19 ms·
What is the point of imagining new technologies without new ways of living?
- oversocialized 5y agoTo increase the wealth of the 1% banker class
- amitmina 5y agoNew technologies will give us time so that we can come back to thinking about life and hopefully think of better ways of living. It need not be this way but with the addiction to work it just needs to go through this route.
- asow92 5y agoCue ceaseless debate between capitalism and collectivism... go!
- mysterydip 5y agoThere have been lots of technology x replacing a manual process with the promise that "now instead of doing y, the person is now free to explore more leisurely pursuits." In reality, there's a race in terms of productivity: "now they can do 2x the work they did before!" As long as companies are driven by profits, and that profit can be increased by higher enployee productivity in the same number of legal working hours, we will continue to do so. Even on a personal level, say a car lets me do a trip in 30 minutes instead of 2 hours walking. I don't relax for an hour and a half. I go check more things off my todo list.
- voisin 5y agoWould this be solved by a universal basic income? Is that “now I can do 2x what I did before” due only to financial requirements of the household?
- danielvaughn 5y agoMy opinion on this is that a better goal (though not an exclusive alternative to) UBI is what I call "basic needs automation". Instead of distributing arbitrary amounts of money to pay for basic needs, it seems like it would be better if we can automate the maintenance of those needs to a point where the costs are negligible. Easier said than done, of course, but imagine reaching a technological point where instead of having self-driving cars, we have self-sustaining food/clothing/shelter.
- marcosdumay 5y agoIf you don't distribute the money, automation can make people poorer just as easily as it can make people richer.
- aspenmayer 5y agoI can see how automation would make poor and middle income people poorer, but I don’t see why automation would depress the wealth of the already wealthy.
- marcosdumay 5y agoWell, "people" here means 99% or 99.9% or maybe a couple extra nines. I really didn't mean the next 0.01%. Anyway, it can, by a complex process that makes an entire society poorer once people gets thrown out of the economy. That includes the absurdly rich too. It's just that if this is the only point where it bothers you, honestly I don't even care about your opinion.
- aspenmayer 5y agoAutomation can put everyone out of a job, for all I care about jobs and the economy. They are potentially mutually beneficial, but usually extremely unfavorable to labor in terms of sharing profits. No jobs means no unemployment.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y ago
- lrem 5y agoWell, the important skill is saying no. While you won't get far saying no to the employer, all those other things on the todo list got there somehow. I'm now fighting the good fight of getting my own time back. I suggest trying the same.
- simonh 5y agoThen again I think it's inarguable (I'm clearly wrong, people will argue with it) that modern life for most of us is incomparably better than the lives most of us had in the past. My kids are 17/18 now, while I was the same age back in the early 80s. There's no comparison. The quality of life available on even a modest salary nowadays is far, far better. One drag on this is property prices. A huge amount of people's incomes go into property, but that's largely something we do to ourselves and each other. There's a very inflexible housing market here in the UK, so we're all in competition for the best houses, and bid up their value against each other.
- willcipriano 5y ago> My kids are 17/18 now, while I was the same age back in the early 80s. There's no comparison. The quality of life available on even a modest salary nowadays is far, far better. Most people aren't having children[0], largely because they can't afford them. This is probably selection bias. My kid has a better life than I did, but that's mainly because I have avoided the addictions my parents had. [0]https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/12/us-population-grew-in-2021-slowest-rate-since-founding-of-the-nation.html https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/12/us-population...
- reissbaker 5y agoLargely because they can't afford them. Number of children inversely correlates to income [1], with the poorest families having the most children and the richest families having the fewest. You're right that birth rates are falling, but I don't think you're right about largely why. 1: https://www.statista.com/statistics/241530/birth-rate-by-family-income-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/241530/birth-rate-by-fam...
- flerchin 5y agoThis is an interesting point. You seem to be implying that rising incomes are causing people to choose to have fewer children. However, it could just as easily be that having children is a drag on people's incomes.
- grenoire 5y agoI do understand this very well as someone who builds process automation tools. There are infinite menial jobs to automate, but in the end the benefit is only realised by the capital owners and employers, rarely the employees.
- eloisius 5y agoThe benefit is also realized by you in the process of automating it.
- randomdata 5y agoWhen I was kid it was said that if you went to university and researched/developed your work there that you would be able to make more money. Idea being that the technology would become capital of your own, which you could offer to business under more favourable terms than if you were to create it for the business as an employee. I suppose in reality that there will always be someone willing to take the quick cash instead.
- bluGill 5y agoMore relaxing is not a goal! Very few people can spend spend days in bed if not forced to. If you try your body will betray you by getting up and doing something. You can do "more work for the man", or you can do a hobby of some sort. Either way though you are up and doing something.
- danaris 5y ago"Relaxing" is not synonymous with "lying in bed." For some people, reading is relaxing. For some, writing is relaxing. For others, playing video games is relaxing. For yet others, making video games is relaxing. The point is being able to decide and structure your own time, rather than being beholden to someone else's demands just in order to have enough money to keep existing on this planet.
- avgcorrection 5y ago> You can do "more work for the man", or you can do a hobby of some sort. Either way though you are up and doing something. Way to miss the point completely. Clearly “relaxing” in this context meant “leisure” or “free time”.
- bluGill 5y agoNo, you miss the point: what is the difference between a hobby and a job? You are doing something either way. I'm not the only person who likes my job. I'm not the only person with a hobby that sometimes gets frustrated with something in the hobby.
- avgcorrection 5y agoThe freedom/free time part is obviously the distinction!
- bluGill 5y agoSure, but why is that important enough to make in the first place? Note if you don't have a background in philosophy you probably can't answer this. If you do the answer will take many pages
- reissbaker 5y agoSure, but I also have a supercomputer in my pocket now, which is pretty neat. We couldn't even have this conversation without incredible amounts of technological innovation that's happened over the last few decades — well, at least not without endless "letters to the editor" happening over the span of weeks (and maybe not getting printed at all). Automated X replacing manual Y is usually good, IMO, even if the idea that it'll result in more leisure time is pretty much bunk. Even on a personal level, say a car lets me do a trip in 30 minutes instead of 2 hours walking. I don't relax for an hour and a half. I go check more things off my todo list. Isn't that good? You certainly could give yourself more leisure time — there's no capitalist overlord forcing you to do your own personal todo list — but since you have more time, you've decided to do more things to help yourself.
- onion2k 5y agoI also have a supercomputer in my pocket now And I thought you were pleased to see me. Slightly more seriously, and delightfully pedantically, you don't. A supercomputer isn't a supercomputer because it does a lot of computations every second. It's the utility of the machine that makes it a supercomputer. Your phone can model entire weather systems or the intricacies of millisecond-by-millisecond fluid dynamics inside a nuclear explosion, but you choose to play Angry Birds on it, so it isn't a supercomputer. It's just a very, very fast, and immensely wasteful PC. You could do everything you do on your phone with a much less well-specced device. We all could.
- reissbaker 5y agoBut you choose to play Angry Birds on it. Nah, I mostly read HN and take photos with it. But — that in itself has been pretty society-changing (well, maybe not the part about reading HN). Literally every person, just about, has a reasonably good camera in their pocket capable of shooting video, that connects to the internet — and by the way, the quality of those images does actually relate to the thing being a supercomputer (thanks, computational photography). Would the George Floyd related protests have happened without someone's cameraphone taping cops killing him in cold blood? Definitely not: only cable news companies decided what to shoot and — equally critically — what to broadcast. And on a more mundane note: ubiquitous internet-connected cameras certainly revolutionized how I pick restaurants for dinner.
- lm28469 5y ago> In reality, there's a race in terms of productivity: "now they can do 2x the work they did before!" And wages didn't follow the increase in productivity: https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sam0x17 5y ago> As long as companies are driven by profits Capital really doesn't drive innovation at all except in very specific situations where there are sufficient regulations and guardrails to coax companies in the direction of progress (and you certainly won't see innovation happening under completely unregulated capitalism). It's almost always independent and/or individual people -- researchers, open source contributors, scientists, etc -- who come up with society-changing technologies and ideas. In the mid 1900s, the large tech corporations ran enormous corporate laboratories, like the famous Bell Labs that would churn out things like this (Unix, almost the internet, etc). Rampant de-regulation of capital in the 70s and 80s led to an industry shift that removed these guardrails and incentives and made it easier to simply monopolize, price fix, and acquire your way to the top, as the oil and rail tycoons had in the early 1900s, and that is where we find ourselves now. FANG companies are not innovators -- they have become machines that swallow up the innovations of others and either neutralize or begrudgingly copy them in such a way that still manages to crush competition via economies of scale. Google, the "great innovator" of search hasn't innovated on the topic of search engines in over a decade, and instead relies on multi-billion dollar deals to ensure Google is the default search engine on every mobile device in the world. When a competitor emerges, they acquire and shutter it, or sit pretty knowing economies of scale will ensure new competitors won't get sufficient traction. For the last decade, Apple has simply watched the tech industry very closely, cultivated their image as a glorified fashion company (everything driven by design and status-symbol imagery), exerted monopolistic control over an entire industry via their app store fees and tight restrictions, and used their unlimited resources to copy or buy their way into the features and ideas actual innovators have proven will play well in the coming years. Amazon uses its size and its control over a global marketplace (that they completely control) to continuously enter new markets and shutter competition with economies of scale, and is taking the same approach with AWS. Notably they won't be innovating on anything outside the realm of "just run it in our network of data centers", and everything they do with AWS is designed to pull you into the walled garden of AWS products. Netflix has simply acquired their way into controlling a large portion of the good movie studios, their only "innovation" being on perpetuating a toxic and cutthroat company culture where everyone is constantly under review and DRM and compression technology to limit who can watch what based on expensive regional licensing deals. All of these companies are threatened by, and afraid of innovation, and they will stop it from happening if they can. They compete and innovate, only if they have to, and would much rather just pay you to not innovate. Capital isn't going to create innovation -- regulation of capital, done correctly, will. Capital has to be dragged into innovating, kicking and screaming.
- Aunche 5y ago> now instead of doing y, the person is now free to explore more leisurely pursuits We are exploring more leisurely pursuits, though instead pursuing hobbies and building relationships, we're consuming media. The average American adult spends over half their day doing so. A lot of it is probably passive background noise, but it's a lot nonetheless. https://www.nielsen.com/us/en/insights/report/2020/the-nielsen-total-audience-report-august-2020/ https://www.nielsen.com/us/en/insights/report/2020/the-niels...
- tehjoker 5y agoI think that's because people are tired and are constantly thinking about how they have to go back to work / school soon. If people had more time off, I think more interesting things would happen.
- czbond 5y agoI agree in theory, but disagree in practice. Covid lockdowns taught me the general public is superb at wasting time and being inefficient. Their mind turned to Netflixing all day, making Tiktok dance numbers, etc. I am bullish on machines & software improving because people are incentivized through salaries to improve them. I am bearish / pessimistic on the average humans productive use of time outside of amusement or relaxation. Humanity has taught me that Pareto's principle applies to humans.
- tehjoker 5y agoWhy shouldn't they relax if they can? It's bizarre to me that we need to regiment the entire population in order to... make sure people don't have fun?
- czbond 5y agoWhether it is human nature, or learned behavior, the typical human is unable to fill their time with productive use over a longer period of time unless purpose is imposed on them. Hence "work". The concept in a more general term is even mentioned in religious text so there must be a basis....
- notpachet 5y agoFrom a Calvin & Hobbes strip: [DAD] It used to be that if a client wanted something in a week, it was considered a rush job, and he was lucky to get it. Now, with modems, faxes, and car phones, everybody wants everything instantly! Improved technology just increases expectations. These machines don't make life easier -- they make like more harassed. If we wanted more leisure, we'd invent machines that do things less efficiently. [CALVIN] Six minutes to microwave this?? Who's got that kind of time?!
- TecoAndJix 5y agoLink to the strip - https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/1995/08/17 https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/1995/08/17
- ByThyGrace 5y agoIs C&H text searchable? Great find otherwise!
- dxbydt 5y agoThe fuck. Its actually searchable! I tried googling this - summer is butter on your chin site:https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/ https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/ found it instantly.
- TecoAndJix 5y agoIt is! https://michaelyingling.com/random/calvin_and_hobbes/ https://michaelyingling.com/random/calvin_and_hobbes/
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoLooks like every strip has a transcript embedded in the markup right under the image, which is very thoughtful of them.
- ThinkingGuy 5y agoOr as Scott Adams expressed it in chapter 1 of "The Dilbert Future": Good trend: Computers allow us to work 100% faster Unexpected bad thing: Computers generate 300 percent more work
- smnrchrds 5y ago> Even on a personal level, say a car lets me do a trip in 30 minutes instead of 2 hours walking. I don't relax for an hour and a half. And that's why building highways does not reduce average commute time—people just move further from the downtown where they work. If you build a new highway that cuts commute time in half, on the population level, the sprawl increases until average population is twice as far and their commute remains the same.
- sokoloff 5y agoThey may very well be happier because they (as evidenced by their choices) prefer to live in a detached house and have a yard over having a shorter commute. Cars and the highway enabled that increase in happiness, even if commute times are unchanged.
- BobbyJo 5y ago> As long as companies are driven by profits As long as people want more stuff. Company profits have a dependent relationship on consumption. It wouldn't matter if the company produced twice as much if people didn't consume the increased output. You hint at that in your last statement, I just wanted to spell it out.
- haswell 5y agoI get what you’re trying to say, but this doesn’t necessarily always apply. For example, demand for some goods is fairly predictable, e.g. certain commodity foodstuff. A profit driven company selling these kinds of goods is focused on increasing their market share, but no matter what, the demand is there. Compare this to something else like SUV sales, where demand exists that probably shouldn’t. Yes, consumer sentiment drives/enables these companies, but the nature of that demand and the behavior it drives is certainly not all equal.
- BobbyJo 5y agoIt isn't equal, but pointing that out downplays the fact that they are in equilibrium. Commodities producers reduce costs to increase profits through greater market share, but without the drive to consume more goods than the present, the excess capacity from the cost reduction would sit idle, which doesn't happen in practice. To make the point more salient, if people were willing to live to the standards of the 1800s, a significant amount of the workforce slaving away could retire right now. People choose increased consumption over leisure time, not corporations, corporations only provide demanded goods.
- loudtieblahblah 5y ago>Even on a personal level, say a car lets me do a trip in 30 minutes instead of 2 hours walking. I don't relax for an hour and a half. I go check more things off my todo list. This is why all the modern conviences that people adore, including myself, just makes our lives more cluttered and anxiety ridden. Nothing is freeing up our time so that we can focus on self care, relaxation, valuable time with family. It just makes us more able to cram more stuff in. And the "to do list" is never ending. There's always yard work, house work, more constructive things your kids could be doing to get them ahead in life, maybe you could now afford some extra education to further your career, there's always just.. SOMETHING to fill in the new holes we now have. It's not just businesses and profit motives. and one day you look back at it all and often you find that 2 hour walk, was probably mentally and physically healthier for you. How many things in life are like this - where we've scarified our mental health, physical/nutritional health, our privacy, ownership rights, and other rights all in the name of a convenient technology that "simplifies" one problem for us while creating 10 more in it's wake? Then we're all convinced that this new, convenient thing is super valuable and can't be done without.
- chasd00 5y agowell the problem is people don't put "self care, relaxation, valuable time with family" on the TODO list. ever. If you make it a priority then you'd get it done.
- loudtieblahblah 5y agoPeople tend to think meditation (or longer prayer) is a waste of time bc you aren't "doing anything". And once you have anxiety and depression (for most) and only then, Do you realize thats kinda the point.
- webmaven 5y ago> well the problem is people don't put "self care, relaxation, valuable time with family" on the TODO list. ever. If you make it a priority then you'd get it done. In general people seem to be fairly bad at getting things that are important but not urgent (hat tip to the Eisenhower Matrix) done unless they establish a habit for it. Holidays are valuable in that they at least reduce the need for coordination between multiple parties somewhat, at least for "valuable time with family", but they don't really help with the "self care and relaxation" bucket. Quite the contrary, for many.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y ago> In reality, there's a race in terms of productivity: "now they can do 2x the work they did before!" I think the reality is more depressing. It’s not companies deciding this, it’s each other. “Now I can do 2x the work I did before.” As a system there’s a feedback loop involved. You only need very few people to decide to undercut each other, but for each person who does, that’s more pressure for the next person to keep up, causing even more pressure on the next people, etc. This is why the 40 hour work week had to come from the top. I doubt we’ll see real leisure time improvements until we see overtime pay starting at 32hr/week or something else top down like that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 5y agoWouldn’t your life be worse off in general if you had to walk for those extra 90 minutes and had fewer things done? If you thought otherwise, why couldn’t you walk now, even though cars exist?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway0106 5y agoThere's a wide variance in who captures the gains from technology, and most of it seems to come from whether the technology enables new transactions. Transactions are all that matter in a market economy; any work done that doesn't alter the terms of trade is effectively invisible (case: housework). Hence why corporations frequently try to deliver the shittiest products and customer service that will not result in them losing customers, employees try to do the least work possible that will not get them fired, companies aggressively expand into new markets and convert new customers, and employees hunt for promotions and job-hop into better opportunities. Your ability to capture leisure time for yourself is largely related to how well you can judge the minimum amount of work needed to not get fired and then execute on that while saving the rest for yourself; or, alternatively, how much value you can create when you do work so that you can bank the rest in financial assets and live without any further transactions. Hint: the former amount is usually more generous than you think it is, particularly if the latter is very high and you let your employer capture that value. Technologies that result in new transaction types result in large amounts of value being captured by their customers, as well as by the company delivering them. Think of YouTube: millions of people have been able to step into the market previously reserved for entertainers, broadcasters, news anchors, and other TV personalities, and in the process they've made billions for Google, millions for themselves, and cannibalized the whole industries of advertising, journalism, and entertainment. The Internet as a whole has created the top 5 most valuable companies on earth, worth a combined $10T+, as well as millions of other small businesses. Technologies that increase the efficiency of existing transaction types typically only enrich the companies that buy them, at least until they penetrate the market entirely, at which point they only enrich the company that sells them and are just table stakes for the companies that buy them. Think of say the high-availability mainframe market of the early 80s (Stratus and Tandem). When banks started using these to process transactions, bank tellers didn't capture any of this value, because it's not like a bank teller can go open their own bank using these machines. Contrast this to say the Apple II and Visicalc, where people could open up their own business because the technology let them cut expensive secretaries and accountants out of the loop. There's a deep connection between this idea and that of Disruptive vs. Sustaining innovations in The Innovator's Dilemma. Disruptive innovations are those that create new customers and new transactions, thus opening up new markets. Sustaining innovations are those that improve the efficiency of existing transactions and customer relationships. Sustaining innovations can widen your moat and increase the amount you can charge for your product, but they aren't going to form new businesses or unlock large market that you don't already have a foothold in. This is also why certain VCs get extremely excited about innovations like PCs, the Internet, cryptocurrency, and wearable/ambient computing. Communication, finance, markets, and proximity are the key building blocks that enable transactions; anything that fundamentally changes these systems is likely to be significantly disruptive. Meanwhile your SaaS that improves the efficiency of a niche industry by 5x is much less exciting, even though it has a higher probability of success, because you know exactly who your customers are and are unlikely to be able to create more of them.
- zamfi 5y ago> There have been lots of technology x replacing a manual process with the promise that "now instead of doing y, the person is now free to explore more leisurely pursuits." Yeah, the "free to explore more leisurely pursuits" part is contrived in most cases, but there is a real argument for automating work that's "dirty, dangerous, or dull" -- freeing humans to do the parts of the work that's more interesting, meaningful, safer, cleaner, etc.
- pm90 5y agoUnless we get to some sort of AGI (or partial AGI), I don't really see this playing out like this. We're already seeing employers capitulate quite hard when they're short on labor: a stark rise in compensation, shorter work weeks, better benefits and so on.
- jdavis703 5y agoIt also means people can make more complicated stuff. For example, it’s crazy seeing what amateurs can do with post-production on TikTok. Far from putting Hollywood professionals out of business, it’s enabled humans to take many parts of mass media for granted, while pros move on to creating ever more dazzling content.
- nine_k 5y agoAs a leisurely pursuit, you can now fly anywhere in the world for under $1000 (some planning required), or listen to basically any music ever produced, or play and record whatever music you happen to compose (a couple grand of music gear suffices), or read any book, or publish anything for the entire world basically for free. But if your idea of leisurely activity is laying in a hammock and watch the clouds go by, it's still as expensive as ever. Time is as expensive as ever; for instance, look at your effective hourly rate.
- somethoughts 5y agoAs a person with a minimalism view on possessions - I've often wondered if with today's technology such as self vacuuming robots, etc. if we designed new houses around said technology and what it could do today - could many more people be able to have robotic house cleaning. If you could spec out a house to have only unscratchable concrete floors, rounded corners, all furniture must have adequate clearance, a Roomba would be way more effective. I'd buy a house with a spartan bathroom if that meant I never had to houseclean. The Revolving Toilet by Sanitronics https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9DjHbj3qon0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9DjHbj3qon0
- qmmmur 5y agoUnabomber was right
- black_13 5y ago
- npilk 5y agoThis piece is an interesting complement: https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2012/05/09/welcome-to-the-future-nauseous/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2012/05/09/welcome-to-the-future-... "This also explains why so few futurists make any money. They are attracted to exactly those parts of the future that are worth very little. They find visions of changed human behavior stimulating. Technological change serves as a basis for constructing aspirational visions of changed humanity. Unfortunately, technological change actually arrives in ways that leave human behavior minimally altered. Engineering is about finding excitement by figuring out how human behavior could change. Marketing is about finding money by making sure it doesn’t."
- joe_the_user 5y agoWhile that's an appealing idea and much as I like Venkatesh Rao, I think the explanation is simple in a different way. Making money on investments isn't generally about know something will happen sometime in the future. It's about knowing exactly when that something will start to pay off. And that knowledge is much more wrapped in small details. Amazon spent ten years losing money but had investors who believed it would even eventually make it, which it did. Determining whether Amazon would have been a good investment at the start wasn't about knowing ecommerce would work, it was about noticing things like committed Amazon's investors were, etc, etc.
- vr46 5y agoThis is pretty much why we need philosophy (include religion in there if you like) - as they say, science shows us the world as it is, but philosophy lets us imagine the world as we should like it to be - so that technology can help us get there.
- em-bee 5y agohere is a religious quote that is relevant to the topic: Mankind has been created to carry forward an ever advancing civilization
- api 5y agoWe really stopped imagining new ways of living and it’s unfortunate. A lot of people seem to think that the various isms that have already existed represent the only conceivable modes of human organization.
- bytehowl 5y agoAgreed. People nowadays are indoctrinated to think that it's either capitalism or socialism/communism. This prevents them from rocking the boat, because the only alternative to the status quo is arguably even worse. There is a system out there which is better than anything we have tried so far. However, to discover it we first need to break out of this mentality that we're stuck choosing the lesser of two evils. That's why I no longer say I want socialism. Instead, I say I don't know what I want, but I know I don't want capitalism.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wombatmobile 5y agoInvention and technology and social change work in a more granular form than TFA supposes. When the electric lightbulb took off it lead to so many new ways of working and studying and entertainment, the world changed a thousand times over. But it wasn’t necessary for Edison to contemplate night clubs or Logic Pro X or alternating night shifts for the changes to happen. Just the lightbulb was enough for one thing to lead to another. The future wasn’t invented at Parc in the 1970s, but a lot of it escaped from there and blossomed over the next fifty years.
- snarf21 5y agoExactly. The Wright Brothers weren't thinking about going to Mars, they wanted to make a "bird" that people could ride like a horse. New inventions spur more new inventions and new ideas. Sometimes it is just an old problem solved by combining two new things.
- dbsmith83 5y agoThis is a great point. The author's examples seemed cherry-picked to justify a cynical anti-establishment diatribe.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- beaconstudios 5y agoThe British philosopher Mark Fisher coined the term "capitalist realism" for the sense that, since the beginning of the neoliberal era with Reagan and Thatcher and the collapse of the Soviet Union, it has become impossible to imagine an end to capitalism. In fact, "it has become easier to imagine the end of the world, than the end of capitalism". Perhaps that's why apocalyptic and dystopian fiction has taken over from optimistic futurism - we are no longer capable of imagining Star Trek futures of abundance and idealism.
- Barrin92 5y agoI think it's important to say that it goes deeper than not being able to imagine idealistic, utopian, or abundant futures. Fisher's point was that we aren't able to imagine any future at all any more. And I think that actually involves Star Trek, which with its sort of 'space replicator communism' and adventurism is in itself not really forward looking, it's just optimistic, and entirely a product of its own time, namely 60s and 70s 'golden age' sci-fi.
- huetius 5y agoI have enjoyed what I’ve read of Mark Fisher, though I haven’t read CR except via excerpt and quotation. If you are open to a compelling, non-Marxist analysis of the present malaise, I would recommend the writings of Augusto Del Noce. The past seventy years have made something of a prophet of Del Noce. He predicted, as early as the 1950s, and among other things which were — at that time — unthinkable: the fall of communism, the sexual revolution, and the global supremacy of a new stage of capitalism, which he believed would become its own, existentially suffocating form of totalitarianism. He wasn’t magic, he just had a very logical way of thinking through the consequences of ideas. He didnt have a philosophical system, but drew heavily from Vico and Rosmini, who did. He was also influenced by his own experience with totalitarianism in the early 20th Century, where he briefly became a Catholic Communist in response to the rise of Fascism, before rejecting both. He was also conversant with modern and contemporary philosophy in a way not paralleled by other Catholic thinkers of his time, excepting Ratzinger. If this sounds interesting, a good introduction is this book review[0], written by him shortly before his death, but after having been vindicated by the collapse of the USSR and it’s aftermath. It touches on a number of Del Nocean ideas: the suicide of the Revolution, the heterogenesis of ends, Occidentalism as ideology, Neo-Capitalism, and traditionalism as an ideological reduction of religious tradition. His books are even better — every bit as clear-eyed and unnerving as what I’ve read of Fisher, but with a glint of hope. [0] https://churchlifejournal.nd.edu/articles/marxism-died-in-the-east-because-it-realized-itself-in-the-west/ https://churchlifejournal.nd.edu/articles/marxism-died-in-th... (don’t be put off by the cold-warrior title, I’m not sure that it’s his own).
- reedf1 5y agoI forget where I came across it but this brings to mind an aphorism I've heard before. Basically, people in cultures that need to build fires to cook and heat their homes usually reject modern solutions saying "But then I wouldn't be able to build and keep a fire!"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DrNuke 5y agoInnovators combine new technologies to improve or expand human capabilities, and that’s happening in many many sectors indeed!
- lawrenceyan 5y agoI have to disagree with the author here if only because the majority of applications he talks about are transitionary in the sense that they are dependent on AI/ML that's at the cusp of fruition. Self-driving is probably the best example I can come up with, where currently something like an Uber or DoorDash relies on a gig-worker underclass in order to drive things. But once autonomous vehicles come online, as they already are starting to, that opportunity will also soon disappear. I think the more meaningful question to ask here is what happens when even the menial labor made available through gig work[0] starts to dry up. The discussion, in my opinion, should really no longer be about the legitimacy of automation which I believe is being argued here, but what we will do as a society in response to the inevitability of automation and its ramifications for the average person as a result. [0]: I see gig work as the culmination of peak labor efficiency, short of perhaps slavery / indentured servitude, which even then isn't enough to compete after a certain point
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DarylZero 5y agoUber and DoorDash don't rely on the workers just as labor, but also as capital -- the drivers provide the cars. Also, Uber at least doesn't even rely on making money from customers, just raising money from investors. So they're complicated situations and not easy to generalize. > what we will do as a society in response to the inevitability of automation and its ramifications to humanity as a result. We already automated production in the 20th century, "the service economy" is what resulted. As long as people can be prevented from accessing the product, they can be kept working for it.
- lawrenceyan 5y agoWhat do you see as the primary pathway for people after we automate away the major components of the service economy?
- hooande 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thenerdhead 5y agoThere is an obsession in knowledge work for productivity (output per time). The goal should be for efficiency (best output per time). Having more slack / diffused time to problem solve, think things through, and actively rest brings more consciousness into knowledge work and makes people more efficient. The problem is...line & middle managers are largely incentivized for results from their people. Results can be achieved in many different ways, but the current approach is brute force which leads to burnout and thus a "reshuffling" to find more sustainable working conditions or be paid more for how many "productive" responsibilities put on your plate. For the workplace to embrace new technologies, this article is spot on in the fact that we must imagine our ideal ways of living, working, and playing. We can't go from screen to screen. We have to have a right to disconnect.
- chasd00 5y ago> There is an obsession in knowledge work for productivity (output per time). The goal should be for efficiency (best output per time). i've thought about this a lot. I wouldn't read a book about how to be more productive but i may read a book about how to be more effective.
- thenerdhead 5y agoI think you have to read through the productivity books to realize it's all just tools to your efficiency.
- netcan 5y agoI think it's trite to pick on The Jetsons, while ignoring the many attempted predictions of the future that did focus on "underlying social relations." Marxism was, in large part, a techno futurism. JM Keynes predicted a future of 15hr workweeks and leisure societies. Feminism, at various point in time, was had strong techno-futuristic elements. It's either really hard to predict people, or we aren't objective enough to do social science. Our predictions and attempts at critical analysis tend to reflect our ideals, or anti-ideals moreso than an objective conclusion. Meanwhile, predicting the butterfly effect of a technology or change is almost impossible. Could a western european living in the 1400s and pondering the importance printing presses have predicted the Protestant Reformation? I'm not saying it's bad to delve into such questions. I'm saying not to start with a "no one ever talks about X..."
- giantg2 5y agoI think there's some truth to the idea that sci-fi relies on and mimics the same type of living to some degree. In order to have a successful book, you need the consumer to feel a connection. That's hard to do if everything is fundamentally different from what they know. I would also say that some stories do change one or two fundamental aspects at a time. Sometimes just to explore the inverse of current society.
- narrator 5y agoThe novel I am currently writing imagines a world where all human values are subordinated to ecological sustainability. All progress is measured by that. Perfection is zero resource consumption. This is not the Jetsons future. It probably won't sell that well because it is not at all like the present and is kind of brutal, though there are some good parts.
- giantg2 5y agoIt might sell well. That troupe sort of exists today to a lesser extent - lots of talk about sustainability. I think there would be a segment interested in the next step of no consumption, or would wonder what that looks like. So I do see this as a tie that could make the problem relatable to people even if the outcome is more brutal.
- martythemaniak 5y agoI like these types of essays, even if I largely disagree with them. Truth is, our imaginations are quiet limited, and always have been. Think of all ancient mythological creatures (half man, half goat, half man, half bird, etc) they're all pretty lame when compared to the wonders you see under a microscope. Reality is infinitely richer than our imagination, and the same applies to the future. It'll surprise us in ways we can't quite predict. The other thing is, the future almost by definition can never come. The moment it does, it becomes the present and gets taken for granted. We have video calls, cars that drive themselves on highways and fantastic voice recognition (on the latest Pixels for example), but these just become "obvious" and expected and the future moves on. Finally, why should we expect human nature to change? Some of the biggest social changes over the last few decades - LGBTQ rights and marijuana legalization - are just new spins on the same old thing people have always been up to: getting high and fucking. In the future, they'll figure out even more ways to get high and fuck. Are these new ways of living any different than a self-driving car is a new way of living?
- aaron695 5y ago
- motohagiography 5y ago> These recurring technofutures perpetuate a familiar equation in which convenience equals freedom This statement I agree with. When you view convenience through the lens of dependency, you see something like Ivan Illich's "radical monopoly," where a technological change subordinates everyone to it. The car and roads are the example he uses, and the internet and its platforms are another.
- backtoyoujim 5y agoUsing "The Flintstones" as the basis for this article makes it even more depressing.
- penjelly 5y agonew technologies also require new systems to exist in, which tend to reduce how long it takes to do something once, but almost always comes with a cost. ie: light switches versus smart bulbs. lightswitches: a system that relies on the user to hit the lights in whatever room they want light. This means a physical action. maintenance: low, only if electrical outlet has problems does the user need to do repairs, or change a lightbulb. smart bulbs: system can be controlled automatically or with voice, or even the switch. System is more flexible but comes with increased maintenance cost. maintenance: bulbs require connection to a hub, which requires internet conn, automations require time to setup, firmware updates can break functionality, and other unknowns. i point this out because we often forget, we usually have ways of doing the "new" things the way we did before, and they worked well, new ways are great, but sometimes come with hidden externalities
- ballenf 5y agoThe quote from Jony Ive > In the words of Apple’s celebrated designer Jony Ive: “When something exceeds your ability to understand how it works, it sort of becomes magical.” This really gets it wrong. It becomes your master. Perhaps a benevolent master, but a master nonetheless.
- karaterobot 5y ago> The work of Ruth Schwartz Cowan demonstrates this dynamic in the arrival of appliances like microwaves, washing machines and refrigerators in the first half of the 20th century... Cowan showed that these technologies did not necessarily result in a net reduction of women’s housework hours. Instead, the new electrical machines were often replacing the paid labor of domestic workers. American families in the early 20th century, even economically “uncomfortable” ones, often maintained day workers or live-in workers as a regular supply of labor. In the U.S., only a minority of families ever employed domestic workers on a regular basis. Most people did not employ domestic workers. Domestic workers, for example, did not generally employ domestic workers. Electrical appliances did decrease the amount of labor required to run a house. That's why families today, who work more hours on average, can run a house without employing domestic laborers.
- garden_hermit 5y agoThat description really does a disservice to Cowan's work. A more general argument was that: - Prior to the industrial revolution, men's and women's work was distinct, but reciprocal—they both contributed towards the general maintenance of a home (farming, animal care, cooking, cleaning, chopping wood, repair, etc.) - With the industrial revolution, men left for work, leaving many women solely responsible for nearly all home-based tasks. Household tasks became associated with women's work. - Over time, electric appliances reduced the necessary labor to perform their household tasks. However, shifting expectations of motherhood and cleanliness standards resulted in less time saved than you would expect. Before washing machines, clothes were cleaned only seldomly, but with them, it became a weekly or even daily task. The domestic workers part of the book is real and was common, but I'd hesitate to use it to exemplify the overall argument of the book.
- simonebrunozzi 5y agoBertrand Russell, the English philosopher, was not a fan of work. In his “In Praise of Idleness” (1932) [0], he poised that if society were better managed, one would only need to work four hours a day. Not to be confused with the "4-hour workweek" by Tim Ferriss. [0]: https://harpers.org/archive/1932/10/in-praise-of-idleness/ https://harpers.org/archive/1932/10/in-praise-of-idleness/
- dv_dt 5y agoThat’s why I’ve been trying to keep a nonjudgmental eye on the solarpunk community. There is a positive outlook we need to foster to think with fewer constraints about the future. Most recent HN topic on it. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27868913 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27868913
- gtsop 5y agoSolarpunk is truly the art movement the world needs desperately right now.
- smm11 5y agoMake me a folding phone rather than one that will run a week between charging, and not shatter when dropped, or break when under water.
- orky56 5y agoYou can have a color changing car instead
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ryukoposting 5y agoMaybe the goal of the Jetsons isn't to accurately imagine the future, but rather to entertain a contemporary audience.
- PikachuEXE 5y ago> Cyberpunk is a subgenre of science fiction in a dystopian futuristic setting that tends to focus on a "combination of lowlife and high tech" Which is why I like Cyberpunk... though living in it is something else
- somenewaccount1 5y agoThis is so many consider Demolition Man an extremely underrated movie. It actually projected life differently. I also summise, it's why it's not as popular a sci-fi flick. Im eager for it's remake someday.