22 ms·
Michelin Airless
- EvanAnderson 5y agoThis design looks to be much less mosquito-breeding-friendly than traditional tires at least. I was shocked when I learned how much "help" discarded tires lend to mosquito breeding.
- kaminar 5y agoCheaper no flat bike tire solution: be sure to install a quality wheel liner (inside of wheel, over the spoke edges), then install a quality plastic tire liner (inside the tire, between the tube and tire tread)...the tube is the weak point, not the tire. Wheel spoke edges cut tubes easily and are not often covered. These 2 items will protect your tires from glass, nails, curbs, etc...no flats ever. Ps: stay away from slime products
- jpm_sd 5y agoWould these work on Mars rovers too?
- bkanber 5y agoMars rovers already use tires like these.
- amelius 5y agoOr how about bicycles?
- jaclaz 5y agoSuperwheels, discussed here (but tyres remain conventional): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25158215 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25158215
- dingaling 5y agoSpring tyres were used on bicycles in World War One https://onlinebicyclemuseum.co.uk/ww1-german-bicycles/ https://onlinebicyclemuseum.co.uk/ww1-german-bicycles/
- bkanber 5y agoTweels are probably too heavy to be viable on bicycles.
- amelius 5y agohttps://www.bridgestone.com/corporate/news/2017041701.html https://www.bridgestone.com/corporate/news/2017041701.html
- bkanber 5y ago> The companies will advance feasibility studies seeking to make this new tire available in market by 2019. Given that I haven't seen tweels for bicycles yet, I assume the feasibility studies did not go well. It also looks like they also announced that bicycle tweels were 'coming soon' nearly two years ago: https://jalopnik.com/bridgestone-says-airless-tires-are-coming-soon-to-bicyc-1841140591 https://jalopnik.com/bridgestone-says-airless-tires-are-comi...
- bb123 5y agoI always wonder how these things would stand up to stones getting caught in between the rubber “spokes“.
- mabub24 5y agoCompletely guessing, but I wonder if they designed the "spoke" baffles to pinch in under the load and thus expel any stones that might fit between them, like a pebble squeezed between your two fingers and shooting out.
- rbanffy 5y agoA pebble shooting out of the upper side of a tire of a car at 250 km/h is probably as bad as a bullet. Probably worse.
- kadoban 5y agoSo about the same as a pebble that gets stuck in treads or kicked up by same? Definitely better than a bullet though just by nature of lower speed, what it's made of and because of its poor aerodynamics.
- rbanffy 5y agoThese spokes seem to be able to fit larger pebbles that may be launched from the side of the wheel and escape the wheel well.
- TimTheTinker 5y agoI don't think that part of the tire is open to the outside -- you're seeing a cross-section in the pictures and video.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- drewmol 5y ago
- karmicthreat 5y agoI will believe it once I see them drive the same tires on West Michigan roads for 29k miles during the spring. We’ve had highways just disintegrate during the thaw here.
- ytechie 5y agoWouldn't these be great for trailers? Trailer blowouts are common, and often unnoticed, or can heavily damage the trailer. I have no interest in these on a car, but for a trailer, sign me up!
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoI think they'd be better for trailers than cars because all the tradeoffs people are complaining about (small increase in rolling resistance, NVH, inability to air up for increased load or down for comfort) are far lesser in a trailer application. Combine that with all the trailer tires that go bad from long term exposure to the elements before they get worn out and it seems like an obvious application. But..... one of the most important aspects about trailer tires is cost and these may not quite be there yet. Michilin and other tire manufacturers don't really compete much in that space and leave it for the low end import brands to fight over. Rental trailers and towed equipment (like towed light plants and air compressors) seems like the only obvious niche where both the cost and downsides are justifiable.
- einpoklum 5y ago> Airless technology will drastically reduce the number of tires that are scrapped because of punctures. Well, maybe, but don't these new tires use more rubber instead of air? In which case they will actually increase the amount of discarded tires? Also, what about the recycling potential of these tires? I'm not an automotive buff, but this claim of being "good for the environment" sounds like just empty marketing talk.
- jrootabega 5y agoI wonder how hot those spokes get at speed.
- aezell 5y agoI see a LOT of lawnmowers in my area with this kind of tire. It's especially prevalent on the larger, commercial mowers that landscape professionals use.
- musicale 5y agoInteresting - the design seems to have built-in v-shaped rubber shock absorbers all around the tire.
- skywal_l 5y agoIs it only hype? What about road adherence, endurance, etc. As long as I don't see independent assessments by car journalists, I'll reserve my judgement. But if they live up to the hype, it will be a game changer indeed.
- wayoutthere 5y agoFrom my understanding, the dealbreaker is that these tires are incredibly noisy at highway speeds.
- jcims 5y agoIIRC they have some interesting attributes. Lateral stiffness is incredibly high, but IIRC rolling resistance is higher and they are quite a bit heavier than standard tires. Seems like there might be some interesting capabilities to pump air one way or the other for aero purposes.
- x62Bh7948f 5y agoI remember reading about airless tires back when I was in high school and it seemed like the concept was ready for mass production in a couple years. That was around 2004~5 ish. I wonder how much has changed and how close are others, like bridgestone.
- chinathrow 5y agoDo tire manufacturers really have the desire to develop tires with less tear?
- bkanber 5y agoFormer automotive engineer chiming in. "Tweels" have been around a long time, but have always failed in terms of "NVH" (noise, vibration, harshness). Michelin is claiming that this generation of tweels are appropriate for passenger cars, which means that they think they've solved the NVH problem. They seem to be marketing these alongside EVs, I wonder if they're only really intended for lighter, compact-style cars. (Edit: I'm talking about EVs like the BMW i3, which are on average about 1000 lbs lighter than the cars most Americans drive, ie, the CUV/SUV form factor.)
- 725686 5y agoMaybe the noise they generate is good for EVs which are dangerously quiet for pedestrians?
- smilekzs 5y agoValid point, although pedestrian safety is mostly discussed in the low-to-mid-speed regime (<= 45 MPH), while tire noise (at least according to my own observation) dominates in the high speed regime (>= 65 MPH). There might be some overlap though. Also worth pointing out: NVH is not just Noise --- it includes Vibration and Harshness that are only felt by the people inside the vehicle.
- Scoundreller 5y agoAnd effective at rattling off any untorqued/loose nuts/bolts.
- agumonkey 5y agoSome EVs have mandatory sound emitters to not be fully silent (and thus dangerous). I thought it was weird harmonics from the synRM engine but it's synthetic and enforced by regulations.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoI thought it was a plastic valence rubbing on something.
- alecst 5y agoWhat technology finally brought this idea to market? I'm impressed and happy that it exists, but it seems like this should have been around years ago.
- bkanber 5y agoThey were around years ago; Michelin's first tweel was developed in 2004.
- intrasight 5y agoGood video I just found https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ql0Mkr3dwNU https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ql0Mkr3dwNU
- Yizahi 5y agoI don't worry about punctures at all, despite living in a country with a shitty roads. What I worry about A LOT is a catastrophic collision of tire with a 90 degree sharp pothole edge, often made by roadworkers before doing point repair, which potentially can destroy tire irreparably. I wonder if these tires are better protected against such impacts, and just looking at them it seems they are - no side walls which are cut in a strong impact. Looking forward to more impact tests of these tires.
- rodgerd 5y agoPunctures are much more of a problem for me - the roads are generally good, but tradies seem to love scattering nails, bolts, and other random bits of construction crap on the roads.
- bkanber 5y agoThese tires do have sidewalls. The sidewalls are removed for marketing and demonstration purposes only.
- marcellus23 5y agoI'm sure everyone in the tire industry (?) knows that, but it would be nice if Michelin had something to suggest that on their page.
- bkanber 5y agoThe only little clue is that one photo of the EV where the sidewalls are visible on the tires. You have to squint to see it :)
- marcellus23 5y agogood catch!
- jacquesm 5y agoTotally missed that on first reading, thank you for pointing it out.
- t3rabytes 5y agoMichelin has been talking about these things for years and has yet to actually put them into production. All talk and no show.
- ur-whale 5y agoRide comfort on those?
- bkanber 5y agoRide comfort on tweels has historically been poor. But Michelin seems to be claiming they've solved that problem for this generation.
- syncsynchalt 5y agoThe same claim has been made yearly for the past century and a half. I don't think that any advancement in materials or mechanical science can create a solution that outperforms the advantages of a standard pneumatic tire.
- markild 5y agoInteresting that they say nothing about consumption. I would expect them to be less fuel efficient, but having some number to go by would be nice.
- bkanber 5y agoAs a general rule, tweels are worse for fuel consumption -- they are both heavier and have more rolling resistance. (Edit: weight automatically adds rolling resistance, but so does flexion, which tweels have more of. So tweels are a double-whammy for fuel economy.)
- kbenson 5y agoI wonder how that breakdown works for under inflated and overinflated tires, and what percentage of the nations tires are in that state at any moment? For a consumer product like this I think it's probably more important to compare the common case than the optimal case, because I know my tires often aren't in an optimal state, and as much as we could save as a nation by making sure tires were inflated correctly, we just don't, and I don't expect that to change meaningfully.
- bkanber 5y agoOverinflated tires will always have better economy than underinflated, all other things being equal. My guess is the average vehicle owner could improve overall fuel economy by about 0.5-1.0% by making sure their tires are at the correct pressure.
- kbenson 5y agoSo, my thought when I said that was back when Obama mentioned keeping tires inflated correctly and getting tuneups to reduce oil consumption, and looking into that lead to this[1], which puts it at 0.6% on average, but up to 3% in specific cases. So I guess the question is how does 0.6% fuel economy loss on average for current tires compare to the loss in efficiency for using a Tweel, but according to some data from Michelin here[2], it looks like they're actually projecting them to be more efficient than current tires? I didn't read through the whole analysis, so I'm not sure, but that's what Table 7 looks like to me at a cursory glance and reading a few paragraphs in that section. 1: https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/maintain.jsp https://www.fueleconomy.gov/feg/maintain.jsp 2: https://manufacturing.gatech.edu/sites/default/files/uploads/pdf/2011-01-0093.pdf https://manufacturing.gatech.edu/sites/default/files/uploads...
- bborud 5y agoI wonder what the speed rating of these will be. (I'd guess they would overheat really fast if you drove them even moderately fast, plus the inertia would be pretty insane?)
- jrootabega 5y agoI had the same thought, but they probably have cooling built in to the hub.
- jaclaz 5y agoPrevious related thread here (about one month ago): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28537549 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28537549
- ableal 5y agoThanks. Second comment: """ I am an engineer working in the tire industry (throwaway is needed here). The Michelin "Tweel" IP was actually acquired when Michelin bought BF Goodrich 31 years ago. Goodrich developed the concept as a replacement for compact spare tires, doing the initial R&D in the 1980s. Every 3--5 years Michelin has a press release like this, and the technology is always 3--5 years away from release. Currently the US DOT and it's equivalents abroad are still in the rulemaking phase regarding airfree technologies, so there's that, too. """
- mcguire 5y agoWhich brings up the one ideal use for these that hasn't been mentioned: spare tires, if you can make them narrower with the same load capacity.
- _fat_santa 5y agoI wonder, how would airless tires be able to handle offroading? On the one hand they seem like the perfect candidate as running over a rock or stick won't cause the tire to puncture. But on the other hand you loose the ability to air down the tire for more traction.
- andreygrehov 5y agoWhat I like about companies like Apple is when they release something, they explicitly say: "This product will be available in stores starting Oct 15". On Oct 15, you go to apple.com and buy the product online. Done. I can't even count how many years I've heard about airless tires being developed.
- fomine3 5y agoYou don't like to open R&D status but like secret?
- rbanffy 5y agoI wonder if the rubber structural spokes could be shaped to pull air from the underside of the vehicle (tire rotation would be slightly more complicated) to increase stability at higher speeds.
- pomian 5y agoOr cooling. There also might not be expansion with increase temperature?
- rbanffy 5y agoThe wheels themselves could pull air through the brake disks, but their rotation and the shape of ventilated disks already help with that. I think I'll need to instrument my car. If something like this works, it'll seem from the inside the gets heavier the faster it goes in addition to what clever airfoils and aerodynamic design already does.
- j56no 5y agoshouldnt they be “closed” laterally for aerodynamics, to block dirt and snow from getting stuck inside? guess these will collect dirt 100 times more than regular tires no? update: similar questions here https://m.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=206&v=sc8ghIqKqnI&feature=emb_logo https://m.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=206&v=sc8ghIqKqnI&...
- loufe 5y agoIn another comment it was mentioned that there will doubtlessly be "sidewalls" on actual airless tires, and that the exposed ones shown on this page are just for show. I admit that makes a lot of sense given your point about dirt/rocks entering in and effecting the absorption effect of the honeycomb.
- hirvi74 5y agoThey will have walls, this is just a demo model to show the internals.
- agys 5y agoThe 3rd illustration displayed (the one that accompanies the claim “A smaller environmental footprint”) is extremely enigmatic…
- spcebar 5y agoWhat does this mean for those 'severe tire damage' traffic control devices?
- dreamcompiler 5y agoIt means they probably won't work anymore. But they're mostly theater anyway; they are easily defeated.
- syncsynchalt 5y agoThe magic of the pneumatic (air-filled) tire is that the entire air-filled space of the tire acts to absorb shock and vibration from the road surface. Airless tires give up this advantage, and only the tire structure between the wheel and contact patch are available to do the same work. The result is always a heavier tire that is a harsher ride. All the materials science in the world can't and won't find a solution to this. You can safely ignore any airless system for all but the most specialized applications.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThe result is also always an efficiency loss. Periodically solid bike tires become faddish and it's like pedaling a bike made of lead.
- elif 5y agoor a country that has its roads together like japan and china
- modeless 5y agoI am skeptical that these will be better for the environment. Maybe there will be fewer tires discarded due to flats, but the tires will weigh more. That's more material discarded per tire and more energy to drive them around.
- AStrangeMorrow 5y agoMaybe I am wrong, but I think I've red somewhere that these are made to be re-threaded. Meaning when the outer layer get damaged with use, instead of changing the whole tire, just the outer part can be replaced. Not too sure how that works though. If that is the case, it should help reduce the amount of waste by a lot. Plus even if these new tires are heavier, I doubt they are 10 times heavier either. I'd be surprised if the added weight to the car will increase the energy consumption in a very noticeable way.
- andylynch 5y agoThey call it ‘recharging’ on this page. They even propose converting between summer/winter by reprinting the tread.
- modeless 5y agoPneumatic tires can also be retreaded. But we generally don't do it for passenger cars. I'm not sure of the reasons why so I can't say whether these tires address any of them. I'd want to see some explanation before I believe it.
- Chris2048 5y agoSurely the ability to recycle/repurpose an old tyre matters more than the flats, so I'm not sure how this helps. Also, I see the biggest concern as degradation of tyres contributing to rubber-dust pollution: "according to the UK government, and they are the second largest source of microplastic pollutant in oceans after single-use plastic" Seems like it would be better to find an eco-friendly alternative to tyre rubber instead. If this design allows that (e.g. by allowing tyre materials that aren't as stretchy as an inflatable would need to be) I'm all for it, but that's a more complicated definition of "good for environment", dependant on other tech being developed.
- sgarrity 5y agoI have airless tires in the same bucket as flying-cars and video-phones (things that sort of exist, but are always just around the corner from being widely adopted). (I realize that video-phones are kind of widely adopted now via Zoom/Facetime/etc. - I'm thinking more of the vision from the 90s of a telephone with a screen in your kitchen)
- zaptrem 5y agoThose are also widely available now (ie Facebook Portal + similar), but nobody needs them. My grandparents had a similar model which they used until a few years ago.
- tootie 5y ago"Every year, 20%* of tires are discarded as scrap " Really? They cite a survey, but don't link to it.
- thinkling 5y agoTires are usually rated for 40 ,000 to 60,000 miles. Americans drive 13,500 miles per on average[1]. That would cause tires to be replaced on average after ~4 years. So yeah, seems believable. [1] https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ohim/onh00/bar8.htm https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ohim/onh00/bar8.htm
- aidenn0 5y agoI have never gotten the rated tread lifetime on a tire. I've gone through maybe 60 tires in my lifetime and none of them were replaced due to punctures (I had one repairable puncture). Partly because 90% of my miles are stop/go rather than cruising.
- Ensorceled 5y agoThe number doesn't seem to far off. I have summer and winter tires, replace them every 6-7 years. Lots of people drive more than I do.
- lrem 5y agoI don't drive that much and still feel that changing tyres every five years is pushing it.
- aidenn0 5y agoYou misunderstood; the claim is that 20% of the tires that are discarded are due to punctures or improper inflation. 12% of the tires that are discarded are discarded due to punctures or blowouts and 8% of tires that are discarded are discarded due to uneven wear caused by improper inflation.
- whatever1 5y agoWeren’t we trying to reduce plastic waste? This seems to need multiple times the amount of rubber that a normal tire needs. And for what? To prevent a fixable puncture that may or may not happen in a lifespan of a tire?
- jedberg 5y agoHave you ever been driving when a tire blew out at high speed? It's extremely dangerous not only for the driver but all the nearby cars. This is a tradeoff between environmental concerns and safety, as are most safety features on a car. We could make a car that gets insanely good milage and has little raw material, but it would be terribly unsafe.
- whatever1 5y agoYou are not talking about a puncture. You are talking about a catastrophic collapse of the tire from an impact (damn potholes) that has happened to me. I don’t see how these tires are immune to catastrophic failure that typically can take with it the rim and the suspension.
- jedberg 5y agoPunctures can cause those catastrophic failures, especially when they hit the edge near the sidewall.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago> Have you ever been driving when a tire blew out at high speed? It's extremely dangerous not only for the driver but all the nearby cars. Have you? Your characterization of the experience makes me think you have not. I have had two rear and one front blowout. Blowouts are just flat tires that have a loud intro before the typical "driving on flat tire" music. None of them were any more eventful than a normal flat tire. I'd take a blowout (or normal flat tire) over tread separation any day. The internet highly highly highly highly highly overrates the danger, likely because blowouts are so rare these days and unfamiliarity tends to result in fear which compounds the Internet's tendency to reward certain commenting patterns. Other than the noise potentially causing a driver to incorrectly make massive control inputs (which would be equally hazardous to do after suffering a normal flat) there is no more hazard from a blowout than from a normal flat. And I say this as someone who drives old junk with fat sidewalls. On something with small modern sidewalls all the danger is less still. Frankly, the one time I had a valve stem leak that caused a slow flat was much more unnerving as I initially wasn't sure if I was feeling things or if the vehicle was pulling to that side.
- tyingq 5y agoAlso handy for Michelin revenues that the wheel is integrated. Yes, I get that it might be hard for them to be separate.
- JAlexoid 5y agoThey aren't airless, they just don't depend on compressed gas.
- moolcool 5y agoTechnically correct
- JAlexoid 5y agoThe best kind of correct
- danans 5y agoBy that definition, almost nothing but the vacuum of space is airless. Even a galvanized rubber hockey puck is going to have some amount of air in it. Airless in this case means that they don't use pressurized air for rigidity, and therefore they do not need to be engineered to maintain air pressure, thereby reducing material input, and removing a major failure mode. They are wheel-shaped springs.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoI'm unimpressed with their pilot location choice. Las Vegas? Chicago or NYC would be much more of a proper test with potholes, humidity, potholes, temperature, potholes, and precipitation. Did I mention potholes.
- uwagar 5y agothe michelin man is so full of air though
- rahimiali 5y agoThe page uses the phrase "revolutionary structure". It's a fascinating pun to make about a wheel. I wonder if it's intentional.
- themodelplumber 5y agoOr it could just be both...a wheel with revolutionary structure, since wheels are nowadays so much more of an engineering project than a simple circle drawing in a book on theory...
- karambahh 5y ago16 years ago, I was an intern at the European HQ of a Japanese tyre brand. We received and chain forwarded a "leaked" video of Michelin testing a similar design. We ICT folks thought we were doomed as it seemed miles ahead of our own R&D. 16 years later and we are yet to see these tyres on the streets. This time, I'll believe it when I see it ;)
- taoufix 5y agoI'm a bit confused. Are they going to leave the sides open like that? What if a pebble gets stuck in there?
- goodmachine 5y agoFun fact, almost half of particulate road pollution comes from conventional tyres. Not clear whether these new airless tyres will help or worsen that. More resistance = more wear, I would assume. Anyone? https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/195595/worlds-first-device-capture-harmful-tyre/ https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/195595/worlds-first-device-c...
- andylynch 5y agoI head looked at these before, and only now noticed they that talk about retreading/ recharging treads by 3D printing- this doesn’t directly address the particulate issue but is a very interesting idea for reducing the waste from worn tyres more generally.
- koheripbal 5y agoI don't think it will change much. Friction between the wheel and the road will continue, and the surface of the new tire will still need to wear and be replaced.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tynpeddler 5y agoCool stuff. I hope they make it onto the road. What was really interesting to me is that the page suggests that most of their on road testing is done in the US. Michelin is a French company and there are lots of good European card companies. Does anyone know why they wouldn't do their testing in Europe?
- nickpinkston 5y agoThese being around forever, but not being released, I wonder how much of why this is happening now is because they're finally coming off patent?
- jacquesm 5y agoI hope the open sides will be closed up because those are going to be grime collectors if exposed to the weather. I'd expect them to be full of crap before the first month of use is out. Edit: apparently they are.
- henry_bone 5y agoI get that "no punctures means less waste", and "Every year, 20%* of tires are discarded as scrap due to flats and rapid pressure loss (12%) or irregular wear and tear caused by poor tire pressure (8%), i.e., the equivalent of 200 million tires, or 2 million tonnes*. That’s 200 times the weight of the Eiffel Tower." However, there is still the problem of getting rid of "a flexible load-bearing structure made from glass fiber reinforced plastic (GFRP)". I would hope there is a way to degrade, reclaim or reuse these materials.
- toomuchtodo 5y ago> I would hope there is a way to degrade, reclaim or reuse these materials. Plasma gasification
- ElijahLynn 5y agoNice, I have seen this tech ~25 years ago when I was a little boy and always wondered why it never came to market. I think they were called tweels back when I saw them.
- 908087 5y agoHow much more do they weigh than standard tires? I expect the extra material required might end up negating any "environmental benefit" which comes from reduced scrapping of tires due to punctures/etc.
- aemreunal 5y agoSeems like it's 404ing now; here's a snapshot: https://archive.is/9m1gs https://archive.is/9m1gs
- itomato 5y agoFiberglass doesn't recycle well, does it? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ql0Mkr3dwNU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ql0Mkr3dwNU
- ycombigator 5y agoTyre waste arguments seem like absolute nonsense.
- sMarsIntruder 5y agoGetting 404 now
- sam_goody 5y agoCould these be used to drive over the spokes at a checkpoint or garage that prevent entry? Would that have any impact, f such tires would become popular?
- mnemotronic 5y agoIt's dirty out here in the real world. What happens when those grooves get plugged up with mud, bits of glass & other tires and dead squirrels? But I'll admit, I do want the "Picyures to download".