15 ms·
As someone living on the eastern NATO border this has been a most interesting week. In the Chinese proverb way. Ghosts of 1939, about which I’ve heard stories
by baq 5y ago
As someone living on the eastern NATO border this has been a most interesting week. In the Chinese proverb way.
Ghosts of 1939, about which I’ve heard stories from my grandfather and was taught in history lessons, suddenly came to life just around the corner. The only consolation is that the west finally saw the Kremlin for what it always has been - a treacherous, lying dictatorship that seeks to enrich itself through any means and cannot be trusted.
Putin managed to do in a single week what multiple US presidents couldn’t in years - remilitarization of Germany. Also, he managed to get Scandinavia to join NATO and dismissed any ideas some countries might have had about leaving EU for decades.
Europe will pay a price which is unknown, but it is certain it will be huge. You just don’t quit drugs (cheap energy) in a week. There will be massive projects undertaken to public dismay.
Ukraine, unfortunately, cannot win - it already lost, even if Russian forces withdraw this instant. The question which remains is can Putin still win. He must be given an option, otherwise this ends really, really ugly.
- teawrecks 5y agoCare to elaborate on what "Ukraine has already lost" means? Is joining the EU the loss? I would assume that if Russia withdrew this instant, Ukraine would likely survive this. No?
- david927 5y agoIt's not joining the EU. Its application has been accepted. Bosnia's application was accepted in 2003 and it's most certainly not in the EU.
- hraedon 5y agoEven if the war ended right now, Ukraine has hundreds of thousands of refugees to move and shelter, huge amounts of destroyed infrastructure to repair and work around, most of their army expended, and a lot of civilian losses. They also won't get Crimea back, and they probably can't hold onto the separatist regions either. Provided that the world continues to rally around Ukraine and gets critical supplies to the population centers they may avoid grievous additional losses, but Ukraine is unavoidably much worse off than it was pre-invasion.
- bnt 5y agoIf history taught me anything, a retreating army will destroy everything around them just to damage their enemy and make their life hell. Imagine if Russian troops just flood Ukraine with land mines, it would take decades to make the country safe again. It’s been 30 years and Croatia is still riddled with land mines.
- basementcat 5y agoTo an extent, this has already happened. https://reliefweb.int/report/ukraine/landmines-still-pose-threat-two-million-ukrainians-enruuk https://reliefweb.int/report/ukraine/landmines-still-pose-th...
- theplumber 5y agoI think that if Russia pulls back its troops Ukraine has a bright future. Even if Crimea and the other two regions are lost it will receive more investment than it would have received otherwise. Both the EU and the US want Ukraine to become a succesful EU country. The Ukrainian people also seem to have a strong will to build/rebuild and defend Ukraine so they are reliable partners unlike the cases we've seen in other countries.
- tromp 5y agoRussia pulling back is more unimaginable now than a Russian invasion was in January.
- ignoramous 5y agoHow long can Russia hold such a massive country surrounded by NATO allies? I don't think there's a single scenario where Russia wins.
- nine_k 5y agoWith a change of the regime in Kremlin, it's quite imaginable. I suppose that a lot of the Russian elites, locked out of their wealth and prospects, would be more than happy to see and even effect a serious change of the leadership. I hope they have a fair chance. A huge lot of non-elites would support that, too.
- baq 5y agoOh, it will survive. Chechnya, Georgia, Syria, Iraq, Crimea, etc., they all survived. But… Rebuilding infrastructure lost this week will take billions of dollars and years of time. Some displaced people won’t come back. More of both with every passing week of this tragedy. That’s completely discounting people who died. Russian people, the normal citizens, also lost, and lost big. The currency and market sanctions have blown up savings and businesses basically overnight. Also, don’t forget that every other Russian family has Ukrainian relatives.
- teawrecks 5y agoI think you're saying that Ukraine has lost the battle, but I'm saying they can still win the war. Virtually every country in Europe has had to undergo post-war reconstruction at some point in its history. I don't think that means they lost. They're still there, after all.
- baq 5y agoBut lost I mean opportunity cost of waging war (yes I know it isn’t a choice) is devastating. It sets them back 20 years. Basically a generation of development has been lost.
- teawrecks 5y agoIt sounds cheesy, but if they're still a country and have allies and citizens who believe in their future, I don't consider that a loss. A loss would be if the dust settles and, for one reason or another, Ukraine is not recognized as a country anymore (either because Russia declares them as theirs and the rest of the world just forgets about it, or because they simply can't sustain themselves anymore). Germany took Poland to start WW2. Did Poland lose?
- CRConrad 5y ago> Germany took Poland to start WW2. Did Poland lose? Kind of, yeah: After WW2, Poland was part of the Warsaw[1] Pact for forty years. And if Communism hadn't fallen, they'd still be. ___ [1]: The name becomes doubly ironic in this specific context.
- neverminder 5y agoActually, it's Putin who cannot win. Even if he threw everything he had and managed to occupy a country of 44 million people, second largest in Europe by landmass - he wouldn't be able to hold it. That would require the kind of resources he doesn't have. Also the minute he withdraws, which is just a matter of time, ukrainians will kill his puppet government and take their country back. So yeah, Ukraine will suffer major losses, but ultimately time is on their side.
- tromp 5y agoI hope the records of which citizens were given arms, will be destroyed before falling into Russian hands, and that people manage to hide those arms well.
- simonh 5y agoNo records, they’re simply handing out weapons, armour and munitions to any Ukrainian who wants them. Not just Ukrainians either.
- layer8 5y agoThere are conflicting reports on that. From a Reuters journalist in Lviv: https://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/t4ebff/comment/hyy6jdk/ https://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/t4ebff/comment/h...
- simonh 5y agoThanks for the correction.
- biohax2015 5y agoNot true. Every gun has an ID registered to it.
- filomeno 5y ago
- ivan_gammel 5y ago> dismissed any ideas some countries might have had about leaving EU for decades Let’s not steal the credit from Boris Johnson and Theresa May for that.
- onei 5y agoI'm not sure Theresa May gets any real credit for Brexit as a concept. She didn't campaign for it; she was just daft enough to think anyone could negotiate something that satisfied the multitude of unworkable or contrasting promises.
- ivan_gammel 5y agoShe decided that her country should actually proceed with Brexit and has chosen the process for it.
- drumhead 5y agoThe electorate decided that with the result of the referendum. Boris Johnson won the election with a landslide on the promise that he'd leave.
- netsharc 5y agoI'm a bit annoyed that people say 52% is "the electorate said...", and the referendum was non-binding, the government could've said "OK, but here are the effects of Brexit and why we're not going to proceed...".
- jimmydorry 5y agoWhich is what the general election was for. Boris got into power on the back of promising to deliver...
- oarsinsync 5y ago
- layer8 5y agoAt this point, Putin will likely achieve his goals regarding Ukraine (which I can’t imagine he’ll ever be willing to give up) in the near term, at huge human and economic cost, unless (a) NATO decides to step in after all (unlikely), in which case all bets are off, or (b) China decides to join the West in opposing Russia (quite unlikely, they don’t have much reason to), or (c) Putin is overturned from within Russia (also unlikely it seems to me). The situation is pretty much doomed to get uglier and to remain ugly for quite some time.
- ignoramous 5y agoThe diplomatic channels are still open. Let's see if a miracle comes off it. I'm optimistic since there's not much left for Putin to prove. Europe is terrified and has wisely chosen to not engage with the Russian military. The absolute worst would be the continued escalation of economy warfare forcing China's hand in the conflict.
- layer8 5y agoPutin wants Russia, Belarus, and Ukraine (Great Russia, White Russia, and Little Russia) unified, to restore the Russian empire and to reunify the Russian people. This is not about proving something, it’s to restore historic justice and to undo the humiliation and tragedy of Russia’s breakup over 30 years ago, in the eyes of Putin. His legacy depends on it, and also he believes that if it doesn’t happen soon, then it will become impossible, because of the cultural contagion of the West. That possibility is something Putin can’t stomach, and preventing it is worth a lot of Russian hardship to him. EDIT: Just to be clear, I believe Putin is delusional. Just trying to explain what appears to be his world view, based on his speeches and published articles.
- throwaway_4ever 5y agoNo, comrade, it is NATO's fault. How dare they prevent the other Eastern European countries from being invaded.
- 5y ago
- heikkilevanto 5y agoAs far as I know, no Scandinavian country has joined NATO recently. Yes, there are discussions in Sweden, and even more in Finland, but that is not the same as actually applying for a membership. Such things take time. And I am not quite so sure about Ukraine being already lost.
- baq 5y agoI understand that and you’re of course right. This has been perhaps unwarranted hyperbole on my part. The fact is though, this topic was basically inexistent in any public discourse anywhere and as good as unthinkable. It isn’t anymore and that in itself is a tectonic shift.
- celticninja 5y agoSweden and Finland are on approved list to join, they literally just have to put in the paperwork.
- phire 5y agoSweden and Finland essentially have a pact, that they will both join or not join NATO together.
- morpheos137 5y ago
- m348e912 5y agoSorry that you're being downvoted for an unpopular take. Here is an interesting article from an economic forecaster, Martin Armstrong, that underlines some of the dirty dealings that lead us to where we are with this conflict. https://www.armstrongeconomics.com/international-news/russia/the-real-backdrop-nobody-will-discuss/ https://www.armstrongeconomics.com/international-news/russia... *PS can someone please upvote so HN isn't a constant echo-chamber PPS well that went well
- 5y ago
- darrennix 5y agoDuring the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in the 1980s, the Mujahideen had a phrase, "You have the watches, we have the time."
- BitwiseFool 5y agoIn your assessment, who has the time in this scenario? Russia? Europe? Ukraine?
- tarboreus 5y agoRussia has the watches. Ukraine has the time. Not sure if I agree in this circumstance, but traditionally insurgency is something of a waiting game.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoI feel the same way. I wasn't sure if Russia had some long-game tactical advantage I was hitherto unaware of and wanted to ask.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoI've barely followed what's going on in the conflict, but I think some regions of Eastern Ukraine are the insurgents with respect to the Ukraine government. So in their case perhaps they've had the time for the past years and finally Ukraine's watches are winding down there. Great proverb.
- jacquesm 5y agoThen maybe you should go bone up on what has happened in the last week or so before commenting? Things have moved quite a bit compared to the state that you describe, to put it very mildly.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoNo I know enough to know about the separatist regions, if not by propaganda then by actual action because western governments have begun to scrutinize business dealings with entities in those separatist regions, not just Russia. If everybody had to be actual experts in something before commenting on it here, there would be zero comments about any Russia/Ukraine story. Aside from that It's extremely difficult to get reliable information from any source I have found about the details of the situation. I've not seen anything that is contrary to what I said though. Maybe you can enlighten me.
- rizkeyz 5y agoMy predication, for the record: Putin is mad, old, and he certainly would not care to die these days looking outside the window into a sea of mushroom clouds. I'm virtually certain that he had at least one dream about this in his sleep - maybe long time ago, in the '80s. So he is mad, surrounded by yes-man with a populace that is used to being lied to all the time, used to the feeling that they know more than what is allowed to say publicly, you can read The Master and Margarita, written about hundred years ago, that describes this same exact feeling. Ukrainians, in an act of fatal heroism will fight; all that gets bloody. Kiev stands; Russians will try to starve the city to death; won't let any humanitarian help into the city; West will try to not lose their cool about the atrocities; but then something happens; some image that just surpasses the cruel picture of war we already have; people in West will demand justice; it will be hard to be bystanders when millions of lives are at stakes so obviously. That will be on a Friday. On Sunday, we defconned our way back to the stone age; world population will be back to 500M to 1B within this year. And a new world will be born.
- drcongo 5y agoThe Master and Margarita is possibly my favourite fiction book. It never leaves you.
- imperialdrive 5y agoSuuuch a great read.
- fredley 5y agoMy pet theory is that Putin has received a diagnosis of some kind. One that has made him accelerate the actualisation of his dreams of Soviet reunification.
- sitkack 5y agoMaybe he has the cancer he has used to kill so many others with.
- throwaway_4ever 5y ago
- pedalpete 5y agoAlong with others here, I'm questioning your "Ukraine...cannot win" comment. As I see it, they have already won, and will continue to win for a long long time. What I mean by this is that western countries didn't support them in the way (I feel) they should have, probably because they believed that Russia would easily walk over Ukraine, similar to how it had caused such confusion and prevented a defense in Crimea (I'm not a historian, this is my naive view of those events). Ukraine stood up to the bully, and showed us (the west) that we were wrong to not believe in them. It isn't over, and it can't be claimed as a victory yet, but they convinced the west that they had enough of a chance that we should come to their aid. They showed us what the Ukrainian spirit is. They have given hope to other regions and countries that may come under threat in the future. I wonder if they have given China extra pause in their stance toward Taiwan. If Putin loses in Ukraine, could that also mean the end of his regime in Russia? The Russian people are standing up to him. He has proven that he is not only fallible. Will this also be taken as a sign of weakness to Russians? You're absolutely right about cheap energy, and it's why I thought this was a strange time for Russia to invade Ukraine. Europe will be coming out of winter in a few weeks. This gives the summer to shore up reserves and build out alternative energy sources. Remember, Tesla built the Adelaide, Australia power plant in less than 100 days[1]. What happens when Europe faced with the threat of a lack of energy going into next winter? [1] https://news.sky.com/story/elon-musk-wins-50m-bet-with-giant-battery-for-south-australia-11141165 https://news.sky.com/story/elon-musk-wins-50m-bet-with-giant...
- itake 5y ago> probably because they believed that Russia would easily walk over Ukraine Sorry to be brass, but why would NATO support Ukraine? Its not a strategy ally. There aren't any special resources there. I don't know why the US was tempting Ukraine to join NATO in the first place.
- sidibe 5y agoWith neighbors like Ukraine has article 5 is the obvious temptation, USA didn't have to do anything. Believe it or not Ukrainians can have their own opinions and not everything they do is because of they are pawns
- crate_barre 5y ago“He must be given an option, otherwise this ends really, really ugly.” Assuming we are still in a world where pure madness is not an option (nukes), it is possible Putin will commit to a protracted occupation of Ukraine (years). The west has a, how to put it, a lack of consistent ability to pay attention to a drawn out occupation in a land far far away (that shit might as well be middle earth to us). Putin has said in his own words that if Russia is to be left out of the world, then why should Russia care what the world thinks? They will occupy Ukraine for years, maintain and build relations with Iran, Brazil, China, India. The west will go through its own turn over, Trump may run again in 2024. It could be years, the EU could turn right wing. Border states will have to stop being romantic and start really incorporating the half a million Ukrainians (soon to be more, Britain has already Brexited because their population will not tolerate migration. Watch how awful the reality of the refugee crisis will be). It will be 2032, years later, with new government powers all over the world. It’ll be a changed world, but perhaps not as ‘green’ as people believe. India and China increase their energy demands and Russia is still there to provide it. Like the Taliban, the world may tire of them by then and capitulate. Now they own Ukraine, and have demonstrated an ability to survive isolation. The game plan may not be shock and awe or nuclear destruction, but a true willingness to simply endure. We are buying the narrative that Putin has lost because the invasion is taking so long, but in reality the whole thing is supposed to be a long drawn out operation. We’ll be tired of hearing about Ukraine in month 2, 3, 4 …. we’ll be exhausted. Reddit front page will be back to mostly cat videos. The window of opportunity is really on Ukraine and the west to do something now, not Russia. The UN can walk out of the chamber in protest, but cannot even ratify a modest peace keeping force. Not one country dare even send planes to create limited no fly zones over certain places, even Chernobyl. Most of us are not watching the poker hands carefully here. Just because you have two face cards to start with, doesn’t mean the flop won’t be a bunch of 2s and 7 of clubs. The flop is what’s going to get Zelinsky either killed in a air raid or exiled if he is smart. The modern world is the slow apartheid state of Palestine, the silent destruction of Syria and Yemen, the ignored subjugation of Hong Kong, the forfeited Afghanistan to the Taliban, the tacit acceptance of Khosgi killing in an embassy. The occupation of Ukraine or the valiant liberation of a democratic state? Which of those two fits with all the others?
- tapas73 5y ago
- apples_oranges 5y agohow certain you are..
- tlear 5y agoWho won and lost is not clear. West always writes Russian's off too early. They did subjugate Chechnya. In fact they were so effective that now their shock troops in Ukraine are Chechens. On other hand every nation is born in blood and this is Ukraine's real birth. Likely the country will be smaller, lots of people will die, but this is the time it becomes a real nation(well it started in 2014). It is time to prepare for insurgency in the west Ukraine. It took Stalin 6 years to finish off UPA. But they were surrounded and without any help, plus they faced NKVD. Ukranian insurgency in the west with arms flowing through Carpathy will make Russian regret they were ever born. There will be nothing pretty about it.. but there will be no victory for the tsar this time.
- drumhead 5y agoAny victory Putin has will be entirely phyrric. The west are determined to inflict severe economic damage on Russia. Which considering they represent about 50% of global GDP they are well capable of doing. Putin's reached the point of desperation where's he's hinting at using Nuclear weapons. That of course will never happen, the generals will put a bullet in him before they let him destroy their country.It almost feels like the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbour, they roused a sleeping giant in the form of the USA which went on to crush them. This time round the sleeping giant is the EU and they're going to flatten Russia economically.
- morpheos137 5y agoIn the long run present day nominal GDP doesn't matter. For example, after world war I Germany had a very bad economic situation. Land, natural resources and culture matter. Russia is the largest country on Earth. China is the largest population and largest economy. India is a close second. The fact is Eurasia does not need the North Atlantic Empire. Time will tell but much of the vaunted "Western" prosperity is a fading high from the now 70 year old post war era. It is not inevitable that America leads forever. I wouldn't be too cocksure. Also, things like population trends or nominal GDP are very changeable over the course of short decades. What matters is resources, land and will and unity of purpose.
- topspin 5y ago"Ukraine, unfortunately, cannot win - it already lost, even if Russian forces withdraw this instant." Ukraine can win, they just can't meet the bulk of Russia's forces head on. They can, however, defeat Russia in time, and with the support of allies that time can be short. If Ukraine comes out of this an EU member then they will have profound and victory that will benefit Ukraine for generations. This is an opportunity. Putin has rolled the dice and thrown the first punch. Russia needs punishment in the form of military humiliation and Putin has given the West a once in a century moment to deliver exactly that.
- jstgord 5y agoindeed.. I think there is a chance Europe will offer air support in Ukraine, and get drawn into this conflict, and thus be at war with Russia. which will mean EU, USA, UK, CAN, AUS .. will be at war with Russia. ie. WWIII. I see the attack on Ukraine as an existential threat to the West as a whole - and Im probably not the only one asking if maybe its worth risking nuclear conflict. Can we trust Putin with a nuclear arsenal in any case, even if he withdraws ?
- shrimp_emoji 5y agoIt's not really WW3 unless China joins. "The West" vs. Russia is just a military execution of Russia.
- rchaud 5y agoIn the post WW2 era, the Allies pulled together to institute the Marshall Plan which rebuilt Europe's infrastructure and led to diplomatic alliances to deter expansion of the Iron Curtain. That didn't happen overnight, and neither will energy independence. What kind of big projects do you think will create public dismay? Infrastructure projects create jobs, which increases economic activity and boosts stock market indices. Why would this be a problem for the public?
- Ygg2 5y ago> That didn't happen overnight, and neither will energy independence. Thing is, if energy independence doesn't happen overnight, climate change might renderer Europe and US uninhabitable. The only countries that profit from that is those that have access to artic circle.
- jacquesm 5y agoPutin has managed to get the EU to be pretty much united on a subject, that's something that I never thought I would see in my lifetime.
- kvathupo 5y agoInversely, I'm concerned that it's strengthening relations among Saudi Arabia, Russia, and China. In the worst case, this is barreling towards a Cold War 2.0 where nations throw humanity out the window for political leverage: * Saudi Arabia has consistently rebuffed Biden's calls to pump more oil [1]. Even after releasing oil from our strategic reserves, oil futures have jumped over 10% in a single day [2]. As discussed in the article, high prices only aid the Russian kleptocracy. * In an attempt to appease Saudi Arabia, the US added more sanctions on Yemen, undoubtedly worsening the humanitarian disaster there [3]. * Similarly, China is propping up the major Russian exports of Wheat [4] and natural gas [5]. Again, to our detriment, under the consideration that wheat futures went up today (8% I think?). [1] - https://www.axios.com/biden-drill-oil-saudi-arabia-energy-costs-54682844-1ba0-417d-8d34-bbe5debba221.html https://www.axios.com/biden-drill-oil-saudi-arabia-energy-co... [2] - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-28/oil-steadies-as-u-s-mulls-spr-release-to-quell-russia-concerns https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-28/oil-stead... [3] - https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/02/28/ukraine-russia-war-spills-over-yemen-uae/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/02/28/ukraine-russia-war-spil... [4] - https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3168278/ukraine-crisis-deepens-china-lifts-all-wheat-import https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3168278/u... [5] - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-28/gazprom-paves-way-to-new-china-gas-deal-as-sanctions-hit-russia https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-28/gazprom-p...
- kelnos 5y agoThis is the thing that drives me nuts about people in my country (USA). Especially the conservatives, those who buy the "America First" line and think we should be more isolationist. Embracing alternative (which usually ends up being renewable) energy sources seems like a no-brainer to reduce our dependence on the Saudis et al. Oil has given that region ridiculous amounts of geopolitical power. But I guess "green energy" is a "dirty librull" thing, so they can't get behind it even if it would dovetail with their foreign policy platform in other ways.
- uoaei 5y agoTiniest, off-topic nitpick: Finland is Nordic but not Scandinavian.
- kvetching 5y ago
- birdyrooster 5y agoI think humanity could use the lesson of a catastrophic near-world-ending nuclear event. Look on the bright side, the future of humanity will be much more certain after we get through this learning.
- vba616 5y ago>Europe will pay a price which is unknown, but it is certain it will be huge. You just don’t quit drugs (cheap energy) in a week. I mean, surely it is a massive disruption, but...<gestures vaguely at the Berlin airlift and currently ongoing LNG shipments to Europe>. Saying the price will be huge - compared to what alternative right now? Are there really any costs that are not opportunity costs?
- baq 5y agoThis development changes “transitory” inflation into a potential long term problem. Do not disregard that: inflation is what causes democracies to fail.