11 ms·
Why didn’t auto-braking stop these crashes?
- comeonseriously 5y agoAfter several officers where nearly injured/injured/killed because drivers ran into them as they were stopped on the side of the road, some states instituted laws that say you either slow down to 45 or you move over a lane. Is that built into AutoPilot and whatever it's called on other brands? Humans have to do it, so cars should have to as well.
- ape4 5y agoEvery lane change is a possible collision. I wonder if that was taken into account.
- comeonseriously 5y agoConsidering how far away flashing lights can be sensed (in both humans and cars), that shouldn't be a problem.
- asdff 5y agoCan autopilot even change lanes? It seems like that would be impossible to code for freeways in cities in California. You have to muscle your way into the lane and force people to back down or get hit or else they aren't ever letting you in.
- YarickR2 5y agoExcept it's not. Every lane change in semi-dense and dense traffic is a possible collision; I'd say if you have a car moving in the same direction as you are, and it's closer than ~50 feet, then it's a non-negligible possibility, other than that you just have nobody to collide with during lane change . We're talking highway speeds, of course, not racetrack
- pugworthy 5y agoYes, that's why slowing down is the other action you can take.
- vkou 5y ago> I wonder if that was taken into account. It was, but as the moral accounting stands, it is better for ten 'civilians' to be hurt, than for one police officer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- frosted-flakes 5y agoIf all lanes are full, in practice you don't need to, and shouldn't, evacuate the right lane. If there's space for you to change lanes safely, then do so.
- ggreer 5y agoA couple weeks ago Tesla pushed an update that causes autopilot to brake and alert the driver when emergency vehicle lights are detected.[1] 1. https://twitter.com/Analytic_ETH/status/1440537502272536581 https://twitter.com/Analytic_ETH/status/1440537502272536581
- gleenn 5y agoTrying not to be a Tesl fanboy, but they have a nice graph showing the number of auto pilot complaints but fail to mention if they normalized for the number of cars on the road (with autopilot) of that brand. Maybe there are a ton of Tesla complaints because they have way more cars on the road? What's the percentage? I guess we'll never know. Not great reporting.
- queuep 5y agoNot sure about the US but I can’t believe there’s more Tesla’s than Audi’s on the road in the U.S? Edit: oh there is, that’s quite cool honestly. https://www.goodcarbadcar.net/2021-us-vehicle-sales-figures-by-brand/ https://www.goodcarbadcar.net/2021-us-vehicle-sales-figures-...
- ahahahahah 5y agoAre you somehow under the impression that everyone is driving at most a one year old car?
- lukyanovic 5y agoAs far as I know all new model luxury cars like Audi and Mercedes come with automatic braking for frontal impacts. So considering the number of Mercedes sold in the last few years, I think it's safe to say there are more of them than Teslas.
- nradov 5y agoAutomatic braking has been a common feature even in non-luxury vehicles since at least 2018.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoYeah, once the Toyota Corolla has something, you can pretty much assume it's just standard now.
- Someone 5y ago
- slownews45 5y agoOnce again an article with NO context. TACC and ebreaking are in MANY auto's. We get no data on the number of accidents and fatalities for cars 1) Driven by humans 2) Other systems of ebreaking For all we know, despite these 17 accidents, teslas may be far safer. For example, a quick google shows that there are 1.7 MILLION rear end collisions EACH YEAR in the US. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/dr-gridlock/wp/2015/06/08/there-are-about-1-7-million-rear-end-collisions-on-u-s-roads-each-year-heres-how-to-stop-them/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/dr-gridlock/wp/2015/06/0... Note that the 17 items discussed here with Tesla are over multiple years. So in the time teslas had these 17 crashes there were perhaps 3M+ rear end collisions alone? The sad reality is that the clickbait headlines sell, and any effort to actually look at data does not (on the web and more recently on HN). Folks just do not want to engage with an idea or with numbers, but the outrage (or downvote) button is usually close by :)
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoWouldn't be surprised if this is their radar whitelist blinding it to sensor input.
- plebianRube 5y agoQuite possible. They've physically removed the radar hardware on the newer models.
- rtkwe 5y agoMusk is very adamant that cameras are enough even going so far as to stop including radar in Model 3 and Y units shipped to the US. So even if it were the radar being confused according to the Tesla line it shouldn't matter the cameras should be enough. https://techcrunch.com/2021/05/25/tesla-is-no-longer-using-radar-sensors-in-model-3-and-model-y-vehicles-built-in-north-america/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/05/25/tesla-is-no-longer-using-r...
- dv_dt 5y agoThere are also issues with other makers more simple automatic emergency braking systems. But overall it seems like the systems are a net improvement in avoiding at least some accidents. https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2019/10/29/iihs-automatic-emergency-braking-systems-aeb/2455884001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2019/10/29/iihs-au...
- pmcollins 5y agoyet another tesla hit piece from russ mitchell and the la times. is it just me or does the la times drag tesla at every opportunity? could it be because the owner of the la times, patrick soon shiong, has a company called nantenergy that seeks to compete with tesla? at a minimum, there’s a conflict of interest. and, kind of a tangent, but where are the articles about the thousands of lives lost due to the incompatibility of trucks/suvs and sedans in crashes actually causing thousands of lives lost per year?
- carabiner 5y agoI'm pretty neutral on Tesla/Musk, but I looked at this guy's (Russ Mitchell) writing history and it appears to be an unhealthy fixation on Tesla. His Twitter, and almost every article he writes, is about bashing Tesla. It's like he has real personal beef with Musk, a person he's probably never met.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- asdff 5y agoHe's a journalist, they typically get assigned to cover certain topics. Not surprising that he focuses on the EV space, that's probably in his job description for LA times.
- pmcollins 5y agofocusing on the ev space != relentlessly bashing one ev company
- asdff 5y agoThey are kind of the big cheese of the EV space and you could argue people relentlessly bash Tesla here too. Maybe there is something to these critiques of the company, rather than everyone and anyone just having an axe to grind.
- S_A_P 5y agoIve a Jeep Grand Cherokee. It has the front sensing collision detector and auto braking. It may have hit the brakes 1 time that I wasnt paying attention and 9,999,999 times when there was nothing in front of me. I disable it and thus far have avoided crashing. The point is that driver assist systems are only assist and you have to pay attention when you drive. Ive said this here before, Autopilot is a terrible misnomer. It seems to sit squarely in the valley of being good enough to 'trust' but not good enough for real world use. If I were in charge of the world, it would be rebranded immediately.
- sliken 5y agoDunno, autopilot (at least originally) was just a stupid switch on a plane that would try to hold altitude and speed. It wouldn't try to avoid objects, couldn't take off, couldn't land. Very similar to Tesla's auto pilot, that can't manage your driveway, random surface streets, but can mostly (but not completely) handle highways.
- Diederich 5y agoGood perspective. I think, as you noted, that 'autopilot' is probably fine, but 'full self driving' is actively misleading. Note that I use FSD for 90+% of all of my driving, and I think I'm safer because of it, but it has to be used with understanding and care. The very name 'full self driving' is something it might be some day, but it's nowhere close to that now.
- choeger 5y agoIt's kind of interesting that this appears to happen with police cars and emergency vehicles mostly. Is there a particular way of parking such vehicles that makes it hard(er) for a Tesla to detect it? It might also indeed be about phantom braking. My relatively old (probably designed around 10 to 20 years ago) system gets confused sometimes when I pass a truck or a bus and once even when I passed a bicycle. It happened at least 5 times in less than 10,000km. So I suspect there is some merit to the Autopilot disabling the feature.
- Rebelgecko 5y agoI wonder if the cameras or ML are thrown off by flashing emergency lights or emergency vehicles' livery (most cars on the road use just 1 paint color)
- ajross 5y agoYeah. I'm as big a Tesla booster as you'll find but I'm in the "this is probably a bug in recognition" camp. They can presumably fix this via properly parametrized modelling. It's not a rare edge case at all.
- myself248 5y agoI have a hunch that at some point, there'll be an investigation and a discovery process, and we'll learn that the training dataset deliberately _excluded_ emergency vehicles because they didn't represent "normal driving" or something. That's purely uninformed speculation, but I could see it happening like this: Early on, someone says "The totality of situations encountered on the road is too complex. We're not building a system to do everything, we're building it to take over during the boring parts of a drive. Only teach it the boring stuff." Then a few years later, someone else, forgetting those initial assumptions, says "Hey this thing has done like a billion miles of boring stuff, why wouldn't you trust it for more?"
- ajross 5y agoNo, the car sees emergency vehicles. It sees stopped vehicles. It sees vehicles stopped across lanes. This situation is far, far more common than the count of actual accidents we've seen. There probably is a bug, but it's not remotely as simple as "can't see fire engines".
- lacker 5y agoAutomatic braking doesn't get much attention, but it seems like something that could be incredibly valuable if it got to the "clearly better than human" level. This is purely anecdotal, but I find the automatic braking system on my Mazda CX-9 to be fairly annoying. Once every couple months or so, it has a false alarm and brakes while blaring out alerts, in an urban environment where I don't observe anything out of the ordinary at all. And it's never activated in a situation where I found it to be helpful. That said, it's possible that an annoyance every two months is just the cost of a system that really would help me if I got into bigger trouble. It's hard to say from purely my own anecdotes.
- ajross 5y ago> Automatic braking doesn't get much attention, but it seems like something that could be incredibly valuable if it got to the "clearly better than human" level. It's important to point out here that a handful of back of the envelope analyses are out there that show that Tesla's autopilot is already "clearly better than human" level at avoiding emergency vehicles. These are very common accidents. Emergency vehicles in travel lanes get hit all the time, crews are carefully trained to avoid that situation if at all practical, and taught how to reduce personal risk when that's not possible. In fact (and I don't have a link handy) if you extrapolate out from a few different data sources it looks like Tesla's on AP get in these crashes about half as much as vehicles in the general fleet. Now, that doesn't mean that these 13 events don't constitute a cluster worth investigating. And it doesn't mean that there can't be a bug worth fixing. It doesn't even mean that the media shouldn't write about it. It does mean that we should be very careful with pronouncements about safety from a sample set of this size, though.
- lacker 5y agoI think the problem here is calling something "better than human" because it manages to avoid some accidents. If a car avoids one accident for every 100,000 times it intervenes, that isn't really a good thing. It just means that drivers start to ignore flashing lights and warnings because they are always meaningless. Maybe it even causes some accidents by distracting the driver, and they don't get categorized as "caused by the automatic braking system" because nothing really tracks that. Every time I start my car, about 15 seconds into the drive a popup appears on the screen, saying something like "Warning: automated driving assistance system can cause distraction. Select OK to dismiss". Thanks, you have reduced your own liability in exchange for further distracting the driver.
- tibbydudeza 5y agoSomebody said it is a hard problem to solve.
- gorkish 5y agoMy hypothesis on this is that all automaker's automatic emergency braking systems likely function at approximately the same level, but Tesla drivers are disproportionately likely to rely on it due to the use of Autopilot being so incredibly common. Statistically, drivers of other brands that include similar lanekeeping abilities are far less likely to use them compared to Tesla owners' use of Autopilot. Should it be happening? Well the NHTSA doesn't seem to mind it. Maybe we should be asking them why their automatic emergency braking tests are so stupidly out of agreement with what drivers expect and automakers promise that the systems are able to do. The freight industry has a high speed test and their systems are top notch.
- Zhenya 5y agoSorry, your hypothesis makes no sense. There are WAY more cars sold by other brands, so more Tesla incidents is even more galling. Using autopilot should only HELP the auto braking not make it worse. Other systems use radar and camera. They are thoroughly tested by the OEMs and suppliers to strict tolerances. Meanwhile Tesla is shipping beta software and having people test it. Including removing radar because of “phantom” braking.
- sharkmerry 5y agoOPs point was tesla drivers are more likely to use the features. More cars being sold by other brands, could refute that but it doesnt necessarily. Its about the rate of usage of the software X total sales X avg. miles driven
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sparker72678 5y agoThis article addresses automatic emergency breaking, which is ON by default in the vehicles discussed.
- 5y ago
- andrewtbham 5y ago> Tesla does not have a media relations department and Chief Executive Elon Musk did not respond to attempts to seek comment. Tesla has ongoing response to this. https://www.tesla.com/VehicleSafetyReport https://www.tesla.com/VehicleSafetyReport
- shiftpgdn 5y agoIt always bugs me they trot out the Mountain View crash as an example where a Model X struck an unmarked and unprotected jersey barrier end in what visually looks like a traffic lane. Further that multiple human drivers had hit the divider in the same spot and a near fatal accident occurred literally the next day into the same barrier. If I put a brick wall on the freeway and paint it to look like a tunnel ala wil-e-coyote am I responsible for building the wall or is the driver responsible for hitting it?
- willcipriano 5y agoIs this the one you are talking about? https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/03/30/tesla-autopilot-was-on-during-deadly-mountain-view-crash/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/03/30/tesla-autopilot-was-o... I'd blame a human driver for hitting it in this case.
- fwip 5y agoWere any of the person-driven accidents fatal, do you know?
- ReGenGen 5y agoIf it fools .1% of human drivers and 50% of automated Tesla's I'd say is Tesla's fault.
- erulabs 5y agoIt’s Mountain View California - fully 50% of the cars on the roads are Teslas
- UncleEntity 5y agoThe Mountain View crash where the driver reported that specific location to Tesla on multiple occasions and still let the robocar drive full speed into the jersey barrier on autopilot?
- blitzar 5y agoIt sounds a bit like the 3 foot wide concrete pillar that came out of nowhere and scratched half way down the passenger side of the car recently.
- kazinator 5y agoIf a human driver hits a pulled-over police car, or any other stationary object that can be seen well in advance, the problem isn't simply lack of braking. Why would that be the talking point if an autopilot does that? Because we expect it not to be aware of the obstruction until within emergency braking distance?
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoI'd much prefer a system that stopped my vehicle as smoothly as possible to one that I would rely on to autonomously brake for me. I suspect that if all cars were fully autonomous, that we would have fewer collisions and fewer high-speed collisions simply because we wouldn't need to use traffic signals to push traffic along (and we'd have fewer traffic-stopping accidents). A few months back, an older gentleman collided with my car on US 75 in Dallas while I was at a full stop. Would automatic braking have slowed him? Probably. Would he have collided with me at all if his car were driving autonomously? Probably not. He was distracted and took his eyes off the road, never seeing that the traffic ahead of him was at a complete stop. It took nearly 10 minutes for us to get off the road for a fender bender because nobody would allow us to get over. Traffic simply flowed around us despite the issue. I suspect that within the next 50 years, driving at all in most major cities will require a special license, and it will become a civil rights issue for both those who don't know how to behave like adults but want the freedom to move about anyway, and those who simply do not want to be tracked by any entity.
- peatmoss 5y agoOT: I wonder why sites like the LA Times don’t offer a redirect to Apple News when the content is hosted there. I do subscribe to Apple News+ along with additional iCloud storage, Music, etc. I assume Apple gives LA Times something when I read the article vs. when I click away because I’m not willing to subscribe to more news sites than I already am. Apple News link for those in a similar boat: https://apple.news/A9PXJ2JwHRouQSYO9lQh9tA https://apple.news/A9PXJ2JwHRouQSYO9lQh9tA
- tzs 5y agoIt is not as convenient as a redirect, but on iPhone and iPad you can use the "Share" function when on the page in Safari and select "News" as what to share with and that usually works. I don't know how to do that on a Mac.
- peatmoss 5y agoThank you for the tip! Maybe I’m making too many assumptions about how much Apple pays news sources when someone reads a news article. I’d have thought there’d be an alignment of financial interest in sources like LA Times to facilitating some sort of “read this article on X”, and for Apple in boosting value of News+. I wish there were more of a happy path to supporting journalism without needing to have 50 individual subscriptions. I guess the moral hazard in a “pay per article” model would be a system that rewards clickbait (though I guess that’s the same as status quo with advertising)
- bradknowles 5y agoI’ve been dinged several times for sharing Apple News links, because they can’t be resolved unless you’re using a recent Apple OS. I’ve stopped using Apple News.
- Someone1234 5y agoBecause Tesla effectively doesn't have AEB while AutoPilot is enabled. In a Tesla AEB should be an entirely self-contained ("dumber") system. Its only job should be to look for any ground-level object ahead and brake. It should do this using simpler but more reliable ("dumber") techniques like forward bumper-level radar or camera parallax, not NN/deep learning/object recognition/AI. To use an analogy, AEB should be like two-factor authentication. If your "second" factor is the same as your first, then it isn't two-factor. In this case AutoPilot is the "first" and "second" factor i.e. it is AEB and in control of the vehicle. So Tesla's vehicles absolutely have AEB, when AutoPilot is disabled, because it is offering a "second opinion" relative to the driver. So IIHS's ratings are correct in that instance. But as soon as AutoPilot is enabled it is no longer a "second" opinion and therefore may as well not exist. Unfortunately Tesla aren't alone in making this mistake. We're seeing other vehicle manufacturers stepping into the vehicle automation space double-dipping their auto-drive systems into AEB. It is a bad practice regardless of who, AEB should be its own system with its own simpler/dumber logic that protects people from auto-drive mistakes, not compounds them.
- baybal2 5y agoDoes Tesla even have a radar?
- namrog84 5y agoI dont think so. I thought their whole gimmick or goal was to drive entirely by cameras and nothing else. Because humans only have eyes. Though just speculation and no source.
- taylortbb 5y agoDue to the current chip shortage they've moved to a vision-only system, as they had difficulty getting radar units in the quantity required. Until recently however, all Teslas had radar since ~2014. The high profile crashes are mostly/all radar-enabled vehicles. The thing about automotive radar, and this isn't just Tesla, is that stationary objects are normally excluded. Otherwise the system brakes for things like overhead signs that have high radar reflectivity. Stopped cars, concrete barriers, etc are all basically invisible to most automotive radar. Tesla also isn't the only manufacturer taking the vision approach. Subaru, for example, was doing vision-only emergency braking in 2016.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ancode 5y agogiving new meaning to 'move fast and break things'
- analog31 5y agoI read in another HN thread, that some Tesla owners have experienced "ghost braking," and have adopted the technique of holding their foot just above the accelerator, in order to counteract it. When I read that, I made a mental note to slow down a bit if a Tesla gets behind me, so they will pass me. Usually that's not a problem, as I don't drive particularly fast. I don't know if this is an issue with other brands of cars. My fancy new Subaru has never ghost-braked.
- bb123 5y agoI’ve experienced this in a Tesla. It slammed the brakes on without warning in the middle of a freeway and dropped our speed from 70 to 30 in seconds. Luckily there wasn’t a truck behind us otherwise we would have all died. Tesla fans tend to waive stories like that away with “yeah it happens sometimes” which I think is a pretty astonishing response to what really felt like attempted murder by a car.
- oxplot 5y agoHas journalism been this lousy forever or is it just recently? Quoting numbers of complaints per manufacturer is meaningless. How many cars with the given feature turned on exist from each manufacturer? How many miles driven with the given feature on? What speed were these cars at? That’s just from top of my head. Oh wait? Complaints? How is that a measure of safety? Let me add some more: How many people were injured/killed? What was the cost of repair from the accidents?
- oxplot 5y agoDamn it — fell for this again. All that matters is whether you are more likely to get into an accident/get injured in a Tesla vs other cars in the same price bracket. That's it! All these slice and dice reporting is of little value.
- antattack 5y agoAEB above 55mph is only designed to slow down, to lessen the impact, not to stop.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TedShiller 5y agoThis is the fundamental problem with artificial "intelligence" driving: It works fantastic 99.9999% of the time. But the 0.0001% of the time when doesn't work will kill you.
- resoluteteeth 5y agoThere's no way it's anywhere close to 99.9999% right now.
- TedShiller 5y agoYou're right
- lovetocode 5y agoWe have two Teslas and they are great but I wish they used LIDAR to support the CV powered AutoPilot.