21 ms·
Silenced AirTags with disabled speakers are popping up for sale online
- dschuessler 5y agoI wonder if this modification could at least be made harder by having some kind of heartbeat. Build in a microphone whose sole purpose is to receive inaudible, high frequency impulses (maybe a hash signal?) from the speaker every once in a while. If the signal does not arrive in time, the AirTag shuts off. Of course, no measure can beat physical access to the device but you could at least make the tampering about as expensive as building your own device from scratch.
- causi 5y agoIt wouldn't be hard to make a silent container for an airtag that'd let the audible signal reach the mic but not the alarm. Personally I think they'll eventually have to link every Airtag to a real identity so anyone detecting one knows who it really belongs to.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> have to link every Airtag to a real identity Isn't it already linked to your Apple account? Take the AirTag to the cops, they ask Apple who it belongs to.
- iso1631 5y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted, valid question. I don't know how they work, but I assume they are linked to an account. Why even involve the cops - if you have an airtag, you should be able to scan it's code and it reveals the account holder's name.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> Why even involve the cops - if you have an airtag, you should be able to scan it's code and it reveals the account holder's name. That's easy. If you find my house keys, I'd rather you couldn't just look up my address. I don't know if Apple makes it easy or not, but I'd certainly like to be able to push a notification to the AirTag owner if I have found one of their things. At least so I can send them a message "I dropped this off at the local police station so you can pick it up" etc, or something along those lines.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- causi 5y agoI had a buddy try that just last week after he was alerted to one under his car. They laughed at him and did nothing but write a report.
- throwaway48375 5y ago
- throwaway48375 5y agoCouldn't you just remove the speaker and microphone then wire the speaker output to the microphone input?
- post_break 5y agoTaping them together tightly silences it. Airtags have to be the most nerfed product I've bought. Day one, they were fantastic. Then they lowered the beeping and rogue alerts to a threshold my wife gets them from my keys or wallet all the time. Then they just beep randomly. I regret buying them to be honest. Tile never really got harped on for stalking. The samsung trackers work just as well as Apple and don't have anti-stalking features.
- endisneigh 5y agoSamsung trackers do not work nearly as well imo. Or tile for that matter. I’ve tried most of them and AirTags are clearly on another level for better or worse I do think AirTags should have a button like the Samsung ones, tho.
- phkahler 5y ago>> Samsung trackers do not work nearly as well imo. Well, Apple Airtags use the massive network of iPhones to report the location of nearby airtags to Apple.
- legostormtroopr 5y ago
- endisneigh 5y agoDon’t know why they’re being downvoted when your point is irrelevant - the Samsung tracker only uses Samsung Galaxy devices specifically for the network
- buran77 5y agoAndroid phones don't intrinsically track tags, they need software specifically installed for this. So almost none of those Android phones can be used to track anything. On the other hand all newer iPhones can track any AirTag out of the box, in what's probably the single biggest tracking network in the world.
- andrepew 5y agoNot hard for a non-technical person to remove the speaker. Housing pops right open with a small flathead screwdriver. Then you just remove the speaker's magnet, no desoldering or anything like that required. Took 5 minutes. I did it to one of mine to use it to track my bicycle if it ever gets stolen.
- KIFulgore 5y agoI was going to say, there are valid security use-cases for doing this.
- nomel 5y agoIf the thief has an iPhone, they'll still be alerted that the tracker is following them. If they move their phone around on your bike, they'll be able to find it, within several inches, with the NFC identification feature that gives the last four digits of the owners phone number. Maybe Apple's campaign is working: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/feb/26/apple-does-not-let-bad-guys-use-iphones-on-screen https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/feb/26/apple-doe...
- pinot 5y agoYeah but at least when I loan my bicycle to my friend it won’t beep constantly.
- nomel 5y agoAbsolutely. With all the air tags in my family, I think I'm completely desensitized to the beeping and notifications. I really doubt I would notice if I was being stalked.
- andrepew 5y agoI'm banking on a bike theft being a crime of opportunity and not necessarily being done by someone who has thought things through completely. But against a professional thief an AirTag probably won't do much.
- 5y ago
- kazinator 5y ago> To make it harder for stalkers to abuse them, Apple included (and has since upgraded) several safety features that will alert someone to the presence of a nearby AirTag that’s not their own, including an audible beep. Is this saying that Apple is relying on the unknown tag to announce itself by emitting a beep, and is that true? I think you want your management device (e.g. phone) to alert you to the presence of such a thing, not that thing itself. (Of course, you still need to find it.)
- throwaway2048 5y agoNot everyone has an iOS device, or bluetooth/wifi enabled even if they do.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> Is this saying that Apple is relying on the unknown tag to announce itself by emitting a beep, and is that true? Not by itself, no. If you have an iPhone, you get notifications on your phone whether the AirTag ever beeps or not.
- duxup 5y agoAlso there's an Android app that does the same thing.
- celsoazevedo 5y agoAirGuard (open source), but there's a battery hit. The official Apple app only alerts when users run a manual scan (not very useful).
- rootusrootus 5y agoI guess I don't get it. For the price of an AirTag, you can buy a more capable tracker with GPS and mobile data. And it won't be notifying the trackee that it's there. The AirTag seems like a downgrade.
- endisneigh 5y agoIt won’t last a year on a $1 battery nor will it be as small.
- bin_bash 5y agoA Tile will, so will SmartThings
- endisneigh 5y agoA tile doesn’t use mobile data and have gps and is inferior to an AirTag anyway
- bin_bash 5y agoI've been using Tile for years. It's inferior, yes, but it's definitely good enough for spying.
- endisneigh 5y agoThe parent comment is talking about using mobile data and gps - not sure why you even brought up the tile. Tile is inferior to an AirTag if you seriously want to stalk someone. The network is orders of magnitude smaller. Don’t know why anyone who owns an Apple device would bother with it at this point
- rolobio 5y agoTile does not have nearly the network that Apple does. I attached an AirTag to an electric scooter, which I ended up returning. I forgot to remove the AirTag; I've been able to track the scooter over hundreds of miles with quick updates (even driving down a freeway). I've been having a fun time checking in on the scooter for months now. I have a Tile attached to a generator at my house. Since I've disabled Tile on my phone in favor of AirTag, my generator hasn't been detected in over 31 days. Even with neighbors walking past my house constantly.
- endisneigh 5y agoThere’s not really any way to make something that can reliably find your own stuff without also enabling stalking. Either you support the use case and the downsides or not
- AdamJacobMuller 5y agoIt doesn't matter if you support the use case or not. The hardware exists, has existed for years, and much of it is better suited for stalking purposes.
- rlt 5y agoI assume Apple only cares enough about the anti-stalking feature to avoid significant negative press. As others have pointed out, you can buy small GPS trackers without anti-stalking features already, and those will only get smaller / better battery life over time.
- nomel 5y agoOr, perhaps Apple only cares about the anti-stalking feature up to the point where it makes the product impossible to implement, because both have the same use case (finding). There are many AirTags in my family, and I'm constantly hearing beeping and getting notifications that I'm being followed, because my wife is sitting next to me, with her purse on her lap, and her keys, and her wallet. And guess what, you can't "trust" someone else's AirTag. I can't permanently turn off the notifications, because stalkers would do that too. The amount of anti-stalking that's present is so annoying as is that I'm probably not going to be buying any more. In your opinion, what else could Apple do here, assuming you're familiar with the product?
- pajko 5y agoSo this is a failed product then. Too good for tracking because it can be abused. While the new version alerts the thieves in the intended use case. Should have been given a 10x-50x price tag right from the start, to make it less available and affordable for malicious activities.
- babyshake 5y agoIf I wanted to make sure I knew about an AirTag attached to my vehicle, for example, is there something I can do or something I can put in the vehicle to detect it?
- jccooper 5y agoAn iPhone will eventually notify you about a tag that is following you. You can get a "Tracker Detect" Android app that will do a similar thing. There's also plenty of apps that'll just tell you all the NFC devices in your vicinity.
- tssva 5y agoApple's "Tracker Detect" app for Android will not automatically notify you about a tag that is following you as an iPhone will. Tracker Detect only supports manual scans for tags.
- Gigachad 5y agoThey likely can't. Background bluetooth scanning is a highly locked down thing because retail used it with apps to scan tracker beacons.
- rich_sasha 5y agoiPhones warn you if they think there is a “stalker” air tag, and you can get an app for Android.
- paxys 5y agoYour iPhone will notify you eventually. Or you can get a bluetooth signal tracking app and try and find it yourself.
- duxup 5y agoNot a big surprise. I can buy a lot of things and modify it to do bad things. AirTag is an interesting choice as if you want to REALLY track someone I think an AirTag is a wonky choice. Very much a cheap-o 'best effort' kind of tracking.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI think AirTags are only the right choice for casual stalkers who haven't really thought their plan all the way through. Anybody who is properly motivated will easily find better options.
- duxup 5y agoThat and parents who only kinda want to track their kids bags ... mostly ... I guess.
- rootusrootus 5y agoRight about now I wish I had pasted one to my son's iPad. Of course, I wish the iPad just had that function built in so it wouldn't need a booger attached to the outside.
- duxup 5y agoWell you can have the iPad share its location ... that's a thing. How you do it depends on if your iPad is setup under a different apple ID or not (still can do it either way). My father in law who is older and prone to wandering off, I put an airtag on him while on vacation temporarily when we were out and about, and set his phone to share his location to the whole family all the time just to be save. It's very handy that way.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> Well you can have the iPad share its location ... that's a thing. As a member of my family account, his iPad does share its location. But only for 24 hours after the battery dies, at which point Apple will no longer show you were it was last found. And since it's only a WiFi iPad, it'll only report when attached to a network it knows about. And even in perfect circumstances, it doesn't work worth a crap. My daughter 'lost' her iPad last night and asked me to beep it. So I did. "Find My" said "playing sound" for maybe 10 seconds and then just stopped, without any further notice. It told me it last saw the iPad two hours previously, so I told my daughter it may have run out of battery. She found it a couple minutes later in my wife's office. 80% battery. In our house, attached to our WiFi. She came up and played with it a while sitting behind me in my office. "Find My" still couldn't see it. This morning, about 10AM, while my daughter was in school and her iPad was sitting on the charger, it started beeping to be found. LMAO. Thanks Apple, for nothing. They should put a rechargeable AirTag in the iPad somewhere. With all the usual features. Then I could tell you where my son's iPad is right now, and I could make it noisy, even though the battery died a few days ago and he doesn't know where it is. We think it might have gotten swiped by the neighbor kid, but we'll probably never find out since it's a game of eliminating possibilities, not positively finding the device. Since he didn't mention that it was missing until more than 24 hours after it was last seen, I can't even say for sure he lost it in our house somewhere. Such a misfeature.
- errcorrectcode 5y agoAnecdotal regional issue: I had an AirTag on my AirPod Pro's case that was stolen. I immediately notified Austin's police (APD) as I could see where it was going. Unfortunately, due to understaffing of 100-200 police officers and detectives, most calls unrelated to imminent threats of injury or death aren't being handle for days or ever. So, it's open-season on packages and property because APD can't or won't do its job, even if you tell them where stolen property is located. As long as a crime is nonviolent or the threat of violence has passed (with the exception of rape), ATX has the security measures of a third-world country. I met a UT campus police officer who refuses to live in or bring his family to ATX because of the risks and de facto lawlessness.
- shiftpgdn 5y agoThis is every major city right now, unfortunately.
- errcorrectcode 5y agoWhich? Where?
- radicaldreamer 5y agoSan Francisco, for one.
- mushbino 5y agoThey've never responded for things like this, be it now, pre-pandemic, or 20 years ago. It's never been an understaffing issue.
- flounder3 5y agoSan Francisco. Los Angeles. Seattle. San Jose (albeit theft has never received attention in San Jose)
- 5y ago
- ed25519FUUU 5y agoAnyone who would use these to stalk someone is an idiot. They’re tied to your Apple ID. It’s not at all anonymous. Apple warns people about the abuse. There’s a million GPS trackers for sale online that are near anonymous. The AirTag is a horrible device used to stalk people.
- rich_sasha 5y agoIt’s perfect for stupid people, and there’s enough of them...
- loceng 5y agoOr to frame someone if you're wanting to paint them in a bad light, create suspicion; "I didn't put my AirTag on their car."
- post_break 5y agoHave you seen anyone get busted by tying their Apple ID to a stalker? You can easily make a new Apple ID and fill it with fake data.
- paxys 5y agoIt takes 10 seconds to create an Apple ID. How exactly can it be tied back to you? Every GPS tracker on the market needs a monthly subscription and your credit card info.
- equon_ 5y agoI removed the speaker myself and hid one on my bike, I am super happy with it in Paris. Every minute its precise location is shared through Find My network and I get an alert when the bike is far from me when it is not at home.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- seshagiric 5y agoA number of iPhone users are reporting instances of unknown object tracking their location. https://discussions.apple.com/thread/253235422 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/253235422 Apple support does not provide any details about the issue.
- Gigachad 5y agoThis sort of thing has happened to me but it was just my bfs airpods which triggered the alert.
- up6w6 5y agoOr you can load your own firmware to any other embedded device with Bluetooth and also make it totally undetectable from iPhones by changing keys frequently and making it appear like multiple different AirTags. https://github.com/seemoo-lab/openhaystack/ https://github.com/seemoo-lab/openhaystack/
- lgats 5y agoPreviously Discussed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26342504 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26342504
- Gigachad 5y agoI think the cat was out of the bag in a way on this one. Apple put in a good effort to stop abuse but the technology is in people hands now.
- TSiege 5y agoThey in no way put in any effort to do this. They added the bare minimum that they were told at the outset was not enough. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/05/13/apple-airtag-tracking-threats-abuse/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/05/13/apple-air...
- gonzo41 5y agoThey could NOT sell the tech. It's a choice.
- stickfigure 5y agoIt's already being sold by other companies. The cat has been out of the bag for years, you're just being notified. Don't attack the messenger.
- gambiting 5y agoOther companies sold trackers which could already use every single iphone/ipad in existence to track their whereabouts???? That's complete news to me. Can you name any of them??
- pkulak 5y agoI've got a tag on my bike and it's pretty dumb that it starts beeping at the thief if it ever gets stolen. Why do we have to gimp everything to make it difficult to use them to break the law? Isn't enforcement of laws how we're supposed to make people not break the law?
- RIMR 5y agoThe problem is that without the beep, these devices are no different than your standard GPS tracker that you could use to track someone without their consent. So it beeps so indemnify Apple from that use case. And for good reason. These devices are already getting popular with abusive spouses. It's worth planning for the worst case scenarios for these things, because they are real.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- asdff 5y agoApple already sells a silent gps tracker: the iPhone. Realistically a piece of duct tape is all you need to put an iPhone under a car, then you can track it with Find My. This way would be better than using an airtag, since it wouldn't beep and I think it also wouldn't send a notification, but it gives you the same resolution (albeit shorter battery life).
- lm28469 5y ago> Realistically a piece of duct tape is all you Realistically you have to be much more determined to buy an additional phone and another sim card + pay for the data vs simply using an airtag. If you're already that determined just buy a proper gps tracker. You'd also have to find a way to recharge the iphone constantly, problem that you wouldn't have with an airtag. An airtag is much easier to hide too (bags, clothes, ...) The fact that you can already track someone relatively easily doesn't mean that introducing a new small/cheap/easy to use tracking device is a good thing
- watwut 5y ago
- julienb_sea 5y agoAirTags are so irritating. If you ever travel with a group its like daily notifications about someone's stalking you with their airpods and there isn't a way to permanently ignore a device.
- Gigachad 5y agoHave certainly seen it happen with airpods. It's meant to not trigger if the owner is nearby but it seems this fails often with airpods while the airtags are good at not alerting you.
- pyronik19 5y agoMy ex gf uses these to track her fiancé ...sticking it in his bag where he doesn't look. These things are SO ripe for abuse.
- slig 5y agoYou dodged a bullet.
- exabrial 5y agoApple's Airtag's are a solution looking for a problem. You can't use them to "track lost items" while alerting thieves to their presence. Conversely you can't allow thieves to scan for their presence when they steal something. Their intended use case is pretty useless "find your stuff you've lost" I think, as it covers a small market segment compared to "LoJack, but cheap and fancy like Apple". The solution requires a lot more governance, and puts Apple in charge of a "court system" with a lot of support cases. * Every Airtag must have a registered owner. People are limited to the number of tags they're allowed to purchase and use. * If an Airtag is lost by its owner, they can request it be located. If the Airtag is a significant distance from the owner, Apple must intervene. * Apple must ask the user if they suspect the article is stolen. If Yes, the user can provide a police report and will be provided the location. * If they suspect they misplaced the item, but not stolen, things get complicated. * If the location is mobile since the owner departed the tag, and is tailing other Android/Apple iPhones, Apple will probably need to tell the owner too bad so sad, get a police report first. * If its location is static since it departed contact with the owner's phone, Apple makes a judgement call as to if they believe it's a stalking situation. If the tag is tailing another Android/iPhone user, Apple should allow that person to have a setting on their phone to passively allow this case, allowing users to consent to being tracked. There are other obvious edge cases, but I think this at least a start to how this useful technology could avoid stalking but provide for a wider variety of use cases. And of course this breaks the e2e promise that Apple made, which _prevents_ them from getting NSLs when the government wants to track somebody... so, I don't see a good way out of this.
- Gigachad 5y agoFor me the airtags are really useful for keys/wallet. They aren't stolen but are just lost. I somewhat agree that the rest of the solution needs to come from government since Apple has done their best to prevent abuse but it isn't possible. It should be a serious crime to track someone without their knowledge. Something that police take seriously.
- seanp2k2 5y agoIt’s like normies have discovered small radio transmitters for the very first time or something. This isn’t new tech, it’s just more accessible and the monitoring network is better. ISM 433/900mhz transmitters with small microcontrollers have been around for quite a number of years, but I guess the reduced burden from “watch a few YouTube videos and spend some time tinkering with a soldering iron and batteries” to “buy this and hide it somewhere on a car you’d like to steal” + the anonymity (even though they’re registered to an iCloud account…) and ready availability of these now is a game-changer for criminals.
- wanderer_ 5y agoWow, that is one well-optimized site! Time to first model was lightning.
- fungiblecog 5y agosomeone will get stalked and murdered by someone using one of these devices before they're withdrawn. a completely foreseeable result of bringing such a stupid device to market.