6 ms·
Wow, if they aren't suggesting dietary and exercise based solutions first, that's a huge red flag. Find a new doctor.
by giantg2 5y ago
Wow, if they aren't suggesting dietary and exercise based solutions first, that's a huge red flag. Find a new doctor.
- SpodGaju 5y agoYou will be hard pressed to find a doctor that talks nutrition. It took me four years to force my doctor to test my serum zinc levels. When she did they found I was deficient. She did not know what to do, nor did it even seem to impact or shock her. Zinc sulphate gave my life back to me. (Lupus, mood disorder) You would think that my doctor would share this with everyone. But no.
- giantg2 5y agoInteresting. A family member was having memory issues and the doctors were very supportive of our idea to look at the possibility of testing blood levels and taking supplements or changing diet based on the findings.
- SpodGaju 5y agoMedical care is not distributed evenly in the U.S. I think my issue was I was already disabled and on Medicare diagnosed with Bipolar disorder which is caused by my immune disregulation, probably Lupus. https://apm.amegroups.com/article/view/60122/html https://apm.amegroups.com/article/view/60122/html Anyway, it is difficult for the doctors to get medicare to cover these tests. I also insisted she perform a serum amino acid test which revealed several high amino acids including all of the branched chain amino acids. She had to make up reasons to get them to cover the tests even though I have all these issues, including poor kidney function. There is defiantly a stigma with how they treat people with mood disorders. Any physical complaint was always treated as it it were something I was imagining. I was only luckyy that my mother and brother has Ankylosing Spondylitis because even though I still had to fight to get an MRI for my lower back pain and they found I was in the early stages of the disease as well. She said now that she had the nutritional results she did not know what to do with them and she could not even send me to a specialist.
- giantg2 5y agoAh, true, coverage can be an issue. We were willing and able to pay out of pocket for tests, if needed. So were they hesitant to do the test at all, or was it that they didn't know how to order it for your insurance to cover it? That would be a big difference in my mind. Most doctors don't fight having blood tests done if there's at least some rationale for why to do it. They're so common and low risk. Yeah, I have had doctors just totally dismiss things when they know nothing about them (like saying things that are unsupported and contrary to new research). I have also had doctors say they didn't know but would do some research (good sign, but less common).
- SpodGaju 5y agoShe was hesitant because of my mood disorder diagnosis. She frankly admitted that. What I feel changed her mind is that I asked here what caused my mood disorder. She said she did not know. So I asked why she is not doing everything to help me find out. But all this too extensive logging, research, and persuasion on my part. To emphasize the issue I have had with doctors on medicare; I had IBS-D, a flare up so bad, for over a month. I went to a doctor, they took one fecal test which showed nothing. They did not reply to my continuing issue so I went back to them. The doctor said exactly this; "What do you want me to do about it?" I lost it. Yelled at him so loudly others came into the office. They never sent me to a gastro doc. I need up curing it on my own by using my understanding of my genetics and diet changes.
- s5300 5y agoAssumption makes an ass, but I think he means first line treatment when it comes to medicine. I’m sure that both nurse & doctor wholly recommended lifestyle changes.
- giantg2 5y agoIf you read the comment they said there was mention of losing weight but nothing about a low carb diet. Carbs are something any diabetic person should be counseled on, even if being placed on a medication.
- brenainn 5y agoOne of my scariest adulthood realizations is that doctors are like everybody else; fallible. And that being certified means you're good at studying, but doesn't always mean you're good at what you've studied. Not trying to discredit medical professionals or the amount of work they put in. I'm sure the majority are intelligent, conscientious and good at their jobs.
- fsckboy 5y ago> Not trying to discredit medical professionals... I'm sure the majority are ... good at their jobs I'm sure half of them are below average
- pdpi 5y agoThat’s not very informative without knowing what the average is.
- imtringued 5y agoBelow average compared to the patient? The problem is that it's true way too often.
- adrian_b 5y agoI have encountered a large number of excellent medical professionals, to whom I am greatly indebted for how they helped members of my family or myself. Unfortunately I have also encountered an about equal number of medical professionals who have been grossly incompetent. What I consider to have been by far the greatest mistake that I have made in my life, a mistake which had irremediable consequences, was to have excessive faith in the competence of some well-paid medical professionals. Both my parents had the bad luck of being misdiagnosed the first time when they had some medical problems (for completely unrelated causes). In both cases the correct diagnostic was discovered by other medical doctors, but only after many months, when their conditions had become much worse. Because of the delayed diagnostics, both their lives were shortened by maybe 4 to 5 years. After the correct diagnostics, I have read the appropriate medical textbooks and I have discovered that in both cases my parents had presented the typical ensemble of symptoms described in the textbooks, they were not some weird cases, easily misdiagnosed. For the correct diagnostics, the first doctors should have recognized the textbook symptoms and they should have sent them to the appropriate investigations that were necessary to confirm their maladies. Instead of that, they have chosen the lazy way of saying that they do not need any further investigations because old people complain all the time for various minor problems and they have prescribed them some useless treatments. If I would have been more skeptical about medical fallibility, I should have sought a second opinion since the beginning, but unfortunately I did not.
- dominotw 5y ago>Find a new doctor. why would someone need to go to a doctor to tell them that
- giantg2 5y agoIf they are in that situation it stands to reason they might not have that knowledge. It seems the grandparent(?) is an example of that when it came to low carb diet.
- refurb 5y agoHigh blood sugar levels are doing damage right now. Nothing wrong with starting on a therapy while trying to institute a diet and exercise change. The doctor would be negligent if they said "let's try diet and exercise", then after 6 months of damage say "nope, that didn't work, let's try metformin".
- giantg2 5y agoYeah, I sort of mentioned that in one of the other comments. Even when they start the meds, they should be trying to fix the underlying cause like dietary issues. Hopefully it would help make the medication more effective. It's something else to not even counsel a diabetic about carbs.
- ceeplusplus 5y agoPrescriptions of diet and exercise are ineffective because many obese / type 2 diabetic people can't exercise self-control. That's why they're obese in the first place. It's way easier to take a pill than cut to 1500 calories a day for 2 years.
- bsder 5y ago> Prescriptions of diet and exercise are ineffective because many obese / type 2 diabetic people can't exercise self-control. That's why they're obese in the first place. Research continues its trend against this statement. 1) One problem is the fact that the number of fat cells in the body is conserved after some point. So, if you grew lots of fat cells as a child, sucks to be you, you're now stuck with them as an adult. 2) Caloric consumption has been tracked and cross referenced between countries, and obesity doesn't always correlate with it. Apparently, there are other things going on. Some of these seem to be environmental. 3) Fat cells "remember" your weight when they were formed. Once you become obese, your body fights your attempts to lose weight all the way down until those cells die off and are replaced (about 10% per year or so). It takes MASSIVE amounts of willpower to fight your own body over years. 4) Exercise is practically useless for weight loss. The body demands a fixed number of calories (up until you're doing something at the level of extreme training) and shunts the available calories between systems. Exercise has lots of benefits. Weight loss just isn't one of them. 5) I do agree that nothing in the US helps you avoid gaining weight. Portion sizes are gigantic (a "personal" pizza in the US is a full pizza in Naples). Walking or bicycling is rarely useful for most people. Sugar gets added to everything (For example: Austin, TX has been a particular victim of this--gigantic glasses of unsweetened iced tea used to be the default a decade or so ago but has been replaced by sweetened or double-sweetened iced tea (which used to be limited to the Southeastern states)).
- adrian_b 5y agoI agree with a part of what you say, e.g. that exercise is almost useless for weight loss. I know these theories about the number of fat cells and about their slow replacement, etc. Nevertheless, they do not match my experience. I have been obese during about 15 years. Then I began to measure precisely the quantities of food that I eat and after almost a year I reduced my weight to only two thirds from that of the previous year. Since then, another 15 years have passed, during which I controlled easily my weight, also by eating most of the time only carefully measured quantities of food. During my weight loss, I was concerned about possible problems, precisely because I had also heard these theories about the fat cells that you have mentioned. However, I have not seen any evidence for them. Before losing weight, climbing stairs was difficult, it felt like carrying a huge backpack, and I could not even see my lower body due to my belly. After losing weight, not only all physical activities became easy, but even if there was a very large reduction in waist circumference, so initially the skin remained rather loose, after not a long time it adjusted, so no signs of the former size remained. There were no problems whatsoever caused by the weight loss, but I had to retain forever the habit of eating according to a plan, because any day when I eat outside the plan, I immediately gain weight. If you do not eat enough food to keep alive all your cells, some cells must die (after you have already consumed most of the internal energy supplies stored in fat). It is very unlikely that your internal regulation mechanisms will not ensure that the unused fat cells will die before cells that are in active use, e.g. muscle cells. So that theory about the constancy of the fat cell number can be true only while you are still eating some excess food or while you have not lost most of the fat reserves yet.