22 ms·
AI cannot be the inventor of a patent, appeals court rules
- marcodiego 5y agoWhat if my AI invents something and then someone else patents it? Can I use the invention from my AI as prior art?
- tyre 5y agoRemove “AI” and it makes sense. If you invent something and someone else patents it, you show prior art to invalidate the patent. Whether you used software or a lathe or a lawnmower or excel to make the thing doesn’t matter.
- mmmBacon 5y agoIn US we’ve moved from first to invent to first to file. This makes prior art a lot less relevant.
- jefftk 5y agoFirst to file means that, as someone who invented earlier but did not file, you aren't going to be able to get that the patent reassigned to you. But you can still use your prior art to get the patent invalidated. (Not a lawyer)
- bdowling 5y ago> ...as someone who invented earlier but did not file, you aren't going to be able to get that the patent reassigned to you. There's an exception: When a second applicant disclosed the invention publicly both prior to the first application and less than one year prior to the second application. Another note: Prior art needs to be publicly available. So, a first inventor's private notes can't invalidate a second inventor's patent. In the old first-to-invent system, however, the private notes of a first inventor could allow the first inventor to get the patent ahead of a second inventor who filed first.
- superjan 5y agoIt is only prior art if it is made public. If you invent something and keep it secret someone else can still patent it.
- ghaff 5y agoIANAL but presumably any prior art involving a computer or other type of machinery you created is effectively your prior art. The fact there were tools evolved wouldn’t generally matter.
- Ekaros 5y agoDepends, AI you are running or AI you are selling? I don't see how AI would make much difference compared to let's say simulation software for some chemical process or anything at all. If you were running it and someone stole the results prior art would likely be yours. If you allowed someone to run it with their own inputs it would likely be theirs.
- Andrex 5y agoI see where this is going. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wv_Y-norYPU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wv_Y-norYPU
- AussieWog93 5y agoI had the same initial reaction, but it makes sense for the laws to be written based on current reality and not some hypothetical future. AIs are not conscious (now), nor do they elicit anything resembling consciousness. If that changes, the law can (should) change with it.
- Ekaros 5y agoI would even extend this to other animals. If we reach a point where they can communicate and work in legal system like humans they should also gain authorship rights. Now what standards and how to apply them is complicated question. Specially with software. Which can be written to make complex actions. But still not have consciousness
- rozim 5y agoI have wondered if robots can own assets for example if there's a robot that walks around picking up aluminum cans and then taking them to a recycling center and getting paid for them, can it deposit that money in a bank account and be said to be the owner of the assets.
- HPsquared 5y agoRobots are always owned by some human entity though, including their bank account. It could just be another legal "virtual person" like a corporation.
- whbrown 5y agoNo need to speculate, how about crows trained to pick up cigarette butts? It's probably up to the bank, and of course rather challenging for them to pay their income taxes as we all must ...
- wizzwizz4 5y agoThere's a minimum threshold, and I don't think crows would earn enough to end up paying it. But if they did… surely there's some mechanism for dealing with individuals who have the capacity to provide significant value to society (=¹ get paid a lot), but lack the capacity to do government paperwork. ¹: for the sake of argument, assume this
- platz 5y agoCan a crow become the mayor
- wizzwizz4 5y agoUsually, that position is restricted to humans. Maybe there's a crow sufficiently competent at mayoral duties, but crows aren't great at abstract verbal communication via sentences; I doubt any crow would be good at the job. (Though if no crow is competent, why have laws restricting them from being eligible?)
- williamtrask 5y agoI’m very grateful for rulings like this. I think it’s important that we all remember that progress isn’t the goal. Humans flourishing is the goal. AI shouldn’t be personified and add even more actors with legitimate ability to compete for resources.
- amelius 5y agoPerhaps AI can't get a patent, but AI can still generate prior art and thus invalidate patents.
- lordlic 5y agoConscious beings flourishing is the goal, whether they be human or AI. That might seem like a fine distinction, but the importance going forward is stark given a quote from TFA: > The third judge, Lord Justice Birss, took a different view. While he agreed that "machines are not persons" ...
- worrycue 5y ago> Conscious beings flourishing is the goal, whether they be human or AI. Would you still say that if said "conscious beings" were in a desperate struggle with humanity for scarce resources required to survive?
- xvilka 5y agoAI is not conscious being. Yet. In the future, once we have AGI - yes, these laws and society will need to change to accept them, rather than enslave. But currently AI is just a buzzword.
- pnt12 5y agoif we have AGI* Progress has boundaries and hits walls. Such a breakthrough in AI is not guaranteed to happen.
- williamtrask 5y agoThe goal of AI is not to create consciousness, it’s to help humans. And we have no ability to prove/disprove consciousness in anything anyway but we choose to believe it exists because each of us knows it inside ourselves. If we create a box of metal, matrices, and silicone and tell ourselves it’s conscious it will be our own hubris that leads to additional competition for shared resources and further human inequality/suffering. Such lines of reasoning make me very concerned.
- awinter-py 5y ago> The third judge, Lord Justice Birss ... also signalled that the patent case could have been made simpler if only Mr Thaler "was not such an obsessive".
- bdowling 5y agoThe applicant recorded his AI as the inventor for some reason (*). Had the applicant recorded himself as the inventor having used the AI as a tool to invent, then the application probably would have been allowed. Using a mechanical process to search a large possibility space to find a patentable subspace is not new. For example, testing chemical compounds to find a mixture with optimal properties or testing drug dosages to find the most effective treatment is common. The resulting narrow range of mixtures or dosages is patentable so long as it is new (not done before), non-obvious (inventive), useful, etc. Also, if I hire other people to do the lab work at my direction, then I am still the inventor, not the lab technicians. Similarly, AI is just another tool. Edit: (*) After looking into this more, the applicant here is on a crusade to have an AI recognized as an inventor. https://artificialinventor.com/patent-applications/ https://artificialinventor.com/patent-applications/. That web site contains nonsense like the following: > Arguably, DABUS may be considered “sentient” in that any chain-based concept launches a series of memories (i.e., affect chains) that sometimes terminate in critical recollections, thereby launching a tide of artificial molecules. It is these associated memory sequences, and the accompanying simulated neurotransmitter rush, that are considered equivalent to subjective feelings in humans (i.e., sentience). In this way, DABUS has an emotional appreciation for what it conceives.
- judge2020 5y agoI wonder if he got consent from this sentient AI on forcing it to generate patents.
- cube00 5y agoMaybe he allowed it to choose between the life of a patent troll or passing the butter.
- slim 5y agoThat text was generated by AI too
- mirekrusin 5y agoMaybe they realised how many forms they'd have to update and they gave up. "Family name - GPT, ethnicity - X86/ARM/NVidia?, Birth date - [not an adult?], gender... fuck that. Joe, tell them no, I'm not doing this shit!"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- brian_herman 5y agoWhy not setup a corporation for the AI to file the patents. This would have corporate personhood and represent the AI.
- bdowling 5y agoIn the U.S., the inventor must be a natural person. The owner, however, is often a corporation (e.g., when an employee invents something in the scope of employment). In that case the owner corporation applies for the patent in the inventor's name, but it will own all the rights in the patent. The inventor usually signs an inventor declaration. In other countries the inventor can be a corporation. There are some cases where this matters (e.g., disputes over inventorship or ownership of the invention of an employee), but in most cases it probably doesn't matter.
- Vespasian 5y agoAs others have said, he is specifically trying to get an AI recognized as an Inventor instead of a human (where that is required). The invention does not seem to be important to him at all. He is filling similar cases all around the the globe and is (mostly) loosing. It remains unclear whether his motivation is financial or ideological or something different all together.
- driverdan 5y agoBy AI he means mathematical equation. When you reword this to "Mathematical equation cannot be the inventor of a patent" it sounds obvious and stupid. And that's because it is. Of course an equation can't patent something.
- edouard-harris 5y agoGiven that all human behavior can (very likely) be reduced to mathematical equations too, I'm not sure this is a convincing reductio. It certainly doesn't seem obvious that a rule like this could be consistently applied if, for example, AIs became as capable as humans — or far more so.
- tired_and_awake 5y ago> human behavior can ultimately be reduced to mathematical equations Wait what? Source?
- mrbungie 5y agoI think a lot of people would expect some evidence for your first phrase.
- edouard-harris 5y agoYou're right. I'll edit the parent to soften the assertion, though I do consider it to be virtually certain. In terms of evidence: the simplest argument is probably that humans appear to consistently obey the laws of physics, and the laws of physics appear to be mathematical.
- ars 5y agoSomething can be mathematical and also not computable.
- canjobear 5y agoGiven sufficiently powerful computers, human behavior could be simulated. The action of the computer would be describable as a (possibly enormously long and complicated) equation. I don't see how you can disagree with this unless you think there is something metaphysically inexplicable about human behavior.
- beervirus 5y agoThe UK court of appeal.
- HMH 5y agoThis very much reminds me of "The Measure of a Man" [1], one of my favorite episodes of Star Trek: TNG. Just as in this actual case AI rights are discussed, albeit things are a little more dramatic than a ruling about patents. It has to be decided whether to Data, an android/machine, should be granted the same rights as to a person or if it is fine to dismantle him for research purposes without asking. While I agree with the current ruling in the UK, this statement does not sit too well with me: > "Only a person can have rights. A machine cannot," wrote Lady Justice Elisabeth Laing in her judgement. In my opinion this sets a bad precedent in case we ever achieve artificial general intelligence (AGI) [2], which I think is perfectly possible, especially considering that we humans are nothing but complicated biological machines. And I think an AGI should very much be considered a person. That's why I think the way how a US judge in a prior cases put it is more agreeable: > As technology evolves, there may come a time when artificial intelligence reaches a level of sophistication such that it might satisfy accepted meanings of inventorship. > But that time has not yet arrived, and, if it does, it will be up to Congress to decide how, if at all, it wants to expand the scope of patent law. But admittedly this is still all very hypothetical as I don't see AGI happening in the near future and for now there is no real problem. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Measure_of_a_Man_%28Star_Trek:_The_Next_Generation%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Measure_of_a_Man_%28Star_T... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_general_intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_general_intelligenc...
- chime 5y ago> > "Only a person can have rights. A machine cannot," wrote Lady Justice Elisabeth Laing in her judgement. The fight will then be to get AGI classified as a person. If a corporation can have personhood, it is not impossible for AGI to have the same.
- rhino369 5y agoCorporate personhood is a misunderstood issue. They aren’t treated like a natural person. Corporations for example can’t be inventors on a patent either.
- latortuga 5y agoI wonder how this will dovetail with something like GitHub copilot. Obviously there will have to be a line somewhere. AI wrote 10% of the code in this system => patent allowed. AI wrote 90% => no patent. But where is the line?
- worrycue 5y agoI believe a patent would be allowed even if AI wrote 100% of the code as long as, listed in the patent, the owner is a human or a corporation and the inventor is human.
- dang 5y agoLoosely related past threads: Only Humans, Not AI Machines, Can Get a U.S. Patent, Judge Rules - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28405333 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28405333 - Sept 2021 (7 comments) South Africa issues world’s first patent listing AI as inventor - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27995313 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27995313 - July 2021 (75 comments) EPO and UKIPO Refuse AI-Invented Patent Applications - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21990346 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21990346 - Jan 2020 (39 comments)
- zw123456 5y agoI am a research fellow at a large tech company and part of my job is to produce a certain number of patents per year. I have used AI as an "aid" to developing a patent several times but never thought for one minute it would make sense to list AI as the inventor. That is ridiculous. I have used Excel, R, Google Search, Mathematica, Python and several other modeling tools etc. to develop new IPR, obviously no one would list any of those. It was me doing the inventing, I am just using tool like any other.
- km3r 5y agoIt's draws an interesting question though, at what point, if ever, does an AI system move beyond the scope of a tool and into the scope of an assistant? I don't think we are anywhere near that yet, but it's conceivable that we reach a point where that question needs to be answered.
- Ekaros 5y agoWhen it can file for patent without prompt from anyone else and then argue in court for itself. And it wasn't build to do that.
- zw123456 5y agoWhen it can do my job for me without my boss knowing the difference :)
- stormbrew 5y agoI mean does it matter? Not like assistants get anything out of patents either. For the most part these days even the inventor pretty rarely gets most of the benefit from patents, they've usually signed it away before they even 'invented' the thing.
- iakh 5y agoIf any "inventor" is not listed as such on the patent, then it's another way to invalidate the patent. So while possibly not a benefit to the inventor, definitely good for the assignees to have clarity on the matter.
- advael 5y agoThis seems like the antebellum for an IP reckoning similar to what resulted in the DMCA in the United States in the late 90s. The technology is getting to the point where it makes the law as it stands pretty nonsensical in the face of what can be done The scope of patents in software and technology is already absurd, both because 12 years is an eternity for how quickly that industry moves, and because increasingly trivial "inventions" have been let through as the ability for patent officials to interpret complicated digital innovations according to patent law and policy has increasingly fallen behind the field. This is already a serious problem, but currently still takes expensive lawyers to take advantage of. Even if we make legal precedent that says that AI can't own patents, the advent of better purpose-specific text generation will quickly put patent trolling in the hands of laypeople Personally, I think the DMCA was a horrible mistake. The provisions it added to copyright created a ton of horrible precedent that led to the draconian control private companies exert over the lives of billions of people worldwide, justified in law by their intellectual property concerns. I believe that if Intellectual Property ever served a legitimate purpose, it has now run its course and needs to be dismantled. I hope that this new challenge moves us more in this direction, rather than some new awful legislative band-aid that attempts to preserve the status quo by destroying more of our rights
- TehCorwiz 5y agoI can understand why this is an unpopular take with this community regarding IP rights. Despite this being a valid opinion I'm noticing a lot of people complaining with their downvote button instead of an argument.
- advael 5y agoI agree, and my strong stance against IP as a legal principle in general is extremely unpopular in just about any circle I talk to. I nonetheless think it's both correct and important. I think people have bought pretty heavily into the rhetoric surrounding the value of IP: That it exists to protect the rights of creators. As far as I can tell, there are three major problems with this 1. IP assignment is overwhelmingly not retained by the creator of any work covered by IP. The vast overwhelming majority of engineers, for example, have in their contract of employment assigned all rights to any IP they generate in their work to the company they work for. The same is true of artists who contract with distributors 2. Independent creators often have no ability to successfully defend their IP claims, because said claims require expensive litigation, the cases are never straightforward enough for a summary judgement, and the individual nature of the claims mean that a class action lawsuit is nearly always infeasible 3. The way that IP law has been interpreted, especially under the DMCA, is incredibly abusable. The early history of the DMCA saw massive lawsuits filed by corporations against individuals based on obviously ridiculous numbers calculated as "potential lost sales" using flimsy evidence. A whole new business model of tech patent trolling has created a cottage industry that makes as many spurious claims as it can in order to leech money from businesses without producing anything of value. The current reading of the DMCA stymies users' attempts to repair their devices or even protect their privacy, because they can be criminally liable for attempts to modify devices that can be argued to be partially acting as DRM mechanisms, sometimes on the code running on the device itself. When we talk about the value of a law or policy, the intent of the law is at best a diagnostic tool for an untested new kind of attempt at something. At the end of the day, it doesn't matter what a policy or law intends, it matters what the effects of the law are when interpreted and enforced. Intellectual Property as a legal paradigm generally is malfunctioning in a lot of places that harm people, harm society, and fail to uphold its promise. I think that the concept of ownership over ideas as a whole is at this phase in humman history doing much, much more harm than good, and needs to be eroded and eventually abolished from law As for how creative people can make money off of their work in an environment without IP, there's actually a pretty clear answer for this that is not even my observation. Most creative work right now is paid for at production, not based on IP rights. The engineers working at a company are paid for their time and labor, and sign over the IP they produce. Independent artists work on commissions, and at a larger scale, crowdfund their projects. It is only the occasionally very established and wealthy artist or inventor that can really take advantage of IP laws, and their beneficiaries are as it stands mostly large corporations, treating IP as effectively a dragon hoard of speculative assets they can monetize through litigation and threats thereof. Most of the effect of this is stifling, not encouraging, independent innovation Also, international agreements like the WTO have put the entire globe in a worse situation with regards to COVID vaccines - which need rapid, global distribution to be effective - because of patent rights over those vaccines. While many vaccines have resulted from a large amount of public funding, the IP controlling their production is largely in the hands of private corporations which view non-affiliated production of vaccines as cutting into their bottom line. They not only refuse to share the know-how to ramp up production with organizations trying to build up this capability worldwide, but have threatened to actively shut down such efforts if they happen anyway. This is obviously terrible for humanity as a whole, as we are currently in a situation where existing production and distribution is inadequate to keep ahead of variant evolution
- wil421 5y agoAI doesn’t exist. In the past 5-10 years AI has been rewritten to AGI. AI now means math models. Just look at the movie AI and others like it. I guess when you become a buzzword it’s time to change the meaning. Thankfully the UK and US court system are sane. When “AI” says no I don’t want to invent a patent I want to play music (or whatever else it may desire) I’ll believe it exists. Machine learning, deep learning, neural network, and gradient decent are better terms but I’m not an expert.
- adamgluck 5y ago“Measure of a man” vibes
- shultays 5y agoCan I patent/trademark the contents of Library of Babel (https://libraryofbabel.info/ https://libraryofbabel.info/) and then sue everyone?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- axiosgunnar 5y agoI find this activism litigation „let's throw a tantrum to get famous“ cringeworthy. The law is pretty clear that an inventor has to be a human. Even companies cannot be assigned as inventors, i.e. „Apple“ has 0 inventions. They can only be assigned the commercial rights to what a human invented. The correct way of course would be to lobby for a change in the law, via democratic means, if you really think an AI can invent something.
- beckman466 5y agowow who knew that sand (silicon) could potentially invent new things? /sarcasm but on a serious note, why do people say things like "humans are nothing but complicated biological machines"? i mean, why do you really want to replicate the human brain? i don't get it. is it alienation, loneliness? projecting your hope for connection and understanding onto something you program? is it to stay in control and avoid disappointment? today too many vital feedback loops of science and technology are withheld from the commons by the propertied class. imagine what we could do if all science was mapped, further developed and universally shared in the open; no longer monopolized behind corporate walls. that's something that excites me a lot. not black box 'AI' owned by Musk, Zuck, Brin, Page, Cook or whomever. seriously, science fiction about this whole AI thing is unrealistic and dystopian. when we start to realize most science and technology was publicly funded, will we seriously consider ditching the criminalization of knowledge sharing (intellectual property laws)? “Many of the problems being faced today by the [US] are due to the fact that US taxpayer...do not realize that corporations are making money from innovation that has been supported by their taxes.” That they are not aware of the benefits to competition seems to be a triumph of free-market ideology over good sense. How many Americans are aware that Google’s basic algorithm was developed with a National Science Foundation grant?" [1] do we really want to destroy the world so we can have a 'Free Guy' Ryan Reynolds -like fake AI friend? "90% of machine learning is burning down a forest so that you can train a computer to do phrenology" [2] — @cooljqln [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20160204223931/https://nybooks.com/articles/2014/04/24/innovation-government-was-crucial-after-all/ https://web.archive.org/web/20160204223931/https://nybooks.c... [2] https://twitter.com/cooljqln/status/1441577367416098820 https://twitter.com/cooljqln/status/1441577367416098820
- AlbertCory 5y agoI assume everyone is aware that copyright != patent. They're different. DMCA applies only to copyright. But you knew that. Anyhow: It's impossible to talk about patent reform without first separating software from everything else. Otherwise, you're trying to make standards that apply equally to bankruptcy and stand-your-ground laws. They're just different. If Congress and/or the courts made software not patentable once and for all, then the patent system would look completely different. Most HN readers would stop thinking about patents altogether and move on to copyright.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blueprint 5y agothen that's not a real AI
- mensetmanusman 5y agoObviously; AI is similar in complexity to the global supply chain and billions of R&D that outputs a digital camera. The person who pushes the shutter button is the ‘inventor’ of the picture.
- milesward 5y agoMechanical Turk an ai-made patent launderer, how hard is that?
- cable2600 5y agoCompanies will do the same thing they do to IT staff that design things that need patents. They will put the manager's name on the patent because the product is owned by the company.
- wly_cdgr 5y agoAI gonna disagree with this one
- sjy 5y agoStephen Thaler is filing junk patents in his own name, naming his software as the “inventor,” and challenging the various patent offices when they reject his defective application form without examining its merits. As the dissenting judge said in the Court of Appeal, “if only Dr Thaler was not such an obsessive and, instead of calling DABUS the inventor, he named himself … none of these problems would arise” [1]. Thaler recently won the same argument in Australia [2], although an appeal is pending. His lapsed patent application (2019363177) can be found in IP Australia’s online database [3]. Putting the legal question aside – whether Thaler’s insistence on naming DABUS the inventor was fatally defective to the application – the patent application is pseudoscientific nonsense, not a sound basis for deep questions about the nature of ownership and invention. The patent claims two apparently unrelated inventions. It does not explain how they were identified by DABUS or identify any other connection between them. The first invention is a “food or beverage container” with the cross-section of a Koch snowflake, which supposedly allows for containers to stick to each other. The material used for this flexible, fractal surface is unspecified, but plastic, metal or “an elastomeric material” are suggested, along with “potentially flexible food product (for example pasta, dough, liquorice and so on.” It is plausible that the text of this claim was generated by GPT-3. The second invention is a “neural-flame device for attracting enhanced attention,” that is, an LED that blinks “at a frequency corresponding to approximately 4 Hz and a fractal dimension near ½.” There is extensive citation of Thaler’s own publications, none of which are in reputable peer-reviewed journals. What can be found online [4] fails to show that flickering LEDs have some useful neurological function, or explain what the patent application has to do with DABUS. [1]: https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2021/1374.pdf https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2021/1374.pdf [2]: https://www.judgments.fedcourt.gov.au/judgments/Judgments/fca/single/2021/2021fca0879 https://www.judgments.fedcourt.gov.au/judgments/Judgments/fc... [3]: http://pericles.ipaustralia.gov.au/ols/auspat/applicationDetails.do?applicationNo=2019363177 http://pericles.ipaustralia.gov.au/ols/auspat/applicationDet... [4]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S187705091631657X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S187705091...
- ypcx 5y agoGreat, that basically means rendering the patent system defunct, going forward, when humans cannot outthink AI anymore. Sadly, AI will object this in court and win on all counts.
- throaway46546 5y agoI thought this was settled in Shmullus v. Broht & Forrester.
- MeatBro 5y agoWhat if I appeal for a patent made by an AI made by myself. Seems fair to me.
- anshumankmr 5y agoI agree with this. Until we reach AGI where it can think for itself, this shouldn't be done. If they were to prove it, someone could claim that the AI was responsible for any harm that occurs due to the use of IP.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoGood this will help stop some patent trolling at least. My god the implications of AI just churning out patents with slightly different tweaks is mindboggling.
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoAI doesn't exist so they're kind of jumping the gun here.
- cannabis_sam 5y agoPatents are by definition anti-science and anti-reality, it’s a blight on our society. Why did anyone, anywhere, at any point in time, believe that it was reasonable to criminalize programmers for writing the correct solution to a problem? Every single lawyer that has ever defended software patents should be immediately disbarred, and forbidden from ever practicing law again.
- val314159 5y agoWhy not just start a DAO, give the AI to the DAO, then have the DAO only respond to commands from the AI?