14 ms·
Apple Podcasts suddenly became a five-star app
- marcellus23 5y agoEh. I work for a company that also gets reviews like this a lot (reviews for products we offer instead of the app itself). You’d be surprised how many people accidentally do it, and how hard it is to prevent. I really think it’s a bit rich to suggest it’s intentional.
- basisword 5y agoReminds me of when I would frequently get 1 star reviews with the subject “Amazing app! Highly recommended”. So, so frustrating especially when the reviews can have such a big impact.
- bin_bash 5y agoWell it doesn't look like they're in a big hurry to "fix" this UX issue so I think it's worth pointing out
- hwers 5y agoIf that were the case why was it ever at 1.8 stars to begin with then? The drastic change (with no software updates) certainly doesn't make intentional manipulation far fetched.
- hbn 5y agoIf it's hard to stop, why did it used to have a low rating before 3 months ago?
- hbn 5y agoActually I figured it out, it's in the article linked within the article. 3 months ago they started interrupting podcasts with a prompt to review (the app). https://www.theverge.com/2021/11/19/22791968/apple-podcasts-star-score-review-prompt https://www.theverge.com/2021/11/19/22791968/apple-podcasts-...
- marcellus23 5y agoThere's nothing in the article to suggest they're interrupting podcasts: > We weren’t able to track down a copy of the prompt ourselves to confirm when and where it appears or what it looks like It sounds more like they just didn't have any in-app prompts before 3 months ago, and then they added them.
- iqanq 5y agoI like the app. I wish that if you tapped on a show's name, you got a complete list of episodes. The way it is now you have to tap the "see all" button.
- newsclues 5y agoApple recently changed the podcast app and made it worse. I’ve lost many downloaded podcasts because they jammed in features at the expense of reliability.
- nereye 5y agoWhat’s worse is that even ‘See All’ does not list all episodes, e.g. am seeing it go back only as far as episode, say, 48. And the UI does not have affordances for navigating easily in that scenario either.
- tjpnz 5y agoIs submitting reviews for actual podcasts a new thing; or were such reviews previously removed? I'm having a hard time understanding what point the author's trying to make.
- scim-knox-twox 5y agoI feel like there was a lot of discussion on this topic a few years back.
- concinds 5y agoApple Podcasts prompts you to review it on the App Store, but apparently only while listening to a podcast. I believe this is the only Apple app that prompts for reviews; and it's the new behavior that's responsible for bringing the rating from 1.8 to 4.9. Strange that the article doesn't mention this. https://www.theverge.com/2021/11/19/22791968/apple-podcasts-star-score-review-prompt https://www.theverge.com/2021/11/19/22791968/apple-podcasts-... > I wondered if maybe this was a common confusion with podcast apps, where listeners think they’re reviewing a podcast instead of the app itself. But no, I didn’t see that obvious pattern when I checked reviews for other top podcast apps in the App Store. Almost every review on competing apps was a review of the apps themselves. > Apple confirmed to The Verge that it’s using a new prompt but claims it’s nothing out of the ordinary. “With iOS 15.1 released last month, Apple Podcasts began prompting listeners to leave a rating and review just like most third-party apps — using the standard Rating & Review prompt available to all developers,” wrote an Apple spokesperson who only agreed to comment if they were not named.
- teekert 5y agoMaybe they are feeling the heat from [0], an actually free podcast index. (For supporting free(dom) apps: [1]). [0] https://podcastindex.org/ https://podcastindex.org/ [1] https://podcastindex.org/apps https://podcastindex.org/apps
- Maxburn 5y agoNice mention. ALSO they have their own decentralized mastodon instance; https://podcastindex.social/web/home https://podcastindex.social/web/home These developers are pretty interactive and responsive there. Lots going on around podcasting 2.0 right now.
- janandonly 5y agoI don't use the official Apple Podcasts app anymore at all. My favorites now are Breez [1] for all Value4Value[2] podcasts, and Overcast[3] for all podcast that haven't upgraded yet. [1] https://breez.technology/technology.html https://breez.technology/technology.html [2] https://podcastindex.org/podcast/value4value https://podcastindex.org/podcast/value4value [3] https://overcast.fm/ https://overcast.fm/
- LoveMortuus 5y agoWhat is it that these apps offer that the default Google podcast doesn't? Does it give better discovery options? I'm asking because, I use Google podcast, but I use it to listen to podcasts that I already know exist, using the app itself to find interesting new podcasts hasn't been very successful for me.
- janandonly 5y agoYes and yes. > What is it that these apps offer that the default Google podcast doesn't? For one, donating directly to the podcaster herself instead of to Spotify/Google/Anchor/Apple or whoever else runs the app. > Does it give better discovery options? Sort of, yes. Let me explain: All podcasting apps rely on the Apple podcast index. [1] One of the very early podcasters, Adam Curry, was worried about this index being run by Apple, who may or may not one day decide to censor the index or ask money for it. So he set up his own [2]. [1] http://adam.curry.com/html/PODFATHER-g6c2RMsVnxgTdZ2DgHlVfMvzg4jqS1.html http://adam.curry.com/html/PODFATHER-g6c2RMsVnxgTdZ2DgHlVfMv... [2] https://podcastindex.org/ https://podcastindex.org/
- 7sidedmarble 5y agoI'm curious then, how does this work with platform exclusives? Are they entered into these databases?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lelandfe 5y ago
- taspeotis 5y agoThis is old news https://www.macrumors.com/2021/11/19/podcasts-rating-prompt-app-store-reviews/ https://www.macrumors.com/2021/11/19/podcasts-rating-prompt-... The article contributes nothing new to our understanding: > But in the nearly three months since I helped point this out at The Verge and brought it directly to Apple’s attention, the only thing that’s changed is Apple Podcasts’ rating has gone up from 4.7 to 4.9 — and each of its five little gray star marks is now completely filled in, for a five-star rating overall.
- nmstoker 5y agoMaybe they found a way to push for reviews from the people who answer Amazon product questions saying they don't know? Or they got people in from Wells Fargo to advise them on meeting targets? More seriously, isn't it time that app stores were pushed to define common industry standards and those were enforced by external parties. In other spheres of life, we typically don't let companies mark their own homework when in a position of power like this (at least not all the time). Apple and Google are known for their unreasonable behaviour this way, be it lacking transparency with rules, ignoring appeals from devs and users, and letting malicious software in (last one is admittedly a tough call at times)
- arbitrage 5y ago> we typical[ly] don't let companies mark their own homework when in a position of power like this In the United States, yes we do.
- herghost 5y agoIt might have been my failure, but I couldn't get the Podcast app to list and play all my outstanding podcasts in the order that they'd arrived. So I had to be regularly fiddling with it to switch what I was listening to rather than just letting a timeline of content play out. Like I said, maybe it was my failure, but it seems like an odd thing to not be really obviously available to a user of a podcast app. Overcast is my app of choice now, and I subscribe to it since it's such a great app.
- hericium 5y agoI also experienced this feature.
- blakesterz 5y agoI found the same thing. I forget which update it was, but I used Podcast for years, then one day it got redesigned and it no longer made sense. I tried a few others, and Overcast was the one I found that "just worked".
- barney54 5y agoExact same story with me. For years the Apple Podcast app was fine and I had no issues with it. One day I didn’t understand the redesign, switched to Overcast and I have been happy ever since.
- toxik 5y agoMy suspicion is that it’s the watch that drove the redesign. It only synchronizes podcasts while charging. The watch is also impossible to listen to podcasts with for this reason.
- easton 5y agoThere's a good reason for this though; when transferring data to the watch, Apple has two options: Bluetooth, which goes at a maximum of 2Mbps, or Wi-Fi/LTE, which destroys the battery. You can test this by using the "Download with Apple Watch" feature in Spotify, where it takes hours to do 100 songs unless you disable the Bluetooth on your phone, but then the battery drains on the watch. As such, the only way to do podcast transfers in a reasonable amount of time is to do them on the charger, because you probably wouldn't want to have your watch die half way through the day because several of your subscriptions released a bunch of long episodes. This is also why I don't listen to audio from the watch pretty much ever.
- indymike 5y agoIt's good to be the king. At least part of me wants to believe there's going to be a meeting at Apple about how we can ship and app with a less than two star app.
- tristanc 5y agoCould somebody please explain to me how TicketMaster on the iOS App Store manages to supposedly have 1.8M(?!) reviews averaging 4.8 stars when all of the written reviews I’ve scrolled through have 1 or 2 stars? Do they trick people into reviewing the app favorably or something else? I had a terrible experience with their app and don’t understand how they’re managing to game the App Store rating system.
- jamil7 5y agoYou can reset your rating with a new release so maybe it's something to do with that, I've never actually tried it but maybe it keeps the total review count but resets the average stars?
- Sosh101 5y agoThen that's a very deceptive model on the part of Apple, since then it's certainly not "4.8 stars from 1.8M ratings".
- jamil7 5y agoI might be wrong, I've never actually tried it, last time I looked the explanation on how it works is unclear which is pretty on-brand for Apple-Developer relations.
- mabub24 5y agoTicketMaster might actually compete with Comcast for the most universally reviled company in NA. It's as if every single component of their business has been designed to piss off their customers. I'm aware that, for TM, it's much more that event planners and venues are their prioritized customers, but I'm at a point in my life where I will refuse to go to any event that uses TM. TM could easily make their systems work better, but they just feel no need to out of naked greed and market capture.
- inasmuch 5y agoI work for a ticketing company (not TM) and can confirm this is 100% true. We are completely beholden to our clients and as long as I've been working here our entire roadmap has been a reactionary, ever-growing list of demands from clients and potential clients with little to no consideration of the customer experience. The whole industry operates on exclusivity of inventory (in this regard, Comcast and other ISPs are quite apt comparisons), so it simply does not matter how much customers hate the company selling the tickets, because their only options are to buy from them, buy at a higher price from scalpers (or the increasingly popular scalping platforms), or not attend the event at all. I think you're pretty rare in your commitment to the third option.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoRecently found this app was hoarding 40gb of podcasts when I maybe open it twice a year.
- bitexploder 5y agoA friend had it but out and burn 400 GB bandwidth for like 3 GB of podcasts. Dumpster fire of an app.
- mrtksn 5y agoFTA: > That’s right: they’re reviews of the podcasts themselves, not the Apple Podcasts app. Yep, this happens all the time. People often rate the message and not the messenger. If you think about it, kind of make sense since many people would not understand who provides what in the experience. I wouldn't be surprised if Google Chrome has 5 start reviews about that great website they visited or 1 start reviews about website that was not nice to them. To put yourself in their shoes, consider how do you review a shopping experience in a supermarket. Are the low quality products the shop owners fault? Are the high quality products shop owners success? You might think that the answer is straightforward but it is not, some shops simply sell stands where the producers put their products and in other shops they are very involved through the whole experience. Time that with the recommended pattern of "Ask for a review when something good happens in your app" and you have a glee of happy users recommending the experience to everyone.
- martini333 5y agoThis is exactly what happens. I have listened to a few podcast asking for a 5-star review on Apple Podcast. Most people don't know the difference.
- hapidjus 5y agoI'd say the answer is still straightforward, at least in the example you gave. To me as a customer it doesn't matter if it's the store owner who is stocking the stands or if they rent them out. I walked in to your store, handed you my money and received the item from you. If you're not vetting the producers that's on you.
- smokey_circles 5y agoNo, that's on you. There's no standard store operational model. Some are whole chains, others are just endpoints. The onus is on you to check your assumptions if they contain something important (like what you're expecting)
- mrtksn 5y agoSee, it's kind of a trick question. I ask you to rate the shopping experience but you rate the product you bought. Out of nowhere, a really bad shop can have very good reviews because some customers really enjoy the Mars bars. There's really no mystery in the Podcasts app getting very good reviews, people really love the experience even if the app itself might not be that good. It's just like happy Tesco customers that enjoy their Pringles and not nerding over the store design. From customers perspective, the store design and the Pringles are not separate experiences.
- azarovalex 5y agoActually, there is a simple explanation – Podcasts app now shows the review popup inside the app itself. iOS devs can control when to show it and most probably they do it right after you submit a 5-star review to a podcast. If you've just submitted a 5-star review there is a good chance that you will submit it to the app itself as well. That's why review examples in the article are not about the app itself, some people think that they are reviewing a podcast. Note that you don't even need to update the app to enable this popup review feature, this can be done with A/B tests at any moment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- api 5y agoI switched to Downcast when they removed the ability to really archive podcasts, since that was obviously a move toward the dark pattern of locking everyone into streaming. Downcast is pretty nice. It's not as polished as the Podcast app but I actually like it better and it works just fine. Also lets you archive.
- imwillofficial 5y agoIf a lot of 5 star reviews come from mistaken reviews for podcasts, should apple reap some of that glory for curating their recommendation system so well? If it was garbage, the app would be rated 1 star.
- darkwater 5y agoJust like many product reviews on Amazon get 1 star or 5 stars depending on how fast the delivery time was... Although lately the phenomena has decreased, at least it's the feeling that I have when I periodically lose some of the time of my life to smile while reading "funny" products reviews on Amazon.
- Bud 5y agoCan someone please explain why anyone—anyone at all—would care at all, in any way, about this story? Why did The Verge even write it? And why was that bad decision compounded by posting it on HN?
- makecheck 5y agoI kind of wish the world would just move on from “star reviews”...they have so many problems that make them impossible to depend on, and yet psychologically it is hard to ignore whatever they say! They doom good products, promote bad ones, and generally do not force reviewers to even write something relevant to the product (cases like this). On top of that, they can literally be “bought” by the thousands. Worse, stores do not encourage customers to follow proper channels for things like support or feedback. People clearly can’t figure out any other way to communicate so they use that giant “review” text field to vent about anything and everything. What’s better? Remove all reviews. Publish real numbers, like: downloads, time spent using, time installed on device (I would love to see scam apps fail once everyone can see they have an “average time on device” of 30 seconds). And, make proper support channels much more obvious on store pages (not to mention, enough gatekeeping: let developers interact with their customers much more directly).
- jgust 5y agoThis would be excellent to see, but I fear it's in direct conflict with the incentives of running an app store.
- iKnowKungFoo 5y agoI left the Apple podcasts app once they changed the way they ordered episodes that I've not yet heard and lost my place on a number of podcasts. I was suggested the Overcast app and it took me three days to completely convert to it and delete the Apple app from my phone. I've even paid the annual subscription to turn off ads, which aren't noticeable anyway, just to support the developer for understanding how (I feel) people actually want to listen to podcasts. https://overcast.fm/ https://overcast.fm/