21 ms·
Facing housing crisis, L.A. voters back duplexes in single-family neighborhoods
- seibelj 5y agoI live in Jamaica Plain, a neighborhood of Boston, Massachusetts. Nearly every single home is multi-family, and the single families that do exist are usually $2 million and up. Take a stroll down one of our streets https://www.google.com/maps/@42.3130357,-71.1188873,3a,75y,175.75h,76.83t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sCjBDFfdRrZi4VuQG1-fVZw!2e0!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@42.3130357,-71.1188873,3a,75y,1... It is dense, walkable, and extremely beautiful. There is no reason every neighborhood with duplexes has to look like cookie cutter sprawl that makes people unhappy.
- HNTA_1 5y agoThat just looks like many older, low density suburbs (single family homes with some duplexes and ADUs sprinkled in) all across the US (especially older suburbs in the South). >It is dense It's absolutely not dense, probably less dense than newer suburbs with smaller lots. >walkable, and extremely beautiful. I'll give you that, it definitely looks beautiful.
- nluken 5y agoI'd certainly call JP dense- it's got more than twice the population density of Houston, and it's slightly more dense than LA.
- HNTA_1 5y ago>it's got more than twice the population density of Houston You're comparing a neighborhood of Boston to one of the largest cities in the US. A more apt comparison would be the West University Place suburb of Houston that has roughly the same population density and similar size as JP. It's an older Houston suburb. A "dense" suburban area would be something Jamaica in Queens, NYC. That has something like 6 times the density of JP.
- sgt 5y agoHave you ever had your mail sent to Jamaica?
- seibelj 5y agoNot yet!
- Slow_Hand 5y agoSeconded. I lived in JP for several years and it was easily my favorite of the Boston neighborhoods to live in. Absolutely gorgeous. I lived in a 6 bed unit on the top level of a 3-story duplex that had 4 people living on the ground floor. It was a massive house that allowed for ten non-related people to live together on a street filled with similar houses, lined with massive oak trees and a five minute walk from a lovely pond. Gorgeous neighborhood. Edit: I’ll add that I never experienced any negative effects in JP that I’d associate with such dense living. Unlike the more rowdy student oriented neighborhoods like Allston that were far more rough and messy.
- seibelj 5y agoIt's for more mature and professional people than Allston, but there is a growing group of Northeastern students starting to populate things. I obviously can't prove this, but I believe because everything is so beautiful, people instinctively treat the location better. Whereas Allston is a party area and everything is grimy, so no one cares and joins into the debauchery and littering.
- ghaff 5y agoI've never spent a lot of time in JP, but my understanding is that it is nicer than it used to be. And the gentrification has been somewhat controversial: https://planetgeogblog.wordpress.com/2020/04/22/the-two-jps-how-a-whole-foods-split-a-gentrified-boston-neighborhood/ https://planetgeogblog.wordpress.com/2020/04/22/the-two-jps-... Also, for those not from the area, JP is indeed a "Boston neighborhood" but it's on the outskirts around parkland, the Arnold Arboretum, etc. and is about a 30 minute public transit ride [edit: on the Orange line not Green line]. So don't imagine this is in Boston in the way many might imagine. It probably has more in common with close in suburbs like Arlington than downtown.
- seibelj 5y agoThe JP line is the orange line, and getting downtown takes less than 20 minutes. It is the second fastest and most reliable line after the blue line. Arlington is a car suburb and is not Boston proper.
- tjr225 5y agoBoston was incorporated two hundred years before Los Angeles. Of course it is going to have more beautiful, old houses. Of course it is going to have more walkable neighborhoods. But what I'm more interested in is this: > Nearly every single home is multi-family, and the single families that do exist are usually $2 million and up. SFH are already 1 million and up in LA, really in SD, LA, SF, Seattle, and Vancouver. It will be interesting to see what happens to SFH values if they become scarcer. It seems like it might have the opposite effect that the NIMBYs generally fear, and make them even _more_ wealthy.
- thehappypm 5y agoMost houses in JP are from the ~40s.
- quadrangle 5y agoYup, in other words, the last period of development before the interstate highway push and car-sprawl suburban experiment ruined and bankrupted the country.
- grandmczeb 5y agoIn my experience, it’s a misconception that NIMBYS are motivated by property values directly. There are exceptions of course, but usually it’s either some sort of perceived lifestyle impact (traffic, shade, “neighborhood character”, etc) or just general anxiety over change.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Tiktaalik 5y agoYeah I mean, what do you figure the value of a SFH would be in downtown Manhattan? SFH's or rather, the underlying land the house sits on, is going to become insanely valuable as the amount available dwindles and population grows. There is no unwinding this trend. The only thing that can be done is to ignore and not worry about the price of a SFH, and subdivide the land into more apartments so that more people can afford to live on that parcel of land.
- nluken 5y agoGreat example. JP isn't quite a suburb but I look to it as a fantastic example of how suburban development could be condensed without losing its character. With proper upzoning, suburbs could have denser cores of multi-family housing without impacting those that want less dense housing outside the core. These towns would be more walkable and prettier places to live.
- foobarian 5y agoAh yes, Boston. No need to worry about what would happen to those 2, 3, and 4 story wood houses if they got a good shakeup at 5+ on the Richter scale.
- RandallBrown 5y agoExplain the thousands and thousands of new 2, 3, and 4 story wood houses in Seattle. From my understanding wood is actually pretty good for earthquakes.
- nluken 5y agoRight, that's why San Fransisco consists entirely of single story buildings.
- ethanbond 5y agoThat’s why they build so small and spread out in Tokyo, and never with wood!
- foobarian 5y agoNever say never, recently there has been a spate of news about engineered wood beams looking like pretty capable replacements for steel. Example: [1] [1] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/is-mass-timber-the-building-material-of-the-future https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/is-mass-timber-the-buildin...
- ehutch79 5y agoIt's not like developers in LA don't know how to build things resistant to seismic events.
- TYPE_FASTER 5y agohttps://earthquaketrack.com/us-ma-boston/biggest https://earthquaketrack.com/us-ma-boston/biggest I remember that Sanbornton quake. We lived in rural NH. At first I thought it was the clothes washer...then the house really started shaking.
- throwaway1777 5y agoI agree it looks great. But the density is around 8500/sq mile, which happens to be almost the same as Los Angeles. So, this type of development wouldn’t do that much for housing affordability in LA. I feel like people seriously underestimate how dense Californian cities already are.
- nluken 5y agoI suspect that JP's density is actually a bit higher than that today, given that it was 8500/sq mile based on 2010 population. Regardless, it's important to consider that JP is miles outside the city center. It isn't so much a model of super dense housing as it is a good way to up the density of neighborhoods that might otherwise only support 3500/sq mile. JP represents a good middle ground between the car-centric deep suburbs and the extremely dense city center.
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoParticularly in the era of remote work, I anticipate LA moving towards a denser downtown and West Side and relying on expanded suburbs in the inland empire and OC to provide the classic single family housing neighborhoods for those who want them.
- jedberg 5y agoIt's already happening. In 2020, San Bernadio County had the largest growth in the entire country. 80% of the people who lived in California and moved in 2020 moved to somewhere else in California. LA and SF counties lost the most people, but in most cases they all went to neighboring counties.
- sjg007 5y agoMakes sense, young single people live in the dense part and then when they couple up and have kids move out... east!
- _fat_santa 5y agoAs soon as you look at the zoning of LA, the housing problem there becomes clear as day, even for someone who doesn't visit very often. I don't know what you would call this system but LA's problem is that the folks that have the power to fix housing have zero interest in doing because it would hurt their self interest. Housing is only a "problem" if you haven't bought a house yet, once you purchase a house, all the issues with housing there all of a sudden become benefits. This is a small step in the right direction but California has really dug themselves into a hole here. California needs whole apartment blocks, not just duplexes, but apartments is something that is likely to never happen because of the above issue where no one will vote against their self interest. One could say the State should step in but that would be un-democratic. In fact this whole situation is weirdly democratic but un-democratic. Un-democratic in the sense that it casts out folks that don't live there, but democratic in the sense that the voices of those who own homes are clearly heard. You guys and gals have an interesting problem on your hands.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Un-democratic in the sense that it casts out folks that don't live there, but democratic in the sense that the voices of those who own homes are clearly heard. And the voices of those who own land?
- notJim 5y agoIn the US, you typically own the land your house is on.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoIn what sense? Say I buy a bunch of land in San Francisco so I can put a skyscraper on it. This is a form of "ownership" in which you don't control the property and you have to pay rent on it every year. What's left?
- this15testing 5y agoProp 13 needs to be repealed
- jeffbee 5y agoDuplexes, literally the least they can do.
- jperras 5y agoMontréaler here; I live in a neighbourhood which is uniquely composed of plexes - 3 to 8 units per "plex", with the typical number being 3, thus the term "triplex". Honestly, it's the ideal density IMHO. I get the convenience factors of urban density, but without (most) of the downsides of a high-rise condominium building.
- DanCarvajal 5y agoWhen I was last in Montreal I was struck by these types of units and deeply jealous.
- jperras 5y agoMost cities and urban areas would be much better off with a preponderance of middle-density housing! But, as has been mentioned elsewhere, protectionism in zoning laws and rampant NIMBYism is a difficult wave to break. Our love affair with middle-density housing is a bit of a cultural/historical oddity; there really aren't other places in Canada where this is wide-spread norm.
- mrep 5y agoWe call them three-flats here in Chicago.
- jperras 5y agoI had no idea that they were common enough in Chicago to have a colloquial name! That's awesome.
- mrep 5y agoThey are literally everywhere in Chicago. I live in one myself.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoThey're a different type of construction... but we have triple-deckers in Boston.
- gautamcgoel 5y agoObviously I support these kind of movements - the housing crisis is no joke. But every time I see an article about multifamily homes, I think: ok, but we really need is are hundreds of tall high rises with 500+ units, like in New York or Boston, each of which uses land much more efficiently than LA (2x more residents per square mile).
- CPLX 5y agoThere's truth to that, but Paris and Barcelona are some of the densest cities on the planet. People really underestimate how much you can get just with 5 stories or so if you do it consistently. As anyone who's been to those places knows there's no sacrifice of beauty, sun, or livability really.
- et-al 5y ago> People really underestimate how much you [density] can get just with 5 stories or so if you do it consistently. This is the rub, right? We can only redevelop a block or two at a time, so the only choice is for 10+ story towers. Especially because land is so expensive in these cities. I'm curious if new residential buildings (non-luxury if that even exists) in Paris or Barcelona are only 5-6 stories high.
- ceras 5y ago> We can only redevelop a block or two at a time, so the only choice is for 10+ story towers. Especially because land is so expensive in these cities. That's not necessarily true: it's much easier to build a duplexes/triplexes than a high-rise. Companies that can build the former cannot necessarily build the latter. IIRC when Bloomberg downzoned many "missing middle" outer-borough neighborhoods and upzoned core areas to support high-rises in NYC, many small building companies couldn't transition and just folded. > I'm curious if new residential buildings (non-luxury if that even exists) in Paris or Barcelona are only 5-6 stories high. I'm curious to see actual data on this, but many (most? almost all?) European cities have zoning rules that prevent building much taller than that in residential areas. It's especially true near the city center, where the restriction may apply to all buildings. So my guess would be it's still pretty common to not build high-rises in European cities -- similar to many NYC neighborhoods outside Manhattan (that weren't downzoned by Bloomberg).
- dredmorbius 5y agoFWIW, this turned up through Shane Phillips's Twitter feed, highly recommended. https://nitter.kavin.rocks/ShaneDPhillips https://nitter.kavin.rocks/ShaneDPhillips His book Affordable City was published last year: https://islandpress.org/books/affordable-city https://islandpress.org/books/affordable-city He hosts the "Creating More Affordable Cities" podcast https://elgl.org/podcast-creating-more-affordable-cities-with-shane-phillips-ucla-lewis-center/ https://elgl.org/podcast-creating-more-affordable-cities-wit... He's with the UCLA Lewis Center's housing programme: https://www.lewis.ucla.edu/programs/housing/ https://www.lewis.ucla.edu/programs/housing/ Excellent information and insights on housing policy, both for LA and more generally.
- cletus 5y agoI'm somewhat surprised at this given the intensity of California housing NIMBYism but I'm pleased to see it happen. Allowing fourplexes in some cases is a nice plus. This won't end the housing crisis. It'll take a long time for this to have a large impact but it's still an important step. To anyone saying you need high rise apartments like NYC, it's not as simple as that. You can't just plop a 500 unit high rise in the middle of a city like LA and hope for the best. There are a lot of considerations. For example: 1. How will you deal with all those cars; 2. Will there be enough public services in the area? 3. Is that even a good idea given that LA is an earthquake zone. Sure Japan has high rises but it's extremely land-constrained and people live in much smaller units, which partially offsets the higher costs of building in an earthquake zone. LA has been spending billions on a rail network and continues to do so. I don't know LA but I've heard people say it doesn't take you anywhere useful. There has also been resistance for adding stations in richer areas (eg Santa Monica) because it brings the riffraff in. But if you are going to build higher-density housing, the obvious place to do it is around train stations. You'll be less car dependent and you'll increase ridership of the light rail. The same applies to the Bay Area. Higher density housing should be a no-brainer along the SF to SJ Caltrain corridor.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoTragedy of the commons. California is an issue but this is a nationwide problem. Solve it in only one place and folks just move in and recreate it. Hence the lack of will.
- throwawaysea 5y agoGood grief. Not everything is a "crisis". This type of alarmist language games needs to stop. This is less a housing crisis and more an entitlement crisis. There is an entire country between the coasts. There are jobs available over the country. There is open land and housing all over the country. It's more that people feel entitled to a certain location, a certain line of work, a certain income level, a certain proximity to [friends, family, or whatever] and are upset they can't have it. But there's nothing stopping people from making a living and thriving elsewhere, and it would also be beneficial for the country by driving a more distributed and decentralized economy.
- francisofascii 5y agoSure, but the entitlement goes both ways. The current landowners feel entitled to enjoy massive appreciation gains while paying very little property tax, just because they settled there first. But I agree we are lucky in that we have other places to move, but that might not always be true.
- sjg007 5y agoPeople can vote for change.
- francisofascii 5y agoActually, no, they can't. You can't vote for change in a place you don't live yet. It is a flaw or an unfair downside of federalism. Call it tyranny of localism (or something)
- throwawaysea 5y agoWhy should someone be able to vote for change in a place they don't live in? It's not a flaw, but a thoughtful and smart design from my perspective. Having that locality is what lets people with many different perspectives and ways of life to coexist in the same country. People who don't like one way of doing things can go elsewhere.
- robomartin 5y agoI am very skeptical of both the surveys quoted in this article and the purported benefits this legislation is supposed to produce. Nobody wants their street to switch from single family homes to quad housing units. Nobody. Well, the only people who might want this would be those who are intent on moving elsewhere and want to maximize rental revenue. I would definitely do this because we would go from a singe rental revenue stream to four or five (the law sounds like you can build four additional units). The fallacy here is that rental rates don't come down as a function of n --n defined as the number of units on a lot. It isn't a linear relationship at all. If I had to guess, the rental cost per unit might be somewhere around 50% to 80% of what one might get by renting the entire home as a single unit. Taking the low side on that and assuming we build 5 units, this means the gross rent income for the property just went up 2.5x to 4.0x. If construction costs fit the model, this could be a great deal. Nobody is going to rent one of these units for less than the prevailing rent for similar units in existing apartment buildings. So, no, rents will not come down by a significant margin. The other angle is to just build an n-plex and sell the units. My guess on that one is that you'll make far more on the property than if you sold the single family home. I would further postulate that the cost per unit will track with comparable properties and will not really make things more affordable. I mean this in the sense that you are going to pay per square foot whatever anyone is paying per square foot elsewhere in the area. This law will not magically create a 50% discount per square foot. One of the reasons for this being as simple as: Construction, materials and permit costs keep going up, not down. In very rough terms, construction costs are in a range between $150 and $400 per square foot (depending on location, design, quality, low-end, high-end, etc.). That quickly becomes a very real lower bound on property valuation. The ONLY way to make home more affordable is to, at a minimum, reduce construction, regulatory and permit costs. And then there's the issue of what happens to a street and a neighborhood when you multiply the population by four or five. I am trying to imagine my street with 5x the vehicles. It is unimaginable. However, it goes beyond that. The sewage system, power, gas and water distribution systems were not designed to support five times the demand. Simple example: Our water comes from a large water tank atop a hill serving this neighborhood. That tank, while large, was sized based on regional planning approved many decades ago, which, of course, consisted of single family homes almost exclusively. There is no way this tank and the system that feeds it (pumps, aqueduct, etc.) is sized to support a 5x growth in demand. Similar issues with power and other utilities. Then there's the issue of traffic. We already have high traffic density and glorious traffic jams in the immediate region on a daily basis. A 5x explosion in population would turn this into nothing less than a living hell experience. Here's a data point. Many years ago I had to drive 50 miles to go work at a client's facility. I did this for two years. When the contract started I could do the 50 miles in about 45 minutes --so long as I left at 6:00 AM. Towards the end of the contract it was taking 2 hours. If I left at 5 AM I had a chance to cover the distance in an hour. A few minutes later and it got ugly quick. It was not uncommon to spend three hours on the road to get back. I won't even go into the likely in increase in crime. No, this isn't a judgement on the quality of people who would move in. It's a simple reality, increase the population five-fold and you will have an increase in crime. Simple example: More cars parked on the streets means lots more opportunities to break into them for profit. The consequences of these effects are very easy to predict. In our case, if I saw this transition happening, we would likely build our five units, rent or sell them and get the fuck out. Seriously. I am going to watch this like a hawk. My guess is the potential exists for entire neighborhoods to turn into multi-plex hellholes. Lots of people will make a lot of money by making the right move at the right time. Others will be left in limbo. And residents will be treated to expensive, stressful and substandard living conditions. This is also as far from "green" and "sustainable" (in quotes because these terms are becoming jokes) as one can get. What you want is sparse population fed by a solar grid and serviced by equally sparse commercial and employment centers (not centralized as a place like LA can feel) and real improvements to mass transport. Why does someone from Lancaster or Riverside have to travel to LA or Santa Monica for work? That's the real problem. What we need are incentives for businesses to spread out. Home construction will follow and will likely become more affordable as a result.
- bastardoperator 5y agoIf you've been or have lived in Los Angeles you would already know plenty of neighborhoods in LA already have this and almost nobody wants to live in these neighborhoods but do so out of necessity. All the giant craftsman homes in South Park are duplexes and they do not look inviting. This seemingly addresses nothing, the price of housing is the crux of the issue.
- starik36 5y agoI can't believe I had to scroll down this far to find this. If anything, this law will make the problem worse. LA is already packed with people and it takes 30 minutes to drive 3 miles on the city streets. If implemented, this will bring yet more people to the neighborhoods, increase density and make the situation far worse. But, like you said, the crux of the problem is the price and not anything else.
- almost_usual 5y agoHOA SFH neighborhoods about to get a lot more expensive.
- opportune 5y agoI find it interesting that the majority of democrats were in favor of the duplexes, republicans were split, and the LA city council (14/15 democrats) were all opposed to the new law. This matches my experiences in SF and other parts of the country. I’ll ignore the irony that republicans are voting against expanded property rights and transparently are voting simply for class interests… I am not sure why democratic elected officials are so opposed to these rules, whether it’s not in the lawmakers’ best interests directly (ie maybe since they are on average much wealthier, they think the law will hurt them. Or result in redistricting, etc.), bog-standard graft and corruption, or whether they legitimately think the measures are unpopular and likely to result in non getting re-elected. NIMBYs are certainly loud but they actually aren’t the majority. I am so tired of hearing tortured, nonsensical explanations for why new housing must be denied or become onerously hard to get approved. So at this point I’m leaning less towards thinking politicians are (incorrectly) following what they think their constituents think, and more towards suspecting some kind of inherent conflict of interest between lawmakers and the prospect of expanded housing.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoYes, and a lot of Democrats want open borders but no housing for them or existing younger generations. I understand some may not want to hear, but it is a direct aspect of the problem, and not unsubstantial. Nothing against immigrants of course, they'll surely need a place to live—just like everyone else. The "not in my backyard" strategy of (14/15) is not a solution.
- dang 5y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments? You've unfortunately been doing that a lot lately, and it's not what this site is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Slow_Hand 5y agoAs you've suggested the dissonance between democrats largely polling in favor of the measure but city council democrats rejecting could be because the city council members have conflicting personal interests or are being influenced/lobbied by a minority who oppose the law. So perhaps the distinction of democrat is too broad and unhelpful in this situation and it should be broken down into finer demographics. 26% of Americans identify as democrat and there is bound to be a lot of diversity of opinion within such a large body of people.
- kart23 5y agoSeems like single family homes are going to skyrocket in value. Especially ones that are on bigger lots. The law removed the owner occupancy requirement, so the ones that will be making the most money is investors and developers, like always.
- almost_usual 5y agoSFH in HOA neighborhoods
- autarch 5y ago(Stealing this argument from a friend who I discussed something similar with ...) It's hard to see how allowing duplexes will do _anything_ to address housing issues. We have a similar law here in Minneapolis which allows triplexes on any property. But what are the economics of this? Surely there's not a lot of vacant land in LA or Mpls just waiting for a new plex to be built. Instead, all the plots are already occupied. So that means either converting an existing house or tearing it down and building something new. What would it cost to convert a single family home to a duplex? I'd say a _very_ conservative estimate is c. $200,000. And what does it rent for? A typical house might be converted into a 700-900 square foot rental. Looking at Zillow, it seems like you'd get maybe $2,000-2,500 for that. Let's be optimistic and say $2,500. So it's $30,000 per year. You'll make a profit in ... 7 years ... after the construction work is done, which could itself take 6+ months. And I suspect my cost estimate is way too low. Seven years for a positive ROI doesn't seem like a very strong incentive. And if this is your own home that you live in, it'll be unliveable for much of the construction time. That means you'll have to live elsewhere and that cost further delays a positive ROI. I can't imagine a developer seriously investing in duplexes or triplexes, or even quads. What they would want is to tear down several adjacent houses and build an apartment building in the same space, and to really make it worth it that building probably needs to be 3+ floors. This plex stuff seems like political theater.
- denimnerd42 5y agonah. you'd do a 3 story and get 3.5kft out of it per unit. would cost around a million for the 2units with today's material prices. rent it for 6000-8000/mo. affordable housing never starts with new built unless there are major incentives.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoWhat happens in LA is that an extra apt or two will be built in the backyard, which can be rented for a few thousand a month.
- autarch 5y agoIs the ROI on that worth it? Again, I think we're looking at $200k in construction costs for $2,500/month in rental income. Also, one other thing I forgot is that this construction will probably increase your property taxes, further pushing out a positive ROI.
- davidw 5y agoHuh, nice to see Los Angeles, a city of some 4 million people catching up with... uh, Bend, Oregon, which recently passed its city code changes to allow up to fourplexes thanks to HB2001. Bend recently hit 100,000 people! And you wonder why California has a housing crisis.
- RandallBrown 5y agoDoesn't Bend also have a housing crisis?
- davidw 5y agoIt does. It'll take a while for changes like this to help, but it's good to see them happening. And while I dislike the NIMBY-ish "don't move to Oregon" stuff, it is undeniable that California is exporting their own housing crisis up and down the entire west coast. A place like LA should have enacted this kind of incremental change years ago.
- mateo411 5y agoYes, you are correct. All of the Californians should sell their over valued houses and move to Oregon. There is no sales tax, and you don't have to pump your own gas. I hear that Bend is nice!
- gumby 5y agoMan, I wish I could say the same about Palo Alto. We used to go out of our way to support the homeless and families (and had a lower median income than most surrounding cities) but since the selfish jerk proportion went up (IMHO in the dot com boom) the city has turned into “I’ve got mine, jack, so fuck off”
- subsubzero 5y agoWhat is the end solution to this housing crisis? The solutions will all hurt existing homeowners or multi-homeowners and are not likely to be implemented. The duplex in a single family lot is not going to move the needle on this crisis much, as building 2 houses on a existing lot will require a teardown of the original structure, then a buildup of the new duplex, all very costly. It will run at least $500K+ and I don't see many middle class owners using this route, also construction workers are scarce in the state due to high housing costs. What would truly fix things right away: #1. Prohibit Companies/Entities/hedgefunds from buying houses and renting them, ala zillow, blackrock etc. #2. Repeal CA prop. 13, all housing should be taxed at current market value. (exclusions for older retirees and the disabled) #3. Homeowners that wish to own a second property should be taxed at a very high rate. #4. Mandate real estate commissions to be halved, currently its 6%(3% buyer, 3% seller) it should be closer to 3% total, this would allow greater mobility and encourage more buying and selling of houses. #5. Rezone unused commercial(3 years unused) to residential to allow for more units to be built. None of these solutions above would change the makeup of a neighborhood by introducing high density housing which some owners don't want, and could easily be implemented by a few laws being crafted and passed. I bet 10-15% of the housing market would free up right away and prices would come down 20-30% within a year or two. But the root of the problem is just the people who are intentionally moving to southern California due to the mild climate. They know how crowded and dry[lack of water](and also expensive) it is but move here anyways contributing to the congestion. They don't want to move to other areas even when there are jobs there, and this issue will always be there.
- dmode 5y agoTwo things I would add to your list: - CEQA reform to now allow single individuals to hold up project - State level zoning guidance (similar to SB 9 / SB 50), where if a developer meets certain zoning guidance, local communities cannot oppose
- subsubzero 5y agoyeah good mention, I would def. add that as the state currently lets these phony "environmental" concerns prevent housing from being built.
- jp57 5y agoDo these California laws (or other laws in CA) address restrictive covenants that would prohibit duplexes in a neighborhood regardless of city zoning? You often hear about how Houston, for example, "doesn't have zoning", but a huge fraction of new housing in Texas (Houston and elsewhere) is in planned neighborhoods covered by restrictive covenants that prohibit all sorts of things. In those neighborhoods, it's unlikely that anyone would be able to tear down a single family house and build a duplex on the lot. (Or even paint the existing house a different color without approval of the HOA board.)
- 999900000999 5y agoThe city has been too far gone for 20 years. You have some of most inept local politicians you can imagine, who are more focused on taking glamor shots in front of half a million dollar per unit homeless shelters. If it's really costing half a million dollars to house a single homeless family, why not just give them $5,000 to move? Even for someone like myself, and I do consider myself to be somewhat upper middle class, LA is a bad deal. Deal. The bare minimum to afford a place to live plus transportation ends up being around 3,200 per month. That's about $2400 for a 1 bdrm + 800$ for a car payment / insurance/ gas. Compared to Chicago where a 1bdrm in a fantastic metro accessible area can be had for 1300$ or so. 100$ metro pass gets you around. LA and much of California is past saving, get out while you still can.
- dmode 5y agoYeah, it is too expensive. Nobody goes there anymore
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> If it's really costing half a million dollars to house a single homeless family, why not just give them $5,000 to move? I'm sure they would if they could, but with all the greyhound buses full of people going to LA from places like Texan prisons, how do you prevent them from coming back? Also, I don't think $5k provides as much influence these days as you think it does, even to someone who is homeless. > LA and much of California is past saving, get out while you still can. Yes, LA has too many people with more coming, housing prices are too high, and again growing. Chicago is losing people, so it is much easier to live there.
- 999900000999 5y ago5k is more than enough to get established in a more reasonable state. I'd say offer families a one time lump sum if they want to relocate. After that forbid them from ever receiving another dime in assistance. While you'll have some who try to take the money and come back anyway, I imagine many would find better places to live. California is losing people https://ktla.com/news/california/california-sees-its-population-fall-for-the-1st-time-in-states-history/ https://ktla.com/news/california/california-sees-its-populat...
- bit_logic 5y agoOne of the most powerful NIMBY arguments against more density is traffic. And unfortunately they're right. We see it again and again in the cities and suburbs that grew since the car became mainstream. The roads can only take so much volume before the residents become really unhappy. And so of course they don't want more density, they're tired of waiting on red lights, looking for parking, and all the other problems of a car dependent society that has too many cars. Buses have failed for a variety of reasons. Rail and BRT (bus with dedicated lane) are good and should be greatly expanded, but they only help with connecting major areas. We need to stop looking at Asian mega cities as an example. It just won't work here. Those super dense cities are designed for walking + public transit. The "last mile" problem in those cities are solved by walking because they're super dense enough that you can get to public transit easily by walking less than a mile. And also don't look at NYC or any old east coast city as an example. Those were designed before the car. Most people in the US live in places that were designed for the car. Rail + BRT along major routes is part of the solution. But in the past, it hasn't worked well because of the "last mile" issue, which is more like the "last few miles" issue in the typical American suburban design. If someone has to still have a car to drive the few miles from their home to the park-and-ride, that doesn't do anything to fix the local road congestion issue. When they get on the train, it helps with freeway traffic, but does nothing for the local traffic. And the "last few miles" is too far to walk. And again, buses/shuttles have failed to fix this for a lot of reasons. When ride-share was introduced, some thought that this was the solution. If someone depends on ride-share to get to places, that certainly helps reduce parking requirements. But, the traffic on the roads doesn't change, and may even increase due to idling ride-share cars waiting for rides. Uber Pool tries to help with this, but it's just not enough. With the rise of electric micromobility (e-scooters and e-bikes), we finally have something that can fix this "last few miles" issue. But it will require a big step from the government and society as well. We have to be willing to sacrifice a lane in all the local roads. The current bike lanes are simply not extensive enough, not wide enough, and not safe enough. The only way to achieve true effectiveness for e-micromobility is to dedicate an entire lane of roads to them. It's a radical idea that would get a lot of opposition. People already upset with traffic don't want to lose a lane to make it worse. That can only be countered with a critical mass of people who own an e-microbility solution (e-scooter or e-bike). Is it ever going to happen? Maybe if there's a city brave enough to try it and show it can work. But true support and infrastructure for e-bikes and e-scooters is the only way to get real density in the typical suburban sprawl layout without a disastrous increase in traffic and parking shortage.
- reactspa 5y agoTwo interesting takes on SB-9 (the Senate bill mentioned in the article): https://www.livablecalifornia.org/sb-9-allows-8-units-on-all-single-family-lots-california-would-kill-single-family-zoning/ https://www.livablecalifornia.org/sb-9-allows-8-units-on-all... https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/sb-9-it-s-not-a-duplex-bill-it-s-a-2431534/ https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/sb-9-it-s-not-a-duplex-bil... Accordingly, if a lot is over 2,400 sqft, one could split the lot into 2 (minimum 1,200 sqft is needed per part), and build a duplex, an ADU (Accessory Dwelling Unit) and a JADU (Junior Accessory Dwelling Unit) in each part, ending up with 8 units in total.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoIn another HN thread a couple of days ago, someone mentioned Ambler v Euclid, the landmark SCOTUS case that set the stage for zoning back in the 1920s. There's lots to be said about that case, industrial development, racism and more, but in reading the decision I came across the court's description of the impact of apartments on single family housing. Even if you allow for some level of racial motivation in this non-racial piece, the court's position really makes clear the core position, over a century old, that has underscored housing issues in the US: "With particular reference to apartment houses, it is pointed out that the development of detached house sections is greatly retarded by the coming of apartment houses, which has sometimes resulted in destroying the entire section for private house purposes; that in such sections very often the apartment house is a mere parasite, constructed in order to take advantage of the open spaces and attractive surroundings created by the residential character of the district. Moreover, the coming of one apartment house is followed by others, interfering by their height and bulk with the free circulation of air and monopolizing the rays of the sun which otherwise would fall upon the smaller homes, and bringing, as their necessary accompaniments, the disturbing noises incident to increased traffic and business, and the occupation, by means of moving and parked automobiles, of larger portions of the streets, thus detracting from their safety and depriving children of the privilege of quiet and open spaces for play, enjoyed by those in more favored localities-until, finally, the residential character of the neighborhood and its desirability as a place of detached residences are utterly destroyed. Under these circumstances, apartment houses, which in a different environment would be not only entirely unobjectionable but highly desirable, come very near to being nuisances." If you're an American like me, this is your SCOTUS at work!
- sushsjsuauahab 5y agoI live in Washington and I don't understand how anybody can live in LA unless they have a physical job or family that is tying them there. If you like hot weather, there are many better places to live, like Scottsdale or Naples. If you must live in California, why not Palm Springs? If you are concerned about taxes and cost of living and you don't need California's weather, virtually any other state has a safe community for you to live in.
- apengwin 5y agoThe food is really good here.
- sushsjsuauahab 5y agoThis is a true criticism of Seattle, I have to cook everything myself haha
- dmode 5y agoPalm Springs and Scottsdale are magnitudes hotter than LA. When I used to live in Scottsdale, every day between early May and end of September will be above 100. LA weather barely gets into the 90s. Most days it is between 75-85. Also, Palm Springs and Scottsdale do not have beaches, do not have nearly the same level of entertainment (music venues, clubs, bars, nightlife, two football teams, two basketball teams, stories baseball teams). Not to mention access to nature, wine countries, international airports etc. I lived in LA for 2 years, even with all its traffic problems, it is a 10x more interesting place to live than Scottsdale
- sushsjsuauahab 5y agoAppreciate this information and perspective :)
- SnowProblem 5y agoTo each their own. I used to live in Seattle and had some reservations about LA, but my opinion changed after living there, on the west side specifically. I've since moved, but I do miss 70° and sunny everyday, all the diversity of food, and generally blissful living. Weekend trips for skiing, palm springs, malibu, even vegas were great too. There's a lot to like.
- thewebcount 5y agoLA resident here. There are a number of problems with housing in LA. This will help a little, but more will need to be done. However, it should be noted that duplexes in single-family neighborhoods are not new. There are plenty of them here. I'm over in Westchester, and our neighborhood has dozens of 2 and 4-plexes. I've never heard a single-family homeowner here complain about it. My brother used to live in a duplex down in Redondo, as well. They've also built about 4 or 5 low-rise apartment complexes within 1 mile of my house in the last 3-4 years. Again, I haven't heard any complaints from homeowners. (And as one myself, I have no complaints.) People like to say the problem is that we don't have enough housing. While that's part of the problem, the bigger problem is that we have plenty of housing that nobody wants. A few years ago, the LA Times ran an article about how there were several large luxury apartment complexes built downtown that nobody wanted to move into. The problem is less that housing isn't being built and more that it's only being built for the high end, and the people at the high end have better options. Honestly, I'm not sure whether a duplex is that much more affordable than a house. Maybe your recently minted Googlers and such will move into them, but the much larger pool of people who work in the area and don't get paid those salaries still won't have anyplace affordable to live. Hopefully this is just the first step.
- black_13 5y agoWhat all these cities should do is have hi rises or mid rise apartments or condos and get over the myth of suburbia.
- bagels 5y agoWhy can't we have single family plus high density where it makes sense (near transit, major roads and freeways)? This push to ruin suburbs is just ruining things for those that don't want to live somewhere dense.
- milkytron 5y agoWe sort of can, but it's mostly temporary on a long term scale unless you're talking about areas really far from the core of a metro. When more people move to an area, there is (generally) more economic opportunity. With that comes rising land values and demand to live in that area. As cities grow, expand, and generate wealth for the residents, they envelop the suburbs, and development makes those suburbs more urban. If you keep those suburbs as single family housing, their value goes up tremendously at the cost of everyone else. It is not beneficial for the community at large to have these single residences in areas that could provide jobs, services, organizations, to many more people. Having more people also increases the tax base for a city compared to a single family.
- bagels 5y agoIt still seems like rezoning a few blocks for high density vs the whole city for duplexes would be more effective and less disruptive.