19 ms·
Why Galesburg has no money
- duxup 5y agoThis seems to be largely focused on road maintenance and property taxes. Are those really the only factors in that area? I know plenty of spread out small towns that do fine with such scattered developments. I’m also a little skeptical of “our population is shrinking, let’s build tiny houses “.
- sackofmugs 5y agoI don't understand why they divide the appraised value by three, then compute 1.5% property tax from it and say they can't raise it any higher. Where I live, our property tax rate is higher even with a homestead exemption AND we don't divide by three. Simply removing the division would fix the revenue problem according to the article's math. More specifically, right now I just checked and I pay 1.6% of my home's appraised market value each year as property tax. Galesburg pays 0.5%. So there's an easy fix.
- Findeton 5y agoDon't people think it's just crazy having to pay the overlords a wealth tax? One thing is to pay for capital gains or new income, but you already paid taxes when you bought the house/property.
- imtringued 5y agoIt is crazy to have private ownership over publicly funded services. The government built the infrastructure that made your plot of land valuable so it is only fair to pay a land value tax. If you don't do that then the rich will become your overlord instead and they charge as much as they can get away with.
- igorkraw 5y agoThere are people (free market people, not communists) who'd argue the idea of owning land as a private person and extracting rent/speculation is folly itself and who'd argue you should either pay much higher taxes (Georgism) or they you should only be able to lease land from the community around you. Free market capitalism doesn't work well (in terms of social welfare) with natural monopolies, and land could be called the ultimate natural monopoly.
- radu_floricica 5y agoEh, that's an extreme position. Mostly we say that property taxes should be around half the land rent value, i.e. around half the value the property generates without taking into account what's built on it. This has the rather obvious difficulty of having to estimate the yearly value generated by the land itself, which is a topic too large for me (but solvable), while having a large number of advantages. It aligns incentives very very well, and that's hella important. If a municipality develops an area with proper regulation, infrastructure and various services, the land value grows which gives them extra income. It has a much more direct invest->income dynamic. It also incentivizes owners to be a lot more aligned to the interests of the community around them. You want to have a home with a large yard in the middle of the city, instead of developing it more in line with the location? You can, but you'll pay for it. It also forces owners to align to the community around them continuously. If currently you own a piece of land which is way underdeveloped, the only moment when anybody even cares about this is when it's being sold. As opposed to having to adjust each year to current land value and land taxes - you're not forced to do something about it, but it's surely on your mind a lot more when you see taxes grow. Ah, and it fixes NIMBY, and dramatically lowers rent. Apartment buildings are very efficient, so they'll be favored exactly where they make sense - in crowded, high-value land areas.
- pessimizer 5y agoWhy half? Is that just an arbitrary number?
- radu_floricica 5y agoTheory says 100%, half is just a realistic target.
- imtringued 5y agoBaden Würtemberg doesn't give a damn about the complexity of the assessment, they already have to assess land value for estate taxes. The assessment argument is actually complete rubbish. The assessment rules for the rest of Germany are significantly more bureaucratic. Assessing building value is an even bigger nightmare because you cannot automate the majority of assessment work. You also don't have to asess every single building. You can asess the value of bigger plots of land spanning multiple properties and allow an appeal process for special circumstances.
- tomschwiha 5y agoBut isn't it that you also need repair stuff with your house? The same for public property - it's never "finished" and needs repairing, etc.
- charcircuit 5y agoMoney spent on taxes doesn't go to fix your own property.
- meheleventyone 5y agoNo it goes to fix the shared infrastructure. People would definitely like it less if they were billed for the infrastructure costs directly. For example it’s clear here that the downtown subsidises the sprawl.
- charcircuit 5y agoBut why take it out of property tax?
- imtringued 5y agoAre you going to tax income so landowners become richer at the expense of others? Do you want landlords to charge for public services that they did not provide?
- charcircuit 5y agoI don't know. I don't like paying any tax. Maybe you could have the government start companies to make money instead of taxing others. >Do you want landlords to charge for public services that they did not provide I'm not quite sure what you mean by this, but it's not legal to sell an item or service and then not give them that item / service.
- pessimizer 5y agoDo you think that it costs the government more to protect a homeless person or a person with a house? Do you think it costs the government more to protect a person with a house, or a person with a mansion? Piles of wealth require protection. Without government protection, they would be expropriated without considerable expenses on private security. Income tax is the tax that is hard to justify. Wealth taxes are taxes to protect wealth, and sales/transaction taxes are taxes to enforce sales and transaction agreements. Libertarians believe those should be the only functions of government. If you don't even believe in those, you're an anarchist, or maybe even a Mad Maxist. edit: imagine the absurdity of people sharing a rented shed paying as much for fire and police protection as a person in a mansion.
- nivenkos 5y agoYeah, income tax is the real evil. I live in Scandinavia, and the high income tax (and no property or inheritance tax) keeps the class system intact for generations. You can't work your way up when the government is taking almost 60% of your income. That said, I'd still prioritise abolishing sales tax on groceries and electricity here. Both are incredibly expensive and make life a struggle for a lot of working people.
- mavhc 5y agoMost countries have more of a scaled income tax, but Sweden has 57% if you earn 1.5x the average. Why is that?
- _vbnz 5y agoTo keep the class system intact. The ultra-wealthy don't pay much more tax (and don't pay property or inheritance tax, and capital gains tax is also lower than income tax (wtf?)). It's a far less progressive country than the marketing would have you believe. And unfortunately all the political parties are just focussed on giving more money to the boomers or liberalising the housing market, so it won't change any time soon.
- 5y ago
- PostOnce 5y agoHouses need roads and plumbing and a fire dept and electrical and all kinds of stuff, dog catchers and such. These things aren't a buy once product, they require maintenance fees. Civilization costs money, and its worth it.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoNo, because the services you expect from living there do need to be paid some way or other. > One thing is to pay for capital gains or new income, but you already paid taxes when you bought the house/property. Servicing the property obviously costs ongoing money, so why wouldn't the taxes be ongoing?
- barnabee 5y agoNo, I think property (or better, land value) taxes are probably the most justifiable of all taxes. You are occupying land, which is scarce. Noone else can use it, but except for some accident of history or geography you have no more right to one there than anyone else. It makes total sense that you compensate society for your use of the land. There is a lot to like about Georgism.
- Proven 5y ago
- pessimizer 5y ago> Take for example the taxes I pay on my home. I pay $260.17 to the city every year in property taxes. I live on a 60 ft wide lot. If you take the $20/ft/year road maintenance metric, cut it in half because I’m just on one side of the street, and then multiply it by the width of my lot you get $600. I would need to contribute $600 a year through my property taxes to just pay for the maintenance of the portion of the street in front of my house. But I’m not, I’m contributing less than half. Almost no single family houses are contributing enough in property tax to support basic necessary maintenance of the street in front of their house. > The smallest lot width you can have in Galesburg with the current zoning code is 50ft in R3 districts. With that 50 ft lot you would need a house worth $98,500 just for the city to break even on the maintenance of your portion of the street. If you have a 100ft wide lot you need an assessed value of $197,000 to break even. While wide lots may be nice to have and historically how we’ve built housing, they have a tough time paying the city back for the services they consume. > Is every house and building going to pay for all the infrastructure it uses? No. There will be plenty that do not. Does that mean that corner lots have to be twice as valuable to pay for both the streets? Also no. Another way to look at properties in an apples to apples comparison is to use the metric of total property taxes paid per acre. Why is that? The greater the area the further road and water infrastructure needs to extend and the further away police and fire services need to travel. So comparing on a per acre basis is a good proxy for how productive it is for the city.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI pay over $4,000, for a 75-foot-square lot. People marvel at how low my taxes are. The average around here, is three times as much. It doesn't bother me that much. I live in a fairly affluent area, with good services and infrastructure. The schools are also excellent.
- airza 5y agoIt would let the revenues pay for the cost of the roads in the city, but not the rest.
- r_hoods_ghost 5y agoYeah... I'm in the UK and my council tax (nearest equivalent) is currently about 1.7% of my house's value p/a, although council tax is fairly regressive and has a hard cap. Whenever I hear Americans complaining about how terrible their infrastructure is (and it is compared to every other developed country I've ever been to) I can't help but wonder why you don't do the obvious thing and just pay to fix it. edit 1.7% not 2.7%!
- arethuza 5y agoInteresting, our council tax here in Fife in Scotland is about 1% of our house valuation and that includes water supply and waste water.
- r_hoods_ghost 5y agoShould have been 1.7% not 2.7%! Fat fingers. Combination of being in band C while living in a small flat that's not worth much.
- ajuc 5y agoUK has population density of 280 people per km2, most of Europe has over 100, USA has 36. It's ok if you put everybody in densely populated areas, but when you spread them around you either pay 10 times the taxes or get 10 times worse infrastructure. There's no cheating math.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoUnless you are paving the Nevada Desert, that comparison is basically useless - it includes areas where nobody lives so they need no maintenance.
- ajuc 5y agoThere are such areas in every country. USA might have more of them but not so much more that it cancels out the low population density entirely. You still have to have a road going through these areas.
- PostOnce 5y agoThe city tax isn't the only tax, they also pay county (and other?) taxes raising the total well beyond 0.5%?
- PeterisP 5y agoYes, but that's also an argument why "tripling the tax" isn't something impossible, since tripling the tax that goes to the city would mean a relatively small increase to the total property tax someone is paying.
- beowulfey 5y agoSee the pie chart in the post again -- citizens of Galesburg are paying 9.89% property tax on their home, not 0.5%. There are a lot of other taxes that make up the total property tax. Your 1.6% is incredibly low, in my experience.
- sackofmugs 5y agoI don't believe their property taxes are 10%. $50,000 per year on a $500,000 home? Come on
- sgerenser 5y agoAccording to the article, most houses are more like $50-$100k, but 10% would still be a very high property tax rate.
- beowulfey 5y agoYou’re right, I looked it up— it’s only 1.41%, I must have misread that chart myself. My state, they can go up to 7.5% so I didn’t really think too hard about it, but I think I’m desensitized to how crazy high that is…
- Dumblydorr 5y agoDoesn't Illinois have pretty high taxes to begin with? I'm not a tax expert but I've heard this repeatedly stated while living in Chicago.
- macinjosh 5y agoYeah just charge the working families just scraping by that make up a town like this 3 times more. Jobs done! /s
- kristjansson 5y agoI don’t get that part either. OTOH, an effective property tax rate of 3.2% or so seems much more reasonable that the 9.8% percent implied by his table. Assuming people but anywhere close to as much house as they can afford, the city taking 10% per year seems just confiscatory.
- wombatpm 5y agoIllinois calculates property taxes off of 1/3 assessed value. Apparently it allows the rates to not have to go out to an insane number of digits. But it gets weirder. The city/county/ whatever determines their budget and uses property taxes to determine how that cost is allocated across residents. What happens when housing prices fall? Simple! They take a multiplier, and increase all assessments by some factor. People think property taxes set the budget, when in fact the budget sets properly taxes
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoWhat a great deep dive into a fascinating subject I have never seen the actual math on. > This section of road is approximately 584 feet long and is going to cost around $350,000 This is the cornerstone of the article he uses for all other calculations. Is this number reasonable? It seems ridiculously expensive but maybe that is just how things are.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoThis article claims costs of $2-3m for a mile of two-lane road in a rural area. 584 feet is a bit over a tenth of a mile, so that cost would make sense for building a new road. Not sure whether the cost to major repairs or replacements would be higher or lower. Also gotta factor in that this article is from 2016 and right now costs for building anything seem substantially up. https://blog.midwestind.com/cost-of-building-road/ https://blog.midwestind.com/cost-of-building-road/
- silvestrov 5y agoAnd the road is in a really bad shape, ee Google StreetView: https://www.google.com/maps/@40.9373005,-90.3943558,3a,75y,339.89h,62.56t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1somcIVp4KYloQTEoJlwVGtg!2e0!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@40.9373005,-90.3943558,3a,75y,3...
- cbsmith 5y agoYeah. Fundamentally, roads are really costly. The whole notion of designing a city around cars is horribly expensive and we keep pretending that's not the case.
- lixtra 5y agoIn some countries you have to pay for the road maintenance and development along your plots. That can lead to other absurdities, that a field owner along an agricultural road has suddenly to pay for make over and street lights that add zero value to their field. A solution could be a more federal approach. Residents of the neighborhood have to decide how their taxes are used for maintenance. And they would directly feel the lack of taxes for maintenance.
- bell-cot 5y agoThat solution feels like it needs refinement... - In a commercial / industrial district (taxpaying companies, but no residents), do those taxpayers decide? - Is the "Residents...have to decide" voting weighed by how much each one is paying? It seems reasonable for Walmart to have a bigger say than any of the little stores & restaurants across the street from Walmart. - Is there some "I don't need" opt-out? A farmer growing 640 acres of corn across the road from Walmart probably doesn't even need the road to exist - the dirt roads along the other 3 sides of his field are good enough for tractors.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoThis is basically what Strong Towns harps on: the infrastructure for super low density development is extremely costly relative to how much 'stuff' you're building the infrastructure for. Initially it's not so bad, because it takes decades before you need to do replacement-level repairs/maintenance, but eventually it catches up with you. Some cities escape it (at least for a while) by building even more or by simply having a fantastic economy, but the ones that don't...it's not pretty.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThe problem boils down to this: we've vastly over-paved and in general overbuilt our road network. We've paved all sorts of roads we should have left as dirt/gravel, but they got paved because it's a sign your neighborhood has "made it." It's a pretty high level problem a well; we built a ton of bridges starting around the 50's, without anyone thinking about how we were going to pay for them. Well, those bridges are starting to crumble because repairing or replacing them would mean massive hikes in taxes, and no politician wants to touch that. Ironically, the vast majority of vehicles purchased are SUVs and trucks to the point that Ford will stop selling sedans entirely. At least everyone is prepared for the coming changes? If we hadn't allowed the automotive industry to essentially dominate american society, we'd have neighborhoods with dirt/gravel roads or narrow paved paths for walking and bicycles, neighborhood parking lots for those who own cars, functioning bus services, lots of passenger rail, etc. Instead we have a country where we're slaves to cars.
- rexreed 5y agoMany Roman roads have lasted a long while. Maybe we should move back to cobble stone? Certainly easier to patch and replace and open up for underground utilities.
- m0llusk 5y agoRoman roads were built with extremely robust foundations below which required very large amounts of labor to put in place.
- javitury 5y ago> As a town we are essentially a fixed plot of land cultivating a crop of buildings which we tax to fund our corporation This is a very interesting point of view that I have not seen anywhere else. However it omits side-effects that buildings have on citizens other than taxes, e.g. hospitals improve health, universities improve human capital of citizens, factories create network effects with respect to suppliers and retailers, etc. A healthier and more educated workforce will be more productive and a healthier business network will add more value generating more sales taxes and increasing property value.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoThe analogy has limits, but it's a useful framing when you're dealing with finances like this.
- asimpletune 5y agoYeah I was just thinking about that. Basically, using business terms, those things you mentioned should be thought of as liabilities. Maybe it's not the perfect analogy, but if everything can somewhat be captured or at least get within the right order of magnitude, I think it could maybe help guide decisions towards creating the optimal density.
- imtringued 5y agoYou can charge for the presence of the hospital through a land value tax.
- treis 5y agoIt's a good strategy when you're playing SimCity but the real world doesn't work that way. The major costs of government, as the article's pie chart clearly shows, are services to people. And in the real world dense cities spend more on services per person than rural areas. It's just the fundamental misconception that underlies all these sorts of articles. Land doesn't pay taxes and land doesn't really consume resources. People do.
- ghaff 5y ago
- TulliusCicero 5y agoIt seems like the root problem is that the way property taxes are assessed doesn’t actually line up with how much demand a given development puts on the city for services/infrastructure. Property taxes are based on, “how much would someone else pay for this”, which isn’t the relevant metric from the city’s perspective, it should be, “approximately how expensive is this property to service year by year, including eventual replacement of infrastructure?” If you did it that way, low density developments would pay their true costs, and would become more expensive to the ‘end user’ and thus less popular. And if they didn’t, well, they're paying their true costs anyway, so problem solved.
- netcan 5y agoPartially, but only partially if you take this sentence literally: "our town is essentially a corporation where the citizens are the investors and stakeholders.. We are a real estate development company that also provides services... with holdings totaling $1.29 billion," Apple is essentially the stakeholder in the Apple ecosystem. Some decisions are made as you suggest. Apple price phones and laptops such that costs are covered and profits are made. Some decisions are "strategic." There's no direct revenue from their photo app, but a photo app helps sell phones and (more importantly) if Apple doesn't provide one then FB or Google will. A lot of Apple's decisions are like this. Some, currently very important decisions are all about leveraging power to extract revenue. Apple charge Google $15bn to be safari's default search option. They apply similar logic to all activity on iphones. As in-app purchases emerge, subscriptions, digital goods, physical goods or any other category emerges... Apple study that market and determine how much they can charge. It has nothing to do with how much these cost apple to support. IDK if this applies to Galesburg, but I think most towns/governments/municipalities have the power to generate a lot more revenue than they do... certainly during a building boom. What Apple would be doing in this position is (a) determining where real estate profits are being made (b) moving to claim the majority of those profits as revenue. I'm not saying they should do this, but the point of difference is worth noting.
- sokoloff 5y agoMaybe banning the import of anything from the outside and charging a 30% sales tax is the answer?
- khanan 5y agoI listened to their radio station for a while, it was all Jesus and God. This is why they have no money.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ejb999 5y agobigoted much?
- ajuc 5y ago> The last paragraph sounds like something we’ve all heard before. Anti-progress and looking at the past with rose colored glasses. Building cities around cars is not progress, and arguing for making them pedestrian-friendly isn't "anti-progress". Suburbanization is just one possible development path and one that's not particularly smart. To fight suburbanization the only thing that will work is taxing external costs. So you want to live 30 km away from the city but enjoy all the benefits - work there, have access to culture, entertainment and services on demand? Pay for the infrastructure that city needs to maintain to let you do it. This would make suburban lifestyle very expansive and would stop suburbanization. But people won't vote for this, because they want the profits and someone else to pay for the costs.
- sokoloff 5y agoPlenty of people want to live in the suburbs precisely because they want nothing to do with the city center. They live outside it; they work outside it (often on a ring road built specifically to avoid the city); they shop outside it; they view any requirement to go into the city as a schlep. If the only “new” penalty is they can’t go see the pro sports team in person without paying a lot of taxes, that seems like a fair trade. (Or they’ll go see the NE Patriots at the stadium a little over 25 miles from the city.)
- ajuc 5y ago> often on a ring road built specifically to avoid the city I wonder who financed the ring road. Curious that we don't build ring roads where there's no cities. > If the only “new” penalty is they can’t go see the pro sports team in person without paying a lot of taxes The new penalty should be "you want to live in 100 km radius of a city - you chip in for infrastructure it builds the more the further you are". It's no accident that suburbanization doesn't happen in areas where there are no big cities nearby. > Plenty of people want to live in the suburbs precisely because they want nothing to do with the city center. Sadly you can't have suburbs without a city center somewhere nearby.
- sokoloff 5y ago
- rceDia 5y agoOther than a hospital, schools and big box retail, what is the economic "engine" attracting new homeowners? Big box retail was the place to spend the cash, but what is the source of "earn the cash"? Illinois is a top state for "fleeing" citizens.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoMaytag used to have a refrigerator manufacturing facility in Galesburg, which moved to Mexico around the turn of the aughts, and incurred a loss of thousands of jobs. Usual NAFTA hollowing out of middle America story. Can’t be a strong town when you’re a dying town. https://www.peoriamagazines.com/ibi/2015/mar/galesburg-after-maytag https://www.peoriamagazines.com/ibi/2015/mar/galesburg-after...
- everybodyknows 5y agoA private liberal arts college, 1200 students: https://www.knox.edu/about-knox/fast-facts https://www.knox.edu/about-knox/fast-facts Festivals in the historic district downtown: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galesburg_Historic_District https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galesburg_Historic_District Doesn't seem like enough. And note this: > Walmart builds their buildings to last only 15-20 years and then builds a new facility. We are in year 15 of our Walmart, so they are exploring their next rebuild. If Walmart leaves its current location ...
- niftich 5y agoBNSF Railway has a major classification yard in Galesburg. Just like other railroads, they use their Chicago yard for intermodal traffic (loading containers from the trains onto trucks and vice versa), and use a nearby yard outside of Chicago to manage general traffic. According to the Knox County Area Partnership [1], the largest employers in Knox County (of which Galesburg is the urban center) are BNSF, the hospital, the schools, Knox College, Blick Art Materials, Gates Corporation, the local government, and the prison. It's fairly common for small US towns to have the local health system, local school system, and Walmart (or the local grocery store) as the largest employers. Galesburg is more fortunate and is more like a typical midwest town, with a handful of manufacturers and warehousing-type jobs that exceed the standard rural fare, and a college also. [1] https://www.knoxpartnership.com/top-employers/ https://www.knoxpartnership.com/top-employers/
- talkingtab 5y agoIn Amsterdam, the tax laws were based on the number of feet (or meters) of street frontage. Hence even long ago houses in Amsterdam tended to go up rather than out. (I don't have a reference for this so it may not be completely correct). Clearly tax laws should focus on frontage, but even more they should focus on the long term costs of the city to provide the infrastructure.
- pooper 5y agoQuick question: who collects the taxes? Is it the local government or the central government? I suspect we need to take property taxes away from the local government to the federal government in the US so businesses cannot pressure local governments to give them a handout for opening their business there.
- ejb999 5y ago>>Clearly tax laws should focus on frontage, That really doesn't make any sense at all imo; if you have a flag lot, i.e. a small amount of frontage with a 100 acres behind it accessed by the 200'ft of road frontage, shouldn't that be taxed higher than someone with a 1/4 lot also with 200' of frontage? I object to the current state of property taxes altogether - seen too many people (in some areas) that buy a house live in in for 30 years, pay off their mortgage and are forced to sell it because all of a sudden the property taxes are $40K/year. Doesn't seem right to me. IMO, taxing people on income is much fairer - by definition as you income goes up, you can afford to pay more - but having a house that you live in go up in value really doesn't give you more ability to pay the tax bill, and we shouldn't be in the business of taxing people out of their houses. 2nd, 3rd, 4th houses - ok in that cases, but a person living in their only house shouldn't be forced to sell it just because it went up in value.
- neilparikh 5y ago> taxing people on income is much fairer - by definition as you income goes up, you can afford to pay more It's fairer in that sense, but it's not fairer in the sense of who gets the benefits from the taxes. Suppose the government constructs a transit line from income taxes. Then, the property values (and rents) near the transit line go up. So the renters in that neighbourhood essentially end up paying twice: once through their income taxes, and once through the increase in the rents they pay. On the other hand, the landowners (both landlords and owner-occupiers) essentially get "free" wealth. That doesn't seem very fair to me. Fundamentally, property values go up when the neighbourhood becomes more desirable. But the desirability comes from the actions of the community as a whole, not just the landowner. Property tax is a way for the community as a whole to reclaim (some of) the wealth that comes from that desirability. > but a person living in their only house shouldn't be forced to sell it just because it went up in value. There's a relatively easy fix for that: allow them to defer the property tax to death or when they sell the property. So they still get to live there, but when they leave, they can pay for the taxes from the profits from the sale. If we think that it's unacceptable for people to have to pay extra for when their house goes up in value, why do we think it's acceptable for them to profit from it?
- tzs 5y ago> Take for example the taxes I pay on my home. I pay $260.17 to the city every year in property taxes. I live on a 60 ft wide lot. If you take the $20/ft/year road maintenance metric, cut it in half because I’m just on one side of the street, and then multiply it by the width of my lot you get $600. I would need to contribute $600 a year through my property taxes to just pay for the maintenance of the portion of the street in front of my house. That is a questionable calculation because the street in front of their house is not just used by them. For example, consider a dead end street with 100 houses on one side and a forest on the other, with each house having the same length of street in front of them. Assume each house uses the street once a day to leave the neighborhood and once a day to return. The house at the open end of street, call it house 1, uses the segment in front of their house (call it segment 1) 2 times each day. The house next next to house 1, house 2, uses its segment (segment 2) 2 times each day and it uses segment 1 2 times each day. In general, house N uses each of segments 1 through N 2 times a day and does not use segments N+1 through 100. Looking at it from the point of view of the segments, segment 1 is used equally by 100 houses, segment 1 is used equally by 99 houses, and so on. Figuring fair share by width of lots is even more questionable. A wide but shallow lot and a narrow but deep lot of the same area with similar occupancy aren't going to inherently have different street usage (or different water, sewer, police/fire, or other tax funded service usage).
- acdha 5y agoI’m sure the author would be the first to agree that this isn’t a detailed analysis - they had various comments to that effect - but it doesn’t change the point by anywhere near enough to invalidate it. Most roads are not long dead end streets and especially now that people use navigation apps there’s a lot more traffic on neighborhood roads than there used to be, too. The big problems are low density and how much most cities end up subsidizing non-taxpayers who drive a significant fraction of road demand with only minimal economic contribution. Those subsidies are doubly expensive because they hurt the city and discourage use of more sustainable transportation.
- _dark_matter_ 5y ago"Fair share" is irrelevant, they're now designing an actual taxation policy. Instead they're trying to apportion costs to describe how high the expenses are, based on maintenance costs.
- jSully24 5y agoIn Minnesota when improvements or repairs like roadwork are done, directly effected property owners are billed above their normal property tax. This story explains it better than I can: https://www.twincities.com/2020/02/25/15700-street-assessment-stillwater-to-explore-protections-for-low-income-residents-and-others/ https://www.twincities.com/2020/02/25/15700-street-assessmen... work on a street with only local traffic will have a higher percentage of the project cost paid by the property owners on that street.
- adolph 5y agoThis seems like a way to make sure nice neighborhoods have the best maintained streets. Oddly regressive for Minnesota.
- jSully24 5y agoI had not thought about it from that perspective. That’s a great point. My thinking was that it puts real costs in front of people. You see more directly what that street to your house costs. I’ve always thought about advertising the cost of the section road you’re in costs to build, maintain, and push the snow off.
- adolph 5y agoI'd agree that putting real costs in front of people is important because what people will pay for something is critical to understanding the relative value of that thing. People don't like toll roads but given there is no free lunch, the toll of other roads is just hidden. On the other hand, I once chatted with a person who performed a large wintertime bicycle give-away in low income neighborhoods. The operation was so large that they ordered bikes directly from factories. I asked something like "why don't you put your branding on the bikes then" or something like that. The person's reply was that they didn't want the bikes to be seen as the free ones--that the bikes could be ridden without the stigma of poverty. Maybe the roads, sidewalks, bikelanes and parks in any city are likewise and the cost of them should be abstracted somewhat from the adjacent properties so that any person biking along them feels a sense of belonging.
- smoyer 5y ago"So, what do we do? Can we just pay 3x the property tax to the city and fund our roads? Our city already has pretty high property tax rates for a city in a state that already has pretty high property taxes. We can’t raise our property taxes, and we can’t raise any of the other taxes to make up for the difference. What is causing this and what do we do going forward?" I'd love to have property taxes this "high" - I live in a village outside a small rural city in PA and my property taxes are about four times as much as the author's taxes. The author states that they'd need to assess property taxes at 3x in order to fund their infrastructure so we'd (in theory) be ahead of our infrastructure maintenance. (Clearly this comparison isn't apples-to-apples since our properties aren't directly comparable.) I think the real answer is that if we're going to restore communities, we're going to have to pay more than we're accustomed to.
- kansface 5y agoMy understanding is that Illinois is in a economic death spiral wherein taxes are high enough given the quality of life that people leave the state thereby increasing the burden on those who remain l, perpetuating the cycle. Pensions are the enormous, underfunded obligation that can’t be shed outside of bankruptcy. Increasing taxes only accelerates the problem, no? Even if you could stabilize your particular city, the looming crisis for the rest of the state will still destroy you eventually as proportionally more state money goes to paying pensioners who live out of state instead of maintaining infra.
- lettergram 5y agoI’m glad we’re talking about the finances of towns here. Almost every town in America is bankrupt. I disagree somewhat with the author here around the issues. For instance, he uses the $20/ft/road and points out they need roughly double the tax base to support their current roads. Sure, that’s a way to look at it. Alternatively, they can cut back the roads, fill with gravel and honestly it might be cheaper to just build and maintain a concrete facility. If you can cut the price of laying concrete by 50% thatd also be a solution. Alternatively, pre-purchase X tons per year and reduce costs that way letting the concrete makers in the area expand and reduce overhead. Regarding city planning, yes totally agree. I’d argue the major issue is that we lost manufacturing here in the United States. Factories paid relatively well, and were running at 20% fewer people per capita in the workforce than in the 60s. This means less wealth generated across the board, less wealth in these towns, etc. Finally, IMO as a town the best investments are those that attract more jobs and wealth. So make fresh paint available for free to any businesses. Hire better police. Cut back on road quality. Cut back on taxes for businesses that bring net jobs. Invest in community activities, particularly for kids. Advertise. It’s a difficult spot to be in, the reality is that smalls towns across the country were decimated between the 1990s - 2020s. Most of it was policies sending stuff over seas and reducing wealth creation in rural towns (where factories used to run). To fix that will require some national solutions and scaling back the towns which haven’t seen growth (and many declined) in 30 years
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- acdha 5y ago> It’s a difficult spot to be in, the reality is that smalls towns across the country were decimated between the 1990s - 2020s. Most of it was policies sending stuff over seas and reducing wealth creation in rural towns (where factories used to run). I’d put this further back. Manufacturing is part of it but not everyone worked in factories before and the post-WWII white flight was part of the setup. There are two related parts to that: On the city side, that took on a lot of unfavorable trade offs – reducing tax revenues, converting neighborhoods into unproductive freeways and parking, greater expense and demand for roads, etc. On the personal side, cars lock in a lot of personal expense both up front and ongoing (how many people are one expensive repair away from potentially losing their job?), and force other choices like needing to live somewhere with storage space, deal with the health impacts, etc. I think that combination left things quite brittle and a lot of it is time-delayed by a decade or two, at which point it’s much harder to reverse. Losing a factory hurts but so did losing most of the workers a generation earlier, and the resulting economic climate from both makes finding replacements harder.
- dfadsadsf 5y agoI saw a few articles like that on Strongtown. They make for a good story but frankly economically they do not make sense for me. In my surburban town with pretty big lots, school taxes are 2/3 of property tax and things that are more expensive in surburban setting than in the city (roads, sewer, electric, gas hookups) are something like 10% of taxes. Even in this story, city currently spends 3.2M/year maintaining the roads. City has 15k housing units so city currently spends roughly $200/house on roads. It's $16/month. Author thinks city actually need to spend 4.2M - this is $280/year per house which is only $23/month. That's really not much even if cost need to be doubled. Hardly unaffordable. This is per dwelling - not even per person and does not count that commercial buildings pay more so residential rate is even lower. Electric/water/sewers generally pay for themselves thru user fee - I think average is $20-60/month/house for sewer/water in US and electric is thru usage fee. School busing in rural setting is probably a bit more expensive but is still rounding error in overall school budget. Everything else - school, governance, police, fire are probably about the same in rural areas and in the dense city. SF is a shit city with 15k/year spending per person and most rural/suburban areas are much nicer on a fraction of that spending. Overall rural lifestyle does not cost much more than the city in infrastructure costs - and I did similar calculations for previous strongtown articles. On a feeling level it make sense that dense city should be cheaper but reality is frankly it's not. US cities has a lot of problems but frankly cost of maintaining roads is not the thing that will bankrupt them.
- 300bps 5y agoYeah I saw his property tax of $1,600 per year and how it was already too high to raise. Tax rates of $8,000 to $20,000 are common around me.
- cableshaft 5y agoGalesburg is a declining city in the middle of nowhere. People who live there probably drive to work ~50 miles away to Peoria or Davenport/Moline every day if they don't have a (probably) low paying job in town. And if that's the case, they'd probably be better off moving closer to those cities, there's probably even cheaper homes within a shorter commute. Also it's in Illinois, which is #2 in the country for highest overall property taxes[1]. Keep in mind he said a reasonable house value just north of their downtown is $75k, where the national average price for a home is $374k (as of Q2 2021), which is 5x the price. $1600 * 5 = $8000, which brings it up to what's near you. And considering Illinois' property tax is higher than every other state other than New Jersey, I'm guessing the homes appraised value near you is likely a lot higher than $374k, even. That being said, I don't understand why the government wouldn't be able to up just the city's percentage (as opposed to all line items on the property tax bill) by about $100-200/yr per person and use that to help close the gap. The percent going to the city of Galesburg is currently a tiny percentage of the overall tax. [1]: https://www.illinoispolicy.org/illinois-again-ranks-no-2-in-u-s-for-highest-property-taxes/ https://www.illinoispolicy.org/illinois-again-ranks-no-2-in-...
- tr33house 5y agoThis is a general statement about smaller towns in general: I also think that the fact that the US birth rate is falling (for a myriad of reasons) is partly to blame. Not that the author can do anything in particular about it but it's a problem we must face as a society
- Dumblydorr 5y agoYeah, the author's video shows a hustling bustling main street with children running around. Today, the children are half as numerous, and they're all inside to be sheltered from the lethal traffic that they could run into. I have many acquaintances who won't procreate for economic or climate reasons. I totally get that, however if everyone chose that path, there'd be no more human race, other than the occasional accidental child. That would lead to demographic collapse, the aging populace wouldn't have anyone to support their wants and needs. Not a good outcome.
- AndroidKitKat 5y agoI don't live there anymore, but it so weird to see my hometown on the front page of Hacker News. Some of my friends still live there and it is depressing to hear them talk about what's going on. When I have gone back and visited, nothing seems to be the same anymore, save for the few restaurants I liked.
- stephaniepier 5y agoSmall world, it's my hometown too! I had to do a double take when I saw the headline. My parents are still there but they're looking to leave. It's so different there than it was 20-30 years ago.
- perardi 5y agoNot quite my hometown, but in the same Central Illinois area. (Farmington. Go Farmers.) And yeah, I had to do a heck of a double-take when I saw “Galesburg” on the page here. At least some of the towns/cities in Central Illinois have had a little success in revamping their economies. Canton (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canton,_Illinois https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canton,_Illinois) comes to mind.
- op00to 5y agoApparently fire codes don’t exist in this dudes mind.
- Dumblydorr 5y agoThe damage inflicted onto roads by vehicles goes up by the fourth power of the vehicles weight. So, should average citizens be on the hook for most road repairs, or should those who utilize extremely heavy trucks? Furthermore, as society progresses, we're not going to need so many roads. Either we'll technologically eclipse them, or sociologically we'll reorient our society towards walking and biking. I don't see us having nearly the amount of road maintenance in future as we do now.
- umvi 5y ago> So, should average citizens be on the hook for most road repairs, or should those who utilize extremely heavy trucks? You can scapegoat the trucks, but average citizens are utilizing heavy trucks (indirectly) by buying stuff on Amazon or Walmart (to name a few examples).
- notch656a 5y agoPeople who don't drive any vehicle take advantage of that. So it's small vehicle drivers subsidizing [via fuel tax] those who don't drive at all, yet take advantage of shipping via heavy truck.
- trgn 5y agoWhy preserve the opacity of that relationship? Tax trucks higher, and it will reflect in the prices of the products those trucks are hauling, fairly distributing the cost increase of their operation across the consumers of those products. We absolutely should tax goods and services based on the negative externalities they impose. Taxing vehicles by weight is a fair tax, much more fair than doing the _exact_ opposite right now, work trucks being taxed less. Heavy vehicles used productively will remain, but spending on heavy vehicles for recreation will be less attractive, since that kind of use consumers balance against other discriminatory spending.
- perpetualpatzer 5y agoTrue, but average citizens don't _choose_ to use heavy trucks. I'm not sure of the relative costs of road repair v. fuel, but if you funded roads entirely through a tax on the fourth power of vehicle weight (if that's the right proxy for repair costs incurred), Walmart might find they could reduce total costs in the system by using fewer large trucks and shift their logistics mix.
- lr4444lr 5y agoThe fallacy here is fixed costs. A capital project to repair just 584 ft. of road is insane. The author then projects these outsized fixed costs as the variable cost of fixing all roads in the town. This kind of small job is either something you petition the state dept. of transit to do in a special division they have for these things, or you find some temporary workaround until a more comprehensive road repair plan is warranted. Yes, even in big well funded cities sometimes roads are just detoured for months if not longer. The budgetary breakdown of the towns I've lived in simply do not support this thesis. The major cost is always schools and to a lesser but noticeable extent the police, specifically the labor and pensions. Not roads.
- Macha 5y agoThe argument is that the cost cities are paying for the roads is less than they need to. Underfund a school by 50% and there are immediate consequences - class sizes go up, more consumable supplies like photocopying, art or gym equipment run out. Student satisfaction goes way down, if they can't heat/AC the building as appropriate, they have less personal space in classrooms and less time with teachers. Underfund a road by 50% and in the first year and nothing happens. Over a few years, you get potholes. With the standards these roads are being built to, in 30 years the road is unusable. But there's no money to rebuild it. It was built the first time with revenue from new developments, but there's no such revenue now. People aren't going to sell their houses and give a comparable amount to the city as it took the developer in building it to setup that infrastructure (i.e. probably a net loss for the home owner, even with property price inflation ahead of general inflation) just because the road needs replacing.
- z3ugma 5y agoThe NotJustBikes YouTube video series on Strong Towns addresses this. One thing to look at is the collective cost of state tax, federal tax, and private debt. What’s true of all Ponzi schemes: eventually, someone has to pay. You can move the money around to different budgets all you want but it doesn’t change the fundamentals.
- iandanforth 5y agoThere are a couple good ideas in the article my favorite is: "As a town we are essentially a fixed plot of land cultivating a crop of buildings which we tax to fund our [town]." But myopic statements like "We can’t raise our property taxes, and we can’t raise any of the other taxes to make up for the difference." just strike at the heart of American self defeating ideologies. Also the statement "By being incorporated, our town is essentially a corporation where the citizens are the investors and stakeholders in the business that is Galesburg Inc." is deeply misinformed. It's like saying "We have some strawberry jam so we should us it to hold open this door because it's a jam."
- curious_cat_163 5y agoThis will sound off-topic. Not being snarky, but genuinely curious about answers: How do you ensure equality of opportunity to all students everywhere if the quality of education they receive is tied to how wealthy their town is? Surely, there can be a better answer for small towns.
- collaborative 5y agoControlling funding for education is extremely tempting for state and national politicians. It's better handled at a local level because this way you give parents a chance at choosing the type of education students receive The drawback is the inequality in funding But just to give you an example of what can happen when education is funded at a state level: majority of voters could elect an oppressive regime that targets minorities, and impose a certain type of education that is detrimental to them (i.e. not in their mother tongue)
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI do not see how you can replace the benefits of network effects of growing up in and around wealthy and knowledgeable people and their families. It is human nature to trust people more in your own network or close to your own network than outside of it.
- chrisco255 5y agoRetail isn't coming back like it was. Downtowns in the past centered almost entirely around retail businesses. The author spends a lot of time bemoaning Walmart and other big box stores, but even the box stores themselves are facing more pressure than ever from Amazon. A small retail store in a run-down third rate city doesn't stand a chance at success against the economies of scale and expectations of consumers that exist today. If a town can draw in boutique retail and bars and restaurants, it can sometimes be revitalized to an extent, but that seems to be the extent of what's possible with old downtowns.
- ghaff 5y agoI live in the country near a couple of small cities about an hour outside of a major city. The small cities are probably best described as "hanging on." I basically frequent businesses that aren't food oriented once in a blue moon--and never walk around the downtowns. I do shop in the city limits but it's mostly either a supermarket or the Walmart. The travel agency downtown sure isn't going to pull in a lot of traffic.
- mark-r 5y agoI read a story in the last couple of years about small towns that shot themselves in the foot by keeping out the big box stores - I wish I could find it again. The theory was that the traditional small downtown couldn't meet 100% of everybody's needs, so they started shopping at places like Amazon. And once you start shopping at Amazon, it just becomes convenient to do more and more of your shopping there. Suddenly instead of your downtown being killed by the big boxes a mile out of town, they're being killed by someone much bigger and farther away and harder to fight back against.
- rdtwo 5y agoYeah small retail is basically done. All that’s left if restaurants and services. And those are getting destroyed by Covid.
- swayvil 5y agoIf schools take most of the tax then reduce school funding. Is that crazy? We have a similar case in my town. Schools get most of the property tax. We're paying for laptops for all the kids. Subs are making 12/hr.
- intrasight 5y agoI live in a "strong town". On my modest home, I pay $8000/yr in property taxes. In addition I pay over $10,000 in local income tax to the town. The housing market is strong. Houses sell within days. The schools are excellent. The roads are well-maintained. The community center is awesome. Taxes are too high for sure, but we get outstanding services and facilities for those taxes. Galesburg is a city not a town. It can't benefit from the wealth effects of a town within 20 minute commuting distance (car and bus and light rail) of a major city. Small cities like Galesburgh can only thrive if they bring in significant outside money - usually in the form of tourism and tourist who decide to stay. I think of Bend OR as an example.
- twoodfin 5y ago$10,000 in local income tax? That’s something like double what the median U.S. household pays in Federal income tax! If that’s the kind of tax base required for a “strong town”, we’re really tilting at windmills here.
- sgerenser 5y agoUnless intrasight makes 1M$/year or more, that truly is an incredible income tax rate for a town.
- intrasight 5y agoOpps - that included state 3% income tax. Local income tax rate is 1.3% 0.3% of that goes to school - which is on top of the $5K from property tax that goes to school (the other $3k of property tax goes to both town and county)
- tomohawk 5y agoOne obvious problem is that the roads are too expensive to maintain, primarily because they are only built to last 20-30 years. Government expenditure favors employment over long lived infrastructure. Legislators favor distributing funds to contractors who may reciprocate with campaign funding. There's no technical reason why these roads could not be put in to last far longer than 20-30 years without major repairs. Source: family member was a civil engineer specializing in road pavement and construction for many decadeds.
- macinjosh 5y agoAn easy solution is to just not build roads for new developments. If a private interest wants to establish a new development they should pay for it all. The market will magically include all the costs in the final product (buildings/homes) and no one will be out a dime involuntarily. Things will cost what they actually cost. Some would counter that this isn’t how economic development works. Arguments would be things like businesses need incentives or the city is responsible for common infrastructure. The problem is that roads just become a form of corporate welfare. If a enterprise or business doesn’t want to fully invest in its new location, IMHO, it is not worth it and you need to face the fact that your town just isn’t ready for it yet.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gumby 5y agoI have never heard of Galesburg but I found this analysis riveting. Somehow it was more informative to me than the Strong Towns posts. I suspect you can extend this analysis to the country at large. The national budget suffers from the same imbalance.
- otikik 5y agoWhy American Cities Are Broke - The Growth Ponzi Scheme: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IsMeKl-Sv0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IsMeKl-Sv0
- qwertox 5y agoThank you. It does have a touch of "Practical Engineering" by Grady Hillhouse, but just focused on Cities and without the Engineering part. In terms of information quality and tone.
- muth02446 5y agoWhat puzzles me: if you focus on tax revenue per plot area/width, dense cities have a huge advantage - not even considering economies of scale and stuff like savings for heating/AC. And yet dense cities tend to have much higher cost of living and run huge deficits. How can this be explained?
- honkycat 5y agoI grew up in Forgottonia, about an hour from here. I have to say... A lot of the problem is brain drain, lack of nature and recreational activities... And the factories did leave. Forgottonia gets its name because it missed out on a lot of economic development and was essentially bypasses by the highway system, which lead to factories moving away and the region becoming impoverished. I am sure there are many beautiful and wonderful small communities out there, but the people have left this area and they are not coming back. The jobs are not coming back, they are not going to build more infrastructure, there is nothing notable except for cornfields and flat forest land to bring people in. I'm sure the poor infrastructure planning did not help, but my opinion is that the problem with Burlington is that it has nothing to offer anyone anymore.
- _keats 5y ago> Walmart builds their buildings to last only 15-20 years and then builds a new facility. I'm really curious about the 15-20 year statistic that the author mentions and I was disappointed not to see a source on that claim. I couldn't find much from official sources after a quick search. That seems like an incredibly short lifespan, especially for buildings so large. Great article nonetheless.
- eldavido 5y agoThe claim is correct, but incomplete. It's true that many commercial real estate developers design buildings to roughly match depreciation lifetimes, reason being, depreciation reduces tax and once your basis hits zero (the item is fully depreciated), you can't use depreciation to shield any more taxable income. The base depreciation lifetime of US commercial real estate is 39 years though, not 15-20. The other elephant in the room is that building to last is really expensive, at least upfront. So it isn't, and perhaps shouldn't, be something we do for everything. Every town has "forever buildings": schools, village halls, religious institutions. Places that cater to basic needs that aren't going to change. Imagine a typical "old" American school: a giant brick building, with a steam boiler, well-made doors, and thick walls. This is what "built to last" looks like. There are often ornamental features like murals on the outside walls. Ditto for churches: thick, heavy buildings with materials like marble or other stone. Old, well-made houses are the same way. This isn't how big box stores are made. They have way more drywall, polished concrete floors (definitely not tile), cheapo sliding doors, thin walls with stucco or other flimsy materials, standardized designs that don't change based on where they are (vs. something designed specifically for the area), and giant parking lots. The entire mentality is different. These are built to last a couple decades, then get taken down, or demolished. It's actually the same with McMansions, giant 4000 square foot houses in deep suburban areas. One other thing, read patio11's "Mortgages are a manufactured product" [1] -- CRE (buildings) is also a "manufactured" product for a lot of the same reasons, namely, there are buyers in the economy that structurally desire regular income streams (rental payments) from these buildings, and the fact that they're a Walgreens, or a Wal-Mart, or whatever else, barely even registers. The "customer" of a lot of this stuff is the pension fund / endowment that ends up holding the debt on the property, not the people or businesses that actually, you know, occupy the place day-to-day. Source: husband of an architect, and commercial real estate owner/manager [1] https://bam.kalzumeus.com/archive/mortgages-are-a-manufactured-product/ https://bam.kalzumeus.com/archive/mortgages-are-a-manufactur...
- brazzy 5y agoI don't know in what kind of fantasy world you live in. Pretty much everywhere the dominating trend is people moving to cities in droves while the countryside degrades, because it cannot provide the services people want. Can you name any city that has "irretrievably collapsed" in that way? Just one?
- UIUC_06 5y ago> Pretty much everywhere Um, no. If you mean "moving to blue cities" no, that is not the trend. Just the opposite, in fact. As for "can you name any city": Sure. How about Detroit, Cleveland, Newark, Camden, Baltimore, Akron, Hartford, Flint, Cairo, St. Louis, East St. Louis for starters?
- Daishiman 5y agoNewark and the adjacent Jersey City and Kearny have seen a lot of development in the past decade, new high rises, and new shops.
- brazzy 5y ago> If you mean "moving to blue cities" no, I mean "moving to cities", period. > that is not the trend. Just the opposite, in fact. Source, please. > Detroit, Cleveland, Newark, Camden, Baltimore, Akron, Hartford, Flint, Cairo, St. Louis, East St. Louis for starters? Don't have the time to debunk every single one of those, but the first three are absolutely not examples of the claims "The people running the cities run them into the ground by applying more and more gold plating to the services they provide" or even "People move out of cities because they do not feel safe, and the services suck." Those cities experienced decline due to deindustrialization: the over-reliance on certain manufacturing industries like steel and automotive to provide jobs, which were lost to international competition. People moved away because they could not find work. Nor are those cities examples of "it all collapses and is irretrievable" - the population of Newark and Cleveland has plateaued since the 1990s and is now seeing slight increases. And even Detroit has seen a continuous decrease of poverty and crime rates in the last 10 years.
- 5y ago
- runxel 5y agoEventually they will realize that the zoning laws are the culprit. Until then most US urban planning will stay the sh*t show it is.
- citizenpaul 5y agoI remember about 8 years ago I read a very interesting report (Bloomberg?) that said basically over 50% of American cities have overbuilt highly inefficient infrastructure and cannot even by greatly raising taxes continue to maintain them. I think it called them zombie cities or something like that. The only choice for the distant suburbs will be to come up with some sort of self sustaining infrastructure (old farmhouse style) or abandon the suburbs and move closer to the city.
- tankenmate 5y agoThe prime example of overbuilt highly inefficient (and unsafe) infrastructure that comes to mind for me is the "Stroad"[0]; it's somewhat like a comment that Elon Musk made about optimising something that shouldn't be there. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORzNZUeUHAM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORzNZUeUHAM
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- siruncledrew 5y agoGreat, thorough read. As someone that doesn’t have any life experience of what towns/suburban development was like prior to the 1990s, what was interesting is the part where the article brought up the types of big changes happening after WWII. Building roads everywhere, zoning houses with big yards, building big new commercial complexes on the outskirts because they needed more land. It seems like there was a ton of exuberance and pride post-WWII, but terrible investment strategizing. All these “developments of the future” saddle so much cost over time that it makes the financial balancing act to stay long-term sustainable very precarious. (Of course, this is all retrospective looking after the fact). What seems like a crazy takeaway is: with these towns like Galesburg that have been around over 150 years, it seems like the town planners in the 1870s had better judgement than the ones post-WWII. Despite the conventional thinking of the last 60 years across these towns being all those bad investment decisions were believed to be the pinnacle of American real estate development and bonafide testaments of greatness.
- masklinn 5y ago> It seems like there was a ton of exuberance and pride post-WWII, but terrible investment strategizing. All these “developments of the future” saddle so much cost over time that it makes the financial balancing act to stay long-term sustainable very precarious. (Of course, this is all retrospective looking after the fact). Do note that it was not just "exuberance and pride", it was also a way to get white families out of inner-city mixed-race neighbourhoods, and to enforce segregation. This was not a secret either e.g. William Levitt refused to sell levittown homes to racial minorities, and deeds came with a racial covenant.
- throwawayboise 5y agoHow does this matter to how we tackle the financial problems of cities in 2022?
- masklinn 5y ago… I was specifically replying to a segment about the reasoning behind the creation of those places, to indicate that financial viability far from the only input into their design. If these cities were not created with financial viability at the forefront, it’s unlikely you can magically make them financially viable. But I guess you’re more of the “ignoring inconvenient history” persuasion. I’ve had bosses like that, always asking for solutions to the problems they’d created (against advice) and oddly enough never interested in riot cause analysis when there was any chance it would not be favorable to them.
- stillsut 5y ago"With a crime rate of 40 per one thousand residents, Galesburg has one of the highest crime rates in America compared to all communities of all sizes - from the smallest towns to the very largest cities. One's chance of becoming a victim of either violent or property crime here is one in 25." Yeah OK, Strongtowns, let's scrutinize the road budgets (~5% of the property taxes). Who wants to live in these hypothetical high density developments when you can't even be safe?
- conjecTech 5y agoTheir argument is that road budgets are a consequence of the same poor designs that lead to conditions that promote crime as well. Busy streets tend to be safer. Additionally, places that aren't economically self-sustaining drive people to property crime. All of this is addressed in the first pages of "The Death and Life of Great American Cities".
- closeparen 5y agoPerhaps small town and exurban governments will at some point find it cheaper to purchase lifted pickup trucks for all three families in their community who don’t already have one.
- mcguire 5y agoThe Kensington looks to be 7 stories, .44 acres; that gives it about 134,000 sq ft. There are 171 1-bed, 1-bath units, (and apparently 2-bed units) so ~800 sq ft per apartment. Its total property tax bill is $82,000, or about $480 per apartment, or about $1.60 per sq ft. (That's a little odd, since apartments.com shows a "similar rentals nearby" 1-bed, 1-bath apartment as $450 per mo. (But it's 250 sq ft. (OTOH, The Kensington is unlikely to be entirely devoted to apartments. YMMV.)) In comparison, the author's property (.18 ac, $1693.14 per year) is about 22¢ per sq ft. So here's my question for the author: Would you be willing to live in an 800 sq ft apartment paying 7 times more property taxes, per sq ft, or roughly 1/4 total? (Oh, by the way, The Kensington is an assisted living facility, meaning that the residents are likely paying somewhat more than $480 per month (or at least Medicare is), which is likely why they can afford $82,000 per year in property taxes rather the Kensington being an empty building. (Trying to fill downtown with assisted living facilities is an exercise for the reader.) "You could build 3 of these 18 foot wide houses and people would want to live in them and they’d be profitable for the city per the infrastructure needed." Here's a collection of 18 foot wide house plans: https://houseplans.co/house-plans/search/results/?q=&am=&ax=&wm=&wx=18&dm=&dx= https://houseplans.co/house-plans/search/results/?q=&am=&ax=... And here's realtor.com on Galesburg: https://www.realtor.com/realestateandhomes-search/Galesburg_IL https://www.realtor.com/realestateandhomes-search/Galesburg_... * https://www.apartments.com/the-kensington-galesburg-il/qyk39zy/ https://www.apartments.com/the-kensington-galesburg-il/qyk39... * https://thekensington.net/index.htm https://thekensington.net/index.htm
- kragen 5y agoThe real answer is that young people move to Peoria so they can get a job. It's not just that people took advantage of cars to build houses with bigger yards further from where they did their shopping on Main Street, or even that they switched to doing their shopping at the Walmart out on the fringes; it's also that they took advantage of cars to leave their houses where they were and do their shopping in Peoria. They mostly couldn't do that in 01912, even if they did have a Ford. In 01912 nearby farmers would go to Galesburg to do their shopping and ship their corn by rail; now the farmers have mostly been replaced by tractors, and the remaining farmers can just as well drive their pickup to Davenport, an hour away on I-74, for the wider selection. Or order from Amazon. The article focuses a bit on property tax rates and tax assessments, but those are sort of a distraction, because they just have to do with how the paying of the costs is distributed. The problem is not that Galesburg is full of fat cats not paying their fair share to maintain common infrastructure, or that it's some kind of tax haven where everything well-maintained is privatized. (To be fair, the article does explain this.) The problem is that people in Galesburg are poor, because the economy left, so they can't afford to maintain the infrastructure they're using. An extra US$1200 per family per year to maintain the roads wouldn't be a significant burden in a place with a prosperous economy. Shrinking that infrastructure by redirecting development to downtown is one way to accommodate that reality, but it will probably just accelerate Galesburg's decline. The reason kids aren't playing in Main Street anymore is that it's US Highway 150, full of cars, truck exhaust, truck noise, and speeding trucks. In 01912 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XgucvsVEigA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XgucvsVEigA it was full of horse-drawn carriages with the occasional Ford or streetcar, and no trucks. If you give up your "big houses with big yards out on the edge of town" to move to downtown Galesburg, you aren't going to get a street where you can have a pleasant stroll down the middle of Main Street for relaxation. You're going to get semis honking air horns at you if you try it. Downtown business districts are primarily about information delivery. The reason that commercial real estate is valued by "location, location, location" is that people will buy from your store if they see it when they walk by, and they won't if they don't. If you're selling your stuff on Amazon, MercadoLibre, Etsy, or eBay, there's no benefit to having big plate glass windows in a high-pedestrian-traffic area; you might as well be in a warehouse out on the edge of town or on the 7th floor of an apartment building. But if you're near FedEx's national air distribution hub, you might have a significant advantage. In the particular case of roads, Galesburg would be able to afford road maintenance if the roads were used by pedestrians, bicycles, four-wheelers, or maybe even cars, but when they're used by SUVs and semis, they get potholes pretty quickly. But truck driving is one of the few decent jobs left in Galesburg, so you can't just ban it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galesburg,_Illinois#Demographics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galesburg,_Illinois#Demographi... shows how Galesburg has been slowly shrinking since 01970.
- obblekk 5y agoThis is very clearly laid out writing - props! Only suggestion is to add 1 more option for the town: pass the cost of excess road maintenance to the owner of the land where the road goes. At the end of the day, I don't particularly mind if Walmart/the mall want wastefully gigantic lots, so long as they pay for their privilege. The issue is not enjoying the luxury of space, but saddling other people will the bill for it. If these large plots were required to pay extra taxes (much like your "downtown special tax") their property values would be lower, and the corporations would take that extra cost into mind before setting up business. That might result in them concluding "people really like driving to the mall because it's so much easier to haul back a bunch of stuff... we'll pay for the extra roads!", or "gee we really should condense into that old building downtown." Both would be sustainable for the city, and the free giveaway to rural / low density areas would end. That's all that's required... no extra subsidies, no extra penalties. Just aim for neutrality.
- alex_young 5y ago"Why Galesburg has no money" never even suggests that Galesburg has no money. Not only that, but it never tells us anything about the actual financial shape of this town. Is Galesburg running in the red? It's not easy to tell from searching. It's a 30k person town, so that doesn't really surprise me. I don't really understand why road maintenance is the huge problem Strong Towns thinks it is. The Urban Institute says that roads and highways account for about 5% of spending by state and local governments [1]. I agree that development in an urban core is way better than sprawl, but I don't think road costs are the big issue. Quality of life and being able to walk to stuff seems a lot more important, and honestly if you want to save some money in a municipality, you should start looking at stuff like correction expenditures which have increased by over 350% since the late 70s [2]. [1] https://www.urban.org/policy-centers/cross-center-initiatives/state-and-local-finance-initiative/state-and-local-backgrounders/highway-and-road-expenditures https://www.urban.org/policy-centers/cross-center-initiative... [2] https://www.urban.org/policy-centers/cross-center-initiatives/state-and-local-finance-initiative/state-and-local-backgrounders/criminal-justice-police-corrections-courts-expenditures#Question3Police https://www.urban.org/policy-centers/cross-center-initiative...
- titanomachy 5y agoRoads don’t have to be the biggest infrastructure cost in order for the argument to hold. You can say “this proposed development is financially unsustainable, it can’t even pay for its own roads, let alone all the other services it uses!” It’s helpful to have a simple heuristic like that to explain to non-experts why a project doesn’t make sense.