10 ms·
A Look at the Slow, Silent Death of America’s Middle Class
- gwbrooks 5y agoIt's hard to take the author credibly when he trots out the trope about 91% marginal tax rates and 50% corporate tax rates. Yes, they existed. But those numbers don't matter. What does matter is federal revenue as a share of GDP, an apples-to-apples comparison across years. And it turns out that number doesn't vary a whole lot.[1] [1] Figure 2: https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-are-sources-revenue-federal-government https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-are-sourc...
- angarg12 5y agoI moved to the US a few weeks ago after living in a few European countries, and I'm still shocked by seeing abject poverty right next to mindboggling wealth in a developed country. I see multimillion dollar houses literally two streets away from homeless tent camps. Even with a fat +200k big tech salary I feel less middle class that I did in Europe. Makes me wonder how less privilege people manage.
- emerged 5y agoIt sounds like you don’t live in “the US” you live in one of the giant cities. People are surviving on much less income in the rest of the country, with land and space.
- sien 5y agoThe guy doesn't define what he regards as middle class numerically. What is middle class in the US ? How about looking at : https://www.statista.com/statistics/203183/percentage-distribution-of-household-income-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/203183/percentage-distri... How about saying any household with less income than 35K is not middle class. Also any household with more than 150K income is high income. That still leaves more than half the US population. The US middle class isn't dying. Also note that ~20% of households are high income, and they are doing OK as well. Of course the US could do better. But saying the Middle Class is dying is not correct.
- RickJWagner 5y agoThe author's not looking at things clearly. 40 years ago, we watched tv on 3 channels. We drove cars that were junk 5 years later. We had to accumulate huge quantities of stuff to listen to a variety of music. Today, even those of modest means have smart phones that entertain, bring news and weather, stream the whole world's music straight to you. Cheap used cars often easily last decades and go hundreds of thousands of miles. Everything is cheaper and better. People have learned how to make things as time passed, and the trend is only accelerating.
- Digit-Al 5y ago> If lucrative careers and some middle-class opportunities were largely shut off to minorities and women, whoever was left was suddenly a more valuable resource than they really were. For me, this was one of the most interesting takeaways. It seems obvious in retrospect, but was something that had never actually occurred to me. To me, this appears to show that it would be in the best interests of employers to fight against discrimination and promote equality of opportunity; as this will naturally lead to a larger employment pool, and thus lower wages.
- seibelj 5y agoAmerica doesn’t make anything anymore. Core issue is the dollar as the global reserve currency. Petro dollar system means all oil is priced in dollars which generates strong demand for dollars. Other countries export to the US to get dollars so they can buy oil. End result is the US can buy imports cheaper but our manufacturing base is hollowed out. What do the most ambitious do in the USA? Go into software or Wall Street. Becoming the best widget maker is noble, and many go into it and earn a fine salary, but the truly ambitious sniff out the money and go there. If you want to reduce inequality, stop incentivizing money pushing. But to do this will require a ton of pain as we get out of the current global system and reorient towards actually doing stuff. Inflation is finally getting bad for cheap shit imported from foreign countries. But inflation for all manner of things that are conveniently ignored in CPI like how much it costs to make skyscrapers, how much it costs to make subways, how much medical care and education costs, etc. etc. has been rising forever because foreigners can’t manufacture that and ship it on a container to the US. No amount of tax dithering will solve this fundamental misalignment of our currency. Until this is solved expect those closest to money printers to keep winning.
- iancmceachern 5y agoI 100% agree. Somewhere over the last 50 years we went from telling our best and brightest young minds to make the world better to make as much money as you can. We've even aligned our higher education institutions to that goal and not necessarily the greater good. Institutions like Harvard lead the way. They set an example by priorizong financial gains and the health of the endowment and not the greater good. I've heard it several times here on HN before. The greatest minds of a generation are working on adtech. It's important to also note that the best minds of previous generations spent their careers working on war machines. I think that is the greatest part of the whole Kennedy Apollo story. It's easy to assume that the decision to go to the moon was the difficult one. There were many reasons leading the US to need to do something during that time to stay in the space race. The big thing Kennedy did for us all was to choose to make it a civilian program and not a military one done in secret. We are at another inflection point in history now. We can choose to do something great together, as civilians, to bring us together (climate change comes to mind), or we can build more war machines and re arm all of Europe, again. It seems as though we are going to go down that path.
- baron816 5y agoHad medical care, education, child care, and housing followed a cost curve similar to food over the last 40 years [1], no one would be complaining. A big reason why those things have become so expensive is because the country chose to make them expensive. Housing had to be a “good investment”. Elite schools were priced for the elite. Health care became a rent seeking operation in far too many ways to count. It absolutely kills me that the Democrats haven’t brought up immigration as a way to tackle inflation. The left made immigration all about race, but there’s a huge supply side benefit to having more people who are able to produce more goods and services in the country. Immigrants are often the ones who build houses, and look after our sick, children, and elderly. The country would be a better, more affordable place with more people to help out. [1] https://images.app.goo.gl/N7rBSDDseMyiBTQb8 https://images.app.goo.gl/N7rBSDDseMyiBTQb8
- ciphol 5y ago> Elite schools were priced for the elite. Note that most people don't go to elite schools. In particular, the middle class (almost by definition) doesn't go to elite schools.
- bcoughlan 5y agoBecause exploiting foreigners to work all the tough low-paid jobs that nobody wants to do is how we created racial disparities to begin with...
- antifa 5y ago> The left made immigration all about race This is some weird gaslighting.
- lamontcg 5y ago> It absolutely kills me that the Democrats haven’t brought up immigration as a way to tackle inflation. What we need is wage inflation to readjust prices and you're talking about how to continue to keep wages suppressed, which would not help the people who have fallen out of the middle class. Immigration isn't going to decrease the prices of housing, except for providing cheap labor, which is just exploitation. I actually agree with more permissive immigration standards (because ultimately I believe in a world without borders and free movement of people that we need to get to eventually), but you're trying to cheap immigrant labor as a club against the working class to keep prices down. That is an upper class concern. At this point wages must rise so that people can afford things again, or else the massive decades-long asset bubble really needs to fall. And its possible that we do have a worker shortage now caused by the effects of the pandemic which are going to allow workers to have bargaining power. That kind of inflation is what we desperately need, and trying to prevent it via importing cheap labor is an argument that the elite would make. And this is likely to be an actually extraordinarily unpopular opinion on this forum. Everyone is terrified of inflation and is about to explain to me why a wage-price spiral would be terrible for everyone and hurt the working class (but as long as wage inflation outpaces commodities inflation and asset bubbles in housing that is good in the long run for the working person, while all other roads are just terrible pain for workers short term and long term). That's why I think the central bank will throw the brakes on hard at some point and pop the asset bubble and create a truly massive economic crash (unless other policy measures suffice to get wage inflation back under control again, like dramatically increased immigration).
- bloodyplonker22 5y agoThis article was a painful read. It was a long drawn out word salad, or shall I say "verbal diarrhea" of socialist complaining with no backing at all on any of the talking points.
- betwixthewires 5y agoI didn't get that at all from it. I didn't see a real push for socialist talking points, mention of unions aside. Basically the article says "there's no going back, but this isn't the way forward, and the only solution I can see is for people to voluntarily consume less so that they have more financial security."
- WalterBright 5y agoIf one expects the government to provide, one doesn't need to plan for financial security.
- rscho 5y agoLogorrhea
- InvaderFizz 5y agoIf we were trying to make this work, it seems to me that Pathos is more applicable than Logos. Therefore I would suggest Pathorrhea as a descriptor for an "emotionally charged and factually unsupported article."
- refurb 5y agoI kept scanning to see what data points were referenced and what the sources were and... there were none.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- betwixthewires 5y ago> We’ll only see real change if semi-skilled and skilled positions start atrophying from major corporations. And there’s little chance of that happening now. We’re far too extravagant. Even people making $100,000 are leveraged up to their eyeballs in unnecessary luxury. Our marketers are effective. This basically hits the nail on the head. You (probably) have way too much shit and spend way too much money. And the marketers are effective. You don't feel like you've made it unless you've spend all that money on extravagant creature comforts and status items. You rationalize why you need those things, but you don't. And you'll remain a slave as long as this is the case. Comfortable, but a slave still.
- kortilla 5y ago> And you'll remain a slave as long as this is the case. Comfortable, but a slave still. No: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery Slavery is one of the worst atrocities in human history and diluting it to voluntary work for luxury goods is offensively downplaying history. It’s no different than calling leering “rape”.
- hhjinks 5y agoBeing a slave to something is a very common turn of phrase.
- betwixthewires 5y agoIt is different than calling leering rape, but I see your point. I guess what I mean is, if you make good money you could get ahead. You could become financially independent, give your kids a leg up, build something that lasts, not have to kludge through another workday with no end in sight. But most people don't do this, most people are convinced that they haven't made it unless everyone sees that they've made it, and they keep themselves financially at the same level of security as a poor person with debt.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 5y agoI've posted this many times. Its essentially been: 1. Money printing, which pumped assets, cutting off younger middle class from buying an affordable house. The money printing starting in 2008 patched up flaws in our economy, and there is no free lunch. Along the same lines, the financialization of assets like homes in the 80s by firms like Blackstone transformed what a home was and what it costed. This was a financial innovation, almost on the same level of societal impact as Google creating search. 2. Immigration. The biggest lie ever told in economics was that, "replaced american workers would move up the value chain and be retrained for new jobs". This never happened, and the phrase, "you cant teach an old dog new tricks" is true. It was a core tenant of both the left and the right. 3. Outsourcing. In the 90s there was a massive business arbitrage of sending whatever you could be done overseas. Politicians on both sides of the isle have acted like the above three are the second coming of christ. Paradoxically, the left is pro immigrant and pro free trade, both of which actively hurts the lower and middle classes in america. Very puzzling how capitalist doctrines have been construed as left wing. Last caveat I'll say is immigrants have produced extreme value and innovation in tech. They are intelligent and dilligent. They just arent good for the american middle class.
- anamax 5y ago> Last caveat I'll say is immigrants have produced extreme value and innovation in tech. They are intelligent and dilligent. They just arent good for the american middle class. Are you saying that immigrants are interchangeable?
- ldjkfkdsjnv 5y agoI dont want to argue the merits/drawbacks of immigrants. Its a simple fact, flood a labor market and watch wages and working conditions go down
- astrange 5y agoIf that was a simple fact then Russians’ upcoming autarky would make them richer and you could get a raise by killing your coworkers. Well, unless they got to you first.
- cjohnson318 5y ago> The houses I'm seeing built are absurd. When you have small kids and two people that are WFH due to a multi-year pandemic, then your need for space changes. Sure, maybe covid is a total non-issue, but normal everyday folk we won't really know for another twenty years, like leaded gasoline.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoYou are trying to fit the narrative to the symptom but the huge houses trend has been steadily increasing in the US and Canada for the last 30 years, well before the pandemic. It is absolutely an aspirational thing of people made to believe they _need_ that space or that they will 'look poor' without the square footage. I would even go as far as say that, I think the increase in housing square footage in US/Canada and the increase in SUVs and SUV tonnage are a big factor in why the US/Canada are not on par with other developed nations in terms of carbon emissions. The average US house is 1660 square feet, to my knowledge most middle class families in Europe live in houses under 900 square feet and they still have room for baby rooms and WFH offices.
- twblalock 5y ago> It is absolutely an aspirational thing of people made to believe they _need_ that space or that they will 'look poor' without the square footage. It really is nicer to have more space. A lot nicer. If Europeans could afford it they would do it too. They are also buying a lot more SUVs than they used to.
- scruple 5y agoI'm dealing with a situation right now that is, IMO, simply unsustainable, in terms of number of living things vs. square footage of living space. I've got 7 humans and 3 animals living in 3 bedrooms / 1,634 square feet. 3 of us are working full-time remote. We can make it work, and we have been, but it isn't a healthy or viable long-term situation. Add on to that the fact that my parents are rapidly aging and dealing with declining physical and/or mental health and will likely be living with us in the next 3-5 years... I know that there are plenty of people who are afraid of "looking poor" and who are buying McMansions that they simply don't need but that isn't the case for all of us...
- pinephoneguy 5y agoThe US is dead; she was dealt a mortal blow in the late 60s and succumbed to her injuries around 2004. What's left is the slow decay that will take many decades. That people continue to volunteer and fight for the country surprises me but I guess not everyone has noticed yet.
- n8ta 5y ago2004 referring to the victory of George W. Bush over John Kerry? Or something else?
- forrestthewoods 5y ago> Our top tax rate was 91%. Corporate taxes were over 50%. And yes, gasoline taxes and capital gains taxes were around then, too. The federal minimum wage, adjusted for inflation, was about 50% higher in 1960 than it is today. Make no doubt about it, the economy that preceded/persisted in the middle-class boom was a tax-and-spend economy. Ehhhh. My understanding is that tax revenue as a percentage of GDP has been relatively flat. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hauser%27s_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hauser%27s_law
- imtringued 5y agoSorry, but the answer is still the same. Solve the land question and then solve the money question. People losing their land through debt is as old as civilization itself. At some point people will start fighting over it because there is no place for them in their own country.