7 ms·
3 months ago ME: I got a work proposal from some company MANAGER: That sounds awful! Don't you like here? ME: I like the people. MANAGER: Is there anything
by DeathArrow 5y ago
3 months ago
ME: I got a work proposal from some company
MANAGER: That sounds awful! Don't you like here?
ME: I like the people.
MANAGER: Is there anything that can change your mind?
ME: It actually is.
MANAGER: It's money, isn't it?
ME: Well, yes. Inflation is 10%, I haven't got any raise.
MANAGER: How much do you want?
ME: The other company is offering me +25%, so that's the amount.
MANAGER: I will try to speak to the higher ups, but there's already an order from above not to raise wages.
ME: Please do. How much do you think it will take?
MANAGER: speak to me in one week.
Two weeks after.
ME: Hey, did you speak with the higher ups?
MANAGER: Yes, and they said we shouldn't raise your wage.
ME: Ok then, we should talk about my resignation.
MANAGER: But couldn't you still not leave? You don't have a small salary after all.
ME: The prices are crazy, next year there is a prognosed high inflation too, and I have kids to take care of. So, regretfully, I will have to say good bye.
I wasn't the only one who resigned and for three seniors who left, they only found a junior to joined them now. I don't feel sorry for the company, I feel sorry for my former colleagues who have to endure a higher workload, because business people don't care there is a smaller number of people to do the same jobs.
- whiplash451 5y agoAlternative (observed in my company six months ago). MANAGER: your salary was just raised by 25%. SWE: wait, why? MANAGER: that's the new market salary for you. SWE: ok...
- Freak_NL 5y agoFor a lot of companies, this is economically sound thinking. If someone who is considering leaving because of a low salary is already a good few steps towards the door in terms of decision making, pre-empting any such motivation from occurring can be a lot cheaper than losing employees who are fully up to speed and have a lot of internal know-how. They're not getting an adequate replacement for the same salary after all.
- krona 5y agoThe same happened to me this past week. A 30% "re-benchmarking".
- torginus 5y agoThe extremely sad thing about this is that threatening to resign is the only way to get a decent raise in my experience. Nobody cares if you just phoned it in during the last period, or went above and beyond and implemented great ideas that ended up saving hundreds of man-hours.
- Gareth321 5y agoMy manager is busy arguing with senior management to ensure that he, myself, and my team receive at least a CPI adjustment this year. Preferably something more, since the job market is so competitive. I'm not getting the impression it's going well. It's a pain to change jobs but if they won't keep up with wages then I see no choice.
- Arcanum-XIII 5y agoFunny, it's the same for freelancer: ME: I'm working on this project for one year, we were due to discuss about raising my fee BOSS: yeah, but you already have a lot ME: yes, but I'm doing more hours than I should. I like the project but I have another lined up with what I want. BOSS: we're already paying you a lot, so, well, it's normal you do more ME: no, it's not. You're paying me for X, not for X+Y. BOSS: oh so you're only here for the money and want to be a civil servant? ME: Ok, so here's the end of contract BOSS: but...
- Aissen 5y agoIf you're a freelancer, you should say CUSTOMER, not BOSS. Also, you decide when you raise your prices (yes, it's still a negotiation, and yes, it depends on your contract).
- tpxl 5y agoYou decide when to raise prices, but the other party can just break the contract, much the same as with normal employment (except it's the other party raising wages and you breaking the contract in the absence of a raise).
- NeverFade 5y agoWhy do you feel like you need to justify your pay requirements? Does your CEO need to invoke inflation to justify his multi-million pay package? If other companies are offering you +25%, then that's your current market value. You do not have to justify or apologize for it, no more than your CEO apologizes for the far higher pay package required to hire and retain them.
- blitzar 5y agoPersonally playing the "I have kids to feed" justification just acts to remind me (coldly) that you can not afford to not be collecting a pay packet from me or someone else. The market for me is $X, you are paying $X*0.5 - that is unsustainable
- linspace 5y agoIt may sound cold, but it's so true. With or without kids, never let others think you have no option
- dzikimarian 5y agoDepends if you care in any way about the outcome. If you in general want to stay, just with a higher compensation, it's good idea to help them rationalize your salary. Especially if your manager will have to argue for you with his boss. If you simply want a raise and don't care where, indeed that will not benefit you.
- michaelt 5y agoI think you and NeverFade actually have different definitions of "justify" If you can point to where you went above and beyond, which improved the company's bottom line by $X, that will never hurt you in salary negotiations. In that sense, being able to justify your raise strengthens your position. But you don't have to defend yourself against accusations of sinful greed, or justify why you should earn 3x what teachers or nurses earn. You're talking to someone who is paid more than you, not speaking at a college anarchists' debate about fat cat bosses. You don't need any special justification in that sense.
- zensavona 5y agoSomething which made me want to stay where I am even more is a recent counterexample to this seemingly common response... I went to my CTO with a similar conversation and his response was "totally understand, leave it with me" - 6 hours later he had spoken with whoever it was he needed to speak with, and my ~20% raise was formalised. I was not expecting that response and the way it was handled made me even more happy to stay. The company I work for even improved their benefits in some ways which do not directly affect the salary spend (added unlimited paid leave) to further sweeten the deal for everyone. At the time I assumed they wouldn't want/be able to match it so I was very regretfully ready to go. These conversations sometimes go differently to the way you expect!
- blitzar 5y agoPerhaps helped going to the top of the food chain? Otherwise the 3 managers betwen you and the decising makers start to wonder if they too deserve a 20% pay raise and bat harder for themselves than for you.
- vmception 5y ago> added unlimited paid leave Make sure to use at least 20 days a year Take a whole week off per quarter and set that expectation and the Christmas to New Years time doesnt count so double it in Q4
- 5y ago
- throwaway63626 5y agoAt my current job (Series E+ fintech) 3 of my team of 4 are quitting over an 8% pay rise being too low. This would have been unthinkable a few years ago, but the market is going nuts. I'm currently on a TC of £130k and I've been offered roles with a TC of £470k (this is UK remote)
- godelmethis 5y agoHey I’m UK based too. Those amounts are way higher then what I’m on, 60k. I’m curious about the type of companies paying such TC, do you have an email to chat more?
- bambataa 5y agoYou can get above £100k fairly easily by working in finance or even just a profitable PLC in London (eg I know of Sainsburys offering that several years ago albeit for an EM role). Even if you don’t like investment banking or hedge funds, high street banks also pay well and have generous pension, annual leave etc. Never seen £470k TC though!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oesmith 5y agoStaff SWE at Google UK can get you to 400k+ (depending on stock grants / stock price gains).
- bambataa 5y agoIs that higher TC on offer from an American firm? I didn’t realise such numbers were accessible from the UK. Even FAANGs in the UK seem to top out around £200k for mid level.
- throwaway63626 5y agoYeah, American company but UK Remote working - they've just set up a UK company to employ British people through
- kavalg 5y agoI am astonished at how accurately this describes the situation in many other companies, with the difference being that sometimes they give you e.g. 5% raise instead of 25% and promise "future growth" also underlining how important you are to the company. You just forgot to mention that they are probably giving market level salaries to the newcomers. Such a pity.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> promise "future growth" also underlining how important you are to the company No-one can promise future-growth: if they don't offer an immediate equity grant in lieu of cash then just walk.
- secondcoming 5y agoA company offered you a new job with a 25% pay rise and you kept them waiting for two weeks? Sounds fishy.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoIt makes sense because leaving a job you're actually happy with is a big step to take, especially if said job may choose to match or go beyond the other job's offer.
- bluGill 5y agoJust leave. I've seen more than one senior engineer given a raise, then the.company extracted their knowledge and laid them off in the next downturn when it was harder to find any job.
- sirwhinesalot 5y agoIs it that surprising? Colleague of mine rejected a 50% pay rise at another company because the commute would be too annoying. He then took it when the next company offered full remote. Another colleague of mine is struggling to pick between all the companies offering him almost double his current salary. That's the market right now.
- secondcoming 5y agoIt's surprising to me that OP made them wait two weeks.
- sirwhinesalot 5y agoWhen you're getting showered with options, 2 weeks is low. We tried to hire a guy who told us he'd only give us an answer more than month later.
- turbinerneiter 5y agoKeep in mind that it is very likely that your new employer is treating their own employees the same way.
- tjpnz 5y agoAny insights into why companies are allowing people to walk? I've been at both ends of the carnage which can occur when a senior member exits, replacing the knowledge that went with them can sometimes take years (and in some cases it never happens). Training replacements is expensive and has a measurable impact on a team's output. Why is offering even a small raise so unpalatable?
- everfrustrated 5y agoI'm not justifying it, but at most companies a budget is set for a team. Most CFOs rule with an iron fist and so any money for raises comes from general budget raises. As a manager it's your job to wheel and deal within that constraint. Eg turn a vacant role into a less senior position to free up budget for keeping a valued team member.
- michaelt 5y agoWhen there's a buyer's market for talent, making the raise process difficult and slow is a negotiating tactic on the part of the corporation. Instead of telling your employees "no" you can tell them "ask again in 6 months" because of the "budget process" or "headcount approval" or "appraisal process" or "salary bands" or "fixed pool for raises" or some other nonsense, as a soft way of refusing their request. Junior managers will be able to deliver that message sincerely, because they genuinely believe it. Maybe the company finds there's a good chance the employees stay around. Of course, if the job market favours workers this tactic doesn't work any more. But how many companies are agile enough to respond quickly to changing employment market conditions?
- manuelabeledo 5y agoHaving been employed at both very small and very large companies, my experience is that the former cannot compete, while the latter prioritise money over talent. Two examples to illustrate this. Back in the 2000s, I got an offer from a larger corporation, for 25% more than what I was making at the time. Told my then manager and his counter was a 5% raise, plus a not quite moving “we are all a family here” speech. It wasn’t only me though, at least ten other engineers left in a few months, all were offered between 3% and 7% raises. The team was eventually disbanded and people were reassigned to other projects. After some years, someone told me that they simply didn’t have the budget. In the late 2010s, while working at a large multinational, I asked for a raise. At the time, I was repeatedly told that the project I was leading was, by far, the most impactful of the whole division, so I thought I would deserve it. Manager went to HR they recommended that I shouldn’t get a raise, since I was doing “well” already, according to their salary charts. Now, my manager could have fought it harder, but the disconnection and power over budget HR and higher ups have, made it so difficult and dragged for so long, I ended up leaving.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- txdv 5y agotell them: its just business
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jxidjhdhdhdhfhf 5y agoPersonally, I'm not going to endure a higher workload just because my teammates left. The company will just have to find and train replacements or deal with slower delivery and missed deadlines. The worst they can do is fire me and that will just hurt their projects even more.