18 ms·
U.S. satellites are being attacked every day according to Space Force general
- setpatchaddress 5y agoAnd why should we believe this? Edit: The "space force" needs to justify its existence, and this is a way for them to do it. Why haven't we heard about this before?
- andreilys 5y agoDo you really think after all these years of public hacking by state actors that U.S. satellites would somehow be off limits?
- echelon 5y agoWhy not? China and Russia are ramping up on military presence, maneuvers, and armament. Our top businesses are constantly under attack by nation state actors. I've witnessed a few attacks directly. I'd be willing to bet that there will be some action taken in Ukraine and Taiwan within the decade, possibly simultaneously.
- senectus1 5y agoyeah I rarely believe things that the US military industrial and political complex says. Bu this is not a hard thing to belive.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoYear. Possibly month.
- fallingknife 5y agoI feel like the best way to prevent a Taiwan situation is to give them nukes. China would never invade if it meant losing their 10 largest cities. And when they throw a fit just say "but China, you already had nukes. Which part of China they are in is no concern of ours."
- dividedbyzero 5y agoWouldn't Taiwan need a credible second strike capability as well? The US probably can't credibly guarantee their safety, so they'd need to be able to do that themselves, otherwise the threat is empty and useless. But say the US really did arm Taiwan with first and second strike capabilities, I don't even think the US could stomach the reaction to that. How long could they hold out if embargoed by the PRC?
- kelnos 5y agoWouldn't a PRC embargo of the US hurt the PRC nearly as much as the US?
- fallingknife 5y agoMore. Exports to the US are a much greater % of Chinese GDP, than Chinese imports are of US GDP.
- Eelongate 5y agoThe US Navy could block all Chinese exports and imports by sea around the world, not only those between China and America. This is why China's "Belt and Road Initiative" (aka the 'New Silk Road') is so important to China. It's meant to decrease China's reliance on shipping for international trade, by opening up land routes across Eurasia.
- randomopining 5y agoI always said the same thing. Give those 3 nukes and then declare defensive strike doctrine. My military friend says “it’s not a good idea” but I don’t see why. Call their bluff.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- redis_mlc 5y agoPerhaps you're not well-informed ... Space and the Moon are the high ground for modern warfare. Stay tuned for NASA to schedule manned lunar landings within months.
- dragontamer 5y agoBecause in a Taiwan scenario, China almost certainly would attack US Satellites. And vice versa: USA would want to stop Chinese Satellites, so that they are blind to the movement of our carriers. ----- Frankly, I'd expect that the Space Force is already conducting testing-level operations against our opponent's satellites. From temporary blindness (this laser-thing they're talking about), to permanent disablement (missile, like Russia's test). Maybe the US isn't so gaudy to publicly create space debris like Russia, but I'm sure we have weapons in development that can do the same thing. ------- > Edit: The "space force" needs to justify its existence, and this is a way for them to do it. Why haven't we heard about this before? "Space Force" always existed. Or do you think that the US Army doesn't use GPS or Spy Satellites? The issue with before, is that we used to have a Space-component for US Army. Then a 2nd space-component in the US Navy. Then a 3rd space-component in the US Marines. Finally, we have a 4th space-component in the US Air Force. This was stupid. We removed the space-elements in our 4 branches and combined them into a singular 5th branch. Instead of redundantly creating 4 different space branches subservient to 4 different organizations, we can have one branch focus on the space stuff, and the other 4 branches asking the 5th guy for support as needed. If anything, Space Force is going to be a hell of a lot cheaper than the stupid organization we had before.
- User23 5y agoAnti-satellite weapons have been around for some time[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASM-135_ASAT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASM-135_ASAT
- nine_k 5y agoI can imagine lightweight semi-permanent disablement by spraying paint on lenses and wrapping the entire craft in aluminum foil. Zero space debris, and not even destruction of property. This takes more fuel and an advanced robot craft, but should be preferable for a time when a fast all-out war is not being fought. And I hope both sides would like to avoid an all-out war.
- FredPret 5y agoSpace rendezvous is really hard. Easier to get line-of-sight and then beam attack it
- boardwaalk 5y ago... didn't we just have a Russian ASAT test that had ISS astronauts sheltering in place? Is this that hard to believe?
- tata71 5y agoIn fact, that's why this statement is "50/50".
- thatguy0900 5y agoDoes the space force need to justify its existence? Seems obviously justified to me, anything in space will be one of the first targets in any near peer conflicts and every state with the capability is working on and even openly testing space capable weapons.
- dylan604 5y agoIs there anything from the ground that can be done by Space Force to protect assets in space from direct attack from projectile weapons? Is there anything Space Force can to from space to protect them? No? Then what have they actually done except get new uniforms and patches?
- thatguy0900 5y agoI mean those are the problems that are being worked on, I presume. Seems a little tautological to say we currently have no space defense/offense capabilities so it's senseless to invest in space defense/offense.
- dylan604 5y agoI see your point, but at the same time, whether it is a branch of the Air Force or its own branch, it's the same situation. I'm willing to stipulate that I'm basing my opinion at the farcical manner in which it was created, and how can we take anything seriously like that especially after their uniform design so clearly ripped off of scifi. Edit: sorry, I meant logo/emblem in place of uniform.
- thatguy0900 5y agowell, we can agree on the emblem lol
- post_from_work 5y ago>>>how can we take anything seriously like that especially after their uniform design so clearly ripped off of scifi We have all sorts of neat things because people with real jobs "ripped off sci-fi". Plus I'm glad to see a military uniform that breaks with such conservative conventions, and if you are gonna steal style cues from sci-fi, TMP-era Star Trek & nBSG are some of the best to copy. https://www.techrepublic.com/article/tech-leaders-share-how-star-trek-inspired-them-to-pursue-a-career-in-technology/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/tech-leaders-share-how-... We're still waiting on our Starship Troopers power armor though: https://www.forbes.com/sites/vikrammittal/2020/08/17/military-exoskeletons-science-fiction-or-science-reality/?sh=69388bb2a69e https://www.forbes.com/sites/vikrammittal/2020/08/17/militar...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Mizza 5y agoSpace has been used for weapons of war since the V2 in 1944. The next Big Stupid War will certainly continue the trend.
- notJim 5y agoI agree we should approach this with skepticism. By their nature, a lot of these things are hard to verify independently, and the incentives are for the military to exaggerate them. This article doesn't seem to even attempt to independently verify the facts. This should be treated as a press release from the military, not journalism.
- ars 5y agoThe parent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Force_Space_Command https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Force_Space_Command has existed since 1982, so why do you think they need to suddenly justify their existence? Is this just a stupid reaction to Donald Trump being the one to do the reorganization?
- Rebelgecko 5y agoPutin has been talking up Russia's anti-satellite laser weapons since before the US created its space force. As xkcd[1] famously mentioned, just because you're learning about something today doesn't mean it's brand new [1]: https://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/
- fallingknife 5y ago> There may come a point where we demonstrate some of our capabilities so that our adversaries understand they cannot deny us the use of space without consequence Obviously that time has come if they are attacking our satellites. Why is everyone in the US government so afraid to stand up to China?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jimmygrapes 5y agoTo put it simply, the second we (U.S.) show what we can do, everyone else can start developing countermeasures. It requires a circumstance where the risk of exposing our capabilities is worth the deterrent or retributive effect. So far, throwing shit at satellites doesn't count.
- fallingknife 5y agoThat's a good point but when pushed, you have to push back. Not necessarily with your most advanced tech.
- devoutsalsa 5y agoI wanna see one of the USA adversaries magically lose a satellite somehow with firing a missile at it. Like a tractor beam or something. We need some good source material for our high tech, near future science fiction.
- colechristensen 5y agoEverybody’s already demonstrated their ability to shoot down satellites. Mysteriously deorbiting one with our mini robot shuttle though…
- devoutsalsa 5y agoThey’d see the X-37 sneak up. But maybe it could deploy a small, stealth drone to push a satellite down?
- bigyellow 5y agoA computer in another country is running SSH brute-force attempts and random port scans (which hit pretty much every IPv4 address at least once an hour) - quick, ask for several more billions in funding and claim Russia/China is behind it - your wish will be granted without a second thought. Man, why is this propaganda on the front page of a "hacker" website?
- pezzana 5y ago> “The threats are really growing and expanding every single day. And it’s really an evolution of activity that’s been happening for a long time,” Thompson, told Rogin. “We’re really at a point now where there’s a whole host of ways that our space systems can be threatened.” Although the article doesn't mention it, the close integration between each country's nuclear force and satellites means that what happens in orbit affects survival on earth acutely. And the rate at which new technologies are enabling the militarization of space is shocking. That applies whether you believe Thompson or not. See: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29045286 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29045286
- lettergram 5y agoThis has been happening for decades at this point https://www.wired.com/2009/04/fleetcom/ https://www.wired.com/2009/04/fleetcom/
- nraynaud 5y agoI just love the complete lack of self-awareness. Russia and China bad, the US is good.
- Afforess 5y agoNarrotor Voice: Next up, Manifest Destiny, Imperialist Propoganda, or our glorious past!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kelnos 5y agoIt's not a lack of self-awareness. It's propaganda. Of course the US military is going to paint the people attacking them as the bad guys, even though the US military is likely engaging in the same kinds of attacks.
- ies7 5y agoI read it as: US complained that their spy sattelites got attacked for spying.
- knownjorbist 5y agoGenerally speaking, yes.
- plandis 5y agoYou think that Putin and Xi are the good guys here? You really think the world would be a better place if the US let them be the world’s super powers?
- randomopining 5y agoThese types lock onto a bad thing the US has done as the be all end all, and completely ignore the logically conclusion of a world controlled by Xi and Putin types… for example, none of this quality HN discussion would be available in Autocratica.
- jazzyjackson 5y ago
- pvarangot 5y agoThis is propaganda, the US is the only military with operational space drones and space planes. They have the technology and enough budget to defend military and commercial satellites and just looking for political support to actually do so. The CCP military may be ahead in number of rockets but the US is way ahead in number of spy satellites by a far margin and can also commission civilian capabilities for this.
- dsjoerg 5y agoIf you can substantiate your claims they would be interesting.
- hereforphone 5y agoThat's the benefit of being an early innovator. That doesn't mean threats don't exist.
- baby 5y agooh man... it is really hard to see through news nowadays. What is real, what isn't? That's why transparency is such an important value in organizations and governments. The more transparency, the easier it is to move things in the right direction. That's why I'm confident that China will have a lot of trouble with corruption and long-term growth. But it doesn't mean that we're good at it, and we should strive for Democracy to also imply transparency.
- colechristensen 5y agoIt’s not nowadays, it has sheets been the case.
- afterburner 5y agoSheets has been
- colechristensen 5y agoAlways.
- vexxed-concave 5y ago“Space Force” has been around for decades. See the “National Reconnaissance Office” https://www.nro.gov/ https://www.nro.gov/
- catillac 5y agoNRO is different than Space Force. Space Force is relatively new and has a different mission.
- jand 5y agoThis article presents some thoughts on how, if and when the US should or could strike (back) in space after summarizing the alleged current space combat capability developments of other nations. You can easily replace "US" with other nations and the target audience with their citizens and allies. By this logic, every nation needs to ramp up space combat capabilities, because their perceived or real enemies could also do so. This train of thought leads to a cold war 'space edition'. In the long run it will boil down to disaster only preventable by some courageous individuals doing 'the right thing at the right time'. We should better begin stockpiling characters like Stanislav Petrov [1] to make sure we haven't run out of those by then. Good luck to all of us. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov
- pvarangot 5y agoI'm also picturing something like selling anti-anti-satellite defense systems to US military allies to keep money flowing to military contractors.
- eftychis 5y agoCan't say we promote that anywhere though. Did he rise to a high rank? Became a thought leader? He was reprimanded, and he considered according to him that he just did his job and nothing really (that is to his credit perhaps). I didn't see him getting a Nobel peace prize either, and it seemed it was the west that celebrated this years after he was retired his heroic decision.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoWe didn't really celebrate him, after all he could have been given a noble peace prize, that a western organisation. Average Joe in the street never heard of him, he is unrewarded and forgotten
- abledon 5y agobut will the next Petrov 'candidate' grow up on a diet of tiktok videos?
- jandrewrogers 5y agoThis is currently a very active area of so-called grey-zone[0] warfare. It goes beyond the US, which is better prepared for this than most. Some European governments recently started investing heavily in their own satellite warfare capabilities as a response to increasingly aggressive and diverse activities targeting their assets as well. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grey-zone_(international_relations) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grey-zone_(international_relat...
- thoughtstheseus 5y agoThe lack of public awareness of gray zone warfare is truly astounding.
- ianbicking 5y agoA bit of an aside to the exact article, but it makes me think about all the software attacks that might be made on satellites. It's kind of like they have an open port, small deployment, and no way to physically reset the machine. It seems inevitable that they have many serious and exploitable security flaws...
- apcragg 5y agoThe USSF hosts Hack-a-sat at DEFCON! See here for details! https://www.hackasat.com/ https://www.hackasat.com/
- john37386 5y agoUsed to work for internet video game companies at the infrastructure level. We were constantly under attack. I mean, out of 40 Gbps of bandwidth on internet spread over multiple data centers, a good percentage was just pure hacks and attacks. I can't imagine to drop our firewalls, ips and all of the security gears we had for few seconds. The knowledge built to reach this level of maturity in internet security was several years of man power. I'm not sure how bad are the attacks against the space force, but I suspect it's slightly higher than any other normal high profile entities on internet. They probably deserve a good shake. Let's give them a good shake, shall we?
- wolverine876 5y ago> They probably deserve a good shake. Let's give them a good shake, shall we? What does that mean?
- snypher 5y agoThe state of accepting something as honest or deserving of trust even though there is some doubt.
- Groxx 5y agohuh. that's basically the opposite of what I'd think of it as - on the American side of things, I read that as "shake them and see what falls out", i.e. see what they're hiding. I'm also not sure how to search for that kind of phrase though. "a good shake" / "give them a good shake" doesn't seem to find anything relevant in my google. Anyone know of effective ways to search for culturally-idiomatic phrases?
- duduer8fttg 5y agoFrom usage in this scenario, the actual term you want to search for is "fair shake". You're thinking of "shake down" or possibly "shaking the tree" which is why it seems odd.
- kwertyoowiyop 5y agoIt’s budget time again. Gotta get those billions!
- IncRnd 5y ago> "Both China and Russia are regularly attacking U.S. satellites with non-kinetic means, including lasers, radio frequency jammers, and cyber attacks, he said." So, having a satellite is just like having a server on the Internet.
- aero-glide2 5y agoI'm sure the reverse happens too.
- dumdumdumdum 5y ago> The systems that Russia and China are known to be developing or have already fielded include destructive and non-destructive types that are deployed from Earth, such as ground-based jammers, lasers, or interceptors, as well as small "killer satellites" positioned in orbit. A killer satellite able to maneuver close to its target could use various means to try to disable, damage, or even destroy it, such as jammers, directed energy weapons, robotic arms, chemical sprays, and small projectiles. It could even deliberately smash into the other satellite in a kinetic attack. Seeing a lot of could. > In another prime example of the secrecy issue, when asked, Thompson could not confirm or deny whether any American satellites had actually been damaged in a Russian or Chinese attack. Beyond that, he told Rogin that even if such a thing had occurred, that very fact would be classified. Ok. Can we go back to the UFO discourse now? Or maybe Havana syndrome? At least those are somewhat imaginative. Please come-up with something more interesting like Russia/China training space dolphins or something.
- 14 5y agoIs it really fair to say attack when they openly say “our spy satellites”. Is not spying considered an attack on those you are spying on?
- cascom 5y agoSeems like there is a difference between passive spying (say monitoring radio transmissions from international waters or taking pictures from space) vs active spying (conducting intelligence operations on foreign soil or hacking a network)
- nyokodo 5y ago> Is not spying considered an attack on those you are spying on? It depends on the meaning of “attack.” Spying against a country inside their country is generally illegal in that country but is also not generally treated as an act of war. Spy satellites are not even in the target’s territory and are not doing anything to the target’s territory or their stuff. There isn’t really any rationale to call it an attack. Attacking the satellite though is attacking their stuff, of course everyone does it, but has a better rationale for the word “attack.”
- Eelongate 5y agoIt's not the job of any military to be fair.
- imglorp 5y agoThe secrecy part of this game is infuriating, where the existence of some of these birds is not even acknowledged. Everyone knows that stuff is there, egs: stuffin.space and https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/satellite-database https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/satellite-database etc. But if the US wants to respond to some wrong diplomatically, or in kind, there's no point to keeping it secret.
- monkeybutton 5y agoForget radio waves and lasers, what would happen if someone aimed a particle accelerator at a satellite. Just a tight beam of relativistic protons fired from the earth's surface into the sky?
- russli1993 5y agoOn Aug 2020, a US spy satellite moved close to a Chinese satellite, attempting to shadow it closely. It was caught by the Chinese and they maneuvered it to get away from the US satellite. This seems to constitute ill or malign intent. Why would you go and bother the property of another person? What is the intent behind this move? Trust goes both ways, and it takes effort from both parties to build trust. This kind of actions will only been seen as aggressive and ill intent by the other party, and when there is lack of trust between two parties, the other will come up with defensive and offensive counter measure to protect themselves. And that doesn't help when one party has got an active military branch named space force. Looks like the space arms race and militarization of space will only escalate in the future. I hope people will realize, like the nuclear arms race before, this kind of wild west arms race is unsustainable for everyone involved, and for humanity as a whole. I hope leaders from all countries involved to have the courage and consideration for all of humanity and our collective peaceful use of space, to put geopolitics aside, to come up rules of responsible use and engagement in space. https://breakingdefense.com/2021/10/us-china-russia-test-new-space-war-tactics-sats-buzzing-spoofing-spying/ https://breakingdefense.com/2021/10/us-china-russia-test-new...
- b_emery 5y agoThe intent, according to your link: "What we think is happening here is the development and experimentation and validation of what we call a tactic, technique and procedure, a TTP, to spoof an enemy’s network for SSA [space situational awareness]"
- judge2020 5y agoWhat could possibly be gained moving a satellite closer to another? Threatening to crash into it?
- ddingus 5y agoI wonder how long it will be, before some government somewhere makes a high-powered maser type of device, which would basically be an electromagnetic attack. Seems to me something like that would be very difficult to detect.
- wolverine876 5y agoSimilar things happen regularly between competing militaries in more atmospheric situations. Russia flies planes near or into NATO airspace; China flies and sails near Taiwan and various neighbors. The US spies everywhere and challenges Chinese claims to the South China Sea. Planes take dangerously close approaches to other planes and as we know well, cyber attacks happen constantly. I wonder how the orbital activities described in the OP compare. Are they more or less consequential? Are the rules of engagement as mature? Are these just run-of-the-mill encounters?
- motohagiography 5y agoRegardless of the article, space superiority is the new air superiority in that if you don't have it, you only ever have permission from whomever does. Over space scale distances, the only meaningful sovereignty is the cryptographic integrity of your networks, which, as it turns out, can have 20min or greater RTT latency, so you also need a high degree of autonomy. There's also the small matter of the entire substrates of those networks being produced by fabs and on equipment controlled by a rival superpower. Post quantum algorithms and key distribution are going to literally define sovereignty in less than 30 years, and we haven't landed on one for standardization yet. I get that a lot of americans want to forfeit their governments role in the world, but I'd invite them to consider the alternatives. What bothers me is that we've seen supersonic missiles from both China and Russia in the last couple of months, and officially the multi trillion dollar US military is mystified by them, while some random guy on hackaday just built a supersonic trebuchet for two hundred dollars. Someone should call him and tell him his country needs him, because its military is too busy navel gazing to do its one job.
- aaron695 5y ago> U.S. satellites are being attacked every day according to Space Force general Give one example if it's true. The time the Russian satellite went close to others was well known about. A daily attack will be noticed by 3rd parties if true. I'm not sure there's a single example?
- tehjoker 5y agoYawn. New US military branch that everyone wonders why it exists seeks to justify budget.
- iwasnothere 5y agoAm I the only one unable to see "Space Force" without laughing and thinking about the Steve Carroll show of the same name?
- stevespang 5y agoRussia claims falsely it has the capability to take out all our GPS sats, yes it <may> have the technology, but it does not have the rockets in place to do it. It's high time we resurrect the "Star Wars" program of the Reagan years, which was what brought the original Soviet Union to it's knees. Giant sats in space all around the globe with huge laser banks that can identify and destroy ICBM's from Russia and China.