17 ms·
There's been a big rise in monitoring workers at home
- SubiculumCode 5y agoThere was a recent decision, in the UK I believe, where an individual sued for worker comp for an injury that occurred during his walk to his desk. While the story was amusing, it actually worried me. If businesses are liable for what occurs in my home, would they not push on controlling more of what is in my home?
- stordoff 5y agoIt appears to be Germany: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/09/fall-on-walk-from-bed-to-desk-is-workplace-accident-german-court-rules https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/09/fall-on-walk-f... There are a couple of things worth noting here. Firstly, the accident was covered as the walk was deemed to constitute commuting. This suggests that events that happen outside of an employer's premise and in an environment they cannot control being covered is not particularly new or uncommon. Further, it was the employer’s insurance that refused to pay out - the employer did not directly suffer any loss (though presumably the insurance company could set requirements for the employer as a condition of the insurance contract).
- wayanon 5y agoWhen you leave a job, voluntarily or not, it's amazing how long it takes for that job to leave your mental system. A year later I still find myself occasionally wondering whether a project went well or more recently after I left I'd still have the monthly work schedule in my mind. It requires discipline/distraction to free yourself!
- hereforphone 5y agoThis would be the point where I quit and find another job.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Victerius 5y agoIf you work remotely, there's a 100% chance you're already being monitored without your consent. It doesn't matter if you work for FAANG, a startup, or a government. And, no, you won't be able to find an alternative employer that offers remote work and doesn't monitor you. An employer can also deny that they're monitoring you, and there's nothing you can do about it.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoCould you be less cryptic, please?
- _joel 5y agoWhat if you own the equipment you work remotely on and have not installed anything (inbuilt OS VPN doesn't count)?
- altdataseller 5y agoThere’s different levels of monitoring. Having a webcam so your every movement can be seen is drastically different than monitoring whether you have moved your mouse, or are online (ie your Slack status) The first would be a non-starter for me and I would quit if that was done. The latter, I would probably be OK with.
- tehjoker 5y agoA great thing to unionize over. If you just quit your job eventually the equilibrium of the system will probably result in most jobs having this surveillance over time. You need to fight it directly with coordinated work stoppages. The reason the system will equilibriate is that at first you'll have your pick of many more jobs. However, certain employers at the margins try it first, then more prestigious ones that keep their employees there with golden handcuffs. Then the rest follow the prestigious ones until there are few jobs without it and your individualist strategy has no where to turn.
- throwoutway 5y agoCan we just unionize against _this one topic_ and not the other baggage that unions bring?
- tehjoker 5y agoI think you'll find that unions are defined as democratic organizations of workers and so they will be whatever you and your colleagues want them to be. There is also a legal framework established to keep labor peace, but you don't have to be peaceful (in the sense of not resisting) if you don't want to.
- gadflyinyoureye 5y agoSomething that gets lost in the US is that the Union is made up of members. Many Americans appear to have the idea that the Union is the HR department for the employees. As a result, members often stop attending meetings, advocating for policies, etc. The unions devolve into a corrupt body because the lax democratic oversight allows a populist leader to provide just enough bread and circus to member while lining his or her own pocket.
- BrazzVuvuzela 5y agoThe problem union advocates in America have is whenever things don't go their way, they immediately resort to calling the workers idiots. The workers aren't idiots. When they perceive that unions aren't listening to them, it's usually because that's true. The union corruption and contempt for workers is the cause, not the consequence, of workers giving up on unions.
- beeskneecaps 5y agoMy Solution: artists tape for covering the webcam and the Jiggler to randomize my mouse movement: https://github.com/bhaller/Jiggler https://github.com/bhaller/Jiggler
- brazzledazzle 5y agoIf they can install monitoring software on your client they can see what software you’re running, what its hash is, what special permissions it has and what api calls it’s making. If this is something you need to do I would recommend you accomplish it outside of the computer.
- theshrike79 5y agoThis would be the perfect project for a simple Arduino board connected to USB pretending to be a mouse and/or keyboard. Add an on/off switch and you can step away any time you want. The best choice would be to have it open Notepad and type "All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy" over and over again.
- rei_ayanami 5y agoDevilish
- m-i-l 5y agoThat's one of the reasons why, according to a friend of a friend, those in the know prefer hardware mouse jigglers to software mouse jigglers. It seems to have spawned a whole new industry, with devices like the Wee Shoogle: https://www.weeshoogle.com/ https://www.weeshoogle.com/ . Edit: It seems there's a wikipedia page about this too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mouse_jiggler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mouse_jiggler
- slickdork 5y agoI put my work computer on it's own vlan this week, no rules to talk to anything else in the network. I keep the laptop closed so the camera doesn't catch anything ether. Really just peace of mind things. I wouldn't be surprised if there's some sort of productivity software installed on my work laptop that I'm too lazy to investigate. It's their computer, they can do what they want with it. If a manager ever talks to me about metrics vs output, I'll likely just not listen. The advantage of being skilled labor, I guess, is you kind of make your own rules as long as you meet goals. This situation is much more dire for upcoming generations who work low level jobs like the service desk, where metrics are absolutely hammered and abused by bad managers. I can see this breeding a generation of tech workers who have ptsd about 'not being productive', which leads to burn out before they even get to a level where being monitored stops being relevant.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoThis is mostly my sentiment. They can monitor the laptop they provide. I am mildly concerned about 'company' attempting to monitor wifi traffic, which I use for other things, but not enough to setup its own vlan ( although I will admit that I am debating it ). In my case it helps that my current boss is not into simple metrics and goes out of his way to be fair and transparent, but not everyone is so lucky. I still remember one of previous bosses, who wanted me to track average processed cases and wanted to make sure they did not know what is being measured. What I quickly learned is that people are not idiots and figure out what is being rewarded even if they are not explicitly told.
- xyzzy_plugh 5y agoIf you work for an employer that has rolled some monitoring service out, or is considering it, and you are in a place of power or privilege to influence that decision: do so. Resist the temptation. Just say no. I've yet to hear a legitimate argument for monitoring employees against their will. If there's a security concern, patch it another way. There's always another way.
- 0xB31B1B 5y agoI’m a remote team manager and I’ve considered putting tracking software on low performers computers, and have not gone through with it yet. I’m super happy to put in the time to coach someone who is trying to make it work but if they’re putting in 2 hrs/day on a remote job and not making the cut it’s not worth my effort to try to coach them out of that.
- xyzzy_plugh 5y agoWhy do you need the tracking software to tell you what you already know? Have you considered talking to them and asking them? If you're looking to catch people in a lie, there are easier ways than installing spyware.
- black_13 5y agoThat you would consider this. Maybe you are the problem?
- smabie 5y agoThen just find someone better? I kinda doubt monitoring low performers will suddenly turn them into high performers
- _zzaw 5y agoAnd it’ll encourage the high performers to look elsewhere as soon as they learn their boss is doing creepy stuff like installing spyware on their machines. I think a lot of these “solutions” are rooted in the fact that managers—like the spyware-considering person above—are genuinely not good at interacting with other people. This person already knows who’s not getting work done, but for some reason isn’t comfortable having a direct conversation about it. “You’re not meeting your goals, and you don’t seem to be improving, so I think you should find another job” is a more mature, professional way of addressing the problem than surreptitiously collecting statistics on how much time your employees spend in the toilet. Keeping in mind who I’m talking to here, I think a far better approach would be to step away from the tools and data-mining for a moment and deal with people like people, not machines.
- black_13 5y agoWhat bothers me about him is how i see his behavior becoming a norm in places that are not startups. My managers are some little version of him but luckily the company has in place some standards of behavior.
- MrWiffles 5y agoYou want to monitor me in my home? Then you fucking PAY. MY. RENT.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments or fulminate, regardless of wrong something is or you feel it is. Maybe you don't owe nosy employers better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- MrWiffles 5y agoYou're right, and I apologize. I just got really pissed off at this and didn't think before I hit the button, so I'm going to own my mistake here and fully admit that's on me. I'm sorry about that, folks. If there was a delete button on my comment here I'd hit it, but I don't see one. Feel free to delete this entire "thread" (my comment itself and these replies) if you like, I don't mind at all.
- dang 5y agoAppreciated! We don't need to delete anything. The important thing is just to course-correct for the future. We're all learning here.
- DangIsSoSilly 5y agoOh Noes! A curse word! Solution: Monitor every single comment with a curse word! Wow, Dang, you must be a busy zir Here-- I found another use of the "f" word here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29588054 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29588054 Time to go rebuke them! Yayyy, dang has a life purpose everyone! come look!! pats dang on the back you're doing such important work bud!
- dang 5y agoYou know we don't give a fuck about swearing right? https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20bowdler&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- justusw 5y agoThat’s just plain creepy. Germany had many cases of super market and drug store chains secretly spying on their employees and they were rightfully punished for their practices. https://www.focus.de/finanzen/karriere/berufsleben/spitzel-vorwuerfe-gegen-schlecker-tochter-datenschutz_id_1933417.html https://www.focus.de/finanzen/karriere/berufsleben/spitzel-v... (2013)
- Tomte 5y agoSupermarkets and drug stores are the worst. Remember when one of them made menstruating employees wear arm bands, in order to make it obvious for the supervisor that this employee is entitled to additional bathroom breaks? https://www.theguardian.com/business/2004/sep/05/theobserver.observerbusiness https://www.theguardian.com/business/2004/sep/05/theobserver...
- timemachine 5y agoThis sounds so much more difficult and costly than have qualified managers.
- nexuist 5y agoIMO this doesn't go away until we get rid of the 8 hour model. Stop caring about how much time (salaried) people are spending at work. If workers participate in meetings, remain reachable during the work day, and meet deadlines, why does it matter if they're on their work laptop for 30 minutes or 8 hours? OTOH, this monitoring stuff makes sense for hourly paid jobs where the employee has to deliver a certain amount of completed items per hour. But that's the exception, not the norm.
- pdonis 5y ago> this monitoring stuff makes sense for hourly paid jobs where the employee has to deliver a certain amount of completed items per hour. Couldn't you just monitor that deliverable directly? Why would you have to monitor anything else?
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoYeah, it probably makes sense when there isn't an output product, like minding the counter - pay for an hour of time, doesn't really matter if you ring up 100 customers or the store is dead and you literally get no customers.
- cryptica 5y agoI've observed this issue over and over at a dozen tech companies I worked for. They're not interested in deliverables IMO, they're interested in employee head count and total compliance.
- Verdex 5y agoYeah, I've noticed something similar. If feels to me kind of like everyone who has people working below them are interested in having a story that prevents them from being fired if something goes wrong. "Hey, I had everyone working 50 hour weeks. So it clearly wasn't my fault." Because random events can make things go wrong at any time, there's always a pressure to have all your ducks in a row. Apparently, just saying your employees were working a bunch of hours and having time sheets to back you up isn't enough proof for some people. Enter employee monitoring software. Prove to your bosses that you can't be fired because you made a bunch of people jiggle a mouse for 8 hours.
- emersonrsantos 5y agoLook out for companies using Hubstaff or similar tools.
- throwaway_2009 5y agoThere's a big rise in, well, everyone asking everyone to do stuff. People keep asking me to stand inside little circles, put things on my face, walk in specific directions, etc. The more you acquiesce to silly stuff, the more it happens.
- BarryMilo 5y agoAre you equating following safety measures with docility?
- Havoc 5y agoSeen this a lot on the internet lately. Usually followed by some crazy extrapolation along the lines of allow the small restrictions and before you know it bam fascism
- throwaway_2009 5y agoI'm equating standing on little circles and walking in proscribed ways with docility, yes. They are not safety measures, they're some bizarre form of religious ritual / cargo cult like behaviour. Motorcycle riders don't wear little pin badges for good luck, tape toilet rolls to their knees, or simply look at and polish the bike, they wear real protective gear, practice evasive maneuvers, look for escape routes, etc. It's not at all "safe" to run around like a headless chicken panicking for years on end; it's a mental disorder. Intelligent people owe it to themselves and others to protect them from maladaptive thinking and help them to develop mechanisms for operating normally in society.
- tomrod 5y agoInteresting. Things monitored and systematically captured can often be translated into ML models. What do you think? Is this how white collar workers become more fully outsourced via automation, as an unintended side effect?
- justinlloyd 5y agoMy previous job used MS Teams with that "productivity dashboard" built in to it. I reported to multiple people within the organization. One of those people was adamant about the team being signed in and available at precisely 9AM PST and he loved his dashboard metrics. And whilst I spoke with this particular manager about this issue, he wouldn't budge on the subject and unfortunately wielded a bit too much political power to be routed around. To sign in to MS Teams at the company you needed to run a 2FA app from your phone to get the code that would let you log in. I wrote a Python script that ran on a Raspberry Pi, that would pull the 2FA code from an Android emulator running on another machine running the 2FA app, and then the script would paste the 2FA code in to MS Teams running on the corporate laptop using a USB keyboard/mouse h/w emulator. Every morning my machine dutifully booted up, logged in, signed in at precisely 9AM and made sure it showed I was available and active throughout the day until it was "time to go home." The company overall was pretty decent, but unfortunately there are toxic managers and little Napoleons everywhere.
- travisgriggs 5y agoNice. If you can automate the observation, you can automate your observance of the observation. The symmetry is great. It’s even kind of poetic, because the more creative type of person who is less valued as a drone is the type of person to extend the effort to do this, whereas the clock-in-clock-out type with less investment and motivation is less likely. Sort of a “if you’re clever/motivated enough to end run it, your clever enough to not need this anyway.”
- theshrike79 5y ago> If you can automate the observation, you can automate your observance of the observation. The symmetry is great. Never measure the productivity of engineers with plain numbers. They will just take it as a challenge on how to optimise for that particular measurement.
- wayoutthere 5y agoNot even engineers; this is true of all business. Any metric defined quickly becomes a goal whether it was intended to or not. Once you attach incentives to the metric, it will be focused on to the exclusion of everything else.
- CyanLite2 5y agoBig legal issues for the video/audio monitoring. That's essentially wiretapping. Also other data privacy issue if your housemate also works from home in an industry like financial or healthcare and has to routinely discuss customer/patient information.
- vlunkr 5y agoIt must be incredibly anxiety-inducing to have a camera in your own home that someone else could be looking through. And I thought the horror stories about at-home test proctoring were bad.
- rpmisms 5y agoBig big no-go for me. The only metric you get from me is my performance and interaction with colleagues. Those are what matter to the company, anything else is an ego trip.
- filoeleven 5y agoIf you want to monitor my work PC usage, you also need to take into account my unbidden shower-time work insights. And my countless 3 AM waking work thoughts. And the dreams I’ve had about my job that are really hard to quantify, but which played a role in the solutions I have provided. And all the outside-of-work time spent exploring and evaluating the ideas I came across from just being interested in the state of the art. And what I learned from building hobby projects that put those ideas to the test with things that nobody cares about except for me, instead of trying them out for the first time on the company’s flagship product. And. You also need to account for all the time I had nothing to do because I wasn’t allowed to proceed since I was waiting for the Product Owners to approve the development effort, and they rescheduled the meeting four times. You need to account for the times when I asked for more work and wasn’t given any for three days, and was told to “just be available.” You need to account for when my workspace broke when someone in Security blocked ALL of eclipse.org because “you can’t trust that open source stuff,” and your sanctioned resolution process is slower than a tortoise on quaaludes. You need to account for choosing to band-aid your tech debt until even the scion of [Rube Goldberg, Frankenstein’s Monster, IE11’s Quirks Mode, accidental dynamic scope, the Pennsylvania Lottery] told you that the latest “feature” would break stuff with 100% confidence, and you still went for it. I stopped putting sugar in my coffee and I think it might be affecting my outlook.
- newusertoday 5y agodon't give them ideas, you don't want them to start monitoring your showers and dreams too :-)
- JetAlone 5y agoTell me about it... My own experience with forced fun and creepy contests that encroach on free time has left me in a state where I wouldn't be shocked if a company one day didn't introduce a "dream tracker system" where employees wear electrodes at night and are expected to compete for the scientifically recommended amount and kind of sleep, to drive down premiums.
- coldtea 5y ago
- derwiki 5y ago> Everything about their employees is monitored and tracked, down to individual finger and eye movements, to prevent waste and track performance. All emails that are sent out include an estimate of how long they should take to read. Go to fast, you get scolded for not paying attention. Go too slow, you get scolded for inefficiency. Get it just right? You get scolded for being a smartass. —- Snowcrash
- jl6 5y ago“Monitoring” covers many things, some more concerning than others. Activating the camera or mic without consent? Yeah, that’s bad. What about recording which websites are visited on a work device? Not so unreasonable. Taking screenshots of desktops at random intervals? Could be a huge liability if you capture some confidential information and the screenshots go into an unmanaged data dump.
- theshrike79 5y ago> Taking screenshots of desktops at random intervals? Could be a huge liability if you capture some confidential information and the screenshots go into an unmanaged data dump. I'd just have a fully naked picture of myself in the corner of my screen at all times :D
- corobo 5y ago> Activating the camera or mic without consent? Creepy > What about recording which websites are visited on a work device? Creepy > Taking screenshots of desktops at random intervals? Creepy Don't hire people if you don't trust people. Monitor their output not their process
- TecoAndJix 5y agoLogging DNS traffic is valuable during a security investigation. Depending on your company’s acceptable use policy, no one cares that you are on Reddit. Monitoring Remote Desktop sessions either by random interval screenshots or screen recording is valuable when you have vendors/contractors connecting to your net. IMO, this is unacceptable for normal employee workstations. Turning on the mic or webcam is a major violation of privacy. If your doing something SO important/secret/critical that you need to monitor the person doing it you should not be working remotely to begin with.
- corobo 5y agoI'm not using employer provided DNS servers either haha
- 5y ago
- usrbinbash 5y agoWell dear companies, it's really simple: for _, e := range employees { if e.surveillance && (e.type == "engineer" || e.hasOptions()) { hr.taskQueue.insert(hrTask{ type: "look for employee (" + e.type + ")", why: "existing employee likely to leave"}) } }
- DrBazza 5y ago"There's been a big rise in monitoring workers at home" Which operating systems can the monitoring be installed on? I understand the principle of wanting to ensure that if you pay someone to do 9-5, they actually do it, but in practice, "nicer" employers get more from their employees by not being complete muppets. There is of course always one or two employees that spoil it for the rest, but intrusive monitoring is only one obnoxious way of detecting under performers. Also, this sort of monitoring just reminds me of horrible stuff like Blizzard's "Warden", and Sony's root kit (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootkit_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootk...).
- kwhitefoot 5y agoI think what is described in the article would be illegal here in Norway. Quite possibly illegal in the office too, not just the home.
- vladak 5y agoIncidentally: after working from home since the start of the pandemics, I feel the need to actually monitor myself as I often lose track of my working hours and I have a suspicion that I work longer hours than previously. Related to that, less amount of movement/exercise. My plan is to monitor the situation with simple Raspberry Pi zero based project - add a current sensor (to sense if my main display is on/off) and a distance sensor (to see if my standing desk is up/down), store the data in local time series database and present in local Grafana (no way I am going to put this outside my home network) with the possibility of alerting via PagerDuty.
- tluyben2 5y agoThat would probably be the fastest way of making me quit.
- Kharvok 5y agoI refuse to place monitoring software on any company device unless there is an open HR case corresponding to a specific issue. I'll die on that hill.
- lmilcin 5y agoMonitoring your employees' work at their computer is losers game. This only works for menial jobs where you can actually see the work happening, the widgets being cranked. But even in a job as simple as callcenter operator you can have people who treat your customers well and you can have people who are there to just get as many calls as possible to get their stats for the day. You can't tell that by looking at time spent and number of calls served. For people who are supposed to organise their work, think through plans, etc. the work does not happen in the computer, it happens in peoples' hearts and minds. I know a lot of people who spend their entire days with busy work providing no value to the company, because they are only interested in continuing their employment. It is stupid because it is saying "I can't evaluate the value you provide but at least I am going to make sure you pay the costs (in time spent at the computer)" My company has very simple vacation policy -- take as much vacation as you want. Come back when you feel fresh and ready to something great. Which makes me want to figure out how to actually be more productive.
- fart32 5y agoA colleague at the company I worked for was asked to explore available options regarding this matter. It simply didn't occur to him that this was supposed to be kept in secret, so pretty much everyone knew about this being planned, which turned out to stop this idea before it has been implemented. Later, I was asked to implement some metrics in our in-house ERP, which would tell the management exactly at which time what employee was doing what - think of a same level of insight an Apache access log would give you. This was one of the few times I intentionally obstructed and eventually blocked this request. There were ways to measure performance anyway, I just refused the idea of live-monitoring.
- solididiot 5y agoIs there anything good that humanity did not turn to shite given enough time? I mean we could very well work half the hours and be as rich and have zero unemployment but heck no. We need to have 10% or more unemployment rates and work our a$$es off. Same thing with remote working. It was a dream that came true and in record time turned to a maze of horror rooms. Dunno. I guess do not work for such companies (if you can find something better anyway).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TrispusAttucks 5y ago“The telescreen received and transmitted simultaneously. Any sound that Winston made, above the level of a very low whisper, would be picked up by it; moreover, so long as he remained within the field of vision which the metal plaque commanded, he could be seen as well as heard. There was, of course, no way of knowing whether you were being watched at any given moment.” - George Orwell, '1984'.
- blablabla123 5y agoIMHO experienced devs should leave places like this or demand change - others might not be able to move so easily and companies cannot afford working only with unexperienced staff.
- mikotodomo 5y agoWTF? Imagine some old creep, hyper-focused on worker productivity, constantly watches your camera, and you having no way of knowing when, and your daughters run around the house half naked. They might shower and put on a towel and go across the house to get something, and the towel might slip off which normally won't be an issue. Even if you tell them there is a camera, how often to children take abstract instructions seriously? And you might move / reposition the camera and forget to tell them about it.
- undersuit 5y agoThe last 4 years I've been following TransparentBusiness as they lobby state legislatures to mandate the use of their tracking software on state employees. Only Louisiana has picked it up so far, but that was before covid. 2023 is going to be the the year when I predict a bunch of Republican led state legislatures start accepting the intrusion into their worker's privacy at the cost of tax payer money and trust. https://transparentbusiness.com/news/louisiana.html https://transparentbusiness.com/news/louisiana.html
- twirlock 5y agoProbably 50% of the reason I withdrew from the workforce is because I'm sick of shit like this. Cool, you're spying on me, so now wtf is your dumb ass actually going to do with that info? (Drive me to just quit, that's what.)
- 908B64B197 5y agoStory time I suppose (from a former colleague). Managers were looking at buying a monitoring tool for a dev team. Somehow dev lead was included in the meeting. Vendor comes in, does his pitch. Dev leads pulls the manager aside and tells him "we already have a monitoring tool installed called git". Non-technical manager is intrigued so dev leads pulls out a GUI front-end for git and shows the commit history. "You can see who added what to the codebase and when" "Neat. How much does it costs us?" "Nothing. It comes with the tool! How much are they trying to charge us for this monitoring software?" "They want to schedule a separate call for pricing..." We all know git metrics are pointless, apparently management was satisfied to know that they were collecting metrics and could use them if they wanted to (and they never bothered with it).