11 ms·
Design evolution of the Windows control panel
- kaetemi 5y agoClassic view with classic icon arrangement is still the easiest to find things. Mostly, I guess, because the organisation of things doesn't change every other version, or goes to hide under a different vaguely named subsection every so often. The fact that Updates are under Security, and not under Apps does say something about Windows, though...
- bee_rider 5y agoEh, updates and security go hand-in-hand. I'd say it would be best to completely split it out. Updates should just contain security update and be mandatory. Some other thing (call them upgrades) should contain new features and be optional.
- hulitu 5y agoThis is, unfortunately, for a lot of OSs not true. Windows and Android for example combine security patches with normal updates which introduce new bugs.
- nwah1 5y agoLeft off Windows 11. The new one is the most logical one yet. Don't like that much about Windows 11, but the control panel is improved.
- tech-historian 5y agoIt's on my todo list - thanks for stopping by the website!
- LeoPanthera 5y agoAre there still two separate ones? A "modern" one and a "classic" one? What frustrates me about Windows 10 is that each one has settings which are exclusive to it, so you always need both, and never know where to look.
- im_down_w_otp 5y agoIf there wasn't a search function, I'd absolutely never figure out where anything is in there in Windows 10. It's an absolute mess.
- Shared404 5y agoLuckily it's one of the few things that actually work well in my experience.
- JonathonW 5y agoWindows 11 still leaves a few things in the legacy Control Panel, but there's less that's only accessible there than there was in Windows 10, and every recent dev channel build has moved more things into the modern Settings app. More importantly, they've gotten pretty good about linking into legacy Control Panel applets from the modern settings app-- so, even if a setting hasn't been migrated yet, you should be able to find a link to it in a logical place from the new Settings app. That's not new in Windows 11 (Windows 10 is pretty good about it too, for the most part), but the Settings reorganization in Windows 11 helped this along a bit.
- wruza 5y agoW10 wasn’t pretty good at it, and something tells me I wouldn’t find my relevant settings quickly in 11 either. Settings reorganization never helped, I know this because never heard from my non-power-user friends or relatives “oh, I just went to settings and set it up myself, so convenient” even for easy things. It’s always arcane don’t touch it thing for them, every release. And every power user I know basically said “I can’t find shit after every damn release, why the fuck they do that every time???”.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoThere always will be because if you removed it people would freak out. Even though there are barely any settings left that you need to go there for.
- nwmcsween 5y agoI dislike windows 11 UIs, while it is pretty it ruins super fast drilling down of information
- dleslie 5y agoHow many clicks does it take to find and change your DNS?
- lisnake 5y agoThree clicks to get from the root of the settings app to DNS assignment window
- shp0ngle 5y agoI know people sometimes take Windows XP as a peak of Windows design, but damn, I always hated the "simplified" control panel view. It was never what to do there. Still better than the stupid dog when trying to search files.
- alok-g 5y agoWhy does Windows not have settings for touchscreens? (It has for touchpads.)
- TrianguloY 5y agoI remember when they changed (in Spanish) the "Agregar o quitar programas" (add or remove programs) to "Programas y características" (programs and features). Not only was the new name less descriptive and harder to search, but it also made that setting to no longer appear as one of the first icons (they are sorted alphabetically). I'm still mad about that change, and to this day I still take a couple failed attempts to find it.
- gjvc 5y agoWindows 2000 was clearly the peak in this article, and (as a whole system) it did feel like it at the time. (I do wish it had included ClearType though...)
- gjvc 5y ago(wish #2) ...and that it had been available in a 64-bit version.
- canadaduane 5y agoAfter Windows XP I always felt like they were hiding the actual control panel from me, and I no longer felt in control.
- Sindisil 5y agoThey were (and are) and, to an increasing degree, you are not.
- kumarvvr 5y agoFor me, it was Windows 7.
- throaway46546 5y agoFor me, it's the McChicken.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 5y agoSame here. One thing I also felt about Windows 2000 is that it was designed for professionals. Windows XP, in my mind, made compromises to appeal to a wider swath of consumers.
- voidfunc 5y agoWhile I agree, Id also argue virtually every posters opinion on HN about design of the Windows CP is useless. Most of us are power users and it we are not power users we are incredibly opinionated about some UX stuff.
- claviska 5y agoMy first PC had Windows 3.1 and I very vividly remember the buttons, the menus, and many of the icons. In a way, they still inspire me to this day. In fact, I themed a Shoelace button based on 3.1 a few months ago. https://codepen.io/claviska/details/zYwgyEO https://codepen.io/claviska/details/zYwgyEO
- tech-historian 5y agoHey, my son and I run this site. Cool to see it here. Thanks for stopping by!
- russelldjimmy 5y agoThanks for your work! Just uncovered a gem.
- tech-historian 5y agoAppreciate it, thank you!
- pmontra 5y agoWell done. To improve on it you should add screenshots of the internal dialogs. I'm always pissed off by those non resizable windows that never changed since 20+ years ago. They were large enough back then but they require a magnifying lens on our screens now. And not being able to read all the content of text input boxes because they are too narrow? It's a common problem in many MicroSoft programs. The inner dialogs of Task Scheduler are the ones I'm running into more often.
- pjerem 5y agoHo, I just thought it was some sort of random blog post then I saw your comment. Great website ! Thank you for the memories. May I suggest you to add links to archive.org downloads where the software you show is available ?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tech-historian 5y agoGreat suggestion, thanks!
- jaclaz 5y agoThanks for the nice site/review. As a side note somehow (and as I see it) "evolution" has a positive connotation, i.e. an evolution step brings something that is seen as "better", and unfortunately, in the case of Windows Control Panel, this is very hard to state. By reading the title only I had the at first sight impression of the article being some form of MS fanboysm. Something like "How the Windows Control Panel design changed over 36 years" would IMHO be more neutral.
- FridayoLeary 5y agoI have a vague memory of feeling slightly cheated the first time i clicked on the XP control panel. I saw shiny icons hiding plain, (ugly?), mundane texts. I felt they were spending more time on the pretty and clever button image, and less effort on the options behind it.
- unnouinceput 5y agoI prefer the "God mode" one, on all versions of Windows.
- transfire 5y agoAm I the only one who actually liked what M$ was doing with Windows 8?
- kindly_fo 5y agoAt least they were trying and had some vision.
- magarnicle 5y agoNah, I liked it to. Having a hybrid tablet (Asus Transformer) helped, I think.
- pjmlp 5y agoNo, I was a beliver on WinRT as merge for COM/.NET world, .NET Native as it should have always been and C++/CX as Microsoft finally getting the point of C++ Builder. They just borked the whole execution and burned the bridges that many of us had, with the multiple rewrites since Windows 8 came to be, dropping support for devices and finally dropping even .NET Native and C++/CX. The irony is that Windows 11 is so rushed out, that they needed to still make use of UWP for the new UI regardless of WinUI 3.0 marketing.
- takk309 5y agoThe windows 98 one brought back some serious memories! That was when I first started to really dig into computers and started to want to control and change everything I could.
- aasasd 5y agoThis could be much more interesting if it included shots of the various windows listed in the panel, and perhaps also the ‘advanced’ interfaces available since Win2000 (iirc)—opened via ‘properties’ on the ‘My computer’ icon, though I think it's also in the panel somewhere. For me, the control panel is the litmus test of the OS interface—partly because usually it's where the OS has the most of its interface, while the rest is a bunch of bars and menus. Compare e.g. Gnome's panel to KDE's panel, at least around KDE 4 (last I've tried it): Gnome's is an example of austerity lifted from OSX, while KDE went full-in on tree-lists of dozens of pages of settings. So: in Windows 7's control panel I've counted ten different kinds of windows—with ten somewhat different approaches to their design. Some of the widgets in there aren't used anywhere else in the OS. This only includes MS' own built-in settings windows—no third-party stuff, which frequently also has custom one-off looks and widgets. And apparently, things became even worse in Win 8 or 10, with half-assed attempts at a redesign.
- CptMauli 5y agoIt's pretty simple, they are all bad, aren't they? Especially all the network configuration variants went from bad to worse over the time.
- beardedscotsman 5y agoI was involved in part with the Windows 8 control panel refresh. What a nightmare it was working with that team. There was just no care for actually improving user experience, everything was shoehorned into the modern ui mainly as a push for ARM windows devices which were so slow they just never took off. MS wanted to force an enclosed ecosystem like apple iOS, but just didn’t have the hardware to make it happen. I remember one story asking why it was so difficult to manage switching to Bluetooth speakers for the surface which was still somewhat secret at MS at the time only to be told that they did follow up with my question and only 0.005% of users ever used Bluetooth speakers with windows and it wasn’t a priority. (Obviously the number is t right, but it was something utterly tiny)
- atoav 5y ago> only 0.005% of users ever used Bluetooth speakers successfully? How many tried? This can btw. be an issue with telemetry: if people don't manage to do something, maybe you will never know.
- mattlondon 5y agoThis is where a "funnel" approach can be useful. E.g. you want to measure people on their way to feature X, so you measure the steps before feature X too and see how far down the funnel people get. When you start to see people going in loops or doing the same things over and over but not quite reaching the destination, then you know you have UX issues. Of course this is good only for "near misses" - you may have users who don't even know where to start - that is harder to identify.
- jcelerier 5y agoAnecdotally, I don't remember ever meeting anyone who even talked about entertaining the thought of using Bluetooth speakers on win32
- causi 5y agoI tried using bluetooth speakers with Windows. It was fucking atrocious because Windows makes zero effort to compensate for bluetooth lag. Watch a video file or a Youtube video on Android and it inserts a split second of delay into the stream so the video and audio sync up. Windows does nothing of the sort, and it feels like you're watching a dubbed foreign language film.
- alkonaut 5y agoThe old one that people praise isn't that good. It does all the things it needs to, but it uses eight layers of popup dialogs, it works poorly at DPI's over 150% and so on and so forth. Basically, a 2005 Windows UI is mostly a bad windows UI. The proper solution would have been to refresh the old one. Make a full-featured control panel that uses just slightly more modern UI paradigms and technologies. And with zero weird extension points for third parties. But no, instead we get half the controlpanel made into a usless minimalist web design look, and the other half is still the original. I don't know what parts of the control panel must remain for backwards compatibility (with what!?) or why someone even thought it was a good idea to have extensibility points that become a nightmare of compatibility of maintenance. Or why it's apparently more work to rewrite a single control panel page than it is to ship a whole major release of Office. But more importantly, I don't care.
- qalmakka 5y agoYeah Windows UI really took a turn for the worse with Windows XP. People now praise it mostly due to a nostalgia factor, but when it came out its UI was derided due to resembling something out of a Fisher Price toy. Still given that it finally brought NT to a mass of people accustomed to an interior OS, it was a massive improvement.
- mschuster91 5y ago> I don't know what parts of the control panel must remain for backwards compatibility (with what!?) Because programs and drivers can and did ship their own control panels, it's fairly easy (https://www.codeproject.com/Articles/29264/Control-Panel-Applets-for-everyone https://www.codeproject.com/Articles/29264/Control-Panel-App...). Java comes to my mind, as did some virus scanners, and drivers for all kinds of hardware - and the latter is the key why MS keeps the architecture in place, they take backwards compatibility extremely serious, to the extent you can (generally) use Windows 95-era games and other software on a Windows 10 machine! The other part is that there is an utterly absurd amount of things that can be configured in Windows, with a lot of ways to do so: text-based configuration files on the disk (e.g. /etc/hosts), registry settings, group policies that are mapped to registry settings, classic control panel applets, new control panel applets, the whole mess that is the bootloader config... all of this needs serious effort to re-organize, for something that 99% of end-users won't ever touch. And that explains why there is such a split: the stuff that end users regularly need (display resolution, wallpapers, audio, ...) is in the new crap look, and the stuff that even nerds rarely touch (user-wide environment variables) is in the old school CPL applets.
- ale42 5y agoTry _editing_ an existing WiFi Enterprise profile with Windows 10? Looks like they dropped all links to arrive to the right windows in the classic control panel, and there's no way of doing that with the horrible minimalistic modern UI that has less settings than you can find on a usual smartphone...
- clavicat 5y agoThe control panel was solved, so to speak, once they added a search interface. It doesn’t matter how complicated the hierarchy of modules is if what you want is only a search away. Only Microsoft could unsolve a solved problem by segregating the settings into two paradigms, neither of which is a superset of the other. Even the duplicated functionalities are not equivalent—the list of programs you can uninstall with the new UI is not the same as old UI. No sane person would ever intend to engineer this outcome, but it’s what we get. Very strange how that can happen.
- bob1029 5y agoThis is what happens when you have too many chefs in the same design kitchen. Microsoft really could use some product/UX zealot in the driver seat for a while. They should also work on reducing the latency of their products in general... Everything feels like laggy trash now. Someone should do a study on stress levels between windows XP and windows 11 user groups for basic daily office tasks and then throw it into the boardroom.
- vardump 5y ago"Microsoft really could use some product/UX zealot in the driver seat for a while." I hate to say this, but I think it would just result yet another UX camp in the system. The weight of legacy is heavy. To clean up the UI mess, Microsoft would need to heavily deprecate supported APIs and conventions, and I don't think that's going to happen.
- pulse7 5y agoBackwards compatibility is pure gold and is worth more than any new trend...
- usrusr 5y agoYet another camp is the most likely outcome, but it could be avoided by declaring a winner. But that's certainly the approach they always try, yet it never works. Because that declared winner always turns out to be yet another superficial subset full of broken promises. And this declared but failing winner is always the latest incarnation. What they have never tried: going back to the oldest and extending that with new additions. There are always far fewer new additions than the backlog of existing settings that would have to be ported to the latest variation, doing the reverse, properly, wouldn't be that hard.
- dusted 5y agoWindows 2000 control panel was perfect. I'd take pretty much any of the interfaces over the abominiation that is windows 10 control panel. It's form over function so hard it hurts, in a place where function is all I want. I'm not on a "journey" or having an "experience" or whatever they're aiming for. I just want to change a setting, so show me ALL the settings programs, RIGHT NOW. It's laughable how much you need to click on random stuff to see where stuff may be hiding.. Search is great, if you can remember what it's called, but often, I can't and I need to look through the options to be reminded.
- AndyJames 5y agoIMHO Windows XP classic view was the best from what Windows offered. To be fair, every design between Windows 95 and XP classic view was good. Icon view was Windows oldschool design that just worked. They could add categories, kind of like OSX did at some point and just leave at that.
- johnday 5y agoOne of my most-used muscle memories is Win+R -> "control". Works even as far as Windows 11 and is still the most effective way to make changes happen on a Windows PC.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoWindows 2000 was something of a local maximum of UI. I contend you simply can't do much better without completely changing the paradigm. While the underpinnings of Windows have improved since then, the UI only continues to go backwards and it's a real shame.
- bni 5y agoI agree about Windows 2000, it was the pinnacle of Windows UI. The font, buttons and how everything is spaced is just perfect. I wish we could have a minimalistic Windows, that have this UI. Just x3, x4 integer scaling so it can display on modern screens. No crapware included by default. And then you download software you need form the net, like browsers, mailclient, torrent client, games, or what ever you need.
- 2ion 5y agoI came to dislike the control panel interface on Windows because it is disjunct from management console snapins and does a bad job at reconiling administrative/power user access knobs with basic computer controls. The control panel does not adapt to the user level / user role (Administrator, plain user) well enough. You have to switch between control panel (including "modernized" network controls), advanced properties dialogs (interesting network settings, classic style), and msc snapins for diskmanagement, event viewing, task and device management in order to get things done. On top of that gpedit is not even included in the default compmgmt.msc. Oh and these days add powershell scripts on top. Oh and regedit. One more issue is that they kept "evolving" the design (classic, settings view, etc) without retiring previous interfaces. Now you have access to everything and you keep wondering how the controls and components all interact. Almost as catastrophic as explorer.exe and "shell" integrations, resulting in the most laggy explorer.exe yet.
- qwerty456127 5y agoIt's degradation, not evolution. Windows 3.11 - 98 control panels were the best. If only they had built-in parameter search option (kind of like VLC's settings advanced view) they would be perfect. All the GUIs should have been searchable by the way, so sad Ubuntu's Unity is dead.
- ChoGGi 5y agoMy favourite part of the windows 10 Settings is it needing Explorer to be the shell. I have to close my shell and run Explorer to be able to open it. Thanks Microsoft
- sha-3 5y agoWhere is the Windows 11 control panel? Does it even have one?
- jcranberry 5y agoI think the control panel is fine. You can search for all the functionality you need through the start menu search bar so I rarely have to use it directly but when I do it's perfectly usable. I also found windows 11 to be an improvement.
- ___q 5y agoHas MS announced plans to port the Hotdog Stand theme to W11?
- JoBrad 5y agoI had completely forgotten about wireless link. Tried it with my Sony Walkman phone once. I was able to transfer a presentation to my phone via infrared, then use my phone to show (and control) the presentation in my classroom. It was one of the most magical things I’ve probably ever done.