8 ms·
Outdoor cats are using $500 Starlink satellite dishes as self-heating beds
- betwixthewires 5y ago
- uejfiweun 5y agoHaha, this is one of the funniest things I've seen in a long time. Wouldn't be surprised at all to see Musk incorporate this into the marketing in some way.
- mbg721 5y agoI just figured this was a feature that improved the reception, something like the old (true?) urban-legend that holding your car unlocker keyfob up against your skull increases its range by using the fluids in your head as an amplifier.
- wmeredith 5y agoIt uses the bones in your skull as an antenna amplifier and it works. This is pretty easy to test out. I can work my car remotely from further away if I hold the fob to my jaw.
- throwawayboise 5y agoYeah that actually works.
- paulcole 5y agoElon in shambles that he didn’t think to charge extra for this.
- arcticbull 5y agoHe's going to have to find a way to pump a cat-based crypto.
- Pasorrijer 5y agoLike Stoner Cats!
- vmception 5y agoNyanLinkInu Honestly, if you like money this is something you can do. You can do this and avoid ripping off other people by setting an equally balanced liquidity pool with 100% of the tokens created, and letting them play greater fool theory with each other. At this point its just the entertainment sector. Nobody can sell below the initial price of the token due to how liquidity pool systems work, and this means you are have no way to make them your exit liquidity. You can still make money by programming in a trading tax that is also auto-liquidated to any token you like, such as a stablecoin. This is extremely common, things like this are launched probably once every minute. No advertising necessary since people and bots just watch the blockchains for liquidity pools being deployed. They want to be first, so trade and ask questions later. Its up to you to consider the community, but you can build in a lot of confidence by burning your liquidity pool access and doing some other obvious things so people don't have to care about what your intentions are.
- jondwillis 5y agoYou’ve put enough thought into this to just go ahead and do it, I think.
- vmception 5y agoI have other stuff to do and make enough. Actually there was something I wanted to buy, yeah this could be a quick fun thing to do. I can also do it for other ppl, email in bio
- HWR_14 5y agoWhat is an "equally balanced liquidity pool" and why would no one be able to ever sell below the initial price of the token?
- fnord77 5y ago> Starlink satellites are responsible for 1,600 near-crashes in orbit every week, reports Futurism’s Dan Robitzski, a number that he reports is likely to increase as Starlink plans to launch more satellites.
- throwhauser 5y agoI did some googling and there seems to be some truth to this, although following the numerical estimate back toward the source finds "near-crashes" expressed less dramatically as "close encounters", defined as within 1km, most of which occur with other Starlink satellites.
- kiwijamo 5y agoI'm curious to see if this could get any worse when all 12,000 of their satellites are up there. Plus not to mention there could be competitors putting up another 12k of their own satellites.
- tigershark 5y agoDo you mean 42k? 11k was only the first phase.
- bpodgursky 5y agoYou know this is not true in any meaningful sense of the word "near-crash", because Starlink satellites have been in orbit for years and have not collided with anything. When you drive down the highway, do you consider every passing car a "near-miss"? That is the only way that your statement seems at all plausibly correct.
- noahtallen 5y agoI agree with you, but noting that the comment is a direct quote from the article, which includes a bit of controversy at the end to keep the article sufficiently polarizing ;)
- 5y ago
- martyvis 5y agoClearly using a CAT5 physical layer.
- deepsquirrelnet 5y ago
- Lammy 5y ago"CATS: All your base are belong to us."
- judge2020 5y agoOn that note, the new starlink connector is absurd. It's apparently shielded cat5e but with a custom connector[0]. 0: https://redd.it/s0rih3 https://redd.it/s0rih3 and https://redd.it/rmtxjq https://redd.it/rmtxjq (direct link to main image: https://l.judge.sh/ZCg5 https://l.judge.sh/ZCg5 )
- Tempest1981 5y agoLooks almost like mini-HDMI? Is there a better way to do an outdoor Cat5 connector? On mine, the Cat5 female port always ends up being a home for small spider families.
- petre 5y agoJust plug an empty connector in it.
- Tempest1981 5y agoI have. They can still get through, maybe around the latch tab. Insects can be quite tiny.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- qbasic_forever 5y agoIf you built a small elevated box with an entry hole, placed the starlink on top, and then put a plastic dome or shroud around the starlink so cats couldn't rest on top you'd make everyone happy. The warmth of the dish would keep the little nest below it comfortable for cats, and you'd be happy with good reception.
- suzzer99 5y agoCats like to have a perch to see the comings and goings in their territory, at least during the day. I believe in the big viral photo the cats in the dish have a heated cathouse nearby, which they only use at night.
- More-nitors 5y agoif it's possible to put a plastic dome, can we just make the dome such that the snow won't build up? (which will probably make self-heating unnecessary... or are there temperature requirements?)
- scarab92 5y agoStarlink dishes don't have a dedicated heater inside to melt snow. I don't know where the author of the article got that idea from. They are just power hungry and produce enough waste heat that it's not a problem.
- fignews 5y agoI think the idea is they can run extra-inefficiency to produce even more heat if needed.
- ChuckMcM 5y agoWe have a pretty decent hawk and owl population so perhaps that discourages cats from sleeping out in the open on a serving plate.
- animal531 5y agoIt would have to be a pretty sharp shape to deter a cat, perhaps a traffic cone type configuration would work well.
- eyelidlessness 5y agoGlad to see this is getting some lighthearted response. Surprised because lots of these cats are probably mousers ^_^
- dboreham 5y agoI suspect this image was staged. I have dishy, and cats, and snow, and the dish doesn't get hot enough to interest the cats.
- nosianu 5y agoSo with a sample of 1 you declare another sample of 1 as false with enough confidence for an online press release. I don't know, this kind of statement does not sound right to me. I would expect for plenty of samples of 1 to be different unless I can be sure the distribution of possible results is really narrow and limited. Both cats and the context (how long were they out, when was the last meal - digesting creates heat, how cold is it, etc.) have quite a large number of possibilities.
- remram 5y agoClearly needs MORE SATELLITES
- Syonyk 5y ago"Staging" a picture with that many cats at once seems rather less likely than the alternative of "They found a warm spot that also annoys the nearby humans."
- anonimo37 5y agoIf the cats had access to the indoors there would be no reason for them to want to be on the dish. I assume these are feral cats, probably from the same litter, as 5 random cats would not want to get that close to each other.
- wheresmycraisin 5y agoWow those things must be strong! That's 50+ pounds of cat in that picture.
- usrusr 5y agoKessler's cat syndrome?
- DesiLurker 5y agocat-estrophic failure
- tw04 5y agoI still can't fathom why anyone thinks it's OK to leave cats outside to roam free. They decimate the songbird population and kill for fun. You want to talk about low-hanging fruit to protect mother nature? Keep your cats inside or tethered if they're outside... we expect it from dog owners, and rightly so. Not sure why people with cats think they should be free to roam.
- jmspring 5y agoI have five cats. They are indoor / outdoor (I get them inside before dark). Living in a rural (forest) area, there is a fair amount of critters around. In the last six years, there have been maybe 6-8 birds caught and about 2 chickarees (small, fast squirrels - one was caught my since deceased senior cat). Cats are hunters for sure, but not all decimate things.
- nosianu 5y ago> I still can't fathom why anyone thinks it's OK to leave cats outside to roam free. See, I can't fathom the opposite. Cats belong outdoors. I will never have an indoor cat. Vote me down as much as you like, THAT is unnatural (I will also not have exoctic cats that could only live indoors). The greatest danger to songbirds is human changes to the environment, not cats, by several orders of magnitude. Animals having predators is not exactly unnatural, to put it carefully. Although I do wish we could create cats, by selection or some day by gene editing, that leave birds alone completely.
- More-nitors 5y ago> Animals having predators is not exactly unnatural, to put it carefully. uh... but if those predators are bred by humans, it's unnatural
- nosianu 5y agoWe do? I know of pup mills, I am unaware of cat mills. Maybe for exotic cats, but those would be the types people keep at home because they would not fare so well outside anyway. And since when is one species doing something that benefits another unnatural? That exists among animals too.
- jcims 5y agoHeats people too - https://twitter.com/lucysrausch/status/1477211906817413120 https://twitter.com/lucysrausch/status/1477211906817413120 (Read some of the follow up comments)
- leros 5y agoThis is a great example of unexpected design challenges.
- poulsbohemian 5y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the squirrels like them too.
- smoldesu 5y agoI live in the upper latitudes, and have both a Starlink and a couple outdoor cats who like to get into trouble. Unfortunately, I haven't spotted any of them really approaching the dish itself... I think it mostly comes down to two things: 1. The satellite dish doesn't warm up that much. It basically just heats itself to be hot enough to melt the ice, and that's more or less it. It still feels fairly cool to the touch on a winter day. 90% of the time, I'd imagine your router will be hotter than the dish itself. 2. The dish also makes a very faint whirring noise as it tracks satellites across the sky. You can only really notice it when you get within 5 feet of it, but I'm pretty sure my cats hate it. Sometimes they'll huddle at the base of the dish if it's a particularly cold day, but most of the time the motor sounds are enough to drive them away. Knowing how much companies like Starlink like useless novelty features, maybe a "cat deterrence" button in the app would be in order. Make the dish spin around a few times until the cats get scared. I dunno, food for thought.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoStrange about the whirring noise.. The motors are only to do the initial alignment, the tracking of sats is done purely with the phased array which should not make any noise (nothing physically moving) I think with cats sitting on it it would heat up more due to the insulation provided :)
- dghughes 5y agoHaving the dish on the ground isn't too smart either the snow will get deeper and cover it cats or no cats.
- tyingq 5y agoI don't imagine a "can't sit on this" shaped radome would be too expensive.
- NeoVeles 5y agoTesla has dog mode. Starlink has cat mode.
- hffftz 5y agoDOGE mode?
- quickthrower2 5y agoCats. Always trying to take over the internet.
- drdeadringer 5y agoIn my olde neighborhood, a neighbor of mine [due to an allergic husband] was an "outdoor cat only" meow-by-mouth only place for several decades. I took care of the feeding whilst they were on vacation. It's been a while since, but stories like this make me smile if I was still having a going thing with these neighbors.
- Tempest1981 5y agoI'm impressed that it still works, albeit at at lower speeds.
- Syonyk 5y ago> Starlink satellite dishes have a self-heating feature to melt snow... No, they don't. They just run hot. There are a ton of little ASICs behind the flat plane running the various antenna bits required for the beam forming (directing the beam without physically moving the dish, once it finds a spot it mostly stays put), and they all put out some good heat. Plus, the high frequency RF involved isn't the most efficient in terms of antennas. Yes, they're warm. No, it's not a dedicated heater mode.
- shaklee3 5y agoyes, they do. they have a deicer.
- Syonyk 5y agoSource? At least the first gen Dishys have nothing of the sort, though they will draw more power when covered with snow - presumably due to increased attenuation and the need for higher radiated power to maintain a link. Mine idles around 85W, 100-105W when transmitting heavily. Basically all that heat goes into the flat surface of the dish, which is enough to melt off snow. But it's not a dedicated heating functionality, and I've not seen a teardown that demonstrates a dedicated heating device. Though I imagine a cat attenuates the link a good bit and encourages heating.
- morsch 5y agoWow, that's a lot of power for a device running 24/7.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoYeah it's about half my baseline house power draw. And I'm a nerd with several 24/7 servers so it would be higher than someone who doesn't. By baseline I mean nobody home, lights and appliances off but internet, WiFi, IoT stuff etc all running.
- 5y ago
- gorgoiler 5y agoStarlink’s AUP lists quite a few types of behaviour that will mean you get cut off: https://www.starlink.com/legal/acceptable-use-policy https://www.starlink.com/legal/acceptable-use-policy If you are accused of being cruel and they uphold that complaint then bye bye connection. What if some crazy Twitter mob accuses you of animal cruelty for throwing your cats out in the snow? The implication is there that they monitor all your traffic to be able to enforce these rules. If one were to encrypt ones traffic to evade SpaceX’s surveillance, is that too a violation of the AUP?
- elcapitan 5y agoHard truth: Cats simply enjoy sitting on absolutely anything that wasn't intended for them to sit on. It doesn't even have to be warm for that. It's one of the oldest constants of the universe.
- ystuck 5y agoThat is adorable
- aspyct 5y agoSo hang on! We named bugs so because we discovered actual bugs in the early computers (in the eniac, I believe) Should we rename timeouts to "cats"? "I tried pinging your website, but I had a cat"
- CameronNemo 5y agohttps://http.cat/408 https://http.cat/408
- aspyct 5y agoNice!
- plumeria 5y agoWe now need a Starlink dish in Neko Atsume
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dawsmik 5y agoMaybe they could do a software update that rotates the dish if connectivity drops, or a least give the owner the option of remotely turning on a dish rotate function.