12 ms·
Ivermectin works because the first trials were done in developing economies where the average person had a high chance of parasitic infections. The steroids use
by jiggawatts 5y ago
Ivermectin works because the first trials were done in developing economies where the average person had a high chance of parasitic infections. The steroids used as a standard front-line treatment for severe COVID decreases the immune response to parasites, allowing them to multiply unchecked. This killed patients indirectly, but dead is dead, and they "checked in" with COVID, not parasite complaints.
Ivermectin is a wildly effective anti-parasitic, so unsurprisingly it reduces mortality rates in countries where the endemic parasite infection rate is something like 50 percent.
This study appears to have been done in Canada, where parasite infection rates in the general population are probably 1% or less. Hence... no demonstrable benefit to using Ivermectin!
Nonetheless, Ivermectin is safe drug to take in normal doses, and will help people that are hospitalised with COVID and are given steroids.
It's not a prophylactic and high doses are not a treatment for COVID itself.
The misunderstandings around this drug stem from misunderstandings of basic statistics and the scientific method. This is why you shouldn't get your medical advice from Joe Rogan.
- simonh 5y agoTo be fair to Joe he wasn't giving medical advice, but licensed doctors on his show were.
- HL33tibCe7 5y agoThis sounds reasonable, until you realise that his opinions massively skew which licensed doctors he lets on the show. So effectively you’re ending up with him pushing his opinion anyway. If you cherry-pick your experts enough, you’ll be able to find one that agrees with you, no matter how absurd your position. I’ll also note that much of the time the licensed doctors he invites on aren’t actually in relevant specialties at all. And in many cases they are grifters in some way or another.
- leereeves 5y agoSerious question: What media doesn't choose their guests to fit their opinions or their political stance? I'd like to watch that one.
- HL33tibCe7 5y agoThe coronavirus experts that the mainstream media platformed are far more representative of the general opinion of the medical and epidemiological community than the experts Joe Rogan platformed.
- leereeves 5y agoYes, as the evidence comes in, it seems probable that the mainstream media got Invermectin right. They've gotten other things wrong. Whether they ultimately turn out to be right or wrong about any particular topic, the problem occurs much earlier: they choose their position before conclusive evidence is available, often, as in this case, based mostly on politics, then skew their coverage to fit. I'd prefer to hear the arguments and evidence from an impartial source, not a political position.
- azangru 5y ago> are far more representative of the general opinion of the medical and epidemiological community But that isn't the answer to the question asked in the parent comment. The parent was wondering which media would choose guests that have a differing view from theirs. The mainstream media happened to align with the people representing the general opinion of the medical and epidemiological community, and were rarely inviting Robert Malone, Peter McCullough, or Jay Bhattacharia, who had different views.
- willcipriano 5y agoThe media manufactures opinion so that isn't surprising, the same can be said for the Hunter Biden laptop story, or WMD in Iraq.
- lkfjasdlkjfsad 5y ago
- chefandy 5y agoHonestly— PBS News Hour. You’re just as likely to see current or former GOP talking heads like Mitch McConnell, Newt Gingrich, or Pat Buchanan as some DNC talking head. In fact, scrolling down their page just now, McConnell is the only actual politician I saw interviewed, though they did have a Biden speech clip. Keep in mind that inviting Political opponents into your show can advance your political message if you lampoon them — but PBS News Hour has about the same ratio of push to pull interviewing politicians, never ever interrupts, and doesn’t ask cheap shot gotcha questions. They are more likely to choose topics from a loosely mainstream democrat perspective — you’d be more likely to see a story about the ACLU releasing a statement about immigration than a law enforcement agency doing the same, but that sheriff or whatever is going to get equal respect and air time in that segment… and it’s not that extreme of a shift compared to mainstream outlets. So I firmly believe that they fit the criteria for your specific question. Truthfully I think most people just don’t want that.
- coldtea 5y ago>If you cherry-pick your experts enough, you’ll be able to find one that agrees with you, no matter how absurd your position. So? Some experts are more experts than others?
- headsoup 5y agoInteresting you are downvoted, this is precisely what is happening. The contradicting experts are quickly labelled as quacks and loonies, yet we have a long history of the early critical voices being eventually proved right (cholesterol, sugar, cigarettes, asbestos, Oxycodone, bio-labs, roundup, DDT, radium, etc). It's a long list and yet we behave the same every single time. This time I'm sure the consensus/"the science" has got it right though.
- cudgy 5y agoThe same thought came to mind regarding how easily manipulated the US population is regarding wars. They keep falling for the same fallacy of making conclusions without enough evidence.
- odonnellryan 5y agoI don't really like this fallacy as I think it is really dangerous. Because you're wrong about something (or even everything) doesn't mean you're wrong about another thing. Because there are examples of the medical community getting it wrong (btw they did not get it wrong when it came to opiates - everyone knew opiates were addictive) doesn't mean they are always wrong. Also there is no way for you to figure out who the quacks are (of course they exist, there are MDs suggesting insane things all the time) and who the correct but contrarians are. So, by default you assume if the opinion is not mainstream it must have validity. Now, I'm not saying the opposite is true. I'm saying it is just as bad (or maybe even worse statistically) to form an opinion because it isn't mainstream as it is to form an opinion just because it IS mainstream. You're not a critical thinker because you dismiss the mainstream because it is mainstream. Just the opposite.
- headsoup 5y ago
- moonchrome 5y ago>This sounds reasonable, until you realise that his opinions massively skew which licensed doctors he lets on the show. Don't like to defend Joe Rogan, but he literally had the guy that laughed him off at CNN (Sanjay Gupta). While he is often pushy with dumb ideas he will often have guests that contradict him. I stopped listening to him regularly because hearing his opinion along so many guests gets kind of old, and he isn't the smartest guy in the world so it gets boring even faster. But I wouldn't characterize him as closeminded.
- edmcnulty101 5y ago
- HL33tibCe7 5y agoI have never said that he _only_ platforms experts that agree with him. I’m saying the skew is enormous. So (say) 99% of the relevant scientific and medical community realise ivermectin is bogus and the vaccines work. But he’ll invite on (say) a 75/25 split for/against ivermectin.
- edmcnulty101 5y ago
- HL33tibCe7 5y agoYou need to go back and re-read my comment. He is skewing by cherry-picking. The two aren’t mutually incompatible.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoIt's skew to you because the world is binary to you. My opinions vs The bad guys. Joe Rogan has people with all kinds of differing opinions to create a rich marketplace of ideas where the idea wins on merit not censorship. As I said, there's no reason to have more than one main stream person repeating the same thing repeated on every network. When Labotomies won the Nobel Prize you would have possibly been upset that anyone would be questioning the science.
- bena 5y ago> create a rich marketplace of ideas where the idea wins on merit not censorship. This is demonstrably false. Ideas on Joe Rogan do not win on merit. Unless merit is based on quantity of bullshit.
- nradov 5y agoDo you mean licensed doctors like Peter Attia or Michael Osterholm? As guests on Joe Rogan's podcast, both of them repeatedly recommended that people get vaccinated, and said that there wasn't reliable evidence for ivermectin. https://open.spotify.com/episode/5DuxGhOJSa7X0AKvJGwwta?si=PDXSLx8tTomvIlSxxjTDww&utm_source=copy-link https://open.spotify.com/episode/5DuxGhOJSa7X0AKvJGwwta?si=P... https://open.spotify.com/episode/5VSukFrMYGae1ILd0e4HuR?si=BvzPxC9cR86fez7gSQQtdA&utm_source=copy-link https://open.spotify.com/episode/5VSukFrMYGae1ILd0e4HuR?si=B...
- eggy 5y agoSo tired of people attacking Joe Rogan. He's a pod caster. How come people don't push more on the 'experts' like Wolensky or Fauci or the main stream media? Ignoring natural immunity, not releasing publicly funded data to scientists and citizens to do science, openly lying in the name of 'for your own good', or tweeting a statistic that is way off from the data they released - the list goes on, and these are the highly-paid experts who have pushed for science as a belief rather than a method or system for examining phenomenon. How many people have they harmed (children being masked while old farts in government hug and talk face-to-face; pushing vaccines on 5-11 year-olds with a 12% efficacy after only 30 days, on and on). I think people just like to dog pile on people like Rogan; they should be turning some of that scrutiny upon the people they listen to or extol as experts. CNN calling Ivermectin "horse dewormer" or "horse medicine" was blatant propaganda, and not journalism, yet people rely on CNN for their information, too much I fear.
- decremental 5y ago
- thurn 5y agoYou have committed the logical fallacy of 'to quoque', responding to criticism with criticism. The scrutiny (or lack thereof) for other individuals is of course irrelevant to the question.
- gatlin 5y agoOther than as a substitute for bird watching I don't have much use for logical fallacies: https://maartenboudry.be/2017/06/the-fallacy-fork-why-its-time-to-get.html https://maartenboudry.be/2017/06/the-fallacy-fork-why-its-ti...
- topaz0 5y agoI think the linked piece makes an important point, but I disagree that that point is relevant here. "Your argument pattern-matches to tu quoque" is probably an unhelpful thing to say, but what GP says is more like: "Your points about other people are not relevant to the discussion we were having out this one person, and therefore are unhelpful. This pattern of bad argument is sometimes known as tu quoque." Seems fine to me. Edit to add: not sure if I am alone in this, but I also disagree with the author's characterization that the purpose of thinking about fallacies is to understand how people come to wrong conclusions. I think it has much more to do with the structure of an argument. It's not "you have come to this wrong conclusion by treating this fallacy as a good argument". It's more like "you believe this for whatever personal reasons you might have. You are trying to convince me to believe it as well, but you are failing to do so because your argument is not valid". I.e. it is more about the rhetoric than it is about coming to wrong beliefs in the first place.
- phoinix 5y ago
- spaetzleesser 5y agoWhen the pandemic started I got some of the best information on Rogan. He had some immunologists on that predicted exactly how it would turn out. While a lot of people still believed that this could be stopped these guys predicted that it would run through the population. Which it did. I don’t really like this need for people to hear only what they want to hear and get angry when people say something they don’t like. Rogan lets people on and lets them talk. Sometimes it’s interesting , sometimes it’s not, sometimes it’s right, sometimes very wrong. I much prefer Rogan over all the people on big news that constantly spin things one way or the other to get more viewers. The mainstream news has lost the ability to give straight news.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI would be highly suspicious that in this post, the msm is tasked with the standard of giving “straight news” but Joe Rogan is apparently no more quality with “sometimes it’s right, sometimes very wrong”. Why would you actively prefer one mediocre source of news over another mediocre source of news? They both seem mediocre and neither seem worth listening to.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoRogan is not a news program and doesn't claim to be one . His thing is conversations with interesting people.H It can be serious scientists, questionable scientists, flat earthers, UFO people, Alex Jones and many others. He lets them talk and it's up to you do with it whatever you want. I personally find it very interesting to listen to political extremists, conspiracy guys, COVID deniers or flat earthers and learn what they are thinking. I don't need or want to be protected from wrong information. Actually it's very important to know where people you are disagreeing with are coming from. It's very unhealthy to only hear what you think is true. If people want to get protected from wrong information a good start would be advertising. Maybe the woke people at Spotify should start there.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoAll I’m saying is that I don’t get why Joe Rogan and MSM are even comparable if they’re being held to totally different standards. You can critique them both without comparing them. They can both spout misinformation and bias differently because they are fundamentally different products. And they can critique each other’s biases and failures because, wel, they’re different things??
- gadders 5y agoIf you cherry pick your experts enough you end up believing that the Wuhan Lab Leak theory is hate-speech and that Hunter Biden's laptop is a Russian disinformation campaign.
- Graffur 5y agoJoe brings on guests that are informative and interesting. He didn't come up with a scheme to hype up Ivermectin or any other treatment. Do you think otherwise? I believe he has had on: Dr. Sanjay Gupta, Dr. Michael Osterholm and and Dr. Peter Hotez. That doesn't look to be cherry-picking experts to push an absurd position.
- MarcoZavala 5y ago
- maxerickson 5y agoWhy isn't it fair to criticize his use of his platform? There's enough people with MDs that are willing to do more or less anything for money that checking for a license isn't really much in the way of diligence.
- tux1968 5y ago> The misunderstandings around this drug stem from misunderstandings of basic statistics and the scientific method. This is why you shouldn't get your medical advice from Joe Rogan. You're 100% correct, of course. But the prevalent MSM response, of calling it horse medicine, was equally damaging. Since it is a well known, effective, and respected medicine used in humans, this characterization as "horse paste" made it easy to believe that it was additionally being unfairly maligned in regard to its effectiveness for Covid.
- Macha 5y agoTo my understanding, this came about because of people trying to self treat with it and the most accessible way for a lay person to get access was the aforementioned horse medicine (which came with dosages way above those for people) I.e. it's not that ivermectin is horse medicine in all forms, but the forms of it which the people were taking in response to Trump's early promotion were horse medicine
- baumandm 5y agoSure it's click-bait, but people were actually taking livestock versions of Ivermectin, in paste form. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2021/08/23/covid-warning-treatment-ivermectin-fda-mississippi/8244302002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2021/08/23/covid-...
- moistofreason 5y agoMany major pharmacies in the US refused to fill prescriptions for off-label use of IVM, due to the media freak out about it… Some people decided to go to farm supply stores and take the sterile bovine injectable form of IVM orally. This whole situation would not have happened if social media, YouTube, and major news outlets didn’t make such a stink about using a drug. It has virtually no negative side-effects, over 40 years of safety track record, and is safely taken prophylactically for other uses around the world. Its efficacy has yet to be proven and there are conflicting studies on this, but its safety is not disputable.
- 5y ago
- edmcnulty101 5y agoWhat you're saying is a theory. It's a good theory but youre technically spouting misinformation by claiming it's hard fact. This theory was developed by Scott Alexander from SSC in his ivermectin blog post. Joe Rogan never claimed anyone should take medical advice from him. He had Sanjay Gupta and Robert Malone both medical doctors with differing opinions. This is how the media is supposed to work. It's not supposed to be just the people you agree with(that's propaganda).
- rootsudo 5y agoMisinformation seems to be the boogeyman of our time. Something you don't agree with just slap the label "Misinformation!" "Yes, the evidence suggests it but.." - "MISINFORMATION.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoStating something with no scientific backing is literal misinformation. Theres been not a single study to show parasite Covid ivermectin connection. Claiming it's fact instead of a theory is literal misinformation, even if it's a good theory.
- WaxedChewbacca 5y ago
- FeepingCreature 5y agoFar as I know, the theory was proposed first by @GidMK on Twitter. (For the record.) edit: Apparently someone else? I've seen it on Twitter before Scott's blog, but I can't find the thread anymore. edit: It was Avi Bitterman @AviBittMD. Also linked in the article.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoYes you're right! Thanks for the clarification. Scott does address this in his blog/article. It's been almost 5 months since I read the article. Scott does attribute numerous references to the original postulators after looking again. Via Scott's article plus numerous links: " As several doctors and researchers have pointed out (h/t especially Avi Bitterman and David Boulware)" * https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/ivermectin-much-more-than-you-wanted?s=r https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/ivermectin-much-more-t... * https://twitter.com/AviBittMD/status/1461076939192602628 https://twitter.com/AviBittMD/status/1461076939192602628
- rscho 5y ago> Nonetheless, Ivermectin is safe drug to take in normal doses, and will help people that are hospitalised with COVID and are given steroids. In what way will it help in people having no parasite?
- jiggawatts 5y agoYou don't necessarily know if a patient has parasites or not when they present at a hospital with severe COVID. Even if just 1% of patients have parasites, then giving them a single pill of Ivermectin before commencing steroid treatment could save their life. For the other 99% of patients, it does nothing. It's a bit like an episode of Dr House. Trying to determine an illness solely with tests is often futile or prohibitively expensive. It can also take long enough that meanwhile the patient will die. Directly treating them "just on the off chance" can actually be a better approach, but obviously this would have to be weighed up against the side-effects and risks of the treatment and drugs involved. Ivermectin luckily is so safe that some doctors have called for giving it to every COVID patient that goes to hospital. Saving 1% of patients is... thousands of people at the scale of the pandemic.
- evilthrow 5y ago> This study appears to have been done in Canada, where parasite infection rates in the general population are probably 1% or less. Hence... no demonstrable benefit to using Ivermectin! "Dr. Mills and his colleagues looked at 1,358 adults who visited one of 12 clinics in the Minas Gerais region of Brazil with Covid-19 symptoms."
- rendall 5y agoTo close that circle, apparently parasite infection is quite high in Minas Gerais: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4964320/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4964320/ > Eleven sites were selected for sampling. Cysts of Entamoeba coli were the most frequently found in this study (50%), followed by Hymenolepis diminuta eggs (27.6%), Iodamoeba butschllii cysts (5.6%), Ascaris lumbricoides eggs (5.6%), Taenia species eggs (5.6%) and hookworm eggs (5.6%). The highest positivity rates were found in the samples drawn from the cafeteria's eating table. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30050346/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30050346/ > Results: A total of 216 slides were analyzed [sampled from public bus seats], of which 86 (39.8%) were positive for at least one intestinal parasite. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29972467/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29972467/ > The aim of this study was to establish the prevalence of Schistosoma mansoni in indigenous Maxakali villages, evaluating the TF-Test® performance for diagnosis compared to the Kato-Katz technique. Stool samples from 545 individuals were processed by the TF-Test® (1 sample) and Kato-Katz (1 slide). The positivity rate for S. mansoni by Kato-Katz was 45.7%. The rate by the TF-Test® was 33.2%, and 51.9% by the combined parasitological techniques. The amplitude of parasite load was 24 to 4,056 eggs per gram of feces (epg), with a geometric mean of 139 epg.
- rendall 5y agoSadly, I could find no studies on parasite infection rates in Minas Tirith, however.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoThe dreaded Morgul Crabs are a known problem.
- biorach 5y ago> [internal parasites] can cause, among other things, diarrhoea, fatigue and weight loss. However, they only pose a graver threat if their numbers grow out of control. Such “hyper-infection”, which is often fatal, becomes far more likely if a patient is receiving corticosteroids, which both suppress the immune system and appear to make female worms more fertile. And dexamethasone, a corticosteroid, is now a standard treatment for severe covid-19, because it prevents the immune system from going into overdrive and attacking the body’s own cells. [1] The amplification effect of steroids on parasites is backed up by research on mice [2] and an informal survey of the ivermectin/covid research shows good evidence for the same effect in humans [3] [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20220220090522/https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2021/11/18/ivermectin-may-help-covid-19-patients-but-only-those-with-worms https://web.archive.org/web/20220220090522/https://www.econo... [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3110371/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3110371/ [3] https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/ivermectin-much-more-than-you-wanted https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/ivermectin-much-more-t...
- nojito 5y agoThis entire comment is wrong and yet it is currently the top comment. What is it about COVID that causes people to just forget to think critically about what they read?
- andruc 5y agoCould you be more specific? I have a suspicion that, like myself, they came to this conclusion after reading this extensive post from Slate Star Codex https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/ivermectin-much-more-than-you-wanted?s=r https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/ivermectin-much-more-t...
- giarc 5y agoIt's any topic. You know the joke now is that all the epidemiologists suddenly became experts on eastern European foreign relationships. I listened to the Mr Beast and Joe Rogen podcast the other day. The best part about it was all the times Jimmy would simply say "I don't want to speculate about that, I don't know anything about it." It was glorious, a person not providing opinion on something because they don't know anything about the topic.
- cdelsolar 5y agowhat is wrong about the comment
- prohobo 5y agoThat is not the effect they're trying to test. Yes, ivermectin is an anti-parasitic, and yes that's probably why there's anecdotal evidence of it working. The reason people are testing it is because it has potential anti-viral properties as well. Researchers discovered that ivermectin is a protease inhibitor - which means it can prevent viral replication when it comes to Covid. The problem, from what I understand, is that no one knows the dose required for that effect to occur, or whether the drug needs to be modified in some way to do so. The new Pfizer anti-viral drug is based on the same protease inhibition mechanism and seems to work very well, but costs hundreds of dollars for a single round of treatment. So, finding a way to make ivermectin work would create an extremely cheap treatment. You talk about misunderstandings but it's funny how badly you misunderstand the situation. Sources: https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acsptsci.0c00108# https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acsptsci.0c00108# https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2021/cp/d1cp02967c/unauth https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2021/cp/d1cp0... https://www.nature.com/articles/s42003-020-01577-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s42003-020-01577-x
- bonIvermectin 5y ago> it has potential anti-viral properties as well doses much higher than the maximum approved or safely achievable for use in humans would be required for an antiviral effect while treating COVID-19 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7172803/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7172803/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7934083/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7934083/
- jjoonathan 5y agoRight. Figuring out the dose would not take years if it actually worked. There are always leads, always more possibilities to try, so it's a critical scientific skill to understand how promising they actually are. Nobody will ever publish a peer-reviewed scientific paper saying "this shit is completely fucking hopeless" -- even if it is -- so you have to make that inference from a growing pile of negative evidence "we haven't been able to replicate / determine dosing / find support for" and from the shift of attention to different theories.
- chiefalchemist 5y agoGood info. Thanks. That being said, the WSJ article is limited to looking at hospitalizations. Full stop. Nothing about deaths, length of hospital stay, so called long Covid, etc.
- StreamBright 5y ago> This is why you shouldn't get your medical advice from Joe Rogan. Could you elaborate on this one? Did he give any medical advise ever?
- rdxm 5y ago
- roenxi 5y ago> The misunderstandings around this drug stem from misunderstandings of basic statistics and the scientific method So I agree with your post both in letter of what is written and in spirit, but... The misunderstandings around this drug also stem from the fact that its detractors were unhinged and anti-scientific. They were dismissing a large, obvious statistical effect without any argument. The publicised pushback around Joe Rogan was spearheaded by people who thought the problem was that Ivermectin is effective in horses. I'm perfectly happy to pick this hill to argue on - the people who had hope that Ivermectin helped were the sort of people who are persuaded by evidence. It was never strong evidence, but the balance was in favour of Ivermectin for a while there for people who only looked at studies and hadn't had their attention drawn to the endemic parasite thing.
- eightysixfour 5y ago> The misunderstandings around this drug also stem from the fact that its detractors were unhinged and anti-scientific. They were dismissing a large, obvious statistical effect without any argument. No. The extreme pushback started after higher quality studies came out that showed there was no effect and those swayed by the initial Brazilian data wouldn’t let it go. For some segment of the population it became a magical COVID cure and any high quality studies were just big pharma ignoring cheap solutions so they could make more money.
- gadders 5y agoNo. The extreme pushback started when Donald Trump mentioned it.
- SamBam 5y agoI think that's right but not complete. I think the biggest pushback came from the notion that a large segment of the population appeared to be against the scientific consensus on Covid, contemptuous about risk mitigation strategies, skeptical/fear-mongering about the vaccines, and pushing conspiracy theories, and then these were the who turned around and said there's a great drug that works miracles against Covid and the government doesn't want you to have it. Now, this may not be an accurate representation of all those who were talking about ivermectin, but they were the most prominent voices -- the "do your research" types. The bias that this produced in others against even considering ivermectin was strictly irrational, of course, since it was against the sources and not about studies, but, that said, many of these same people had been pushing hydroxychloroquine, massive vitamins C injections, and urine therapy, all without evidence. The underlying desire for ivermectin to be real seemed (at least from the outside) to stem more from discovering some cheap secret weapon that "the scientific community" didn't want them to know about.
- maskil 5y agoIvermectin isn't popular because of Joe Rogan and he hasn't especially promoted it. At the time that Rogan did have the episode with Dr Kory and Bret Weinstein, Ivermectin was already very popular and he hasn't been promoting it since (yes, he may have had a guest or two that brought it up during the conversation, but it was peripheral). The media had a collective freakout because when he got Covid he mentioned on Instagram a laundry list of medicines he's taking and Ivermectin (the human form) was among them. Blaming him or Spotify for all of society's ills is just an attempt to prevent dissent on mainstream discourse.
- michaelcampbell 5y ago> Blaming him or Spotify for all of society's ills That's a leap only you took so far.
- alecst 5y agoYour first paragraph is a wild guess. There’s no reason having parasites should make Covid-19 more severe, and many human parasites do not even multiply inside the body during their life cycle. In fact there’s even a paper floating around showing an anti-correlation between helminth infection and Covid-19 severity. My point being: the “obvious” mechanism of action may not be as obvious as you think.
- xadhominemx 5y ago> There’s no reason having parasites should make Covid-19 more severe That is simply not true. Parasites do have an impact on the immune system and can amplify or reduce response to other pathogens. This is a very well known effect and an important area of study due to the prevalence of parasitic infections in tropical regions.
- alecst 5y agoYea you're exactly right, and I think you've taken a stronger interpretation from that quoted part than what I intended. My point was that it's too early to jump to conclusions about parasites making Covid-19 more severe. But I do think that, if anything, the data points gently to the opposite conclusion. > Recent studies have shown that helminth endemic countries showed fewer cases and deaths so far and helminth co-infection might reduce the severity of COVID-19. from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/iid3.573 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/iid3.573. Others: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34861106/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34861106/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7430705/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7430705/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33073203/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33073203/
- bananabiscuit 5y agoI think it’s interesting how quick everyone is to use 3rd world parasites hypothesis to explain away promising ivermectin results. It’s a valid hypothesis for sure, but should be tested with as much rigor as you demand the hypothesis that ivermectin is helpful against covid is tested. On that front I think it is not totally plausible that parasites explain these discrepancies. Here is a large study in the United States https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1201971221009887 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S120197122... that found ivermectin to be effective against death.
- mikeyouse 5y agoEven the authors of that study disagree with your characterization of it - it’s a conference abstract about an association (not causal relationship) with a ton of confounders and couldn’t weigh things like vaccination status. > Moreover, both Efimenko and Nackeeran also told Reuters that other evidence available so far clearly refutes the benefits of ivermectin to treat COVID-19. https://www.google.com/amp/s/mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/idUSL2N2VC2JZ https://www.google.com/amp/s/mobile.reuters.com/article/amp/...
- JasonFruit 5y agoYou're doing it right, opposing bad information with good. All of what you say here makes sense, including "This is why you shouldn't get your medical advice from Joe Rogan." Where that breaks down is when that turns into, "This is why you shouldn't be allowed to get your medical advice from Joe Rogan." People make unwise choices all the time, and when we try to prevent them from doing so coercively, we fall into a pit of unintended consequences. When people see powerful people suppressing a point of view, it makes it more sympathetic to many of them, even if they would otherwise have rejected it as unreasoned.
- toss1 5y ago>>Where that breaks down is when that turns into, "This is why you shouldn't be allowed to get your medical advice from Joe Rogan." People make unwise choices all the time, and when we try to prevent them from doing so coercively, we fall into a pit of unintended consequences. Depends on the coercion. Taking action against false advertising of medical benefits is and should be under the purview of qualified government agencies, and should be a private cause of action. E.g., the FDA and FTC have jurisdiction over false claims in drug and food advertising [0-2]. This is an unqualified good thing. It would be a large net benefit to society if these are also extended beyond specific paid-for standard-format advertising claims but also persistent promotion of false and unsubstantiated claims by jucksters like Joe Rogan, whether or not it is the result of direct paid promotion or just as part of his self-promoting schtick to increase it popularity with contrary opinions, and without regard to the number of people he will literally kill with his bad advice. If you want the libertarian version, then when Jack's relative takes bad advice from adverts or some on-air huckster, then he has a cause of action to sue (and of course must establish that the relative relied on that advice and died from following the advised course of action, and that Jack has suffered losses). Yes, countering disinformation is a thorny problem, but resorting to First Amendment absolutism is intellectually lazy at best. It feels like having a nice solid black&white answer, but it is not, since the result of the answer is the destruction of society. Bigger challenges and higher complexity society require more complex answers (and NO, simple censorship isn't the answer either). [0] https://www.fda.gov/drugs/office-prescription-drug-promotion/bad-ad-program https://www.fda.gov/drugs/office-prescription-drug-promotion... [1] https://www.fda.gov/drugs/prescription-drug-advertising/background-drug-advertising https://www.fda.gov/drugs/prescription-drug-advertising/back... [2] https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/topics/truth-advertising https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/topics/truth-advertising
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwawaycities 5y ago> This is why you shouldn't get your medical advice from Joe Rogan. Nor strangers on the internet. Nor cable news networks. Everyone agrees medical advice and treatment should be between a patient and their physician…unless you are Joe Rogan and one of the hosts of treatments your physician prescribes is Ivermectin. Then it seems it’s newsworthy and fair game to cherry-pick a single prescription therapy and disingenuously frame it as “Joe Rogan takes horse dewormer”, rather than Joe Rohan’s physician prescribes anti-parasitic therapy which studies show has potential anti-viral applications and early studies showed potential benefits for treating covid, and has otherwise is generally harmless to humans based on nearly a billion doses over decades.
- verisimi 5y ago> This is why you shouldn't get your medical advice from Joe Rogan. Joe Rogan is a terrible person to get advice from. But where are the good sources? Are science studies (funded by government, military or corporations) trustworthy? Is the government? The issue is that all information has become obviously politicised. Which means it there are agendas in play foremost, rather than enabling the population to make informed decisions.
- MagnumOpus 5y agoThere are dozens of democratic, well-led governments in the world that fund studies and release recommendations. Arguably many are less corrupt/business-friendly/polarised than the US. You can source your advice from any of them or a sufficient consensus. Most even publish their recommendations and findings in English too. Interestingly, none of them asked their healthcare systems to prescribe cheap-as-chips ivermectin, all of them provide free vaccination and all of them recommend face masks for the last year and a half.
- toolz 5y agoPlease don't state your speculation as an understood fact - afaik there is no published literature that has controlled for parasites and I know the article from scott alexander you're referencing here as he was the one who came up with the hypothesis. Let's not act like the parasite idea is more than an untested hypothesis though.
- Graffur 5y ago> The misunderstandings around this drug stem from misunderstandings of basic statistics and the scientific method. This is why you shouldn't get your medical advice from Joe Rogan. This part of your post is confusing. Your conclusion and the conclusion promoted on the JRE are the same.
- logicalmonster 5y agoI think jiggawatts came up with a reasonable overall summary on Ivermectic's known effectiveness with the information we have available. What I think is baffling is why there was such resistance to even trying Ivermectin and other alternatives in the first place? I'm not talking about after Joe Rogan used it here, I'm talking about well before he said he used it and there were some initial reports from some Indian and other doctors that this might have been very effective in their initial usage. Sick and dying people wanted to try this out and were shut down. If we had an inexpensive and marginally effective treatment, Covid would have been over very quickly. Yet, every initial inexpensive treatment (Hydroxychloroquine) that showed some initial effectiveness was given the stiffest resistance possible. It's the easiest risk management decision in the world to try out inexpensive (and safe in human dosage) drugs when the alternative is death, and for some reason there was supreme resistance to this. Why? It still feels like potential solutions were totally shut down precisely because nobody could really make any money off of it.
- Alex3917 5y ago> Sick and dying people wanted to try this out and were shut down. If they were severely sick or dying, it would already be far too late for an anti-viral to do anything.
- logicalmonster 5y agoMost likely this is the case for many of the sick people, but it's the reasonable and human thing to still try and give people the best possible chance.
- pibechorro 5y agoNor should you from any politically influenced or funded talking head. Unfortunately, the whole thing became political when lockdowns, forced vaccines and massive tax funding (and legal immunity) where given to historically sketchy pharma companies. Thankfully, we have this forum for intelligent discussion without the rampant censorship we saw on more mainstream platforms.
- michaelrpeskin 5y agoI think the key statement you make is correct "safe drug to take in normal doeses". If you look at the toxicology, it's safer than Aspirin. My story (yes, I know, just N=1, but it's good to put it out there): I found a doc to give me two prescriptions for a treatment protocol as recommended by the FLCCC. Since it was in short supply, I didn't want to waste it prophylactically. I've had IVM available to me since early sprint 2021. If I ever got that nagging feeling in my throat like I was coming down with a cold, I just took a single dose of IVM. The next day I was always better. This happened about a half dozen times over the last almost year. Would I have gotten better that quickly without it? I don't know. I just didn't want to risk thing getting worse, and the risk calculation was obvious since IVM is so safe. Was it just a cold attacking me and not COVID? I don't know, but it was still better than coming down with a cold. Colds always take me down for a week anyway, so I saved a week of my life even if it was just a cold. From my understanding IVM is a broad spectrum antiviral that seems to work well on coronaviruses. I'm going to keep taking it on first symptoms of a cold, just because so far I haven't had even a sniffle since I started taking it on the first sign of a infection. It may not be the thing that's working, but as you say, it's so safe, it doesn't hurt to use. Before the downvotes: I'm not saying that this is the solution to the pandemic, and I'm not touting that it's better than other treatments or vaccines. I'm just saying that the downside to taking it is negligible, and my experience is that it did help (or at least didn't hurt). And it's cheap, so why not experiment.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoDo you have a source citing this? This sounds like a possible reason but it's pure speculation without a study to control for this, or at the very least a pre-eval where they were evaluated for parasites before the study begins.
- kodah 5y ago> This is why you shouldn't get your medical advice from Joe Rogan. I mean, you should never really take advice from any expert that isn't sitting in front of you, imo. Podcasts exist to gather views and often incorporate bias and misinformation in various forms to achieve those ends. They're no different from listening to Tucker Carlson or Rachel Maddow in terms of information quality; they may interview SMEs but at the end of the day the way they interview them and the subjects they focus on matter much more if you're not a discerning person on a given subject. When I listen to podcasts, even ones that try to give good information like Freakonomics, I always listen to them for entertainment first. It's like maintaining boundaries with your information sources.
- Nursie 5y ago> Nonetheless, Ivermectin is safe drug to take in normal doses, and will help people that are hospitalised with COVID and are given steroids. On what evidence are you basing this? There appears to be no good reason to think so.
- DanBC 5y ago