30 ms·
Please don't use Discord for FOSS projects
- xena 5y agoThen make something better than Discord. It's that simple. People choose Discord because it's genuinely better for their needs.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 5y agoI remember a while ago I was very much in the "I guess it's ok to use Discord, even if I don't like it". A number of tech/programming communities are there, and so I participated despite having a bad feeling about it. Now more recently I started receiving my first "hey we believe there is something wrong with your account, attach a (first time, new) phone number to it to join this server". That is most likely a lie of course, Discord just wants to blackmail me into giving them my phone number. Also apparently there is an option to make an attached phone number mandatory in order to join a server, which quite a number communities activate for some reason. So it turns out the bad feeling was correct.
- redwolf22 5y agoIts more likely that they just want the number for Multi-factor authentication. Not that I like, that every site now asks for a phone number. But it is more of a security reason. Otherwise there must be real people involved in oder to restore your account. It also insures that most of the user accounts are no sock puppets. Not every user has access to vast ammounts of mobile phone numbers. Another great thread, describing this dilemma is "Don't build your castle in other people's kingdoms" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29108662 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29108662 In discords defense: It was never made for open source projects in mind, but gamers and small private communities. Having a free service provided might come with traps and pitfalls, but I would prefer that over having only paid online services. Choose your poison. I don't think discord is the right choice for FOSS communities.
- jrootabega 5y agoIt's to prevent people from creating unlimited "anonymous" accounts. Phone numbers cost money and are, in many cases, something that can identify you if needed.
- redwolf22 5y agoAh sorry. I did not see your comment while editing mine to include this argument as well.
- heavyset_go 5y agoIt's also a good way to signal to investors and advertising partners about how many real humans actively use their services versus how many bots are using them.
- Sebb767 5y ago> Its more likely that they just want the number for Multi-factor authentication. You can do that with an app or an U2F key. You don't need a phone number for that and, in fact, SMS-based 2FA is mostly discouraged by now due to sim swapping attacks. So it boils down to avoiding sock puppets (most likely IMO) and to collect your data (which is something nice to get on top).
- indrora 5y agoThe reason for having SMS-based 2FA as a default is that it's At least something. Adding a U2F token and having SMS as a backup means that you don't have people locked out because their yubikey failed -- which happens. Discord is trying to solve some of the bootstrapping problems that arise from "oh fuck my computer and phone were both stolen" -- which, again, happens.
- minimaul 5y agoWhile it's annoying, the reason communities activate this is to reduce spam/bot accounts. It's a big problem on Discord and requiring a phone number linked to the account helps quite a bit :(
- OtomotO 5y agoSame goes for twitch. Found this cozy stream and followed. Was called out, wished a merry christmas. Wanted to say thanks, but couldn't, because apparently "verified accounts only chat" is a thing. Well, not gonna share my phone number with the world. My phone number is kinda holy to me.
- unixhero 5y agoUhm that thing about the phone number is a totally losing battle. You should adapt by getting a burner phone with a separate number.
- OtomotO 5y agoOr I just don't use such services. I know it's not en vogue, but abstinence is one possible solution. I don't feel like having to pay 10€/year for a burner phone (so the SIM isn't deactivated) It's fine, I can live without most of these services just fine. And if I can't any longer, I will walk that bridge then.
- unixhero 5y agoHow do you achieve multi factor auth at all then, if you regard tour phone number to be a secret.
- say_it_as_it_is 5y agoI get robo-called and scam-called every day, several times a day. Do you? I am interested to know whether your cautious behavior involving sharing phone numbers helps you to avoid this sort of attention.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 5y agoI haven't even thought about it that way yet. I just generally want to avoid sharing things with companies unless really necessary. But no, I rarely if ever receive calls of that kind.
- busymom0 5y agoI get spam calls every day and they leave voicemails. Until a few months ago, I had disabled incoming calls on my phone because of this but recently had to activate it for a specific reason. Often, the spam calls spoof the number to be either my OWN number or my area code too.
- slashink 5y agoPhone number verification is purely one of many ways for Discord to drive down the amount of spam. Not used for any other purposes. We’re ofc working hard on enabling alternative solutions. Source: I lead the anti-abuse team at Discord
- bruce343434 5y ago> Not used for any other purposes ...for now. I'll never give out my phone number to discord. The messages aren't even E2E encrypted.
- slashink 5y agoI understand the concern, trust me. We’re working on alternative methods.
- greyface- 5y agoProvide a specific commitment. What methods, and when will they become available? "We're working on it" is worthless and when I'm told this I assume I am being blown off.
- pndy 5y agoSo let's say that in the future you got this alternative method deployed but then, what happens with already acquired phone numbers? Will you remove it once this method will be running nicely? Or you'll keep phone numbers giving a promise you won't use it to anything naughty and users will have choice to either keep it for "security purposes", or they will have ability to remove it by themselves directly from the client or by going the longer way, asking support to remove it from account data? Can you tell which solutions were considered so far? Also, not sure if you're aware there but in some countries it's no longer possible to use SIM card without registering it first under name and last name and that means, the state has a possibility to track your online presence.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 5y agoIf you give me the option to verify my account for 1$ or something like that instead, I'd much prefer and just use that and accept it as an alternative. If phone number is enforced as the only option, I find it hard to believe that spam is the only reason you want it and that the phone number won't be used for other things (in the future). As has been said, there is sadly little reason to trust a company in that regard. Usages of user data are always expanded upon, official (or unofficial) promises from companys aren't worth anything, and leaks also happen all the time.
- alexiaya 5y agoDiscord already has a huge problem with spam as-is. Yes, it may suck to be randomly locked out of your account when you haven't done anything wrong, but if they removed the requirement altogether it would just open the floodgates even more. Even if you don't trust them fully, they're not some random shady website that's likely to leak your number or use it for advertising. I've been regularly providing my phone number to big services like Discord for years and have never once received spam calls or texts for them. In the incredibly rare case that I do get spam it's always some Hungarian number rather than a foreign one, and they probably just got my number from some public database. It's much more common to get spam via email instead. Either way, it's pretty easy to get a burner SIM or use Google Voice (if you're in the US), or services like getsmscode.com which provide disposable phone numbers that work with hundreds of major services for 10 cents per SMS, and you can even pay with crypto.
- heavyset_go 5y agoIt feels like more than a coincidence that the flavor of "security" that comes out of these companies hinges on infringements of ever increasing amounts of their users' privacy. > Even if you don't trust them fully, they're not some random shady website that's likely to leak your number or use it for advertising. The last few years of leaks and hacks say that trust should never be implicit. Every company has the incentive to use your data for profit.
- wott 5y ago> It feels like more than a coincidence that the flavor of "security" that comes out of these companies hinges on infringements of ever increasing amounts of their users' privacy. It is the same as in politics: saying 'because security', is a very convenient and easy way to get about anything accepted, little by little.
- caaqil 5y ago> By choosing Discord, you also lock out users with accessibility needs, for whom the proprietary Discord client is often a nightmare to use. The author takes it for granted that accessibility issues are more prevalent in proprietary software like Discord (vs FOSS alternatives), is there any evidence to back this up? I ask because it seems counter-intuitive. Since most proprietary software in this space tend to have more users than their FOSS counterparts, it seems pretty straightforward to think that accessibility will be less of an issue in the former category (i.e., more users = taking into account and addressing more accessibility needs vs when you only have a few thousand users). Maybe the logic is being open source encourages volunteers to address accessibility issues and submit patches? Although even that's debatable; unless the project is quite popular, there will always be shortage of volunteers.
- detaro 5y agoOne very simple point is: Forbidding third-party clients puts you at the mercy of the main developers caring about accessibility, a small-but-caring group of outsiders can't fix it. Whereas if you have an ecosystem of clients in an open system, a) users have a choice of options and can pick the one that suits their workflows best and b) don't have to rely on the main devs to care to be able to tweak one for their needs. EDIT: this also supports the "bridge everything to IRC/Matrix/..." approach, since it lets people use whatever setup they already have working for their specific needs. And if Discord kills our bridge one day because "evil bot", well, rest of the group still works. And if something new and shiny comes up, sure, bridge it.
- zimpenfish 5y agoI mean, Discord have only recently committed to making it easier for blind people to use[1]. Their forums seem to have a lot of people complaining about accessibility issues too. [1] https://www.lflegal.com/2021/10/discord-press/ https://www.lflegal.com/2021/10/discord-press/
- techdragon 5y agoAccessibility issues, user to user security and privacy issues, API design issues, developer relations issues... Discord gets a lot of complaints but they seem focused on chasing their success metrics to the absolute exclusion of everything else. Those complaints don't register in their chosen and still upward trending metrics, therefore they don't matter. It doesn't matter that a significant part of Discord's growth is backed by users benefiting from bots which will be broken by the upcoming API changes, it doesn't matter that their developer relations are so bad that major developers are abandoning their projects instead of updating to the new API, all of this doesn't matter as it isn't being measured by their success metrics.
- mnd999 5y agoWish the Scala community had read this. They literally just switched to discord and it’s just another facepalm in a long line of daft moves.
- esarbe 5y agoYes. And the frustrating thing is that they are moving away from an FOSS solution. > But in the end, Discord’s feature set and its sheer popularity decided the matter. Sad. [0] https://www.scala-lang.org/blog/2021/12/21/discord.html https://www.scala-lang.org/blog/2021/12/21/discord.html
- fghgg 5y agoAt least they bridge to Matrix
- tpxl 5y agoNit > the right to set up useful bots Discord allows bots. They probably can't do _everything_, but there are useful bots and even bridges for IRC (and probably others).
- Starlevel001 5y agoDiscord hates bots. They've been trying to restrict their power for the last three years.
- mst 5y agoOnce I logged in once manually from a browser running on the VPS the bitlbee plugin for discord has worked fine for me since. I am, however, very much aware that it may stop working at any given moment and have made sure I have 'plan B' ways to keep in touch with anybody/anything on discord that I actually care about.
- thinkingemote 5y agoHow does Slack compare? The only couple of FOSS projects I know using either app, are only using slack. They are both American and open source rather than European libre projects if that is a characteristic? For me, the lack of history and good search in Slack unless you have a paid account is hostile.
- beermonster 5y agoOpening sentence of article begins : “Six years ago, I wrote a post speaking out against the use of Slack for the instant messaging needs of FOSS projects”
- phoe-krk 5y agoNitpick: > Discord appears to inflate its participation numbers compared to other services. It shows all users who have ever joined the server, rather than all users who are actively using the server. There are plenty of popular IRC channels full of sessions whose only activity is rejoining on disconnection. I mention this because the recent forced move from Freenode to Libera made me notice how many IRC names simply kept on joining Freenode during the period when all other activity on the channels has otherwise died and the topics were updated to point towards Libera.
- smarx007 5y agoTo be fair, I rejoined most of the channels on Libera AND stayed in the Freenode channels to keep an eye on them (until they wiped all accounts overnight, didn’t re-register).
- phoe-krk 5y agoYes, that's one other point that inflated the statistics a little bit - still, on the channels I was a part of, I kind of knew which names belonged to people who were active lurkers and which ones were names that I hadn't ever seen say a word.
- mst 5y agoThis is absolutely true but "all users who could be bothered keeping a client running w/autoreconnect to that specific channel" is still less inflationary than "all users who bothered joining this channel cluster ever". So ... you're absolutely correct, and it was kinda fascinating to get a clearer handle on those numbers as I helped what felt like half the world migrate to libera, but I don't think your being right about that makes your point a particularly good nitpick of the article itself.
- phoe-krk 5y agoYep, I agree. I simply wanted to notice that user inflation is also a problem on IRC, even though it's a smaller one - now even more so after Freenode is gone.
- jakzq 5y ago
- phoe-krk 5y agoPeople choose platforms because of their functionality, not because of their code licensing status - see the case of Scala, linked in a different sibling comment. Matrix and Zulip, even after years of chasing, still sadly haven't caught up to Discord functionality- and UX-wise; until that happens, people won't have a good reason to budge. Regarding IRC, Drew is kind of famous with his ascetism, claiming that the impossibility to share GIFs, videos, files, use threads, have internal chat history, are all features rather than limitations[1]. The thing is, people don't care about it, they'll simply vote with their own legs. Mail and mailgroups face a similar UX challenge. Not everyone is willing to endure the pain of learning and using mailgroups and IRC just because they're FOSS. [1] https://drewdevault.com/2019/07/01/Absence-of-features-in-IRC.html https://drewdevault.com/2019/07/01/Absence-of-features-in-IR...
- cinntaile 5y agoHe's probably right they are features, features most people prefer over IRCs barebones experience. Not being able to catch up on what was said while you're offline is another one of IRCs features, sadly even less people seem to prefer that.
- smichel17 5y agoHere's the catch. I'm someone who likes the idea of IRC being impermanent, available only if I was online at the time. However, I also want people to be able to @mention me so that I can see it later, even if I was offline, overriding the default. AND, when that happens, I also want to be able to read the context before the message and probably some conversation after. In other words, I want "@smichel17 ^" to be a thing. I don't see any way to combine those features. I can approximate this experience in Discord and its ilk by having all history about l available; muting conversations, except for notifications; and relying on willpower not to read the backlog unless I was mentioned. So that's what I do. Maybe the closest thing would be Snapchat, where messages can be "saved" by any of the participants so the whole group can read them later. There's no way to approximate this experience in IRC. So although I still use IRC, it's mostly over a matrix bridge; matrix becomes my bouncer.
- cletus 5y agoSo I agree with this but not for any of the reasons the author states. I find the UI/UX of Discord to be beyond awful, like really, really bad. Am I alone in this? I can never intuitively find a setting, for example. There are multiple settings buttons. Adding channels to your own Discord so you can collect notifications you're interested in sounds cool except it often doesn't work. I suspect the source Discord has disabled this. Why is that even possible? the other big reason is discoverability. Finding things in a Discord is terrible. I've never seen Discord posts pop up in Google search so I suspect that's not possible. The search in Discord is of course bad (pretty much every non-Google search is bad, to be fair). People don't care about it being a walled garden. They only care if it accomplishes the job they want it to.
- kevingadd 5y agoThe horrible UX is part of why I use Ripcord. In practice though, I would rather not use Discord at all - but I have to since that's where my friends and coworkers are, so the best I can do is a third-party client.
- moffkalast 5y agoChecked out Ripcord, does it really look like this https://cancel.fm/ripcord/static/ripcord_screenshot_win_6.png https://cancel.fm/ripcord/static/ripcord_screenshot_win_6.pn... ? Usability may be better but damn their design is from like the 90s. Have they ever heard of padding? And colours?
- jcelerier 5y ago> Have they ever heard of padding? And colours? my first reflex whenever I see a website with tons of paddings and colours is ctrl-w. gimme those win9x UIs please !!!
- diarrhea 5y agoThe worst searches I have encountered are Thunderbird and Discord. While Google is the gold standard, there's a whole range between the former two and the latter. Just fuzzy search goes a long way, but it seems Thunderbird and Discord only match whole words, exactly. The worst kind of search, but could be easily improved.
- rcarmo 5y agoOn a related note, I’ve found myself actively seeking alternatives (edit: to the project itself, not just to chat) when an OSS project only has a chat-based community as opposed to forums or mailing-lists, for two (edit: three) reasons: - it’s impossible to search chats meaningfully, whereas forums/DLs let you quickly figure out if you’re facing a common issue (and finding resolutions easily) - asking about something in chat and tracking replies a day or two later (because you will quite likely not get a quick reply to complex issues) is also quite hard unless you just happen to be awake at the same time as a core dev and can actually spend the time together (although that usually devolves into “file an issue with more details and tag me”). - I don’t want to sign up for a dozen different services or private forums to even access that info. Not to mention that (depending on community) you might just get a lot of irrelevant chatter thrown in, or just plain “this is the wrong channel” replies because there are no signposts.
- nyuszika7h 5y agoI don't like mailing lists, it feels a bit dated to me, and you either get a lot of noise in your inbox or hope that people don't forget to CC you when replying. Forums are OK, but do you really need one for most projects when there's GitHub issues and even discussions now? I personally like it when there's a chat (Discord, Telegram, whatever), it shouldn't be a replacement for an issue tracker but there can be things that aren't clear-cut issues, and I feel less embarrassed to ask in a chat if some behavior is intentional rather than opening an issue.
- rcarmo 5y agoMailing-lists are the most effective way to keep track of things long-term and “catch up”, and they are trivial to filter into a folder IMHO.
- nyuszika7h 5y agoI disagree, mailing lists suffer from many issues. Editing or deleting messages is impossible, which means moderation is also impossible unless you force pre-approval for every post. There is no reasonable way to categorize discussions after the fact, only creating separate lists and hoping people post in the correct place. Trying to share code is the worst, you have a few options here: * Attach it and hope everyone's clients handle attachments properly (especially the online archive will likely not include them). * Include it inline and hope people aren't using a proportional font and it's formatted correctly in the archive. (I've recently had the displeasure of the python-ideas mailing list archive "helpfully" formatting >>> [which is the Python REPL prompt, so you'd think they would have thought of this] into a 3 levels deep blockquote. Thank god we're using such ancient technology in 2021 which makes it impossible to edit the message to correct it!) * Post it on a pastebin, and hope the link isn't dead in a few years when someone is trying to find a solution to their problem in the mailing list archives a few years later.
- lnxg33k1 5y agoI have used Discord for some gaming communities and I use IRC for some projects I want to follow, at a certain point I have looked for the channels of projects I want to follow on Discord and left, as I feel like there are things that used to affect IRC which now affect Discord channels (users looking for warez, stupid battles about which distro is best, battles about DE, users shaming like "Oh only stupid people use XYZ", meanwhile IRC is clean, I'd say IRC is very clean today, I idle every day, and other people are either idle too or having some interesting conversation, so I think Discord and IRC and Slack have good reason to exist for the kind of users they are willing to adopt, like IRC more technical, Slack is where you find corporate clerks, and Discord is for young fanbases?
- matheusmoreira 5y agoElitism can be a force for good. IRC is great but somewhat impenetrable compared to modern messaging platforms, this acts as a filter. Mailing lists seem to be the most impenetrable, still haven't figured those out.
- zelphirkalt 5y agoWhat is there to figure out? Usually you get some e-mail telling you about new messages on the mailing list. That e-mail usually also contains a short info on how to reply or how to send a new message and perhaps some addresses of sister mailing lists. What you need to do is read the e-mail, use the "Reply" button on your e-mail client and put the mailing list address in CC. If you want to reply to the whole lis, not to a specific person, you click the "Reply List" button instead. All you need to look out for is, what you have as TO and CC, like any with other e-mail, only knowing, that there is a general address for the whole list, in case you want a message to be seen on the list and not have a private conversation with people.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> What is there to figure out? Plenty. Do I reply to the person or the list? How do I make sure my reply is properly threaded and doesn't show up as a new thread in the list or something? If I'm emailing the list in reply to a post, how does that even work? From my research it seems there is some kind of in-reply-to message identifier that's supposed to be included in the email headers. Does gmail even do that or am I supposed to use mutt and edit my email headers by hand? At that point I gave up because I didn't want to assume things and risk looking stupid.
- laumars 5y agoWhat moaners of Discord often forget is that setting up your own IRC channel and monitoring that isn’t the value add for the FOSS project. It’s an additional maintenance overhead. So if maintainers choose Discord because it is easier for them to work with (and thus allows them more time to work in the FOSS project) then that’s a good enough reason to use Discord. Furthermore as someone who does run some reasonably popular FOSS projects, I will also use whatever damn platform I chose because it’s my FOSS project.
- laurent123456 5y agoIndeed, I think we have to be pragmatic when running a FOSS project. The infrastructure is chosen based on cost and required maintenance, not based on some FOSS ideal. That's why we're on GitHub and not hosting our own Git server, and we're on Discord for the same reason.
- smashah 5y agoWe rightly shut down the sense of entitlement that some users have to project maintainers' time and effort. I believe this whole recurring "open source + discord = bad" talking point comes from the same sense of entitlement. As an open source maintainer, I use discord (along with email, issues, discussions, PRs, Twitter, site chat etc.) as another option for those wishing to use it. It's not forced upon anyone. A small groups' esoteric (sometimes self-imposed) handicaps doesn't constitute a change in course for everyone else.
- cycomanic 5y agoYou do realise who the author of that blog post is? I guess you could accuse DDVault of many things, but entitlement towards FOSS maintainers is pretty far of that list IMO. That guy is one of the most prolific free software authors and maintainers at the moment. So I think he clearly knows about the burdens of maintaining software.
- emptysongglass 5y agoIt's not entitlement. It's a large cohort of people who have seen what happens when you buy into products not protocols, got burned (everyone has their example but for me it was Google Talk back in the day), and said enough is enough businesses cannot be trusted to be good stewards over any significant length of time. I'm sorry to say but this is a youth-oriented vector that exploits a lack of experience in the target population (game communities were the bread and butter of Discord in its early years) in what happens when you trust any essential product in the hands of a corporation. When I was younger I did the same thing and it's unfortunate because the fact is a drive for profit eventually turns any business against its users' interests and with it torpedoes years of knowledge that could have helped others for decades to come. CEOs come and go, boards change, teams change, investors expect their money back, etc. etc. Just follow the money.
- gcau 5y agoMy opinion, but I think this a Stallman-esque, overexagerrated and unrealistic thing to say. Discord is by far the best chat/voice client, any alternative you try to mention, I'm sorry but it's inferior in atleast a dozen ways. If you don't want to alienate those of your users who are so allergic to proprietary software - what about alienating all the users who prefer discord and don't want to install whatever "free" alternative you suggest? Serious question, because in my experience, the amount of people in the latter outnumber the other 100:1. Almost every developer I know loves having all their projects and developer communities on discord, and get annoyed when there's one using IRC that we want to interact with. Another thing to consider is, how user/developer friendly discord is (privacy/donating to open source/opensourcing their tech/etc), its not like they're some big evil company - their code is proprietary, they're a business. I completely respect you personally not wanting to use discord for FOSS projects, as a matter of principle/ideology, but I just think it's not realistic or practical.
- goodpoint 5y agoYou are trying to dismiss FOSS using the word "ideological". Describing using closed source IM as "practical" and FLOSS ones "overexaggerated" is in itself an example of ideology.
- rvense 5y ago> their code is proprietary, they're a business. Their code can be proprietary, but their protocol shouldn't be. Walled gardens are antithetical to the spirit that built the internet, and no amount of donations can't change the fact that Discord is bad for the net.
- gcau 5y agoI'm not surprised they don't want to "un-wall" their garden to satisfy a truely tiny amount of people. The "walled garden" is an argument that goes in circles, what if we all like our walled garden? Apple too, for example. If there were more competitors outside of the wall that would be a lot more beneficial, than trying to attack the wall because users are so happy they don't want to leave it.
- slimsag 5y agoI recently did a little survey of the top 2,000,000+ GitHub repositories and found (corrected) 28k listed a Discord, 4.3k a Slack, and 1.4k a Matrix chat room[0] This is one of the reasons I chose Matrix for a new game engine project I'm working on. Highly encourage anyone who has not used Matrix/Element since they added Spaces[1] to give it a shot, it is not perfect but it's the closest FOSS messaging system to reproducing the Discord experience (which I truly love, a good UX is so absolutely critical) [0] https://twitter.com/slimsag/status/1474453626328207362?s=20 https://twitter.com/slimsag/status/1474453626328207362?s=20 [1] https://element.io/blog/spaces-blast-out-of-beta/ https://element.io/blog/spaces-blast-out-of-beta/
- djrockstar1 5y agoNote that there's an error in the assumptions behind the discord regex, discord invites do not necessarily have "invite" in the url, and may use the domain discord.gg instead. For instance the yarn repo[0] uses the url "https://discord.gg/yarnpkg https://discord.gg/yarnpkg" which was missed by your search. Another worthwhile mention is the Svelte repo[1], which uses discord, but instead of linking directly to their discord invite, links to "https://svelte.dev/chat https://svelte.dev/chat" which then redirects to their discord invite. Looking for the "discord.gg/invitecode" pattern[2] gives 27k results, safe to say discord is severely under-represented in your statistic. [0] https://github.com/yarnpkg/yarn https://github.com/yarnpkg/yarn [1] https://github.com/sveltejs/svelte https://github.com/sveltejs/svelte [2] https://sourcegraph.com/search?q=context:global+https://discord.gg/%28%5Ba-zA-Z0-9%5D%7B1%2C9%7D%29+select:repo+count:all&patternType=regexp https://sourcegraph.com/search?q=context:global+https://disc...
- slimsag 5y agoBah! Can't believe I fumbled that, thanks. Looks like the most accurate count, if you include both, is then: * 28k for Discord[0] * 1.4k for Matrix[1] [0] https://sourcegraph.com/search?q=context:global+%28https://discord.com/invite/%28%5Ba-zA-Z0-9%5D%2B%29+OR+https://discord.gg/%28%5Ba-zA-Z0-9%5D%2B%29%29+select:repo+count:all&patternType=regexp https://sourcegraph.com/search?q=context:global+%28https://d... [1] https://sourcegraph.com/search?q=context:global+https://matrix.to/%23.%2B+select:repo+count:all&patternType=regexp https://sourcegraph.com/search?q=context:global+https://matr...
- da39a3ee 5y agoPlease don't tell other people what to do.
- TheChaplain 5y agoHm? He's free to say whatever he likes, it's up to the audience to decide whether they agree or not. So please don't silence people.
- da39a3ee 5y agoHaha! Surely you see the flaw in your argument? If he's free to boss people around from his high horse telling them not to use Discord, then I'm free to remind him that bossing people around is not an appealing sight. And you're free to tell me that you don't like nobodys like me criticizing bigwig darlings of HN such as Drew DeVault, whoever he is. We're all free! I mean seriously, re-read your last sentence and note the contradiction!
- alvarlagerlof 5y agoPlease many altenatives that are as good or better.
- byteski 5y agoThe problem with using Discord for FOSS projects for me is that there are hundreds or thousands of unread messages on a server. People are chatting in short messages and I just don't have time to read all this. Forum-like platforms as Discourse seems more readable for me and it can be indexed by google and other search platforms.
- fghgg 5y agoChats can be indexed by Google as well, see Matrix and Gitter
- charcircuit 5y agoThis is usually handled by having like an announcement channel so important messages don't get buried.
- tester756 5y agoI agree that Discord ain't perfect, but over like 15 years of using various voips to talk with friends - ventrilo, mumble, teamspeak, skype and recently teams I found Discord unparalleled - it has great chat, great voice, streaming, files/images sharing and also is centralized, thus secure for user. I don't have to worry about joining random ass server and then getting DDoS'd (yes, stuff like this happens, especially in gaming from my experience) ___________ >Users who cannot afford new enough hardware to make the resource-intensive client pleasant to use are also left by the wayside. Choosing Discord is a choice that excludes poor Sorry, but C++ compilers are N times more resource intensive than Discord's client Where's the boundary? what's the minimal level that should we "require"? Ability to code in VS Code? Visual Studio? JetBrain IDEs? ability to run Chrome? Firefox? VIM? 256 MB of RAM? NVMe M2 DISK? ________________ >are also locked out of the client until Discord sees fit to port it to their platform How about via browser? _______________ I'll go even further and provoke You're increasing entry level for younger/newbie developers by using arcane and dated ways of contributing instead of "standards" like GitHub.
- dijit 5y ago> Sorry, but C++ compilers are N times more resource intensive than Discord's client I personally don't have a problem with discords client, but this statement does more to harm your argument than you think it does. Compilation is a specialised process, and an intensive one. You might as well say "Why shouldn't my wallpaper use all my resources? Video editing does!". Niche workflows and one-off tasks are inherently different beasts than platform software which by its nature requires everyone to be running at the same time.
- tester756 5y ago>Niche workflows and one-off tasks. The context is about FOSS, I believe it's programming heavy, thus software compilation it's not niche workflow, but something that you do a few times per programming session. Some people within project don't write code, but majority I'd say at least tries. Where's middle ground?
- 5y ago
- politelemon 5y agoAlong the same lines as author's opening paragraph. The Apache Airflow team used to use Gitter.im, which was actually pretty good in terms of search. Google search results would link right to a specific conversation and that provided great value. Joining was easy too. However the community voted to move to Slack. The main reason given was around its popularity, more so than anything else. It was also the Slack free tier, so there was very little in the way of conversation history being available. However, it is what the community wanted, even though it became a barrier for me.
- whirlwin 5y agoWon't discouraging Discord usage when developing FOSS limit the number of contributors? Why focus so much on the tooling instead of actually creating fantastic free open source software?
- commoner 5y agoUsing Discord excludes contributors who, for instance, don't want to provide their phone number to participate in the conversation when Discord demands it. There are other chat solutions that never demand as much personal information, and this includes both FOSS and closed source software.
- acd 5y agoOpen source is a philosophy. Open cook book vs closed recepie. Ie you share openly vs keeping secrets.
- wolframhempel 5y agoI would make the exact opposite argument: We should make it easier for open source contributors to focus on their FOSS project instead of all the infrastructure around it. This is an insight that's fairly undisputed in most other spaces (use the cloud because your business is not in running servers, use SaaS because your business is not in hosting applications etc...), yet somehow every maintainer of a "check-is-email" npm package is expected to host their own Matrix Instance, Git Server, Build Status Dashboard and ideally video tutorial portal? In fact, wouldn't it be great if Github would offer a public realtime discussion board for each repo so that everything about your project is in one place?
- moffkalast 5y agoIn fact, wouldn't it be great if Github wasn't owned by a money grabbing multinational conglomerate? Yeah, that's not happening.
- wolframhempel 5y agoDoes it provide more value to you than it expects you to put in?
- moffkalast 5y agoDepends on how much my code is worth to them for their machine learning projects.
- wolframhempel 5y agoAll the reflexive anti-capitalism/anti-corporatism aside, the emergence of company-backed hubs such as Github has been a massive accelerator of the success and overall relevance of open source. When FOSS was confined to Linus Torvalds and co, sharing postings on Usenet groups, transparency and adoption stayed low and larger adopters rather paid intermediaries like Redhat to mitigate the risks of what was perceived as "niche software". Today, open-source is an undisputed standard and has a bustling scene of creators - made possible by easy-to-use and accessible tooling and hubs. Operating these isn't free - but in difference to OS itself, I don't think there is any inherent conflict between providing OS infrastructure and a profit motive. Maybe there will be a fully decentralized, blockchain-based version of Github with individual users contributing for the value they receive in the future, but until then Github - whether owned by MS or not - remains a massive enabler for OS at large.
- Ginden 5y ago> It sets up users who are passionate about free software — i.e. your most passionate contributors or potential contributors — as second-class citizens. False premise. Die-hard free software fans who refuse to use proprietary software aren't numerous enough to make significant part of your contributors.
- causi 5y agochoosing them is a short-term, individualist play which signals a lack of faith in and support for the long-term goals of the FOSS ecosystem as a whole. The FOSS ecosystem needs your investment I will never understand this "command economy" vision of some FOSS advocates. FOSS and proprietary software can and do coexist. Considering most FOSS code is written by people whose income is dependent on revenue generated by proprietary code, the purity obsession becomes frankly ridiculous. Proprietary code needs FOSS to keep it from stagnating and becoming abusive, and FOSS needs proprietary code to put food in the stomachs of the people writing it.
- edem 5y agoThe problem is that the group of people I lock out if I _don't_ use Discord (or Slack) is much bigger than the group of FOSS advocates.
- jerjerjer 5y agoDisregarding closed source issue I find Discord, any chat, unsuitable as a public user-developer interface. Why? 1. Asynchrony. User needs time to collect data, write a bug report and so on. Developer needs time to reproduce the issue, work on it. Finally there are a lot of timezones - people ask/answer at different points of time. 2. Long lasting. Communication can take days, weeks and even months as new details emerge. Accessing a year old thread should be as easy as accessing a thread created yesterday. 3. Publicity. You want everything written to be as public as possible. Read access should be available to everyone without registration. Read access should be available via web browser. So that other users (who often experience the same issues) can easily find existing communication on the topic, and if they can't find it themselves you can at least send them a link which brings me to permanence. 4. Permanence. Each individual communication (message) should be accessible by a URI which never changes. Each individual communication page should have links to thread/parent/children/references. 5. Searchability. Follows from (3) and (4) but the easier it is for a user to find past discussions - the less noise you'll have. Chat systems such as Discord, Slack or Matrix are fundamentally incompatible with these requirements as they are focused on synchronous, ephemeral communication.
- feanaro 5y agoPermanence, long lasting messages and cross-server replication are one of the primary selling points of the Matrix protocol.
- charcircuit 5y ago>3 Discord servers can be configured to not require an account >4 Each message has a URL. You can easily copy a link to a message. >5 Discord allows you to search all messages in a server and use filters too.
- Macha 5y ago> Discord servers can be configured to not require an account But literally no one does this because of spam concerns > Discord allows you to search all messages in a server and use filters too. In Discord, while a forum or github issues or whatever will show up in your general internet search engine of choice.
- gsliepen 5y agoFor my own projects, I have git repositories on self-hosted infrastructure, and IRC channels on Libera and OFTC. But I don't want to force others to use my preferred infrastructure. So I also have mirrors of my git repositories on GitHub and GitLab, and I don't mind if people send pull requests or create issues on those platforms. Basically, just don't put all your eggs in one basket, and make sure at least one basket is under your own control.
- zmachinaz 5y agoIf you try to connect via VPN, Discord insists on a phone number for verification. That says all ...
- beepbooptheory 5y agoI think you can simply point out that if the protocol was open, beyond bot development, if users could choose their clients, and searchable plain text archives could be made available, etc, all but the most political detractors in these arguments would be appeased. But the thing is, that will never happen, because we are not talking about a protocol, but a service. And that to me is just the whole problem. There is just nowhere to go, and people who try to develop in this space are squashed by the TOS. At the end of the day you can either be fine with the lock in here, or not.
- charcircuit 5y ago>you also lock out users with accessibility This might make me a terrible person but I don't care. They should get a better screen reader. >Users who cannot afford new enough hardware to make the resource-intensive client If you can't afford a computer that can handle Discord you should probably be focusing on earning more money than working with my software. >Users of novel or unusual operating systems or devices Discord works in a web browser. >Discord also declines service to users in countries under US sanctions, such as Iran. I don't care. >Privacy-concious users will think twice before using Discord to participate in your project, or will be denied outright if they rely on Tor or VPNs Discord cares about people's privacy, but also has to deal with abuse coming from people who want to be anonymous. >Ownership over your chat logs 99% of my chat logs are garbage >the right to set up useful bots Discord has great bot support >or to moderate your project’s space according to your discretion You can moderate your server however you want. As long as you don't get reported you don't even need to follow Discord's somewhat restrictive ToS.
- Zababa 5y agoA good thing about that article that I haven't see anyone else mention: it's easy to send it to people to explain your position. It's not aggressive, it's based on fact, and clear about its values. Thank you for that, this will save me a lot of time when the topic of Discord comes up.
- pelorat 5y agoLook, FOSS is great. But FOSS fundamentalism is not (perpetrated by those who refuse to use any proprietary software).
- jimmyvalmer 5y agoBy choosing Discord, you also lock out users with accessibility needs And by choosing Sourcehut, you deprive yourself of anything resembling usability.
- rascul 5y agoI've been using chat clients since the '90s but for the life of me I can't figure out how to use Discord. At least for me, the interface is effectively unusable. It was bad enough for me to attempt to use such a proprietary service, even if I couldn't figure it out. And then I learned about all the shady practices, such as going after third party clients, seemingly random deleting and/or locking of accounts, requiring phone number, and now I just refuse to touch it. I am clearly not Discord's target audience.
- zppln 5y agoI'm in the same boat. I find Discord's UI a strangely unintuitive mess. Slow and clunky, and for some reason there's always a bunch of patches that need to be applied every time I start it. Patches that never seem to improve the core experience.
- jokoon 5y agoThe only advantages of discord over IRC or other things, is the chat history, voice, and the ability to delete messages. Discord is made for gamers. Not to mention each server has channels, which make it impossible to follow up certains topics. You can't even favorite a channel, and you have to "subscribe" to the whole server. Oh yeah and a full electron instance, of I don't know how many megabytes, just to display images, gifs and a certain interface style. I hope the low tech trend comes back.
- new_realist 5y agoMore sermons, and it isn’t even Sunday.
- new_realist 5y agoDiscord functionality is driven by market forces, which is more than I can say for FOSS. FOSS is less likely to offer a product that works for mainstream users.
- r_hoods_ghost 5y agoI'm about as far away from Drew as possible when it comes to my views about the benefits of open source yet I also loathe Discord as a method of supporting users because its essentially a memory hole. I want to be able to ask or answer a question once and then for it to be easily findable by a future user searching on the public web. That's just not possible with Discord, especially if a server shuts down. A lot of the discussion around a large open source project I develop add-ons for has migrated onto Discord and it makes it an utter nightmare to work out what is happening, why certain design decisions were made, or get an answer about a technical question without directly contacting someone. If that discussion instead took place on their public forums (which is where it was previously) then I wouldn't have to bug someone 90% of the time.
- Proven 5y ago
- hammyhavoc 5y ago
- dang 5y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments? It's not what this site is for and you've unfortunately been doing it a lot lately. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- hammyhavoc 5y agoMatrix protocol is a great fit for FOSS projects, Discord isn't.
- dang 5y agoOk, but that isn't relevant to what I asked you.
- emptybottle 5y agoLicensing, hosting and privacy aside. IRC not having built-in chat history is actually a wonderful feature. The Discord communities I’ve experienced are a mess of dozens of topic driven channels each with long backscroll and various pins to jump around to various points in the chat history. Conversations between the same set of people are fragmented across numerous topic channels. I find it hard to follow and cumbersome to find/search information. IRC forces chat to be transient, and any information that should persist or reach a wider audience must be handled intentionally.
- yosito 5y agoI've had my Discord account permanently deactivated because I somehow triggered an automated system to think my account was suspicious. My phone number was verified, I was a good faith participant in many servers for years, and a paying Discord customer. My only guess about what might have happened is that I was using a VPN and there may have been someone using the same IP that did something suspicious. In any case, there is no recourse for me, and I am permanently banned from using Discord. So yeah, please don't use Discord for FOSS projects, or anything else important.
- city41 5y agoI totally agree with this and I find real time chat is a terrible way to support and collaborate on software. But in my case, the users of my project overwhelmingly prefer Discord. I have begrudgingly accepted it. I started with just GitHub issues and discussions, then went to a subreddit. Users created their own unofficial Discord for my project and everyone flocked there.
- ourbetterworld 5y agoI hate Discord passionately, but even as head of operations for open source development groups, I have not been able to make the case that alternatives are viable replacements. Who wants to step up and give us a grant to change this situation?
- kaetemi 5y agoWe started using Discord recently, bridged to IRC. There are 10x more members on our Discord than on the IRC. Conversation went from nearly-dead to weekly help threads and updates. Project feels alive again. Member acquisition and retention is much better. You cannot grow an open source community by only selling to the open source crowd.
- hameggmayo 5y agoI find it remarkable how many people here will willingly defend discord as not being evil and "its fine, what could go wrong" and many will in the same breath decry facebook for being bad and privacy invading and so forth. At one point in time facebook was cool and trendy and nobody was really freaking out about it. Discord can at the drop of a hat become a new facebook -- or get bought by facebook or some other megacorp that wont just bleed money on their investments and will start selling your information, and we can start the new cycle of everyone jumping on some hip new product that has all the same problems. The average person (my parents, grandparents, all non technical) can successfully navigate email and its a bit insulting to the average person to insinuate that something like matrix/xmpp with a little bit more UX work is simply too hard for the layman to grok. Maybe discord is convenient right now but it wont be when everyone has to jump around to some new maybe less evil service.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoOn the other hand I think people should keep their discord history as at some point I suspect more "corporate earnings" will be the goal and the "board" will require to start charging for channels and there will be a mass exodus to matrix or something similar
- PufPufPuf 5y agoPlease don't use any real-time chat as the main community channel. Use a discussion forum instead. FOSS projects last many years while rarely needing real-time collaboration -- using a "slower", more focused and more searchable communication platform makes better sense. Also, and this is very subjective, from my experience real-time chat (Discord especially) allows toxic community members to be toxic without much fear of punishment since the interactions are ephemeral. Moreover, toxic people often lurk the channels 24/7 and thus are the first to respond to questions. Questions that happen to be "stupid" since the same question is asked often -- even though the last instance has already been drowned out by a half-kilometre of memes and off-topic talk.
- LdSGSgvupDV 5y agoThis. The real problem is not communication. It is the online searchability of the issues and source code.
- ourbetterworld 5y agoWhere are the HN chat communities now? Matrix? Zulip? Discord?
- stagas 5y agoThe magic of IRC is that you are not always connected and there isn't any way to reliably keep a connection alive. The urge to always be online, always want to lookup history, is a kind of FOMO-paranoia. We've developed weak memory a species for some important reason. It's ok to forget things, it's ok to not attend everything, it's ok to have off-time. The important things will surface by themselves, there's no need to be digging, plus you have a lot of work to do already. So, in my view, IRC is more like the being in the park, flowing with the Tao. It is simple and it is good. Discord is like getting cocaine and going to a festival. It's fantastic, but exhausting.