won't put it past lobbyists to try. Maybe they are already trying? I personally would never go for this. Cash in my pocket can't be "disabled" individually. In fact I am seeing a transition to targeted risks in many places. Amazon destroying small local stores facilitating the ability to disable someone's purchasing capabilities or limiting what one person may buy. As a side note, porch pirates are becoming a real nuisance for local authorities. Network connected cars can be remotely tracked, disabled or bricked. Smart homes that can monitor an individual. Smart phones tracking individuals. I don't think I could fully embrace the Amish way of life but I suspect my local community mostly farmers and ranchers could implement a barter system if we had to. Some of this already exists. We could be self sufficient for things like food, basic repairs, transportation via horses. I am personally not opposed to giving up some luxuries like internet and online shopping if it came to that. I realize some people born into these things perceive them as absolutely mandatory but I did just fine without them for a big part of my life. In the last several months I have not needed to travel more than 16 miles from home. I suppose I could stock up on e-bike parts and solar panels then fall back to horses. Come to think of it, we could build a local warehouse business that stocks up on things not made locally then sell them locally using cash or maybe even implementing a Craigslist-Style barter system over Lo-Rad. Am I alone on HN in thinking this way? I know I am not alone in my local community, but I am curious how many on HN have thought about this.
- brianwawok 5y agoNot alone, but not in the majority I suspect. I touch maybe $100 in actual cash a year. Mostly for like a random garage sale or two. The less I touch the better.
- kmonsen 5y agoI don’t think I touch any cash at all, but I think society is better when the option is there and used. Also some people have a hard time getting a bank account etc.
- sslayer 5y agoSo,what happens when the following get ahold of your data: Health insurance companies start buying your purchasing info and decide to up your premiums due to the amount of alcohol you buy, fast food you purchase, or your grocery shopping habits? Do you eat too much red meat, too many carbs, not enough greens? Is your sugar intake put you at a higher risk for diabetes? How may cigars/cigarettes are you smoking? What about marijuana use, or over the counter drugs? Home owners insurance: What if your shopping data shows risky patterns or behaviors - do you or spouse buy too many candles, is your home at a greater risk for fire hazard? Law Enforcement: How much ammo do you purchase? Are you frequently buying guns? Are you an active shooter risk? Are you spending too much at strip clubs? Are you spending too much money in high risk neighborhoods? Obviously these are all just examples, but don't think for a second that they don't already have most of this data, and can brainstorm many other use cases for it, honestly we are just living on borrow time at the moment before it gets unbearable.
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.ph/6EK3p https://archive.ph/6EK3p
- nerdawson 5y ago> Around 10 million people, or one in five adults, would struggle to manage in a society without cash, a report from the Royal Society of Arts commissioned by cash machine network Link found. A study commissioned by a cash machine operator finds people really need cash machines.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> Royal Society of Arts I really want to know what their interest is here... high-arts certainly don't depend on cash-tips the way that seedier types of artistic expression do...
- f7ebc20c97 5y agoArt sales and donations are used for money laundering and tax evasion. That's why the quality of art has no relation to its price anymore. Modern art streamlined this business (since it can be mass produced quickly) and NFTs streamline this even further.
- akimball 5y agoYet FinCEN allows artists to just make paintings as they please, and their trade is unregulated. Shocking!
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> Modern art streamlined this business Not a fan of po-mo then, I take it?
- f7ebc20c97 5y agoI'm a fan of some, but it's a subjective thing, isn't it? Don't you think that maybe perhaps some of the "auction prices" and "appraisals" are a bit more "objective"? Can nobody on this website think outside the box?
- slg 5y ago
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoalso known as "80% of Britons see no or few issues with going cashless; welcome coming changes"
- daenz 5y agoAlso known as "It's ok to ostracize 20% of the more vulnerable people when it's something I like."
- rufusroflpunch 5y agoAlso known as “democracy.”
- gruez 5y agoWhich is why we also have a more specific term called "liberal democracy"
- wolverine876 5y agoThat's not democracy, as it's actually conceived. Democracy isn't mob rule, but is about individual self-determination and rights.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoDemocracy is absolutely not about individual anything. You might want to add individual self-determination and rights to the governing principles of a particular organization, state or nation, but there's nothing about the idea of the people voting (directly or indirectly) on policy that offers any guarantee of any kind of self-determination. Democracy absolutely can be mob rule, or put differently, mob rule is not inherently not democratic. Whether it is wise or just however, are different questions entirely, and so most democracies in the last few hundred years have supplemented their democratic systems of governance with fundamentally liberal but non-democratic constitutions that limit the scope of majoritarian decision making.
- NaturalPhallacy 5y ago>One more step >Please complete the security check to access archive.ph I'm so sick of this. Isn't there a better archive site out there?
- timbit42 5y agoTry the ByPass Paywalls Clean browser plugin.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoYou could try paying for the content instead of leaching it for free.
- TeeMassive 5y agoSurely, the government will never arbitrarily freeze citizens' accounts by retroactively marking certain donations as illegal.
- Nursie 5y agoWhere did that happen? And before you say "Canada", take note that there is no evidence that such a thing happened. One person was reported by a local politician to have had her accounts frozen, but when a list of donors was leaked later, no matching name was found. AFAICT, and I've looked, there is no decent evidence that any donors had their accounts frozen. It's just a right wing talking point. The donated funds were frozen, temporarily, while the border blockage and other illegal protest activities were cleared up. But donors? Nope.
- JetAlone 5y agoEven if I give you your denial, Justin Trudeau's administration did at the very least threaten to do it. If you were living with someone who threatened financial abuse against you, would you not be seriously concerned about them being financially abusive? But that's more rhetorical. I don't care that much what you think cause I know you'd be downplaying it if it did happen. And whenever it does happen (again?), you'll be out there denying it, carrying water with all the others for the establishment's ability to overreach, shielding them from consequences and making it more likely to happen in the future. You'll do it until such time as it happens to you, and then you'll be confused, and possibly sorry.
- AvAn12 5y agoAny opinions from the crypto crowd? Cash seems like the ultimate libertarian way to go. My cash is physically in my wallet - nobody can touch it or take it. It is indisputably mine. And I know shops, vendors, and pubs will accept it. As soon as I de-materialize the cash into some electronic form, then I become dependent on (1) my phone provider (2) my computer (3) whatever coin exchange is involved (4) whatever method the merchant uses to convert electronic units into national currency so that they can pay their taxes (and probably their suppliers and employees). There are plenty of 100% cash business out there - I think because they like the same liberties which crypto offers...
- oneoff786 5y ago> My cash is physically in my wallet - nobody can touch it or take it. It is indisputably mine. This holds up surprisingly poorly if the other guy has a knife.
- hexis 5y agoOr a legislature.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoor a badge.
- kimixa 5y agoOr simply you misplace your wallet. Then you have to make the decision of how much you're willing to risk in taking out of your "totally safe" under-the-mattress stash each day, and that runs into inconvenience of if too high you lost a lot after a few beers on a Friday night, if too small you can't buy everything you wanted in the spur of the moment.
- paxys 5y agoOr just the power of the state behind them. The government can always take your money, regardless of what form it is in and where it is.
- gerdesj 5y agoI can remember the days when the Tele (and all other rags) used to whine about those new fangled cash dispensers. Britain really isn't being forced to go cashless. There's a move towards more cashlessness. There is an argument to be had about anonymity ie if you spend a £10 note, there is nothing to link you to it but that's something else.
- asdff 5y agoI really like cash for a few things. For instance local buying and selling. It's so much more convenient to just hand someone a $20 and walk away with the item than to spend the 5 mins dallying on venmo trying to look up their handle, with terrible cell service, and hope you don't misclick on a total stranger who won't return your money if its missent. When I'm selling I prefer cash in hand too. I don't want to find myself in some elaborate scam using these electronic transfer apps. Cash also helps with tipping. If I hand a waiter cash, I know it goes to them. If I write a tip as a line item on the check, who knows how management is skimming that pool. Then there is the security aspect. Credit card info can be leaked or scammed many ways. Meanwhile, with a cash payment our relationship is severed the minute I leave the establishment. There is no opportunity for you to collect my info, or for a hacker to steal my info through you, or to take any more money from me than the finite amount I already gave you. Plus there is the human aspect too. Many people beg for cash, but also many small business owners cannot afford to work over the table. I'm talking things like food vendors in trucks or simply on tables on the sidewalk. I love me some al pastor, and I know that should these businesses have to go from grey market to white market they wouldn't nearly be so viable. Cash makes these sorts of businesses possible and provides a lot of opportunities for plenty of people that for many reasons, do not currently use electronic means.
- makeitdouble 5y agoGranted we’re on a startup forum and most of us develop services: > It's so much more convenient to just hand someone a $20 and walk away with the item than to spend the 5 mins dallying on venmo trying to look up their handle Wouldn’t this be solved at the matching level ? You probably found that person online, checked the photos and description and decided to make the transaction. If there is a “complete the purchase“ button you just click, there would be no thumbling in Venmo. And this is exactly my experience with local marketplace sites. > If I hand a waiter cash, I know it goes to them. It might be different where you live, but they can be requested by contract to add it to a pool. The same way when you pay your meal you hand the waiter cash but it doesn’t go to them. > Credit card info can be leaked or scammed many ways. Meanwhile, with a cash payment our relationship is severed the minute I leave the establishment. Wait, have you ever been scammed by paying by card in an offline setting ? Or have the transaction replayed or reused ? How would it work ? > I know that should these businesses have to go from grey market to white market they wouldn't nearly be so viable. This is I think the most prevalent point. Going forward I’d only see prepaid offline system to cover this, and we’re not there yet on the user to user money exchange side (it currently only works in a centralized setting as far as I know)
- dd444fgdfg 5y agohere in Australia nobody ever seems to have cash anymore, and it doesn't seem to be an issue. Tap your phone to pay, done.
- tallytarik 5y agoAbsolutely! It just sort of seemed to 'happen' here in Australia over the past ~10 years. It's always a bit surprising when this comes up that this isn't the norm elsewhere. I personally love the convenience, but admittedly I'm not the demographic that this article is talking about.
- epilogue 5y agoOne shortcoming that I found recently as I was selling my car is we don’t seem to have a good system for instant payments for large amounts of money. Having lived in the UK for a while I noticed how bank transfers there seemed to be instant regardless of the amount (just my experience, never did anything over a few thousand). But I was stuck in the position of either asking for way to much cash that I would be comfortable having to then take into the bank (and probably hard to find a bank that even had that much to withdraw in the first place) or accept a bank cheque which while most people say it’s “as good as cash” I noticed certain banks like NAB have a disclaimer that they can cancel them if they are reported lost or stolen. I ended up accepting the bank cheque on Friday afternoon, couldn’t deposit it till Monday and then had 3 nervous days of waiting for it to clear. While PayID and Osko seem to be taking us in the right direction, the limits are still too restrictive for large in person transactions like this.
- Nursie 5y agoWTF? I sold a car through gumtree here in Aus a few years ago, the buyer sent a bank transfer, I received it, went about my day. Seems very similar to the UK (where I have spent most of my life and still have accounts/make transfers).
- epilogue 5y agoAs far as I understand bank transfers here are only instant if you are both with the same bank or you use PayID/Osko, which seems to have the caveat of your bank can set their own limit as to maximum transfer size (A quick google shows anywhere from 5k to 30k) and not all banks support this (HSBC don’t). Of course you could ask the buyer to transfer the money and wait for it to clear before handing over the keys, but that just moves the uncomfortable and stressful situation to the other party (I wouldn’t want to transfer someone money and then have to wait a few days for it to clear before they handed me the keys) and doesn’t actually solve the underlying issue.
- 21723 5y agoA cashless society will be a disaster in other ways, too. You think banks are bad now? You dislike fees? If there's no cash, third parties will be able to hike percentages on transfers of all kinds. You could see credit card fees of 10+ percent, which will be passed on to you even if you're not aware of them. Cash has to exist as an option to keep middlemen honest. Until, that is, we achieve communism... but that's several decades away at a minimum.
- zanethomas 5y agoThe day will come when people once again use silver and gold as mediums of exchange. Some states allow same to be used as legal tender. For example, Utah: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_Legal_Tender_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_Legal_Tender_Act
- irrational 5y ago> The public now withdraws around £100m less from cash machines each day compared to before the pandemic I found this astonishing. I haven’t used cash in so many years that I can’t even remember which decade I last used it. The fact that so many people are still using ATMs astonished me.
- standardUser 5y agoThere are still cash-only bars and restaurants in the US and lots of transactions that usually can't be completed without cash, like drugs and sex.
- irrational 5y agoLOL Well, that explains some of the reasons I haven’t needed any cash in more years than I can remember.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoI pretty much stopped using cash because of the pandemic. Pretty much every place I shopped refused cash to start with and I never went back. I had the same £60 in my wallet for two years and only used it because the notes are going out of circulation soon. Having said that I still keep some cash on hand for emergencies.
- bouncycastle 5y agoThe biggest issue I see with a cashless society is that we stop owning our money. "Your" money in the bank is just a record in somebody else's database. You do not own the database, you do not have any oversight over how this database is used and your access is limited to their "permissions" list. Is this what we want in the future?
- YZF 5y agoDo you keep all your worldly possessions as cash under your mattress? Isn't your "cash" a database entry in your bank account anyways?
- jjav 5y agoThere is a very large area between the absolutes of "all your worldly possessions as cash under your mattress" and all your payment ability as numbers in someone elses database which can be cut off any moment. Personally I'd recommend (and do) keeping enough months of living expenses in cash somewhere convenient.
- YZF 5y agoIn the hypothetical situation that me and my wife are locked out of all my bank accounts (multiple in multiple countries) and that somehow my family and friends are unwilling/unable to assist I still have assets I can sell. But sure, if you're planning on/for becoming a fugitive from the law (lessay) then it might make sense to keep cash or something like gold. I'm really not planning or going to worry about that sort of low probability event. I have considered keeping gold but that's more because I like how shiny it is than any real concern.
- jjav 5y ago> all my bank accounts (multiple in multiple countries) Realize that puts you in a fairly special position with a lot more flexibility than the average person. A lot of people just have one account, so if that one gets locked up, it's a tough situation.
- philwelch 5y agoJust in the space of a single month earlier this year, we saw two extraordinary things happen: 1. The executive branch of a major Western democracy unilaterally invoked emergency powers to freeze the bank accounts of political dissidents. 2. Two American credit card companies unilaterally and without warning revoked all service to an entire country. In a cashless system, your money does not belong to you. It belongs to authorities and institutions that do not care about you. Whether or not you can buy groceries can change in an instant, regardless of whether or not you personally deserve it. You might be trying to get your family out of a country that’s made itself an international pariah—you may even condemn your government’s actions—but that doesn’t mean your card is going to work when you try and buy a meal for your family at the train station.
- irrational 5y agoDespite the efforts of the Republicans to destroy the USA, I can’t seriously see this kind of thing happening. Russia on the other hand, since the war started I’ve read a number of articles by Russians saying they weren’t too surprised by what happened to them.
- solarhoma 5y agoPoint 1 happened in Canada not the US. Also, It was not republicans who invoked this power but Canadian leftists. Trudeau invoked emergency powers to quash dissidents in Montreal (?) because he did not agree with their protests. Incredible how the western world has turned a blind eye to this event because the ‘right’ people were targeted.
- codeecan 5y agoIt was Ottawa, and Trudeau used all same rhetoric Putin is using now, calling them Nazis[1], denying the leaders bail[2], charged with mischief, and pushing propaganda thru state media. Like the story of truckers attempting to burn down an apartment building[3], that turned out to be completely false, but used to prove violence and justify the emergencies act. [1] https://nypost.com/2022/02/16/justin-trudeau-sparks-outrage-after-accusing-conservatives-of-supporting-swastikas/ https://nypost.com/2022/02/16/justin-trudeau-sparks-outrage-... [2] https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/key-convoy-organizer-tamara-lich-denied-bail-while-patrick-king-appears-in-court-1.5790773 https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/key-convoy-organizer-tamara-li... [3] https://ottawa.ctvnews.ca/suspect-charged-in-downtown-ottawa-arson-last-month-not-connected-with-freedom-convoy-police-1.5828171 https://ottawa.ctvnews.ca/suspect-charged-in-downtown-ottawa...
- kdinn 5y agoI'm interested to read the vast majority of comments being pro-cash with concerns over security or convenience. I'm not sure where you all live, but as a counterpoint, I live in Australia and I don't use cash hardly at all any more. I don't even use cards, or take my wallet. If I have my phone on me I can charge anything to any of the 4 cards I have in my phone's wallet (also I can bring up my official Medicare card, drivers license, etc. on my phone). So whenever I go out I just grab my phone and keys. Everywhere accepts this. Whether I'm paying for a coffee or a $2,000 TV, I just unlock my phone and tap it on a payment terminal. It takes literally a second. For larger purchases (over A$200) you have to enter a PIN. I certainly wouldn't like to go back to carrying notes and coins around - making sure you have enough, handing it over, waiting for change to be organised (and waiting for them to do this with everyone before me). Pretty much all establishments still take cash but I don't use it, and most of my friends are the same.
- sergiotapia 5y agoMorally and philosophically I agree with you! Cash needs to exist for personal liberties. But I've been in the states for 7 years now and I can't think of one time I used cash when purchasing anything. Except the few times I picked something up from OfferUp (a palm tree, some other plants).
- jollybean 5y agoYes that's all fine and good, but finance is at the heart of structured civilization, and we're note quite there yet with respect to open, transparent systems, that have privacy and resiliency. The INTERAC network in Canada is owned by the banks and it's yet another 99% margin rake on small businesses. It's a game of leverage - the big chains can negotiate a deal, the smaller vendors are out. The Canadian government just invoked a kind of 'Marshall Law' because protestors were honking horns and not moving. While I'm glad the Police moved them (and should have sooner), the fact is, personal financial bank accounts of individuals not very related to the transactions were shut down by the federal government. A politicized situation should not allow for the cancellation of the flow of money, that should be strictly an issue of the justice system, and then, proportionately. The thought that the gov, or a bank, or Amazon could stop me from giving someone $40 for almost whatever reason, is Orwellian. All of our leaders relish, at least on some level, the opportunity for control - and I'm not being conspiratorial here, I do think that for now things are benign, but it takes the smallest 'problem' for things to go south. I think we need a system that has privacy, that has no fees, and whereupon individuals cannot be 'de-banked' from the system in any way, i.e where it would take some act of interdictive oversight for the justice system, with a warrant, to get access to, or control some transactions (i.e. major drug bust, bribery, organized crime). In effect: we need a 'digital cash' that's 'just like cash', meaning that it's open, anonymous, secure, maybe not very useful to transport large quantities, there's no arbitrary means of interdiction etc..
- motohagiography 5y agoSimply, this is an attack to permanently seize economic power and to subdue a society and culture. Words mean nothing to the architects of these plans. Discussing this at all is like being jumped and when your attacker fails to get you into handcuffs, you try to have a discussion about the pros and cons of being handcuffed.
- mark_l_watson 5y agoI don’t accept a world where people and businesses can’t both choose whether the use cash or eCash for any transaction. I think diversity is good. Have some cash in case the ATMs fail for a week, have credit cards for day to day convenience. Privacy issues are also a huge issue but most people choose to ignore them.
- garbagetime 5y agoAt least we'll have cryptocurrencies
- Clubber 5y agoI would guess this is an attempt to quash the drug trade, which requires cash. I'm sure people will find a workaround though. It would restrict many private person-to-person sales, so it would boost retailers quite a bit. Garage sales and the like will be a lot more difficult. Farmer's markets too. Also it makes it easier to track down people who the police are looking for. That sounds fine until you realize how many false convictions exists and how eager cops are to find, "medium height, medium build, medium skin with a red or blue shirt on." If I trusted law enforcement / justice system to be accountable and right their wrongs, I'd be more okay with it. They can freeze your assets and make it really hard to get a lawyer and no cash to afford one. Also it would suck during hurricanes and other natural disasters. Assume the worst before you sign over your privacy. It's just not worth it, I pay taxes, the government can continue to provide cash as a transaction method for citizens. I'm sure the credit card companies are lobbying to push this through as well. 3% on all transactions forever ain't nothin'. So what's the benefit of forcing this on people? Why is having a choice between cash or card on any transaction bad?
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>I would guess this is an attempt to quash the drug trade, which requires cash. It's driven by consumers and businesses serving them. I'm sure the government don't mind, especially HMRC, but they aren't the ones instigating this. >3% on all transactions forever ain't nothin' Not in the UK, Visa and Mastercard fees are capped.
- markdown 5y agoThis happened in Fiji, a couple of years ago, in terms of public transport. The government made it illegal for bus operators to accept cash as a form of payment.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoIn the UK buses never seemed to have any change so the transition to using cars has made taking the bus much more convenient.
- randyrand 5y agocash does not require internet access or electricity. I don’t see how it can be replaced.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoIt already has been replaced, we are dependent on internet access and electricity.
- rswail 5y agoFor those in the US worried about cash "disappearing", see this legislation recently introduced in the House [1]. It specifically counters the problems of crypto-currencies (the excess energy requirements, the transaction processing speed, etc) while providing the same guarantees as physical notes and coins and for settlement of public/private debts. For those outside the US that are nout (hide-)bound by the US's antiquated banking system, cashless/contactless credit and debit processing has dramatically reduced physical cash usage everywhere. Physical cash (notes/coins) is likely to mostly die out over this century. The issues raised about anonymity and traceability etc are solvable with appropriate legislation, regulation, and design. First, there was a mandate for Chip+PIN (not signature) from the various payment networks/processors. The EMV standards for this dramatically reduced fraud and the transfer of risk from the merchant to the network reduced costs. Second, in many countries (I'm in Australia), interchange fees are regulated and capped, while costs for processing card transactions must be separate and advertised to consumers and also limited. Third, the introduction of contactless EMV, along with high "floor limits" (AUD200 in Australia's case) means that for the majority of transactions, there is no physical interaction required. Fourth, most countries not only have the two primary payment networks (ie Visa/MC) but also have a third network, usually sponsored by the local monetary authority and/or local banks, for debit transactions tied to bank accounts (EFTPOS network in Australia). Fifth, in EU, Australia, and other places, there are now "instant payment" networks, with direct settlement between accounts at the monetary authority's accounts. (New Payments Platform/Osko/PayID in Australia) [2] [1] https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/7231?q=%7B%22search%22%3A%5B%22H.R.+7231%22%2C%22H.R.%22%2C%227231%22%5D%7D&s=7&r=1 https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/7231... [2] https://nppa.com.au/ https://nppa.com.au/
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoI fell in love with NFC (tap to pay) when I visited Australia, and I haven't carried around cash in the states for 5 or so years now (and now I'm not even using my card anymore, just double tap a button on my watch and tap against the card reader). Before coming back to the states I was in China and since I didn't have a Chinese ID card, couldn't use WePay so had to use cash or UnionPay for everything (I hear it is easier for foreigners now).
- asplake 5y agoIn my household we refer to coins as “parking tokens”. We hardly use cash for anything else, and even that need is diminishing. UK-based.
- alexb_ 5y agoA lot of people in this thread are missing the main problem that people have. Yes, cash can be inconvenient, but by eliminating cash entirely you are putting 100% of all wealth into the power of banks. Those without a bank account will be left behind and FORCED to open one. This gives banks and governments immense control and power over literally all the money you own. Given said power, they will abuse it for their own profit. It's not a question of "IF they abuse it" it is a GUARANTEED. They WILL abuse this power. If you deny this fact, you are living in a fantasy. Give people power, and it will be used, 100% of the time, and not to your benefit.
- HideousKojima 5y agoSee, for a recent example in a supposedly free first world country, Canada. Even people who donated to the truckers before the crackdown got targeted in the bank account freezes. Just like with any bulk data collection and surveillance technology, it is only a question of how soon it will be abused.
- lottin 5y agoAre you sure this is abuse? My guess is a judge ordered the accounts to be frozen.
- nmca 5y agoI wish someone could produce a cryptocurrency that actually worked (high throughput, anonymous, distributed account recovery, good ux). Tap-to-pay, but without enslaving the world to the whims of HSBC etc.
- exdsq 5y agoJust because it’s easy to use contactless doesn’t mean we should lose the privacy that cash gives us. The only people who win from this situation is the governments ability to control at a more granular level.
- jgaa 5y agoThe move towards cashless was one of the reasons I left Norway 14 years ago. This is matter of such magnitude that it makes sense to vote with your feet.
- jdrc 5y agoIn an entirely financialized world, control of money is used as a substitute for violence. Demonetization, sanctions, unbanking are increasingly used for behavioral adjustment. People who want to reduce the risk of monetary violence will learn from whatever the chinese and russians have been doing for decades
- pengaru 5y agoRecently I encountered this kind of horse shit visiting friends in Santa Monica. Half the places we went to for food or drinks refused cash, if the federal government isn't going to prohibit this the cities should at least do it. Plenty of people only have access to cash, it's arguably discriminatory which is already illegal in the US for businesses serving the public. I'm just waiting for a savvy LA attorney to gather together enough homeless people from Skid Row for a class action lawsuit and take this issue to the supreme court on discriminatory grounds.
- s1artibartfast 5y agodiscrimination isn't illegal, only against specific groups (e.g. race). Discriminating on factors that affect those groups is legal, as long as the intent is not to use it as a proxy for protected group. See credit scores for more information.
- pengaru 5y agoYou're not wrong, but discrimination in businesses serving the public is a pretty hairy subject. The protected groups are broad enough and the spirit of the law clearly such that there's a pretty straightforward path to arguing refusing to accept cash at public restaurants/bars is discriminating against minorities which tend to overlap substantially with poverty, or religions that prohibit the use of debt/credit where cash would be perfectly fine. The fact of the matter is this move towards cashless retail commerce alienates significant numbers of citizens, and those people overlap substantially with the existing protected groups. If you're going to refuse cash, it should be a private members-only club.
- xcambar 5y agoA cash-only society is also a more expensive one, for everyone: not only individuals are forced u to opening a bank account and owning a card, but the businesses have to pay fees to accept card payments. I have seen many small businesses go back to cash only at the reopening last year to save money. If we stretch mentally, maybe a seemingly easier, more secure means of payment (cashless) can ruin the web of small shops in our cities...
- idiocrat 5y agoIn next 10-20 years we all will be happily implanting chips with information about banking, tax, health, vote, employment history, criminal history, credit history, social score, DNA records, fingerprint records, driver license, keys to home, car and office, the BIOS of your notebook and phone. In name of progress (e.g. cars vs horses), whoever does not have an implant will be designated as anti-chipper and will be marginalized, not being able to participate in most of social events, like sport and musical events, driving cars, public transportation, flying, shopping. Maybe our generation (20-60 olds) will be able to come-by, moving out of big cities and living country side, the new Tick-Tock generation will not be able to understand how the life could be otherwise.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sumosudo 5y agoA cashless society means no cash. Zero. It doesn't mean mostly cashless and you can still use a wee bit of cash here and there. Cashless means fully digital, fully traceable and fully controlled. This means: No more tuck-away money for those preparing to leave an abusive relationship. No more purchases off market unless you want to risk bank transfer fraud. No more garage sales. No more cash donations to the homeless you pass. No more cash slipped to the hands of a child from a grandparent. No more money in birthday cards. No more piggy banks or tooth fairy for your child. No more selling bits and pieces from your home that you no longer want or need for a bit of cash in return. Less choice of where you purchase based on affordability. What cashless society does guarentee: Banks have full control of every cent you own. Every transaction you make is recorded. All your movements and actions are traceable.
- signal11 5y agoNewspapers often publish stories like these off the back of a single source. In this case, it’s “a report from the Royal Society of Arts commissioned by cash machine network Link”. Not to say it’s not newsworthy or even inaccurate, but it’s worth noting that this is a report commissioned by one of tHe UK’s biggest ATM operators. Second, there are costs to managing cash, especially when it’s a niche payment method. However, I’ve yet to see a place with human cashiers that doesn’t take cash. The big problem usually is vending machines / supermarket checkout machines whose cash readers have stopped working. Also the rise of “card only” machines, but again, these are placed alongside machines that take cash. I do agree it’s frustrating though, if you’re faced with machines that won’t take cash. Unfortunately, unless society starts using cash more (vs cards), this will just keep happening.
- sumosudo 5y agoWhen Ripple releases a whitepaper, you sit up and pay attention.. CBDC. Central Bank Digital Currency. Going Direct. https://ripple.com/lp/cbdc-whitepaper/ https://ripple.com/lp/cbdc-whitepaper/
- jlokier 5y agoIn Britain, specifically, one of the issues is that the law says a subset of people are to be denied banking. Banks must check; those people are not allowed to open bank accounts, or be added as users of shared accounts. That's the UK Hostile Environment "right to bank" policy (orwellian for "no right to bank"). It affects undocumented migrants and asylum seekers of course, but it also anyone whose papers are not in good order, whose visa expires and they don't manage to obtain new paperwork in time (and that event may trigger closure of existing accounts if unlucky), people who've grown up in the UK and only when they turn 18 discover they don't have normal rights, and a surprisingly large amount of government incompetence (notable example Windrush people), and some irrational cruelty against people who have not broken any rules. In short, banking in the UK is a government-controlled privilege not a right, and the government of the day isn't exactly strong on treating everyone well. But most people take banking for granted and think of it as available to everyone. Personally I think that access to essential basics such as buying food really needs to be open to everyone, not "subject to status". A cashless society that prohibits by law the means of payment for an underclass of people in it is a cruel society indeed, and pretty much guaranteed to increase modern slavery and abuse. We have enough of that in the UK already.
- evandijk70 5y agoI am from the Netherlands and studied in the UK for half a year. I asked if I should open a British bank account to save on transaction costs every time I bought something, and to make paying my rent easier. Other students from abroad told me not to bother, because it would take 3 months at least to setup a bank account. They also said I could probably pay my rent in cash if I asked (the landlord was actually rather pleased when I asked her if I could pay in cash). I ended up paying for everything in cash for half a year, as most places would not accept my debit card. I don't know how expats solve this that need a bank account to receive their salary..
- mFixman 5y agoYour friends were wrong. Opening a bank account in the UK is fast as of ~5 years ago.
- Bancakes 5y agoIs there a term for the situation "What is possible is optimised, what is impossible is unnecessary"? That's the word I'd use for money transfers. Cash is batteryless, offline, distributed, and always available. A solved problem.
- h0nd 5y agoCash is freedom and independence. Its not about convenience or struggles.
- FerretFred 5y agoInteresting .. We just spent a long weekend in a very popular seaside resort in the North and found that many shops were not accepting cash at all (fear of Covid living on plastic banknotes I guess), but many more were only accepting cash due to the exorbitant card fees now being levied by card companies. It'll be interesting to see how this pans out...