10 ms·
I'm perpetually perplexed at why some people seem to think that lowering the standards is going to help anyone. Do they not realise the source of all scientific
by userbinator 5y ago
I'm perpetually perplexed at why some people seem to think that lowering the standards is going to help anyone. Do they not realise the source of all scientific and technical advancement is really the result of a minority of high achievers, and that by trying to "flatten" this inequality and effectively make everyone equally stupid, they are also going to be affected negatively?
applies social justice principles to math lessons
The inmates aren't running the asylum anymore; they're running the government. All I hope is that this cancerous ideology (I'll resist the prop65 joke...) doesn't grow any further than it already has. The decline is certainly sad to see and already rather visible.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoYou have to understand, this is no trap. It goes as planned, the masses will rap. Mad to the max, under the thunderdome. Their new home, erected by truly democratic means. Who are you to insist that someone intervenes? Bow to your new transqueer queens!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gumby 5y agoWhat if you invert your thesis. Sooner doesn’t necessarily imply “higher standard”: 1 - American school teach the alphabet before grade 1, and push kids to read early. German schools don’t even teach the alphabet until grade 1' yet by the end of that year the reading level of the kids is the same as US kids at the end of grade 1, or better. German Pädagogin justify this by saying there is some neural development issue — I think that is likely bull. But what I do recognize is that instead of being pushed to read before the kids are ready, the kids instead learn other valuable life skills. I happened to learn to read at age 5 (not in Germany nor USA) but that didn’t make me “better” than other kids; they did other things. 2 - kids who have parents who can afford tutors and such can push the kids through the prescribed steps sooner. Kids whose parents each have two jobs to get food on the table, well, they simply can’t. So the former define “higher standards” because they chose their parents well? 3 - To combine the two: if we can open up opportunities for all the kids aren’t we likely to end up with a larger pool of well educated people who will end up being the inventors, leaders, poets etc of the future? How many ramanujans are we leaving behind? I’m not saying “throw out all the standards” but rather quite the opposite. I think your unidimensional absolutism is narrow and inadequate.
- watwut 5y ago> German Pädagogin justify this by saying there is some neural development issue — I think that is likely bull. Why would that be bull? Kids brains develops over time.
- gumby 5y agoGood question: I should not have phrased it that way at all. I mean there isn’t a sharp delineation that magically happens; there are n factors (some large, unknown number) each of which develop at a slightly different rate in each child; there’s nothing magic about reaching 6. My opinion might reflect an accidentally rigid expression of this when my own kid was 6. Thanks for your comment!
- Hitton 5y agoad 1) that's caused simply by phonemic orthography of German. English orthography is hell compared to that, it's not surprising that they need to start to learn it earlier.
- dathinab 5y agoUhm, are you sure. I multiple times heard from exchange students that the standard of the English curses they had in the US hand been below the standard of the English cursed they had Germany...
- threatofrain 5y agoIf there was a mixed program where you could either choose to have your children under Equitable Math or Common Core (the current standard which is adopted by the majority of US states), that would risk Equitable Math being framed as the way to fall behind. That's why the central contention is not about improving Common Core, but rather about whether all children should always be at the same level. Sometimes children benefit from a delay, and other children benefit by moving ahead; but all children deserve the opportunity to advance according to their individual math ambition and ability. Under Equitable Math, all children must be at the same level up until the last year. This is a huge win for private schools and after-school programs such as RSM.
- candiodari 5y agoThat would be a political goal (not having Equitable Math get framed) that is implemented by putting a cost, or at least a reduction of service, onto every child. Besides everyone knows what the real problem is: teachers not having decent levels at a bunch of subjects themselves, and not willing to improve. This is about saving money on the back of children, not about being equitable. Whilst there should be some allowance for high achievers and (very) low achievers that no teacher has much influence over, the average achievement of students is very much a property of the teacher, not so much of the students. This is about cheaper and less capable (not just in subject knowledge either) teachers, at any cost to children.
- threatofrain 5y ago> Besides everyone knows what the real problem is: teachers not having decent levels at a bunch of subjects themselves, and not willing to improve. It is not abnormal for Californian high schools, including in some of the prestigious areas mentioned in other posts, to have math classroom sizes of 40 children, with classroom size penalties ending in middle school. When classroom sizes get that big, the problem becomes one of classroom management (are children even listening now?) and targeting average performance. And then there is the matter of teacher pay. To have the credibility to convince the math faculty that you are ready to teach Calculus, you likely have a Masters in education and a Bachelors in math. Such a technical person may just have well earned a CS degree instead. Lastly, the students. The schools which are severely underperforming are those schools where absenteeism may be enormous... in all classes. This is not a matter of math teachers not being engaging or ambitious enough. One might merely volunteer at some schools in East Palo Alto to see some of this. These are problems which extend well beyond the school. I would also ask, if learning were just a matter of quality instruction, then what's wrong with Khan Academy? Khan Academy is a world class resource and it is delivering pedagogical wins. But something is missing.
- cik 5y agoThis is the problem. It's also horrifically bad for the future economy. For comparison, the rest of the world - at least the parts that want to catch up aren't running this slowly. Also - I think the lack of basic Science + Math education is part of the reason we see things like vaccine hesitancy - but that's just a guess. My daughter in grade 4 (Israel) is currently learning basic algebra tenets, notably associative, commutative, and distributive properties in basic equations, in addition to basic solve for variable questions. SIN, COSIGN, TANGENT and friends start in grade 6.
- dekhn 5y agoThe associative property is not remotely a basic algebra tenet (it's widely used, but it's a much more basic form of symbolic math). It's spelled "SINE, COSINE, and TANGENT".
- cik 5y agoAgreed - associative properties aren't solely basic algebra, but that is how they're (mostly) thought of in the early years. I'd argue a step further that commutative properties have a direct link to other subject, and aren't strictly algebra either. However, neither of these change the point I made.
- charlieyu1 5y ago[flagged]
- thenewnormal 5y ago>they are also going to be affected negatively No. "they" are going to lead fine lives, revered as warriors against social injustice, and living in the most exclusive corners of the state. As is typical, the next generation will pay the price. For what it's worth, it drives me crazy too. The only reason we live such comfortable lives, that we can dedicate so much effort and money to such considerations, is due to the giants on whose shoulders we stand.
- watwut 5y agoI engaged in math competitions and such as a kid, I hope we can put this into the realm of "higher achievement". I dont think minimum standards or curriculum moving accross grades have all that much to do with what competitive higher top does. The higher top require way more knowledge then what standards require. And more importantly, it requires more depth and speed. High achievers are expected to know so much more then standards and to apply it in much higher variety of situations to compete.
- wesleywt 5y agoI only got into algebra late. Some people just have more advantages earlier. Why is this concept so hard to understand?
- bla3 5y agoIn my experience, high achievers become interested in topics only covered in higher grades sooner or later anyways. And once they do, they pursue them only out of interest and intrinsic motivation, and that tends to boost their motivation. So I don't think this affects high achievers all that much either way. Almost by definition, school (and everything else) is designed for the top of the bell curve. Now, maybe school plan design can move the median ability up or down, and I don't have an opinion on if this change here does that, and if so, in what direction. I do think it doesn't affect the high end much either way.
- lordnacho 5y agoSure, that works for resourceful high achievers. There's probably a lot of kids who wouldn't go looking for interesting stuff simply because they don't have access to their own computer, or there's no teacher who's noticed that they are interested in stuff and has extra time to throw a few bones their way. Basically self starters who haven't been ignited yet.
- delusional 5y agoLet's cut the bullshit and get straight to the heart here. Are black people, in your opinion, predisposed to be bad at math? If yes, then i guess your opinion is at least logically consistent. If no, then why are they (according to the article at least) underachieving? If black kids aren't being served by the current curriculum, then I think it's reasonable to assume that some white kids aren't either. I suggest that certain kids are being served poorly by the current system. If those kids were served better we could lift the floor, which would enable the high achievers to reach even further. If you have 100 high achievers it's much more likely that one of them will produce a breakthrough than if you have 10.
- userbinator 5y agoRegardless of which side of the race-intelligence debate you're on, this will only widen the inequality. If you want blacks to achieve more, you should be investing more in their education. Not making things easier for everyone because then they will just continue to underachieve while those who can afford private schooling and such continue to excel.
- dopamean 5y agoWait a sec... you almost sound like you think there are legitimate different sides to the "race-intelligence debate."
- candiodari 5y agoYes, there is the Californian position, which is really very racist. Even more than outright saying there are racial differences in intelligence. Why? These actions will: 1) HIDE the difference from the weaker students (whether black, or poor, or ... we can abstract about which exact group you think is less capable here) 2) take away the opportunity these classes give children to work to compensate In IQ studies it is reported diligent work can increase your aptitude by slightly above 2 standard deviations, if you start young enough. That would imply that with enough support some mentally retarded people (which starts at IQ ~85) can be taught up to above normal intelligence (IQ ~105) Both factors of course increase whatever innate differences exist. I find it very hard to believe these people working for California, who have studied pedagogy, would not be aware of this. So you can be very sure they are purposefully working to hide the difference. Well, until these kids try university, or to find a job. Then it can't be hidden anymore. Also, then it'll be much more difficult for them to do anything about it. So this is very much about denying kids opportunities, for the personal gain of the people implementing these policies.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y ago> All I hope is that this cancerous ideology doesn't grow any further than it already has. Give me one reason why you think your hope is valid. Everywhere I look this attitude seems to grow stronger and even discussing it becomes socially awkward, at least in some circles.
- argentinian 5y agoThe situation sounds very similar to what happened in Argentina. About 30 years ago, Argentina's education level was good. In the name of social justice , high school standards were significantly lowered by the populist/socialist ruling party. Low grades started to be considered 'stigmatizing' for the students. The effect is that now there are some children that finish high school without being able to read fluently. Don't be like Argentina. However, regarding math, if there are cognitive research studies that justify delaying some topics, I don't consider that as negative.
- etergri 5y agobecause most people are morons. The same who advocate that males and females are completely 'equal'. They are not. And you can rage all you want, there are and there will always be evolutionary differences. Deal with it, idiots. Discriminating != pretending differences don't exist.
- KorematsuFredt 5y agoThe mass universal education system was designed to control and brainwash masses. The massive "free and universal" education movement launched by US was meant for this sort of end games and I am not surprised at all. Having said that as a priviledged parent I merely chuckle at this social justice wanking as my kid goes to a private school and is tutored by me. She will be more successful than the "equity" kids from California if eveyrthing else remains the same.