9 ms·
US Special Operations Command picks Anduril to lead counter-drone in $1B deal
- jvanderbot 5y agoScrappy, highly productive, and technically deep people all around that org. Congrats to them!
- Mizza 5y ago
- jvanderbot 5y agoI'm not aware of a single weapon being developed there, esp not for use against people. https://www.anduril.com/work https://www.anduril.com/work
- Mizza 5y agoYou see the words "US Special Operations" in the title, right? You think they're organizing picnics? Techno-Eichmanns.
- alistairSH 5y agoThe first product listed does target classification.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wonderwonder 5y agoGood, would be nice to see spacex style startups start to win contracts for the military. Reduce cost, break up the boeing / lockheed / northrop / etc. lock on hardware contracts and optimally produce new dynamic ideas.
- colechristensen 5y agoThey have always been lots of startups and small companies in defense, but very often focusing on one very specific thing leveraged by a main contractor that interacts with the government. For example a company of a dozen people that make just a laser sensor which is then integrated into defense products. What would be nice is more like defense contract interaction as a service. How to navigate the defense contract acquisition and compliance environment is hard and boring and part of why defense systems actually work and why they’re so expensive.
- FredPret 5y agoMilitary contracting will always be frightfully hard. Generals have to make judgement calls about what will work in the next conflict - talk about incomplete information - while the future enemy’s preparations and even identity is unknown. Then this has to be translated into something that can slot into existing military systems. To say nothing of political and career considerations, moving budgets, revolutionary new ideas that will come along, training and culture. And if they get it wrong, the bad guy wins the next war.
- ren_engineer 5y ago>What would be nice is more like defense contract interaction as a service it's called bribing politicians and generals
- dmoy 5y agoYes exactly. There's entire classes of contracts reserved exclusively for small companies and startups even. Many exist only because of the constant pipeline of SBIR/STTR money.
- systemvoltage 5y agoOne of my best buddies is a mid-level exec at Boeing/Lockheed/Northrop. I just met him a week ago and we had a discussion about the utter waste of Tax Payer dollars in these companies. He was getting compensation beyond his contributions (par for the course in large corporations), but his job was to make sure billable hours continue to exceed the budget - like a boiling frog, projects continue to get delayed bit-by-bit and after 10 years you realize that your program is 3x over budget (F-35 Program?). I want SV/Texas enterpreneurship to completely dismantle the MIC and start afresh. Even if you disagree with defense applications and its ramifications, simply from ROI perspective (tax payer dollars), instead of increasing military budget, we should be asking how can we do more with current budget. Or even cut down the budget and expect 2x more productivity from these fat military contractors with moats like no other.
- cm2012 5y agoI'm just stoked we live in a time where companies are named after stuff from Lord of the Rings. It does seem like it's all war stuff though (aptly fitting?) Anduril - Aragon's sword after it was reforged, also called "Flame of the West". Palantir - One of the seeing stones, originally made by men but corrupted by Sauron to drive people to despair who used it. Ominous TBH for an intelligence company.
- thizzbuzz 5y ago
- boeingUH60 5y agoThere's Mithril Capital Management, the VC firm. Valar Ventures, another VC firm. And they all share one thing in common; Peter Thiel as a co-founder or investor.
- omarhaneef 5y agoDon't forget elf on a shelf.
- Victerius 5y agoAren't Tolkien's proper nouns copyrighted?
- harshreality 5y agoCopyright doesn't apply to created proper nouns. They're too short. Maybe some extreme example might be considered copyrightable, but generally it's a work or creative design, something that has meaning in itself, that's copyrightable. A proper noun without context means next to nothing. What is copyrighted is a character, or potentially a detailed fictional entity behind the proper noun. If you make a story about a character with similar identifiable traits to Harry Potter, for instance, that violates Rowling's copyright on the character. Even if your character isn't named Harry Potter, but using the same name would make the case super easy to win. They could be registered as trademarks, but then the estate would have to show that the use of the trademark was confusing or deceptive. I don't see how it could be, unless someone believes we live in Middle Earth, or unless Tolkien's estate used those names for companies (which would have to do things, not just be paper or shell companies) or products. They'd still have to show that the other companies' use of the names was confusing or deceptive; if the estate's companies or products weren't in the tech space, that might be difficult.
- bpodgursky 5y agoWhile I would be thrilled to not need any counter-drone military spending at all (there should be an international initiative to ban automated military weapons), if have to spend billions to counter them... I feel safer when the contracts aren't going to Boeing.
- credit_guy 5y ago> there should be an international initiative to ban automated military weapons You think the Houthis will agree to that?
- bpodgursky 5y agoThe Houthis improvise with existing technology but don't have any real manufacturing capacity. Restrictions on the underlying drone tech would be effective for now. Longer-term, as the technology becomes easier to DIY... if it became unavoidable, it would not be fun, but I am confident the right coalition of the willing could align the Houthis with international weaponry guidelines.
- jabl 5y agoWasn't there this crazy bloke from New Zeeland that made his own DIY cruise missile? Just for fun, apparently, but he got into trouble with the authorities when they found out?
- snowgrove 5y agoYep, that’s Bruce Simpson. He still uploads regularly on his YouTube channel, mostly about RC planes and NZ drone regulation: https://youtu.be/o10FzfI4zLA https://youtu.be/o10FzfI4zLA
- snowgrove 5y ago>Restrictions on the underlying drone tech would be effective for now. RC planes have been around for decades and are mechanically very simple. High-performance quadcopters and their component parts and widely available on sites like Ali Express. Everything that’s difficult to DIY in a modern UAV- microchips, gyros, cameras, radios- are necessary component of any regular smartphone. This genie isn’t going back in the bottle.
- ttul 5y agoIf you’re interested in some deep academic thought on the topic of AI in warfare, I highly recommend Berkeley’s Stuart Russell’s two-part lecture on the topic, which you can find on the CBC Radio program, Ideas: https://www.cbc.ca/radio/ideas/quit-using-the-terminator-as-an-example-of-ai-gone-wrong-argues-bbc-reith-lecturer-1.6309630 https://www.cbc.ca/radio/ideas/quit-using-the-terminator-as-... "This Terminator picture is wrong for so many reasons. First of all, the Terminators fire a lot of bullets that miss their targets. Why do they do that? Secondly, it makes people think that autonomous weapons are science fiction. They are not. You can buy them today," Russell explained. "Third, it makes people think that the problem is SkyNet, the global software system that controls the Terminators. It becomes conscious, it hates humans, and it tries to kill us all."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- staunch 5y agoThe US military could probably use a few dozen Andruils to modernize it and make it truly effective at its core mission. It does seem like a failing of Silicon Valley that it doesn't produce more military tech startups. Palmer Luckey had to get megarich first before it was possible to get Anduril funded. Same thing Elon Musk had to do to create SpaceX. There's obviously a VC funding gap, and clearly "the VR guy" and the "the PayPal guy" can do a lot more than most people believed. And so can a lot of other people who understand modern software and hardware.
- AyyWS 5y agoNavigating the DoD bureaucracy is not trivial. We had to work through a prime contractor. I never understood why it worked that way. My defense company will be a portmanteau of a LOTR weapon and a Nikola Tesla reference.
- dmoy 5y agoThere's already a few thousand Andruils. There's a pool of something like 3,000+ small defense contractors like this. What they should absolutely do is put more money into the SBIR program. And stop doing so much of it through the fucking navy lol.
- staunch 5y agoOf course there are lots of military contractors. There were lots of space-related government contractors before SpaceX too. SpaceX and Anduril seem to be unique in that they're following the Silicon Valley tech startup playbook and not the typical US government contractor playbook.
- namelessoracle 5y agoThe normal customer/client relationship is completely twisted in regards to the military industrial complex. A normal relationship would be that you have 5 people who make guns who all show their gun to the army and the army picks the best gun. Instead the army has the 5 companies "propose" a gun, and they choose who gets to TRY To make that gun. And if they fail its sunk cost fallacy all the way down. Also part of why they choose a company to try and make that gun is because they always choose that company and they have the most "experience". The argument for this state of affairs is that the military industry can no longer be spun up on demand and basically needs to be subsidized so it can continue exist in peace time. The reality is that these industries fuel continual low level conflicts, waste massive amounts of money and destroy the country. The only real solve is that the they need a new branch of the military that handles production and R&D in house, and also mans and owns the factories, and to stop giving contracts to parasitic companies.
- sroussey 5y ago
- sroussey 5y agoThe above is the text from Techcrunch. But you can see all sorts of stories when you search for shitpost and his name. Apt word too… it like the guy that walks his dog and shits on your lawn everyday. Im the guy that gabs the shit and throws it at his face after he walks away.
- steelstraw 5y agoThat's misinformation. Check the update at the bottom of that article.
- davidu 5y agoA tremendous achievement in an incredibly short period of time. Congrats to the absolutely stellar Anduril team and to America and her allies for getting better technology to save lives.
- pphysch 5y agoThe year is 2030. The government of Tel Aviv has outsourced site-management of the Gaza relocation camp to Anduril Industries, which provides 24/7 full-spectrum security guarantees from their command center in Orange County, California. Nothing will get in -- or out. America's allies are now safe from malevolent authoritarian actors.
- throwoutway 5y agoI don’t follow. How do you get here from anti-drones? Terrorist Drone attacks just killed civilians at Dubai airport
- pphysch 5y agoThese "anti-drone" drone-launching turrets will be briefly successful, until opponents code trivial evasive maneuvers (randomly perturb velocity) into their cheap attack drones. Then some genius at Anduril will say "what if our 'drone' was really small and got catapulted really fast to overcome any meaningful evasive capabilities of its target" and then you have autonomous rifle turrets, effective against a wide variety of targets.
- germinalphrase 5y agoBut… there already are autonomous rifle turrets.
- neartheplain 5y agoIsrael doesn't need Anduril. They have a large domestic drone industry with decades of experience and a strong export sector. Israeli drones gave Azerbaijan a decisive edge in that country's recent armed conflict with Armenia. By some estimates, Israel is the world's largest exporter of military drones: https://www.haaretz.com/.premium-israel-is-greatest-exporter-of-drones-1.5243373 https://www.haaretz.com/.premium-israel-is-greatest-exporter... They have a strong anti-drone industry, one area in which Anduril seeks to differentiate itself: https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2019-08-30/israels-anti-drone-industry-takes-off https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2019-08-... And Israeli designed-and-built sniper drones have already killed people in Gaza: https://www.discovermagazine.com/technology/israeli-military-veterans-built-a-sniper-drone https://www.discovermagazine.com/technology/israeli-military...
- throwawaymanbot 5y ago
- tra3 5y agoDoes anyone know if Pentagon's procurement process has changed since the days of "The Pentagon Wars" [0]? I initially jumped into this whole topic because I was terrible at estimating and thought it was a uniquely personal failure. I started reading into it an US Military has a history of projects that are incredibly late and massively over budget: - The joint strike fighter program, of which F35 [1] is the result. 10 years late and double the cost (projected life time cost of nearly 2 TRILLION, with a T). - F22 raptor, initially 750 were planned for but only 170 were made [2]. - C5 is known for massive cost overruns ($2 billion) [3] Burton, the author of the pentagon wars attributes it to the procurement process itself. The process does not incentivize delivery. The contracts goals is to get in with the pentagon by underbidding or not clearly defining the requirements and then having the issues be fixed in "operational testing", basically at the point right before front line troops get the hardware. In developmental tests contractors faked stuff a lot: > The Air Force’s sensor fuzed weapon concept of the early 1980s was advertised as a new, high-tech antiarmor weapon that would home in on the heat of a Soviet tank engine. Fourteen tanks had been arranged in a tight circle, nose to tail like a wagon train in an old western movie. The antiarmor weapons were suspended on a tall crane high above the circle of tanks. When dropped from the crane, the weapons could hit a tank even without the high-tech sensors guiding them. To make matters worse, the weapons did not home in on the heat from the tank engines because the tanks did not have their engines running. In fact, the weapons had homed in on electric hot plates that the program manager had placed on top of each tank. The hot plates were heated to a temperature four times the threshold temperature for the infrared sensors in the weapons, thereby guaranteeing success of the test. and > The Air Force’s third-generation laser-guided bomb, PAVEWAY III, scored fourteen direct hits out of sixteen launches in developmental tests conducted by the program manager.* During the operational tests, thirty-nine launches yielded only twenty hits and nineteen failures. Operational testing was suspended seven times because the system did not work well enough to run a test. When it worked, it usually hit the target. When it did not work exactly right (which was half the time), the average miss distance was five miles.1 Yet, PAVEWAY III was approved for production largely on the recommendation of the new commander of the Operational Test and Evaluation Command. It was his view that the “bugs had been worked out,” and he expressed this same view after each of the seven interruptions. This may sound strange, but the new commander was General Richard Phillips, whose former position was that of advocate for Air Force weapons systems, including PAVEWAY III. Finally: > The secretary’s chief tester continued to be subordinate to and work directly for the chief developer. Under this arrangement, the chief tester’s views on the adequacy of testing and the implications of test results were stifled by the chief developer. Has this changed at all? 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pentagon_Wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Pentagon_Wars 1: https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a35631305/f-35-doesnt-work-1-7-trillion-dollars/ https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a35631305/f-3... 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-22_Raptor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-22_Raptor 3: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_C-5_Galaxy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_C-5_Galaxy
- baybal2 5y agoI highly suspect Anduril to be the next Theranos https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28838650 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28838650 The man is passing a Chinese RC toy as his own development.
- neartheplain 5y agoYou mispelled "Theranos." >The man is passing a Chinese RC toy as his own development. Citation needed
- baybal2 5y agohttps://ibb.co/8DT5JMc https://ibb.co/8DT5JMc And me being in electronics industry, working on 5 drone projects so far, with one more fixed wing in making. These are exactly same parts of heli drone sold by one the biggest RC toy makers in China — Fly Wing (also apparently some cooler looking SAB, and MKS parts) lobotomised, and wrapped in a sci-fi looking sheet metal skin.
- neartheplain 5y agoDid you know that iPhones also say "Made in China," and include Chinese-manufactured components?
- baybal2 5y agoI do, and I also know they are largely engineered in China since not so long ago