14 ms·
‘Fix My Computer’ Cry Echos on Social Media; Air Force CIO Responds
- alexpotato 5y ago“It has been the absolute most frustrating thing in the world since the [Department of the Air Force] … made OWA crazy locked down,” said Oliver Parsons, chief of esports and virtual fitness for the Department of the Air Force The above made me stop and ask "The Air Force has an esports group??"
- jrootabega 5y agoRecruiting
- HideousKojima 5y agoIt's part of their recruitment efforts IIRC. Kind of like the America's Army video game
- encryptluks2 5y agoSort of how coaches and educational staff will get a nice vacation to let the Army recruiters come in and try to convince a teenager to donate thier life to the military.
- imwillofficial 5y agoMcAfee HBSS and Tanium, the worst products ever. Back room deals all the way.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoWow: "1 hour and 20 minutes from logging in, to Outlook opening" - getting a computer or network that bad almost requires active effort.
- black_puppydog 5y agoI clicked through to the linkedin post [0] and airforcemag was clearly not reading this carefully. Not sure how they missed that, but Mr Kanaan never once in his letter wrote "Fix My computer" as is stated in the airforcemag title (and in quotes) but rather every. single. line of this letter ends with "Fix our computers." Quite a different tone. He seems desperate, but he's not self centered. [0]: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/michaeljkanaan_technology-future-innovation-activity-6891726752759074816-2qCv/ https://www.linkedin.com/posts/michaeljkanaan_technology-fut...
- illnewsthat 5y agoThe article does mention that: “ Each barrage ending with the same invocation: “Fix our computers.””
- rzzzt 5y agoThe title is the part that does not match the quote, and I agree, it does sound a little bit different that way.
- ChicagoBoy11 5y agoNot to be missed in the article: The Air Force has a "chief of esports and virtual fitness"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rdtwo 5y agoDoes he just get paid to turn on and off his computer because apparently that takes all day
- ChicagoBoy11 5y agohence the fitness part of it /s
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThe US army has sponsored development of games quite a lot; I remember a friend of mine who was really into America's Army, that must've been 15 years ago now.
- ceedan 5y agoThat game was really solid
- machiaweliczny 5y agoPlayed it as well. Good stuff.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoThe US military is very serious about its recruiting.
- thatguy0900 5y agoThat game was pretty fun, to play as the medic class you actually had to sit in a first aid lecture with a test afterwords. I remember the lecture actually being really entertaining and educational.
- noahth 5y ago
- codyb 5y agoAlternatively. The USAF are a bargain for a more stable world with less regional conflicts. While the Middle East is a disaster, and there are many easy to point out missteps on its record that truly are awful and horrific. It's also currently the world's pre-eminent power in a history dominated by strong militaries and during its tenure as such the world has unequivocally been more stable and peaceful than it's ever been statistically. The access to free trade over more porous borders has lifted billions of people out of poverty. Europe hasn't been this peaceful ever as far as I can tell. Every major democracy in the world exists under America's umbrella. Certainly it's not all roses, Iraq was probably just a decade of war crimes, but we can see what happens as soon as we leave places like Afghanistan (wasn't perfect, but was certainly a lot better a year ago than today), Syria (Kurds abandoned have to re-align with Russia, Turkish troops move in), Philippines (never even left after Duterte quickly reconsidered given China's encroachments in the S China Sea). Pulling the US military into a more isolationist or more equal to others stance would almost certainly result in more regional conflicts around the world as the stakes go from "hey we definitely won't win this thing" to "hey, we've got a fighting shot here".
- gnramires 5y agoI would support a more pro-active humanistic military, but many humanitarian causes have been left to the United Nations. The US knows its legitimacy (as well as political support) will come into question in those scenarios. How about we strengthen UN instead?
- codyb 5y agoI'm certainly very pro working cooperatively with other Democratic nations to secure a more just and peaceful future less dominated by a singe nation state. The problem is, alliances fray (Turkey, Belarus, Britain, the United States... we've all had our issues with current alliances and treaties in recent history alone). And that gets problematic and very hairy. The other issue is, a single state dominance is prone to being coopted by less than benign actors and we've certainly seen that in the US I believe, especially given our invasion of Iraq. So there's no cure alls on these things unfortunately. As a general practice I believe brining more members under our umbrella and strengthening the organizations like NATO and the UN which can act as a cooperative unit and not as a unilateral actor is a positive.
- yabones 5y ago> Currently the service uses both McAfee and Tanium software packages to scan and protect service-issued endpoints like laptops. The problem isn't hardware, it's that they're using the worst antivirus known to mankind. It's not throwing money at the problem, it's about what can be removed.
- iforgotpassword 5y agoThey should switch to Norton to make some crypto money on the side.
- 3np 5y agoWat?
- nucleardog 5y agoFew articles floating around from about a month ago, this is one: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29795910 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29795910
- 3np 5y agoOh wow. And here I thought they were one of the relatively clean ones among the crowd of McAfee and Avast!. Agreed with the top comment there that the whole industry is reeking. Seems like the only reasonable one is Windows Defender, with the only Linux alternative being ClamAV (non-shady but questionable if it's effective at all for a workstation)
- unionpivo 5y agoIt's there mostly for the checkboxes on copliance, but it's not that bad, compared to others.
- tanjtanjtanj 5y agoThe Norton product that provides the services here is made and sold by a different company than the one shipping crypto-mining software.
- Havoc 5y agoI’m impressed with the person that waited over an hour to get into outlook. With determination like that no enemy stands a chance
- Tookl 5y agoEnemy has to just overload outlook.
- iamben 5y agoI'd love to know WHY it takes over an hour to load Outlook? Can anyone enlighten me as to what takes the time? Is it connecting to something and periodically backing off when it can't? Scanning something? What?
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoIf I were to guess and remember my time working at a 'hot desking' company, it's because on login, the user's profile will be copied from a central server onto the local system. I found out this is a thing when Chrome and Firefox started to put their files in the user's home directory by default. If that has to traverse a network - and who knows where all that data is coming from or how fast the internet connection is - that can take a long time.
- iamben 5y agoInteresting. So potentially downloading the entire browser cache each time? Goodness.
- Yoric 5y agoI remember "fixing" the university's computers by preventing the browser cache from being downloaded. at every Windows startup. That was maybe 15 years ago?
- JackFr 5y agoEven better - Java devs who use the default settings for Maven will have their entire local repo copied over the network. At my company people would remotely log in on Sunday evenings to avoid the hou long wait while a few hundred gigs get copied across the network. Why not chnage the location of the local repo, you ask? Of course our machines are locked down and we have no access to the local drive...
- mysterydip 5y agoThe crux of the issue is in these four words: "lowest price technically acceptable." In the name of saving money, good intentions cause more waste in time and money.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI disagree. I think the crux of the issue is that modern computing is garbage. https://www.google.com/search?q=frustrating https://www.google.com/search?q=frustrating My, a lot of those images involve computers for some reason...
- nexuist 5y agoThe defense budget is over $700 billion. They should just buy or build two million Chromebooks and be done with it. Any native apps can be converted to SaaSs that run on nationally managed DoD infrastructure and everyone can do their jobs without needing to deal with this security BS.
- mysterydip 5y agoI agree with you, but that's the battle everyone is fighting. They have to do it with one hand tied behind their cost-effective back.
- metabagel 5y agoThe military should evaluate wholesale replacement of spinning hard drives with SSD, rather than replacing many thousands of computers.
- praash 5y agoThat won't solve the problem, unless you're assuming that it's perfectly normal for modern applications to use disk space as working memory.
- Ancapistani 5y agos/normal/typical, and I’d say your statement is truthful.
- donkeyd 5y agoYeah, that sounds like a great idea in theory. In practice, this is horrible. You need to get people to bring in their laptops, wait until the HDD is switched for an SSD and then leave with a laptop that isn't new, but behaves as new. Then you need to switch laptops again in a year or two, because the rest of the hardware is now written off. The cost of a new laptop is negligible in the grand scheme (~3m employees, 1k per laptop = 3B on a 700B budget) and saves them from a logistical nightmare. Replacing all the HDDs bij SSD is a perfect example of being 'penny wise but pound foolish'.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoWindows security bloatware can still bring a system to its knees with an SSD.
- mschuster91 5y ago> She said a service culture of stoically persevering in the face of impossible odds didn’t do anyone any favors. “If we suffer in silence it doesn’t get fixed,” she said. And that's the point where IT should go, run a filter in the inventory list for all models < 2018 and have local IT service desks replace them. If you know your users are of the type to not cause any trouble with IT due to culture, you go the other way around to bypass that culture.
- Cromation 5y agoI wish it was that easy as she stated. You cant just tell Comm to get you a new laptop. They will laugh in your face, unless you are like her a high ranking officer. Typically Comm will hold their budget close to the chest and buying only big project items until the fiscal year is up and then they buy a bunch of crap laptops to complete their budget or a bunch of gamer chairs, or fancy desks, some of which just sit in storage and waste away. As a typical enlisted airman though you will never get a brand new laptop ordered, even for a mission critical device, unless a high ranking officer is involved.
- the_only_law 5y agoThe military has the most interesting issues with tech. My brother asked me for help getting to a website to work at one point. If I recall correctly there was a slew of issues, for one, the certificate on their Exchange server was expired, but more frustratingly, the site he needed to access seemed to use some sort of TLS version or feature that didn’t work in IE. That’d be fine and all, as they worked in other browsers, but what didn’t work in other browsers was the entire interface implemented as a Java Applet.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoJust last year I was working on a defense project that is still in development that uses a Java Applet as the front end. If this is an on-Friday somebody is probably working on it right now. Imagine implementing a new Java Applet today?
- stult 5y agoProbably mutual TLS. There is a whole completely unofficial website that just walks people through debugging issues with CAC authentication…
- pdimitar 5y ago> Knausenberger said the ACC team would “streamline [existing programs] into one endpoint solution that meets our security, operations, and UX needs.” I've read sci-fi books that are more realistic than this. Only the wildest cyber-crime novels portray the military network systems and administration ops as competent. When watching "Alias" a long time ago, I had to laugh every time I saw an instantly responding laptop from sleep that basically took 1 second to show a login screen (of course they used Linux so it is actually possible, especially if they picked laptops with good compatibility). And in light of Spectre/Meltdown and the complete hardware and software security circus that we've been witnessing for years (a new CVE in a popular software on a regular basis, anyone?), I also have my doubts that the military control their physical computer supply chain that well and from "trusted" vendors, but who knows. They love doing it, so that part maybe they got right. Doesn't change the fact that they have thousands of machines that are potentially back-doored on the hardware level, even below ring zero. -- Needless to say I completely agree with the article. Like 1h to just log-in, WTF?! And another 20 minutes to just send an email?! I have a laptop with a Celeron J4155 CPU and 12GB RAM and a SATA III SSD that starts Manjaro + XFCE in 10-12 seconds. A browser and mail client are fully started and ready to use another 10-15 seconds later. The machine doesn't lag on any of the casual tasks that I do on it, unless I play a 4K YouTube video. It costed me exactly $170 on the second-hand market, and has a very acceptable 3000x2000 display as well. Maybe the military should look into those laptops.
- pwr-electronics 5y ago> Knausenberger said the ACC team would “streamline [existing programs] into one endpoint solution that meets our security, operations, and UX needs.” Sounds like they're going to get the F-35 of antivirus software. Having multiple programs might not be the problem, but consolidating to just one is an easy sell for a lucrative non-solution.
- pdimitar 5y agoSecurity should be practiced in depth. Having only one program that hackers / crackers can write uber-specialized scripts to target seems like an awful idea. I mean, what if they just bought their people budget laptops with 8-12GB RAM and an SSD, lol. Will be much cheaper over a course of 3-5 years. Or have good network ops and not allow viruses inside in the first place. A lot of corps have super paranoid (and actually good) teams doing that.
- johnklos 5y agoWhy aren't aircraft made as simple to fly as cars are to drive? Why aren't regular people allowed to just get in an aircraft and start flying after a couple of hours of practice? We see no problem in assuming that people need the lowest-common-denominator operating system in computer to suit the people instead of the people learning how to use a proper computer, though. If something is mission critical, then it should NOT be running on Windows. And if people find it a little harder to use because it takes a little bit of learning, so be it. "It's not as simple as that!" Bullshit. If something matters, it's worth extra energy to do it right. In reality, it's only extra energy at first. Once people learn how to use it, it's LESS energy because it works, it works the first time, and it works properly, unlike Windows.
- pc86 5y ago> Why aren't regular people allowed to just get in an aircraft and start flying after a couple of hours of practice? I mean, they are. Student pilots often solo at 8-10 hours total flight time.
- slingnow 5y agoFirst of all, that's on the low end of the spectrum, so "often" is a stretch. Second, that only takes into account seat time, not all of the other study required to understand the instruments and other assorted knowledge.
- pc86 5y agoIt certainly falls into the category of "a couple hours of practice" - reading the PHAK or FAR/AIM doesn't qualify as "practice" to any reasonable person.
- nexuist 5y agoYes, let's put the incompetent buffoons who thought installing McAfee on every government computer was a good idea in charge of their rolling own Linux distro. That sure would solve all of these problems.
- joshstrange 5y agoI will never understand when a company/government entity pay people a high salary then give them crap or low-end hardware. You should be maxing out dev machines and the rest of the company should rarely see a spinner or have to wait on their tech. It's a huge waste of time that you are paying for. I once calculated how much time I wasted waiting on slow processes at a job and then multiplied it by my effective hourly rate... I could have bought multiple maxed out MBPs with the money they lost, it's ridiculous. Also it's not just the time they spend waiting, it absolutely slaughters productivity, focus, and motivation.
- projectileboy 5y agoOne big problem is misaligned incentives. At most big orgs, you have an infosec dept with authority to put all kinds of virus scanning, etc etc on every computer in the org. They get rewarded if there are no incidents; they do not get penalized if they make your machine impossible to use.
- ninju 5y ago> they do not get penalized if they make your machine impossible to use. An "impossible to use" machine won't have any incidents reported against it
- projectileboy 5y agoExactly.
- pletsch 5y agoWell designed security programs shouldn't slow down your PC. This is a failure on the infosec department. Sysmon/Windows logging can do most of the hardwork with very few resources.
- Macha 5y agoThe same goes for the guy in the purchasing department who gets rewarded for his cost saving measures when he goes for Acer's cheapest laptop with a Pentium and 8GB RAM rather than something with a mid range CPU and 16GB of RAM.
- newaccount2021 5y agoYou cannot fix problems on this scale with moderation or half-measures. You must smash the system and restart. Get rid of Windows, reset the entire chain by moving to Chromebooks. Schools have proven this truth: the only way to deploy to large numbers of transient and unsophisticated users is to go thin-client. That will force the DOD to build scalable networked services. Most of the time, using off-the-shelf services is fine. If DOD can be in AWS then they can also be in GSuite. Everyone will have excuses why everything in .mil needs to be custom or done to some twisted set of DOD requirements, or why Windows is essential. That's fine, the problems will never go away It would not surprise me to learn that NKorea with its in-house linux is able to run IT better than DOD.
- imperialdrive 5y agoYou're probably getting down voted by government contractors that wouldn't like this idea one bit.
- Ensorceled 5y ago> Knausenberger called this “a cultural issue … We need people to call the help desk to complain and order a new laptop when it breaks.” She said a service culture of stoically persevering in the face of impossible odds didn’t do anyone any favors. “If we suffer in silence it doesn’t get fixed,” she said. Apparently all you need to do is call IT and get a new computer! I wonder why none of these service men and women thought of that?
- machiaweliczny 5y agoYou get 90min for coffee time :)
- ferrumfist 5y agoI worked as a helpdesk tech in the USAF years ago. The policy on who gets a new computer if they ask generally comes down to fitting into one of the following criteria: 1. How fucked is the PC? Do we have the skills/time to fix it? 2. Is the person an officer or important civilian? Are they in a leadership role? If a low-ranking airman had a slow laptop, we'd give them advice and tips to speed up the PC and send them on their way unless it was a chronic issue. If it was a high-ranking officer who had a slight performance degradation, we'd replace the PC that day. These weren't codified rules, it was just the culture of our organization and the military in general.
- csours 5y ago"I am not a fish" - Policy is set by people who are not affected by that policy (or affected to a much lesser degree). https://youtu.be/aNDiHSHYI_c?t=796 https://youtu.be/aNDiHSHYI_c?t=796
- Damogran6 5y agoI think there's an intersection between the number of common running processes, the 2 core/4 thread of the common business class Dell, and the additional abstraction layers that applications bring with them these days. I just turned in a 7400 Latitude...the motherboard on it is dated 2018, it was out of production 6 months before it was given to me as a new machine...that was to last 4-5 years. it was out of date on day one and we kept getting them due to lifecycle hardware contracts. Running Teams, Outlook, and a few Chrome tabs was enough to leave the poor mobile i7 running at 100% all day long. I'm certain it resulted in an enterprise cost increase in repair costs due to thermal damage...fans...dust... The exact same system with a fresh Ubuntu install would be quiet and quick...but the layers of policy, software, and workloads keep pushing for more of everything....what Moore gives, Microsoft taketh away...
- yborg 5y agoApparently an enemy just needs to time an attack to happen at 0800 local for whatever regional command is in charge to get an hour or so before HQ can do anything about it :/
- taurath 5y agoLoving that the solution from the CIO of the air force isn’t “we’re going to move our resources into this problem” but “we’re going to ask for more funding so we can tackle this”. Which seems just stupid in its face, but then you realize that almost all of the budgeting is line itemed for specific capabilities. If leadership can’t change resources around to fix such a glaring problem due to legal/budgeting rules, then I’m sorry to say they can’t win a conflict. Pretending corruption isn’t corruption because it is signed into law is one of the great blind spots of America, one on which it will continue to lose in its foreign excursions just like every major conflict it’s been in since I’ve been alive.
- stadium 5y agoWouldn't any competent CIO of a company or government office big enough to need a CIO do the same? Which roadmapped strategic projects are going to get chopped so that this new project can start immediately?
- nexuist 5y agoWhat's the point of all the roadmapped projects if all of them will have 1hr+ startup times? Is the enemy going to wait for squadron commanders to log into Outlook before firing artillery? All of the strategic projects should get chopped until this one is addressed. What is the point of managing IT infrastructure if none of it works.
- stadium 5y agoI'm not so familiar with the military but wouldn't it be up to brass like generals or strategic command to decide if the IT infra upgrades are a threat to combat readiness, and prioritize it accordingly? They can give the CIO budget to do this, but the CIO can't unilaterally decide to do it.
- nexuist 5y agoIt is up to them, but it's the CIO's job to advocate for his employees and convince them to do it. You hire a CIO to be able to advise you on decisions such as this. The CIO isn't expected to be down in the trenches resetting Active Directory accounts or applying group policies, of course.
- Beltiras 5y agoI'm astounded that the military uses Windows at all. It would seem a no-brainer to make everyone use a better protected OS. Which *nix is a fine starting inquiry.
- _fat_santa 5y agoThe "vendorization" of government and government contracting is astounding. I interned for a government contractor back in college and it was floored by some of the decisions being made. Basically we were not allowed to use any free/open source software. The reason is that we couldn't "purchase a support contract" for the thing we were using. Not that we would actually try and buy support, company just wanted the capability of getting support. This drove down to the trivial. I remember we needed a calendar to display a team meetings. There was a kick ass open source calendar that did everything we needed it to. Well we couldn't get it approved because there was no "provided support", I pleaded with them that it's a fucking calendar widget and we don't need support, the response was always "well what if someone has to support this in the future", like lady this isn't some super complicated financial system, it's a fucking calendar. This example repeats itself throughout the industry. The US Govt has the capability to build their own OS, their own security and tech, but they instead choose to engage with a million different vendors to get their job done. It's like a SaaS startup that gets a bunch of subscriptions to software they may or may not use, just on a much larger and grander scale.
- lowbloodsugar 5y agoSure. It's almost as if we live in some kind of dystopian alternative universe where the trillion dollar defense budget is actually just a giant trough for businesses big enough to bribe (sorry, "lobby") government stooges into giving them a cut. I guess in that world, we'd have a lot of PR about having the #1 military, and yet we'd consistently fail at every long term military goal, up to and including basic protection of our allies and meeting promised mutual defense statements. Sure we could invade the odd tropical island and depose a warlord, maybe trade some class A drugs, but actually defending an ally? Oof. It'd be a world where we are, in fact, powerless. The kind of world where we'd say "Russia would be stupid to actually cut off gas to Europe as Europe would have to find another source and then Russia would have no leverage nor market." while at the same time cutting off chip IP to China, who, er, presumably won't develop their own chip IP, and won't become the #1 chip super power, because that's not what the President wants to happen and if it does he'll throw a tantrum and make a pee pee? In that world, the USA is over. The only option the US has for relevance in that world is to go to war with Russia, and bomb that pipeline to Europe while they're at it, just to get Germany off the teat. But it can't. Because "world's #1 military" is just PR. Good job we don't live in that world.
- Someone1234 5y agoThis is clearly the problem: > Currently the service uses both McAfee and Tanium software packages to scan and protect service-issued endpoints like laptops In my experience McAfee alone will do exactly what this thread describes. But you then combine it with another security solution, and you end in on contention hell. They can even scan one another during scans of underlying files/processes unless they're both correctly excluded from one another.
- dbg31415 5y agoNot just an Air Force problem. At every agency I've worked at, people were given sub-par machines. The joke was, "We bill by the hour, don't we?" McCann, AKQA, Digitas... was always standard to give people 5+ year-old laptops, often without even wiping them between staff members. We had one new hire, a junior UX designer, try and screen share with a client only to realize all of the bookmarks were packed with porn sites. I remember in 2018 getting an 11" MacBook Air with 2 GB of RAM on it... as the team lead for a $25M project. Just a total joke. It was on par with what the devs were given. "Be happy they gave you a Mac!" Meanwhile, 50% of the CPU was taken up with some BS security scanning program IT installed that require you be on the company VPN, and junky VPN software that hadn't been updated in 5+ years and only supported like 15 people trying to use it across the whole company... and it seldom worked from clients' offices... the moment I got on-site, my laptop was nothing more than a paperweight. And even if I could log in, all my bandwidth and CPU would be spent trying to backup the computer. And... when I fought for better machines for my staff, at AKQA I was told by the MD, "Just drop it, we aren't going to spend any more money on hardware. You're being obnoxious and there's no benefit." Meanwhile my team was bringing their own external keyboards, mice, and monitors (and dongles) because the company wouldn't supply them. Ever try and design for 4k screens on a 11" MacBook Air with 2 GB of RAM? Ha. Most everyone just resorted to bringing personal equipment when they had to go on-site. It was too painful to use the company-issued junk. It's a lack of understanding. Some bean counter who only uses his computer for checking Facebook all day assumes that nobody else does anything else, so 2 GB of RAM seems like enough. Meanwhile, the IT guys -- who aren't ever client facing and seldom needed the powerful machines -- all got top of the line equipment. "They're IT, they need it..." Um... wait what? At a time when I couldn't get my designers even 1 4k monitor, the IT guys were all rocking dual Apple Cinema Displays. Yay agencies! Anyway look, it's all maddening. Make sure it's easy for anyone to put in for the tools they need to do the job well. Give everyone a new computer ever 3 years, keep staff happy and productive. Give the old ones to charity, get a tax write-off. Seems like that would work fine.
- SCHiM 5y agoWhat I like is many people in this thread summing op exactly which products their companies have installed on their laptops. It's becoming more and more difficult to write an initial access file for every single EDR and anti-virus combination out there. But if you know what you're working towards it's a breeze :)
- dsr_ 5y agoIt's not the hardware, it's the crap that runs on it. You want a system which is secure and usable? Time for the DoD to commission their own OS. "Nobody will know how to use it!" is an objection which can be overcome by training, which is a thing that the armed forces understand. "It won't be compatible with the COTS!" is an advantage, not a disadvantage. "It will take too long and cost too much!" means that they aren't in a good position now and lots of jobs will be created. "Nobody wants to work on a military system!" is technically true, but run it out of NASA or the Department of Energy and develop it with an open source license (effectively a necessity, anyway). Also, it turns out that lots of people and companies will work on things when money is involved.
- snowwrestler 5y agoOS does not matter anymore, it is a commodity. That’s why copies of any OS cost almost nothing at retail. What matters is the configuration of the OS and the network, and most importantly the selection and configuration of applications, whether hosted or client (or both). That is where DoD should focus their resources.
- Jtsummers 5y agoCOTS is useful in many circumstances, it is much quicker to field if you can reuse existing commercial software. The only advantage to being incompatible with COTS is that it would feed the defense contractor industry as they'd need replacements or compatibility layers that some contractor would happily provide for $1 billion and 3 years (with an extra $100 million/year after it's late).
- willcipriano 5y ago> commission their own OS. I'd advise they start with a Linux distro. They can audit/replace components as they go to increase security over time. Even North Korea wasn't paranoid to build it's own OS[0]. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Star_OS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Star_OS
- jasonjayr 5y agoLinux + wireguard-only network interfaces? With physically secured, uncloneable memory cards for each device's/interface's private key?
- rasengan0 5y agoI wonder about IT woes in the other branches, Army, Navy... Space Force? Maybe they could share notes on best practices/trade equipment On Sundays, Space Force gets to login on the "good computers", Navy on Tuesdays Seriously, this sounds like a national security risk or consultant's wet dream. Do other countries run Microsoft too? :-((
- sandworm101 5y agoFor perspective: I work in a difference armed force but with basically the same issue. We once had a problem with soldiers stealing memory sticks from workstations (unclassified systems). Take only one stick and the machine still works. The theft problem goes unnoticed long enough that we cannot nail down who stole what when. Answer: Give the computers only one memory stick. Thefts will then be noticed quickly. Now, almost two decades later, we are still stuck with that bonehead decision. I requested an upgrade, an extra 4gb of ram on a "new" windows workstation. "Sorry sir, but we don't have any 8gb sticks and are not allowed to give you 2x4gb." I know of a military computer (simulation display, 4x4K screens) running off a single 64gb stick because they couldn't bring themselves to install 4x16 or even 2x32.
- xnyan 5y agoAnd you lose the 2x bandwidth increase you get from using two sticks of RAM. Oof.
- pushcx 5y agoI had something similar happen to me at IBM in the late 90s. I came to my cubicle one morning to find the PC case slightly ajar. I set the monitor aside and opened it. The sole 8 MB RAM stick was gone. I reported it to my boss who explained that someone would've taken it because getting an upgrade was an impossible bureaucratic feat, but getting a fix was trivial. Probably I was picked because I was obviously the youngest person in the office, so I must not have any power. I did indeed have a repaired PC the next day, though.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThis was a technique for getting necessary goods back in the USSR. You frequently couldn't get things on demand that your workplace could so if a lightbulb went out at home you'd steal one from work.
- lostlogin 5y agoI spent way too long trying to work out how a USB memory stick being absent would prevent system usage, and why that would be a thing. Time for coffee.
- salamanderman 5y agoI'm sure the spinning disks are encrypted by some 3rd party software as well. When my old job did that my laptop's bootup time suddenly went up to 30 minutes.
- causality0 5y agoGovernment IT expenditures are insane. At work I have an i7 and 32GB of RAM with a spinning hard disk chaining the whole workstation to the ground. Booting up, logging in, and launching a browser takes over fifteen minutes at my last count, most of which is waiting for it to become responsive again after launching Edge. Frankly I'd love an explanation as to why Windows 7 works just fine on a hard drive but Windows 10 staggers around like it's been shot.
- toast0 5y ago> Frankly I'd love an explanation as to why Windows 7 works just fine on a hard drive but Windows 10 staggers around like it's been shot. Windows 7 had an independent QA team, and Windows 10 did not. I'd guess that some Microsoft developers and testers for 7 had SSDs, but most had spinning disks; but during the 10 development, most developers were using SSDs and neglected to test with spinning hard drives. It's terrible, and doesn't make sense. When 7 booted, especially if you didn't have a lot of ram, it would thrash the hard drive for a while, but once the update service and windows defender got fully started and calmed down, you'd be good to go. From what I can tell, Windows 10 never stops thrashing the drive, and whatever it's up to ruins performance for anything else you want to do with the drive.
- causality0 5y agoI really need to look into whether there's an ecosystem of customized Win7 builds with ongoing user-created security patches. I'm so weary of hating my operating system.
- Uhhrrr 5y ago> “USAF says we need top talent cyber warriors,” he continued, enumerating the many barriers to competing with the private sector for such individuals. “Let’s say we successfully do that, and let’s assume we can cut through the bureaucracy/policy and assign them meaningful work that keeps them engaged and allows them the autonomy to move fast. The hardware alone will cause them to leave.” I'd imagine the kind of people who get Linux running on a toaster would be up for getting an Outlook-compatible email client running on a toaster-equivalent PC.
- gopher_space 5y agoI'd also imagine the kind of people who get Linux running on a toaster aren't super interested in hardcore top-down power structures and shouty bosses.
- wildrhythms 5y agoThe pay is also horrendous compared to other IT jobs at similarly large organizations.
- huijzer 5y ago"U.S. Air Force Airman 1st Class Wesley Carrow, 52nd Communications Squadron client systems technician” Had to read that twice
- zelon88 5y agoFederal government needs to do something about the technical debt of their lifers. Many federal IT departments simply lie low and hope that their project/department gets folded into something bigger with a team who actually knows modern tech. The problem is they all are in the same boat and there is no actual "wonder team" that could ever possibly save them.
- the__alchemist 5y agoHackers - is there a good way to diagnose or fix this without a USAF comm admin account? Ie find out specifically what services are doing it? Some context: - It takes 20-30 minutes to go from login to having excel or outlook up - Opening a program like Outlook, Chrome etc takes on the order of minutes once booted up/settled - Regular problems regarding permissions, popups that take minutes to close, licenses for things like Adobe etc - If you call comm, they blame it on Sq leadership not buying faster computers - Substantial latency on every action - Each computer is often shared by a rotation of ~30 people, which may contribute to the issue - I harbor suspicions DoD comm leadership has been compromised by a foreign power I've worked around our scheduling and training software being useful by deploying a webapp used in an unofficial context. The AF dumped an updated to the official software recently that made it go from bad to unusable, and now I get new account requests every week. One approach - not ideal: Non-DoD computers on squadron Wi-Fi. Can't connect to network drives etc, but is a lifesaver for one off mission planning products. Or get whatever queep you can at home before coming in.
- motohagiography 5y agoThis is a windows issue. I have had a lot of public sector clients, and rules have prevented me from doing a forensic analysis on the machines they provision, either MSFT's products are so egregious and unusable that we just pretend to use them, or the more plausible idea that corporate IT groups are using enterprise laptop fleets to run bitcoin mining.
- andrewflnr 5y agoThey're talking about "capital investments" and only talking about process failures on the user side. Nothing will change.
- blunte 5y agoLinux (or openbsd?). Hire current critical open source contributors. Give them a general direction and some freedom, with 6 and 12 month goals. Do this also with security researchers and developers. DO NOT CONTRACT typical approved suppliers. Those are the non-technical leeches bleeding the public coffers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]