14 ms·
136 Countries agree to minimum corporate tax rate
- codesuki 5y agowow, unrelated to the article content, but... I was on the page and thought 'how come there is so little noise on this page and I can focus on the text?' Didn't know there is a 'lite' CNN. I wish the internet would be like that again.
- MR4D 5y ago> * the pact includes provisions to ensure that multinational companies pay tax where they generate sales and profits, and not just where they have a physical presence* Will be interesting to see how Alibaba and other Chinese multinationals deal with this. If they aren’t fully into this, then the whole thing will not work as intended.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhy not? If the Chinese government and the governments where they do business chose to enforce it, then the companies will be paying.
- zsz 5y agoChina will be first in line for this, since it finances its own corporations already (meaning, any tax collected from party-controlled entities -- i.e. all of them -- is reinvested in the same, thus automatically conferring a competitive edge over foreign entities.
- keewee7 5y ago>Four countries that participated in the talks -- Kenya, Nigeria, Pakistan and Sri Lanka -- have not yet joined the agreement. Why not?
- lbriner 5y agoI can only guess that they either have or might want to have in the future, some foreign companies come and base their businesses there to generate some much welcome money and jobs into the national economies. They might also be suspicious of the motivations of the West.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oceliker 5y agoOfficial announcement: https://www.oecd.org/tax/international-community-strikes-a-ground-breaking-tax-deal-for-the-digital-age.htm https://www.oecd.org/tax/international-community-strikes-a-g... List of countries: https://www.oecd.org/tax/beps/oecd-g20-inclusive-framework-members-joining-statement-on-two-pillar-solution-to-address-tax-challenges-arising-from-digitalisation-october-2021.pdf https://www.oecd.org/tax/beps/oecd-g20-inclusive-framework-m...
- cameronh90 5y ago> "The treaty will need to be ratified via a two-thirds majority in the US Senate, which is unlikely given that it allows foreign countries to tax US companies, the Eurasia Group analysts said." So, it's not going to happen then?
- zxcvbn4038 5y agoHaha, I think you called it!
- ko27 5y agoIt will, just like in Ireland. That's the beauty of this deal. It's blackmail basically. If the US does not pass it, other countries will tax the difference even on US profits (company just needs to have presence in the EU). US would be shooting itself in the foot, especially being the one to propose it originally. Also, I am pretty US is already above 15% corporate tax rate.
- cgearhart 5y ago>US would be shooting itself in the foot… That’s very “on brand” for the US. All we need is a change in party running the White House to torpedo our own ideas. See also: TPP.
- wutbrodo 5y ago> All we need is a change in party running the White House to torpedo our own ideas. See also: TPP. TPP was opposed by both major-party candidates by the time of the general election; Hillary Clinton flip-flopped her position on it to pander to Bernie-inclined voters (or charitably, in order to better represent her constituents' views). Regardless, our withdrawal from it had nothing to do with "a change in party running the White House", and we would've likely withdrawn regardless of who won the election. It was just a consequence of the populist wave that swept America across the political spectrum (and is sweeping much of the world).
- 5y ago
- zozin 5y agoMinimum tax rate 15%; tax loopholes unlimited!
- bitshiftfaced 5y agoFor those like me who were confused by what's the deal with removing the "at least" 15% for Ireland: > The vast majority of companies will not be impacted by the proposed increase in the 12.5 per cent corporate tax rate, Taoiseach Micheál Martin had said earlier in relation to this point. > Speaking in Dublin ahead of a Cabinet meeting, he confirmed the Government’s intention was still to only apply the new 15 per cent rate to companies with turnovers of more than €750 million, in line with OECD proposals on the matter. https://www.irishtimes.com/news/politics/ireland-s-corporate-tax-rate-set-to-rise-to-15-as-part-of-global-deal-1.4693782 https://www.irishtimes.com/news/politics/ireland-s-corporate...
- anonymousDan 5y agoThe reason is we (quite reasonably) don't want to sign up to something and then have the goalposts shifted in a few years such that the minimum rate is increased again. Frankly I'm a bit annoyed we even signed up to this. If the US really cared about tax avoidance by their MNCs they could fix the problem tomorrow.
- pavon 5y agoWould you mind elaborating your thoughts on the last bit? I don't pretend to be an expert on international corporate taxation, but in the case of Ireland it didn't sound like US companies are avoiding taxes in the US. All the complaints are about revenues earned outside of the US, which should be taxed outside of the US. So I can definitely see why the EU would be upset with Ireland's policies, and support participating in treaties to make the situation more fair, but it seems inappropriate for the US to unilaterally "fix" a disagreement that is largely between EU member nations.
- yojo 5y agoMy understanding is that schemes are often employed to shift profits that occurred in high tax regimes to lower tax ones. E.g. company registers their IP to subsidiary in <low_tax_nation>. That subsidiary charges crazy royalties for the rest of the company to use the IP in <high_tax_nation>. The effective earnings in the high tax regime is low or zero because of the “cost” of licensing the IP. Meanwhile the subsidiary in low tax land makes bonkers profits on some extremely lucrative licensing. You can try to shut down these shenanigans playing legal whack a mole, but the law moves slower than the corporations. Or you can just set a global floor on taxes and not have to worry about keeping up with the latest corporate nonsense.
- zxcvbn4038 5y agoThey might agree to raise the rate to 15%, but in reality they will turn around and give tax credits, exemptions, or some other mechanism to bring the effective rate back down to whatever level brings in business. Biden won’t remember anyway ;)
- LeifCarrotson 5y ago> ...it is now supported by all OECD and G20 countries. Four countries - Kenya, Nigeria, Pakistan and Sri Lanka - have not yet joined the agreement. But this list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states contains not 140 but 193 UN member states and 206 listed states. Which are missing? Just to start, I don't see Algeria, Azerbaijan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, or Bolivia listed; to my knowledge those are ordinary nations like the four enumerated. Either it's not "all OECD" because those four are missing, or that list of four is very much incomplete. Or are they saying that those four support it but have not yet joined? Either way, the hard part comes when individual countries have to legislate compliance with the treaty that their state departments have agreed to, and the really hard part comes when other countries have to collectively enforce the treaty when a signatory adds a loophole or ignores it...
- realityking 5y agoOECD only has 38 members: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OECD https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/OECD The four countries mentioned are those that participated in the negotiation but are not signing the final agreement. Unfortunately the article doesn’t explain their objection.
- swman 5y agoI'm no expert but let's say this happens- they'll just incorporate in Space, Moon, or Mars.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 5y ago> they'll just incorporate in Space, Moon, or Mars. Incorporation is a government act. It also is irrelevant if it is not recognized by the governments of the places where you try to do business.
- swman 5y agoI was being cheeky considering big corporations always find a way to dodge taxes.
- gnopgnip 5y agoIt doesn't matter as long as they have customers in the 136 countries that ratified it
- motohagiography 5y agoWhile it may not pass in the US, this is bad news. The reason to do this is to collude to bar the exits to capital flight, and then impose exploitative policies that would not have been possible previously. Why wait for your economy to grow with supportive policy when you can just take from the people today? Humans are innovative, someone will find a new way to make more, and then you can take it from them again and give it to the few who keep you in power. This cynical logic is what makes revolutions inevitable, because this ruling view is that people are basically chattel. Words are just a way to part you from your stuff. We can dress it up as concern for others, but we all know that on these leveled playing fields, some are more equal than others. It is not the playing field that gets leveled, it's us.
- smolder 5y agoThis is one of the too-rare cases where government is doing precisely what you said they aren't doing: leveling the playing field --increasing fairness, as opposed to giving sweetheart deals. I have plenty of concerns with how my government is run and how their tax revenue is allocated, but tax avoidance is a basic problem of fairness and a problem to be solved.
- motohagiography 5y agoFrom the perspective of a state, the rule of taxation is, "progressive, simple, enforceable: pick two." The US code gave up on simplicity and probably has 10% of GDP dedicated to dealing with the result. Specifically, the playing field is being leveled between nations by their colluding against competitive countries to prevent capital from leaving them when their policies become unbearable.
- nybble41 5y ago> The reason to do this is to collude to bar the exits to capital flight, and then impose exploitative policies that would not have been possible previously. Exactly! If a private organization tried something like this most major governments would be rushing to enforce anti-trust regulations against them. But when it's the governments colluding to set price floors, suddenly that's acceptable?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The treaty will need to be ratified via a two-thirds majority in the US Senate Says who? Just because the it is characterized as a treaty under international law doesn't mean it won't be implemented as a congressional-executive agreement [0] in US law, just like virtually every other important economic treaty in the last several decades. Simple majorities in both houses is a lot easier than 2/3 in the Senate. [0] https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Congressional-Executive+Agreement https://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Congressional...
- fsckboy 5y agothank you for teaching me something I didn't know. no thank you for being a teeny bit snarky about it, as if everybody obviously should already know this. oh, and a small correction, it's not the "treaty under international law" aspect that's bothersome, it's the skirting of the treaty provisions of the US Constitution that raises eyebrows.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> no thank you for being a teeny bit snarky about it, as if everybody obviously should already know this. I was responding to the article text; anyone writing a news article speaking to the prospects for an international agreement coming into force in US law ought to have a basic understanding of how that actually happens in practice in US law. > it's the skirting of the treaty provisions of the US Constitution that raises eyebrows. The treaty provision is a permissive mechanism that allows the President, with strong Senate support, to make agreements with foreign nations while bypassing the House of Representatives role in normal legislation. It is not skirting that to make law within the scope of the legislative power through the normal Constitutional legislative process, just because the content of the legislation was agreed with foreign parties. The treaty power doesn't silently reduce the scope of the legislative power.
- pavon 5y agoWhat are the practical differences between the two? Is it that we aren't making any binding agreement with sovereign countries like we would when ratifying a treaty, instead we just happen to change our laws in line with the accord, but are free to change them again at anytime?
- hinkley 5y ago@dang someone else posted this minutes prior to this post. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28801537 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28801537 Same domain, different url format.
- GDC7 5y agoMisleading title, it's just for large multinationals. There will be a revenue treshold of 890$ million This is good news for startups! Cancel that, this is good news for the vast majority of unicorns as well. It's still early because we have to wait and see what the loophole seekers are gonna find, but in any event, as it stands it looks like a good development for startups and VCs. Loophole seekers are disgusting and dumb, they engineer solutions that save billions in taxes for multinationals but aren't paid proportionally. A genius in the transfer pricing dept. at one of the big 4 makes like an above average lawyer in NYC or LA. They are more instrumental to the public company profits than the CEO in many instances.
- president 5y agoThe cynic in me says it wouldn't have been agreed on if the loopholes weren't already baked in.
- goodpoint 5y agoNothing cynical, it's lobbying 101.
- acd10j 5y agowhat will prevent an multinational to make dozens or hundreds of subsidiary with each having revenue threshold of $890 million ?
- evgen 5y agoOh wow! You found that ONE TRICK that governments HATE. Somehow thousands of legislators and economists around the world never, ever thought of that and are going to be completely fooled by a company that structures its revenues in this fashion. I am absolutely sure that will work...
- jessaustin 5y agoDo you believe that "loopholes" exist?
- jakozaur 5y agoThe problem is real, many big tech paid less than 1% on non-USA income. This is likely one of the best agreements in decades. Will increase tax collection by decreasing incentive to avoid taxes. Little burrocracy, huge increase. Previous mesh of transfer prices and other meassures added huge amount of burrocracy on a lot of companies, yet still did not make much difference for the biggest avoiders.
- oh_sigh 5y ago> burrocracy I always felt like we were being ruled by donkeys...
- chosenbreed37 5y agoI see what you did there :-)
- jikbd 5y agoIt’s a common word play in Spanish; I’m not sure that it was intended in this case, though.
- Aerroon 5y agoAnd why is it so important that businesses pay a high corporate tax rate? Isn't it enough to tax the money when it actually leaves the business? (Is paid out.) Some economists say that corporate taxes distort capital allocation.[0] A minimum global tax rate removes the ability for a country to decide for themselves whether they want this or not. Estonia, for example, is worried that their tax system has to change as a result, because they don't charge a corporate tax on money that's reinvested or retained. Edit: apparently Estonia is banking on an exemption for reinvestment. [0] https://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/publications/economic_paper/2013/pdf/ecp503_en.pdf https://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/publications/economic_p...
- Aa9C4xPz43Gg7k6 5y agoFor socialists it's never enough, money has to be taxed 10 times. And I'm not using it in the slur way that Americans usually do. There's a kind of thinking that believes that money belongs to the person who earned it. There's another kind of thinking that treats everything as communal (but managed by elite class at the top of the system), taking anything away from the pile is evil then.
- johntiger1 5y agoSo they'll just move to the remaining ~50 countries that didn't
- nicoffeine 5y ago"Alongside a minimum corporate tax rate, the pact includes provisions to ensure that multinational companies pay tax where they generate sales and profits, and not just where they have a physical presence. That could have major ramifications for tech companies such as Google and Amazon, which have amassed vast profits in countries where they pay relatively little tax." I share your skepticism generally, but it seems like this agreement is a good step towards getting corporations to pay taxes. There's no point in starting a shell company in the Caymans if your taxes are paid based on where your products were purchased.
- mr_toad 5y agoIf I run an .io website selling services to the UK using AWS servers in Singapore and employ coders in India, where exactly do I generate revenue and profit? Sounds like this could devolve into record-industry accounting.
- nicoffeine 5y agoIn the postcode of the card used to purchase the services.
- mr_toad 5y agoSo if I was previously incorporated in the US, and paying taxes in the US, does anyone think that the IRS, and more importantly Congress, is going to give up that tax revenue to the UK?
- nicoffeine 5y agoSec. of Treasury Janet Yellen in a letter to Sen. Crapo, earlier this year: "Treasury also takes seriously the protection of the U.S. fisc. Our Greenbook proposals will bring corporate tax revenue as a share of our economy closer to its 21st century average before the 2017 corporate tax cut. Meanwhile, our Pillar 1 comprehensive scope proposal will be largely revenue neutral for the United States since we will be on both the receiving and giving end of the proposed profit reallocations. Indeed, one interesting feature of Pillar 1 estimates is that they demonstrate the extent to which both U.S. and foreign-headquartered corporations have managed to shift profits derived from sales to U.S. customers outside the United States for years, including under the 2017 tax act." https://mnetax.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Yellen_letter_to_Crapo_on_OECD_tax_negotiations920.pdf https://mnetax.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Yellen_letter_...
- KKKKkkkk1 5y agoI distinctly remember the claim that most economists (left and right) believe the optimal corporate tax rate is 0%, but I can't find the source for this. The argument is that the corporate tax is simply an indirect income tax, and so as an alternative to raising income taxes, all it does is to penalize entrepreneurs for incorporating their businesses.
- jostmey 5y agoExcept some bosses use their business as personal assets. A personal jet is a good example
- Aerroon 5y agoThat is very much illegal though. If the jet is for personal use and the company isn't compensated for it then it's tax fraud.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoThat's straightforward to work-around: arrange for an important industry meeting that's coincidentally in the same city as your weekend getaway.
- Aerroon 5y agoIf you need to set up a business meeting every time you want to use "your" private jet then why wouldn't you just charter instead?
- walshemj 5y agoAsk yourself who pays these "economists"
- russh 5y agoAsk yourself, where does the money the corporations use to pay the tax come from?
- ur-whale 5y agoCountry level collusion. Ugh.
- snidane 5y agoWelcome to the future where only big companies survive. As a small business you don't have means to avoid taxes. As a multinational corp you just invent research, marketing and other fictitious expenses between your branches and always come up with expenses close to incomes, paying 15% corporate tax of close to zero net profits You operate very efficiently in the market where other participants have to carry the 15% deadweight as they are unable to avoid it like you. After certain rounds of Mergers and Acquisitions to achieve ever bigger economies of scale incentivized by the tax system we end up with a few single players per market, if not only a single one. Such bureaucracies become almost indistinguishable from state owned companies operated under soviet union. How that ended up you can find in history textbooks.
- wolverine876 5y agoThe minimum applies only to large corporations.
- dane-pgp 5y agoSo it turns out that "But corporations would just move somewhere else" wasn't a valid argument against raising corporation tax all along, and countries could have agreed this 100 years ago. Now let's create a wealth tax using the same international approach. The treaty could say that each country should have a wealth tax of say 8%, with the first $100m being tax free. For comparison, the average US household has a net worth of $120k and pays $10k in taxes every year. If a billionaire lives in a country that doesn't join the treaty, then the countries which have joined can refuse to allow that billionaire to travel to or through their territory, or own any assets in their jurisdiction.
- phendrenad2 5y agoCounter-intuitively, this will just entrench the rich even more. A tax that only affects large multinationals will just make it harder to become a large multinational. You'll see a big discontinuity in the graph of corporation size. There will be corporations that are large enough to absorb this tax, and corporations that are too small to qualify for it. The "activation energy" to get across the gap will be significant.
- mikaeluman 5y agoPeople pay taxes, not companies. These taxes are poor, because they obscure who is really being taxed. Is it the owners? The employees? The consumers? Most likely the last two groups.
- jgalt212 5y agoIn theory, you are correct. However, if companies don't pay taxes, then they build up huge cash hoards, and the stock price goes up and the execs (who get paid in shares) don't pay taxes. why? because they never sell, and just take out loans against their ginormous paper gains. And if they do sell, they pay lower capital gains rates for share-based instead of cash-based compensation.
- csomar 5y agoWhat you are saying doesn't make any sense. The take-a-loan against your shares will work until you have to stop at some point or you die and your estate is taxed...
- ip26 5y agoat some point or you die https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepped-up_basis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stepped-up_basis
- akudha 5y agoJust text on the page, loads immediately! No stupid ads, auto playing audio/video, nagging popups.... This is how the internet should be. Joy to read.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway34241 5y agoApparently it's also possible to address the issue of shifting corporate profits to tax-havens even without a large scale international agreement, using what's called a border-adjustment tax. [1] Basically, corporations have one place money comes in and two places it comes out, like so: sales = expenses + profits If you tax the sales, then deduct the expenses, that leaves the incidence of the tax on the profits. But importantly, unlike profits, it's usually clear to which country a sale belongs to. Where this gets complicated is international borders, the solution there is to only deduct domestic expenses. At first that seems protectionist, but apparently changes to the currency exchange rates eventually balance out the effect and it ends up trade neutral. This idea was actually seriously proposed a few years ago as part of a Republican tax reform initiative, and even economists like Paul Krugman seemed to think it checked out (who has a Nobel on trade, but is normally on the other side of the aisle). In the end it lost momentum after some big companies opposed it. Even though that's maybe more ideal, just going for an agreement also seems reasonable since it's probably more achievable than in-depth reform (so it's likely solutions like this or nothing at least in the medium term). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border-adjustment_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border-adjustment_tax
- wanderingmind 5y agoIf corporates have freedoms like individuals, they must also be taxed like individuals on the total revenues. I don't get to deduct my day to day expenses before paying income tax, why should a corporation be able to deduct it's expenses for tax.
- cjalmeida 5y agoBecause it’s bad overall. It pushes for large monolithic corporations instead of specialized companies. Also, you do get to deduct expense when doing value adding business activities. Just incorporate. Likewise corporations can’t deduct (loopholes aside) “leisure activities”
- wanderingmind 5y agoThen only tax individual income tax on savings as well because it's bad to see people struggle to make ends meet and the government on top making it more difficult by taxing on entire income
- franciscop 5y ago> The treaty will need to be ratified via a two-thirds majority in the US Senate, which is unlikely given that it allows foreign countries to tax US companies, the Eurasia Group analysts said. An alternative could be "another major tax bill," but the United States is unlikely to consider that until 2025, they added. How is this possibly true? The vote that the US takes should not affect what a company (wherever it is from) is being charged by e.g. France while doing business in France, that'd be up to local laws, right? Passing it in the US should only allow the US to tax international companies there, but they'd not get a say in other country's taxes? Unless I'm misunderstanding it and it's the international treaty itself that needs to be approved locally (does that even make sense, having been approved already?), and not local laws based on the treaty.
- Renaud 5y agoI think they mean that if a company in France manages to shuttle back its profits to the US, then it will need to be taxed 15% there as least. International corporations routinely avoid tax in one country by having charging large fees to the foreign entity for instance, leaving little local profit to be taxed.
- MichaelZuo 5y agoIn your example US and French companies in France would have to abide whatever rules are in France whereas US and French companies in the US would have to abide whatever rules are in the US. As it has always been. Any cross border treaty provisions, or provisions relying on multi party agreement will be ineffective in the case of the French-US relationship until both sides harmonize. Depending on how the treaty is structured it may be that none of the provisions can enter into force until all provisions are able to. And various other possible complications can change the dynamic too of course.
- mrtweetyhack 5y agoonly takes one for a dodge
- nsonha 5y agoI've never understood the argument for corporate tax. If you are after the super rich, then tax the super rich with income tax. Taxing companies just mean you makes it harder to do business, and whatever that entails.
- neilwilson 5y agoTaxing companies is what you need to do - since they would otherwise engage the people that you need for the public service you want to provide. Having said that the corporate tax is the worst way of doing that. Far better just to tax companies for using certain types of employee so they don't use that type of employee that much. Which then leaves some of those types of employees unemployed by the private sector. At which point the public sector can hire them instead. All straightforward once you realise tax has nothing to do with money or funding and everything to do with releasing people from the private sector so they can be hired by the public sector.
- nsonha 5y agoI've never heard of this argument and can't say it makes sense. "releasing people from the private sector" just mean removing jobs (and maybe bussiness activities) I doubt the jobs lost will be offset by the public sector and creating public jobs isn't incentivized in a free market. More public jobs just means tax money allocated more poorly any won't guarantee improved public services.
- neilwilson 5y ago"I doubt the jobs lost will be offset by the public sector" If you doubt that, then the government is overtaxing for the size of government they want. If tax eliminates private jobs, then it is beholden on government to hire those so released. If too many are released - reduce taxes. "More public jobs just means tax money allocated more poorly any won't guarantee improved public services." As I said tax doesn't pay for anything. The purpose of tax is to release people to be hired by the public sector - in furtherance of the elected mandate of the government. If the government has been elected then you've already lost the argument about whether public services will be improved with more people or not.