24 ms·
Banks beware, Amazon and Walmart are cracking the code for finance
- literallyaduck 5y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/17/business/17bank.html https://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/17/business/17bank.html It was right to stop them then, and it is right to stop them now.
- xwdv 5y agoAmazon and Walmart can both benefit from the powerful synergies from their retail operations if they decide to become banks, don’t see how traditional banks can easily compete. Square too is heading down this path, arguably even faster.
- deshpand 5y agoBanks also have a huge cost of supporting legacy systems in Cobol, SAS.. even some 'modern' systems in Java/Python are a huge mess. https://www.efinancialcareers.com/news/2021/02/jpmorgan-still-has-its-python-2-issue https://www.efinancialcareers.com/news/2021/02/jpmorgan-stil... They mostly talk about being tech companies but don't take the time to put in the required investments.
- smnrchrds 5y agoCanada's largest grocery chain, Loblaws corporation, had a vision of the grocery store becoming the hub for a diverse set of services. Under their PC brand, they offered chequing and saving accounts in the form of an online bank, credit cards, travel insurance, cell plans, etc. But in the end it didn't quite work out for them financially. They have been in the process of winding down their services and focusing on their core business as of a few years ago.
- omnicognate 5y agoSimilar experience for Tesco in the UK: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57973960 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57973960
- fartcannon 5y agoCar insurance, too!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoEhh, I heard that song before and arguably there is a threat posed to banks' market power and influence from current breed of fintech and new entrants, but the more time I spend in banking, the less chance I see for a serious disruption. I was initially going to cite an interview I did with a high level executive of a regional bank, whose entire view on the matter could be paraphrased as 'apps may be cool for kids, but when you want a full service, you want a bank'. I personally felt it was a little.. arrogant, but I understand where he was coming from. The compliance burden alone itself can be painful for new players. Then again, Amazon already has experience and they are clearly doing relatively well ( their OFAC settlement was minimal - https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/recent-actions/20200708 https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/... ). The executives should take note. edit: added 'alone' the burden sentence.
- BenoitEssiambre 5y agoWhile it's true that compliance, know your customer, anti- money laundering laws are the crux of this, who knows more about their customers than big tech companies? This is an area where big tech actually has a built-in advantage.
- secondaryacct 5y agoProbably but on my side of banking our main attraction is capital concentration. If nothing else, being enormous and focused entirely on getting more in to redirect to productive investments is the main "secret" to crack. All fintech companies miss this point: they can get sexy, get a bit of retail, but when you want to buy a supermarket or expand a business you already have, you dont need software. You need capital. AWS and Walmart may have some, and could convince clients to switch to them, but they re not going to be anything else than one more big pool of money to lend and collect.
- BenoitEssiambre 5y agoI think Stripe now does lending to customers that need capital to grow so they are slowly getting into that type of thing.
- jasode 5y agoThere's been a long history of non-finance companies branching out into finance. - Sears: had Allstate for insurance and Discover Card for credit. Unlike most "branded" credit-cards, Sears did its own underwriting for the Discover Card i.e. they owned the Greentrust bank behind that card. (That is unlike Amazon Prime card being underwritten by Chase Bank.) - G.E. General Electric: financial services GE Capital like loans and leases I remember finding out that many music stores use GE Capital to finance the inventory of all their guitars hanging on the wall. (Industry lingo of "floor planning".[1]) Sort of strange to realize that a lightbulb company has a bigger subsidiary that sells financial services. It's more profitable to make money by selling money than by manufacturing lightbulbs. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=ge+capital+floorplan+financing https://www.google.com/search?q=ge+capital+floorplan+financi...
- zarzavat 5y agoFamously Sony made more from insurance than electronics.
- robocat 5y agoThat was back in 2010 when although the financial services was a small percentage of revenue it made up a good percentage of profit - nice graph: http://www.fromedome.com/2011/11/sony-profits/ http://www.fromedome.com/2011/11/sony-profits/ Now the segment that makes the most is games: https://www.statista.com/statistics/297533/sony-sales-worldwide-by-business-segment/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/297533/sony-sales-worldw... which shows a beautiful graph showing just how variably some of their business segments generate profits/losses per year - notice how segments disappear from, or appear on, the graph. Edit: Disclaimer: I am not a financial expert, but your fact seemed a little odd to be true. Financial services at Sony do look reliably profitable (perhaps mostly recurring revenue and use reinsurance so predictable profits?)
- oblio 5y agoCar dealerships get most of their profits from after sales service and financing.
- lordnacho 5y agoDoesn't Tesco in the UK have a bank product? Can't say I hear much about it when I shop there. Makes sense though, why not be a lender as well? Then people can get their groceries before they get their monthly paycheck. Also on the payments side, why pay the card company when you can make your own card? These aren't new observations though, anyone looking at a supermarket would think of these things. Big issue is regulatory. There's a heck of a lot of hoops to jump through to get a bank license.
- dazc 5y agoTesco Bank is pretty much a branding of Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) rather than their own financial service company though. I used to have the Tesco credit card which was useful for the reward points but after trying to report a rogue transaction I found the customer service quite awful and left. Dunno if that was always the case of if they have just gone down hill of late?
- tixocloud 5y agoQuite a few grocery stores across the world offer financial services. The issue is that lending is a very different low margin business that requires an incredible amount of capital and complexity to setup. Which is why usually they get winded down to partner with banks or begin with partnerships in the first place. You’re right - regulatory and compliance are huge barriers.
- cm2187 5y agoJust to be clear, what makes a bank is not really lending, anyone can lend money (you might not necessarily be able to write a mortgage depending on the jurisdiction though). And there are lots of non-banks that lend money routinely, starting with car makers credit arms. What makes a bank is taking deposits (that's what requires a banking license). And banks are competitive at lending because they can fund cheaply with deposits.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vishnugupta 5y ago> banks are competitive at lending because they can fund cheaply with deposits. This was my understanding until I read this article[1] which essentially asserts that banks’ primary function is to create money to be lent out. True, banks did start out as deposit taking entities which they still continue. However, banks don't make much profit from deposits. In fact deposits, being liabilities, cost them money to keep them safe. They keep those deposits in short term fixed investment funds, most of the long term loans made by a bank are from money created by itself. That article is from none other than the Bank of England. [1] https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/quarterly-bulletin/2014/q1/money-creation-in-the-modern-economy https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/quarterly-bulletin/2014/q1/m...
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoThis is a pretty bad explanation. In almost all cases the deposit created is taken, sent elsewhere and reduces a loan somewhere. The document does explain this a little way down. The original statement about cheaply funding loans with deposits is spot on. Look at any of the big four banks - they all have over a trillion dollars of deposits at 10-15 bps which they then lend at a few %.
- imtringued 5y agoI've never seen my bank take my deposits and tell me, "sorry, they have been lent out". They might use them for funding but that doesn't mean they actually need them.
- j-krieger 5y ago"Few products escape the Amazon touch," the Duke said. "Books, the cloud, foodstuffs, servers, credit cards, insurance, tv, music - the most prosaic and the most exotic . . . even our poor handmade products from local mom and pop stores. Anything Amazon will transport [...]. But all fades before our personal data. The altered quote above may be a bit of a pessimistic quip, but I think in this day and age, nothing comes quite as close to Herbert's `Spice` as peoples personal data. Gather enough of it, and you do not only have the ability to glance into an individual's past, but into their near future, too. Amazon the company offers a lot of services. Soon you'll be living in your Amazon Home [1], ordering food from Amazon Groceries and household items from Amazon Basics. You'll be working at some Amazon owned company [2][3], drive an Amazon vehicle [4] and pay for your Amazon insurance[5] with your Amazon issued credit card. I find it harrowing that antitrust laws have been neutered so much in current times, where a breakup of the few well known Megacorps would have been necessary a decade ago. Amazon, Apple, Microsoft, etc. are slowly creeping their way into every aspect of life where there's a chance for monetary gain. Currently, a few select ventures are so large they can either outprice any meaningful competition for years until they fold, by just eating temporary monetary losses; or swallow them and incorporating their spectrum of products into their own lines. Even worse, some control the one and only marketplace on which competition can spawn, giving them the ability to shut down their opposition for inane reasons. Look at the FlickType keyboard on the Apple Watch for an example. [1]: They started two years ago by selling tiny houses. More will surely follow: https://www.housingwire.com/articles/49260-you-can-now-buy-your-house-on-amazon/ https://www.housingwire.com/articles/49260-you-can-now-buy-y... [2] Amazon owns more than 100 companies https://www.forex.com/en/market-analysis/latest-research/what-does-amazon-own/#:~:text=Amazon%20owns%20more%20than%20100,%2C%20groceries%2C%20media%20and%20medicine https://www.forex.com/en/market-analysis/latest-research/wha.... [3] Amazon employs 1 Million people - In the US alone. https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/amazon-now-employs-almost-1-million-people-u-s-or-n1275539#:~:text=Business%20News-,Amazon%20now%20employs%20almost%201%20million%20people%20in%20the%20U.S.,double%20the%20federal%20minimum%20wage https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/amazon-now-em.... [4] Did you know that Amazon sells and lends cars? https://www.amazon.com/Vehicles/b?ie=UTF8&node=10677469011 https://www.amazon.com/Vehicles/b?ie=UTF8&node=10677469011 [5] https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/news/technology/amazon-dips-its-toes-into-insurance-with-new-partnership-249646.aspx https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/news/technology/amaz...
- photochemsyn 5y agoThis seems to have a central data-harvesting angle according to the article. The threat to banks is described as: "And that means they'll be further away from the mountains of data others are hoovering up about the preferences and behaviours of their customers - data that could be crucial in giving them an edge over banks in financial services." "Embedded financial services takes the cross-sell concept to new heights. It's predicated on a deep software-based ongoing data relationship with the consumer and business," said Matt Harris, a partner at investor Bain Capital Ventures." This is how you build a dystopian panopticon, isn't it?
- salawat 5y agoYep. Got it in one.
- JohnFen 5y agoYes. We already live in a panopticon, but I think we should at least resist making it larger. My reaction to the trend is that while I'm forced into an intimate relationship with an established bank in order to function in society, there's no way that I'm willing to take on additional intimate relationships with the likes of FAANGs and Walmarts. But I also know that most people don't have the same reservation.
- ur-whale 5y agoThe question is increasingly: what is the actual purpose of a retail bank in 2021? There was a time when banks and the work they did actually provided added value, historically: - keeping your physical money safe - providing safe and regulated accounting - giving out loans based on existing deposits - giving their customer financial advice In 2021, it turns out: who needs these things at all? - almost all money is digital - any accounting need an individual will ever need can be provided by the combo of a phone and a $50 computer sleeping in a data center - AFAIU retail banks don't really need deposits to give out loans these days: loans usually gets resold on the open market almost as soon as they are granted. - there are *way* better places to get financial advice than going to me Henry H Banker at the local BofA desk.
- oblio 5y agoWhat's the alternative? Cryptocurrencies?
- rattlesnakedave 5y agoYes, if you are brave enough to self custody.
- after_care 5y agoReal question, where are my direct deposit “paychecks” suppose to go besides a retail bank? Once they have the money sitting in accounts they might as well lend it or something.
- twic 5y agoMy main use of retail banking is for transactions. Having a bank account means that my employer can pay money into it, i can use a card to withdraw cash from it, or make payments from it, i can authorise direct debits against it, and i can use a web interface to make transfers and review my transactions. When i have money to save, or i need to borrow, i don't go to my bank. I go to whoever gives me the best rate. I'd be interested to know what fraction of bank customers are like me. For the features i use, the web interface is probably fairly easy, but all the rest involves integrations with payment networks, which are not entirely trivial [1]. Money may all be digital, but as anyone who has ever worked with computers knows, that doesn't mean it's easy. So for me, the purpose of a retail bank is mostly to provide reliable implementations of a bunch of API clients. [1] although i led a team which build a large chunk of a system for making transfers, and if i can do it it can't be that hard
- civilized 5y agoWith every pile of money trying to become a finance company these days, is it any wonder that interest rates are at record lows?
- mkr-hn 5y agoIt probably has more to do with the Fed rate and monetary policy than competition.
- kevmo314 5y agoI worked in finance for a bit. The knowledge moat for tech is far greater than that of finance. I wouldn't be surprised if a tech company breaks into finance and traditional finance companies can't compete with the tech moat.
- mkr-hn 5y agoChallenger banks who launched thinking this often end up owned by or serviced by traditional banks. Some of that thinking is at least making its way into traditional banking, but it's a slow process with entrenched interests fighting every step of the way.
- hakfoo 5y agoI had always heard the problem wasn't necessarily the knowledge, it's more that starting a bank from zero in the US is extremely labour-intensive; something about having to get licensed by every state with its own slightly different set of rules. The SOP seems to be to find some dinky bank with an established license and acquire it to get a seat at the big-boy table. I suppose, then, it inevitably leads to a culture clash as the "Bank people" can say to the "Tech people" that the moment they stop playing ball, the whole thing crashes down.
- remir 5y agoBlockchain tech will disrupt the banking industry. Only a matter of time before CBDC (central bank digital currencies) become a reality and exchanges such as Coinbase or Kraken applies to become banks.
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoThere is a vast gulf between "finance company" and "regulated bank". The levels of regulation is huge, and basically culture changing. Coinbase is basically trying to avoid becoming a bank. If it finds it have to then, hey great more competition, but really I think the idea that "startup attitude" will be allowed by regulators or (because regulators basically follow what society has decided it wants from its banks over decades of scandals and abuse) what the market actually wants As an example, there are loads of (US) fintech startups that let you store some money and pay at a shop. Because these are not banks and debit cards, they charge the customer nothing but can scalp the merchant who can do nothing. The fintechs are just playing regulatory arbitrage. It might end soon in which case dozens will drop out and the biggest get bought by real banks for their brand name and cool factor.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThis isn't really true. In the US, if someone is "letting you store money", and it's real, actual money, the deposit has to be held at a bank or a credit union. Thus, the way many fintechs work right now is that they have a partner bank, which holds the bank charter, that keeps FDIC insured deposits. Down the road, though, I think you'll see some big fintechs buy up one of the many small, regional banks just to get their bank charter. Most of the underlying tech at a bank runs on a "Core Banking" system from one of a couple of players (FIS, Fiserv, etc), but down the road I could easily see more modern core banking tech come out from a fintech so they could then control everything from backend to frontend experience and take all of the profits.
- davchana 5y agoOh wow, ok, for curiosity, when I have a Shell Gas Gift Card, or balance in Starbucks app, or walmart or dominos gift card, somehow that money is being held in a real bank? Just asking.
- Nbox9 5y agoGift card balances do not have to be held by a bank. If it were held by a bank you’d need to provide ID for purchasing one and there would be more regulation around _gifting_ them. You can’t just _give_ someone a bank account. However, balances held by PayPal or Venmo? Yeah those are backed by a bank.
- kerng 5y agoWell, wait until one of the big tech companies discovers crypto currencies and starts offering DeFi solutions built into their platforms.
- eyeball 5y agothey'll just use their control of the regulators to crush the competition. this will go about as well as amazon / jp morgan / berkshire taking over healthcare.
- bombcar 5y agoBanks do two things: 1. Help you spend money you have 2. Help you spend money you don’t have The second is profitable the first is almost money-losing. But the second attracts undesirables that can be hard to get rid of.
- DamnYuppie 5y agoI think you are grossly mistaken. Banks make way more money helping you buy things you can't afford. Just look at how much more they make off of credit than they do traditional banking services.
- bombcar 5y agoWhich is why I said the second is profitable … But it brings the risks of those who don’t pay back which they do their best to avoid but regulatory rules come into play
- anderson1993 5y agoThe Waltons (Walmart) already own the regional Arvest Bank with numerous locations in Arkansas, Missouri, Kansas, and Oklahoma so they're no strangers to finance.
- adaml_623 5y agoThis type of article confuses me because it ignores China and India. Specific case. Alibaba copied Amazon's business model. But then it successfully spins off Alipay (later Ant Financial and Ant Group). And before the government crackdown/policy changes at the end of 2020 Ant almost successfully IPO'd at a valuation of $314 billion. Ant's business model involved payments, insurance and lending and was fantastically profitable because Ant leveraged its data about user payments to make efficient risk decisions. If the CCP hadn't decided Ant was too big (and violating data rules) then it would probably be continuing to grow. I don't think any of this is obscure so I don't understand why the article doesn't point out that Amazon and Walmart aren't trying something that hasn't been done before.
- JohnFen 5y agoI wonder if the banking laws in China, India, and the US may be so different as to be incomparable in this regard. The vast majority of the difficulty appears to be regulatory in nature, and I imagine that each nation has its own unique regulatory flavor.
- throwdbaaway 5y agoI thought Ant is fantastically profitable, because it takes a 30% cut from the profit generated by the Yu'e Bao fund (used to be the largest in the world), with the money coming from the remaining balance of all the Alipay accounts.
- hypothesis 5y ago> Mercedes drivers can get their cars to pay for their fuel. Does anyone know more about this? Is this for EVs only? Or is there a standard of some sorts or is it a custom agreement/implementation between car manufacturer and gas stations?
- jlangemeier 5y agoIt's essentially speedpass built into the car, nothing exciting. Just like the Amazon BNPL scheme is just Layaway or a store credit card gussied up in Tech speak. The whole article is just asking a bunch of fintech venture capitalists where they want the market to go; and throwing in a quick blurb from a JP Morgan/Chase exec to make it feel well rounded. Most banks and credit unions aren't JP Morgan, BoA, and Wells Fargo.
- hypothesis 5y agoI see. It’s a bit sad that everyone is so hung onto full-auto driving and car subscription models, that no one is trying to make current things more practical. I’m not even talking about gas cars, is there an EV car that can park itself at charger and charge without human being involved?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bob1029 5y agoWe've been working in the banking industry for almost a decade now. I don't think any of our customers have ever expressed serious concern about technology companies breaking into their market and taking deposits from their institutions. Business banking (esp. loans) is where I see virtually zero competition emerging any time soon. The complexity and value proposition around managing these kinds of customers is extremely nasty compared to the consumer side of the shop. This whole thing is a fairly complex equation, but I would boil the barrier-to-entry down to a 50/50 between regulations & customer needs. From a customer standpoint, the most meaningful specific deposits are going to come from your most painful customers. Our clients are not looking for victory in numbers with razor-thin margins. They prefer to find whales obtained by way of exceptional customer service. When it comes to money, customer service matters a fuck load when you approach a certain level of stakes. I don't think Amazon and Walmart are prepared the engage their customers in a way that will distinguish them from the incumbents. Walmart is already host to Woodforest National Bank (their largest retail partner), who is only able to serve a very narrow band of the consumer banking market. I can see a potential partnership emerging here. I don't see Walmart doing it on their own, and I certainly don't see it taking the market by storm. Amazon, even more so.
- thepangolino 5y agoCouldn’t those big chains at east in theory abuse the fractional reserve system by giving themselves 0% interest loans?
- dodobirdlord 5y agoShort answer is no, regulators aren’t stupid.
- no_butterscotch 5y agoLike they cracked Healthcare?
- ozzythecat 5y agoThis is a rhetorical question. I think American healthcare is a different beast altogether from banking and credit. I could be wrong, but I'm not convinced breaking into financing is as hard of a beast as healthcare. For example, auto companies do often have a financial division that offers loans, often times being very competitive with or beating your bank or credit union. I would argue this might be far easier for Amazon to pull off in the US or Western countries vs. countries like China or India.
- egberts1 5y agoWell, with Green Dot, WalMart is making huge inroad into general banking.
- amelius 5y agoPaypal cracked it years ago, so it shouldn't be too difficult for a company like Amazon.
- neonate 5y agohttp://web.archive.org/web/20210918203424/https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/banks-beware-outsiders-are-cracking-code-finance-2021-09-17/ http://web.archive.org/web/20210918203424/https://www.reuter... https://archive.is/psX8v https://archive.is/psX8v
- hamburgerwah 5y agoThere is no code. Ingratiate yourself to politicians long enough, boom your a [whatever financial thing you wanted to be].
- 29athrowaway 5y agoAmazon and Walmart do not have the money printing machine.
- bokohut 5y agoEveryone in business needs payments. For those of us with significant payments experience living the "build or buy" craze, as it continues to accelerate to light speed, just some insight to share. Your mileage may vary. The financial landscape is significantly changing as entities realize the power of owning and controlling the process and data end to end. Many comments about credit cards and banks but if one has the foresight to see over the horizon the "store of value" "unearned income model" implemented by one very large U.S. coffee company is the future. This model is morphing with the existing gift card industry and the crypto push as the large card brands position to be able to handle and process such 'legitimate' activity. Extremely interesting times once more as the excitement continues to climb and the heat some feel is approaching dotcom bubble temperatures.
- narrator 5y agoBanking looks easy till there's the regular credit crunch. In the last credit bubble that ended in 2008 there were lots of disruptors. However, when there's a crash, who gets saved is a matter of politics. In the last crash, Lehman got sacrificed[1]. Meanwhile, Goldman got it's credit default swaps paid out 100 cents on the dollar when AIG failed by the grace of the federal government.[2] Many of the disruptors crashed and burned though. [1]https://dealbreaker.com/2018/09/hank-paulson-killed-lehman-brothers-cause-karmas-a-bitch https://dealbreaker.com/2018/09/hank-paulson-killed-lehman-b... [2]https://wallstreetonparade.com/2021/08/meet-the-two-congressmen-who-facilitated-todays-derivatives-nightmare-at-wall-streets-mega-banks/ https://wallstreetonparade.com/2021/08/meet-the-two-congress...