53 ms·
Magit, the magical Git interface (2017)
- sharmin123 5y agoHow to Protect Your Privacy And Personal Data from Hackers?: https://www.hackerslist.co/how-to-protect-your-privacy-and-personal-data-from-hackersfrom-hackers-protect-personal-data/ https://www.hackerslist.co/how-to-protect-your-privacy-and-p...
- AtticHacker 5y agoI've honestly come to the point where I have my handful of most used Magit key combinations to handle certain tasks. But I wouldn't for the life of me know how to apply those with raw git.
- pritambaral 5y agoYou could look at the magit-process buffer (hit $ in a magit buffer) to see what commands (and output) were run. That's how I look up when I have to replicate sth I did in magit in a non-magit context.
- agumonkey 5y agoIt's a little concern of mine too. But there are worse things in life
- seanc 5y agoI tell people that even if you're not an emacs user, it's worth installing emacs just for magit.
- mrtranscendence 5y agoOhhh. "Magit" like "magic". I've been pronouncing it "maggot" this whole time.
- gnarbarian 5y agoI like "Maggot" better.
- counthoyle 5y agoThis is almost embarassingly geeky, but I pronounce it as "MAH-giht" because the spell list in the original Wizardry game used "MA" as a prefix for the "upgraded" version of mage spells. E.g. "Halito" was "little fire" and "Mahalito" was "big fire". So it's "version control UI" and "better version control UI"
- mrtranscendence 5y agoMaybe as a compromise I could pronounce "muh-git", as in "emacs has a good client fer usin' muh git".
- eddieh 5y agoI pronounce it maggot despite knowing the “proper” pronunciation. I don’t care—it is maggot and that’s that.
- password4321 5y agohttps://github.com/arxanas/git-branchless https://github.com/arxanas/git-branchless is worth a look as well. Currently alpha, and "designed for use in a repository with a single main branch", but offers extended undo and rebase functionality.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dimitar 5y agoI started using it recently. It feels more like a git app in emacs, you use it in a separate buffer from your files. The shortcuts are ergonomic (single key presses, no gymnastics with modifier keys) and mnemonics are good: s(tage), c(ommit), p(ush).
- chriswarbo 5y agoNote that magit-blame can be run from a file buffer. I also like git-timemachine for stepping a file forwards/backwards through commits (that's not part of magit, I just think it's neat)
- aryamaan 5y agoIf it's so great why are people not building it out of emacs :P
- Tomte 5y agoI think https://github.com/jonas/tig https://github.com/jonas/tig and several other such tools are kind-of like that.
- thom 5y agoEdamagit exists for VSCode and is actually quite a faithful conversion. I would love more modes like that in VSCode that just use editor buffers to get work done instead of feeling the need to create lots of inconsistent custom UI.
- suprfnk 5y agoNext to other posters, there's also LazyGit (https://github.com/jesseduffield/lazygit https://github.com/jesseduffield/lazygit), and vimagit (https://github.com/jreybert/vimagit https://github.com/jreybert/vimagit). So yea, people are building it out of emacs!
- izifortune 5y agoI have both but I found myself struggling to use vimagit over lazygit as it feel faster to work with. Do you have any specific workflows that you prefer one over the other?
- zelphirkalt 5y agoOn the lazygit repo readme an animation is shown with a single line commit prompt/dialog. Suspicious. Is there a way to expand that one-lined thing to enter more? So I looked up "multiline commit" in the issues. Several not solved but closed issues came up and multiline commit messages seem to still not be available. This would be an instant deal breaker for me, if I were trying to use lazygit. Commit messages are not bullet points or titles. In magit I can simply type in a new buffer as much as I want to.
- robbrown451 5y agoI want to know if it is a hard G as in Git, or soft G as in magic. Ok, soft G might be the best choice.
- jrootabega 5y agoMuh git is an option
- ogogmad 5y agoGit is literally an insult in much of the English speaking world. So hard g as in "maggot" would be consistent.
- yakubin 5y agohttps://magit.vc/manual/magit/How-to-pronounce-Magit_003f.html#How-to-pronounce-Magit_003f https://magit.vc/manual/magit/How-to-pronounce-Magit_003f.ht...
- agumonkey 5y agoHonestly it's a non existent phonetic in my head... a [jgj] kinda.
- bregma 5y agoIt's "G" as in "GIF".
- seanw444 5y agoIt's all clear now!
- submeta 5y agoMagit is an exceptionally well made interface to Git. Yes, it’s built on top of Emacs, and that might stop many from even looking into it. - I am glad I made a deep dive into Emacs last year, and although I stopped using it as an IDE (VS Code is just too good), I still come back to it because of Magit (and macros, general text editing and org-mode). Yes, I have an interface for Git in VS Code as well, but it‘s very rudimentary compared to Magit, and it’s limited to the narrow left bar. And to give an example: Making „micro commits“ by staging various lines of changes is super easy in Magit, but I still haven‘t found out how to select several disconnected lines for staging in VS Code.
- smitty1e 5y agoSpacemacs.org brings the vi modal editing configuration to bear and is highly recommended.
- aldanor 5y agoGiven I've been on/off Spacemacs / Doom for years myself, I would definitely pay for a well-packaged isolated one-click-installable Magit as a separate git client.
- viccuad 5y agois this enough? alias magit='emacsclient -t -c -e "(progn (magit-status) (delete-other-windows))"'
- rusk 5y agocould you use magit without knowing emacs? I guess you could ... but I can imagine people getting frustrated when the windows keybindings they're used to don't bring forth the expected behaviour. CUA mode exists. Would that be enough? Is magit good enough to actually force people to learn that little bit of Emacs?
- cyberbanjo 5y agoI dunno, as I am an emacs user, but I have a similar binding for using calc through emacs client.
- seanw444 5y agoCool to know I'm not the only one. Calc is a similarly magnificent piece of Emacs software that I don't see mentioned as much as Magit. With Org, Emacs really is the ultimate all-in-one productivity/research/dev bundle. At least in my opinion.
- rusk 5y agoI recently tried out spacemacs and doom on too different new computers but I just couldn’t make them work for me. Maybe if I was coming to emacs from VIM they’d make more sense. I’d recommend that if you want to do emacs from scratch it’s probably easier to just start Witt vanilla and build up your own config. The hardest part is the muscle memory but you’re going to have that with spacemacs/doom too and then you’ve all the noise of these environments to contend with on top of that.
- warpech 5y agoIf GUI is your thing, I recommend giving Sublime Merge a look. I absolutely love it. I've heard that there are similarities to Magit in the terms of capabilities, e.g. staging (or reverting) by line.
- globular-toast 5y agoThat's an example of an "other git interface" as described in the article.
- yewenjie 5y agoMagit is insanely ergonomic. Like how easy is it to selectively stage portions of files in the git CLI? In magit it is usually just a few keystrokes. I wish magit-forge [0] had more features though - like I cannot create new labels from it. Please consider donating [1] to the developer if it has made your life any easier. [0] https://github.com/magit/forge https://github.com/magit/forge [1] https://magit.vc/donate/ https://magit.vc/donate/
- saghul 5y ago> Like how easy is it to selectively stage portions of files in the git CLI? git add -p Then you can decide if each hunk is staged or not.
- feffe 5y agoCool, didn't know about that. To boost Magit a bit, you can stage parts of patch hunks, I use that quite a bit. Just select any parts of the diff using regular edit text select commands and press "s" for stage.
- angio 5y agoIn my experience magit version is much faster to use since you can simply select which lines you want to stage without having to refine the hunk.
- ljm 5y agoNot even just lines - you can selectively stage arbitrary regions too.
- the_gipsy 5y agohttps://jonas.github.io/tig/ https://jonas.github.io/tig/
- jaytaylor 5y agoA terminal ncurses alternative to Magit :) What is Tig? Tig is an ncurses-based text-mode interface for git. It functions mainly as a Git repository browser, but can also assist in staging changes for commit at chunk level and act as a pager for output from various Git commands.
- johnnyAghands 5y agoI've been using tig for things like this. Are they related somehow? Tig is amazing :)
- keyle 5y agoAlso recommend lazygit. I use it everyday and it's pretty awesome.
- berkes 5y agoFor the lazy: it is on github. https://github.com/jesseduffield/lazygit#readme https://github.com/jesseduffield/lazygit#readme
- rgoulter 5y agoMagit's more feature-rich and has better discoverability than tig, from what I can tell. e.g. with tig, you invoke "!git commit" by pressing C from the status page. With magit, from the status page, commit is performed by pressing cc. But, if you press only 'c', a context menu is brought up which shows the flags which can be set, and commands which can be run. e.g. 'cc' is 'commit', but 'ca' is 'amend'. e.g. An example of a flag might be "--force-with-lease". So, press 'P' opens the push context menu, '-f' enables the "--force-with-lease" flag, 'p' pushes to the remote. (Or just 'P-fp' quickly works, too). tig looks like 80% of the benefits (much nicer to use than git) for 20% of the effort (not having to learn Emacs).
- aequitas 5y agoI love Tig for quickly visualising and browsing the Git tree. Wish it would support interactive rebase in a more elaborate way so you could maybe reorder or amend commits from the tree view itself, instead of breaking out into Git commands.
- lillecarl 5y agogit-imerge rebase is what you want, git-imerge is one of the coolest tools I've used.
- xvilka 5y agoIs there something like Magit for NeoVim? Preferably in Lua.
- FrontAid 5y agoneogit is "magit for neovim". It is written in Lua. Did you already know the answer to your question? ;) https://github.com/TimUntersberger/neogit https://github.com/TimUntersberger/neogit Similar Git tooling can be found in https://github.com/frontaid/git-cli-tools https://github.com/frontaid/git-cli-tools
- erik-h 5y agoI've used vimagit for a long time (it's not in Lua, but it's pretty awesome): https://github.com/jreybert/vimagit https://github.com/jreybert/vimagit
- FrontAid 5y agoIt does not really seem to be maintained anymore. Is there any downside because of that?
- jboynyc 5y agoLooks to me like it had commits in June and August of this year. Or do you wonder whether they'll add features like pushing from within vimagit?
- FrontAid 5y agoI did see the commits, but the last release was almost three years ago. That is not necessarily bad. I was just wondering whether it still works well or there are any quirks.
- xvilka 5y agoMany Vim plugins abandoned the release model since most Vim and NeoVim package managers focus on fetching latest git HEAD for every installed plugin.
- KingMob 5y agoThis post is the epitome of "tell, don't show", when it should be the opposite. It reads like it wants to convince you to try magit, without demoing a single example of how it's superior.
- erk__ 5y agoThen this post may be more appropriate https://emacsair.me/2017/09/01/magit-walk-through/ https://emacsair.me/2017/09/01/magit-walk-through/
- jrootabega 5y agoEven though I use magit and I think it's the best git porcelain that exists, I felt the same way before I started using it, and a little of the same way whenever I need to go find out how to do something I haven't done before.
- skohan 5y ago> Commands are invoked, not by typing them out, but by pressing short mnemonic key sequences. It also sounds magical in the worst kind of way.
- jrootabega 5y agoIt's just like vi, for whatever that's worth to anyone. It also has "transient", which shows you what the key sequence you've input so far will do and lets you customize it.
- jwr 5y agoMagit is such an unbelievably good piece of software. If you haven't used it, please at least take a look. It seems like "just a GUI for git", but that's missing the point — many operations suddenly become frictionless, so your entire workflow changes. I regularly do things like "stash some of my changes, switch branch, cherry pick a commit, switch branch, do an interactive rebase reordering commits and dropping one, pop one of my stashes", and they become routine, so working with code becomes a fluent experience, rather than fighting with your tools. I would say that Magit and structural editing using Paredit are the two most important technologies that make programming great.
- agumonkey 5y agoThe first two extension I set in Emacs. Reminds me it's time to tip some projects.
- wodenokoto 5y agoCan I like magit if I don’t like emacs?
- mgr8 5y agoyou can try https://github.com/jesseduffield/lazygit https://github.com/jesseduffield/lazygit, i think its quite similar. It is a TUI for git. It has made my git workflow very friction-less. Makes it very easy to cherry-pick commits, rebases, selecting chunks of files to add in atomic commits, and simplifies the resolutions of merge conflicts. It is also integrated into lunar vim if vim is more up your alley
- sokoloff 5y agoYou can, but it will be worth it for you to spend a little effort to learn the basic buffer, window, and cursor management keystrokes. My 12 year old uses magit as a git interface and nothing else in emacs. That’s not a great testimonial as it was my direction to do that, but it seems to work just fine. The areas where magit earns outsized praise is not around a basic “pull, add and commit everything, push” workflow, but rather around being selective about crafting self-consistent but single-theme revisions. That will not be as fluid for someone with no fluency in emacs keyboard navigation, but I think I’d still find it easier than using the git command line to do it. (Hard for me to say with 30 years of emacs in the rear view.)
- jhoechtl 5y agoAs a vim-user I wonder how fugitive compares to magit?
- eequah9L 5y agoAs a magit user, I would like to know as well.
- agumonkey 5y agoMagit should be studied in computer classes. I'm from the eclipse j2ee college era. They tried heavy OO guis, none matched the ergonomics of magit. I'm still surprised to this day how lean and translucent magit feels. People should try this kind of thinking instead of big engineering principles that only slow the machine and the user down. It's only the 13th time I wrote this.
- bsdubernerd 5y agoFor the sake of discussion, can we get some contrarian views? I'm using magit, along with tig, plain git and sometimes (!) even plain "vc", depending on context. I'm in the camp that thinks it's ok and it's pretty comfortable to use within emacs, but I don't see the earth shattering praise I see every time it's mentioned here. Tig for example is so much faster for history and blame perusal that I find it faster to keep it open in another terminal and just switch to it. Altenatives? Contrarians?
- jidiculous 5y agoI can't imagine (haven't tried it so I'm just speculating here) that Magit functions very comfortably on something like a deep clone of the Linux repo, but I think there would be very few monolithic projects most of us would encounter with that kind of lengthy history in our day-to-day work. Maybe some Googlers could weigh in on how their large repos are handled by Magit?
- grumpyprole 5y agoMagit is unfortunately so slow on Windows that it's unusable. This is a real shame, because the UI is fantastic. I think a better architecture would use libgit2 calls rather than launching multiple git processes for every single magit operation.
- jolmg 5y agoIs the launching of processes on Windows so much slower than on Unix-type OSes that it would cause it to be "so slow" for that reason? Maybe the reason is another? Personally, I once had Magit act real slow at times because git-annex had added some git hook for something that I didn't need. Just removing that hook improved performance massively. Perhaps something similar is happening. Also, I'm not sure Emacs Lisp can interface directly with C libraries, so using libgit2 might not be an option.
- grumpyprole 5y agoI'm pretty sure it's the main reason. Look how many times Magit shells out to git to render the status buffer, too many to count: https://github.com/magit/magit/issues/1327 https://github.com/magit/magit/issues/1327 In a perfect world, Emacs would link to libgit2 and Magit would be adapted and folded into the core distribution.
- G3rn0ti 5y agoI was pretty skeptical about magit at first because I know all the basic git commands for my daily workflows by heart and I don't find them to be very difficult or slow to use. But since I am also an Emacs user and everybody kept telling me to try it out I finally forced myself to use it. And I must say it is very easy to pickup and use productively. It is way better than most of the git integration features you get with your typical IDE (like VScode for example) because magit supports most git workflows pretty seamlessly. It integrates itself nicely in Emacs' keyboard driven UI. So now I don't need to drop to a shell anymore to interact with git. But does it make me much more productive? I don't know. While developing typically I add some debug code mangled with the actual stuff. So when I am ready to commit I've got to remove that first. I had done this manually in the editor before, now from within magit I can just select the lines I'd like to stage and press "s". Then proceed to commit pressing "c". Finally, by just selecting the remaining lines and hitting "k" ("kill") I get rid of all debug code. That's pretty nice and I will never ever forget to remove debug code again. Similarly, you can manage your git stash with a couple of key strokes. Branching and merging works well, too. But I don't think magit makes it much easier as you still need to type in branch names. Autocompletion is supported, but git provides this as well. Merge collisions are still a pain. And for more complicated tasks like interactive rebases, reflog rescues or bisecting I still keep dropping to the shell. I actually like the expliciteness, here, because it prevents me to stupid things in dangerous maneuvers. And "git help" is always there to remind me on all gazillion command line arguments.
- gpderetta 5y agoI find magit very nice for interactive rebases. The ability to instant fixup older commit is also nice. But yes, I do drop to the shell for some actions when I know exactly the sequence of git commands that I need to execute. Also somehow I often use the shell to switch branches, some habits are hard to change.
- b3morales 5y ago> I was pretty skeptical about magit at first because I know all the basic git commands for my daily workflows by heart and I don't find them to be very difficult or slow to use Same here. I've found completing-read for branch names to be one of the biggest draws for Magit, personally. I can tab-complete them in my shell, but it's much slower and less reliable.
- StreakyCobra 5y agoTip of the day: you can have `magit` as a fast and standalone tool by using this script (require emacsclient to be setup properly): #!/usr/bin/env bash emacsclient -c --eval "(progn (magit-status) (delete-other-windows))" This will open the repository under the current path in a maximized magit window. The only downside I have for now about magit is when using `pre-commit` it can run for long sometimes, so it would be nice to see the progress/output of pre-commit while waiting for the commmit message buffer to appear. If you know a way I'm all ears.
- hirple 5y agoYou should just be able to hit `$` in the magit buffer to watch the output.
- StreakyCobra 5y agoOh… when git fails I always have to navigate to the end of this buffer so I thought it would not auto-scroll. I should have tried earlier. Thanks!
- drekipus 5y agoSeeing a co-worker use magic inspired me to try out fugitive on the vim side and I'm actually blown away. So it's excellent in more ways than one. Also inspired me to try out Emacs but that's a longer story
- nivenkos 5y agoFugitive is amazing. I was once pair programming with someone, noticed a weird line in the code, used the in-line git blame, then open that whole commit, and could analyse all the changes right there in neovim. Compared to opening up Github, or stashing and checking out via git manually, it was so much faster.
- infinitezest 5y agoI'm surprised that I had to scroll this far down to find mention of fugitive. I haven't ever used magit but I use fugitive every single day and absolutely love it.
- laserlight 5y agoI will say it right away: Magit is one of the best software I've ever used. Please support it regularly. Scroll to the bottom of the page to learn how to support.
- shepik 5y agoI use git from the command line, so this looked like a tool i would use. I was able to install it with apt, but i could not find any information on how to run it. Manual says "C-x g" [1], which obviously does nothing in bash. And I have no idea how to use emacs. Is there any helpful user manual? Should i give up on magit? [1] https://magit.vc/manual/magit/Getting-Started.html https://magit.vc/manual/magit/Getting-Started.html
- krylon 5y agoEmacs comes with extensive documentation. "C-h t" opens an interactive tutorial that teaches the basics, "C-h r" opens the manual. "C-h i" opens the Texinfo browser that gives you access to even more documentation, including manuals for Emacs Lisp and Magit (if installed). The learning curve is fairly steep in the beginning, but after ~15 years, I feel that the initial effort has paid off a lot. Not everyone likes emacs, and that's okay. But I do think it is worth giving it a try and seeing for yourself. (As for the whole vi-vs-emacs debate, I have used both over time, and I do use vi quite regularly for quickly editing some config file. There are packages for emacs, like evil-mode, that emulate vi's key bindings and behavior, but I have not tried any of them.)
- seanc 5y agoStay with it! I would suggest you launch emacs with a file in the repo, ($ emacs <filename>) and then run magit, "C-x g". Then you're in the magit window with menus and prompts and so forth.
- dunefox 5y agoYou can give Spacemacs a try if you want Vim bindings.
- krylon 5y agoInitially, I switched from fossil to git because I had to use it at work. After finding out about magit, I have never looked back. For me, magit made git not just painless but actually fun to use.
- funOtter 5y ago" Posted on 1st September 2017 " I'm surprised this has been around for so long and I have not heard of it.
- auslegung 5y agoI love magit, I’ve been using it for a year, which is as long as I’ve been using Emacs. But can someone please tell me how to pronounce magit? If I try to make it sound like magic, I pronounce it the same way as maggot, which seems wrong. If I put the emphasis on the second syllable so that it’s emphasizing git, that also feels weird.
- amai 5y agoGit doesn't need a more complex interface. It needs a more simple interface. Magit is a complete failure in this respect. The author seems to think it is easier to remember "Ctrl-x g" than "git status". Instead we need more tools like Legit: https://frostming.github.io/legit/ https://frostming.github.io/legit/
- faustlast 5y agoThis idea of remembering keybindings in emacs is false. You need a command, a function call, the keybindings are just for convenience...
- jrockway 5y agoI've never seen the upside. I use Emacs as my primary editor, and I regret it every time I say "today is the day I start using Magit". It is exceedingly invasive, triggering itself even when you don't ask for it (like running "git rebase -i" on the command line). The invasive stuff changes how the text editing itself works, but doesn't add deep features. In the interactive rebase case, I lose the ability to treat the interactive rebase text as text, but I also don't gain anything. I can't just navigate around, kill a line, and put it somewhere else. Well, I can do that, but the usual keybindings don't work, they just made their own for no reason. And, for example, if I do use their UI and pick "reword" as the operation for a certain commit, I should be prompted for the desired rewording then and there, right? But that's not what happens, I press C-c C-c to commit my changes (why isn't it C-x # which is how I'd normally close an emacsclient session?), then Emacs goes away, then it comes back up, then I can type my rewording. If you pick it more than a few times, you just get a seizure from all the flashing lights. This isn't a good user interface. It's a bad user interface. Obviously, my experience must be unique, because everyone loves Magit. It might be the most-loved piece of software ever. Every other week, there is an article on Hacker News about how it's the best piece of software ever to exist, and I've never seen anyone say anything bad about it. So I wonder what marketing techniques they use to make people feel this way; the emotions are strong, and widely shared. Maybe there is some fundamental insecurity about Git, and Magit makes people comfortable? I've never felt that way, but I did start using Git the weekend it came out, and my Github user ID is in the low 2000s, so I might have had time to get Stockholm Syndrome with the Git UI. I suppose it's possible that the people writing these articles may not have even been born when Git came out, which is interesting to think about actually!
- agentultra 5y agoI've not experienced this and I suspect most people don't is all. It's probably not personal and certainly not magic marketing sauce. I am a magit lover and have been using it for at least a decade now and can't imagine going back to a terminal. It's not the marketing. It just works really darn well and it speeds up my workflow.
- bombcar 5y agoUsing git for so long is almost certainly what’s up - you not only know all the various commands but “grew up” with git so you didn’t get them all in a rush. Many many people use git as cvs and are confused once it goes past “commit and push”. I know I don't really know what to do if someone pushed to master whilst I was working and it complains. Usually I just make a new checkout and merge in by hand.
- tuxguy 5y agoNoob question : is magit only for Emacs users ?
- jeremyjh 5y agoYes but there is a VS Code version of it that is pretty decent: https://github.com/kahole/edamagit https://github.com/kahole/edamagit
- invincivlepvt 5y ago<a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Logo Designing Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Logo Designer</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/“ https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/“ rel="nofollow">Logo Designing jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Logo Designer Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Logo Designer Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Logo Designing Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/logo-designing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Logo Designer Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/“ https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/“ rel="nofollow">Poster Designing Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Poster Designer </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Poster Designing jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Poster Designer Jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Poster Designer Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Poster Designing Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/poster-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Poster Designer Jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/“ https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/“ rel="nofollow">Banner Designing Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Banner Designer </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Banner Designing jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Banner Designer Jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Banner Designer Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Banner Designing Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/banner-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Banner Designer Jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/“ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-... rel="nofollow">Business Card Designing Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Best Business Card Designer </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Business Card Designing jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Business Card Designer Jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Best Business Card Designer Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Business Card Designing Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Best Business Card Jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/“ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-... rel="nofollow"> Visiting Card Designing Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Best Business Card Designer </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Visiting Card Designing jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Visiting Card Designer Jalandhar </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Best Visiting Card Designer Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Visiting Card Designing Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/business-card-designing-jalandhar-..." rel="nofollow">Best Visiting Card Jalandhar </a> Webdesign <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Web Designing Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Web Designer Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Website Designing Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Website Designer Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Website Designing</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Web Designing</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Website Designer</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Web Designer</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Web Designing agency jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Best Website Designing agency jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Web Designer</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-designing-jalandhar-2/" rel="nofollow">Website Designer</a> Webdevelopment <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Website Development Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Web Development Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Web Development</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Website Development</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Web Development agency Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Website Development agency Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Website Developer Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Web Developer Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Website Developer Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Best Web Developer Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Website Developer</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/website-development-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Web Developer</a> Home <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Graphic Designing</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Digital Marketing</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Digital Marketing Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Graphic Designing Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Digital Marketing Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Website Designing Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Website Development Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Website Designing Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Website Designing Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Website Development Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Website Designing</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Website Development</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Graphic Designing Agency jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Graphic Designing Company jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Digital marketing Company jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Digital marketing Agency jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Graphic Designing Agency Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Graphic Designing Company Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Website Designing company jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Website Designing company Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow"> Website Development company Punjab </a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/ https://invincivlepvt.com/" rel="nofollow">Website Development company Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Youtube Marketing Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Youtube Marketing Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Youtube Marketing</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Video Marketing Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Video Marketing Jalandhar</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Digital Marketing Punjab</a> <a href="https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/ https://invincivlepvt.com/youtube-marketing-jalandhar/" rel="nofollow">Digital Marketing Jalandhar</a>
- bsimpson 5y agoBased on the article, it seems like a CLI implementation of SublimeGit.
- omaranto 5y agoIt's not a CLI at all, it's text-based UI that runs inside Emacs.
- caned 5y agoBetween using Magit and org-mode, I don't know how I could ever transition away from using emacs. I've tried to resist it, I've sworn it off and moved to exclusively using vim + command line tools for several years, and yet I keep coming back. The degree of integration between these tools is making my workflow more and more seamless over time. emacsclient has made working from multiple terminals a breeze; I don't even bother with screen or tmux anymore. And just recently I've discovered org-roam. The whole experience in emacs just keeps evolving for me. Now if I could only find an emacs email client whose interface I can tolerate...
- clojureyoureyes 5y agotried Wanderlust?
- tacker2000 5y agoI never used Magit, I have been using SmartGit for years now and I see the great benefits of git GUIs. Checking logs, checking and merging changes, searching for files and commits… all this is much easier to do with a GUI. Of course, for complicated stuff one should still know the cli commands, but 99% of the time the GUI is what makes me more efficient and faster.
- CyberShadow 5y agoI <3 magit. I believe I was the first to implement a major feature in it which was rejected upstream! So now I maintain a fork :) https://github.com/magit/magit/issues/4285 https://github.com/magit/magit/issues/4285 Thankfully, package managers such as straight.el make it very easy to configure using a fork of some repository, without breaking dependencies.
- beermonster 5y agoMagit doesn’t abstract git away so much as make it more accessible. For those that know Git, it’s an intuitive UI improving productivity and for those that don’t, an invaluable learning tool organised logically. The documentation is first-class and it’s a real pleasure to use. It’s a real gem. And although a cliché, it’s the reason I install emacs in the places I do.
- dr_pardee 5y agohttps://magit.vc/manual/magit/Installation.html https://magit.vc/manual/magit/Installation.html Bye, Felicia
- dang 5y agoPast threads: Magit 3.0 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27274670 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27274670 - May 2021 (140 comments) Magit – A Git Porcelain inside Emacs - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24431216 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24431216 - Sept 2020 (83 comments) A walk through the Magit interface - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21729597 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21729597 - Dec 2019 (81 comments) Forge – Work with Git forges from the comfort of Magit - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19137353 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19137353 - Feb 2019 (34 comments) Magit 2.13 released - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17220630 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17220630 - June 2018 (49 comments) Show HN: Magit, the magical Git interface - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15358723 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15358723 - Sept 2017 (5 comments) Magit Kickstarter fully funded - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15312288 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15312288 - Sept 2017 (71 comments) Magit (fantastic Git mode for emacs) is running a crowdfunding campaign - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15263869 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15263869 - Sept 2017 (4 comments) Magit on Kickstarter - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15154712 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15154712 - Sept 2017 (1 comment) It's Magit the Magical Git Client by Jonas Bernoulli – Kickstarter - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15150476 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15150476 - Sept 2017 (2 comments) Emacs and Magit - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14819256 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14819256 - July 2017 (174 comments) Magit maintainer taking a break - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11077526 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11077526 - Feb 2016 (1 comment) Magit: a Git porcelain inside emacs - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10643977 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10643977 - Nov 2015 (14 comments) What's new in Magit 2.x - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9936095 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9936095 - July 2015 (23 comments) Using Emacs and Git with Magit 2.1 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9873237 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9873237 - July 2015 (29 comments) Magit a Git Porcelain for Emacs - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9547948 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9547948 - May 2015 (2 comments) Meet Magit - Git Mode for Emacs - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2543265 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2543265 - May 2011 (4 comments) Magit: Emacs mode for Git - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=361697 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=361697 - Nov 2008 (2 comments)
- imbnwa 5y agoHow is that pronounced?
- asimpletune 5y agoI feel like I'm missing out on a lot by not knowing emacs. I tried to learn emacs once, and the tutorial started with "I've been using emacs for about 25+ years and I'd say I'm about a middle of the road user"... that was when I was like, "No, I'll just keep using IntelliJ or vscode or whatever". It's not that I love or even care about any IDE, I just literally haven't the first clue as to even get started with emacs. So what should I do if I want to give it a second chance?
- cryptolake 5y agoYou should take a look at doom emacs.
- d_tr 5y agoYou could keep using your current IDE and use Emacs for the simpler tasks while you are learning it at whatever pace is convenient for you. I am a new Emacs user. I decided to give it a try about ten days ago, so I followed the built-in tutorial, read a bit about minor and major modes, buffers, global and buffer-local variables and it started making sense. The online documentation is extensive and the built-in documentation system is very easy to use.
- devcrvft 5y agoI read this as magical girl interface until I finished reading the article and looked again....
- lindeng 5y agoGive me magit+org on top of a more modern foundation than GNU Emacs and I'll be set for life. I wish Emacs would let go of its "It's Free GNU, baby!"-past and instead focus more on user adoption and innovation. Emacs has such a brilliant community, but the project itself feels as stagnant as Vim did right before the community gave Bram the finger and made Neovim..
- savingsPossible 5y agoHow reasonable would it be to use magit given that I dont know (and dont particularly want to know) emacs?
- faustlast 5y agoI would say: don't bother. It's good if you want to use emacs as well.
- ajross 5y agoI mention this every time this comes up. But I absolutely hated magit. It's the worst kind of "nannyware knows best" integration, and it doesn't belong anywhere near an editor. It's a fine front end to git, I'm sure, if you're actually willing to stop and re-learn how to use git. In my particular case, it was cute for a while until I did my first "git rebase -i" to reorder some patches or whatever and found myself in some kind of magical editor mode where nothing worked the way I knew. I literally couldn't figure it out from what was on the screen. Totally greek. Utterly useless without further learning. Did I stop and read the docs to figure out how it wanted me to rebase in this brave new world? Hell no. I restarted emacs, disabled it, and never looked back. Right into the garbage it went. Do. Not. Break. Workflows. Software that doesn't understand this principle is something I don't trust not to break itself when its developers decide to get cute. Stay away. (Does seem pretty though)
- hnarayanan 5y agoYour past tense usage of the word 'hate' made me think your story was going in a very different direction.
- codygman 5y ago> Do. Not. Break. Workflows. Software that doesn't understand this principle is something I don't trust not to break itself when its developers decide to get cute. What use would magit be if it presented the exact same interface as `git rebase`? Do you know what it would lose? > Did I stop and read the docs to figure out how it wanted me to rebase in this brave new world? Hell no. I suppose you don't since you didn't read the docs. Why try it in the first place if you expected it to be the exact same?
- jimmyvalmer 5y ago> Do. Not. Break. Workflows. Speaking of "nanny knows best," your pretentious use of punctuation and capitalization triggers a three-alarm d__che alert. I'll assume your patronage of incontinence products followed naturally from applying this maxim when potty training.
- codygman 5y agoA great video introduction to magit: https://youtube.com/watch?v=_zfvQkJsYwI https://youtube.com/watch?v=_zfvQkJsYwI
- MichaelMoser123 5y agoI have my own vim plugin for git https://github.com/MoserMichael/gitblame https://github.com/MoserMichael/gitblame Please check if out, your feedback would be very much appreciated
- ktzar 5y agoHow does not compare to tig? I've been using it for half a decade and there's only like 6 mnemonics you need to memorise to stage single lines,increase the line count context for diffs, etc...