13 ms·
The new dot com bubble is online advertising (2019)
- slater 5y ago6 November 2019
- klyrs 5y agoWild. From the title I was guessing 2008.
- groundpepper 5y agoPast discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21465873 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21465873 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23101883 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23101883
- dang 5y agoThanks! Expanded a bit: The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising (2019) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23101883 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23101883 - May 2020 (152 comments) The new dot com bubble is here: it’s called online advertising - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21585364 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21585364 - Nov 2019 (24 comments) What do we really know about the effectiveness of digital advertising? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21465873 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21465873 - Nov 2019 (358 comments)
- kbrackbill 5y agoThis sounds great and I want to believe it, but it feels like another case of someone saying the sky is falling when it clearly hasn't. What will it take for this advertising bubble to pop? Is it even a bubble?
- missedthecue 5y agoFunnily enough, the ad based tech companies have the most reasonable stock prices. Facebook and Google are massively profitable, still growing at double digit rates, and each have only mid twenties PE ratios (the same as Caterpillar Heavy Equipment, or electric utilities like ConEd and PG&E). Meanwhile there are companies out there like Lordstown Motors, Lucid, and Nikola, which have never sold a product but have billion dollar market caps. Nikola is universally known as a fraud, somehow has negative revenue, and is still worth $5 billion. EVs are the real bubble.
- runawaybottle 5y agoThey are naive, they really think advertising doesn’t work. It works it’s ass off. You can’t find one identity that isn’t influenced by it. Real programmers use vim. I could sell that for ages. Don’t play games with advertising, you are just as much of a cuck as everyone else (rhetorically speaking, not you specifically). Anyways, real programmers read HN. I could sell that forever. You think you’re smarter than all of this? Real programmers _______, and by god, you will fucking buy it. Here’s some Rust for you, you real programmer. I’ll inundate you, this stuff works.
- ashtonkem 5y agoSome EV brands are clearly frauds, but with Ford introducing its second EV next year, calling all of EVs a bubble is a huge leap.
- missedthecue 5y agoI'm not saying EVs are useless, or vaporware. Maintaining the comparison here, you look back and can see that the internet was clearly incredibly valuable and impactful in essentially every describable way, but there was still a dotcom bubble full of egregious excess.
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agohttps://www.currentmarketvaluation.com/models/price-earnings.php https://www.currentmarketvaluation.com/models/price-earnings... I agree with some of what you are saying, but on a deeper level I don’t think a 25 PE ratio is particularly healthy so I’d say the real bubble is an everything bubble we are currently in. Facebook and Google have some of the lower PE ratios right now because they actually have earnings. >The current S&P500 10-year P/E Ratio is 37.8. This is 91% above the modern-era market average of 19.6, putting the current P/E 2.3 standard deviations above the modern-era average.
- cubano 5y agoMeet the new boss. Same as the old boss.
- amusedcyclist 5y agoI don't think you can build a new consumer facing business without advertising on facebook and google. A lot of the moden consumer internet was built by advertising on those platforms and diverting dollars away from brick and mortar. Some well known examples include Airbnb and all the kardashian family brands. Advertising metrics might be hard to measure for large well known companies, but for startups/ solo entrepreneurs the numbers tend to be much clearer.
- rossjudson 5y agoUltra-clear for small businesses, at times. I was once a partner in a shop, and there was that time that we had a account problem/billing error on the credit card, and all the advertising stopped for the better part of a month. Worst month ever. The whole article reads like something the author wishes was true, but that's predicated on the notion that everyone buying advertising is just stupid.
- Qi_ 5y agoDigital advertising is much more accessible for the small fish too. If a business has a Facebook presence, $10/day can get a campaign going, and scaling it up is trivial.
- rsync 5y agoIt's an idea that just won't die ... If we concatenate enough garbage: (subprime loans, training inputs, consumer information) then the result: (MBS tranches, AI, targeted ads) is somehow not garbage. This appears to be a wonderful model for separating gullible investors from their money so I suspect we'll keep seeing new incarnations of it ...
- glenstein 5y agoI think you are right, but the process you describe is so similar to the way we actually create value. Transforming or changing something from less into more. Normally we might call it work, or a patent. Making garbage can look similar to doing work and making something of value in the right circumstances.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> Transforming or changing something from less into more. "Less" rarely means garbage, and usually it takes more work than acquiring more more more.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> This appears to be a wonderful model for separating gullible investors from their money so I suspect The original model, selective investment funds with management fees, seems to be doing quite well a century on.
- tofukid 5y agoWhat do we really know about the effectiveness of digital advertising? The effectiveness of online ads is easily measurable: Return on ad spend (ROAS) = (revenue from ad referrals) - (money spent on ads)
- cratermoon 5y ago> revenue from ad referrals And exactly how do you get accurate figures for that?
- tofukid 5y agoIt’s simple. You use a URL with the campaign id, and store that when the customer clicks through, then when a sale is made you count that towards the campaign. In offline advertising people would achieve this using campaign-specific phone numbers or discount code given in the ad. Online advertising math is not rocket science. If ROAS is positive you continue the campaign, if not you abandon it or try other methods.
- klvino 5y agoGuess we'll skip branding and awareness campaigns, ignore all post-view purchases, not use cross-device or cross-channel attribution, and not look at attribution of offline conversion/visitation activity. If the only thing you do is Search and Email Blasts, the query string on your URL might work okay.
- namanyayg 5y agoThe query string method will not provide stats for the above point; but the newer methods e.g. using the FB pixel that tracks users based on the user's email/userid you create can accomplish much of that (only offline conversions are difficult, but there are still modern ways to match an offline customer with their past ad exposure e.g. if you get their email/phone on purchase...)
- fieldcny 5y ago
- avalys 5y agoI remember reading this article back in 2019 when it was originally written. Unclear why it is being dusted off now when it is still just as wrong as it was then. Yes, it is probably hard for a large, well-known brand like eBay or Procter & Gamble or Coca-Cola to measure their return from online advertising. If Coca-Cola stopped all advertising for 1 week, would anything really change? Probably not. And it’s not as if anyone is clicking Google search ads for Coca-Cola and ordering a 6-pack right there. This is the same problem that these companies have with TV advertising. But anyone who has ever run a small, consumer-focused startup with low brand recognition can very easily measure their return on ad spend, and will spend a lot of time doing this. You can easily tell which specific ad referred someone to your website, and how much money they spent once they got there. If they’re not convinced by this data, at some point most startups will find the opportunity to simply turn off all advertising for a week for one reason or another. And can usually see the drop in revenue immediately. I was involved in a consumer hardware startup where our COO shared granular ROAS numbers in our all-hands every week for Google, Facebook, TV advertising across multiple networks, etc. They regularly A/B tested different advertisements and messages across different media and directly optimized for revenue. It was clear beyond a doubt that this advertising worked. The company would not have been viable without it. The fact that this proof is easily and readily available from small, lesser-known companies is part of why large companies continue to spend money on advertising despite the benefits being much harder to measure.
- GeneralMayhem 5y agoTo be fair, the point of the article is that ROAS is not a very good metric, and while most of the article is wrong in that it effectively calls all advertising worthless as a result, it's not wrong about that one methodological point. What matters is incremental ROAS - not the conversions following exposure, but rather the conversions that would not have happened but for the exposure. For small companies that have no existing awareness, they're close to the same thing. But like you said, it is very hard to measure for the large brand advertisers that are very well-penetrated. If Coke switched off their advertising they would eventually lose market share, but it would take more than one Christmas of not seeing the polar bears. For companies in their position, advertising is about maintaining dominance. Spending on a Superbowl ad is a way for them to say "we're the best, we know it, and you know it, and when you want a drink, you're going to buy Coke, not RC Cola". It takes a long, long time for that indoctrination to wear off, so there's no way to experiment on it - there's no untouched part of the market that's never seen a Coke ad against which you can do an A/B test.
- tsavo 5y agoOh wow, this is an older article. Read it before, it was much discussed and here we are 2 years later. Market effects from the pandemic have reinforced the reliance on online advertising (more hours spent online by individuals working remote, growth of streaming services).
- IronWolve 5y agoNo tv, adblock, ad skip, filter ads in email. But then I watch youtube of tech hardware, and want the new shiny. Oh look, sponsored video...
- Nextgrid 5y agoOh look, SponsorBlock: https://sponsor.ajay.app https://sponsor.ajay.app
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- systemvoltage 5y agoI've always wanted to inquire the significance of advertising from the standpoint of the business, and yet its failure to please users. Advertising sucks from the standpoint of the user, and some say that if you want to scale any online business from 0 customers to N, advertising is pivotal and word of mouth won't do. Whether it comes in the flavor of give $10 to sign up a Paypal account, banner ads, search engine ads and these days also social ads (YT promotion, sleezy product reviews, IG celebrities) - it's important. So how come we have not solved the problem of user hostility in advertisement? Blendtec's "Will it blend?" series blends entertainment and advertisement. Engineers go to trade fairs and conferences voluntarily to seek out new suppliers/companies. People pay to go to Disneyland. Another genius in advertising is products/services that self advertise (Louis Vuitton). My gut feeling is that there is a deeper, more fundamental trade-off between advertisement effectiveness, and user hostility that always persists. Most of the time, we just adandon further inquiry and call it off as "It is the way it is because it damn well works".
- pm90 5y agoWe haven’t “solved” user hostility because the industry still relies on user data collection and tracking on a massive scale with default opt in rather than opt out. Consumers are spooked by that and the industry has (by and large) failed to convince them of the utility of targeted advertising. It’s the original sin of online ads that nobody really wants to address. Because of that, we have a lot of rather shady players in the industry making the problem even worse.
- whimsicalism 5y agoI feel like there is a distinction between targeting ads based on the profile you've created on their site (say, Facebook) and targeting ads by tracking users all over the internet.
- pm90 5y agoAlmost every web property with a significant user base uses “identity resolution” to personalize ads. Without regulations forbidding organizations from doing this it’s not going to stop.
- sb057 5y agoIn 2020, newspaper, radio, and magazine ad spending was $85 billion compared to all online ad spending (which is far more targeted and thus more valuable) at around $500 billion. Television advertising was around $193 billion. Unless we're in a generalized advertising bubble, I'd say online advertising is still in healthy territory https://www.marketingcharts.com/advertising-trends/spending-and-spenders-112297 https://www.marketingcharts.com/advertising-trends/spending-...
- 3np 5y agoNote that these are forecasted metrics specifically for the USA. I wouldnt be surprised if they underestimate online ad spending - there may be a lot of $ going through channels and companies that are not included. It’s not like they have insight into revenue of all ad companies even within the US, right? How about sponsored YouTube/Instagram/TikTok/blogspam for example?
- fsckboy 5y agothis new dot com bubble, if it exists, is really a subdomain of the .com tld, it would be the google.com bubble.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ZhangSWEFAANG 5y ago"Larry Page and Eric Schmidt, Google’s founder and its CEO respectively, were already seated in the conference room when co-founder Sergey Brin came in, out of breath. He was wearing shorts. And roller skates." Why do tech guys always try and act like they don't care when they obviously do? Why would Google tell Karmazin how they made money?
- otar 5y agoI don't believe in this. Ads really work.
- potatoman22 5y agoDon't their data scientists do causal inference to determine this stuff?
- wombatmobile 5y agoCheap advertising, you're lying Never gonna get me what I want I said, smooth talking, brain washing Ain't never gonna get me what I need https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h9M3b9lh-7s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h9M3b9lh-7s
- heurisko 5y agoI have had the thought that there is something wrong, that I can access nearly any song of my choice on YouTube, with the small penalty of skipping an advert after 5 seconds. Many of the adverts aren't even for products I'm interested in. They're either get-rich-quick schemes, or repeat-ad-nauseum ads for software like Grammerly, which I will never use. If Google has some sort of complex picture about me, by invading my privacy, then they're certainly not using it to sell me anything I am interested in. I guess if Google are funalling cash from advertisers to the record companies, then it will continue. But I have to wonder what would happen if advertisers actually look at how effective their advertisements are. I feel I'm getting a good deal out of this arrangement.
- durnygbur 5y ago> choice on YouTube, with the small penalty of skipping an advert after 5 seconds. YouTube is now in the last stage, cashing out their popularity. Now it's 20 seconds unskippable ad, then ad skippable after 5 seconds, then video interrupted with an another ad. I basically download the video and watch it on my computer or shutdown the browser tab with youtube.
- busymom0 5y agoIf using iPhone, iOS 15 extensions let’s you block those video ads. If using android, use Firefox browser with both an adblocker like uBlock and an addon to allow video playback in background along with another addon for auto skipping the “continue playing” Popup. Both have made my life so much easier!
- kubanczyk 5y ago> skipping an advert after 5 seconds YT ads are not shown on Firefox with a plugin such as uBlock Origin. Just in case you're one of today's lucky 10,000.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- DeathArrow 5y agoOne thing I don't get: if in the entire industry $273bn were spent on ads in a year, how come that one company which derives most of its revenue from ads, such as Alphabet has a market cap several times larger?
- Hermel 5y agoEarning 273 billion per year is much more valuable than owning 273 billion.
- nlitened 5y agoMarket cap assumes that the company captures revenue over multiple years of its future existence. Therefore it could easily be more than one year ad spending, especially if it is assumed that year over year the spending would grow, and the company would continue to successfully exist over decades.
- KoftaBob 5y agoBecause market cap isn't based on how much a company makes in one year.
- zbuf 5y agoThe article explains why eBay shouldn't advertise against the term "eBay", all very logical. ... Until a competitor starts advertising against the the term "eBay". At which point, online advertising becomes protection money.
- allendoerfer 5y agoClick-through rates will be very low. In most countries you cannot impersonate another company, so they cannot call themselves „eBay“ in the ad copy.
- gingerlime 5y agoDid anything change there? I remember Basecamp’s Jason Fried complaining about it[0] but I wasn’t aware of any policy changes that prevent someone from bidding on their competitor’s names and essentially placing their brand ahead of yours when searching for your brand name… [0] https://fortune.com/2019/09/04/google-trolled-search-ads/ https://fortune.com/2019/09/04/google-trolled-search-ads/
- WoahNoun 5y agoIf your brand is a registered trademark, you can have google stop your competitors from referencing it in search ad copy. https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/6118?hl=en https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/6118?hl=en
- youngtaff 5y agoBit that's only in copy… You can't stop them using it for targeting, and that's how part of the ad extortion market works - someone advertises against you brand as a keyword so now you have to advertise against it too… Google wins in revenue terms - it's also the source of scams e.g. people advertising against searches for free public services on say gov.uk, but charging for the same thing
- 5y ago
- axegon_ 5y agoAnnoyingly I feel like it's true. Personally I never had anything strongly against online advertising - there are tons of website and blogs where you can see that people have poured their hearts and souls into their work and the only thing they get in return are a few peanuts from ads. There's the case for trackers and cookies and whatnot but let's be realistic-the analysis and processing is done by a server in the dark corner of a datacenter, not an evil mastermind going through every website I've visited: no one is that interested in me or anyone else for that matter. Frankly I'd be flattered if someone showed that much interest into me but no... But at some point the over-saturation and overpopulation of certain species will cause cataclysms and I feel like we are close. While I stay away from all social media(I'm sure it's a similar story there), the thing that crossed my line was Google and more specifically Youtube. You open up a video, at which point you are already forced through two ads, one of which is unskippable, then you get to the "sponsored message" then another two ads if the video is slightly longer. If I wanted to watch TV, I'd watch TV. And this is what ultimately pushed me over the edge: Brave browser ftw and the hell with all that. And I see more and more people going that way for similar purposes. It's a question of time before enough people have had enough and ads become a financial burden to those who advertise online.
- kwanbix 5y agoI pay for google music, or whatever the name is today, and I see no ads. Bandwidth, servers, the employees, etc. have a cost, so it is only natural that companies make money somehow, either through ads or by subscription. EDIT: it is YouTube Premium.
- rciorba 5y agothat deal is (was?) only available in few parts of the world, sadly
- axegon_ 5y agoMusic is a different thing(I'm also a subscriber), I'm talking videos specifically. I'm sorry but the fact that I have to go through a minute of ads for every 4 minutes of videos watched is absurd. The worst thing I've had to endure was Antena 3 in Spain in terms of content-to-ads ratio. At this point if we include sponsored messages in videos, I'm willing to bet the ratio is worse on youtube.
- system2 5y agoIf it is a bubble, whom is it going to affect? Dotcom bubble was the investor's money. What is even ad bubble supposed to do when it pops?
- Hendrikto 5y agoAlso investor‘s money. If ad revenue suddenly tanked, so would the stocks of Google, Facebook, etc.
- AreYouElite 5y agoand it would tank anything financed by ad-revenue A lot of things are financed by ads: entertainment... music.. sports...
- AreYouElite 5y agoOof! Think about it, when was the last time you saw an ad, and went on to buy that product or service? Who are these people who see an advertisement on the side of the road and then go out and buy that very thing?
- AussieWog93 5y agoI can make at least three people IRL that do this regularly. My business has had huge success with promoted listings on eBay. People will gladly pay 20% more for a sponsored item rather than scroll down literally one inch to get better organic results. Even if these people are a tiny minority population-wise, they make up a disproportionate percentage of people that waste money on frivolous or overpriced goods.
- AreYouElite 5y agoIntriguing! I am new business, and my online ads campaign seen by 4000+ people produced maybe about 2 installations. Appealing to people in real life was much more effective for me. I know my target audience is in the hundreds of thousands but I just cannot reach them through more or less blind online ads.
- AussieWog93 5y agoAs someone else pointed out in a different thread, it depends a lot on what your product is. If you're selling something aimed at a highly tech-literate, "elite" audience, ads will likely be much less effective than if you're selling, say, decorated cupcakes.
- sangnoir 5y agoAdvertising on the side of the road was Burma Shave's schtick - and it was highly effective.
- whimsicalism 5y agoVery different from most people on HN, but very common in reality. I've witnessed this exact thing multiple times: see an ad for something, immediately have to go get it.
- treebot 5y agoTangentially related, I think political advertising actually does work. Not just ads ran by candidates, but all the different memes and infographics and whatnot. At least in America. Most Americans are sort of middle of the road, but in recent years, the right has gotten very good at drawing people in through media. I know many people who are now all wrapped up in all sorts of right wing conspiracies and viewpoints that they were not wrapped up in before, that if it wasn't for seeing it on Facebook, Twitter or Reddit, they never would have believed this stuff or even thought about it.
- whimsicalism 5y agoIs that advertising? And would it mean that they would vote for a particular candidate? The typical consensus I have seen among political operatives is that TV ads very clearly move the needle, whereas online ads don't seem to.
- bserge 5y agoYou mean the second one? First one was in 2008-2009 lol
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoI used the exact title from the article and someone changed it. (I did forget to include the date. That was a mistake and thank you to whomever fixed it.)
- rossdavidh 5y agoThere are two different assertions that should be distinguished: 1) most online advertising doesn't work 2) the revenue from online advertising will soon decline, perhaps precipitously I believe (1), but not (2), hence it isn't a "bubble". If you tell a CEO "hey, you're not going to be able to solve your problem with advertising", then you are in effect telling them, "there's no easy solution to your problem, you must do the much harder work of making your goods or services better". Not many CEO's will want to hear that. They will continue, I think, to spend money on advertising, including online advertising, not because it works well (it only occasionally does), but because it's easier. It's like selling someone a diet aid that says they can lose 50 pounds without having to work hard. Regardless of whether it works or not, people want to believe it does, so they will keep buying.
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoIf I had had a needle that would pop the dot com bubble, I'd hesitate before using it. Maybe there are cool things that were brewing and they just need a bit more time to incubate before we can benefit from them. If I had a needle that would pop this bubble, I'd use it immediately. Advertising is all about making people do things that, when left to their own devices, they don't want to go. Whatever survives this bubble may need to be hunted down and exterminated.
- JacobJans 5y agoThat is actually the definition of bad, inneffective advertising. Good advertising comes from a deep understanding of what people want to do, and then presents them with an opportunity to do just that. This is literally why Google is so valuable. Their ad business is largely based on understanding “intent.” As any decent advertiser knows, you can’t create intent, but you can harness it.
- missedthecue 5y agoI think you've got it backwards. The whole reason the trillion dollar industry of ad targeting exists is so companies can find the people that want what they're offering. Ford isn't advertising their F150 to Amish communities. They're advertising to people who match the profile of truck buyers.
- nikkinana 5y agoNobody clicks on ads. They're just an excuse to track you. And money laundering. That too.
- jokoon 5y agoI feel like advertising was always a scam. I don't think it really helps the small entities reach an audience, and it only allows the largest companies to remind everyone they are the biggest. I'm not sure there are thorough studies that show advertising increase sales.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoWord of mouth is usually the most trustworthy. Yet people need to learn of alternatives from somewhere. Perhaps if those serving ads were more liable, much like friends risking their reputation to recommend something, the negatives of ads could be better mitigated.
- WhisperingShiba 5y agoWord of mouth is king. I've only seen 2 ads in the last year that were even relevant, and only 1 of 2 of them turned into a sales conversion. For the other product, I went to a competitor.
- tflinton 5y agoI used to work for a B2B advertising agency, we did a campaign for the largest teleco in the US targeted at C-level executives to by their enterprise products. Our engagement team said (privately) that they had spent 20k per click. And had no idea if any of those targeted VERY expensive clicks resulted in leads let alone sales.
- tonmoy 5y agoBut wouldn’t a single purchase more than pay for the entire campaign?
- ChrisArchitect 5y agoso much previous discussion when this was fresher: 1 year ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23101883 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23101883 2 years ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21465873 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21465873
- mlinksva 5y agoNot a fan of advertising (online or otherwise, wish online wasn't exclusively...targeted) (tax it!) but bubble accusations seem unfounded. It's possible to find negative or uncertain returns to spend but that doesn't make a bubble. Relatedly the first and third results for https://hn.algolia.com/?q=bubble https://hn.algolia.com/?q=bubble are https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17060085 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17060085 (2018 GDPR Will Pop the Adtech Bubble; didn't happen) and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10572863 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10572863 (2015 The Adtech Bubble; the end was not nigh).
- bradwood 5y agoI thought it was DeFi, Crypto and Web3...