12 ms·
French moratorium on prion studies after two cases of fatal brain disease (2021)
- tyingq 5y agoIs there a post-prick protocol? I'd almost vote for having the tip of my finger amputated post prion-lab accident if it would help and was an option. I get she should have worn gloves, but it seems like there should also be some set procedure.
- domesticsimian 5y agoI think my brain is constantly on the lookout for clickbait. When I read the headline of this thread, I immediately thought of a similarly worded clickbait type headline: "Man dies 3 years after eating cheesesteak"... Maybe I just think about cheesesteaks too much.
- raxxorrax 5y agoMore concerning is that some of these diseases are transmissible. Imagine how many people you could infect in 7 years when symptoms only appear after 5-10 years.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoI read about some of the most common prion diseases and as far as I can tell, all the transmissible ones require the ingestion of infected material. While a transmissible prion epidemic that spreads through the air would be really scary, it doesn't seem especially likely as an existential threat in our lifetimes.
- Aardwolf 5y agoThese prions sound horrible, less defensible against than viruses, and at the same time much simpler in form than viruses so much more common (easier to appear). What is the reason that we can thank for prion diseases not being much more common?
- nikanj 5y agoNo ready vector for spreading. It needs to come into direct contact with your proteins to affect them
- pcthrowaway 5y agoDoesn't that just mean physical contact? Our skin is made out of proteins, is it not?
- littlestymaar 5y agoNot all proteins can exist as prions. (In fact, it's amazing that some can even exist: think about it: a protein that exist in two stable shapes where the shape that does not normally exist in the body can cause the other shape to make the switch!)
- kijin 5y agoThe outer layer of your skin is mostly made of dead cells. It's cold, dry, exposed to the elements, constantly discarded, and has the wrong pH for most biochemical processes that are optimized for the inside of your body. It takes a fairly invasive pathogen to break that barrier.
- washadjeffmad 5y agoAnything expressed by DNA is a protein, but not all proteins are the same. Prion infections are caused by proteins that change the same proteins in the same way, like how crystals replicate. A human analogy might be a disgruntled but charismatic worker who starts spreading a disruptive attitude until morale and productivity plummet in their department. As long as one of that team remains, the issue can still spread. Coincidentally, both the potted plants and highly compensated leadership are unaffected.
- np_tedious 5y agoPrions are terrifying
- vikbytes 5y ago(2021) Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27982991 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27982991
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- diordiderot 5y agoHuman transmissible prions are the most terrifying non-extinction level event I could imagine for humanity. Prion diseases like mad cow kill within one year after 5-10 years of infection. The massive wave of death and terror would end society as we know it
- RyEgswuCsn 5y agoIt will be as "good" as extinction --- by the time we realised there is a prion pandemic, it will probably be too late.
- dtech 5y agoHey all the vegetarians and vegans will survive
- blip54321 5y agoCows are vegetarian, as are deer.
- dtech 5y agoI don't know deer, but cows get it from meat [1] > Cattle are believed to have been infected from being fed meat and bone meal (MBM) that contained the remains of other cattle who spontaneously developed the disease or scrapie-infected sheep products. The outbreak increased throughout the United Kingdom due to the practice of feeding meat-and-bone meal to young calves of dairy cows [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bovine_spongiform_encephalopathy#Cause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bovine_spongiform_encephalopat...
- Gare 5y agoIt is estimated around 400 000 infected cows entered human foodchain in the UK in the 1980s. Less than 200 people died. Samples from appendectomy imply many more are infected, but didn't develop symptoms (yet). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_BSE_outbreak https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_BSE_outbreak
- MrWiffles 5y agoFinger pricks? My mom used a thimble. I know it’s obviously not that simple in a medical research environment, but I do wonder if the basic idea of a sewing thimble could be adapted into a contoured, finger-shaped thin metal layer that’s mounted inside special gloves for the researchers to wear. It would have to be done in such a way as to not hinder their dexterity, but I’d think that’s quite doable if said “thimble” was confined to the first segment of each finger.
- lixtra 5y agoOr that: > and did not wear both metal mesh and surgical gloves, as she was supposed to
- proactivesvcs 5y agoI think that tragedies like these should absolutely cast a spotlight on the institutional and procedural weaknesses that may have contributed. With this in mind I still I have to say - it blows my mind that someone could be working with prions and not be wearing the correct hand protection. Why? How often did they work so unsafely? How many others aren't? Did nobody notice and speak up? Even the article itself doesn't seem to ask these questions.
- PoignardAzur 5y agoFrom articles I've read (and my father's experience in construction work), the biggest challenge in workplace safety is getting the workers to wear the damn equipment that's specifically made to save their life. It's especially dangerous with unscrupulous bosses, who will just shrug and not have a fight with their own employees over making them follow the regulations.
- bzzzt 5y agoThat's exactly the kind of glove the article says the woman should have been wearing, but obviously wasn't...
- supermatt 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 4gotunameagain 5y agoUpon reading the comments on this post, I realised that many people are terrified of prions, as am I. But why much more than a virus or bacteria? I am terrified of rabies, sure, but not in the same way. Something about prions rubs me in the weirdest of ways. Maybe it has to do with them not being an "external" assailant (even if originally acquired externally), but an inherent defect of some part of myself?
- donatj 5y agoFor me it’s the near total lack of hope for a cure. Your body, your proteins, slowly becoming its own undoing.
- arghwhat 5y agoWhile entirely incurable today (like many other diseases), I suspect that reality is not nearly as terrifying as the story that as painted. A virus is after all your own cells used against you, so its modus operandi of having your body fail yiu is not really that unique. Articles make it sound like our entire being unwinds in their presence, while the real outcome is likely much less exciting: clumps slowly forming that fail to get cleared and end up causing problems as they accumulate. Fatal and no available cure once there are symptoms, but... Less scary. (Disclaimer: I, like everyone else in this thread, is not a qualified source of medical information.)
- SamBam 5y agoI agree that it seems at least plausible that a cure will be found in the future. The cell already has a number of quality control mechanisms for detecting misfolded proteins. It seems not unusual that we'd be able to piggyback onto this system do develop something that can detect specific prions and neutralize or destroy them, possibly delivered an an RNA shot. The problem is that there are a minuscule number of prion deaths in the developed world, so I don't see it getting a huge amount of attention. On the other hand, the Covid RNA vaccines were basically invented by a handful of people looking at a string of nucleotides over the course of five days. (It took large companies to actually develop the vaccine itself, of course.) This could end up being something that's solved by more accurate protein-folding simulations (perhaps Google's AlphaFold) and a couple of grad students.
- oneoff786 5y agoPrions to me feel like what the miasma must have felt like to people of centuries prior
- knicholes 5y agoThis is why we don't eat brains, people!
- user_7832 5y agoI had researched on prions and the Kuru disease for a class while looking at the impacts of animal testing (the Kuru disease is a prion found in New Guinea and is considered to be the first prion disease). Prions are scarily dangerous - near-fatal if exposed to it, and stable at much higher temperatures that regular non-misfolded proteins. However, your chances of getting prions is very low. As long as you avoid "exotic" meat like monkey brains and stay in countries with strong regulatory bodies (like the US/EU etc) the risk of exposure is extremely limited. Bonus points if you avoid swimming in random bodies of water to not get contaminated water with brain-eating amoeba traveling up your nose.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andybak 5y agoMy great love is travelling (mostly outside the EU/US) and this often involves countries where swimming in random bodies of water is part of the standard itinerary. I'm sure I'm not particularly unusual in this respect. Most of friends have similar preferences.
- awestroke 5y agoGood for you
- andybak 5y agoDid you respond sarkily because you thought I was bragging or something? I'm not sure I understand why I provoked this reaction from you.
- ubermonkey 5y agoDoing that sort of travel is, for most citizens of the industrialized west, pretty unusual.
- Aeolun 5y ago
- edmcnulty101 5y agoThis is really sad but why are they stopping study on these? Why don't they just hire competent people? We have BSL level 4 and people don't often prick themselves. What gives?
- diordiderot 5y agoShe was a 23 year old doc student. She should've been supervised really.
- PhantomGremlin 5y agoWe have BSL level 4 and people don't often prick themselves. Wuhan Institute of Virology was BSL level 4, and yet here we are. People aren’t perfect. Accidents happen.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoThe chance of an airline accident is 1 in 16 million. 441 nuclear reactors have been operating flawlessly for over a decade. Countless biology labs deal with dangerous pathogens daily with minimal accidents. This French lab from the article had two separate accidents in three years. I dislike when people use the term 'accidents happen' in a hand wavy way. There's a whole world of risk calculations to determine if something is safe or not.
- PhantomGremlin 5y ago441 nuclear reactors have been operating flawlessly for over a decade. Fascinating choice of timeframe: "over a decade". How about going back just one more year. We can find multiple nuclear reactors blowing themselves up quite spectacularly on TV: Over the following three weeks there was evidence of partial nuclear meltdowns in units 1, 2 and 3: visible explosions, suspected to be caused by hydrogen gas, in units 1 and 3; a suspected explosion in unit 2, that may have damaged the primary containment vessel; and a possible uncovering of the Spent fuel pools in Units 1, 3 and 4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_Nuclear_Power_Plant#Nuclear_disaster_of_March_11,_2011 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_Nuclear_Powe... Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how did you enjoy the play?
- thebiss 5y agoThe lab changes under development should include a protocol for protection _after_ accidental prion-disease needle sticks. Prophylaxis protocols exist for clinicians dealing with HIV, hepatitis, etc. [0] A radical (barbaric) way might be to immediately tourniquet the finger, anesthetize, and cut off the tip! They could hang a little guillotine next to the eye-wash station.... [0] https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/bbp/emergnedl.html https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/bbp/emergnedl.html
- thingsgoup 5y agoThe article does mention she was supposed to soak her thumb in bleach immediately and did not.
- SteveNuts 5y agoDoes bleach actually denature prions? I thought they were notoriously difficult to destroy
- FeteCommuniste 5y agoSeems that it does: https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/household-bleach-inactivates-chronic-wasting-disease-prions https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/household-blea... "A 5-minute soak in a 40% solution of household bleach decontaminated stainless steel wires coated with chronic wasting disease (CWD) prions, according to a new study by National Institutes of Health scientists." Although it notes: "Notably, the study failed to find an effective method to decontaminate CWD-infected solid tissue. Pieces of CWD-infected brain retained prion activity even after a 30-minute soak in 100% bleach. Investigators note that bleach fails to penetrate tissues and should be used only as a surface decontaminant."
- beowulfey 5y agoThey are, but almost all proteins are sensitive to the oxidative power of bleach
- 5y ago
- arcade79 5y agoCan't help to think that if I pricked my finger while working with prions, I'd amputate that finger ...
- shoelessone 5y agoCan anybody speak to how this story relates to prions found in deer (and so venison) in Michigan and the Midwest? My family are hunters and now send all deer to be tested before eating, but most don't.
- milliams 5y agoFrom the article: > In June 2019, an INRAE lab worker named Émilie Jaumain died at age 33, 10 years after pricking her thumb during an experiment with prion-infected mice. The HN headline: > Woman dies seven years after pricking finger in prion research lab (science.org) Where did the "seven" year quote come from?
- daniel-thompson 5y agoThe headline is wrong. She pricked her finger in 2010, started experiencing symptoms in 2017, and died in 2019.
- oxymoran 5y agoSome people are terrified of spiders. I am terrified of prions.
- zack-m 5y agoTragic. It’s always scary to handle needles in a lab. Even with good needle safety protocols, accidents are bound to happen. There’s this case that my PI showed me of a student who pricked his finger with a needle filled with DCM [1] (which is very common solvent in used in lab). The residual DCM at the tip of the needle caused the damage shown in the pictures. When your work involves handling tens of needles daily, accidents are bound to happen. I pricked myself once with a needle. Thankfully it was brand new and dry, so nothing happened. It was just the idea of it was terrifying. In an alternate world, I could’ve gone to the ER because of it. Hope someone invents a safer needle. [1]: https://www.chemistryworld.com/news/gruesome-accident-prompts-call-to-find-alternative-to-needles-in-chemistry-labs/4011322.article https://www.chemistryworld.com/news/gruesome-accident-prompt...
- refurb 5y agoJust my opinion, but that’s not DCM residue on a needle, that’s someone using a needle to transfer and forcing DCM under their skin. I drenched myself in DCM and stick myself with needles a few times. Not to say the lab isn’t dangerous. I knew one person who peppered their abdomen with glass when a perchlorate exploded, scarred their face when a peroxide exploded and burned themselves with an organolithium. But a simple needle stick with DCM residue won’t do that.
- ajnin 5y agoBlunt needles are a thing. They are used for example in electronics as a way to dispense tiny amounts of solder paste or flux on components pads on a PCB. Presumably when transferring solutions from container to container, you don't need a sharp needle, unless the container is closed with a membrane that needs to be pierced. There are also gloves that protect against puncture. If you're using both sharp needles and non-protecting gloves then it is probably time to revise the procedures.
- crhutchins 5y agoBut why do the complications start sometime later? Wouldn't it be ideal for running through a series of checks as they are working in a lab?
- fabian2k 5y agoDoes anyone know what the typical safety rules around needles and blades are in a BSL-3 lab? I assume this was a BSL-3 lab as this was a human prion strain. Or were these experiments actually done in a BSL-2 lab?
- timoth 5y agoI'm a complete layman in this field, but the logical conflict between these two sections concerned me: > she stabbed her left thumb with a curved forceps while cleaning a cryostat — a machine that can cut tissues at very low temperatures — that she used to slice brain sections from transgenic mice infected with a sheep-adapted form of BSE Then later: > Aguzzi declined to comment on the French CJD cases, but told Science his lab never handles human or bovine prions for research purposes, only for diagnostics. "We conduct research only on mouse-adapted sheep prions, which have never been shown to be infectious to humans," Aguzzi says. Am I missing something, or is the logical conclusion that Aguzzi thinks his lab is avoiding disaster by only using mouse-adapted sheep prions, but the lady is suspected to have been infected by an injury related to "transgenic mice infected with a sheep-adapted form of BSE". I hope there's some nuance here, because otherwise it sounds like Aguzzi's lab isn't actually avoiding infection. Perhaps the lady's case isn't considered to have definitely confirmed infectiousness due to uncertainty (though no uncertainty seemed to be mentioned)? Or the mouse-adapted sheep prions Aguzzi's lab uses are different to the transgenic mice infected with a sheep-adapted form of BSE? I have no idea; it's just that the apparent conflict between these two sections jumped out to my layman's eyes.
- MathCodeLove 5y agoI don't think there's any logical conflict. They stated that they thought the type of prion they were handling couldn't infect humans. They see now they were likely wrong.
- timoth 5y agoI don't read any implication that they see they were likely wrong. According to the article, he actually refused to comment on the French cases and said their own lab "only use mouse-adapted sheep prions, which have never been shown to be infectious to humans." Not even "_had_ never been shown". It seems unclear what his view is. It immediately goes on to talk about their own discovery 10 years ago that prions could be spread through aerosols which "totally shocked" them and might "warrant re-thinking on prion biosafety guidelines" but that seems an entirely separate thing from the decision to use only sheep prions for research.
- macinjosh 5y ago
- Maursault 5y agoIt'd only be fair that if certain types of misfolded proteins are fatal that other types make you immortal or give you super powers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bottlenose 5y agoThere's work on prion disease treatment being done led by the extremely impressive Sonia Vallabh and her husband. https://www.broadinstitute.org/bios/sonia-vallabh https://www.broadinstitute.org/bios/sonia-vallabh She discovered she has the gene for fatal familial insomnia when her mother died of it. She and her husband retrained to be biologists and now do cutting edge prion research. They have made some pretty substantial progress towards both better understanding and tracking of prion disease and also potential therapy. https://www.genengnews.com/news/potential-prion-disease-treatment-found-in-antisense-therapy/#:~:text=Prion%20disease%20is%20caused%20by,therapeutic%20approach%20in%20prion%20disease https://www.genengnews.com/news/potential-prion-disease-trea...