58 ms·
Pentagon and CIA shaped thousands of Hollywood movies into effective propaganda
- prmoustache 5y agoI cringe every time I hear the US president being described as the leader of the free world, as if there were 2 specific sides and USA were leading it and as if USA was an advocate for freedom.
- 1_player 5y agoOr just the fact that whenever there is an alien invasion, worldwide apocalypse or destruction, the effort to rebuild always starts from the USA. Every time I watch any of those movies I think "I wonder how Europe is faring..."
- PaulAJ 5y agoUp until 1990 that was a reasonable approximation to the truth. The USA certainly had its issues, but in a comparison between the USA and the USSR there was no question about who the relatively good guys were. Since the USSR collapsed, and especially since 9/11, things have gotten a lot murkier.
- lenkite 5y agoYou are clearly American. American administrations preferred and supported third-world tyrants during the Cold War over functional democracies since the former could be easily controlled. This is extensively documented and even admitted by several ex-DC head honchos. Public messaging by POTUS for national consumption is very different from actions on the ground.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoIf the US ever had good guy status, it's because of the principles it was founded upon. I'm not even sure up to which point those principles stood. Certainly not as late as the 90s. The second world war seems to have been the major turning point.
- goodpoint 5y ago> but in a comparison between the USA and the USSR That's a false dichotomy if I ever seen one.
- teawrecks 5y agoIt's literally a dichotomy by definition. If I say "in a comparison between chocolate and vanilla" I'm literally comparing those two specific flavors. To tell me it's a false dichotomy is silly.
- goodpoint 5y agoNo it's a false dichotomy because you are using the behavior of USSR as an excuse to give USA a pass. There's a reason why "I'm not as bad as <other person>" is not an acceptable legal defense.
- mrVentures 5y agoI guess they are saying that there are other options. So for example if I asked you "what is your favorite ice cream flavor, vanilla or chocolate?" you might respond to me with "that's a false dichotomy, there are more than two ice cream flavors, my favorite is banana which you have not listed as an option". At least that is my understanding of the context.
- freyr 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superpower https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superpower
- pjc50 5y agoThat was the dichotomy everyone had to deal with back in the day. Trying to be "unaligned" merely got you interference from both sides, with the possible exception of Switzerland.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoThe "good guys": - Guatemalan genocide - Operation Condor - Mass sterilization in Puerto Rico - Panama as a country - Arming the Taliban - And more... I think both governments had really shady people and cannot be characterized as "good".
- awestroke 5y agoReally? Good guys? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_r... I especially like the US-created Contras in Nicaragua - actual terrorists. Just a massive history of interfering with democracies with the sole aim for furthering the economic goals of the US.
- cycomanic 5y agoI seriously challenge you to read up on the history of the Latin Americas or many African nations. The "leader of the free world" was installing and supporting fascist dictatorships left right and center, who killed thousands of people in their torture chambers (often using CIA resources). It's correct that the US was generally better to its own people (unless you were black of course), but it certainly wasn't a beacon of freedom to the world.
- antman 5y agoI assume you are American? As resident of one of the dozens of countries that suffered US led coups our opinions differ. The US has influenced with undemocratic methods a lot more countries than the USSR even before the 90s. Just compare Europe and US sphere influence (Latin America and Africa) with USSR sphere of influence (Eastern Europe and Caucasian) Also look what happened Foreign interventions in the USSR sphere of influence for Freedom (Syria, Libya and Yugoslavia, Former USSR naval bases in the Mediterranean) those were rebellions against dictatorships. All the others are insurgencies against democracies.
- scyzoryk_xyz 5y agoThe leader of a region of influence yes. “Good guy” “Free world” - relative on perspective and highly subjectively US POV
- avgcorrection 5y agoIs that how one reads history? Whether the Mongolian Empire or the Khwarazmian Empire were the “relatively good guys”? This is a child’s way of seeing the world.
- ashtonkem 5y agoThat’s only possible with an extremely euro centric world view. If you were to focus on say, South America, you would’ve come to the exact opposite conclusion.
- fsloth 5y agoUSA is an advocate of very specific stability. "Free world" is a hyperbolic but US is still a huge global power. In cold war it was obvious there were two sides, and the other was obviously more free than the other. Go ask for example Estonians, Lithuanians or Latvians who they enjoyed the yoke of the USSR. Now, as China is becoming an ever more stronger player, we again see that there are two sides arising. While party lacks expansive ambitions in the traditional sense of landborders (except for Taiwan), they would very much like everyone to kotow to the party. We are in a world where democracies are in decline and autocracies are in the rise. USA is still the biggest democracy. Leader of the free world? It's hyperbolic, but not _obviously totally wrong_. This is not to say we are in some sort of manichean conflict world were one side is good and one is evil, or that US is good and the autocrats are evil. US is obviously a state actor that acts in it's own benefit and in the benefit of it's elites and so on, and these actions sometimes are very bad for civilians.
- callmeal 5y ago>In cold war it was obvious there were two sides Um, no. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-Aligned_Movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-Aligned_Movement
- fsloth 5y agoThe article is pretty obvious about the fact that the "Non-Aligned" movement was in fact closely aligned with USSR "many of the Non-Aligned Movement's members were actually quite closely aligned with China or the Soviet Union"
- cycomanic 5y ago> USA is an advocate of very specific stability. "Free world" is a hyperbolic but US is still a huge global power. > In cold war it was obvious there were two sides, and the other was obviously more free than the other. Go ask for example Estonians, Lithuanians or Latvians who they enjoyed the yoke of the USSR. You could also ask a Guatemalan how they enjoyed living under the US installed military dictatorships (which came out of a US supported coup after democratic elections resulted in a win for the left). Things are by far not as clear cut. Both blocks supported atrocious regimes if it was in their economic interests and worked against "the other side". That we largely only hear about one side shows how well the propaganda was/is working.
- bambax 5y ago"Freedom" in American parlance is like "Truth" in Roman Catholic lingo.
- imwillofficial 5y agoThis was an unnecessarily devisive comment.
- Tostino 5y agoI mean its not wrong, Americans themselves hardly agree on the definition of freedom any more.
- imwillofficial 5y agoThere is no need to attack people’s religion.
- known 5y ago
- kklisura 5y agoTangentially: Isn't it interesting that no anti-war movies are being produced anymore? I'm guessing it might be because we're living in a bit more peaceful times than before and there is no need for such movies, but also access to military equipment for producing such movies would be very limited.
- ilaksh 5y agoBut there are many countries where it has not been peaceful. Ask the people of Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, eastern Ukraine, Iran, etc. if they feel we are living in peaceful times.
- sitkack 5y agoAnd https://historyguild.org/africas-world-war-the-congo-war/ https://historyguild.org/africas-world-war-the-congo-war/
- elcapitan 5y agoOr it reflects that the two genres merged to a degree, because of a more nuanced understanding? Recent war movies like "Dunkirk" don't really show traditional heroism, they show a very bleak version of war, with the soldiers mostly surviving rather than fighting. "1917", while showing a heroic act of one (or two) main characters, also used imagery and portrayal of military and higher ranks that is essentially a reference to classical anti-war movies.
- alephr 5y agoIs this some kind of marketing for the mentioned movie? The article mentions documents that are supposed to substantiate it's claims but then it just goes into speculation and only linking to other articles the author wrote. The mentioned movie doesn't even seem to be publicly available. Weird to see this here.
- phekunde 5y agoWell, it is not just the Pentagon and CIA, the NRA also has its share in damage, albiet internally to America itself, by eulogising and then infilterating the gun culture into the USA. The American movies have played a big part in internal damage to America itself.
- jimmont 5y agoAnd what's wrong with that? Films typically fit amusement generally, or "a-" not and "muse" to think. Finding quality content it like opening a mineral mine and doing the operation manually, less like attending a film or reading HN. The nuggets of value are expensive to uncover.
- tzs 5y ago> Captain Marvel exists to sell the Air Force to women That seems like a ridiculous claim. Carol Danvers was an Air Force officer when the character was created in 1968. No one was trying to sell the Air Force to women in 1968. Marvel, both the comics and the movies, has been more anti-military than pro-military. The military, specifically the US military, is often the bad guys. For example, it was the military that led to the creation of the Hulk, and are generally the bad guys in both the comics and movies when it comes to things related to Hulk. If in a Marvel work the military shows up, it is almost a cliche that they are going to be the bad guys unless it is a military vs. military situation such as with Captain America. And even the first Captain America movie didn't portray the US military all that favorably--they create the first super soldier and then just want to use him as an entertainer!
- tootie 5y agoThis entire article seems like agenda-driven BS. I can totally believe that government entities have sought and occasionally succeeded at influencing some media and entertainment messages but I don't see any proof of a vast conspiracy. There's much simpler explanations for all of it. People like hero stories. Studios would be making heroic soldiers without any prompting. And there's no shortage of successful movies about how bad war sucks. Hurt Locker springs to mind as something commercially and critically successful as an authentic portrait of war being hell.
- woolion 5y agoEverytime I see such a thread, I wonder how many subcommunities there are on hn. Unless you suffer from a very strong case of Gell-Mann amnesia, I don't see how it is possible to be aware of such efforts and then not question any of the ongoing narratives. The narratives are getting worse and worse as time goes, and so we see the consensus-engineering shifting away from the narratives themselves to polarization. So instead of believing in your narrative, you reject the others because "they are embraced by bad people who also embrace other bad narratives". The different government programs to make people unable to distinguish disinformation and propaganda etc are also well-known around. How it is possible to constantly see discussed some of the egregious things that were done during Vietnam, Iraq, and then see as much blind faith in the moral good of going into new conflicts?
- ashtonkem 5y agoAny sufficiently powerful organization begins to see its continued survival as the most important thing. I’m sure that a lot of this was implicitly done as a counter to the “threat” of Americans asking uncomfortable questions about the DoD budget and whether it really is worth spending that much on national defense rather than other things domestically.
- Zigurd 5y agoMaking copaganda illegal would be good, too. Real police are nowhere near as competent and public-minded as they are on TV. Cop shows also normalize the use of deadly force.
- ryanmarsh 5y agoI do not understand people who think their own government will not propagandize them.
- AnonHP 5y agoNo mention of World War II in this article. No mention of how the U.S. single handedly defeated the Nazis and took down the Axis Powers, as seen in the movies. The influence in Hollywood is really seen in all movies on this topic. Anyone watching these movies would think that the U.S. lost the most number of people and made the most sacrifices in that war. A look at the real numbers would tell a very different story.
- teh_klev 5y agoTom Secker, who's one of the co-producers of Theatres of War, has for many years written and podcasted about the CIA and the DoD's influences on movie and TV series scripts: https://www.spyculture.com/podcasts/ https://www.spyculture.com/podcasts/ He's also amassed a huge library of documents via FOIA about this particular topic: https://www.spyculture.com/documents/ https://www.spyculture.com/documents/
- andrewclunn 5y agoWell, we’ll always have The Pentagon Wars: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lLNi4bLc2h4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lLNi4bLc2h4
- spaetzleesser 5y agoNot only movies. It always bothers me when I see the marine corps sponsoring a NASCAR car. Somehow it doesn’t feel right to use taxpayer money to put stickers on a car.
- andred14 5y ago
- _xnmw 5y agoAs a person who grew up without a television at home (I was homeschooled in Canada), this is strikingly obvious. Even the differences in mentality and worldview between those who grew up watching American TV shows and those who didn't is immediately obvious to me within 5 minutes of having a casual conversation. One of the reasons I left Canada and moved to Eastern Europe is for the refreshing change in monoculture: I can have normal conversations with people whose minds have not developed in a Hollywood Matrix, whose entire cultural context is not based on popular TV references (or the tropes presented in them). Lots of people in post-Soviet countries don't watch American television, and it is very easy to tell when they do. I now strongly prefer European TV productions (especially older British and French stuff), because the American superpower-worship and military propaganda, and now wokeism, is positively cringeworthy.
- wadadadad 5y agoWhat features or differences make this "strikingly obvious"? What conversation subjects do you talk about in a 5 minute casual conversation that demonstrate a person has consumed American TV shows?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jimbob45 5y agoBritain invented and filmed the James Bond movies which surely have attracted more young men to the service than anything the Americans have ever come up with, right?
- ddoran 5y agoAs someone who moved from Europe to the US, the pervasiveness of the military in televised professional and college football game is incredibly jarring to me yet is so normalized to Americans. Count the number of times there is a reference to the military, a cutaway to uniformed people in the stands or by the touchline, a clip of troops watching the game while deployed overseas, flyovers etc. Still, after 10 years, my reaction is "what has that got to do with sport?". I've always assumed this to be a very deliberate strategy to build an implicit association between the "nobility" of sport and war, to boost recruitment and win over the hearts and minds of the American public for past, current and future military action. Now count how many times you've seen any sign of the military at a sports event in Europe - rare to never. It's not normal and it's sad to me that it is so normalized in the US.
- smsm42 5y agoWait, so you're telling me Hollywood movies don't actually accurately portray reality and I should not use them as a source of information about the world? Darn it! That changes everything!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- crate_barre 5y agoThe other country that is doing this at Hollywood scale is China, and it’s not just their ‘only popular in China’ movies like Wolf Warrior (1 and 2). Some scenes: https://youtu.be/g7y36UIRAjo https://youtu.be/g7y36UIRAjo IP Man 4, which is more well known to western audiences: https://youtu.be/OlW2VphUNd4 https://youtu.be/OlW2VphUNd4 https://youtu.be/JFmaPK0JyVQ https://youtu.be/JFmaPK0JyVQ You get the idea. Americans make movies where America good, everyone bad. China is now making movies where China good, everyone bad, specially white Americans. Anyways, along with the glorification of US might and power by the pentagon, their recruiting tactics have also used video game stylization to attract young people: https://youtu.be/N0f_ZUgqvxE https://youtu.be/N0f_ZUgqvxE ^ That is a fucking video game ad as far as I’m concerned. No mature person should be turned on by that.
- rocknor 5y agoI mean, if one country does it, everyone else is forced to do it to level the playing field. Hollywood churns out higher quality propaganda because huge budgets and USA global hegemony, but it won't stay like that forever as we move to a multipolar world. The same is happening with online news outlets that churn out cherry-picked propaganda to counter propaganda from another country - information warfare.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoAlso Russia is doing it, also because it has a problem with numbers and/of soldiers… “Russia Doesn’t Have the Demographics for War” https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/01/03/russia-demography-birthrate-decline-ukraine/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/01/03/russia-demography-birth...
- beloch 5y agoRussia has been doing it since the dawn of cinema. e.g. Battleship Potemkin. Mosfilm, soviet propaganda, and amazing advances in movie-making have all marched together from the very start. You'd be surprised at how many of the tropes and techniques that form a part of modern movie language have their origin in soviet propaganda. The thing is, everybody expects a Mosfilm flick to toe the party line. What the U.S. has done was sneakier.
- zibzab 5y agoKinda of like what Putin does with LitRPG now? (I am probably on some kind of list now)
- JetAlone 5y agoMy KGB handlers are requesting me to ask you for examples.
- zibzab 5y agoThe last book I read contained direct quotes from the man himself about the importance of creating new businesses to help the motherland. Nothing major, but when I read that I realised the the entire series was basically promoting some kind of "the Russian dream" as seen by an incel-boomer (can't really put a better word on it)... And please tell your FSB handlers to stop living in the past ;)
- nullifidian 5y agoPutin and LitRPG? Can you elaborate?
- JetAlone 5y agoGonna second this question - my sibling comment was tongue in cheek but belied a genuine curiosity.
- bushin 5y agoI think they meant books like this one: https://market.yandex.ru/product--romanov-german-ivanovich-tovarishch-gitler-kniga-2-povesit-cherchillia/9432320 https://market.yandex.ru/product--romanov-german-ivanovich-t... "Comrade Hitler. Part II. Hanged Churchill"
- heavyset_go 5y agoOnce this was pointed out, I can't unsee it. It's kind of ruined movies that involves the military or military equipment for me, since it can be really obvious when creators toe the line for the military. When I see military equipment my gut reaction is to anticipate the other shoe dropping, and to look for shoehorned hero worship or some good-versus-evil plot point.
- vmception 5y agoOne of the most interesting and moderately uncomfortable experiences for me was being in another country and seeing a war movie in that country’s theatres made by a director in that country It was about a conflict I never thought about before, and also had me rooting for an anti-hero that on a side that would go on to oppose America, although acknowledgement of the US’ future involvement wasn’t even a part of the movie Visitors and immigrants to the US must face that all the time, or dont have such nationalistic conditioning to care in the first place In any case, the most interesting thing was how different the movie was. Like the things they focused on werent an unrealistic show of force and winning. I am enough of a film buff to put this on the specific director’s prowess, instead of culture, but I do think the surrounding culture is what helped the director greenlight working on that film.
- systemvoltage 5y agoSpeaking of good-vs-evil, do you also see WWII veterans and military history in the same light? They got into war that no one asked for. I cannot imagine if US and allies had lost WWII. It is simply unimaginable. Aside: I find the WWII era military training/propaganda videos pretty entertaining: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1QgXuhv7-54 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1QgXuhv7-54
- lamontcg 5y agoI view the veterans of the Abraham Lincoln brigade as having fought and sacrificed on the side of good. When the survivors later tried to join the US Army for the fight against Germans and WWII (which they viewed as a continuation of the same war they had already been fighting) many of the were labelled "premature antifascists" and rejected.
- Lammy 5y ago“[George] Creel urged [Woodrow] Wilson to create a government agency to coordinate "not propaganda as the Germans defined it, but propaganda in the true sense of the word, meaning the 'propagation of faith.'"”: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Committee_on_Public_Information https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Committee_on_Public_Informatio... "Creel later published his memoirs of his service with the CPI, 'How We Advertised America', in which he wrote: “In no degree was the Committee an agency of censorship, a machinery of concealment or repression. Its emphasis throughout was on the open and the positive. At no point did it seek or exercise authorities under those war laws that limited the freedom of speech and press. In all things, from first to last, without halt or change, it was a plain publicity proposition, a vast enterprise in salesmanship, the world's greatest adventures in advertising… We did not call it propaganda, for that word, in German hands, had come to be associated with deceit and corruption. Our effort was educational and informative throughout, for we had such confidence in our case as to feel that no other argument was needed than the simple, straightforward presentation of the facts.”"
- toxik 5y agoIs he... advertising for America in a quote about it? This is some meta stuff.
- Barrin92 5y agoone graphic that stuck with me, that I saw a few years ago is this one (https://imgur.com/svsB0Ub https://imgur.com/svsB0Ub) (question being: which nation, according to you, contributed most to the defeat of Germany?" Being German and having Russian relatives the perspective on the war on the continent has always been interesting to me. The sheer scale and brutality of the Eastern front, the war crimes and death (The Soviet Union lost more than 15% of its population!) is astonishing. I don't think popular media reflects this at all, not even necessarily maliciously or as propaganda intentionally. But that disconnect between the reality, and the recognition of it in Russia itself, has had vastly negative consequences when it comes to other countries trying to understand Russia even today. (and I suppose it's not by accident that in Germany for example, often only elder statesmen point this out)
- tgv 5y ago> The Soviet Union lost more than 15% of its population Yeah, but that number is so high because they were effective at killing their own people. The number of needless victims during the fighting and those of the "cleansing" after a win is incredibly high.
- camillomiller 5y agoTry asking most people about the Vietnam War, then visit Vietnam, especially the war museum in Saigon. Then pay a visit to the Landmine museum outside of Siam Reap, in Cambodia, to learn about Nixon's secret war that carpeted the border between Cambodia and Vietnam with bombs and landmines without anyone knowing. That's a trip that would make you rethink America big time. It absolutely did for me. As an Italian, I was raised with the American Dream firmly in mind. When I turned eighteen I even started applying for the Green Card lottery every year for like six times. In the last 10 years I've grown so deeply disenchanted it's disturbing. The feeling of being force-fed a fake story by media for all these years is so bitter. But it's not just me. I would say that an entire generation of Europeans has been growing up to become deeply skeptical about anything Americans do.
- nsonha 5y agoI heard the Peace Museum in Hiroshima is quite a trip too.
- beebeepka 5y agoI don't know anything about running a country but propaganda is something everyone does because it makes sense. Can't blame them. I always (as an adult) assumed the countless war movies and cop TV shows are just that. That said, a few years ago I stumbled upon some hideous cover of Offspring's gone away. Someone had turned that tune into a cheesy pop tune and made the video about young beautiful housewife and mother getting informed that her darling was killed in line of duty. No way some music production company just decided to do that on its own. Man, it was bad
- 14 5y agoI am very interested to ready the comments and see where the votes land. From my experience any time you criticize the US here on HN you are heavily criticized or downvoted. Sometimes after making a valid point. I have learned to not take it personally and have always told myself I am sure there are state actors from many nations on many forums trying to persuade a perspective. If someone wants to downvote but not provide a rebuttal they probably are just offended by the posters comment or part of some mechanism trying to sway a narrative. I don’t think it is just state actors but also commercial interests.
- avgcorrection 5y agoI think there are actually many posters on HN that are critical of the US. I would say that such opinions are more popular than they were a few years ago. On the other hand there are also a fair amount that have an idealized conception of that country.
- anaccountexists 5y agoReally? I think you can make a generic “US bad, <insert other country name, typically from Europe> good” and you’ll get a cheering chorus from HN, Reddit, Twitter, etc. on… almost any topic these days. As a US citizen I just don’t really care anymore, I sometimes get a good chuckle every time someone tells me I’m oppressed or living in a hellhole. I’m happy where I live and though I recognize there’s faults and I do try to improve them where I can. Maybe it’s state actors, maybe it’s not; I wouldn’t care about a stranger’s opinion in real life, so why would I bother caring about a stranger online? Too little time in life for that.
- 14 5y agoI don’t know much about Europe or other countries so haven’t made many critical comments towards those countries. But when I’ve been critical about the US, my neighbouring country I’ve always had a lot of flack for it here on HN. But you are right life is too short so I say my piece and not worry if people vote down or up I am just trying to be part of the conversation.
- neuro_image2 5y agoThis is my first exposure to the organization 'world beyond war'. I absolutely agree with its stated aims and intents. I would love to believe that what they are suggesting could be achievable - but the cynic/skeptic in me worries that this will end up being steamrolled by the people in power as some sort of fringe hippie movement. Does anyone have direct experience with working with this organization that could relay how effective they are in their approach? Any thoughts on how their stated aims could be realizable?
- xcambar 5y agoAside from military, this tactic became obvious to me when space became (again) a theater of conquest around 2010, involving both private and public sectors, internationally. The narrative around space became very strong, sending messages of conquest, entrepreneurship, science, dreams, you name it. At the exact same period, bloomed movies like: Mission to Mars, Gravity, Interstellar. I won't be surprised to see a surge of interest in space-related careers in younger generations in years to come.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah. I used to think space exploration was about pushing the whole human race forward. Now I realize it's about geopolitics. Superpowers competing for even more power. While we consume optimistic media like Star Trek, the USA is busy setting up constellations of surveillance satellites as well as a literal space force. Wikileaks is such an incredible gift to mankind. Diplomatic cables leaked there showed me that the USA explicitly interfered in my country's attempt to develop a space program because they don't want us to have rocket and therefore missile technology. They actually wanted to use my country for launches due to it being under the equator but only if they could leave us out of it entirely, no one would even be able to enter the premises.
- azalemeth 5y agoWhile that's true, the fundamental missions in space that we are likely to fly are basically all about science and engineering. Even (I speculate) the classified ones. Satellites provide either telecommunications or fundamental information about our world or the universe in which it sits. That information is not going to beinherently military -- it's the purposes that it is put to that may be. On the other have, every American action movie seems to feature guns and explosions and quite a lot of glorification of the military. The military exist to kill people, and to deliver the utmost brutality to others whilst remaining organised, logical and efficient themselves. Guns exist to kill things. Explosive munitions are fundamentally excellent at killing people from a surprisingly long way away, larger than what Hollywood shows. When was the last time you saw a film highlight the loss a family of a minor villain felt when the hero shot him? The true aftermath of an air strike in a foreign country -- lifelong resentment and hatred about the country that provided it? (Vietnam is an interesting place to visit, but don't mention B-52s to the locals). It is an unfortunate but unavoidable fact of humanity that armies are required to exist. There is definitely good that comes from them, ranging from humanitarian aid to the research into high end technology, and I'm not calling for their abolition -- I am not naïve. That is fundamentally why the glorification of the military at all costs is problematic. The ethical arguments for their existence require exploring. American films, on the other hand, will quite happily show a commando killing hundreds or thousands of people in a teenager-friendly film, yet American culture decrees that showing a single naked person mandates that the film is restricted. That mindset -- boobs bad, guns good, explosions fun and exciting -- is slowly but surely exported across the globe. I'm going to look forward to the sci-fi space films where the drama is survival in a hostile environment, and infinitely prefer them to war films.
- roody15 5y agoPretty sure Pentagon and CIA are continuing in this effort.
- dataflow 5y ago> We know that the Pentagon knows this, and what military officials scheme and plot as a result of knowing this, because of the work of relentless researchers making use of the Freedom of Information Act. Any links?
- MK2k 5y agoFOIA in full effect: https://www.spyculture.com/documents/ https://www.spyculture.com/documents/
- xcambar 5y agoIn France, the french secret services (DGSE) worked hand-in-hand with the production of a TV show called The Bureau (https://www.imdb.com/title/tt4063800 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt4063800). The services were supposedly lacking diverse resources for both operators, admins and field agents of diverse backgrounds. This series drew a very strong, credible and positive narrative that led to a massive number of people knocking at the doors of the DGSE to join the forces. Propaganda? I think not. Well thought out recruitment strategy as entertainment? Most likely yes. Is there a difference between the two? To be discussed... ;)
- lostlogin 5y agoIt’s a little surreal to be watching it (sort of) while skimming HN and stumbling into this thread.
- baxtr 5y agoYou are being manipulated in this very second. That you skim HN while watching the show was actually anticipated. This comment will auto-destruct in 60 seconds.
- icare_1er 5y agoThere is no evidence the show was designed as an advertisement for the DGSE. This is simply a happy side-effect of it being popular... I see a big difference with using movies as propaganda to influence the planet's opinions. At the same time, one has to be blind to not see that any cinema industry has a political agenda, I mean, just watch the average Netflix production and it is striking.
- xcambar 5y ago> There is no evidence the show was designed as an advertisement for the DGSE. It is for me inconceivable that the DGSE did not think of the outcome before agreeing to be an active collaborator of the show, and act accordingly to it's own benefits.
- democracy 5y agoSpeaking about movies I am more confused why modern Russian movies portray Soviet soldiers as a bunch of idiots either drinking, shooting each other or being killed by KGB. And most of such movies are sponsored by the government. Go figure!
- vagrantJin 5y agoSomething about Russians and their rather sobering worldview.
- thinkingemote 5y agoComradeship. Solidarity with your brothers.
- jfmarshall 5y agoThe propaganda effort shown in popular movies is just a small tip of the iceberg. The United States and its state-run propaganda and terrorism organisations cannot be allowed to walk through the 21st century without answering and making amends to the crimes committed. It has never before been more urgent to question and criticise the United States for its past decades of war, propaganda, sowing discord and effort to partition the world into those who are with them, subordinate, and those who are against them. It is a good thing that we are still allowed to speak about it without being accused of being shills, spies, or "Russian trolls". But it might not last if these people get their way.
- namdnay 5y agoI think the main thing that gets people accused of being shills it using new accounts to send shrill calls to action
- jfmarshall 5y agoYes, another convenient excuse and something to grasp for when all that matters is to discredit someone whose opinions they do not want to see in the debate.
- nsonha 5y agoI would not publish any of my political views with my identity in this cancel culture. It makes sense some people want to be anonymous with those statements.
- namdnay 5y agomost of us are anonymous here I think? And the cancel culture has been here for at least 20 years, I remember what it was like to dare say that you didnt think it was a good idea to invade Iraq.. my comment was more on suspicious accounts that single post over the top propaganda and then disappear
- jfmarshall 5y ago
- peter_retief 5y agoI feel they have overplayed their hand in the 2020 US elections, not just Hollywood but all media. In some ways it is a bit sad and pathetic looking behind the curtain and the seeing the puppeteer pulling the strings. C'est la vie I guess.
- bjarneh 5y agoIt's even more obvious when it's the other way around; i.e. movies that criticize them have to create war scenes without the all the free fighter jets and Apache helicopters. One of the worst (war) movie scenes in history have to be the one in "Lions for lambs" [1]. It looks like some low budget / film school creation even though it's a massive production, with Tom Cruise, Robert Redford and Meryl Streep. 1: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0891527/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0891527/
- matheusmoreira 5y agoWhy do they even need the military for this? Can't they just use some computer graphics instead? We have video games full of photorealistic fighter jets and helicopters.
- goodpoint 5y agoThis method of propaganda was described by Chomsky in Manufacturing Consent already in 1988: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent
- fsloth 5y agoChomsky is very good! It does not matter if you agree with his political stance or not, the fact based argumentation mixed with political rhetoric is a masterpiece of cerebral political writing, and a very good snapshot of some aspects of modern US history.
- denton-scratch 5y agoManufacturing Consent makes a really good argument that the news media are complicit in propaganda. It's very dry reading, and repetitive; loads of examples to prove their point. John Pilger: ""The BBC is and has long been the most refined propaganda service in the world".
- avgcorrection 5y agoDon’t forget the co-author Edward S. Herman.
- ignoramous 5y agoSee also this discussion on "The [erstwhile] Indianisation of China" by Hu Shih, a Chinese academic: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0009445514534119 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0009445514534119 > [Hu Shih] was among the first contributors for radical ideological change and modernity in China. His article on the 'Indianization of China' presented a scathing criticism of Indian influence on China that inhibited the blooming of 'indigenous modernity', progressivism and dynamism there. Hu’s views supported contemporary 'modernist' Chinese intellectuals' labelling of India under the British as a 'ruined' civilisation, 'failed' state or incapable role model for the agenda of modernity. Yet, he did not overlook affinities, mutual respect and admiration for those in India searching for 'indigenous roots' to modernity. His famous observation that 'India conquered and dominated China culturally for 20 centuries without ever having to send a single soldier across her border' is one of the most quoted sentences in any study of Sino-Indian encounters and connections. Iranians and later Turkic Mongols had a similar affect (Persianisation) on India itself before imperialism took hold, and westernisation came to the fore; for ex: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macaulayism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Macaulayism Dominant cultures have always sought influence.
- sitkack 5y agoSo what culture is trying to dominate here, as in which culture puts forth the war movies? War, Capitalism, ownership and control?
- obblekk 5y agoI think Persianisation of India occured mostly due to conquest by Muslim leaders from Persian roots (see: https://www.historydiscussion.net/history-of-india/invasions/7-historic-invasions-of-foreign-forces-on-india-history/6558 https://www.historydiscussion.net/history-of-india/invasions...). This is different than Hu Shih's point about non-military cultural influence. Military led cultural influence happens by force. Non military cultural influence happens attraction to culture. Post-WW2 United States had both in combination. Didn't know about Hu Shih otherwise, so thanks for sharing.
- say_it_as_it_is 5y agoChina is using movies to propagandize against the U.S. now. What used to be Rambo vs Russia is now Chinese Rambo vs U.S. Let that thought sink in.
- windsignaling 5y agoChina has always done this and it is always comically obvious. The propaganda coming from the US against the Chinese is more subtle and convincing. It's scary not only because of how good it is, but because people here don't even realize they are being manipulated.
- 1_player 5y agoPerhaps you think the US propaganda is more subtle because it's very similar to your world view, as a member of the Western world. I bet a Chinese citizen would find the Hollywood propaganda hilariously over the top, though don't forget that the US propaganda is so widespread it already has infected everybody, including the common Chinese citizen, for decades.
- windsignaling 5y agoI considered that, but upon deeper thought, it is not true. Consider the examples elsewhere in this thread. The Chinese propaganda is the Chinese soldier essentially doing an unrealistic magic trick. American propaganda is often in the form of omission or social stature. Consider the last time you saw an Asian male in a Hollywood production (which are few and far between to begin with) that wasn't: a) a kung-fu caricature b) the joke
- avgcorrection 5y agoHah! Our enemy’s propaganda is such foolish nonsense—no one would fall for that! However, I am quite concerned for the little people of our enemy’s nation, because our propaganda is so subtle and intelligent…
- 5y ago
- 34679 5y ago>The film also notes that the United States has laws against propagandizing the U.S. public, which might make such a disclosure a confession of a crime. I would add that since 1976, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights has required that “Any propaganda for war shall be prohibited by law.” That changed in 2013: >The U.S. government's mammoth broadcasting arm has begun the "unleashing of thousands of hours per week of government-funded radio and TV programs for domestic U.S. consumption," John Hudson of Foreign Policy reported on Sunday. >The content arrives with the enactment of the Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012, sponsored by Rep. Mac Thornberry (R- Texas) and Rep. Adam Smith (D- Wash.), which was inserted into the 2013 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). >The reform effectively nullifies the Smith-Mundt Act of 1948, which was amended in 1985 specifically to prohibit U.S. organizations from using information "to influence public opinion in the United States." >The new law enables U.S. government programming such as Voice of America (VoA) — an outlet created in 1942 to promote a positive understanding of the U.S. abroad — t0 broadcast directly to domestic audiences for the first time. https://www.businessinsider.com/us-domestic-propaganda-officially-aired-2013-7?op=1 https://www.businessinsider.com/us-domestic-propaganda-offic...
- Threeve303 5y agoImagine you have a tech industry that merged with madison avenue along with psychological methods learned from Guantanamo and CIA Black Sites, and you wanted to build a societal manipulation machine, otherwise known as propaganda. Makes me wonder if there is any relation between the changes mentioned here and some of what the social media infrastructure has been used to do.
- echlipse 5y agoI came to know about the Marvel movie military involvement from a youtube video essayist. I don't know whether it's good or bad. It's somewhere in the middle probably. Also every other country does the exact same thing afaik. The opposite of this would be potraying everything about the armed forces in a complete negative light. Now that won't be liked a lot I guess. The important thing here I believe is people should learn to detect if something is a propaganda or not. And the problem now is that its very subtle. Most people with whom I have discussed already detect the blatant propaganda movies instantly. The subtler ones like the marvel movies are the ones which they are very suprised about.
- awestroke 5y ago> Also every other country does the exact same thing afaik Not true. US, Russia, China, North Korea - sure. Can you name any other countries? Can you give examples for even a fraction of "all other countries"?
- cycomanic 5y agoI suspect something similar is going on with all the cop/crime shows that show the "hero" cops completely disregard the law and due process. This always happens in situations where all the viewers completely agree that it is justified, e.g. a clear bad/evil guy (we already know he did it) and a small child that has to be saved from a prison... I think this is essentially suposed to make us conceive law enforcement as always right and doing everything to "keep us safe" even if they have to disregard the law. You can clearly see it's working in how many people unquestionably support the police.
- fundad 5y agoOMG Stuber anyone? Mr. Nanjani’s copaganda comedy
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pdimitar 5y agoI hope this doesn't come as a surprise to anyone. At least for a lot of people outside the USA it was super obvious that the mainstream movies in the cinema are painting an overly optimistic picture of the US.
- some-username 5y agoI was not surprised that it happens, but I was quite astonished about the extent of it. Also it's nice to have proof and insight.
- d23 5y agoWhat proof and insight did this article give you? As far as I can tell, the movie this article is referring to hasn't come out yet.
- UweSchmidt 5y agoPropaganda probably still works even if you're aware what's going on.
- pdimitar 5y agoDefinitely not on me but I know people for whom that applies, yeah.
- UweSchmidt 5y agoI'm changing that to: Propaganda works and there is little defense. Pictures, voices, narratives, emotions directly create memories; connections between neurons are created or strenghtened - you can switch on your "anti virus" but the machine is hacked on the "hardware" level.
- pdimitar 5y agoI agree. Our instinctive reaction is to believe all the subliminal messaging. And we have to actively and consciously resist believing it, and to undo the wrong beliefs. But it also helps a lot to periodically read how yet another US teacher is living in their car. After a while it becomes an instinct NOT to believe the propaganda that tells you otherwise.
- ArnoVW 5y agoI bumped into this video about the making of 'Top Gun' the other day. Interesting in many ways. It shows the photographical choices and approaches that they used. The creative process and choices (and the vision and influence of Bruckenheimer).. and the way that the Navy had an influence. Example: the CO of the Miramar base (where it was shot) had a veto right on the script. He rejected because there was a romance between enlisted, and because there was an in-flight collision. Which resulted in Bruckenheimer finding 'work-arounds' : Charlie becomes an external consultant, the collision becomes a flat spin following a jet wash incident (the CO looked over old accidents to find something suitable) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Knz5LM_FzEE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Knz5LM_FzEE
- rambambram 5y agoAlso saw this recently. I always wondered how movies got access to military bases, jet fighters, and everything.
- scotty79 5y agoRecently I read about Chinese reusing frames from Top Gun as theur military propaganda. It's even funnier that it turns out they just reused US propaganda as theirs.
- ArnoVW 5y agoThat. And since China constitutes a juicy market, the Taiwanese and Japanese flags were removed from Maverick's jacket in the sequel https://www.google.com/amp/s/news.sky.com/story/amp/top-gun-sequel-japan-and-taiwan-flags-replaced-on-famous-tom-cruise-jacket-for-new-film-11768384 https://www.google.com/amp/s/news.sky.com/story/amp/top-gun-...
- mutatio 5y ago"The Patriot" is a good one, there's a scene where Mel Gibson (colonial plantation owner) / his workers proudly declare his plantation workers as "freemen" when told by the British red coat they will be free if they fight on the side of the King. Mel Gibson has a bit of a track record though, so unlikely dark CIA involvement.
- jjgreen 5y agoNot just films, the CIA covertly supported certain artists too (Pollock, de Kooning, ...). https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/modern-art-was-cia-weapon-1578808.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/modern-art-was-cia-...
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoAt the moment there seem to be many more (or at least many) 'anti' government movies around - those portraying the CIA and other organisations as corrupt, self serving or incompetent - the Bourne series etc. Even "Eye in the Sky" gave me an overwhelming sense that the military use of drones was poorly managed and the decision making process was incompetent.
- polytely 5y agobut those movies (at least the bourne ones, haven't seen eye in the sky) Didn't require a lot of military hardware to make, so they aren't entangled with the propaganda people I would guess.
- a0-prw 5y agoBurn after reading is a very funny movie about CIA (and human) incompetence.
- boomboomsubban 5y ago>the Bourne series The series where the protagonist is a CIA super agent who throws away his career because his morals get in the way. You may not leave with the impression that all of the CIA are moral, but it does spread the idea that the CIA is incredibly capable and individuals can sway overall policy. Which is nonsense.
- anjbe 5y ago> it does spread the idea that the CIA is incredibly capable That’s hardly in dispute, is it? > and individuals can sway overall policy Certainly not the impression I got from at least the first three films. The Bourne Identity ends in an unceremonious coverup of a failed operation, and the sole “idealist” character in the next two films torches her career as well to go to the press. Which depending on your view could be considered exactly what Snowden did, for better or for worse. Certainly typical tropey US spy movie fare (American characters playing CIA assassination games in Europe, etc.), but more revisionist Western than John Wayne.
- ajb 5y agoSome amount of promoting "we are the good guys" seems inevitable. Where I think this becomes really despicable is when you have productions like "24" or "zero dark thirty" propagandising the use of torture. It would be interesting to know how directly the military or security services were the source of that.
- SiempreViernes 5y agoMy guy, I have bad news: Zootopia has an torture scene. In other words, torture is so pervasive in American media you don't even notice most instances of it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thinkingemote 5y agoThe Institute for Propaganda Awareness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institute_for_Propaganda_Analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institute_for_Propaganda_Analy... from 1937 to 1942 was set up to train the American people about usages of propaganda in the emergence of fascism and communism in the early 20th century. It was scrapped entriely when USA joined in WW2. I wonder if other neutral countries had similar propaganda awareness education efforts, or if anyone could imagine this state run initiative to exist today anywhere.
- a_throwaway_8 5y agoI wonder at which point the US public will have an "are we the baddies" moment: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU Harsh, I know. But how long can US people watch the lies in their top-selling films about how heroic their soldiers are, while completely ignoring the atrocities their armies are involved in, around the world?
- worldsayshi 5y agoI'm not American but I feel that at least the general consensus on Reddit is already there. But realising that you're bad doesn't itself form a solution. You need some kind of consensus about a plan towards becoming better and that hasn't begun to form.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoIt's nowhere near a general consensus. There's a minority that think so, a minority ultra patriotic, and most people basically never think about such foreign policy. Except when they watch movies or TV shows, which is what makes the propaganda so troubling.
- lurtbancaster 5y agoSecond Thought's video on How Hollywood Sells Us War - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4szttm_e0Ic https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4szttm_e0Ic
- DrBazza 5y agoIt's not just propaganda, it's also the fact that a lot of what is portrayed in films is outside the realm of experience for regular people. People just can't tell what is realistic and what isn't, because many people just don't know. Battles, gun fights ("it's just a scratch, walk it off"), stabbings, fights and so on. Then there's topical films like Contagion, and Outbreak. And then there are disaster films portraying tsunamis nothing like the ones we saw in Japan and Banda Aceh.
- alittlebird0 5y agowhat the US figured out early is that you don't need traditional control of the population as you see in authoritarian states, you just need crafted images, media is much more powerful, they are very good at it. their skill has to be admired. they spend billions on this.
- avgcorrection 5y agoThis reads like a butchered Chomsky reference. In actual fact so-called liberal democracies are free to the degree that authoritarian tools wouldn’t and can’t work.
- denton-scratch 5y ago"In actual fact <opinion>" Is the USA a liberal democracy? Authoritarian tools (like packing the courts) seem to work there. Successive UK governments have tightened control over the BBC. Assange stews in a high-security prison, untried, for reporting the truth. Craig Murray has just completed his prison sentence for reporting the truth. Neither of those jailings has received significant coverage in the mainstream UK press.
- avgcorrection 5y agoIt wasn’t meant to be a compliment. EDIT: I mean that the category “liberal democracy” is not meant as some kind of praise. That’s just what they/we call them.
- 1penny42cents 5y agoIs there any evidence in this article or is it all conjecture + reference to a documentary?
- datavirtue 5y agoReminds me of the old Saturday morning cartoons. Good luck figuring out what your kids are watching these days.
- duxup 5y agoPeople also, like to watch that stuff. I think it is a weird and complicated thing.
- switch007 5y agoThey’re not very subtle. It’s painfully obvious I have no doubt the likes of MI5/6 “work” with British series creators too