15 ms·
The Google home page is 500K
- onion-soup 5y ago500K what?
- chii 5y agoAlso, i wonder who actually go to the google home page to search these days, instead of directly typing into the address bar?
- ehsankia 5y agoEspecially on mobile. Worth noting that the bad score is only on Mobile, I consistently get 45-50, but on the Desktop section I get 99.
- CrazyCatDog 5y agoBut does this really matter? When I pull-up google.com on mobile the search bar is instantaneous; what isn’t instantaneous, is all the superfluous junk that nobody visits google.com for…
- akyoan 5y agoPeople googling Google, which is a lot.
- IncandescentGas 5y agoI do. Google is not my default search engine. In the rare case I want to use it, I must visit the google website to search.
- ehnto 5y agoA few of the other search engines let you do "!g" in your query which automatically takes you to a google search instead.
- kiwijamo 5y agoFor example: DuckDuckGo.
- charcircuit 5y agoYou can just click the Google icon in your search box and it will then search with Google.
- maximus-decimus 5y agoYou can set google as a search engine then when you type "google.com <space>/<tab>" and it will switch the search engine for this one query. You can edit the exact keyword and set whatever search engine you want in settings -> "search engines" in google.
- JansjoFromIkea 5y agoI got an extension that just adds a "search on google" option at the top of any duckduckgo search results page. For most things DDG suffices fine but when it isn't I'll just have to do one extra click. This feels like a better flow to me than having to remember when I explicitly need to use google in the address bar or having to go to google.com and search it there.
- kevingadd 5y agoI think the link is meant to be https://pagespeed.web.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fgoogle.com%2F https://pagespeed.web.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fgoogle.co... - a perf report on the Google homepage. When I click the link from HN it pulls up a performance report on the performance report service (which is also bad.) It's fascinating that according to the report, someone on a Moto G4 would have to wait over 6 seconds for the google search page to be responsive so they could type in a query.
- Laforet 5y agoI wonder how accurate are the results really, or maybe I wasn't interpreting the numbers correctly. Accessing Google.com from my Moto G7 Power (a phone about 30% faster than G4 in terms of CPU performance) shows no seconds long delay. In face it feels almost instant. On the other hand it seems to give a fair critique to other sites that are known to be bloated such as the one below. https://pagespeed.web.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fnzherald.co.nz%2F https://pagespeed.web.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fnzherald....
- kevingadd 5y agoThey simulate slow wireless data, which I suspect is the cause of the gap. It's certainly the case that a big % of the world's population has bad mobile data even if they do have a relatively fast smartphone.
- kiwijamo 5y agoWonder if it's due to a warm cache. I never use Google (hence it won't have google.com cached) and accessing it from Firefox on my high-end Android S21 takes a few seconds to load via my NZ fibre connection. Certainty not instant. DuckDuckGo on the other hand loads nearly instantly (although it's probably a warm cache on my part). To be more fair I tried Bing (which I also never use) which seems to be on par with Google, I suspect due to Bing loading a photogenic but ultimately useless background image.
- Laforet 5y ago
- cletus 5y agoThis is kind of sad. Going back more than a decade ago, google.com used to be brutally optimized. Anything unnecessary was stripped to reduce load times and decrease network traffic. For example, attribute values were never quoted if they didn't have to be and closing tags like </html> were omitted. It was kind of fascinating to read how many terabytes of network traffic omitting </html> saved. But then came the ill-fated boondoggle that was Google+ and with Google+ came the OneBar. This was the black bar across the top of the screen with key properties but, more importantly, the G+ login. The cost of this was really high. We don't have the black bar anymore but a subset of links remain as does the login box, even if it isn't for G+ anymore. The Google home page just isn't the lean page it once was. That doesn't make me mad, unlike say AMP, which makes me incredibly angry. But still I can't help but take it as a sign of lost values.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tomcam 5y agoThanks for adding the right URL, kevingadd. Have no idea how I screwed that up. As they said, it's supposed to be https://pagespeed.web.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fgoogle.com%2F https://pagespeed.web.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fgoogle.co...
- kwertyoowiyop 5y agoIt says 5.5s to first interactive. Yikes. Though on my iPad Air 2 it’s significantly faster than that.
- lelandfe 5y agoYeah - bear in mind this is testing on a Moto G4 with a simulated horrible cellular connection. It’s supposed to be a “worst case scenario” sort of test.
- Rodeoclash 5y agoI have a Moto G4 and a sometimes patchy internet connection. This might be the prompt I need to upgrade!
- google234123 5y agoI think it has more to do with simulating 3g network (which is being decommissioned now)
- lelandfe 5y agoThe performance of the device is actually a huge factor for TTI specifically
- rkagerer 5y agoFrom a company like Google, this is shameful. I don't think it ever would have happened under Marissa Mayer's watch.
- CrazyCatDog 5y agoAgreed, and SO thrilled that Yahoo hasn’t changed one iota since her departure—imagine what’s the world would be like today has she been at lycos or alta vista!
- siva7 5y agoAm i missing some irony?
- mkl 5y agoNo, just history: https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2008/07/what-comes-next-in-this-series-13-33-53.html https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2008/07/what-comes-next-in-t... (linked by sadjad upthread)
- windows2020 5y agoDoes anyone have a link to this story? I remember it as: Way back when, a Google dev started to receive frequent cryptic emails. Each email contained a single number. They struggled to figure out what it represented, if anything. Somehow, it was realized the number represented the word count on their homepage. This story comes to mind when I see promotions, statements and other things there. Perhaps someone should start emailing a byte count.
- sadjad 5y agohttps://googleblog.blogspot.com/2008/07/what-comes-next-in-this-series-13-33-53.html https://googleblog.blogspot.com/2008/07/what-comes-next-in-t...
- dpritchett 5y ago> Posted by Marissa Mayer, VP Search Products & User Experience The years really do fly by. Looked her up and she’s currently a cofounder at a company that sells an iOS contacts app.
- jcims 5y agoFor anyone that isn't aware, she was also a very early Google employee (wikipedia says #20) and CEO of Yahoo for several years.
- thallium205 5y agoAnd she absolutely ran it into the ground.
- seanieb 5y agoKinda hard to say it was just her. Yahoo! was already pretty much dead when she arrived.
- 5y ago
- freediver 5y agoA more intriguing fact is that Google's search result page will often run 2-2.5MB in size (!). And sub 500ms results are a thing of (distant) past. More often than comfortable, user will wait between 1.5s and 2 seconds for results to load. [1] This has gotten out of the hand for a company with so much resources, that literally depends on page speed for revenue. It is incomprehensible that the size (which is probably the main reason for latency) can not be reduced. At Kagi Search [2] (I'm founder) our home page (for logged in users, not the marketing landing page) is mere 68kb, everything works even without javascript, and 90th percentile result pages load in <1s with SERP page being on average 100-200kb total. [1] https://pagespeed.web.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2Fsearch%3Fq%3Dmattress https://pagespeed.web.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.googl... [2] https://kagi.com https://kagi.com
- ddtaylor 5y ago> that literally depends on page speed for revenue. I don't think that's an accurate view of the business model of Google. For them consumers are mostly locked in and their business model is in tracking users and mining as much information as possible from every facet of the experience.
- google234123 5y agoJust did a search and it took 550ms. 1.5s and 2 seconds sounds like an exaggeration
- ec109685 5y agoDon’t you think they have run tests that trade off search speed for additional features and determined the features increase engagement / revenue? There is a lot more going on than 10 blue links these days, including continual scroll on mobile. Perf versus features is always a matter of trade offs.
- freediver 5y agoI suppose you are right. I can only guess that RPU is the primary KPI and somehow more scripts allow for more revenue extraction even if the performance is lower.
- mullingitover 5y agoPinboard has been trying to warn us about page bloat for years. Props to Maciej for still running one of the fastest, most useful, least creepy social anti-social media sites on the web.
- tomrod 5y agoThis is a neat tool. Hacker News hits 100% Reddit fails w/ a score of 23 Looking forward to using it to test against my sites.
- josephg 5y agoA blog post I wrote a few months ago is apparently fast in general, but I get a bad score on pagespeed insights because I'm pulling in 3rd party scripts. The scripts I'm using? An embedded youtube video and some fonts from google fonts. I'm not sure why pagespeed insights says first paint is delayed behind youtube's javascript loading. Sounds like something I should fix. Shame on me for using google's other services in the recommended way I suppose. [1] https://pagespeed.web.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fjosephg.com%2Fblog%2Fcrdts-go-brrr%2F https://pagespeed.web.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fjosephg.c...
- raihansaputra 5y agoHah. Kindof same. Ran Lighthouse tests on my project and on the evaluation it complains about gtag and Google Sign In being slow to load.
- dylan604 5y agoI'm shocked they are allowed to report this. Interesting that they are allowed to be independent and not obfuscate the fact that the other Goog services are so slow.
- SquareWheel 5y agoThat's always been the case. Having too many Google Ads can even downrank you in search results for being a bad user experience. For Youtube embeds, I prefer Lite Youtube Embed[1] by the magnificent Paul Irish. [1] https://github.com/paulirish/lite-youtube-embed https://github.com/paulirish/lite-youtube-embed
- 5y ago
- daniel_iversen 5y agoI wouldn’t be surprised if google serves different html based on location+ISP and browser agent etc. I.e if you’re on a modern browser with a high-speed isp you might get a heavier page than if you’re on dialup or mobile in 3rd world countries.
- rabbidruster 5y agoDoing anything too complex there would be pretty surprising to me. if they are it seems they didn't do too good a job since the test is emulating a old phone that should probably get a simple/smaller page
- lelandfe 5y agoThere's a CSS media detection feature called `prefers-reduced-data` that may be graduating from a Chrome feature flag Soon™, although I'm not sure if Google is using that anywhere on their sites today. https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=1051189 https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=105118...
- Gigachad 5y agoThey absolutely do serve legacy versions to old browses. I'm pretty sure you can still get a version with the black bar on the top.
- prirun 5y agoI had HashBackup's web site hosted at Google Sites for 10 years. The recent migration to Sites V2 looked really bad, so I redid it all in Asciidoc. I downloaded a static HTML-only version of the old site from Google and a cat of all the HTML files was 25.3MB. The new static site is only 1.7MB of HTML, with more than a third of that being the release log. The average HTML page size is 19K, whereas with Google V1, the average was 450K. And it's way easier to maintain now with a text editor and rsync vs pointing and clicking in a browser text window. The other major problem with the V2 Sites is that the HashBackup release log took 15 seconds to load. It didn't do that with V1 Sites, so this was a new "enhancement". With the Asciidoc site it takes a little over a second. Google has a Report Migration Issues button, but of course they never responded to anything I sent.
- ekzhu 5y agoMost of it should be cached. I think it’s a trade off between server load and client experience. Millions of 10KB requests << thousands of 500KB requests (also potentially with lots of compressed stuff).
- lazyjones 5y agoSo what is this 244KB JS taking 1300ms to execute on the simulated G4 actually doing? It contains mostly parts of the Closure Library (https://developers.google.com/closure/library/ https://developers.google.com/closure/library/).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iamleppert 5y agoPerformance only matters if you are in competition with others. You can win a marathon by crawling if you’re the only participant. Who are Google’s serious competitors? Sure there are other search engines but I’d argue that none are serious or even marginal threats. People will tolerate sub-optimal experiences if they perceive they don’t have any option; just ask anyone who has stood in line at the DMV. The first sign of a monopoly is a rapid performance degradation which can’t be explained by economics of scale and which did not exist in prior versions of a product. Free market forces and incentive structures no longer apply to monopolies, which is why many large corporations can get away with sloppy work and treating their customers poorly, but do not see much if any consequences. Behavior that would have been disastrous in a startup is tolerable in a large corporation operating as a monopoly. A product owner or dev at Google would be committing career suicide if they started to care about performance at this point, because that would not result in any appreciable changes or outcomes consistent with the incentive structures at Google.
- nfm 5y ago> Performance only matters if you are in competition with others. I'm not sure that's right. There's a strong link between performance and repeat usage. Even in the complete absence of competition, Google search being fast could result in more searches per user being conducted and more revenue as a result.
- alpb 5y ago> People will tolerate sub-optimal experiences Implying the Google Search homepage loading experience is sub-optimal? Chrome starts loading it before you finish typing google.com on your keyboard.
- hetspookjee 5y agoI think most products from Microsoft are relevant in this context. Teams is horrible and every week another thing breaks. Almost every page by Microsoft takes more than 10 seconds to load on my side. Yet everyone including me uses it.
- LAC-Tech 5y agoLet me ask every single web developer a straight-forward question. If huge tech companies like google, facebook, airbnb etc are unable to make fast websites... then why should we use their frameworks and tools? I really feel like the emperor has no clothes here and it's insane for smaller companies to try and ape them.
- iKevinShah 5y ago> It's insane for smaller companies to try and ape them In my cynical view, When you think about engineers as people who want to stay up to date with 'latest and greatest' so that they are not left behind in the market, the use of their frameworks makes sense. Also, the frameworks do solve very key problems in their own ways (and also avoid re-inventing the wheel). So the truth lies somewhere between the 2 sentences there. There's nothing which we can not achieve without frameworks however managing that solution is a pain. More so if one is working on a bigger team.
- gnz11 5y agoTheir frameworks and tools also generally come with extensive documentation...which is quite rare in projects that are proprietary balls of mud written by a single programmer who left the company several years ago.
- forgotmyoldname 5y ago> then why should we use their frameworks and tools? Because job postings demand X years experience in Y framework instead of looking for actual skills, and many investors look for hot things that are jumping on Z hip new tech buzzword and not all look at what they actually solve. Plus to a certain extent they can be used to get a project off the ground faster. Although at a certain point a good number of projects that are successfully taking off would benefit from a nice rewrite--but that's not as sexy and marketable as adding another new feature in that same time span.
- rapind 5y agoWhile I’m sure there’s some portion of developers who are ready to jump to google and Facebook tools right away, I doubt it’s a majority. There have been a lot of misses from these companies. Some big wins for sure, but it’s definitely not a perfect record. I do think there are a lot of smart people working on hard problems (user engagement… not cancer) with large teams at these companies though. Which means they are bound to come up with some percentage of good solutions. I’m glad they share them even when they flop.
- worik 5y agoHow the mighty have fallen, how far, how sad. Once the Google home page was a master class in good design.
- Gigachad 5y agoHas it ever been? The page used center tags last I checked and a mountain of spec violating stuff but technically works on all browsers. Using the google page as a reference would be like ripping a few note pages from a physicists workbook as an example to learn math.
- kerneloftruth 5y agoSergey used to demand that the payload of the home page be tiny (I think it had to be < 100K, if I recall -- or maybe even smaller). That was part of the appeal of the simple search page, nothing but a logo and a search field. Now it looks minimal-ish, but contains a bunch of crap that serves only Google, not the end-user.
- TheRealNGenius 5y ago500k what? Link says nothing about 500k...
- gapan 5y agoThe title was confusing for me as well. Apparently its size is about 500KiB.
- jraph 5y agoWhich is huge for a page that displays an input box and a button to send the query, which requires a few bytes. Add a few KBs for the suggestions. These few bytes is actually mostly what you get when browsing Google with w3m. By the way I just noticed they now have a cookie banner that works in w3m without JS? Now this is some zeal!
- ciphol 5y agoAs soon as you start typing your search, it starts making search suggestions. That's a complex feature which must involve lots of code. Also, the search page is not just the search page, it's the portal for all Google services and has corresponding links and menus at the top. So we should expect the page to be much bigger than "a few bytes", and it is.
- Gigachad 5y agoNone of us know what the google home page is actually doing. It reminds me of the gnu coreutils where the program "true" which simply returns a successful status code on run, is hundreds of lines in C. I could do that in 3 lines! Except I'd be ignoring all of the weird use cases and architectures that the coreutils have to support. The google homepage works on a _remarkable_ number of devices. You could install a fresh copy of windows XP and the built in IE works flawlessly with google while almost any other page is broken. And also forgetting all the analytics they need. I know its a dirty word on HN but this kind of stuff is essential for a product of this scale. Throw in some extras for accessibility, etc.
- josefx 5y agoIf I remember correctly GNU true violates various specs because it does too much (help and version) when it should ignore all parameters. As you say a valid implementation can be done in three lines.
- Gigachad 5y agoThe code is made way more complex by combining both true and false in to the same binary and then using the output binary name to decide which return code it outputs. It seems overly complex to me but I have no idea what kind of requirements they have.
- avodonosov 5y agoThe page suggests to remove unused javascript. In the past I measured google search (and some other web apps), only around a 1/3 of the javascript loaded was actually used, despite, I suppose, google's javascript is optimized by closure compiler: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IoFleV1ybxE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IoFleV1ybxE Javascript could probably benefit from an optimisation like this: https://github.com/avodonosov/pocl https://github.com/avodonosov/pocl
- mro_name 5y agoWebsite obesity crisis progressing. http://idlewords.com/talks/website_obesity.htm http://idlewords.com/talks/website_obesity.htm A webform requiring truckloads of stuff and gear.
- divbzero 5y agoComparing the Google home page against a few competitors — 1,326 KiB Bing https://www.bing.com/ 829 KiB Yahoo! https://www.yahoo.com/ 506 KiB Google https://www.google.com/ 358 KiB DuckDuckGo https://duckduckgo.com/ 8 KiB DuckDuckGo Lite https://lite.duckduckgo.com/
- cblconfederate 5y ago377 kb Yandex
- Grakel 5y agoI have started using Yandex for image search, it has all the features Google removed to keep from getting getting sued. Excellent results and great tools.
- usr1106 5y agoOh, lite.duckduckgo.com is great on my somewhat underperforming old mobile. Wasn't aware of that. The URL could be more touchscreen friendy.
- authed 5y agoSince they own duck.com, you wonder why l.duck.com doesn't redirect to the correct URL (or lite.duck.com).
- rwky 5y agoI didn't know lite.duckduckgo.com existed! It's amazing I've now set it to my default search engine on my phone.
- merlinscholz 5y ago174 KiB (419 KiB without gzip/deflate) https://search.brave.com/ https://search.brave.com/
- dpark 5y agoOut of curiosity, how much of that Bing load is the lazy-loaded background image? I would guess that the rest of the page is very light but maybe I’m wrong. On my mobile device, Google feels slow because they have to throw up a spinner for 2 seconds while they figure out what local news to share with me. Bing manages that seemingly instantly on on my device. For full disclosure, I’m a Microsoft employee. Not trying too shill for Bing. I’ve just been surprised how slow Google feels lately due to their (slowly) lazy-loaded content.
- lbriner 5y agoI'm sure someone has coined a term for it but isn't it just a tendency for rich companies to keep employing more and more people who are adding less and less value so they invent roles, departments, imaginary needs and requirements so that everything gets more expensive, more complicated and slower. What do you do if your current front page actually works really well with some basic PHP or whatever but you employ x thousand of the world's best developers? You invent new frameworks that are more complicated to solve one problem and create 10 more, you change things so they can be automated even though you can easily afford for people to press a few buttons. And the worst of all, the need to "stay relevant", which is a sad but real pressure in marketing and can involve really expensive design consultants (new font Twitter?) and sometimes something that is not only very different than before but sometimes much worse.
- iamgopal 5y agoThey hire people so that they don’t go to the competitor.
- cblconfederate 5y agoGoogle should consider converting its website to AMP. It will definitely improve their ranking
- gniv 5y agoIt's really only about 43k and it loads instantaneously for me. The rest is scripts and other stuff that's cached. I think this is the right tradeoff for an ultra-popular site.
- lkbm 5y agoYeah, I show just under 60KB transferred because it's cached and compressed. Size is a useful metrics, but actual UX is what matters.
- trasz 5y agoGoogle services are crap, what a surprise.
- DnDGrognard 5y ago500k *Sobs* and goes off to drown my sorrows with an early Christmas Negroni
- digdigdag 5y agoDoes it matter anymore? I haven't used the Google homepage to use Google in years. It's integrated into the search bar now... Also, the Google home page loads dependent services (single sign on, lots of JS for XHR searches, etc.)
- random314 5y agoPretty certain that Google will lower the payload on expensive connections. These things get A/B tested to death.
- Waterluvian 5y agoI think page load times like this are like 30fps vs 60fps in console gaming. 60fps is perceptibly better and for many of us, me included, is usually required or it is palpably uncomfortable. But for the overwhelming majority of people: they don’t notice or don’t care.
- authed 5y agogmail is a lot worst
- einpoklum 5y agoJust use duckduckgo: https://duckduckgo.com/ https://duckduckgo.com/ Their homepage is 5722 bytes not including images.