15 ms·
Is the Russian Air Force incapable of complex air operations?
- mmastrac 5y agoThe key paragraph tucked second-to-last at the bottom. tl;dr appears to be "no, unless they are holding something back". Russia has every incentive to establish air superiority, and on paper should be more than capable of doing so if it commits to combat operations in large, mixed formations to suppress and hunt down Ukrainian fighters and SAM systems. Instead, the VKS continues to only operate in very small numbers and at low level to minimise the threat from the Ukrainian SAMs. Down low, their situational awareness and combat effectiveness is limited, and they are well within range of the MANPADS such as Igla and Stinger which Ukrainian forces already possess. The numbers of MANPADS are also increasing, as numerous Western countries send supplies to beleaguered Ukrainian forces. To avoid additional losses to MANPADS, sorties continue to be primarily flown at night, which further limits the effectiveness of their mostly unguided air-to-ground weapons.
- Overtonwindow 5y agoAlso (in bold) "The Only Currently Viable Explanation: "While the early VKS failure to establish air superiority could be explained by lack of early warning, coordination capacity and sufficient planning time, the continued pattern of activity suggests a more significant conclusion: that the VKS lacks the institutional capacity to plan, brief and fly complex air operations at scale. There is significant circumstantial evidence to support this, admittedly tentative, explanation."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- baybal2 5y agoNATO radars queueing Ukrainian air defence onto Russian planes without them having to turn on their radar. NATO provides eyes, and Ukrainian air defence provides the missile launch without revealing its position. By the time the Russian pilot hears the first beep, an Ukrainian SAM would already been travking know of his flight path few minutes prior.
- riku_iki 5y agoI think current operation areas are very far from NATO borders.
- zabzonk 5y agoNATO has a border with Ukraine - Poland. And it is definitely capable at looking at what is going on, in at least some parts of Ukraine: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-europe-60612255 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-europe-60612255
- gpderetta 5y agoNATO AWACS might just see over Kyiv from the Poland border, but it might be stretching it and probably not close enough to direct SAMs. But of course capabilities might be more sophisticate than what's publicly known.
- riku_iki 5y agoI also think NATO AWACS are likely not integrated with Ukrainian Air Defense. They likely operate on simply different frequencies than old soviet missiles.
- gpderetta 5y agoThat's a good point. Even if the west were providing realtime intelligence to Ukraine, it is very unlikely to be fully integrated.
- topspin 5y agoNATO E-3A Sentries operating out of Krakow are orbiting just short of the Poland/Ukraine border monitoring Ukrainian and Belarusian air space. They can see everything flying over about the Western third of Ukraine at all altitudes and about half of Ukraine, including Kyiv, for medium and high altitude targets.
- 5y ago
- blip54321 5y agoI would give one more potential explanation: In-fighting and a lack of unity. If I were in charge of the air force, and Putin ordered large-scale air superiority attacks against Ukrainians, I wouldn't want to do that. Putin might not have the power to order his air force to launch strikes of aggression. Dictatorships give the impression of being all-powerful, but dictators need to keep constituents appeased, but that's kind of an illusion. Key constituencies -- quite often the generals -- need to remain appeased. I expect if this were the case, Russia wouldn't advertise this externally. There is every incentive to maintain a united external front.
- foogazi 5y agoBut they are advertising that they are unable to control Ukrainian Air Space after 8 days of war This is a war they have been planning for months if not years
- jotm 5y agoPutin's been planning it... I think everyone else couldn't give a flying Bayraktar about it.
- coldcode 5y agoI doubt the majority of Russian military planned this attack. It seems more like Putin and his inner circle made all the decisions and failed to listen (or were not even told out of fear) what could/should be done. Hitler had the same fatal idea that he was a military genius right until the end and his generals were often sacked if they disagreed.
- thevagrant 5y agoI had wondered this also. Although my explanation was that the air force may have 'accidentally' had a lot of aircraft undergoing 'maintenance' .
- jotm 5y agoThey're also likely busy finding the guys who sold all the fuel. While preparing for the invasion, Russians were selling their fuel to locals at the borders in Russia and Belarus. Way to go!
- throw__away7391 5y agoI just had a thought--who are the VKS pilots? This is a pretty kick-ass and prestigious job. Have these positions been handed out to the favored sons of well-connected families, as is typical of many things in Russia? If so, could this be contributing to a reluctance to commit them to a conflict that is not going well against relatively well-equipped adversary?
- nwatson 5y agoSounds plausible. Also in a kleptocracy there likely are opportunities to siphon loads of cash away from military programs and short-change equipment and training needs. An oligarch might think, "Russia will not need to wage a sophisticated air campaign any time in the next fifty years! The slop trough buffet is open!"
- moltar 5y agoThere was already evidence of that. Apparently Russian troops were selling diesel fuel to the locals while they were waiting at the border before the war had started.
- jmnicolas 5y ago> "Russia will not need to wage a sophisticated air campaign any time in the next fifty years! The slop trough buffet is open!" Most people at this level don't have a soul or patriotic feelings, so the internal dialog is probably: "I don't give a shit what happens to Russia, I'll find another country to feed onto".
- avgcorrection 5y agoPretty underwhelming to see a spitball theory on Russia regarding nepotism/corruption based on it being “typical of many things in Russia”—nothing specific to the military or the air force, just a blank cheque that can be used to interrogate anything.
- torbTurret 5y agoUnderwhelming, sure, but likely true. Genuine question: have you spent anytime living there? If so where/how long?
- starwind 5y agoThey lack the technical capabilities. "As evidence of the State Armament Programme’s implementation until 2015 showed, the Russian defence industry still had not made the leap from ‘dumb-iron’ equipment to twenty-first-century sophistication. "Russia’s intervention in Syria is a case in point. As [Russian defense analyst and director of the Moscow-based Centre for Analysis of Strategies and Technologies] Ruslan Pukhov argued, the performance of the Russian Air Force in Syria was impressive if compared to the 2008 war with Georgia, where it lost seven aircraft in blue-on-blue incidents within a matter of four days. From an international perspective, however, it’s technological level now matches at best that of the US air force during the 1991 Gulf War a quarter of a century ago. Weaknesses have been visible in Syria, particularly in terms of the sophistication of precision-guided munitions, a shortage of targeting systems, deficiencies in aerial reconnaissance capabilities, and a lack of long-range UAVs and attack drones." --Bettina Renz, Russia's Military Revival 2018, page 80
- cyanydeez 5y agoTbh, now that we expect uavs everywhere, why would a competitive military in the 21st century even lead with troops. Shouldn't they do clean up to strategic attacks on various critical infrastructure. They were just out shelling the nuclear facility when they could make some strategic strikes. This seems on point.
- AnotherGoodName 5y agoThey haven't been able to modernize due to budget. This document from 2017 was written by the US military and analyzes and points out weaknesses in the Russian BTG (Battalion Tactical Group) doctrine and has some excellent points that make a lot of what is currently occurring fall into place. https://www.benning.army.mil/armor/earmor/content/issues/2017/spring/2Fiore17.pdf https://www.benning.army.mil/armor/earmor/content/issues/201... >Current Russian state net revenues from energy cannot fund the same modernization period as before. Basically they can't modernize. It then goes into the current Russian BTG doctrine and how it leaves armored groups exposed due to a lack of supporting infantry and air. >The BTG’s may be vulnerable to raids, counterattacks and other surprise movements because reliance on analog C2 limits subordinate units’ ability to understand and react to changes of circumstance. >A BTG had the entire brigade’s support and enabling resources, but it had only one mechanized-infantry battalion >According to Russian Army manuals, in the field as many as 50 percent of infantry soldiers can be required for local security and routine administrative tasks. This leaves relatively few infantrymen available for mounted squads. Squads are usually organized ad hoc and are less than fully manned,which makes them less effective and less independent. For opponents, it also means that it requires fewer casualties to neutralize the Russian squads. >The lack of infantry causes BTG commanders to prefer to isolate urban infantry strongpoints for prolonged sieges instead of assaulting The document also goes into supply issues that BTGs will likely face. Basically the current Russian doctrine is ridiculously ineffective. It involves lots of independent battalions of almost pure armor. Which get destroyed consistently due to a lack of supporting infantry. To the point where it's quite possible they'll lose this war. The Russians thought it was effective in Chechnya and Syria and the 2014 war with Ukraine since they simply didn't face significant resistance. All of the above weaknesses are now very apparent however. One last thing >The current military and political leaders are the same leaders who introduced the BTG structure; their reputations and careers are closely tied to its success. Instead of moderating BTG rollout and keeping a portion of the Russian Army in a divisional structure to train for high-intensity CAM, Russia’s leaders are accelerating the rate that units convert into BTGs.
- nickff 5y agoI think this author makes some good points, though it seems like he is downplaying the lack of effective SEAD (suppression of enemy air defenses) equipment and tactics. The USAF and Israelis dedicate a lot of attention to this area, and it seems like the Russians (and their Soviet predecessors) never have.
- ttul 5y agoI wonder to what extent advice and training of Ukrainian forces, not to mention real-time intelligence, has aided the Ukrainians in denying Russia air superiority.
- foogazi 5y agoBut the same is true of Russian forces - they also get advice and training
- ceejayoz 5y agoI don’t know that they expected the Ukrainians to have satellite and electronic intelligence parity, though.
- tablespoon 5y ago> I wonder to what extent advice and training of Ukrainian forces, not to mention real-time intelligence, has aided the Ukrainians in denying Russia air superiority. I read somewhere that Soviet-style air defense turn out to be most effective against Soviet-style air forces. Basically Western militaries have never invested heavily in SAMs, but invested heavily in anti-SAM weapons an tactics; while Soviet-style militaries did the opposite. That leaves Soviet-style forces with with very good SAM capabilities and weak air forces without the ability to counter it.
- js8 5y ago> Basically Western militaries have never invested heavily in SAMs, but invested heavily in anti-SAM weapons an tactics; while Soviet-style militaries did the opposite Hm, I will cynically say that it looks like the Russians were actually more interested in defense, while the Americans were more interested in offense.
- deanCommie 5y ago
- ttul 5y agoHe can call it what he likes, but I think the author rightly points out that it doesn't make sense for Russia to NOT establish air superiority -- quickly -- if it is indeed capable of doing so. Their lack of proven ability to secure the skies demonstrates to NATO that they are not necessarily the adversary one might have thought they are.
- epolanski 5y agoNo one believes the two powers compare, starting from Russia. In case of nato, if it was a defensive one, it would play very differently because russians counter air superiority with their AD, they give up on controlling the skies and are happy with shooting the enemy.
- tablespoon 5y ago> But what if Putin isn't lying about his intentions. What if his intention is to have a special operation, it's just that his definition of a special operation doesn't preclude him indiscriminately killing civilians. (but it DOES preclude him launching the full might of the russian air force) That kind of thinking seems implausible (i.e. he feels tightly bound by some contrived definition to hold back his air force, but not his army). It's far more plausible that the "special operation" language is a propaganda smokescreen. More specifically a domestic propaganda smokescreen, since they've very suddenly made it very illegal to call it anything else.
- celticninja 5y agoBut then you wouldn't use it at all. And let's be honest, his special operation, includes Army, Navy and Air Force, he isn't pulling his punches. My guess is that he didn't want to spend too much on this invasion. Planes are expensive, guided munitions are expensive and so are pilots. Grunts are cheap and so are vehicles (comparatively). He knows that he can't be weak after this war if only due to internal threats from breakaway regions, let alone NATO.
- markdown 5y ago[Removed]
- lupire 5y agoThat video is fake and Ghost of Kyiv is a myth.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoAs fake as the fake tree top at 0:06. Please be careful.
- LeoPanthera 5y agoA simple Google search will reveal that this is not real.
- bombcar 5y agoThis seems a highly optimistic take in the middle of the fog of war.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe UK MoD seems to agree they’re having trouble controlling the airspace, at the very least. https://twitter.com/Osinttechnical/status/1499889915924033540 https://twitter.com/Osinttechnical/status/149988991592403354...
- bombcar 5y agoIt’s the step from “they aren’t” to “they cannot” that is the large one.
- ceejayoz 5y agoIs it? What rational reason would the Russians have for being able to establish air superiority, but preferring not to do so?
- redisman 5y agoMaybe they want to keep some airports intact for their puppet regime? I don’t really know
- jopsen 5y agoNot wanting to use expensive fighter jets. They might think of causalities in terms of money, and not lives.
- OrderlyTiamat 5y agoI think this was addressed sufficiently in the article, but the point bears repeating: if they're really thinking in terms of money, ehy are they continuing the war at all? it's a disaster economically. The only way that works is if the air force itself is thinking in terms of money irrespective of the larger picture, but I'd find that surprising.
- rr808 5y agoDoes anyone have a good source on what is going on in Ukraine skies? Given that long column of equipment sitting outside from Kiev Russia must own the skies around there. But the rest of the country I'm really not sure. I'm guessing the West is UA owned still.
- jonstewart 5y agoThere’s a fair bit of talk (see Gen. Mark Hertling) that the column northwest of Kyiv is pretty FUBAR just with traffic jams and logistics, and so it doesn’t need a lot of attention at the moment. Ukrainian special forces have done a lot of damage at the head of the column, and I believe a bridge in the middle of/behind the column has been taken out, at least partially.
- bostonsre 5y agoIt seems like a big juicy opportunity tho, would be great to take out all of that armor, it might not be stuck forever. I think the problem is that there are a huge amount of sams guarding that column and it would be risky to make a run against it with the few aircraft they have left.
- dragonwriter 5y agoIf it's got logistical problems, taking it out means Russia stops trying to resupply it and shifts effort elsewhere. If you are positioned to do a good job continuing to interfere with the resupply, that might be a favor to Russia, even though it might feel good.
- KarlKemp 5y agoThe optimistic takes are stronger than „temporarily stuck“. It’s basically „in a position where nothing can move forward or backward“. The road is blocked, the vehicles are out of fuel, with many wrecks in between. Food is running out and, soon, the crews will have to abandon their vehicles. It becomes a 40-mile long mass of scrap metal.
- darawk 5y agoPeople keep wanting to chalk this up to Russian incompetence. But I feel like a far more likely explanation is electronic sabotage. Planes are complex electronic, connected instruments. They rely heavily on computers and electronic sensors. As fun as it is to dunk on the Russians for their incompetence here, it seems far more likely to me that it's a sign of the profound competence of the US/NATO at electronic warfare. IMO this explanation accounts for at least half of what's being chalked up to "logistics" failures on the Russian's part.
- TMWNN 5y ago>As fun as it is to dunk on the Russians for their incompetence here, it seems far more likely to me that it's a sign of the profound competence of the US/NATO at electronic warfare. As much as I'd like to believe that US Wild Weasel aircraft orbiting outside Ukraine are capable of zapping Russian aircraft inside Ukraine and Russia itself, this does not seem likely.
- darawk 5y agoYou could be right, but if you acknowledge that it's possible in principle to do this, why wouldn't we be investing heavily in it? Being able to ground an enemy's air force without appearing to fight them would be an incredibly powerful capability. I think there are a lot of reasons to believe it should be possible, and if it's possible, every reason to believe it would be invested in. I certainly don't have any evidence to prove it though, so its certainly reasonable to disagree.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jonstewart 5y agoAny evidence?
- darawk 5y agoNo evidence, just intuition.
- stared 5y agoWhen I don’t know, I extrapolate. If logistics of the ground forces is a challenge (https://www.economist.com/europe/2022/03/04/why-a-huge-russian-convoy-remains-stalled-north-of-kyiv https://www.economist.com/europe/2022/03/04/why-a-huge-russi...), logistics of the airforce would be a disaster.
- lifeplusplus 5y agothere is no correlation, airforce is easier than on ground logistics, they fly and land at the same place
- rmbyrro 5y agoPerhaps what is difficult is coordinating targets for the Air Force considering the mess going in the ground.
- lifeplusplus 5y agocould be but not logistics
- wrp 5y agoIf you are interested in the capabilities of the forces involved in the Ukraine right now, these two short books are very informative. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/30038951-the-modern-russian-army-1992-2016 https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/30038951-the-modern-russ... https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/40653204-armies-of-russia-s-war-in-ukraine https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/40653204-armies-of-russi...
- carrolldunham 5y agoGetting tangential but I believe there many armchair people's perception of this war is that is is going slowly, taking longer than 'expected', fully because of this epoch's speed of news cycle. 'Things' now usually take one day, and are forgotten by the mid week. People who follow 'things' are bewildered that a 'thing' is still going that started last week. Something must be broken with it
- jotm 5y agoThere was a leaked pre-written article for some Russian rag that details the "new world" with Russia, Belarus and Ukraine spearheading it together, united. Safe to say things did not go according to plan.
- Sebb767 5y agoBoth sanction-wise and publicity-wise an ongoing war is a catastrophe for Russia. Also, they invaded from three (!) sides and Kyiv is just about 100km from the border. There's obviously some propaganda and a thick fog of war going on, but I think we can quite reasonably conclude that this is going far worse for Russia than anyone expected, including Russia.
- chillacy 5y agoThis was supposed to be a layup for Russia (90% success) and it's looking like a coin flip (50%). https://www.metaculus.com/questions/9939/kyiv-to-fall-to-russian-forces-by-april-2022/ https://www.metaculus.com/questions/9939/kyiv-to-fall-to-rus...
- epolanski 5y agoThey made serious gains in 9 days and are encircling 3 of the 4 biggest cities. It doesn't seem to be going that bad as some would make you believe. In comparison, took poland a month to fall from germany and ussr combined with much larger armies on both sides.
- celticninja 5y agoI don't think that's the case, we have just come out of a pandemic that lasted 2 years. But we also saw Kabul and Afghanistan fall to the Taliban in a day and the Crimea annexation was so quick. There is also the fact that we all thought the Russian Army was a well oiled machine of war. That's why most people are shocked it wasn't an overnight victory, the disparity in power was obvious from the start, that this is day 9 and whilst they are closer to the capital they have suffered heavy, heavy losses. And their tactics and equipment have been shown to be poor, that's even without including their logistics which have been terrible.
- andy_ppp 5y agoMy pet theory: the thousands of surface to air missiles that we sent Ukraine work extremely well and Russia can’t afford to lose 50-100 fighter jets and more when their objective is to take Kyiv and scalp the Nazi or some other weird fantasy. I think once the Russians have installed a new government/had rigged elections they will leave someone like Lukashenko in charge expecting it will behave like Belarus…
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I think once the Russians have installed a new government/had rigged elections they will leave someone like Lukashenko in charge expecting it will behave like Belarus… Probably someone more exactly like Viktor Yanukovych.
- bergie 5y agoThird time’s the charm, right? Yanukovych has been kicked out of Ukraine by a revolution twice. Madness to think the result would be different this time.
- anikan_vader 5y agoThe Stinger anti-air missiles that the West has been sending to Ukraine have an operational ceiling of around 12,000 feet. This means they can't strike military jets (or commercial aircraft) flying at medium or high altitude. Flying below 12,000 ft is atypical for a fighter, since it also opens you up to potential AA ground fire and flak. Not to mention gravitational potential energy is something you generally want to have on your side as a fighter. Helicopters are another story of course.
- idontwantthis 5y agoYou need to get pretty low to hit something with iron bombs if you don’t have enough smart weapons, enough targeting pods or enough training.
- simonblack 5y agoWho are they going to shoot down? There's practically no aircraft in the sky. The Russian method of war is not to rubbleise like NATO does. Time and again in WW2 the lesson was do not bomb and destroy cities, it turns the destroyed buildings into an urban warfare playground. So no aircraft to shoot down and no cities to bomb means very little need for an air force. Of course, NATO could test my theory by sending over a few squadrons of F35s and see if the Russian Air Force makes any moves against them.
- cyanydeez 5y agoUavs attack high value targets. Why would you not do that first.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoExcept of course that rubbleising is precisely the Russian strategy, now that collapse/regime change due to lightning strikes has failed. They have no other strategy at this point. Probably they aren't too bothered by ground equipment and manpower losses, they have plenty to spare. Ukraine (and indeed NATO if it comes to that) needs be ready to industrialise the destruction of Russian armour and more pertinently artillery. One drone strike is great, but this must be happening at scale.
- newsclues 5y agoRussian doctrine is to rubbleize but with artillery and unguided rockets.
- aldanor 5y agoPrecisely. There's no resistance in the air, and Ukrainian air defense is almost non-existent, having suffered lots of damage on day 1. So, there's barely any need for fighters. Note also that Russia tends to bring in lots of mobile air defense units to support the air from the ground (unlike US which usually relies more on fighter jets for the same purpose). Then, if the point was to carpet-bomb and annihilate the entire territory, NATO-style, it would have been done already. Destroying singled out targets like munition depots or teletowers doesn't require engaging more than a few jets here and there. It seems like helicopters seem to be heavily relied upon (in providing mobility, recon, convoy support, etc) - but that's a different story.
- CapricornNoble 5y agoMy 2 Yen: I wonder if Putin is holding back his fixed-wing aviation as a strategic reserve, so he has some conventional combat power he can commit in case of NATO intervention, before escalating to tactical nukes. He may have assessed that Ukraine could be taken without risking his expensive modern birds (Su-34, Su-35) or any of his big nuke-capable bombers. This isn't to say the Russian Air Force doesn't have the problems mentioned. Those are all legit issues. I just think there might be some deliberate decision-making (even if we assess that those decisions were erroneous) on top of that.
- eternalban 5y agoThat thought (NATO) is worth more than 2 Yens. Part 3 (@33:00) of Oliver Stone's interview has him taking Stone to his situation room ("my functions as Commander-in-Chief") in case you're curious at the level of interaction with MoD.
- blago 5y agoThis sounds very plausible. And not just against NATO I would guess. They've deployed almost their entire active land force to Ukraine leaving their enormously long borders unprotected.
- themadturk 5y agoMy generally uninformed take on it is that I'm as surprised as anybody. I always thought it was a rule of modern warfare that if you're capable of establishing air superiority, you establish air superiority.
- haimez 5y agoNow modern nations will have an example case to understand what happens if you don’t. I’m going to guess based on what we’re able to see at this point, that no country is going to change their military doctrine based on these new data points, because they aren’t going to be willing to pay the price that seems to have be paid as a result. I could be wrong. It’s not totally clear at this point that Russia is going to be able to pay the price either, so I guess we’ll all find out together.
- epolanski 5y ago> what happens if you don’t It's not that simple when you're also missing infantry.
- haimez 5y agoIf you aren’t establishing air superiority and are “missing infantry” (I’m not sure what you mean by this) then… are you describing an air skirmish? Peacetime operations?
- philistine 5y agoThe missing infantry part refers to the fact that it seems way too much of the Russian army is tanks, and not enough of it infantry, to protect the tanks from being destroyed.
- etempleton 5y agoThe current battlefield is entirely based on air superiority. You control the skies, you control the battle. If air supremacy is established tanks and static artillery become useless. They are sitting ducks. I am pretty perplexed with what is happening with the Russian armed forces. They seem to be suffering from poor planning, indecision, and poorly maintained equipment.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoYes, is probably the short answer. Not just due to training, experience, or any particular technology problem, but in fact due to all these things and more. Everything is harder in the sky - the logistics trains are longer, societal and technological depth is more necessary. This is where any rot will first present itself.
- excalibur 5y ago> One potential argument is that the VKS fighter fleets are being held in reserve, potentially as a deterrent against direct intervention by NATO forces. This is unlikely to be the case. If the VKS is capable of large-scale combat operations to rapidly establish air superiority over Ukraine, by not doing so, it is, in fact, weakening its potential deterrent value against NATO forces rather than preserving it. Makes sense if you assume they're being held as a deterrent I guess. I assumed that they were being held in case they were needed for actual combat. I see nothing here that refutes this. I don't think the west really appreciates how realistic (if undesirable) this scenario is in Putin's eyes, to our great peril.
- elihu 5y agoOne theory I came across recently was that the Russian IFF system ("Identify Friend or Foe") has been subverted by Ukraine, possibly due to captured vehicles, and that Russia doesn't trust their own IFF system. So, any attack involving air and ground units involves a lot more coordination than it would otherwise, to prevent Russian forces from attacking each other. Apparently Russian forces are having some difficulty with IFF, if this is accurate: https://twitter.com/andersostlund/status/1499823866893512708 https://twitter.com/andersostlund/status/1499823866893512708
- sandworm101 5y agoIff is not easy to hack. It is communication between radios/radars on two airborne aircraft. It is very hard to get in the middle of that conversation.
- Thorentis 5y agoYes, which is why if you have captured enemy vehicles (as apparently Ukraine have done) it becomes much easier to do.
- danielvf 5y agoIt's not just Russia. Planning air operations is far harder than it looks. In the initial phases of the UK/French air attacks on Libya in 2011, the French Air Force plus a French carrier ended up only able to combined together sustain a rate of one to two supported ground attack missions per day. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opération_Harmattan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opération_Harmattan If I recall correctly, the primary bottleneck was planning. Once the US joined in and provided planning support, the rate of French sorties per day went considerably up.
- noetic_techy 5y agoAnyone surprised. Russia may look like a big scary country on the map, but keep in mind they have roughly the same GDP as the state of FLORIDA. Its why they were once described as a gas station with nukes. The nukes are the only thing really scary about Russia, otherwise they are a turning out to be a paper Tiger. In fact if they didnt have nukes I would think other border countries in the east coughChinacough wouldn't hesitate to take their land. If the reports that they tricked their own troops into thinking it was just going to be an exercise (cant tell if thats just propaganda) then ordered them into Ukraine, and the fact that their convoy outside Kiev is totally FUBAR as far as resupply, we are looking at a major blunder here. Why wouldn't you show strong airpower competence to scare the west. I think others are right, this whole thing was likely planned at the top, didnt involve all the competent people it should, and now Putin is looking visibly pissed in his state broadcasts. Authoritarianism doesn't breed competence, its breeds yes men and ass kissers and kelptos and thugs right up until the poopees hit the fan. I think behind the scenes Russia is having a huge crisis of competence.
- SubiculumCode 5y agoWhat if their nukes are also not as scary as they seem?
- idontwantthis 5y agoI was thinking about that too. What if MAD turns out to have been a hoax on the Russian side? What if we just didn’t need these soldiers or nukes anymore?
- hattmall 5y agoImagine Florida with 140 million people.
- decebalus1 5y agoYes, exactly. An overall poor country.
- zelon88 5y agoI've been postulating that last week, when biden was briefed on his "cyber options", that a devastating cyber attack similar to NotPetya took the Russian Air force offline.
- tomc1985 5y agoImagine if Ukraine had Iron Dome...
- ceejayoz 5y agoIron Dome is a very expensive way to intercept small numbers of not-very-sophisticated rockets and mortar rounds. It wouldn't help Ukraine much.
- cc101 5y agoA successful ground and air attack would leave Ukrainian cities in ruin. If Putin is actually bluffing and positioning himself for a negotiated ceasefire, the potential devastation of Ukrainian cities is a thing of value in those negotiations. Why spend it and gain nothing in exchange? Maybe Putin is holding back the ground and air attack so he can use that threat as a bargaining chip. Putin is the kind of man who would not hesitate to push a threat to the extreme no matter what the humanitarian cost if it eventually gave him a worthwhile advantage.