15 ms·
The notion of a “well rounded student” who does music, art, and extra curricular activities, is a legacy of blue blood WASP culture. That is not to say that I
by rayiner 5y ago
The notion of a “well rounded student” who does music, art, and extra curricular activities, is a legacy of blue blood WASP culture.
That is not to say that I think only test scores should matter. But the kinds of extracurriculars colleges value—in particular that they don’t value having a job or working in the farm—smacks of old money ideals.
- noduerme 5y agoWhen they talk about well rounded students: They do value working on a farm. Or going to Guatemala and building wells for people. Or construction work building houses. It's definitely not just about doing ballet and fine arts. I was the only kid in my class who didn't go to college, but I went to one of the top 3 prep schools in terms of Ivy League placement in the country, and the entire focus for extracurricular activities was doing volunteer work. Sports, music, fine art and theater were all there as a potential route, but the advisers pushed kids who wanted to do those things as a career away from leaning on them as a way to be "well-rounded" in the eyes of the college admission boards. TL;DR In my experience, a kid who had no creative talent but took a summer to build houses in Ecuador was much more likely, in the 90s, to get into the Ivy League than one who played violin, or football.
- rayiner 5y ago> TL;DR In my experience, a kid who had no creative talent but took a summer to build houses in Ecuador was much more likely, in the 90s, to get into the Ivy League than one who played violin, or football. And how is a lower middle class kid in the Midwest supposed to be able to swing a summer off to build houses in Ecuador?
- tiahura 5y agoReddit has plenty of discussions about this. Church groups would be one option. Or, Kayak shows round trip flights this summer from Cincinnati to Ecuador for $500. So, Set up a table outside the local grocery store for a few weekends with pictures of starving Ecuadorans and beg. Or, gofundme. I think the key is initiative, which is one of the main traits they’re looking for.
- MrMan 5y agothe things to which you allude are actually an imitation of WASP culture, WASPS dont strive by doing the things they do naturally. you study music/art because it helps you be a better person, not because it (these days) might help you get into a school you should be able to get into anyway. you do service work because you believe that it is important to give back. using this things as credentials to gain entry into schools is a late development.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> notion of a “well rounded student” who does music, art, and extra curricular activities, is a legacy of blue blood WASP culture This concept finds heritage in Greco-Roman tradition moreso than anything Anglo or Saxon. It's also not uncommon for non-European civilizations to have emphasized educating their elites in both aesthetic and practical matters. For good reason. If your job is to lead a civilization, people are your tool of trade. The tradition in America has racist--specifically, anti-Semitic--roots. But that doesn't mean we have to throw out the baby with the bathwater. If there's something sorely lacking in modern American culture, it's attention to matters in civic, philosophical and possibly even literary.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoSpecifically, the idea originated in the Ivy League (Princeton, IIRC) as a way to limit the number of Jews who got admitted.
- VWWHFSfQ 5y ago> The notion of a "well rounded student" ... > is a legacy of blue blood WASP culture First of all, I don't know what "blue blood WASP culture" is. Explain that please. Second, there's nothing wrong with expecting students to participate in extra-curricular activities like music and art as a basis for admission. MIT is still going to evaluate those things.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoBlue Blood and WASP generally refer to people who come from rich/prominent families. Whether it's fair or not, the stereotype is a polo playing, boat shoe wearing type who has a vacation house somewhere fancy and family connections into good jobs etc.
- danielheath 5y agoSelecting for students whose parents can afford formal music, art and sport lessons is selecting for wealth. Having extra-curriculars you can document costs money and time. Poor kids are getting 'well rounded' by spending summer break at work, saving enough money to survive the school year.
- dbsmith83 5y ago> Poor kids are getting 'well rounded' by spending summer break at work, saving enough money to survive the school year. This is an interesting point: why shouldn't work count towards being well-rounded? If anything, work is much more grounded in reality, and a lot of kids who never had to work in high school and college would come off as out of touch (at least to me, as someone who did work thru high school and college). It would be nice if work experience (even if unrelated to a field) was valued as much as being part of a silly club.
- refurb 5y agoIt does. I've helped with college applications to Ivy League where the "volunteer opportunities" are "working summers for minimum wage, looking after my younger siblings and/or helping at the family convenience store". Those kids got in. I think the point is to show you offer something more than just being good at school. It doesn't have to be volunteer opportunities or something expensive.
- Dig1t 5y agoValuing something like breadth of experience and being a well rounded person might be considered one of the things that makes a western style education as good as it is. Compared to other types of university systems, for example the one in India which is extremely concerned with test scores and performance metrics, many people would consider the western one to be better (including many people in India who try to come to the US for their education if they can). Not saying it's the only thing that makes western education good, but I think it definitely plays a role.
- barry-cotter 5y agoWhat's this Western education system of which you speak? Among Western nations the US is unique in how much emphasis it puts on extracurriculars and character. We know why that is too. The system arose as a smoke screen around Jewish quotas. The overwhelming majority of universities admit students on the basis of results of blind marked exams and nothing else. I'm by no means an expert but the usual examples given of exceptions, Oxford, Cambridge and ENA are looking for academic brilliance, not aristocratic polish ("well roundedness"). Western systems vary a lot in their degree of specialisation too. By 16, after the GCSEs the UK is done with being a generalist. Pick 3 or 4 A-Levels of your choice and if you feel like doing Math, Further Math and Physics or three sciences and Maths no one will stop you in the name of "well roundedness".
- allturtles 5y agoMany of the colleges people are actually attending in the U.S. are the same, and offer automatic admission if you hit some threshold of GPA, class rank or test scores. A couple examples: https://uh.edu/undergraduate-admissions/apply/freshman/freshman-process/ https://uh.edu/undergraduate-admissions/apply/freshman/fresh... https://www.missouristate.edu/Policy/Op5_01_3_FreshmanAdmissionRequirements.htm#selection-index https://www.missouristate.edu/Policy/Op5_01_3_FreshmanAdmiss... Actually here's a list of a bunch more: https://www.collegetransitions.com/blog/10-best-colleges-with-automatic-guaranteed-admissions/ https://www.collegetransitions.com/blog/10-best-colleges-wit... These hand-wringing conversations about fair admissions mostly apply only to the elite top X schools. Those places receive tons of applications from academically top-tier students. The are looking for "something else" to make you stand out from the crowd.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> The notion of a “well rounded student” who does music, art, and extra curricular activities, is a legacy of blue blood WASP culture. For what it's worth, several of my old college friends are heavily involved with extra-curricular programs at the middle school and high school level across a few different states. From what I've observed, your generalization isn't true at all. The extra-curricular programs are actually heavily populated with students who have two parents working long hours who want something productive for their kids to do after school.
- rayiner 5y agoHarvard doesn’t care about the extra curricular activities offered in midwestern high schools—sports (unless good enough to be recruited), 4H, playing an instrument, etc.
- csa 5y ago> Harvard doesn’t care about the extra curricular activities offered in midwestern high schools—sports (unless good enough to be recruited), 4H, playing an instrument, etc. I beg to differ. Anyone who does any of these things at a regional, national, or international level would probably be very strong candidates, assuming they have competitive grades and scores.
- barry-cotter 5y agoRegional isn't true. National depends on the sport and instrument. International they'd care about even as a bit if it's big enough to get covered in national newspapers. Harvard can afford to be extremely highly selective.
- csa 5y ago> Regional isn't true. Actual examples I know of people who got into elite schools: - First chair violin in city youth orchestra - Winner of regional ice-skating competitions, but not nowhere near Olympic competition-level. - Winner of regional judo tournaments, again not at Olympic competition-level. - Winner of regional chess tournaments. Not a national champion. Can’t remember his rank, but he actually didn’t spend much time playing or studying chess as a teenager… he was just a crusher. - Winner of school-based regional trivia tournaments. Attended nationals but never placed. - Winner of regional solo sailing competitions. Note that free/cheap access to small racing sail boats was pretty easy in this person’s community. - Soccer player selected to regional-based national team development squad. Note that, imho, this is not nearly as impressive as it sounds. He also played on a “travel team” (about half of whom also made the development squad) that won many regional tournaments, but never succeeded nationally. - Many athletes who were not recruited (in that they did not get preferential admissions treatment… see “Academic Index” for more insight), but who were varsity athletes in high school and college in track and field, cross country running, rowing, gymnastics, golf, swimming, diving, etc. > National depends on the sport and instrument. Actual examples I know of people who got into elite schools: - For instrument, see local orchestra above as being adequate. - Took two years off after high school to tour and perform with a jazz band. - Starter on nationally ranked football team who was definitely not recruited to any elite schools and had no intentions of playing collegiately. - Player on nationally ranked ultimate (“frisbee football”) team. - Several people who were nationally ranked in various niche sports like fencing, squash, etc., but were not Olympic-caliber. > International they'd care about even as a bit if it's big enough to get covered in national newspapers Actual examples I know of people who got into elite schools: - Went to international science fair four years in a row. Got there’s by scoring well enough in locals, regionals, and nationals. Note that this is something that an elite school-bound 4Her could do if they tried. - Co-authored science research that was published into an international journal. All of these fall into the “sports, instruments, and 4h” that was originally mentioned. It could easily be expanded if community development examples were included. Note that most of my examples were regional, so I humbly suggest your concept of what is needed for admission is way off base. Also note that not all of these folks went to Harvard (not all applied to Harvard), but some did.
- RC_ITR 5y ago>The notion of a “well rounded student” who does music, art, and extra curricular activities, is a legacy of blue blood WASP culture Kind of wild to erase centuries of cultural heritage by implying that teaching academics with art is a uniquely Anglo-Saxan ideal.
- Dylan16807 5y agoKind of wild for you to replace "WASP" with "Anglo-Saxon" and toss in the word "uniquely". WASP is a tiny subset, and that subset has a very specific history with that concept that's coming into play here.
- RC_ITR 5y agoWait wait wait. What do you think the A and the S in WASP stand for? Sorry it felt uncouth to add the race and religion letters...
- pishpash 5y agoIt's not. Being well rounded is the ideal of the nobility in practically every settled culture, ancient or modern. It's the definition of "cultured". Having said that, it is a class marker, so participants of the dominant culture have a leg up.
- fmajid 5y ago> The notion of a “well rounded student” who does music, art, and extra curricular activities, is a legacy of blue blood WASP culture. More precisely it was first invented by Yale to limit the number of Jewish students admitted, and was later repurposed to limit the number of Asian students admitted.
- aj7 5y agoExactly. If you’re really intellectually bright and committed, all those extracurricular activities, populated by average students, are a total waste of time. Regardless of anything they say, MIT and Cal Tech have prospered precisely by ignoring that crap, and giving preference to people who can do the work.
- selimthegrim 5y agoExactly how did they prosper? Caltech seriously mishandled its endowment between 1999-2008 despite getting some of the largest individual donations in history.
- caddemon 5y agoExtracurriculars like research, robotics competitions, math camp, etc. are absolutely considered heavily by MIT. SATs and grades are way too saturated at the top end of the curve to make reasonable admissions decisions, and performing highly at a particular extracurricular can be an important signal for future success in itself. I get what you're saying though, being a typical jack of all trades high school overachiever isn't the best strategy for getting into MIT. I don't think that's because they don't consider personality though - heck one of the admissions short answers is "what do you do for fun?". I think it's actually because they are trying to avoid the type that does things just to get into college or just because it's the thing to do at their school. If you're an absolute prodigy then it probably doesn't matter either way, but if you're borderline MIT is definitely the top school that tries the hardest to take the kid that seems more genuinely passionate and not like a social climber. MIT also does the best job of considering context of all the elite schools. If you went to a great private high school you better have taken full advantage of those opportunities, whereas most other elite schools will just see the better overall resume/prior education. This is pretty clearly reflected in the schools' respective demographics.
- nyolfen 5y ago> The notion of a “well rounded student” who does music, art, and extra curricular activities, is a legacy of blue blood WASP culture. yeah, well so are the ivy leagues
- mitchdoogle 5y agoExposure to other areas of interest, like art, music, helps people creatively. Creativity is a part of every discipline.
- akomtu 5y agoNo exposure to other areas of interest, like art and music, indicates ability to work towards one goal for many years. This kind of persistence is a key to success in every discipline. I'm trying to say that we all here are skillful in hollow rhetorics.
- car_analogy 5y ago> The notion of a “well rounded student” who does music, art, and extra curricular activities, is a legacy of blue blood WASP culture. So are the schools that gated admissions this way.
- passivate 5y agoIf these colleges don't value what you bring, why apply to those colleges? For many areas of study, we have amazing and relatively inexpensive access to instruction/training/knowledge - if that is one's goal. If ones goal is simply to get trained for a job/industry - then colleges are probably not a good fit either.