20 ms·
It is easier to educate a Do-er than to motivate the educated
- bsenftner 5y agoIs this really useful, or another rationalization for choosing the less educated option, believing they are easier motivated? It is a grand generalization. As an accomplished do-er with multiple degrees, would I be filtered out via this thinking?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AriaMinaei 5y agoAlternative take is that education has been anti-maker/anti-doer and it has been so for a long time. The constructionist movement is trying to change that. To make making be the education. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constructionism_(learning_theory) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constructionism_(learning_theo...
- huachimingo 5y agoThe common question at school, even at Uni: "How this is useful, at the _practical_ level" How the hell are you supposed to motivate them about calculus if its all so abstract (see limits)?
- stared 5y ago"We learned quickly that the most important predictor of success is determination. At first we thought it might be intelligence. [...] There are plenty of people as smart as Bill Gates who achieve nothing." by Paul Graham http://www.paulgraham.com/determination.html http://www.paulgraham.com/determination.html
- chmsky00 5y agoIsn’t that just a nice way of saying “less educated people are more easily manipulated”? If industrialist feedback loops are destroying the planet, are more doers engaging grand scale industrialism doing an ideal objective? Maybe we should educate people so they’re less inclined to chase the coin of mere mortals RP’ing grandads emotional memes
- imbnwa 5y agoAs a mediocre frontend dev, this hits hard. I bought a bunch of texts to up my DS&A and college level math skills as I'd like to eventually be able to excecute on 3D animation in the browser, but the books end up sitting on my desk as I consider I'm too old/there're too many people who _do_ have these skills already, etc.
- designcode 5y agoLearning by just consuming textbooks isn’t going to get you far with motivation. Pick a small goal and work towards that. Break the problem down in to small steps and find ways of solving each step that works best for you. You might find you don’t even need any of those textbooks.
- dorkwood 5y agoWhat sort of 3D animation do you want to do? If you're talking about shaders, you might be doing yourself a disservice with the bottom-up approach. In my opinion, learning to use math functions as tools rather than having a deep understanding of how they work is an equally valid approach. I know several great WebGL developers who really aren't very good at math. Consider the following definitions of the dot product: A) Algebraically, the dot product is the sum of the products of the corresponding entries of the two sequences of numbers. Geometrically, it is the product of the Euclidean magnitudes of the two vectors and the cosine of the angle between them. These definitions are equivalent when using Cartesian coordinates. In modern geometry, Euclidean spaces are often defined by using vector spaces. In this case, the dot product is used for defining lengths (the length of a vector is the square root of the dot product of the vector by itself) and angles (the cosine of the angle of two vectors is the quotient of their dot product by the product of their lengths). or B) The dot product takes two vectors as inputs, and returns a value of 1.0 if they're pointing the same direction, -1.0 if they're pointing in opposite directions, and 0.0 if they're perpendicular (as long as they're unit vectors of equal length). This function can be used for diffuse lighting calculations (i.e. is the light direction facing the same way as the surface?), checking if a point is in front of another point, etc. In my opinion, the second definition is much more useful for someone interested in 3D on the web, but it's something you won't find in math textbooks.
- GDC7 5y agoThat's because the educated don't want to just "do" , they want to be successful at it. The most ambitious want to be "world class good at it" . Hence nothing gets ever started because it seems like an unsurmountable mountain to climb. But there is a silver lining. The possibility of exploring social relationships. With regards to social relationships it doesn't really matter if you are having a party in Beverly Hills or in Des Moines. It's exactly the same thing.
- potatochup 5y agoOoooh yeah. After being in national level sports teams, high-performing bands, I took up swing dancing as a hobby. I was garbage at it. After 5 years I'm approximately mediocre at best. Took me a very long time to come to terms with being not at all talented at something. But it's been a wonderful journey of meeting people, humility and learning how to learn something totally new again. I doubt I'll ever be great, but I have no plans on stopping (global pandemic aside).
- willcipriano 5y agoThose who do are in the top 1% by default, the vast majority don't get that far.
- GDC7 5y agoBut again people want to be in the 1% of income, wealth and social status, not in the 1% of "trying".
- AussieWog93 5y ago> That's because the educated don't want to just "do" , they want to be successful at it. I've actually observed the opposite. For a non-insignificant number of people, it seems like their university degree is seen primarily as a piece of paper that allows them to demand a high wage while actively avoiding mental or physical exertion.
- Broken_Hippo 5y ago
- adolph 5y agoInteresting coda to the "Curiosity Is Better Than Being Smart?" thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28753560 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28753560
- Jensson 5y agoIt is a lot easier to find an educated person than a person whose motivation lasts long enough to make up for the education though.
- leetrout 5y agoMaybe. Lots of perspectives and opinions that come along with that for better and worse.
- swalsh 5y agoPart of the problem finding these people is they probably aren't looking to work for you. They know their resume isn't going to pass your assumptions. So instead of applying to jobs they're never be considered for they're out trying to do something instead.
- Hokusai 5y ago> My experience has been that it is easier to educate a Do-er than to motivate the educated So, if someone wants to do something to give that person tools to achieve it will be productive. If someone does Not want to do something it is very difficult to talk them into doing it. Makes sense. But I do not know in what context this is discussed our what is the supposed implications.
- nescioquid 5y agoI agree. It really only suggests that incentives are more important than current skill/information. a) someone has an incentive to do something, but knows not how b) someone is very agreeable or pliant in their personality, and is willing to carry out instructions if they don't already know how c) someone's incentives are not well aligned to do the thing, or are not agreeable/pliant enough to do it anyway, but knows how to do it If I know how to set up and administer a mail server, under c) I won't do it if there are no incentives (e.g. pay). If I need a mail server, but don't know how to do it, as under a) I will pay someone to do it, or to teach me. b) is probably quiet and long-suffering, but may never understand the whys and wherefores. So incentives are probably more important than analyzing things in terms of "doers" vs. "non-doers". Could have implications for hiring policies -- less important that candidate does not have 5 years of Frobnitz framework experience, more important to provide an incentive for the candidate to become proficient. But I think this was not the point. He said "read what you love until you love to read" which sounds like Stockholm Syndrome. So, I don't really think he was saying anything deeper than "follow your bliss", unfortunately.
- mrfusion 5y agoHow’s he doing with the AGI BTW?
- mhh__ 5y agohttps://www.utsystem.edu/offices/talent-and-innovation/event/ai-coming-john-carmack https://www.utsystem.edu/offices/talent-and-innovation/event... Suggests he at least hasn't given up. He's a very smart guy but I expect the net result of his work in this area to be basically zero. Doesn't sound like he has the background for it, and the task is genuinely huge.
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoI am reminded of one of my favourite sitcoms - Blackadder (shortly after burning Dr Johnson's only manuscript of the Dictionary, and realising it will take ten years to re-create): "No, I love the dictionary, and would like to have my manservant Baldrick read it. Unfortunately it will take him about ten years to learn to read, so please leave it here."
- smoldesu 5y agoCarmack hit the nail on the head again. In high school, I had lots of incredibly smart friends who all turned their nose up at the idea of learning how to program. The only person I knew who seemed interested was a sophomore who was retaking his freshman math class. Despite that, I humored him and taught him the basics of Linux one afternoon. The next week when I saw the kid, he was talking about an FTP server he had set up to share movies with his family. I still get mad about it, because even though I was the one who taught him, I can't help but feel like I've never done anything as cool as that. I most certainly could, but the whole idea jades me and sends me back to the documentation I'm pouring over. Another good example is the "nerds vs hippies" generalization that people like to make: half the world's programmers are immobilized by choice, while the other half is motivated by blindness. Only together can they achieve great things.
- genjipress 5y agoIn one of the other forums I hang out on, people come in all the time asking if programming is a good way to make tons of money. These people typically dabble for a little bit, get bored, and move on. The ones who just like to mess around, to play with programming, they flourish.
- ivansavz 5y ago> I still get mad about it, [...] never done anything as cool as that. Quite the contrary, you should feel proud. IMHO, the real metric of success in life is not what you have achieved, but what your "students" have achieved, so in that metric you're the boss!
- mrlanderson 5y agoInteresting. Can you elaborate on the last sentence you wrote? Where is it from?
- smoldesu 5y agoIt's an old Robert X. Cringely quote, I must have lifted it off one of his COBOL books.
- tomohawk 5y agoHad my share of educated, but unmotivated people I've had to work with. They often have the skill of passing classes, but not other things. It seems like they don't know what a job is, or care to know. On the other hand, some of the best people I've worked with in software engineering were never officially trained for it.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoDoing involves a lot of implicit knowledge that reading frequently fails to cover. There's a density of information in doing that reading sometimes lacks. There are good points and bad points to that.
- j_walter 5y agoI would say there is no way to 100% cover with reading what you need to learn on the job. Also there is no way to cover some concepts with 100% on the job training (much harder to make a HS grad a petroleum engineer by just throwing them on a platform in the gulf without any formal education). You have to have some implicit knowledge of how things work in order first...but that doesn't always come from formal education.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoThe challenges are compounded when two people come from very different experiences. The same words mean different things to them and then instead of fostering the transfer of knowledge, "the words get in the way." I suspect this is a root cause of a lot of social and political friction. Doing or showing is sometimes the only hope of getting past that.
- j_walter 5y agoThis is why most if not all trades have apprenticeships. You have to know what to do and all see what to do...otherwise you could screw something up because you misinterpreted the instructions or design.
- mcdonje 5y agoThe problem with this phrasing is it implies that motivation is an inherent aspect of individuals. Nobody is a do-er. Motivation is impacted by a variety of factors.
- jacquesm 5y agoAgreed, and key to both job negotiations and many other situations is to find out what motivates the other party to do as they do, even if it seems to be aligned with your own interests, if the motivation is a different one then that may spell trouble down the road.
- jonny_eh 5y agoWhile you're right that motivation isn't purely an inherent trait of the individual, it is certainly a factor. The old nature vs nurture (or circumstance) debate. The answer is usually a mix of both.
- Trasmatta 5y agoThere's a neurochemical component to it for sure. Motivation is a complicated process that takes place in the brain, and can be influenced by genetics, lifestyle, and drugs. Some people's brains are just wired from the beginning to be more of a Do-er. Some people gain that skill through practice or drugs, and some people learn to Do in spite of a brain that seems to be constantly fighting against that.
- meheleventyone 5y agoMotivation for a particular thing is also highly dependent on your material circumstances. I ski a lot more living by the mountains than I did when I lived two hours away. I ski a lot less than I did before I had kids.
- phaker 5y agoRephrased it even sounds better: It's easier to educate the motivated than motivate the educated.
- allenu 5y agoIf we assume doers as being goal-oriented, then I can see it being easier to educate them in ways to help them get closer to their goals faster and more efficiently. On the other hand, someone who doesn't really care about the goal, isn't going to care as much about getting there sooner or in a better fashion. That said, I've found myself in both camps on various projects. When you're working on something where the end result is really exciting, it makes a huge difference on you and your team. It's exhilarating. On the flip side, projects were you don't care about the end result, are really brutal to work through. You just work for the paycheck. Any sort of educating about how to do things better feels particularly pointless.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoA real do-er is going to do something worthwhile even when there isn't a specific goal. >projects were you don't care about the end result, are really brutal Yup, better to have no goal than a misguided objective, if you can still have decent accomplishments occurring at a non-stop pace. >it is easier to educate a Do-er than to motivate the educated Regardless, I'm going to continue to push to the max in both categories. So what if it takes twice as much action.
- jacquesm 5y agoAlternative take: in the hiring process education is often used as a proxy for motivation, when actually it only proves that once upon a time someone was motivated long enough to get educated, but it doesn't actually say anything about their present state in terms of motivation. A 'Do-er' is at least at present motivated, and educating them will get them to the desired combination of education+motivation in the present, even if that education is going to be by necessity a very narrow one (typically: job specific). Being hungry for money and creature comforts also tends to be conflated with being motivated ('ambitious'), but it doesn't really align well because once financial success (for some very modest success) is attained the motivation will vanish. That's not necessarily a bad thing, but it tends to confuse people who were not aware of the driving power being the outwardly visible motivation. The movie 'Rush' has a nice bit about that, James Hunt just wants to be WDC, once. He doesn't care about anything past that point because it will give him what he wants. But until he's got it he will be super motivated.
- carabiner 5y agoThis only applies to entry level jobs for new grads. What else do they have to go off of? After 5-10 years they don't care about your formal education.
- mrVentures 5y agoI don't think Harvard Business School is a name that fades away until you will it to.
- ChrisLomont 5y ago>but it doesn't actually say anything about their present state in terms of motivation If you take the set of all applicants with education and the set of all applicants without, would you claim there is no difference in the distributions of 'do-er'-ness?
- wizzwizz4 5y agoThis question is somewhat irrelevant, considering you have more information to work from. Given the other constraints you can apply, is level of education still a useful proxy?
- whatever1 5y agoThe educated knows that the thing that the CTO asks for is infeasible. Hence the lack of motivation. The Doer in his ignorance, will embark on a trip of endlessly trying satisfy his boss, thinking that they are making progress, but they are not.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoHey, hey, hey! You're stepping on my turf, there! Everyone knows that it's our (old people) job to say "It can't be done!" Younger folks are supposed to be "boundary pushers," because they don't know that it can't be done. They keep trying, until they give birth to beautiful unicorns. Has nothing to do with education, and everything to do with age and [lack of] experience. Disrupt! FTW! At least, that's what they tell me, while dissing my experience.
- jonwilsonmn 5y agoGiving birth to a unicorn sounds painful.
- mywittyname 5y agoI tend to think of "educated" as meaning "having done this before", while do-er is someone who will maintain motivation. Someone who thrives on novelty will be an uneducated-doer at the start of a project, then convert to an educated-apathetic after completing it. They won't be inspired to do the same thing again because it's not novel. But while it is novel, you can bet they will dedicate a lot of time to it. Someone who thrives are familiarity will start as an uneducated-apathetic. They will get frozen due to not knowing what to do. But with guidance they can be taught what to do, then will go on to be an educated-doer. These people are happy to keep doing the same projects over and over again. They like what they know. Most of us fall somewhere in the middle. But I'm sure most of us have worked with both types: the hyper-focused person who works 80 hours a week to get some cool PoC out the door; and the "stick to the process we have in place, please" type. Both are valuable in certain situations, and a liability in others. Carmack and Torvalds appear to be the first kind of person -- granted, I've never met them -- but they do seem to like to build amazing things, then hand them over to someone else to maintain. I know lots of successful devs who are the latter. They crank out the same kind of code for clients project after project, and will happily work with tools like Wordpress because that's what they know and it makes them money.
- shadofx 5y agoAlso easier to convince someone ignorant of the problem domain that they have an adequate understanding of the problem domain, than to convince someone with an comprehensive understanding of the problem domain that the problem is solvable and worth investing effort into.
- giantg2 5y agoYou still have to motivate a do-er. They have to want to work on your specific thing.
- aaron695 5y ago> It is easier to educate a Do-er than to motivate the educated I really like the current HN title. It has nothing to do with the tweet which I don't understand at all. The comment the tweet is based on is also really good - > "Read what you love until you love to read" It's why we need to get internet porn, shopping, Netflix and video games to the poor. And burn to the ground the idealists who want to get them Wikipedia.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI like that. Carmack is a pretty sensible chap. I find his viewpoints to be practical.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- marsdepinski 5y agoAside from the fact that the two are not mutually exclusive but rather fit a DE,D!E,!DE,!D!E pairing resulting in a higher number of non-doer (!D) educated (E) people in industry, the statement is quite on point. Being a doer implies that you will by definition get more out of an education.
- meheleventyone 5y agoBeing a ‘doer’ is also not a fixed trait. IMO it varies on what a thing happens to be. Motivation and drive also vary over time in complex ways.
- nvarsj 5y agoI have a lot of respect for Carmack but I wish he wouldn't tweet things like this. It just feeds into confirmation bias. You could say the same thing about the work ethic of immigrants... well yes, it's self selecting. Just like the autodidacts who make careers without formal education. For the vast majority of us, an education has huge benefits. And for the hard sciences and math, it's generally just too hard to "do" without learning first.
- TillE 5y agoIt's always odd when people with at least a somewhat scientific world view decide they can draw broad conclusions from their extremely limited experience, especially when they start throwing around hopelessly vague, impossible to measure terms like "do-er". It's great to share your personal experience, that's not worthless, but you gotta understand and accept the limitations of that.
- adrianmonk 5y agoPartially depends on how skilled you are at educating and at motivating. Tech is a very thing-oriented and idea-oriented line of work, and motivating others is a people-oriented task. You need to be inclined toward knowing other people and understanding what makes them tick. Then you can show them connection between that and the work you're doing. There's no reason one person can't be good at all of that, but the field attracts people who are good at the thing-oriented and idea-oriented stuff since that's the main need.
- javajosh 5y agoI am increasingly of the opinion that there is little difference between doing and learning. In fact I would argue that anyone who thinks you can learn without doing is simply wrong.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Jensson 5y agoSo then you'd default to always pick the educated person since to you they are by definition a doer?
- javajosh 5y agoNo, I have no opinion about picking people. What I do have is the notion that it's very easy to convince yourself that you know when you just have theory. (I have a physics degree, and that seems to come with the territory - there is an XKCD cartoon, of course, that lampoons the physicist considering some long-standing problem in biology or chemistry and believing that the idea they just had after 2 minutes would be somehow novel or useful.) Theory is great, and opens a lot of possibilities. But until you pull out the soldering iron, or the compiler, or the hammer and saw, and make mistakes, you can't really say you know a thing. At best, you know how to start.
- Jensson 5y agoAre you saying you learned nothing in your physics degree? You learn different things when you do stuff like soldering, but you still learn things when you practice math and theoretical problems. The main value of a degree is that basically nobody learn those things properly on the job. So after a few years in industry the person with a degree now knows both theory and practice, while those who just worked only knows the practice and has a glaring lack of theory. And theory is extremely valuable, modern society cannot function without having a lot of people who understands the theory well. Not everyone needs it but some do.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- HugoDaniel 5y agoWhere does taking the code from Bethesda falls into that?
- ndesaulniers 5y agoThis is why I don't like when bigco's interview process discounts candidates' open source contributions; it's the only proof of someone being a "do-er!" As an example, it's pretty hard to fake that you're a top contributor to an open source project.
- Jensson 5y agoOpen source contributions aren't discounted, they are treated just like any other development experience you have. A multi year effort at a job receives a few seconds worth of attention as they read the few lines you put in your resume and helps you get hired at higher levels. Open source gets similar levels of attention per level of effort expended by you, if it is a hobby project you spent a few hundred hours on then that is as relevant as a job you stayed a month at, ie not relevant at all unless the project is successful and headed by you.
- westurner 5y ago~ "Imagine that one could give you a copy of all of their knowledge. If you do not choose to apply and learn on your own, you can never."
- westurner 5y agoThis is about regimen, this is about stamina, this is about sticktoitiveness; and if you don't want it, you don't need it, you'll never. And I mean never. The Grit article on Wikipedia mentions persistence and tenacity and stick-to-it-tiveness as roughly synonymous; and that grit may not be that distinct from other Big Five personality traits, but we're not about to listen to that, we're not going with that, because Grit is predictor of success. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grit_(personality_trait) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grit_(personality_trait) To the original point, > In psychology, grit is a positive, non-cognitive trait based on an individual's perseverance of effort combined with the passion for a particular long-term goal or end state (a powerful motivation to achieve an objective). This perseverance of effort promotes the overcoming of obstacles or challenges that lie on the path to accomplishment and serves as a driving force in achievement realization. Distinct but commonly associated concepts within the field of psychology include "perseverance", "hardiness", "resilience", "ambition", "need for achievement" and "conscientiousness". These constructs can be conceptualized as individual differences related to the accomplishment of work rather than talent or ability.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aroundtown 5y agoThis completely ignores the why somebody is unmotivated. I remember being beat down very early in my career. I took advanced math classes, could build compilers, loved embedded device work, wanted to work on more advanced things (operating system level, backend, devices, etc). The only people that would even talk to me were people that wanted web pages built. All because I wasn't fortunate enough to go to a big name school or any education beyond a BS. Often the only motivation I had at that point was to not starve. But after working for an abusive boss and 2.5 bad companies. I was burned out, used up, and left with nearly zero motivation.
- wara23arish 5y agoHow is your situation now? Were you able to transition into different work?
- aroundtown 5y agoPretty lousy but thanks for asking. I spent the better part of the 7 years: moving for my spouse (they have a phd with limited regions to work in), helped various family members through health issues, then had a health scare of my own. Now waiting on a partner to have a surgery. After their recovered, I'll finally be getting back out there. I'd still like to do software work on anything that isn't related to web pages. At this point, I'm not sure how to make that happen.
- Spoom 5y agoWe do web apps so if that's a disqualifier, might not be able to help. But if you're open to web app development at a large tech company, send me an email. Your story reminds me of my own.
- scott00 5y agoIf your grades were good at the small name school a master's degree at a big name school might be both within reach and give you a shot at compiler and OS work.
- 5y ago
- davesque 5y agoI think he's likely to trigger a lot of ire with this tweet. However, given what I know about his history, I think I know where this is coming from. Carmack himself did not finish school and was motivated early on to get involved in the profession of writing software despite lacking official credentials which entitled him to do so. I have a similar story and can relate. Therefore, I think what he's getting at is that it's important to just get started on something without waiting until you think you're "allowed" to. This quality of being a "doer" can stand out in colleagues. But of course there are many sides to the story. I don't think he meant to discount the others. Update: I want to add that I think I recall being aware of figures like Carmack in my teenage years. Knowing of people like him, who were making lives for themselves by actively pursuing their interests, is I think a huge part of why I got involved in software early on in high school. It was a way for weird kids like me to have a sense of self-worth and accomplishment even if we were getting bad grades in more traditional subjects like "World History" or "Social Studies" on account of just not fitting in. And it was also at a time (in the 90s) when the economy highly valued such people going into the dot com bubble. So this tweet doesn't surprise me at all. I think the historical context I've given here probably describes Carmack's life as well and is really relevant in understanding his statement.
- Avicebron 5y agoI'm tired of people signaling themselves as "weird" kids, it wasn't that weird to like computers, there's this fetishization of being "weird", "aspergy", "autistic", that's so tired and sad. no it doesn't make you better or smarter, it's just normal, no no one is a superstar because they were that "hacker" kid, times change, money changes focus and boom, success, it's not smarts, it's timing. and for all the kids out there, that's what I want to impart, it's not smart it's timing, ML today, bioeng the next, maybe something else in the future, maybe "social studies" will become thing once you children learn that twitch is a neural net with concurrent nodes...oops ;).
- xvedejas 5y agoIt's easy to feel weird as a kid with less perspective over the world. I have empathy for anyone who felt they weren't like the other kids around them for good, productive reasons. Sure, thinking interest in computers = Asperger's is an immature way to convey this. But otherwise I think it's worth celebrating whenever anyone has two-sigmas-above-average nerdy interests, why not?
- asciimov 5y agoI'd rather hire a hard worker than someone just motivated. It is laughably easy to kill someones drive and motivation (see burnout), where a hard worker is still going to put forward their best effort regardless of how they feel about the work they are doing. But if you are a big company it that can burn through people, it might be better to hire the motivated as they tend to put in free extra hours, where as a hard workers tend to quit at quittin time and go do something else.
- bsanr2 5y agoIt is also very easy to turn a "do-er" into someone unmotivated by ignoring or discounting their experience, knowledge, and effort. You should also consider if you're really "educating a do-er," or engaging in some form of nepotism. The confluence of these two notions is at a sort of induced early blooming in potential workers and thinkers, where simply being chosen for extrinsic support and attention is a better predictor of outcomes than actual or initial ability. That scares people because it doesn't just fly in the face of meritocracy, but questions it at a fundamental level.
- zeroxfe 5y agoI really think that action changes attitude faster than attitude changes action. Learning this the hard way in my 40s, it's been really life changing for me. Particularly when you're depressed, demotivated, find yourself procrastinating, etc. You can try this yourself -- the next time you're feeling demotivated, start with the smallest amount of tiny measurable action. If you can't get out of bed, move your fingers, shake your head, work your way up to standing up, walking, leaving your house, and very slowly building momentum. If you're procrastinating about work, start with opening up a terminal, launch your editor, write one tiny snippet of code that just compiles, add another snippet, build momentum. You'll find yourself making excuses, telling yourself that none of this matters, or that you're too tired, or that you're not in the mood. Accept the thoughts and push through the actions. Very quickly, as the dopamine hits from these tiny successes arrive, you'll find your attitude changing, and this turns into a feedback loop where you end up performing more actions, further improving your mood and attitude.
- npunt 5y ago"Motion before emotion" is a great little mantra to get you started on whatever - waking up, exercise, writing, working, etc. Emotions are sometimes helpful, but in the case of starting things they're usually wrong.
- thelettere 5y agoThere's an even older term for this, from a little known "anonymous" organization - "bring the body and the mind will follow".
- tenaciousDaniel 5y ago"Motion before emotion" - I love that.
- scns 5y agoI like your mantra very much. Hard disagree on emotions being wrong though. I am glad i learned to view emotions as messages from the more archaic parts of my brain. The ones we label as positive come up if we do something that aids the survival of our species. Examples would be pleasure derived from food or sex. The ones we label as negative are very important IMHO. To prevent harm to ourselves we need Fear, it is a good friend. My theory is that anxiety disorders are like an allergy of the mind. In our super safe world our Amygdala has not much to do, very few (if any) predators around. But it stays on the lookout and reactions to small (or imagined) threats are totally out of proportion. The rise in depression for me is a symptom of feeling lost/uprooted. If we take the theory that we evolved to live in groups of 100-150 individuals, that we all knew and worked with to ensure survival of the group, as basis and compare our modern lifestyle to it, we come out as extremely alienated from our nature. Even animals commit suicide if they see no way out. Put a scorpion in a ring of glowing embers and it will kill itself. <addition> The root of anger is fear IMHO. Anger is there to ready us to fight in case of a real threat to our life. Nowadays anger rises in situations challenging our worldview, questioning our distorted view of ourselves or our status within the group. My favourite one is getting angry when observing behaviours in others, which we dislike in ourselves. It happens even if we are unconscious it. When i get angry about behaviour of others, i sometimes remember to ask myself if i act the same way. The fight or flight situation leaves a third and fourth option. Freezing like a deer in the headlights, experienced it once myself. Read somewhere, that some predators only detect motion. Anger might be expressed as (physical/verbal) violence against others. If it does not, it can turn against yourself and lead to depression. The most healthy option i think is to accept your emotions and use your anger as motivation to change something for the better. </addition> Following Proverb helped me to accept my emotions: "Treat your feelings like a guest. Open up, attend to their needs and say goodbye when they leave." Another useful one: "What you fight gets stronger." - Siddhartha Gautama (edit) formatting, add anger
- personjerry 5y agoHow do I become a do-er?
- didibus 5y agoIn other words: > Can you educate a person who lacks the skills for what you need, but is willing to put lots of effort and determination? But will that motivation remain once they're over the excitement of learning? You have no guarantees that by the time the Do-er is educated they will still be motivated. > Can you motivate an educated person that has the skills for what you need to act on them with lots of effort and determination? The implication of the tweet is that this is "harder", but I don't like the word "harder" here, what does it mean? That it will take longer? That it will require more effort on your part? That it is more likely to fail? Alternatively, hire a motivated and educated person? If someone is a motivated Do-er, why can't they motivate themselves to go through education? That also confuses me, you say you're motivated, but don't want to put the time and effort to learn? Basically, I think this whole "Do-er" and "educated" dichotomy assumption is BS. I think it be more apt to talk about "passion" versus "just a job that pays my bills". If you expect someone to go above and beyond on the job, without you motivating them to do so through actual benefits and compensation (like better pay, bonuses, etc.), you better make sure you found someone passionate enough about the task itself to be motivated to do so purely based on what the task is.
- eptcyka 5y agoI think if you can get the optimum which is getting a motivated doer, go for it. But given the option between the two, go for the doer.
- didibus 5y agoI don't know, honestly in my experience, some do-ers just couldn't cut it, some things are hard and you need people with the talent, not just the motivation. That's because I think some do-ers are also "shortcut takers", they tend to skip really putting in the work of deep understanding, and if your problem requires that, and they always try to skip that part, their efforts just won't provide ROI. Meanwhile, a non-motivated educated person might just take longer as they're not putting as much effort on a daily basis, but they can still make progress. But it depends on the task and the understanding required for it. Lots of task actually benefit from shortcuts, you don't need a major for most programming tasks, you don't even need any understanding of algos, data-structures, hardware, OS, distributed systems, math, etc. A lot of task you just need very simple knowledge of a framework and just put in the time to try a few things until it works, google the answers, etc. So I'm assuming here by "do-er" we mean someone who doesn't bother learning anything unless the task at hand requires them too, and is also going to put constant effort and energy into the task on a daily basis. And this will always be more optimal in the total time spent learning/doing ratio, but if presented with a difficult task, you don't know if the do-er will be able to learn what's needed, because they have no cred that tells you that they are someone who can or can't learn such complicated things. That's where education comes in, you already know the person knows complicated stuff or was able to learn it.
- karmakaze 5y ago> Never underestimate the power of ignorant determination. Right there. The secret to my success. And my motto "How hard could it be?"
- decebalus1 5y agoIs he thinking of making an exit to become a 'thought leader'? This is some Malcolm Gladwell level nonsense.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThis is an incredibly silly thing to write: an average Joe has no working knowledge of psychology and no ability to motivate themselves, let alone anyone else. How could you motivate the 'unmotivated' if, at most companies, employees won't have an honest conversation with their manager about their or the firm's problems? That's step 1 of psycology discussions. The statement could be true of false, I feel this entire thread is the blind leading the blind
- devwastaken 5y agoTaking uni courses later in life, it's because the educated are taught in a very long, boring, and ineffective manner. They believe that's how good education happens because that's what the "experts" do. Turns out that one Khan Academy video is a better instructor than an hour with the math professor here. Students show up just to complete the homework, then forget it, because it's not relevant. Then the uni's pile on wholey unnecessary classes so they can claim to be "elite" and "well rounded", which drains the knowledge relevant to your work even further. Effective education will happen once we remove federal funding from universities. No more administrative cruft, no more extra general classes to pad coffers, no more relying on tenure to excuse poor quality education.
- Uhhrrr 5y agoThis is similar to something he said in an interview long ago: "I think the ability to ship a product is far more important because someone who’s not very creative can have little bouts of creativity, but someone who’s not very productive doesn’t have a bout of productivity and ship a product. You just have to grind it out."
- tablespoon 5y agoGod, Twitter sucks. I can't even navigate to Carmack's profile (https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack) from the tweet without hitting a sign-in block. I had to copy the URL and then paste it into my browser.
- codeproject 5y agoaction take care of everything. Just Do it, then you get inspiration, motivation and enthusiasm. you will say, see, it isn't too bad!!
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoI like this punchy summary, it's been in the back of my head in a more wordy fashion for a long time now when it comes to hiring. I used to do technical interviews (nowhere near the scale and diligence of the big players though), and I tended to gloss over a lot of details, that is, there wasn't so much a "scoring checklist", instead I looked for traits like curiosity and enthusiasm. Our technical assessment included working with XML and JSON; early on (early-to-mid 2010's) a lot of people said "I've never worked with JSON before", later on it was "I've never worked with XML before". Some just gave up before finishing the assignment and didn't show up to the interview at all. I think the most interesting hire we did from our technical interviews was someone who solved in a modern version of J2EE, years after Spring had become the 'de facto' standard as a response to J2EE itself. But Spring became that thing it swore to destroy, and the J2EE solution looked pretty elegant.
- arcanon 5y agoBut then they become educated and you are back to the initial problem: the motivation!