17 ms·
I Miss RSS
- zitterbewegung 5y agoSort of obvious why RSS went away. It is really hard to put ads into RSS. Sure you can just add a update but that's not really feasible (and could be filtered). So the large sites just started removing it and it helped them capture ad sales.
- Forgeties79 5y agoAs a podcast producer, I wish we would wholesale replace RSS soon. It feels like the most paper clip nonsense at this point.
- trvr 5y agoWhat would you replace it with? Bonus points if your answer is somehow de-centralized like RSS already is. ;-)
- Buttons840 5y agoReplace it with what?
- riffic 5y agoactivitystreams
- gnuj3 5y ago
- qbasic_forever 5y agoIt's really no different than email lists, medium, substack, etc. which are all working through ways of effectively monetizing themselves. RSS feed for your content + a patreon or similar place (that potentially gives you access to a premium RSS feed with more/expanded content) would totally be feasible.
- caslon 5y agoDaring Fireball has for years, and Gruber's gotten rich off of it.
- pixelrevision 5y agoThat, analytics and auth. Which is a shame. I can’t deal with most news sites now because I’m usually reading them on my phone. There’s just so much garbage between ads, scroll locked videos and JavaScript breaking the pages. AMP was supposed to help with this stuff but it breaks all the time too. I know I’d happily pay for plain text content that I can format myself but I’m guessing there’s just no market for that sort of thing.
- mmahemoff 5y agoEmail ads are more effective than RSS. The reader's email address is known (obviously!) and the content can be targeted individually. RSS is typically a single feed for everyone. Premium RSS is possible, with individual links per user, but it's much more complicated than just typing your email address into a field (something you already do when you pay for anything). Also, chances of the link being shared around is high and aggregators often inadvertently leak premium links. In contrast, someone's inbox is about as private as it gets.
- gen220 5y agoYou can mitigate link sharing by counting the feed reader hits per link (anything more than two standard deviations is probably a shared link, which you can set a revocation policy for). You can reject requests to content that don’t have a non-revoked referrer. This way, they can only get your content by copy-pasting content and rehosting the feed, which is an unavoidable risk. In any case, as Netflix’s early history shows, depending on your cost structure, link sharing is likely a net positive. It’s probably only worth prosecuting the feeds that get shared with 100s of people. It definitely is more complicated, but the tools to make it simple are easy to build! Maybe we’ll see growth in this space. One can dream
- mmahemoff 5y agoYou can, albeit with some effort involved, e.g. Ben Thomson has mentioned Stratechery does some kind of link counting like that with the podcast feed. It's a good point that some amount of unauthorised sharing can be a positive. The main issue is it's hard to control without also having false positives, where the paying subscriber is annoyed by their service being revoked, having to re-auth, etc.
- naravara 5y agoSuccessful blogs I follow do sponsored RSS feeds. It’s perfectly feasible to work ads into RSS content. What’s not doable is targeted ads, but I’d rather those all go away anyway.
- pizza234 5y agoRSS feeds don't replace a website. Most of the websites don't publish their whole articles on the RSS feed, only a summary (or even just a line). Therefore, RSS doesn't cause any advertisement loss, as the user needs to go to the website anyway (which, to be clear, is totally fine - RSS still works as filter/preview, which is very helpful).
- medstrom 5y agoThis behavior is typical for news sites, but in fact the majority of blogs don't truncate their feed items.
- wilcosky 5y agoI stand by my comments. Video killed the radio star. And, social media killed RSS. Sure, it still exists. But, you don’t see that RSS logo on every website like you once did. A new-ish web user may not even know what RSS is. Everyone’s like, let’s meta, let’s fediverse. Pft, it’s all just kids re-doing RSS.
- WCityMike 5y agoI'm saying this without any connection to the service aside from being a customer, but I think Inoreader is doing innovative work in the RSS space.
- TekMol 5y agoRSS is still alive and kicking. I came here via RSS. But the masses browse a locked down web. That is true. We might have another shot at an open web for the masses via the whole crypto movement. If content goes on decentralized blockchains in the future, nobody can lock the content down like big tech did for Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok etc. Projects like Arweave show how it is possible to store huge amounts of data on a blockchain without using much resources. If we get there, it will be trivial to build blockchain-to-rss bridges. I am ready to build some to get my favorite content into my RSS reader. My feeling is that there might be a way towards a decentralized web via financial incentives. In a decentralized web, crypto currencies can float around freely. Making it easy for the actors to earn. Old platforms will probably be slow to open up to crypto currencies.
- mnd999 5y agoOh please go away.
- diogenesjunior 5y ago
- wizzwizz4 5y agoAlright, I'll bite. Consider a “decentralised” blockchain system that does the work of The Pirate Bay – providing hashes of particular files, along with their names, so that people can select and request data from the P2P network. How, exactly, does this system help with RSS in any way? Additionally, how does this system help with the “censorship” issues that The Pirate Bay has? Even when The Pirate Bay remains up, that doesn't mean anybody's seeding. And a blockchain-based system has to have this limitation. If all the data is directly on the blockchain, nobody can actually download it all, so the blockchain becomes unverifiable and ceases to have any cryptographic properties at all. (In short, there's no benefit to a blockchain at all.)
- verifex 5y agoI miss having a standard for uniform syndication that could be read and updated IN-BROWSER. RIP Firefox RSS feeds.
- breput 5y agoIf you liked Sage or similar extensions in the XUL-based Firefox, check out Drop Feeds: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/drop-feeds/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/drop-feeds/
- frizlab 5y agoEdge has added in browser support for RSS if I’m not mistaken
- squarefoot 5y agoDropping support for RSS feeds was an ill decision from them; thankfully there are extensions to restore and extend the functionality. https://nodetics.com/feedbro/ https://nodetics.com/feedbro/ https://github.com/nt1m/livemarks/ https://github.com/nt1m/livemarks/
- gchokov 5y agoStill alive and I use it on daily basis...
- lastofthemojito 5y agoI'm still consuming plenty of stuff via RSS using the Mac app Vienna. I honestly don't spend as much time in Vienna as I did in Google Reader back in the day though - primarily because over the years more and more feeds went dead. It seems like different niches treat RSS differently - many of the webcomics I've subscribed to still publish via RSS. Even if the actual comic image isn't included in the RSS, there's at least a feed entry with a link to go to the site to view the comic. But my "Cars" category in Vienna is basically empty - I guess the various automotive blogs and magazines I subscribed to were run by folks who didn't care about RSS as they migrated platforms, etc. Or maybe they actively shut their feeds off to try to drive traffic to their homepages.
- gtsteve 5y agoI still use RSS. I use Feedly to curate various RSS feeds and many website still have them, or at least the tech focussed ones. I used to be subscribed to more but some RSS feeds have such high traffic it's difficult to follow them, such as the BBC news feed. Feedly has a nice new feature [0] that makes an RSS feed out of a standard website, so that might be worth considering if you have some news sources that don't publish a RSS feed. Unfortunately this wouldn't work with anything that requires authentication like private Twitter feeds for example. [0] https://blog.feedly.com/easily-follow-websites-that-dont-have-rss-feeds/ https://blog.feedly.com/easily-follow-websites-that-dont-hav...
- majormajor 5y agoSame here. I still use it. Works fine with me, but then, I'm a bit old fashioned in that twitter/facebook/other social media isn't my news source.
- bisby 5y agoWhen Google reader shut down, I moved to feedly for like a week. Then I started getting anxiety that feedly would shut down too. Because if google could kill off a product i relied on, anyone could. And that got me into self hosting and running my own services. ttrss was basically my first self hosted thing almost a decade ago. It was great. And then it turned out the guy running it was a bit not pleasant, and I didn't want to support that. So I recently migrated to freshRSS. Both work great, are open source and self hostable. And feedly hasn't shut down yet (probably just to spite me). So yeah, tons of options for RSS.
- qw3rty01 5y agoGoogle has shut down a bunch of popular services: https://killedbygoogle.com/ https://killedbygoogle.com/ I wouldn't use them as a standard for keeping services up.
- bisby 5y agoI'm aware. but also, they aren't the only company to shut down services. They do it more often and more flippantly than other companies, but other companies still do it from time to time. My response to the situation was drastic overkill, but now I get to rely on myself and I have a hobby I enjoy, rather than having to worry about what other companies decide to do with my data.
- tacostakohashi 5y agoI started using feedly again this week for monitoring some listservs / mailing list archives, and also some craigslist searches for things I want to buy, all in one place. The sensible websites still offer it, and the ones that don't are a toxic dumpster fire anyway. Yes, I too remember the good old days when you could monitor facebook, twitter, etc all in an RSS reader, and then they stopped their RSS feeds. The thing to realize is that they also stopped being useful, user-oriented sites at the same time.
- Karrot_Kream 5y agoThis topic comes up semi-frequently. I'm personally a fan of RSS but it certainly has issues: (For the purposes of this comment I'm mostly referring to Atom/ 1. RSS is, at the end of the day, a syndication format, _not_ a feedback or posting format. 2. RSS feeds have no real concept of portability between devices or user agents. Kludges like OPML can be used to aggregate feeds for sharing across user agents, but they still don't actually store device-specific metadata that a user would like. 3. If RSS feeds contain both the article and the content, then there's both little incentive for the user to actually visit the site and no analytics for the author to understand which articles are popular. When authors put summaries in their feeds with links to the original article, they degrade the experience for the reader. Services like Wallabag which scrape and store article contents for later viewing seems, IMO, more Lin line with what users want while being fairly seamless for the author. There's also technologies like WebMentions for server owners to comment on other blogs or things like Usenet to freely discuss articles.
- kenniskrag 5y agoTo 3: You can encode html in feeds. You just have to mark them as cdata.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- breischl 5y ago>If RSS feeds contain both the article and the content, then there's both little incentive for the user to actually visit the site and no analytics for the author to understand which articles are popular. When authors put summaries in their feeds with links to the original article, they degrade the experience for the reader. Yeah, this is definitely a problem. FWIW, Ars Technica solved that by giving you full-text fees only if you pay for a subscription, which seems like a nice approach that more places could hypothetically use.
- marcosdumay 5y agoFor #3, you should have the relevant info on server side analytics just like for the web facade. Anyway, the people reading your RSS will load every article. They aren't the ones setting the difference in popularity between the articles.
- mawise 5y agoI've been working on a self-hosted (not federated) model for social media called Haven[1]. RSS (with HTTP basic auth) was the obvious answer for "how do I track all of my friends' different sites?" It has the advantage that building an RSS reader into the system means you can follow other Havens and other websites in one place. [1]: https://havenweb.org/ https://havenweb.org/
- nightpool 5y agoIt's interesting to me that you say "Not federated", because RSS has always seemed to me to be one of the best-adopted federated protocols, after SMTP and HTTP. Indeed, the first generation of federated social media protocols were originally based on souped-up RSS feeds (Atom) with an optional PubSub enhancement (Pubsubhubbub, later renamed to WebSub). So when you say "not federated", what exactly do you mean? If you're publishing to your own site, and other people are reading it on their own compatible sites, isn't that fundamentally a federated model?
- mawise 5y agoI'm trying to distinguish between Haven and Mastodon-type systems. "Federated" to me generally means you have many multi-user servers. With Haven, the server only hosts a single identity--yours, since you're the administrator/operator. I wouldn't describe a Wordpress blog with RSS as federated either.
- nightpool 5y agoMastodon runs just fine in single user mode—in fact, it's was one of our most popular options back in the beginning. I personally don't think of single user and multi-user mode as particularly different, and neither is "core" to the functionality of Mastodon—the core functionality is the ability to interface with other users, whether they're hosted on your server or elsewhere. In that sense, whether a server is single- or multi-user is really isomorphic to the way I think about Mastodon's user experience, most of the time.
- frizlab 5y agoI’ve come to this post from an RSS feed of hacker news
- smm11 5y agoI'll say again, Blogger is all we ever needed.
- mcescalante 5y agoI use RSS daily with Miniflux. Tiny Tiny RSS is another popular self hosted option and there are a number of freemium platforms like Feedly & Inoreader. I prefer to self host primarily for cost/no ads or tracking/private data. It's true that social media platforms don't support it but that's never been my personal use case - every news site or discussion group I like to keep up with has a feed and it's worked great for me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- emptybottle 5y agoBy extension, I miss when protocols were more front and center on the internet. These days most things are abstracted away by a web interface or app hosted in the cloud. Sure this makes a nicer UX, but it has the side-effect of creating walled gardens.
- timw4mail 5y agoI follow Hacker News through RSS, as well as most webcomics that I follow. There is one webcomic I enjoy, but can't get an RSS feed, because it's on a service similar to WebToons.
- alserio 5y agoSome days ago there was a ShowHN (if I'm not misremembering) of a tool to generate RSS for sites that do not support them. I haven't tried it but maybe it can be useful to you Edit: it wasn't a showHN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29772540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29772540
- k1m 5y agoIf you're familiar with CSS selectors, you could try this that I work on to generate a feed from the webcomic site: https://createfeed.fivefilters.org/ https://createfeed.fivefilters.org/
- alcidesfonseca 5y agoI am looking for more webcomics. Any that you'd recommend to others? I mostly follow Dilbert and Questionable Content. I used to follow Wizard of Id and a few more, but they also lost support for RSS.
- kevincox 5y agoWebToons does have feeds, but they only show the first frame. Then you need to wait 10s for their shitty JS to load before it starts to download the comic. I really want to make a scraper that will pull the full comic into the feed but don't want to play the cat-and-mouse game.
- electric_mayhem 5y agoThis turned up in my RSS feed of hacker news. <shrug> Yes, google basically killed RSS through embrace, extend, extinguish. There’s no money in democratizing self-publishing.
- eligg 5y agohow do you have a RSS feed of HN? what links does it include out of the thousands that are posted here daily? also, can I ask you what service are you currently using for you RSS feed? thanks.
- altgans 5y agoI personally use hnrss [1], and usually just display the frontpage [2]. [1]: https://hnrss.github.io/ https://hnrss.github.io/ [2]: https://hnrss.org/frontpage https://hnrss.org/frontpage
- eligg 5y agohttps://hnrss.github.io/ https://hnrss.github.io/ was super useful. thanks a lot. i am now using miniflux which is super clean
- simcop2387 5y agoThere's probably more of them but if you look at the html (browsers used to have an icon for this...) there's a <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="RSS" href="rss"> tag in there on the home page, so https://news.ycombinator.com/rss https://news.ycombinator.com/rss should be the feed
- guessmyname 5y agoHacker News’ RSS feed is here → https://news.ycombinator.com/rss https://news.ycombinator.com/rss Unfortunately, it only includes the title and the submission’s link, no content, which makes it a bit useless if your intension is to read the articles and not just the titles, which you can already do by visiting the home page. Some people have created complementary RSS feeds like this → https://github.com/cixtor/rssfeed#readme https://github.com/cixtor/rssfeed#readme which basically take the submission’s URL, download the web page, and removes the irrelevant HTML tags using Mozilla’s Readability.js library. Although, this project uses a Go (golang) port: https://github.com/go-shiori/go-readability#readme https://github.com/go-shiori/go-readability#readme . It seems to work quite well, with minor bugs here and there due to inconsistencies of modern web development.
- Apreche 5y agoRSS hasn't gone anywhere, you just stopped using it.
- wilcosky 5y agoI never stopped using it. Major websites and browsers did.
- altgans 5y agoHaha, I literally just set up Newsboat[1] and this is my second article I read from the comfort of my terminal :) So far Newsboat is great: Everything configurable with text, fast and effortless. The key-binds took a little bit, but now I can even do stuff with hjkl! I will take the opportunity to ask about two issues I am currently facing. - Is there a feed for Github discussions? - Does anyone have some ideas/sources for bookmark scripts? I found [2], but I am not really sure what it does. [1]:https://newsboat.org/ https://newsboat.org/ [2]:https://github.com/gpakosz/.newsboat/blob/master/bookmark.sh https://github.com/gpakosz/.newsboat/blob/master/bookmark.sh --- E: To add, in my opinion the killer feature of Newsboat is the fact that all links get appended to the article, similar to how I added the two links below my post. In Newsboat I can just press the corresponding number and open the link!
- mananaysiempre 5y agoGitHub has per-repo feeds for commits and a private feed for all your events[1], but not for issues or discussions, apparently[2]. Of course, you can always roll your own using the API, a web server, and a cron job, even if it is a bit inelegant. [1] https://webapps.stackexchange.com/q/20535 https://webapps.stackexchange.com/q/20535 [2] https://github.com/github/feedback/discussions/31 https://github.com/github/feedback/discussions/31
- stillbourne 5y agoI still use it everyday: https://theoldreader.com/ https://theoldreader.com/
- didip 5y agoTo be honest, I don't. Websites like Reddit or Hacker News are better because they provide popularity scores into the links, helping me filtered out junk links.
- gnull 5y agoRSS is like your Facebook feed, not HN or Reddit. It's a different application.
- alserio 5y agoI read HN via an RSS feed over the front page. You can filter out junks just fine.
- dqv 5y agoI thought like this until I started missing posts from blogs I liked. I remembered why RSS feeds are useful and got back into it after a friend recommended a reader he uses. I also picked up a good habit from him: subscribing to releases/commits of projects I want to stay up-to-date with.
- latexr 5y ago> because they provide popularity scores into the links, helping me filtered out junk links. Which you can also do—and better—with RSS. hnrss.org allows you to get a feed with posts over N points. Example: https://hnrss.org/newest?points=300 https://hnrss.org/newest?points=300 Adding `top.rss` to a subreddit’s URL gives you a feed you can further manipulate with `t` and `limit`. Example: https://www.reddit.com/r/wallpapers/top.rss?t=month&limit=20 https://www.reddit.com/r/wallpapers/top.rss?t=month&limit=20 lists the top 20 posts from the past month in `r/wallpapers`.
- sam_lowry_ 5y agoI used RSS to read Hacker News since its beginning or at least very close to its beginning.
- beambot 5y agoStill a core staple of my consumption (e.g. Newsblur), but it really does feel like Google Reader's sunsetting inadvertently killed RSS feeds.
- beermonster 5y agoI continue to still use RSS daily. Feedly and Innoreader are both good and use various apps and or extensions that hook into those two. It’s one of the best ways to quickly scan content from multiple upsteam sources and a decent reader makes for a pleasant reading experience too.
- mcluck 5y agoI have a private Discord server that acts as an RSS reader via MonitoRSS[1]. It works great because Discord has really good notification configuration. Some feeds I want to know about immediately, others I only want to see when I check the news, and because I can mute channels I can let my friends use it as well. They set up their own feeds and I don't have to be alerted to it but I can go look if I'm interested in what they're reading lately. All that is to say that RSS still works. What's missing is the original content creators of the early RSS world. Nowadays, most people create small, easy-to-write, easy-to-consume content in one of the walled gardens since the notifications, interactions, and network are all included for them. [1]: https://monitorss.xyz/ https://monitorss.xyz/
- FiddlerClamp 5y agoBlogtrottr (https://blogtrottr.com/ https://blogtrottr.com/) still works for receiving emails when RSS feeds are updated, and many sites surprisingly still have them.
- paxys 5y agoThe author paints it as some kind of conspiracy, but the simple truth is that RSS waned in popularity once push notifications became popular and widespread. Every user's RSS reader polling every website for changes every few minutes for all eternity is horribly inefficient and unfeasible to do on most platforms and devices today (especially on mobile). Pub/sub is the clear way forward, but it's just sad that there is no accepted standard for it.
- Nicksil 5y ago>The author paints it as some kind of conspiracy, but the simple truth is that RSS waned in popularity once push notifications became popular and widespread. Every user's RSS reader polling every website for changes every few minutes for all eternity is horribly inefficient and unfeasible to do on most platforms and devices today. Pub/sub is the clear way forward, but it's just sad that there is no accepted standard for it. Polling isn't a requirement. If your reader is polling it's strictly because the author wanted to implement such a feature; that's it. There's also ETag and last-modified which are used when checking and have very little overhead (most especially in the case when the content has not changed).
- wilcosky 5y ago
- breischl 5y ago>Every user's RSS reader polling every website for changes every few minutes for all eternity is horribly inefficient and unfeasible to do on most platforms and devices today. 1) It's not that inefficient, especially if you recalculate your feed only when it changes and use HTTP statuses (particularly 304 Not Modified) correctly. 2) Most people then and now would go through an aggregator. So they'd really be talking to that instead of the source feed. 3) There were push notification standards out well over a decade ago, including RSSCloud and PubSubHubBub.
- marginalia_nu 5y ago
- acdha 5y agoI still use RSS on a daily basis, and it's great. I like Newsblur.com but there are a fair number of options based on your desire to self-host and/or use social features. The primary thing I wish was better is a way to handle social commentary. Unfortunately this is an extremely hard problem to solve without allowing spamming and brigading.
- pwenzel 5y agoI bought ReadKit for Mac a few years ago and still use it today. I still like having a nice standalone news reader. It even ties into my Instapaper account.
- julienpalard 5y agoI'm still using r2e (rss2email), that's all I need.
- fsckboy 5y agoit's embarrassing to admit (i mean, I have a CS degree from a Famous School(TM) and I'm an old school unix and C programmer), and it's been a long time since I've tried, but I could never figure out how to get RSS working. the instructions always had terms-of-art without explanation, like syndication or something. Like, I know what syndication is in terms of newspaper publishing, but that doesn't tell me if that's something I want to turn on or not. Like I said, it's been a long time so maybe that wasn't one of the words, but it just seemed like an insular world that I wasn't a part of.
- ghostpepper 5y agoFWIW I use News Explorer for iOS/Mac (the syncing is great btw) and newsboat for Linux, and I've never been asked if I want to turn on syndication. I just add feeds and then articles from those feeds show up, and I read them. Unless you mean how to enable publishing an RSS feed for your own website? In that case I have no idea, and I wouldn't expect an old school unix/C person to know how to configure web things (speaking as one as well).
- hintymad 5y agoMy current workaround for not having RSS is to follow twitter accounts and subscribe to email updates. Not ideal, but helps me get by.
- Vosporos 5y agoWell I was consulting my RSS feeds this morning so I guess the feeling isn't shared
- wilcosky 5y agoDepends. If you are technical, RSS is a thing.
- freediver 5y agoVery nice to see the author uses Flarum (https://flarum.org https://flarum.org) an open-source forum software to power his blog. Very innovative use! We also use Flarum to power our user feedback site for Orion browser https://orionfeedback.org https://orionfeedback.org another example of Flarum's ability to adopt to different use cases.
- c80e74f077 5y agoYes, I agree. Flarum is definitely an interesting software.
- axegon_ 5y agoSo do I. There was plenty that needed improving but fundamentally the idea was awesome. What's more is that I miss Google reader like nothing I've ever missed. I've been pitching the idea to rebuild it to multiple people, even started working on it on my own when I got no response but fundamentally it's too much work for a single person... Truly a shame.
- petecooper 5y ago(2021) Sorry for the low effort post, y'all.
- twsted 5y agoI use RSS and I am sad that it is not used universally. I do not miss Google Reader, because I don’t think it was the right choice for a privacy point of view.
- u2077 5y agoWhile this topic is still on the front page, does anyone have some feed recommendations? Some of my favorites are Hackaday, Damn Interesting (including curated links), and hnrss for terms like side project.
- eligg 5y agogwern posted his rss feed which i think it is very interesting. it includes a lot of rss links and they are all divided by category. you can find it at this page https://www.gwern.net/Changelog https://www.gwern.net/Changelog (ctl+f "rss").
- karaterobot 5y agoWhen I see articles like this, my reaction is always: when did RSS go away? I have close to 200 sites in my Feedly list, and I have trouble keeping up with all the articles I get from RSS every day. I think that what the author really means is that he misses RSS feeds from Twitter. I don't use Twitter, so from my perspective, RSS is as present and useful as it was 20 years ago.
- dmje 5y agoYeh, came here to say this. I love RSS, it is such a nice balance of enabling me to keep up with stuff but under my own terms and at my own speed. It feels very much like an alive protocol to me, and more in need than ever before given the insane calls on everyone's attention. And to the guy with "service shutdown fear" - just export your opml and bring it into another service. It's highly portable and imo totally mitigates any risk of getting locked in then locked out.
- anyfactor 5y agoHow did you aggregate so many sources to read articles from? What is your discovery process? Do you have any recommendation where I can read good stuff from?
- gavanm 5y agoNot the OP, but these days I find new things (mostly blogs) through four different mechanisms: 1 - Hacker News - If there's an interesting article linked, then I'll consider adding the site to my feed (using feedbin since the great Google Reader apocalypse). 2 - Blog referrals - Sometimes existing feed items will link to other articles sites (sourced from, similar problem, etc) and I'll sometimes add those sites. 3 - Search Results / Organic - If I'm investigating a particular problem/issue/topic and find a good blog, then I'll add it to my feed. 4 - Topic Specific Aggregators - in some cases there are people that produce topic specific post summaries (such as the .Net Morning Brew https://blog.cwa.me.uk/ https://blog.cwa.me.uk/ or Michael Tsai https://mjtsai.com/blog/ https://mjtsai.com/blog/ ) that link articles - again, if the articles are good, or I notice I've visited the site before, I'll sometimes add it to my feed list. Just checking my OPML, I have around 600 sites (more than a few are likely no longer posting) in my current reader - accumulated over the last 20 years or so - that I've found specifically interesting (mostly professionally, and a few hobby based ones as well). I still get around 60 or so new items per day, and probably skim 20, read 10 in detail, and mark the rest as read. Like the linked article discusses here, it's no longer possible to easily get a feed from major social media sources - which limits the usefulness of RSS from a purely social perspective (but I've never tried to use it that way) - but if you treat it as a personally curated source of sporadic content, then it's great. In many respects Moderate post volume (quality over quantity) is something I find more useful in what I choose. On the aggregator front, I try to avoid anything that's too noisy (low signal to noise) - and I definitely minimise subscribing to news sites as the volume is just too high (I tried rss subscribing to The Verge when it was new, but there were too many articles I don't read). For example, i wouldn't use a RSS feed of Hacker News because I probably only look at 1 in 10 articles on it. RSS is still heavily used for information I find really professionally useful (IT) - but I don't know about other industries. Possibly the only bugbear I have around the RSS ecosystem these days is that some authors don't include the full content in the RSS feed - which makes offline and mobile consumption more difficult / annoying - I suspect that in some cases it's a result of default choices - and in others it's a deliberate decision as a trade off against improved analysis a site gets from a browser hit.
- Fnoord 5y agoI use FreshRSS (because it works in the macOS and Android RSS readers I use) behind a Wireguard VPN. So, nobody can access it, except myself.
- sporkland 5y agoI don't miss RSS. I still get plenty of content via RSS in theoldreader. I even get HN > 100pts feed via RSS via Twitter.
- _2d30 5y agoEvery few weeks there's a post lamenting the death of RSS and here I am still using RSS every day.
- wtf77 5y agoFreshRSS + NetNewsWire. I'm an old school guy and love my curated list of feeds.
- desireco42 5y agoClearly based on the comments, that tech isn't a problem here, but economics. I don't think we should return RSS as it was pretty bad format, but something that would serve like that and have some more wider adoption or approval would be fantastic.
- afrcnc 5y agoRSS is still there, it's just that sites don't enable it anymore. Have loads of sites that don't do it that I have to follow manually through crawlers.
- runjake 5y agoRSS is alive and well. I use it daily and I can't even keep up with the feeds I subscribe to (hundreds). In recent years, it has mostly replaced Twitter for me. I think what the author really means is "I wish I could read tweets as RSS." And the answer to that is that there are several different third party ways of doing so, if you wish.
- m4xm4n 5y agoas other's pointed out, RSS is still here if you want to use it. It's just not ubiquitous as it once was. IMO the big thing that killed RSS ubiquity was Google Chrome not having support for it natively. Before that, Firefox, Opera, Safari all had RSS as well-supported, central thing and I remember finding it super annoying that Chrome didn't have it when it launched. But I kept using Chrome for the same reasons everyone else started switching to Chrome. And the RSS extensions all sucked. And eventually I stopped using them. And here I am, no longer reading RSS. But as Chrome ate up browser share, I'm sure fewer people went to RSS because it wasn't natively there and so the incentives to implement RSS decreased as fewer people expected it to be there, especially as many more people were coming online only having used Chrome. Oddly enough, I switched back to Firefox years ago and _could_ get back into RSS at any point (or with any number of RSS reader apps, etc.), but the habit has stuck, and I now stay up-to-date on everything via email newsletters, Twitter and this orange website instead. it's worse and I hate it, but oh well
- packetlost 5y agoMy solution to this was getting a miniflux.app subscription and pinning the tab/setting it as my home page. I got directly to this page via an RSS feed.
- nikitaga 5y agoIMO, RSS as a browser feature was dead pretty much as soon as smartphones happened (and desktop<>mobile RSS sync didn't).
- erikrothoff 5y agoThis is _exactly_ why I created Feeder, an RSS extension for Chrome. In 2010 I wanted to switch from Firefox but was hooked on live bookmarks. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/rss-feed-reader/pnjaodmkngahhkoihejjehlcdlnohgmp?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/rss-feed-reader/pn...
- m4xm4n 5y agoI remember using this! I liked it and used it for a while! But not having it in the bookmarks bar, I kept forgetting about my feeds :/ and then I stopped installing it. I'm sorry :( Glad to hear it's still going strong though. Maybe I'll give it another shot!
- jrue 5y agoDouglas Adams, [how to learn to love the internet]: 1. everything that’s already in the world when you’re born is just normal; 2. anything that gets invented between then and before you turn 30 is incredibly exciting and creative and with any luck you can make a career out of it; 3. anything that gets invented after you’re 30 is against the natural order of things and the beginning of the end of civilisation as we know it until it’s been around for about ten years when it gradually turns out to be alright really. (I too miss RSS) [1] https://internet.psych.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/532-Master/532-UnitPages/Unit-14/DouglasAdams_1999_Edited.pdf https://internet.psych.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/532-Maste...
- agumonkey 5y agoDoes he talks about the fact that vintage stuff that was before my birth are also better ? and how antique people were better ? These feelings are regularly in my head. Mostly because I feel so much waste from all the new things.. I'm not sure if it's a special attribute of the last decades (smartphones etc) or not.
- kgran 5y ago>3. anything that gets invented after you’re 30 is against the natural order of things and the beginning of the end of civilisation as we know it until it’s been around for about ten years when it gradually turns out to be alright really. This started happening when I was 14 (~2007) and really started to accelerate after I was 20 (~2013). I don't correlate this with me getting old but more like getting more and more aware of the profiteering, surveillance and bullshit everywhere.
- vanderZwan 5y agoAnd from the other side of the coin: I'm in my late thirties now and there also has been plenty of new tech (or improvements on existing tech) from the last decade that has me really excited. Unsurprisingly, almost all of it can be used outside of the aforementioned bubble of "profiteering, surveillance and bullshit".
- themadturk 5y ago
- indymike 5y agoI rediscovered RSS about six months ago when I switched back to Linux from MacOS and realized Akregator was still part of KDE. Most actual long form content - blogs, news, company websites, podcasts all still have RSS feeds, and once you have 10-20 good ones loaded into Akregator, it's actually a pretty good experience. Most of the big socials dropped RSS feeds a while back for the same reason their APIs became less useful: they monetized with ads being mixed in with content. Allowing users to view their stream outside the UI literally cuts into the ad revenue.
- diordiderot 5y agoHow do you set up an RSS feed?
- riidom 5y agoDepends on what your website is built on. But in any case, you can write a feed.xml yourself and update it manually on each new blogpost.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoHm. I have so many rss feeds subscribed that I can't even read them all. What exactly does this guy miss?!
- cblconfederate 5y agoThank you Matt for keeping RSS alive. It's incredible that every wordpress site has it effortlessly.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoThere were many rss to kindle services back then, that I really miss.. The only bad thing about RSS I could find was following the news sites, where every news was equal, so "cat lost" and "massive bomb killed everyone in a city next to you" are treated equally.
- cheschire 5y agoHave you met the people in the city next to me? Honestly I probably care more about a lost cat. /s
- rambambram 5y agoOP, where's your feed then? I would like to subscribe to it.
- riidom 5y agoYep came here to mention that too. You find it under '/rss', but website owner should really put auto-detect in their header and add a link for it.
- wilcosky 5y agoThis wouldn’t be necessary if all browsers automatically auto detected RSS feeds still. But, good point. I will add a link to my feed on the main page. I haven’t because of the fact that society killed RSS. But, you all are disagreeing so I’ll add a link.
- tibbydudeza 5y agoThe obligatory annual lament of google killing off "Reader" ???. I still use RSS via Feedly (paid for the one time lifetime subscription) - start it up first thing in the morning but sadly noticed some interesting stuff posted on twitter but it is like finding a gemstone in a fetid swamp.
- zygy 5y agoSeems like a good place to plug Fraidycat (not my project) https://fraidyc.at/ https://fraidyc.at/
- foresto 5y agoSince my browser removed the two-click feature for sending a site's feed URL to my RSS reader, I now do a bit more manual work to find RSS URLs myself. Twitter lost its native RSS support, but Nitter provides RSS links. Example: https://nitter.net/eff/rss https://nitter.net/eff/rss Reddit provides RSS for most listings, including search results. All you have to do is append .rss to the path part of the URL. Example: https://old.reddit.com/r/hackernews/search.rss?q=web&restrict_sr=on https://old.reddit.com/r/hackernews/search.rss?q=web&restric... GitHub provides Atom feeds in various places. Example: https://github.com/drwetter/testssl.sh/releases.atom https://github.com/drwetter/testssl.sh/releases.atom When I don't know if a site offers a syndication URL, I fall back to viewing the page source, and searching for these telltale strings: <link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml"
- mocheeze 5y agoI use a reader that automatically pulls feeds from Twitter and other social media like Reddit. Just need to plop the URL into the feed field and they figure it out. I pay for it, but it's pretty nice for getting back to the old Google Reader feel. (https://bazcux.com https://bazcux.com)
- kevincox 5y agoThere are extensions that will give you the two-click experience back. For example I use https://addons.mozilla.org/en-CA/firefox/addon/want-my-rss/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-CA/firefox/addon/want-my-rss/
- samatman 5y agoI went to add an RSS button to Safari from the Mac App Store, and the only option is two bucks. I pay for software all the time but this offended my sensibilities. Not the paying for it, although I admittedly didn't, but that RSS has fallen so far that there's no free extension. Desktop Safari is a minor browser, but not so tiny that this should matter. Substack supports RSS, so I'm cautiously optimistic about a revival. But that was a sobering reminder of its moribund state.
- ubermonkey 5y agoI still read some high-volume Twitter accounts via my RSS reader, but I guess my aggregator (Feedbin) is doing something fancy to allow that if Twitter has turned it off on their side.
- account-5 5y agoI'm still using RSS everyday, whether its actual feeds or podcasts. Generally I don't visit sites that don't have it.
- pronik 5y agoI'm with Inoreader and have never been happier. They integrate what they can, which means public Twitter and Facebook feeds, Telegram channels and also plain web pages with either text or image-based tracking in addition to all the "normal" RSS goodies. RSS never died, but a lot of people gave up on "their" web which has been both premature and unnecessary.
- Semiapies 5y agoI'm starting to get as tired of "I miss RSS" blog posts as I used to be of those ever-so-authentic-and-grassroots "RSS is dying!" blog posts years and years ago. I don't miss RSS, I use it all the damn time.
- Vrondi 5y agoSomeone tell this poor author about FreshRSS!
- wilcosky 5y agoSomeone tell this poor commentator to read the author’s post. :)
- mro_name 5y agoatom, actually.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoMy search engine has found RSS feeds on about 70% of the domains it's indexed. It may be dead for the big sites, but I do think RSS is alive and well in the personal website category. (I gathered them because I had this idea of maybe polling RSS feeds of high ranked domains to check for changes without having to do a full re-crawl. It's not something I do, it's more of an experiment at this point)
- soheilpro 5y agoThe sad truth is, nobody bothers to add support for RSS if they write a new custom blog engine. I've started to keep a list of all the websites that I've tried to subscribe but didn't support RSS: https://angel.co/blog https://blog.close.com https://blog.messagebird.com https://blog.twitter.com/developer/en_us.html https://blog.twitter.com/engineering/en_us.html https://bloggingfordevs.com/blog https://business.instagram.com/blog https://developer.spotify.com/community/news/announcements https://discord.com/blog https://frontapp.com/blog https://indiehackers.com https://joelcalifa.com/blog https://linktr.ee/blog https://mixpanel.com/blog https://openai.com/blog/openai-api https://paystack.com/blog https://segment.com/blog https://telegram.org/blog https://transferwise.com/gb/blog https://web.dev/blog https://www.anyscale.com/blog https://www.binance.com/en/blog https://www.bugsnag.com/blog https://www.changeinvest.com/blog https://www.hackthebox.com/blog https://www.integromat.com/en/blog https://www.linode.com/blog https://www.loom.com/blog https://www.makerpad.co/blog https://www.tradingview.com/blog/en https://zapier.com/engineering
- waterhouse 5y agoHmm, I grabbed one of the links, hit "view source", searched for "atom" and "rss", and found: https://openai.com/blog/rss/ https://openai.com/blog/rss/ I haven't fed it into my RSS reader, which is on another machine, but, inspecting it with curl, it looks like RSS XML... does it not work for you? It is a problem that the webpage doesn't give any visible sign that it supports RSS. That is unfortunately common; I don't know why they do that. Anyway, for what it's worth: # fish shell here, with an alias ~> for x in (P | tr -d ' '); echo $x (curl -sL $x | egrep -c -i 'rss|atom'); end ... omitting the non-matches ... https://blog.close.com 1 https://bloggingfordevs.com/blog 1 https://discord.com/blog 1 https://linktr.ee/blog 2 https://openai.com/blog/openai-api 1 https://segment.com/blog 2 https://web.dev/blog 1 https://www.linode.com/blog 4 https://www.tradingview.com/blog/en 1
- soheilpro 5y agoI always check the source code as well to find the RSS/Atom link but looks like I've missed a few of them. However, some of them like (tradingview.com/blog/en) mention words RSS/Atom but they don't have a feed and for some of them (like blog.close.com) it's broken.
- blacklight 5y agoRSS never went away for me. My NextCloud News app hosts ~100 feeds, RSS feeds power my news dashboards at home, as well as my newsletters (who ever needs to subscribe to spammy newsletters when you can easily configure your own based on the feeds you follow, with the frequency you want, with the level of aggregation that you want?), as well as the daily/weekly digests automatically sent to my e-readers. Curate your feeds list well, and you won't need another timeline.
- mgarfias 5y ago100%
- ldd 5y agoBe the change to want to see in the world! My indie game has a RSS feed for the monthly updates: https://www.necromancers-gift.com/feed.xml https://www.necromancers-gift.com/feed.xml
- fajarsiddiq 5y agomost podcast now requires rss, thanks for sharing this post
- TheRealNGenius 5y agoThat's most certainly your problem
- TedShiller 5y agoWe all do. But advertisers don’t. You can’t spam RSS with ads.
- moggers 5y agoThe one time I wanted to use an RSS feed I found I had no (acceptable) way to ensure I didn't miss data. New items could be truncated off the feed after anywhere between 10 minutes and two hours, and the solution to this was supposedly to use a third party service to sit in the middle and act as a buffer. There was no way to provide a timestamp or anything like that and I presume the reason is its meant to be generate 1 & serve M. I'm sure the driving factor to RSS losing popularity is it just doesn't fit into the modern model of making fat stacks of cash off of content that other people create which you control the publishing of. But it certainly doesn't help that it seems very limited as far as a protocol for retrieving a portable log of activity.
- kevincox 5y agoRSS feeds do support push notifications (WebSub) and pagination, both of which allow reliably getting all items. However WebSub requires that you have an "always online" device to receive the notification and very few feeds and readers support pagnation.
- moggers 5y agoYes, unfortunately I was in that case where pagination simply wasn't provided by the feed. Push notifications of course wouldn't have worked (if they were even supported, and I don't believe they were), since otherwise I would have just sat there polling the feed itself every 20 minutes like a maniac. It seems like this widespread limitation leads to the reliance on aggregators, and second-hand it seems google playing the disappearing act with their aggregation service was one of contributing factors to (or a symptom of?) the decline of RSS. Certainly I would have been willing to just shrug my shoulders and use it if it was still operating when I ran into my one and only case of wanting to use an RSS feed.
- ianberdin 5y agoThat's why my friend built https://RSS.app https://RSS.app - make feed from any website. I told him, no one will use it, but... Many and many thousands ones.
- nickm12 5y agoI certainly understand why various sites, including mainstream and social media sites, dropped their RSS feeds, but it's never made sense to me why browsers did (especially when browsers have so many features). It seems to me RSS is good for the web and therefore good for browsers. That said, the UX of RSS was pretty terrible compared to social media. I think it could have been different—podcasts managed to make RSS mainstream and with a bit more tuning and standardization it probably could have worked. I really think the issue was that in the 2009-2015 period huge amounts of industry mindshare went into mobile apps and social media and RSS (or its eventual successor) were left half-baked.
- psanan 5y agoThat also seems strange to me. For a majority of current browsers, based on Chromium, one can argue that Google has little interest in supporting RSS. But that doesn't apply to Firefox, for example. What's the explanation?
- lobocinza 5y agoI got here via RSS.
- mfru 5y agoApparently there are people keeping a clone of Google Reader alive: https://theoldreader.com/ https://theoldreader.com/ (Not affiliated in any form and not a user of the service, just a random internet find)
- marban 5y agoNews aggregators are my main business since 2001 and all I can say is that reports of the death of RSS have been greatly exaggerated. Recently launched https://biztoc.com https://biztoc.com where 75% is still RSS, the rest being APIs and custom scraping. Yes, support is not increasing but drops among established sites are very rare — Even all major crypto news sites sport a feed.
- pinkano 5y agoAndroid and Microsoft are reviving RSS slowly. There'll be a big RSS renaissance coming in the next few years.
- kevincox 5y agoDo you have any info about what Android and Microsoft are doing here? I would be interested in seeing what they are working on.
- mattowen_uk 5y agoThe main problem is that a lot of sites no longer show a link to their RSS feeds, or include a meta tag for it. So I've resorted to trying the following until the RSS reed comes up: example.com/feed example.com/feed.xml example.com/rss example.com/rss.xml example.com/xml ...etc In most cases the feed WILL be there somewhere as the feature is still in the web framework that's being used.
- apricot13 5y agothis feels like something that could be a handy little plugin or bookmarklet!
- minroot 5y agoRSS and others are good, but many popular readers, like Feedly, sucks. Currently using InoReader, I reported one issue, not once but 3 times, still no light on it.
- PaulKeeble 5y agoRSS-Proxy can watch sites without RSS and inform on changes. Well worth self hosting it alongside FreshRSS. There are also solutions for watching Twitter, Facebook et el too. In todays technology there is no reason to just visit a website to check for updates and I find most sites I use do have RSS anyway.
- c80e74f077 5y agoRSS feeds have become my one and only way to consume the web and subscribe to people, websites and various things on the web. Tiny Tiny RSS[0] is an addictive RSS reader with tons of options to sort, manipulate, filter in/out, etc. RSS entries. Feed Preview[1] is a must-have Firefox add-on for finding available feeds on websites (and previewing them). All alternative front-ends to YouTube, Twitter, Instagram, etc. provide feeds to subscribe to people like Invidious[2], nitter[3], Bibliogram[4], etc. (large list of alternative front-ends here [5]). Fortunately, Github and Reddit, still natively support RSS feeds. As others have mentioned, WordPress-based websites natively include RSS feeds for the whole website, by category, for comments of a particular post, etc. This is much better than crappy newsletters. Regarding newsletters, when it's the only option, I use Mailnesia[6] to turn an inbox into an RSS feed. Speaking of bridges, RSS-Bridge[7] makes feeds available to hundreds of websites through community plugins. Feed43 [8] is also a great tool to force an ordinary page to be available as an RSS feed. SearX [9], a metasearch engine, turns into a very powerful tool to watch for something on the whole web with advanced search functions and results available as RSS feeds. This is better than many dedicated tools, imo. Anyway, I don't think RSS feeds are missing or even dying. But they are definitely a relic of the good old days, when Aaron Swartz was around, and unfortunately reserved for people who are looking for them or are curious enough to dive into that world. One thing is for sure though: if they disappear, I'm out. [0] https://tt-rss.org https://tt-rss.org [1] https://code.guido-berhoerster.org/addons/firefox-addons/feed-preview/ https://code.guido-berhoerster.org/addons/firefox-addons/fee... [2] https://invidious.io https://invidious.io [3] https://github.com/zedeus/nitter https://github.com/zedeus/nitter [4] https://sr.ht/~cadence/bibliogram/ https://sr.ht/~cadence/bibliogram/ [5] https://github.com/mendel5/alternative-front-ends https://github.com/mendel5/alternative-front-ends [6] https://mailnesia.com https://mailnesia.com [7] https://github.com/RSS-Bridge/rss-bridge https://github.com/RSS-Bridge/rss-bridge [8] https://feed43.com https://feed43.com [9] https://searx.space https://searx.space
- mehdix 5y agoEverytime I see RSS on HN I'd like to recommend Aldo Gunsing's[0] work on creating a solution for managing Feeds, Calendars and Addresses. It takes some learning but it works fine. Couple it with Syncthing and you have them synced on all your personal computers. He maintains also forks of some popular readers[1]. [0]: https://github.com/39aldo39 https://github.com/39aldo39 [1]: https://github.com/39aldo39/spaRSS-DecSync https://github.com/39aldo39/spaRSS-DecSync Edit: formatting
- b1nj0y 5y agoShare an extension I created for reading RSS feeds in the new tab in your browsers: https://tabhub.io https://tabhub.io
- the_other 5y agoCan anyone recommend a nice RSS client for Apple systems that uses iCloud to sync the list of feeds across devices? I've tried Reeder and NetNewsWire and they both miss the mark of "ideal".
- trizuz 5y ago
- SamWhited 5y ago> I have a feed for this blog although I don’t think anyone would be interested in subscribing. OP has at least two subscribers on the Innoreader RSS reader according to their little subscriber widget thing (but I'm not signing up for an account to post a comment just to tell them that, so hopefully they read these comments and get a smile today :) )
- kevincox 5y agoI don't think Google Reader killed RSS. Sure, it was nice to have a common place to discover feeds but I don't think that was enough to make or break RSS. I think the failing of RSS is that no major browsers have RSS indicators anymore. Defaults are king and if users need to install an extension, view source and search for feeds, paste the URL into a reader and hope that there is a feed or click an RSS link and wonder what this XML is then >90% of users won't use it. If browsers add a "subscribe to this site" button that opens your reader or redirects to your "app store" to get one then there is a decent chance of non-trivial user adoption.
- pers0n 5y agoRun FreshRSS on your own server, its good. Not perfect but very good.
- diminutivesloop 5y agoI use RSS pretty heavily via Feedbin and Unread on iOS but I do sometimes wish I could view my feeds in a curated format akin to a magazine or newspaper rather than a flat undifferentiated list. There probably isn't a big enough market for it but I would love to see more experimentation in feed reader design instead of just cloning the UI of email clients.
- onli 5y agoI remember a feedreaders for this. It might have been https://feedafever.com/ https://feedafever.com/ - but indeed that is dead. According to https://www.reddit.com/r/rss/comments/j7pcv0/any_modern_feed_readers_like_fever/ https://www.reddit.com/r/rss/comments/j7pcv0/any_modern_feed... fiery feeds took some of the concepts. The android client Palabre has a magazine layout, Inoreader as well (no idea how sorted it is).
- derekzhouzhen 5y agoRSS is not suited for large news networks or social medias; had they use RSS my reader would be jammed anyway. On the other hand, RSS is the best tool for blogging so as long as there are bloggers around there will be RSS. The problem is not that RSS is declining, it is people don't write as much as before.
- ymolodtsov 5y agoI've noticed that most major websites covering crypto (supposedly one of the most decentralized industries) don't have RSS at all or it just doesn't work. Looking at you, CoinDesk and The Block.