16 ms·
TSMC “Apple-first” 3nm policy leads to AMD and Qualcomm mutiny
- YetAnotherNick 5y agoAMD hasn't even moved to 5nm till now even though it is available to them. Why are they complaining?
- pmarcelll 5y agoThere is a significant amount of time between starting the development of a CPU die on a specific node and actually releasing the final product onto the market. This has already happened for Zen 4 on 5nm (so R&D/product development has moved to 5nm a long time ago) and the article is probably about Zen 5 (current gen is Zen 3 on 7nm).
- qayxc 5y agoWell, they can't move to 5nm because Apple bought basically the entire 5nm production from TSMC. In other words, they couldn't move to 5nm because they wouldn't be able to procure any significant volume from it. Why bother with 5nm if you wouldn't be able to ship products? That's exactly why NVIDIA ditched TSMC in favour of Samsung despite their inferior process.
- kuschku 5y agoBecause Apple had bought 100% of 5nm capacity, and so no capacity at 5nm was available to AMD?
- webmobdev 5y agoNow that most of Apple's top talents from its CPU division have left for greener pastures (1), I guess this is their new strategy - somehow delay their competitors from launching new and better chips while Apple scrambles to find new talents in the limited pool available. Apple has bet their future on Apple Silicon, and it badly needs to retain a lead on other competing CPU for a year or two, to capture sufficient market share (the perception of Apple Silicon leading over other CPUs is very important for this). TSMC also seems to be taking a big gamble, pissing of existing good clients. Edit: (1) https://semianalysis.com/apple-cpu-gains-grind-to-a-halt-and-the-future-looks-dim-as-the-cpu-engineer-exodus-to-nuvia-and-rivos-impact-starts-to-bleed-in/ https://semianalysis.com/apple-cpu-gains-grind-to-a-halt-and...
- afandian 5y agoGot a link for that?
- webmobdev 5y ago> ... In 2019, Nuvia was founded and later acquired by Qualcomm for $1.4B. Apple’s Chief CPU Architect, Gerard Williams, as well as over a 100 other Apple engineers left to join this firm. More recently, SemiAnalysis broke the news about Rivos Inc, a new high performance RISC V startup which includes many senior Apple engineers. The brain drain continues and impacts will be more apparent as time moves on. As Apple once drained resources out of Intel and others through the industry, the reverse seems to be happening now. > We believe Apple had to delay the next generation CPU core due to all the personnel turnover Apple has been experiencing ... https://semianalysis.com/apple-cpu-gains-grind-to-a-halt-and-the-future-looks-dim-as-the-cpu-engineer-exodus-to-nuvia-and-rivos-impact-starts-to-bleed-in/ https://semianalysis.com/apple-cpu-gains-grind-to-a-halt-and...
- ericmay 5y agoInteresting they’re talking about the A15, since then the M1 chips have come out and they seem pretty good…
- dsign 5y agoFierce competition in this space is a good thing, we sorely need faster matrix multiplication for everything from graphics processing to the grammar checker in [insert name of your word-processing software]. So yes, more transistors please.
- throwaway4good 5y agoDo we really? (Serious question - what are the end-user applications that cannot be done today because of the lack of faster matrix multiplication?)
- pfortuny 5y agoVR headsets, games running at 4K 120fps, etc… Anything using massive linear algebra.
- throwaway4good 5y ago4K 120fps - is that "sorely needed"?
- belval 5y agoOf course not and "640K software is all the memory anybody would ever need on a computer".
- dmitriid 5y agoFalse equivalence
- throwaway4good 5y agoNo. I am asking if there are genuine new use cases that will be enabled by say a ten-fold increase in processing power? Other than it is nice going from 2K at 30 Hz to 4K at 120 Hz (which is an 8-fold increase).
- Jyaif 5y agoWhat are the bottle necks preventing TSMC from meeting the demand?
- mschuster91 5y agoIt is incredibly expensive to expand microchip production capacity. You need extremely large, extremely clean clean rooms filled with expensive machines from ASML and other vendors for the well over 1.000 different steps that need to be done for a modern chip. And then you need staff to operate these machines.
- leoc 5y agoAnd while everyone wants more investment in capacity, presumably no-one wants to be an investor who's left holding the bag if capacity overshoots and supply exceeds demand in 1-3 years' time.
- xyzzy_plugh 5y agoYou'd be surprised. You can almost _always_ sell excess supply given enough time. These parts... take up very little space. Even if it has to sit in a warehouse for 5 years eventually someone will buy them and while they may not break even, they'll get close.
- foobiekr 5y agoThat’s a terrible situation from a capital efficiency standpoint.
- wtallis 5y agoThe problem with supply exceeding demand isn't unsold inventory/capacity, it's that your profit margin gets slim enough that you can no longer fund the R&D and fab construction necessary to remain on the leading edge. This is especially apparent for memory chips that are more commoditized than processors. Boom and bust cycles frequently result in at least one major bankruptcy, merger or pivot away from leading-edge processes. Qimonda, Elpida, Winbond all had their heyday as major DRAM manufacturers. For logic fabs, casualties include Chartered, GloFo, UMC, Motorola/Freescale—all of whom were once able to manufacture competitive processors.
- 1cvmask 5y agoThis seems to me a replay of when Apple bought out all the capacity of Toshiba hard drives to that effectively blocked other MP3 players from emerging: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPod https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPod https://9to5mac.com/2021/10/23/20-years-ago-today-ipod-changed-the-world-heres-what-it-means-to-us/ https://9to5mac.com/2021/10/23/20-years-ago-today-ipod-chang...
- rkangel 5y agoNot saying you're wrong, but an alternate interpretation was that Apple was just leveraging their large order size to get to the front of the line because they want to make products to sell. If you're TSMC, who are you going to favour - the large single customer who's guaranteeing order size over a period of time, or several smaller customers?
- q-big 5y ago> If you're TSMC, who are you going to favour - the large single customer who's guaranteeing order size over a period of time, or several smaller customers? This depends on your business strategy: having a single or few customers makes you much more dependent on their whims and their negotiation power. If you have more customers you are in a better position for pricing negotiations.
- melony 5y agoWhen you have a monopoly on a single component, it doesn't matter.
- bigdubs 5y agoBig point of strength for TSMC in negotiations is they're the only fab that can make 3nm chips in volume, which gives them a ton of leverage to push back against Apple.
- JiNCMG 5y agoNothing to negotiation. Apple invested (pre-ordered) before 3nm was built.
- jagger27 5y agoThis really doesn't seem true. Maybe Qualcomm, but not AMD.
- fomine3 5y agoI really wish Qualcomm to use latest TSMC's latest process to make Android phones competitive for performance. Even when they used same process as Apple A series, their perf/watt (now it's almost same as perf) were a bit behind.
- jonplackett 5y agoIt’s interesting that Apple’s decision to transition to their own chips was probably lead, at least partly, by the fact they knew the could lock down all this next gen production. If everyone else had access to cutting edge TSMC I’m sure Apple’s chips would still be good but I don’t think we’d be quite as impressed.
- sudosysgen 5y agoIf everyone had access to cutting edge processes, Apple silicon would be behind. They're not even cleanly ahead despite a generation leap in RAM and in processes in CPUs and they're still behind in GPU performance per watt compared to NVidia on 8nm. If Apple wants to lead in performance they can't allow NVidia and AMD to be on the same process. They would even risk Qualcomm chips catching up.
- tambourine_man 5y agoSource?
- akmarinov 5y agoWell that's a load of bull that you just wrote. Qualcomm uses the exact same process that Apple uses for the 888 and TSMC produces it, yet it's inferior in every way to the A14
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe 888 is produced on Samsung 5nm LPE, not TSMC : https://www.anandtech.com/show/16463/snapdragon-888-vs-exynos-2100-galaxy-s21-ultra https://www.anandtech.com/show/16463/snapdragon-888-vs-exyno... Despite an inferior process, the 888+ and 888 are only 10-20% behind the A14 in most metrics including energy efficiency, despite being on a process with 35% lower density.
- akmarinov 5y agoThat didn’t work out and they switched to TSMC - https://www.notebookcheck.net/TSMC-to-manufacture-some-of-Qualcomm-s-5nm-and-6nm-parts.531207.0.html https://www.notebookcheck.net/TSMC-to-manufacture-some-of-Qu...
- peteyPete 5y agoThere was a good report on CNBC the state of chip manufacturing, TSMC, etc.. There is investment in building two large fabs in the US to help solve some of the current issues and to help avoid being cut off in case of geopolitical instability in the region. Worth the watch. Secretive Giant TSMC’s $100 Billion Plan To Fix The Chip Shortage https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GU87SH5e0eI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GU87SH5e0eI
- GeekyBear 5y agoApple has a long history of buying their suppliers a production line in return for guaranteed production levels, going back to the start of the Tim Cook era. An early example. https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2005/11/21Apple-Announces-Long-Term-Supply-Agreements-for-Flash-Memory/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2005/11/21Apple-Announces-Lon... A more recent example. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-corning/apple-awards-iphone-supplier-corning-250-million-from-u-s-manufacturing-fund-idUSKBN1W217H https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-corning/apple-award... If you go back to the time when Apple was looking at single sourcing all their SOC production at TSMC, you'll see TSMC's CEO publicly saying it would make sense to dedicate a Fab to a single customer. >The world's leading foundry chip maker Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. Ltd. is considering operating single-customer wafer fabs, according to chairman and CEO Morris Chang. "I think that they are going to be larger customers, and now it makes complete sense to dedicate a whole fab to just one customer and hold that – to hold fabs in fact to just one customer." https://web.archive.org/web/20120728040723/https://www.eetimes.com/electronics-news/4391104/TSMC-says-single-customer-fabs-make-sense https://web.archive.org/web/20120728040723/https://www.eetim... I think the reason that Apple is always first in line at TSMC is that they bought TSMC a Fab.
- Someone 5y agoYes, it is capitalism at work. Whomever pays more, decides. Apple says something along the lines of “we guarantee to buy x million chips this year, y million next year. We know it’s expensive to build that capacity, so here’s a few billion up front”. That’s an offer few can make and nobody else is willing to make.
- _ph_ 5y agoThe big point indeed is, that Apple pays in advance to finance the buildup of the production facilities. Of course they get the first access at the output as a consequence.
- donny2018 5y agoThat’s reasonable, I guess. If that is “capitalism” (with negative connotation) then what is more fair alternative to this?
- 23iuhj23oi 5y agoSamsung S21 beats iPhone 13 in performance (!!!) despite using a less advanced semiconductor technology (not TSMC) and being an older smartphone: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MxC6eVjPFQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MxC6eVjPFQ So, Apple CPUs are not that great at the end. By the way, the guy on the video forgot to turn off power saving mode on S21 (-> less performance) and S21 still beat iPhone...
- akmarinov 5y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QaI3tGLStVQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QaI3tGLStVQ Here's the reverse video where the iPhone beats the S21 ...
- elzbardico 5y agoYeah, sure, a random guy in youtube that gets an opposite conclusion to all the established tech press review teams.
- Zigurd 5y agoThis is Tim Cook's strategic masterpiece. Everybody knows how he made the iPod dominant with a supply chain strategy. That same pattern was repeaded in other places in Apple's products with less media attention. This is next level: Without building his own fabs, Cook has dominated microprocessors with a combination of an industry leading design and dominating state of the art manufacturing. This is even better than what Intel had in their dominant period because this strategic pattern can be shifted into different areas of products and their supply chain. The car industry better watch out.
- smoldesu 5y agoBy the time Apple gets to the car industry, I reckon European antitrust will be knocking them over, hard. There's no way Apple can continue to play this game of lockout without attracting attention from international interests. The US doesn't care since they're domestic, but Europe's repeated questioning is preparing to reach a boiling point...
- Jensson 5y agoOr when China decides they want to compete with Apple for real.
- smoldesu 5y agoI doubt it. They wouldn't punish a lapdog for obedience.
- dang 5y agoIf you continue to post unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments, and otherwise break HN's rules, we're going to end up having to ban you. You've been doing it a lot, and it's not what this site is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Decabytes 5y agoUsing another foundry is good because we need to break TSMCs monopoly. But AMD using a different foundry brings back Glo-flo nightmares
- MrBuddyCasino 5y agoIronic, given that Nvidia is moving away from Samsung for the next gen GPUs. Rumour has it they are dissatisfied by production capacity and yields. Can't imagine their N3 process will be much better, but its good they found customers to finance their latest node with I guess.
- enragedcacti 5y agoyou can't necessarily conclude that Samsung's N3 will be worse because their N8 was worse. Bleeding edge manufacturing requires gambles every couple of nodes with what technology you decide to invest your R&D into. TSMC's mix of lucky and good with EUV patterning won them an advantage over samsung who kept rolling with DUV for 8nm. Intel similarly gambled and fumbled around the same time. Lots of people were asking why TSMC wasn't charging a higher premium for their 7nm when it was the best process in the world, my theory is that they understand the above and need to maintain relationships for the possibility that Samsung (and Intel as they adapt their business model) can come back around with a little bit of luck and a lot of investment.
- xyzzy_plugh 5y agoThis is really nothing new. Apple has been playing this game for years, ask anyone who shared an adjacent floor with Apple in Foxconn in the last decade. Whether it's unibody aluminum milled frames, bleeding edge injection molding, glass, silicon... It's done nothing but good for Apple to be aggressive and as vertical without owning the manufacturer as possible. Some of their processes are _years_ ahead of what anyone else can get their hands on, because they buy all the equipment, lease all the floors, and just throw money around like it's nobody's business. AMD and certainly Qualcomm can't touch em.
- jeswin 5y ago> Some of their processes are _years_ ahead of what anyone else can get their hands on They are about a year ahead on CPUs. But pretty much everything else (screens, camera sensors, battery) has been on a par with, or behind what everyone else is doing.
- hinkley 5y agoUh, no? When they moved away from unibody laptops they did so by introducing friction-stir welding. That was hot tech on Boeing airplanes at the time. Some of those Boeing patents are still active.
- WithinReason 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friction_stir_welding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friction_stir_welding Cool! I mean hot.
- danuker 5y ago> unibody laptops You mean the "unibody" made of two sheets of aluminum glued together in a way that the heat unsticks the adhesive? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7XSckjRPo0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7XSckjRPo0
- hinkley 5y ago
- zucker42 5y agoIs Samsung 3nm competitive with TSMC 3nm? The information I'm finding online says Samsung 3nm pretty close to TSMC 5nm in density (for example [1]). [1] https://www.breakinglatest.news/business/samsung-3nm-technical-indicators-exposed-even-intel-7nm-is-not-as-good-samsung-samsung-2/ https://www.breakinglatest.news/business/samsung-3nm-technic...
- ksec 5y agoYes, because Samsung decide to be the world first in GAA ( Gate All Around d) hence first generation of 3nm is essentially a TSMC 5nm in density but slightly better in performance or energy and power on paper. ( Blame Samsung ) Think of it as TSMC 4nm. Their 2nd Generation 3nm which should be what AMD and Qualcomm are using should he little better than this but we dont have any data. ( yet )
- oDot 5y agoDoes anyone know if Samsung's 3nm and TSMC's 3nm are the same? I recall different fabs measure differently.
- jpgvm 5y agoThey have long since become disconnected from feature size. They are more just for progression/naming purposes now. I think these 2 are similar in performance with TSMC with a slight edge from memory.
- gigatexal 5y agoGood. More supply for Apple at TSMC and more customers for Samsung to drive down per unit costs and make bigger investments to compete in the chip space. This move really only helps the semiconductor manufacturing market and makes it more likely that Apple will be able to make all the hardware their fans like me buy up so ravenously.
- libertine 5y agoCouldn't this pose a case to force TSMC to open their IP? It's a genuine question - because they're in such a crucial industry, and they're taking sizes based on order volume, damaging other businesses?
- melff 5y agoI don't think Taiwan is too keen on breaking TSMC's monopoly, not to mention all the other international politics around this.
- fundad 5y agoChips are critical, the highest value new process chips are not as much. AMD and Qualcomm’s PR departments want you to think otherwise.
- LdSGSgvupDV 5y agoI don't think that would work. Even if they open their IP. Who would like to put billions of money into fabs for a maybe 2-3 years of shortage? How to guarantee this would success? How to cover the cost after shortage? There are plenty of crucial industries. Lots of them are in US, Europe, and Japan. Would they open their IP? No. The only way to break that situation is starting the war commercially or physically just like how US bullied Japan in 80s and China right now.
- stemc43 5y agothis is so depressing (for those not mac fanboys). while amd is pushed out me as a consumer is gonna end up suffering.
- ksec 5y agoAnd this is the start ( if it hasn't already started ) of PR campaign against TSMC. Its going to be a long journey, probably take 4 - 5 years.
- ZuLuuuuuu 5y agoCan't talk much about AMD but Apple-first policy isn't the problem with Qualcomm CPUs. Anybody who follows Qualcomm news knows that they were 99% focused on 5G for the last few years. TSMC 7nm node is available to them for a long time, and yet, they couldn't even come up with an answer to Apple's 2 year old A13 which was also TSMC 7nm. I know I know, they bought NUVIA (which is widely believed to become the savior of Qualcomm CPUs), but we won't see any results of that acquisition until 2023.
- blackoil 5y agoIf it continues for few years as expected, it would be interesting see how anti-monopoly agencies/govt. will handle it. Unlike other times/resources, processors are a matter of concern at all levels. Supply chain issues with unprecedented demand means TSMC can't increase capacity even if money is not an issue. If Samsung can't compete, we'll have a complete monopoly. Apple gaining marketshare because of this should be a matter of concern for many nations.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hristov 5y agoThere is a bigger problem than Apple first that the article does not mention. It is Mediatek second (i.e., after apple). Mediatek used to be a strictly second tier mobile processor maker, with Qualcomm and Apple's internal team occupying the first tier. Now Mediatek has overtaken qualcomm in market share. The main reason is that TSMC is making more chips for Mediatek than Qualcomm. One can explain TSMCs preferential treatment for Apple based on purely commercial terms. Apple is after all the biggest foundry services consumer and they usually demand the advanced nodes which tend to be more expensive. But there is no such explanation for TSMCs preference for Mediatek over Qualcomm. Qualcomm is generally as large as Mediatek, in fact they used to be significantly larger before TSMC hobbled them. Well the first explanation that leaps to mind is patriotism (mediatek is a taiwanese company like TSMC, Qualcomm is American). But if that plays a significant factor then perhaps the chipmakers of the world should not so eagerly trust TSMC to make their chips.
- Jensson 5y agoDoing business with people who live in the same area, speak the same language and have the same culture is a lot easier and less risky.
- NonEUCitizen 5y agoMuch more likely is that MediaTek was willing to invest what's needed (i.e. agree to TSMC's asking price) to catch up to / overtake Qualcomm. Qualcomm as incumbent could've taken too much time trying to negotiate a lower price (e.g. "if you don't lower your price, we'll go to Samsung!").
- throwaway19937 5y ago> But there is no such explanation for TSMCs preference for Mediatek over Qualcomm. Qualcomm is generally as large as Mediatek, in fact they used to be significantly larger before TSMC hobbled them. Qualcomm has a longstanding reputation as a bad actor; they're the Oracle of hardware. It's easy to believe that other companies would prefer to avoid doing business with them.
- Animats 5y agoIt's starting to look like there will be a glut in fab capacity 2-3 years out. New fabs are being built in all the major industrial countries. 29 fabs, with a total cost of $140 billion, are under construction.[1] Even auto parts maker Bosch, fed up with automotive supply chain problems, is building a fab. Capitalism is starting to work again. [1] https://community.cadence.com/cadence_blogs_8/b/breakfast-bytes/posts/semifabdb https://community.cadence.com/cadence_blogs_8/b/breakfast-by...
- shmerl 5y agoShouldn't there be some anti-trust limitation on that?
- mikhailt 5y agoHow would we define the limitations on this? Natural monopolies are not illegal and Apple is selling hundreds of millions of devices that use these chips every year. Apple silicon is in every Apple Watch, Apple TV, iPhone, iPad, Macs of all sizes (soon), headphones, and so on. Placing limitations on a single company itself would be anti-competitive because we'd be restricting natural monopolies from growing and placing favoritism on other competitors, which itself wouldn't be fair either. Wouldn't Apple customers suffer just as well because they can't get Apple Silicon SoC due to supply restrictions enforced on them? Apple isn't stocking chips to prevent others from taking over, they're buying every supply they can to ensure they have enough to sell all year long and they're planning several years in advance. Put it another way, if AMD was richer years ago, AMD would be doing the same thing to get larger share. There's nothing stopping AMD and others paying TMSC several tens of billions of dollars to build a fab for them. Also, let's remember that AMD had their own fab but sold it off (GlobalFoundries).
- shmerl 5y agoNatural monopolies are supposed to be heavily regulated though even if they aren't illegal. If you don't regulate them, they'll abuse the market by being monopolies. The fact that they are natural simply means it's an area where they are very likely to occur due to high cost of entering the market. Like imagine not regulating a natural monopoly that provides electricity. They'll serve only areas they want and will not serve the rest. Good idea? Nope. Requiring them to serve areas equally is a proper method exactly because it's a natural monopoly.
- LdSGSgvupDV 5y agoYou are right. We should have a world level regulation on US dollar or any other currency also. QE for every countries should be regulated by the whole world not FED or central bank in a single country.
- georgeburdell 5y agoAs an outsider, dealing with Apple as a vendor strikes me as dealing with the mafia: once they've set their sights on you, they'll make you an offer you can't refuse. Should you accept, they'll give you a shot of capital in the arm and you'll grow faster than you ever could have to meet their schedules. Soon, your engineers are tied up in daily afternoon stand-ups to go over the latest data with Apple's engineers, and they're dictating your R&D schedule. Your company is effectively dependent upon Apple because investors expect revenue growth. Inevitably, however, they'll discard you when a cheaper competitor comes along, or they decide to take the work in-house. Should you refuse, they'll poach away your employees, or enable your competitors to do the same. I haven't thought of a scenario where a vendor can actually rebuff Apple and stay intact.
- klelatti 5y agoHas any of this happened to TSMC? Are they now the most valuable semiconductor manufacturer? Which is not to excuse some of Apple’s less moral behaviour.
- georgeburdell 5y agoIt's been covered in the media that TSMC loans its employees to Apple. You can also tell that Apple's fingerprints are on TSMC's leading edge node processes because products using it clock lower and consume lower power than comparable Intel processes. Also, to my knowledge, TSMC doesn't particularly stand out in semiconductor sub-fields where Apple doesn't play, such as III-V, embedded memory, and photonics. They are definitely at risk of getting disrupted in these areas.
- klelatti 5y agoApple is the biggest TSMC customer. I would be astonished if Apple doesn’t influence TSMC’s R&D, product focus etc. But to characterise Apple as somehow abusing their relationship with TSMC as a result of what you’ve said is not right. It’s just a normal commercial relationship between a customer and a large supplier. Also bear in mind that TSMC has a large number of mobile SoC customers - maybe they think that’s their strength and focus on that rather than say photonics. Seems to be working!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ruslan 5y agoHow about the good old principle "don't build around one customer" ? In long term Apple will twist their hands out. I don't think TSMC management is so dumb not to understand that, yet their shareholders may be.
- ngcc_hk 5y agoBetting the whole firm onto a chip is something started the computer industry - ibm s360 cost wise is second only to nasa mission to the moon. Apple from beginning has to be sure it can sell … people can ignore m1 as they need boot camp to windows at the very least. They can. You bet they don’t … then ipad, MacBook and iphone can merge and this is Hugh. One day it may not play out. Bombing by china say. But the risk of betting is in the blood of a lot of successful IT firms. For startup easy. For big firm like ibm then and apple now. It is crazy. Sort of.