12 ms·
Myths about cooking steak that need to go away (2013)
- bastardoperator 5y agoI feel like these myths are myths, I've never heard anyone making these claims before.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI actively believe several of them despite reading the article, although some for different reasons. I bring the steak to room temp, sear first, bone in, minimize cutting. That said, most of these are quibbles with the reasons, not the practices themselves. Some are stylistic too, particularly the desire for an even steak. Some like a strong gradient.
- cookie_monsta 5y agoI've definitely heard 1-5. 6-7 were new to me.
- dinkleberg 5y agoOn the contrary, I've heard each of these in the past (several of them many times).
- motoxpro 5y agoI have heard almost all of them
- Wistar 5y agoEspecially the "seals in the juices," myth.
- rsfayez 5y agodefinitely heard all of these over the years
- kzrdude 5y agoI was even taught #5 in school.
- tedunangst 5y agoDoesn't matter how it's cooked as long you put enough ketchup on it.
- errcorrectcode 5y agoWrong bottle. It's all about A1 sauce.
- cellularmitosis 5y agoAs a child, my grandfather would serve filet mingnon at family holidays, and I would drown it in A1. It is only as an adult that I truly understand the severity of my sin.
- tptacek 5y agoThat's not much of a sin; there isn't much flavor in a filet to cover up. It's more a textural experience. But also just this idea that a steak is a pure thing meant to be enjoyed without a powerful sauce --- some of the best sauces in cooking were invented for steaks. Deglaze a steak pan, cook down some shallots, hit it with some cream and maybe a shot of whiskey, and break up some Roquefort in it while the sauce reduces. It's an overwhelmingly flavorful sauce --- invented for steaks. Steaks are delicious. Sauces are delicious. Steaks and sauces are synergistically delicious. Don't apologize for saucing a steak.
- iqanq 5y agoWhy buy an expensive and tasty meat and put some sugary sauce on it? No offence intended, it's just that this baffles me. The only thing I would put on a steak besides salt is black pepper if I feel feisty.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> Why buy an expensive and tasty meat and put some sugary sauce on it? Why does anyone combine flavours and use sauces and different elements of taste? I don't put ketchup on my steak either, but let's not pretend that the idea of sauces or combining sweet and savoury is somehow unfathomable.
- hourislate 5y agoThe only thing I disagree with is I like to pull my steaks out the fridge a few hours before I cook them so they're at room temp when they go on the barbecue. They just seem to cook more evenly (medium rare). Getting hungry....
- tptacek 5y agoAre you salting them right when you pull them out of the fridge? Bringing them closer to room temperature doesn't do anything to improve them, but salting them a few hours before you start cooking will make a very large difference in quality.
- fishtoaster 5y agoSerious Eats had a good discussion[0] on this, agreeing with you: salt well before (or immediately before) cooking. :) https://www.seriouseats.com/the-food-lab-more-tips-for-perfect-steaks#mntl-sc-block_1-0-9 https://www.seriouseats.com/the-food-lab-more-tips-for-perfe...
- jwdunne 5y agoAlways thought I got a better crust without overcooking because I’d brought them up to room temperature. But I was salting them straight away so maybe it was that!
- gunfighthacksaw 5y agoI like a good crusty char tbh, I believe it’s called Pittsburgh style. Or minced up raw as a tartare. Not really what many would consider a steak, but a fine use for a good piece of meat anyhow.
- bradleyjg 5y agoThe Pittsburgh style is a very hard sear but rare or blue on the inside. It’s said, perhaps apocryphally, to have been developed at steel mills where the steaks were seared on the extremely hot plant piping.
- csdvrx 5y agoInteresting, that's what I do with my method (rare inside)
- dilap 5y agoThis is the ideal for me -- a nice good crust on the outside, more or less raw on the inside. Something about the contrast just makes it pop. Sublime. (Also love steak tartare.)
- einpoklum 5y agoUnfortunately, the myth about cooking steak that will be going away is that it can be done widely, at scale, into the future... beef production requires a lot of water and feed, so also a lot more land, than poultry, and still more than non-meat food. Livestock is part of the motivation for clear-cutting forested areas in South America. And of course there is the direct contribution to greenhouse gases... Sorry for being the downer, but it's going to happen. And I like steak as much as the next guy :-(
- greatpostman 5y ago
- DennisP 5y agoSome scientists have managed to make carbohydrates from CO2, several times more efficiently than plants. If it could be scaled up, that could drastically shrink the amount of land required for cattle feed. https://cen.acs.org/synthesis/catalysis/New-method-makes-starch-CO2/99/web/2021/09 https://cen.acs.org/synthesis/catalysis/New-method-makes-sta...
- giraffe_lady 5y agoNone of those are reasons we've stopped doing anything else why would we stop eating beef. Not that I'm endorsing this stance, but dodging large-scale consequences for our indulgences are one of the privileges of being well paid professionals in the imperial core. I don't think people here will be particularly affected by this shift.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThe US is largely self sufficient in terms of beef, feed, and water so I don't see these changing fast. Where is the shortage going to come from?
- einpoklum 5y agoI'm not in the US... in many (most?) countries, beef is mostly an import.
- jeffbee 5y agoThis author is such a treasure. Even if every one of the recipes was awful, it would still be a great site/book just for trying all these things and confirming or debunking them.
- jstx1 5y agoKenji is the man when it comes to no-bullshit cooking. He's also been more active on youtube in the past couple of years - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCqqJQ_cXSat0KIAVfIfKkVA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCqqJQ_cXSat0KIAVfIfKkVA
- andrewbarba 5y agoHah! We had the same idea.
- andrewbarba 5y agoKenji is an absolute legend in the culinary world. I highly suggest you checkout his youtube channel, his wealth of knowledge (backed by his own experiments) is simply unmatched.
- giraffe_lady 5y agoIn the home cook world I guess? In professional circles he's respected within his niche (making advanced technique accessible to home cooks) but not particularly influential beyond that.
- tayo42 5y agoIDK if he made techniques accessible. I found his content interesting but pretty over the top. His stuff feels more like myth busters for cooking. Entertaining possibly educational but idk how its always practical. He has some thing about tonkotsu ramen, that it needs to be this big two day boil event. Emphasis on need. I threw some pork bones in a pressure cooker and it was just as good.
- 5y ago
- bradleyjg 5y agoIf you haven’t heard the good news about the reverse sear yet, today is your lucky day. https://www.seriouseats.com/reverse-seared-steak-recipe https://www.seriouseats.com/reverse-seared-steak-recipe
- AdmiralAsshat 5y agoHaving compared the methods in my own kitchen, I'm also coming around to the idea that the reverse sear is a better method than sous vide, because I seem to get a better crust on the steak (likely because the steak is dryer than what I can remove from the s-v'd steak with paper towels). But, I find this only holds true for really nice cuts like filet mignon. If I want to cook a cheaper steak like a NY strip, I think the sous vide method produces a much more tender piece of meat, probably because I can cook it longer without overcooking it.
- bradleyjg 5y agoHaven’t yet gone down the SV road myself. I intend to buy the equipment and start playing around some time this year.
- tptacek 5y agoI've done the same tests with ribeyes and strips and, in a triangle test, you can't tell the difference between a circulator cook to 54c and a toaster oven reverse-sear cook to 45c (both followed by a hard sear). I really can't see much reason to circulate steaks anymore; there isn't even really a convenience win to it.
- fisherjeff 5y agoHard disagree on convenience: Timing hot steaks with hot sides is virtually effortless with a circulator
- tptacek 5y agoNot really. You have the same problem either way, because you've gotta sear both steaks. If you're going to need to hold the cooked reverse-sear steaks, bring them up to 120-124 (your final target temp is 128-132) instead of 115. I get what you're saying (I've got like 4 different circulators here, I'm not against them!) but the reverse sear is forgiving and flexible enough that I don't really even get a convenience win from it. (For calibration: my modal steak is a Whole Foods ribeye or strip, unmodified except for being salted ahead of time).
- valgor 5y ago
- vkou 5y agoThe same reason people drink, smoke, do heroin, and do California stops at intersections. In the case of steak, the particular reason is because it's delicious.
- astrange 5y agoIsn't steak boring? They're huge and the huger they are the more masculine you are for eating them, but every bite tastes the same and there's no need to experience it past the first few.
- cthalupa 5y ago>Isn't steak boring? No. > They're huge and the huger they are the more masculine you are for eating them I dry age steaks at home, so between trimming off the pellicle (which I then use for mixing in when grinding burger meat or turn into stock/demi-glace) and the water loss from evaporation, my steaks aren't particularly large, and I certainly don't do it because of any sort of masculinity. >but every bite tastes the same and there's no need to experience it past the first few. I'm not really sure what this argument is. If you find something delicious, why would you decide you should stop after a couple of bites?
- astrange 5y agoI've seen this opinion from an actual professional chef recently; don't remember where, but I think it was the author of this article. > and I certainly don't do it because of any sort of masculinity. Good for you. Giant porterhouses at steakhouses is definitely associated with power businessmen and boomers in the finance industry though; it goes with the whisky and cigars. (But Alexander's in Silicon Valley seems to be leaning into very expensive wagyu.) > If you find something delicious, why would you decide you should stop after a couple of bites? Having a short attention span is my foolproof diet tip and has never failed me. Plus, desire is the root of suffering and all that.
- errcorrectcode 5y agoOr: the myth the whole of humanity needs to eat expensive, inefficiently-produced, rainforest clearing, climate change-inducing, antibiotics-immune superbug-breeding, unhealthy animal protein grown on CAFOs. Roughly 12% of GHGs are attributed to meat agriculture. Since few people decide anything rationally since they want their steaks and Big Macs, I challenge anyone to visit Greeley CO, Tar Heel NC or North Platte NE and see if they still want to have a steak, pork chops, or their sense of smell.
- bradleyjg 5y agoI wonder if it was this annoying living through Great Awakenings 1-3. Go peddle your Calvinism elsewhere.
- asimpletune 5y agoWait, doesn’t calvinism have to do with everything being predetermined? What does that have to do with vegetarianism?
- bradleyjg 5y agohttps://www.quora.com/Why-are-Calvinists-Presbytarians-such-dour-arrogant-and-joyless-people https://www.quora.com/Why-are-Calvinists-Presbytarians-such-...
- asimpletune 5y agoOk, that explains everything
- gruez 5y agoBeats me. Maybe he meant malthusianism?
- errcorrectcode 5y agoTo reword Upton Sinclair: It is difficult to get an anti-intellectual to understand something when their instant-gratification poor habits depend upon their not understanding its existential threats: pandemics, antibiotic resistances, and climate change. It's too easy to say "FU, gimme my supersized Big Mac and I don't care how it's made, Bill Nye." This is what a drug addict says out of willful ignorance while participating in long-term omnicide and ecocide because they're hooked and too weak to make the necessary changes themselves.
- csdvrx 5y agoMy favorite method (and no guy tasting my steaks has ever said anything but "hmmmmm"): use salt on both sides the day before (to remove moisture), keep the steak in the fridge until the last moment (to keep its temperature low and limit the risk of overcooking the inside), meanwhile put a decent amount of vegetable oil in a pan, wait until its viscosity is reduce to that of water (this indicate high temp, that will remove any further concerns with moisture), put the steak in (careful with the oil projections) until it gets brown on one site, cut the heat (the oil temperature is sufficient to finish the cooking), turn it over to sear it on the other side - done! It takes about 5 minutes or less depending on your stove, it will get you the rare meat inside, yet the delicious outside - just like the picture in the article, except it's way easier and faster. It will work best on "cheap cuts" as fat fried this way tastes perfect. For keto followers, serve with Otorogi mustard. No extra salt is needed as even if you try to remove the salt you used the day before, enough will remain to give a great taste.
- tptacek 5y agoTry it both ways, yours and the reverse sear. Don't just do a subjective taste test, but rather take a cross section of both steaks. You should find that your pan-grilled steaks have a much bigger band of grey meat --- a much more fluid gradation from gray/seared to pink/rare --- than the reverse-seared steak. That's the point of the reverse sear (which is the opposite of what you're doing); "cook" the steak (bringing it up to almost its desired final temperature) very slowly at low heat, so the whole steak cooks consistently and evenly (almost the same color edge-to-center) and then sear it. You also get a better sear, because the cooked steak is drier than the one you pulled out of the fridge. (Salting ahead of time probably doesn't remove moisture; the steak reabsorbs the liquid it sweats out). Having said all that: some people just prefer steak that isn't edge-to-center the same doneness, so your method might just suit your tastes better.
- csdvrx 5y ago> You should find that your pan-grilled steaks have a much bigger band of grey meat --- a much more fluid gradation from gray/seared to pink/rare --- than the reverse-seared steak I like meat rare, so the grey band has been one of my concerns. But if the oil reaches a high enough temperature while the steak comes directly from the fridge, the coldness of the meat is often enough to prevent the grey band. My method depends on a very high temperature gradient, and in my experience is indistinguishable from the reverse sear, while only taking a fraction of the time > (Salting ahead of time probably doesn't remove moisture; the steak reabsorbs the liquid it sweats out). Very possible; it's likely that leaving the steak in the fridge uncovered is what removes a lot of moisture.
- desdiv 5y agoThere's a reason why Myth #1 is so persistent: the action itself works, just not for the reason advertised. Most cooks who advocate for Myth #1 will salt and pepper the steak, then let it rest for 20-30 minutes. The salt draws out some of the moisture from the surface of the steak and leaves it behind on the resting surface. The less moisture that enters the pan means better browning.
- gruez 5y ago>The salt draws out some of the moisture from the surface of the steak and leaves it behind on the resting surface Unless you're using paper towels to blot the steak dry, the amount of water left on the plate is absolutely negligible. If anything salting that late is worse. For one, you don't get as good penetration of the salt, so it will taste salty on the outside but bland on the inside. Plus, drawing out the moisture to the surface means there's more water to drive off when you're searing, which means a worse sear. Taking all of that into account, I think you're better off salting hours in advance (eg. in the morning or overnight), and letting it sit in the fridge to dry off.
- desdiv 5y agoSorry, I wasn't clear: I'm not advocating for any particular method. I was just trying to explain why Myth #1 remained so persistent for so long. Method 1: salt and pepper, then cook immediately Method 2: salt and pepper, let rest, then cook Method 3: salting hours in advance, let it sit in the fridge, then cook Obviously 3 > 2 > 1, but Method 3 wasn't done historically (by most cooks). Cooks either went with Method 1 or Method 2, and Method 2 "won" out in the end because people consistently noticed that it produced better results. Myth #1 was an incorrect explanation as to why Method 2 is better than Method 1.
- paulcole 5y ago
- gruez 5y agoMind explaining why?
- jmknoll 5y agoNot sure if this is what OP had in mind, but beef has a considerably larger carbon footprint than any other common protein source.
- 1_player 5y agoAnd considerably smaller carbon footprint than industrial emission and cars. The vegetables and grains grown 5000 miles away are being brought via land and sea thanks to petrol right to the vegan store one goes to shop at with their SUV. But yes, let's demonise the food we've evolved to thrive on. It's mental that this has become a controversial idea worth censoring.
- paulcole 5y ago> And considerably smaller carbon footprint than industrial emission and cars Yes, I am recommending people reduce their addiction to cars as well. But honestly, planet is likely a lost cause for humanity, so “Let them eat steak!” I guess. And if you think humanity is thriving today, I’ve got a bridge to sell you.
- enruwhuy 5y agoTransportation overall is a huge emitter. Transportation of most food is only a very small part of that food’s emissions, from what I understand: “GHG emissions from transportation make up a very small amount of the emissions from food and what you eat is far more important than where your food traveled from.” (Source: https://ourworldindata.org/food-choice-vs-eating-local https://ourworldindata.org/food-choice-vs-eating-local)
- Graffur 5y agoI have never heard any of these myths.
- ufo 5y agoCan someone clarify what they mean by resting uncovered on the fridge? I remember being told once that food should always be stored covered in the fridge. Is that another myth?
- gruez 5y ago> Can someone clarify what they mean by resting uncovered on the fridge? From the article: "Or better yet, salt them and let them rest uncovered on a rack in the fridge for a night or two, so that their surface moisture can evaporate. You'll get much more efficient browning that way." (emphasis mine) >I remember being told once that food should always be stored covered in the fridge. Is that another myth? AFAIK that's for food safety reasons.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gumby 5y agoCovering food keeps it from drying out (otoh, if you have mushrooms in the fridge — why? — let any vapor escape. Ditto some raw veggies. Also makes things less likely to spill or have stuff fall into them. So not a myth. Also nothing exotic, just common sense. It you want something to dry out by all means leave it uncovered.
- db48x 5y agoThe point of covering something in the fridge is so that you don’t accidentally drop or drip something else into it, and so that they dry more slowly. For example, you’ve got a pot of left–over spaghetti in the fridge, then you bring home some fresh chicken for tomorrow. You wouldn’t want any of the fresh chicken juice to drip into the spaghetti accidentally, so you make sure it is covered, or at least higher up than the chicken. You’ve got some limes in there too, but their rind keeps them from drying out. The one you cut in half will start to dry out quickly unless you wrap it in something. Best not to get the chicken juice on the limes either. The rind will protect the part of the limes that you will eat only until you cut them.
- shepherdjerred 5y agoThe goal of resting uncovered in the fridge is to evaporate the surface moisture which lets you get a better sear since less energy is spent evaporating water on/near the surface of the steak. You usually want to store food covered the fridge so that this exact thing doesn't happen, and so that odors don't transfer between foods. Or at least that's what I think.
- gHA5 5y agoI only recently learned about myth #7 ("poke test") and managed to cook a great steak using it.
- ankaAr 5y agoWhenever you wants, just contact me, im from Argentina and happy to let you know how to cook beef. People from USA just burn the beef >.<
- ryan93 5y agoCan you please share the miracle way that Argentinians cook meat?
- ankaAr 5y agosearch Locos x el asado on youtube. Or read Francis Mallman books, or look for Christian Petersen videos. Good quality meat, be with friends, more time cooking and NO fire (please, no fire). Use hard wood to burn ember and cook with it. Try not to use charcoal, do not use a fork with the meat NEVER, use kitchen clamps... just let the meat to rest on the grill.., use salmuera sometimes (water, salt, pepper and bay leaves..) to not let the meat dry..., and be with friends. that is all.
- cookie_monsta 5y agoThey burn it. Generally speaking, the quality of beef in Argentina is very good, the price (subject to the economy which is always a factor) has historically been low and the culture is very carnivorous - these are the things that give Argentina its fame for beef along with a strong export industry. Nobody really rates the Argentines as cooks, though, and the parrilla is just a basic adjustable-height open flame grill.
- tptacek 5y agoIt's too bad the Brazilians got the picanha, and will thus always be the South American champions of beef cookery. :P
- ankaAr 5y agoI will not start a flame war, picanha is nice. You can add tira de asado, bife de chorizo, ojo de bife, bife angosto, matambre (also matambre a la pizza), entraña, vacio, cuadril, chorizo, morcilla, salchicha parrillera, lomo, roast beef (that is very tasty and cheap), chinchulines trenzados, riñones, tripa rellena.. you can add those to your repertory, but picanha is nice too.
- emmelaich 5y agoThe 'flip once' rule is to NOT get an even cook. For steak at least, it's nice to have a slightly crispy outer and tender pink inside.
- tptacek 5y agoHe's tested this, as have other people. You don't get a crispier sear by limiting flips.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- copenja 5y agoI thought flip once rule was to encourage keeping the lid closed so the temperature stays even. Everytime u open the lid, all the hot air is released and the grill takes time to reach steady temp. Still... I've done both ways and they certainly work.
- amelius 5y agoHow about the myth that "eating steaks contributes to one's manliness" and which some like to repeat at every possible opportunity at BBQ events?
- Spivak 5y agoI think it’s a more general “eating meat is manly” that I’ve heard more often. I get it kinda, eating meat feels more “predatory” and fruits and vegetables are “health food” — only women care about that something something Dr. Pepper 10. The whole “soyboi” thing has got to be one of the funniest but also saddest things I’ve ever seen. Pour one out for the men who eat nothing but carbs, meat, salt, and dairy. You’re all keeping the blood pressure medication business alive.
- rosndo 5y ago> The whole “soyboi” thing has got to be one of the funniest but also saddest things I’ve ever seen. Pour one out for the men who eat nothing but carbs, meat, salt, and dairy. But isn’t the whole soy thing about US supermarket foods which overwhelmingly contain soy, whereas someone eating a whole foods diet would be unlikely to consume much soy unless they were specifically seeking it out? The “soyboi” thing is indeed terribly sad, you can just go to any American supermarket to witness the hordes of disgusting fatties rolling around on their mobility scooters, collecting their daily doses of HOT POCKETS®. What a tragedy. Of course, soy itself isn’t the actual problem. (correlation, not causation)
- stickfigure 5y ago> eating steaks contributes to one's manliness Only if they're bone-in.
- contravariant 5y agoMyth #3 (Bone-in steak has more flavor than boneless) seems a bit of a strawman, the version they disprove is "the bone somehow imparts flavour onto the meat", but they then go on to say that: > I personally find the tiny bits of connective tissue-rich meat, fat, and gristle stuck to the bone to be the tastiest part of the steak So yeah, unless you can get the bone out perfectly you'll get more flavoursome meat if you leave it in. Also it's not entirely insane to believe bones impart flavour, since marrow is incredibly flavoursome, though you probably won't be able to cook bones enough to get the marrow out.
- ckastner 5y ago> Also it's not entirely insane to believe bones impart flavour Brown stock is made from roasted bones, among other things, so I too feel somewhat skeptical about the claim that bones cannot import at least some sort of flavor.
- tptacek 5y agoHe tested this, for whatever it's worth to you: bone in, bone off, and bone detached and re-attached with a foil shield between the bone and the meat. Indistinguishable.
- ckastner 5y agoI understand that, and fully share his view that "tiny bits of connective tissue-rich meat, fat, and gristle stuck to the bone to be the tastiest part of the steak". I can also easily admit that it's possible that the "bone-in steak has more flavor" argument might actually just be a consequence of the above: people leaving the bone on may mistake the flavors of said meat and fat for flavor imparted by the bone, rather than being innate. However, I'm trying to weigh the one source here calling this a myth against plenty of reputable Chefs who subscribe to this myth - not just with steak, but also with poultry. It's quite possible that these Chefs are fooling themselves (they frequently do; I've seen enough contradictions), but it nevertheless is an extraordinary claim.
- 5y ago
- Zigurd 5y agoAlmost all the myths busted in this article I have seen busted in other places and for good reasons. There are one points on which I disagree: The "poke test" is not trivially easy, but it is easier than most people think. Squishy is too raw. The moment after it stops being squishy is just right. If you can grok that, you can do the poke test. Secondarily, while it is true that letting meat come up to room temperature does not make a difference by itself, the article does point out that one effective option for seasoning meat is to do it at least 45 minutes before cooking. You might as well let it come up to room temperature in that time, too.
- staticassertion 5y agoMost of this sounds right. I think the 'bone in' myth is a little more subtle and I'm not convinced that poking my steak 4 times just to flip it is worthwhile (it's gonna release juice, that's gonna cool the pan down and create steam). Otherwise, yep. I will add that by far the number one thing you can do to up your steak game is to just buy better steaks. There's a massive difference between a good cut and an ok cut. Personally, I find that if you buy American or Australian Wagyu in bulk you can get absolutely incredible cuts for a pretty good price. I buy mine at wagyushop.com .
- spiderice 5y agoWhat is a "pretty good price"? Looking at that website, the cheapest I see is around $80 for a single 8oz steak. I don't see any bulk options.
- tptacek 5y ago$10/oz isn't much better than the price you'd get for genuine A5, is it?
- staticassertion 5y agoIf you buy the 15lb Wagyu ribeye it'll be 40/lb. I do not recommend buying wagyu by the ounce.
- tptacek 5y agoI have never had a "wagyu" steak (served as a steak) that I found special. It's to the point where "wagyu" is kind of a red flag for me. (I've had A5 prepared at sushi places, and that I get, but it's a totally different preparation).
- staticassertion 5y agoAre you referring to American/Australian wagyu as "wagyu" ? Did you get it at a restaurant or make it yourself? I find that American/Australian wagyu is not like Japanese wagyu, but it is still extremely good - it's just a really really good 'regular' steak. It's going to be beefier than a Japanese wagyu with less marbling. I'd be really surprised to hear that you can't tell the difference between a 'regular' steak and Japanese A5 though. They're really, really different - the marbling is extreme by comparison.
- testfoobar 5y agoKenji's sous vide steak guide is where he puts all his theory into action. It is my go to guide: https://www.seriouseats.com/food-lab-complete-guide-to-sous-vide-steak https://www.seriouseats.com/food-lab-complete-guide-to-sous-...
- GravitasFailure 5y agoAll of the Serious Eats sous vide guides are absolute gold mines.
- mark-r 5y agoThe link for xkcd is incomplete. I think he meant to link to this specific one: https://xkcd.com/386/ https://xkcd.com/386/
- Zababa 5y ago> Myth #6b: "If you cut it open to check doneness, it will lose all its juices." > The Reality: Again, the amount of juice lost by a single slit-and-peek is completely inconsequential in comparison to the whole piece of meat. I think this one might depend a lot on how sharp your knives are. And most people that I know have dull knives. Thus, when cutting a steak to peek, they end up pressing it, which releases juices. So this wouldn't be a myth for most people I know.
- spiderice 5y agoI think comments like this (basically just guesses without any data) are where myths like this originate.
- Zababa 5y agoThis isn't a guess. This is something that applies to most people I know. That means that this "myth" is true around me. I've cut steak open a lot, and I can see easily that more juices flow out when I use a dull knife compared to when I use a sharp knife. A simple thought experiment: do you think cutting open a steak with a razor blade will make the same amount of juice flow than with a butter knife? I know for a fact that the razor blade will spill almost no juice, and the butter knife will spill a lot, by pressing the steak. The question is now: Do most people have dull knives? Or do they have sharp knives? Most people around me have dull knives, except for chefs. I've seen lots of cooking videos, and chefs often tend to have good and sharp knives. So my guess here would be that chefs have sharper knives than most people. Meaning that a chef can't properly test this myth unless they take this factor into account. I haven't been able to find any data on knife spending, or average sharpness of knives depending on if people are chef or not. Here's an experiment we could try: have people evaluate the sharpness of a single knife, and see if non-chef tend to evaluate it as better than chefs. This is, I think, how science works. Sometimes you have proved something, sometimes it was just counfounding factors. There's a good article about that being discussed currently: https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/04/28/the-control-group-is-out-of-control/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/04/28/the-control-group-is-o.... I'll finish this by saying I have a huge respect for J. Kenji López-Alt. I only raise that point because here, I believe being a chef can introduce bias.
- globular-toast 5y agoCan anyone guess which xkcd they intended to link to? They seem to have accidentally linked to the home page instead of a specific comic.
- gjm11 5y agoThe "someone is wrong on the internet" one: https://xkcd.com/386/ https://xkcd.com/386/.
- strken 5y agoI think he's misunderstanding the point of the poke test (myth #7). It's not intended to precisely gauge doneness regardless of cut, it's intended to help absolute beginners tell the difference between blue-rare, well-done, and somewhere in the middle. If you're buying a meat thermometer that starts at $83USD and your job is writing for a cooking website, you don't need to compare your steak to the fleshy bits of your hand to tell if it's done, but it's helpful if you just started cooking for yourself.
- leetcrew 5y agoI get the impression he understands that and is arguing that the wide variation in people's hands makes it useless even to tell the difference between rare and well done. I'm sure you could figure out doneness relative to your own flesh with enough trial and error, but cooking a nice steak is already stressful enough for a beginner cook (at least in my experience). just get the thermapen. it only takes four or five overcooked steaks to break even on $83.
- tatersolid 5y agoMy instant-read thermometer was $20 at Target. Even so, my crotchety father-in-law is amazed how everything I grill is always “perfectly done”. He spent 50 years as a purveyor to the best Chicago steak packers. We use that $20 instant-read for everything including baking, and it works great after 15 years.
- cheese_goddess 5y agoI think scientific cooking completely misses the point about cooking and about eating food. You should cook your food the way your senses tell you is right. You should cook your food so that your senses tell you it's right. You're going to taste the food with your mouth and smell it with your nose. You're not going to taste it with a thermometer or whatever else silly probe of irrelevance anyone might think of sticking into it. The same goes about following arbitrary rules about how food "should" be cooked. It's your tongue and nose that will experience your cooking. Not Julia Child's. Cook food using your senses and cook food so that you like it. Cook as thou likest. That shall be the whole of the law.
- readthenotes1 5y agoThe comment above this is from CS Lewis. The contrast in morality is pungent.
- cthalupa 5y agoWell, sure, if you like your food some certain way, then cook it for yourself that way. But a lot of the "scientific cooking" is about repeatability. I know I like my steaks rare, edge to edge, with a hard sear. I know that the easiest way for me to accomplish that is using an immersion circulator, combi oven, or reverse sear, drying it (and if I have time, cooling it down briefly), and then either searing/basting it in cast iron or finishing it off on my kamado grill with the temperature ramped up to inferno. I've cooked hundreds of steaks just on a grill, or just in a pan. I can nail a rare or medium rare steak on the grill, and adjust for temp, etc. But there are inherent limitations to those methods - it might be rare in the center, but simply because of the physics at play, more of the meat than just the surface is going to be well done. And as for the myths in the article... a lot of these are just things that are patently untrue. It's not about "scientific cooking" vs. cooking to personal taste, people just believe a lot of things that are just flat out wrong.
- cheese_goddess 5y agoAren't you just saying that you cook your steaks the way you like them?
- scrame 5y agoThe whole perfect steak thing is not new. "Males are best turned into gluttons with the help of their vanity. They ought to be made to think themselves very knowing about food, to pique themselves on having found the only restaurant in the town where steaks are really “properly” cooked. What begins as vanity can then be gradually turned into habit. But, however you approach it, the great thing is to bring him into the state in which the denial of any one indulgence—it matters not which, champagne or tea, sole colbert or cigarettes—“puts him out”, for then his charity, justice, and obedience are all at your mercy." C.S. Lewis -- The Screwtape Letters 1942.
- tzs 5y agoI have a steak-adjacent question. Why are steak knives usually pointy? I've never had the need to stab my steak with a steak knife. I have on occasion accidentally stabbed my finger with one.
- Cerium 5y agoPure conjecture: steak knives are sharpened knives. It is easy to grind an edge that terminates in a point than a flat. Compare the detail of the blade near the handle to the point, the point is much more precise. I think it also helps symbolically since kitchen knives are sharp and have points. You won't mistake the steak knife for a butter knife.
- tptacek 5y agoThis question, as I just learned from Google, has an interesting answer: modern steak knives have their current shape because they're derived a specific letter opener.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway64643 5y agoLooking back at this thread, it's funny that there's always debunking of myth debunking.
- Apofis 5y agoSerious Eats is such a disaster for someone that prints things.
- atom_arranger 5y agoI like blue rare, seared and seasoned outside with a gradient to a blue rare center. The article talks a lot about cooking steaks evenly (they use the word 7 times), which is not what I'm interested in.
- helij 5y agoBeef my way medium-medium rare: 1. dry it out and salt the steak 2. Heat the pan to highest 3. Put the stake into the pan with a lid on 4. Wait till the whole steak changes colour 5. Lower the temperature to 5 or 6 (out of 9) 6. Flip it 7. Flip it again 8. Flip it again 9. Check the temperature 9a. If 54 degrees Celsius take it away to rest 9b. If less than 54 flip it and measure again shortly afterwards - should be done in a minute 10. Done Something like that. Steak is always tender and good. Guests are amazed every time. Better than any restaurant I've ever been.
- papito 5y agoIt doesn't matter how you cook your steak if your plates are not warmed before you serve.
- barrenko 5y agoHere https://www.reddit.com/r/food/comments/3w8bb2/magnus_nilsson_cooking_steak/ https://www.reddit.com/r/food/comments/3w8bb2/magnus_nilsson..., you're welcome.