25 ms·
Is America Inc getting less dynamic, less global and more monopolistic?
- sbt 5y agoyes. lol
- mc32 5y agoAmerica Inc., riffs on the now dated "Japan Inc." But... other than cute, it's a poor take. Japan Inc was Japan Inc because much of their economy was capitalistically centrally planned. The central Gov't would have monumental plans and would greatly incentivize their keiretsu to follow and undertake such monumental tasks. There was METI at the center making policy for an export driven economy. That is in no way a parallel to what we are seeing in the US. In the US we are seeing companies become more influential and powerful than the central government and implementing their own policies (Uber in transportation, Facebook/YouTube in content censorship). That is no USA Inc. It's Incs in the USA with global projection. Very different.
- oenetan 5y agohttps://ghostarchive.org/archive/bUsjL https://ghostarchive.org/archive/bUsjL https://archive.is/GOYrX https://archive.is/GOYrX
- pm90 5y ago2008: Worst economic recession in a generation 2008-2020: 3 Presidential terms with pretty lax antitrust enforcement. That’s a long time for the monopolistic tendencies to bloom. Which is to say, yes, it is more monopolistic now (but doesn’t need to continue being that way).
- cheriot 5y ago> since the start of the covid-19 pandemic America Inc has been anything but stagnant. Applications to start new businesses have soared. In the first six months of 2021 around 2.8m new businesses were born, 60% more than in the same period in pre-pandemic 2019 When people have something to fall back on they take more risks. Kind of like how the most successful large companies are in tech. Those founders had less downside than someone opening a restaurant.
- bricemo 5y agoThis is the opposite of what the article is saying. The economy was getting scary so people headed out on their own. Did you mean to say “when people have nothing to fall back on”?
- baybal2 5y ago> Did you mean to say “when people have nothing to fall back on”? This is better than sitting doing nothing, starving, and waiting for a handout to come, as happened in many, many countries. My strongest belief is that America needs an economic shock therapy, to spring out of economic lethargy. Lets face it. America is no longer the financial superpower. China is currently world biggest foreign investor, and creditor, and has banks that make Morgan's balance sheet look like pocket change. Betting on banks to lead America's return to prominence is futile. It's akin to trying to wing a card game against a professional card trickster who lives off ripping off casinos. Nor is the dream of service the dream of "service economy" feeding much of the country materialised. You can't earn much FX selling McKinsey consultants, nor are they are much needed around the world, because the world doesn't have American problems.
- reducesuffering 5y agoYou're exaggerating the bank size difference, ICBC is only 25% larger in assets. If you meant to convey all Chinese banks against just JPM, sure, but that's a silly comparison because there are many more US banks that when also compared in aggregate the % difference is still roughly the same.[0] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_banks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_banks
- otikik 5y agoWhat America needs is the rich stopping buying politicians and gaslighting other Americans, and start paying more taxes.
- ipatec 5y ago
- baybal2 5y agoAmerica is becoming more isolationistic, in everything, but economy. The manufacturing is unfortunately not only not returning to the US, despite efforts of 3 previous administration, but is leaving at the accelerated pace, faster than even at the "peak outsourcing." Having no real economy, but banks, and McKinsey, while being in a such dependency on imports is a recipe for nothing good. US trade deficit has passed $70B, and we are on the route to see it pass 100 this decade because of enormous government borrowing to fight covid, and stimulate the economy. Why it is so bad? Because, it tends to spiral out of control, when your only means to pay for basic living necessities is to spin the printing press, and kill the economy even more, precluding any chance at repayment. People wee saying that US is facing the worst balance of payment crisis in eighties, when it just passed $10B, and the White House was in total panic. Now, fancy economists are now coming, and saying "nah, $70B is normal, we can always print more"
- mjevans 5y agoOn-shore manufacturing, automation, and making more than just ideas to sell the rest of the world does seem like a good thing. I wonder why we can't seem to invest in the future (in the USA).
- baybal2 5y agoAs a man who worked in OEM electronics for 10 years, I can say, automation will not help USA a dime. There are far richer Asian countries than China, business people with far more capital to buy fancy tooling. You think they never tried that? They did, and it didn't work largely, or the impact was minimal. Look at Malaysia, or Taiwan. Hopes on robots, and automation as an economic "Wunderwaffe" is plainly silly, and are largely coming from people who haven't put in a single nail in their life. Don't listen to these men who say that.
- systemvoltage 5y ago100% agreed, as someone who’s automated manufacturing lines, the problem of automation is beyond just robotics. It’s automation with high reliability, yield, less downtime, high throughput, low costs and have to beat humans in the long tail of weird situations. The reason why your home printer can separate sheets of paper and only pick one sheet at a time is nothing short of a miracle backed by thousands of hours of engineering and years of failures. That said, some applications are very easy and we could automate effortlessly (Pick-and-place tools for example in PCB manufacturing).
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoI don't know about "America Inc" but as an expat American living in Asia who recently visited after not having been back for a couple of years, I didn't leave with the view that things were improving. To the contrary, while I do think that the massive "stimulation" of the economy has made things seem less worse, America today seems a lot less healthy than the America I left.
- bricemo 5y agoWhat are some things you saw that made you feel it wasn’t improving or less healthy?
- LurkingPenguin 5y agoEconomically, it seems like the disparity between the haves and have nots has increased significantly. Price inflation is not an illusion. In the Bay Area, it felt like no matter where I ate a meal, it always cost at least $20. The supply chain issues are also real and seeing bare shelves, empty car lots, throughout the duration of my visit was disturbing. I noticed a significant decline in the quality of service at many businesses. The labor shortage is apparent, and many service workers seemed not to care about their work, which reflected in their attitudes towards customers. On a personal level, I felt that people were less friendly and, more worryingly, less respectful. The public cursing everywhere I went was really unattractive. I'm sure some of this is that I have been changed by living in East Asia, where people tend to be more polite (if not friendly) and focus less on the individual than the group. But I don't think it was just me 100% either. I believe the increased politicization of just about every subject is a part of this.
- refurb 5y agoWell if your sample is limited to "SF bay area" then I could see why. Quality of life has definitely been degrading in California.
- LurkingPenguin 5y ago
- Barrin92 5y ago> If true, that would be bad news for the spiritual home of free-market capitalism I'd question the premise that the US is the land of free-market capitalism. America is the home of Hamilton's American system, of the Rockefellers and the gilded age, and of monopolistic competition (now Bezos and Amazon). Startups like to describe themselves as free-market oriented but they're either giants-in-waiting or dead. There's no equilibrium of middle-sized, free market startup capitalism. That Jeffersonian ideal you're more likely to find in the artisanal, small and debt avoiding family business in the German Southwest, say. Same goes for trade. With trade volume only constituting a quarter of the GDP[1] the US is one of the most domestic economies in the world. Compared to France and the UK at 60% or Germany and South Korea at 85%. It very much explains America's bipartisan streak for protectionism compared to much of Europe and Asia. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_trade-to-GDP_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_trade-to-...
- iammisc 5y agoThis is true... But only on the coasts. In the majority of this country, the people there don't care about silicon valley and many people own businesses.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoBut they all shop at Walmart.
- iammisc 5y agoI'm not 100% sure what this has to do with business ownership.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoIt means there is no local supermarkets, just one large monopoly.
- 5y ago
- dukeofdoom 5y agoAmerica was built in the last century. New high tech cities are being built all over the world now. They are paying top money so getting top talent and top firms to work for them. America is getting left behind, and routed around when needed. The corporations have left their home base for greener pastures.
- kcb 5y ago> New high tech cities are being built all over the world now. They are paying top money so getting top talent and top firms to work for them. Where? China, who has effectively no immigration? Definitely not Europe.
- vgatherps 5y agoChina has a billion people and is a major top-talent provider to the USA. They can source internally and/or provide enticing alternatives at home for talent who might otherwise leave for the US.
- herbst 5y agoI am not sure what qualifies as high tech city. But we have all the big names plus a healthy startup culture here in Switzerland. Adding the good wages, low taxes, the high living standard and the stable society it's obvious why we draw in tech talent from the whole world and only very few are leaving.
- ramphastidae 5y agoAny specific cities you want to mention?
- renewiltord 5y agoI'd say Shenzhen is one of these. Went from a provincial small city to a global powerhouse in twenty years.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoDubai is one I visited personally. But there are other middle east cities with tons of money. Many cities in China, South Asia and Europe are growing and modernizing too. Even former Eastern Block countries are going through a building boom. Some of these places don't really need America for anything. They can trade between each other.
- bonnie76 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20210916034205/https://www.economist.com/business/is-america-inc-getting-less-dynamic-less-global-and-more-monopolistic/21804757 https://web.archive.org/web/20210916034205/https://www.econo...
- hikerclimber1 5y agoyes.
- orionblastar 5y agoPeople are refusing to work minimum wage jobs and causing small businesses to shut down. My relatives have a Japanese Steakhouse with Sushi and they are short people working. Meanwhile Covid means reduced hours and mask wearing.
- gethoht 5y agoIt's a very very good thing that people are refusing to work for minimum wage. You want employees worth a damn? Pay for it.
- wnevets 5y agowhy haven't they tried paying more than minimum wage?
- josephcsible 5y agoBecause a lot of businesses, mainly small ones, can't afford to.
- wnevets 5y agoWhy not? Being short staff implies there is more business than the current staff can handle. There are tech startups (aka small businesses) that would kill for that problem.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoBecause the business owners took out loans assuming x labor costs, and now that labor costs are y > x, they would need to default on the loan. No reason to not let them suffer from their erroneous assumptions though. But politically, I expect them to be bailed out.
- wnevets 5y ago>No reason to not let them suffer from their erroneous assumptions though. Why not? If we were talking about a tech company, would you feel the same way?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gethoht 5y agoThis is a big fat "Duh". Capitalistic monopolies also largely explain a majority of the supply chain issues we've been facing for the past few years, largely driven by "Just in time" production.
- Frost1x 5y agoThere's this idea that resiliency and efficiency aren't trade offs and I agree some times, they aren't always direct trade offs, but they seem to be a lot of the time. Efficiency usually means cutting redundancy and redundancy is exactly what creates resiliency (backups, parallel paths, so on).
- Animats 5y agoYes. Ten years ago, Jeff Hammerbacher, an early Facebook employee, wrote: “The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads. That sucks.” Look at the big names now. Google, which did most of its best work in the early days. Facebook, which is part of the problem, not part of the solution. Amazon, which has figured out how to exploit workers. Microsoft, which is still trying to sell Windows N+1. And the gig economy crowd, which has figured out how to pay below minimum wage and not pay benefits. What don't we have? - Really good battery companies. Tesla just packages Panasonic. GM just packages LG. They're not making batteries from raw materials. - Progress in aircraft. Boeing is still flogging variants of the 737, which first flew in 1967. - Semiconductors. Does anyone in the US still make commodity RAM? - Electronics in general. There are few US sources left for small components. - Telecom. The US no longer has anybody who makes telephone central office equipment. The US can no longer make smartphones. - Power. The US does not make many large power transformers. - Appliances. Few US manufacturers remain. - Manufacturing engineering. Who gets a degree in manufacturing engineering today? Who knows how to lay out a production line?
- dluan 5y agoThe truth is that we're always in late stage capitalism, except for when we can creatively destroy something well enough to keep our minds off of that reality.
- postmeta 5y agoTesla has their own battery factories too, one is already live at Kato in California: https://spectrum.ieee.org/tesla-4680-battery https://spectrum.ieee.org/tesla-4680-battery Tesla is also working with Panasonic and CATL to implement their own factories for 4680 cells and scale production.
- rektide 5y agoeven within software, it feels.like their is so much room & space for new ideas, innovation & novelty. but the best minds are all paid to captivate attention for big systems, or manage various well established rent-seeking comluter offerings. it slays me that the engineers, the techies, have never had our day. we havent gotten good. we havent started new things, havent been augmenting & enhancing the world: we've been well paid to do the opposite, to capitvate & control & take technology, to dollop it out in little well managed productized offerings. the whole culture of innovation has dried up. i think of tech as still having so much prowess, skills, potential, and power, but wow, it is so squandered. it is so hard to break off on our own, to step away from the giant faucets of money & to start pursuing the radical, the good, the possible, the exciting. the potential. and what possibilities do arise, they seem so very quickly picked up, bought out, folded in to the mass corporatized system. comoetition & competency & novelty keep dying before they really get a chamce to bloom. it's the Thiel'ian advice to Facebook to sell, to take the money, get rich now, rather than keep working & trudging on, hoping.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zz865 5y agoOne thing is the rest of the world has caught up with America. Imagine in the 60s, 70s much of the world was communist and closed, dirt poor or isolated. Now living in Korea/Poland/Mexico/Turkey people have cars, TVs, cellphones access to travel like most Americans.
- herbst 5y agoCought up is relative, they developed their own way of living and sometimes highly surpassed US living standards years ago.
- zz865 5y agoDefinitely I've noticed free public healthcare & education makes people less stressed and better QOL.
- Frost1x 5y agoThe US thrives on a precariat class now, though. General safety nets that allow people to contribute a reasonable amount and still live comfortably doesn't create a class of people desperate to do any work to survive, ripe for exploitation.
- matttproud 5y agoYou just noticed? Snark aside, this trajectory has been clear as day since the 1990s (for anyone willing to broach this question) and brazenly undeniable since the early 2000s.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"... and Apple is reportedly building a search engine." Often Ive wondered they dont build a social network.
- lupin_sansei 5y agoThey’ve tried a couple of social networks around iTunes but they failed.
- silvestrov 5y agoThey don't (want to) understand that social network means that users talk to each other. The iTunes stuff was unidirectional from 'artists' (i.e. ad-agencies) to users.
- meragrin_ 5y ago> They don't (want to) understand that social network means that users talk to each other. No, I think they perfectly understand that. The iPhone is their social network. You can use it to manage your contacts, call, send messages(both long and short), share photos and videos, and video chat. What more else do they need that they don't already have?
- sangnoir 5y agoMobileMe included user-to-user communication (iChat), as well as a Gallery that could host publicly-accessible pictures. If you squint a bit, those were social network features. Unfortunately, MobileMe bombed pretty badly - and very publicly.
- sho_hn 5y agoDoesn't feel like that would be in Apple's DNA at all. A lot of their brand identity is a certain Disney-like pristine safeness, and they use it to sell lifestyle products that allow customers to associate with and embody that identity. A social network is all about self-expression and human mess. Just compare customization/personalization options in Apple software and other software, historically. MySpace it ain't. Apple products are not the ones you import your personality into. They've certainly dabbled in social features here and there, but none of them have been useful enough to be a hit with customers, I'd argue because what they're willing to do within the limits of their brand guidelines doesn't make for easy social success. Unclear if a working formula exists somewhere in that space on the spectrum.
- nottorp 5y agoJudging by my limited knowledge of US industrial history, that title needs an "again" added at the end. I vaguely remember Edison fighting AC solutions (as opposed to his DC solutions) by spreading FUD instead of attempting to compete on technical merits. So, no news here?
- quantum_state 5y agoBased on my observations, lots of the traditional large companies are quite feudal … lots of “yes” people …
- mrkramer 5y agoNobody is forcing them to work for large companies. There are thousands of jobs available at small and medium sized businesses.
- mrkramer 5y agoIdk about America but The Economist is getting more boring each day.
- bsenftner 5y agoThe 90's was their integrity apex, and it's been downhill since.
- m12k 5y agoI mean, IP is by its very nature designed to be monopolistic, and with the decline of manufacturing and the rise of tech, IP is making up a bigger and bigger part of the US economy. So of course it's becoming more monopolistic.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoIP is designed to allow a certain subset of solutions to be monopolize by inventors for ~ half the life of the inventor (although most patents are abandoned after a few years). It shouldn’t, ideally, block all possible solutions. In my experience (have applied for over 50 patents), the act of understanding and inventing around other peoples patents has very often lead to brainstorming resulting in superior solutions (this was an unforeseen advantage of good US IP law that other countries are trying to replicate). I would note that my ventures are in the area of atoms and not bits :)
- OneEyedRobot 5y agoLooking at the US Constitution, IP law should be designed to heavily encourage innovation. I would think that the actual details of law would reflect that rather than maximizing the value of an idea to it's owner. To be fair, the current results should have been predictable. A small, finely focused and self-interested group can usually defeat an unruly mass. >I would note that my ventures are in the area of atoms and not bits :) Good for you. My own bias and personal experience highly tends towards that, including US manufacture. Thinking about the article at the top, I wonder sometimes what the 'economy' even is anymore. I tend to distrust articles on it as all the news tends to involve internet-based FIRE 'industries' and surveillance marketing startups. I'm not feeling the love for those segments.
- Buttons840 5y agoOf course, a downside is a person can set out to invent something entirely on their own, succeed in doing so, and then find out what they've done is illegal. That's a big downside. Paul Graham said if you're successful you will be sued by patent owners. How many are discouraged from even trying?
- netcan 5y agoTesting prevailing hypotheses, in this sense, is a treacherous game. Number of business starts, IPOs, patents and most attempted refinements of such measures are very crude measures. For example, Cowen later softened some of his positions on learning how much of the data he commented on was retail driven. Retail is relevant, but he was accidentally modeling the retail market where he intended to model the economy. Besides crude metrics, there are always implied assumptions connecting new business starts, IPOs or unicorn milestones to the bigger picture. In short, this is rhetoric. Hypotheses testing is fine figuratively, but let's remember where the pitfalls are. IMO, it's worth noting where a lot of this is coming from: market caps. These are very much monopoly-related. The bull case expectation for a 2020s Great Company is 25-40% profit margins, double digit growth or potential for such. This is possible because Alphabet, FB, Apple & such do not need to borrow or raise to grow. This fuels a fire of speculative startup investing at the lower tiers, the only place where capital is required. The problem is, IMO, that there's almost no relationship between FB's size and gross economic output, productivity, economic utility, etc. Online communication is great, but online communication isn't better because FB is 10X bigger. Google's freeware is great, but we were getting search, gmail, etc when Google was 10X smaller. Where's the relationship between aggregate revenue (nevermind profit) at JPMorgan, Alphabet or FB and economic utility? IMO Cowen, The Economist and much of this cohort/generation of economists have an economic worldview that totally lacks an adequate model for market structure/maturity and such. This has led to a lot foolishness. If you are Ford in 1921, the world is young. You get more efficient each year. Cost per car decreases, but you can outrun this by making more cars. The market is growing in both dollars and number of cars. If you are intel in 2021, same game. The world is young. Moore's law only tells half the tale. Transistors halve in price and size every two years, but the number of transistors produced increases by more than than. The more they make, the more we want. Gotta mine that crypto, train GPT-N, etc. We need more chips every year, and the cheaper they get the more we need. If productivity keeps goes up, but we don't need more and more cars... the market contracts and this is now a different game. If $Nbn worth of grocery shopping that once happened in supermarkets now happens on amazon, the markets value this is a net capital gain, because $Nbn at amazon is presumably more profit generative in the long run. That doesn't society bought more groceries, or received much more value. This is not that hard. Look to the largest companies. What are they outputting? How much of it? How good is it? What changed? I get that it's harder to add up than the number of cars coming out of factories but, it's still less abstract than viewing the world through a purely financial lens.
- ravenstine 5y agoWhen it is stated that the American economy is "free-market", I find that to be a non-starter. Yes, a certain amount of the price of goods and services is determined organically, but the market is by no means "free" in the way that people think it is. It's heavily regulated, influenced by powerful industry lobbies, and substantially dictated by how the federal and state governments want to trade with other nations. It might not be overtly communistic or totalitarian, but that doesn't make it Laissez-faire, and it never really was in the first place. If we had a free market, then we wouldn't be allowing a small number of corporations to drive down prices, invite regulation, and collude with the press so as to snuff out meaningful competition. Some would argue that this is indeed a free market by the virtue that it is what the market has chosen, but not really. It's hardly different from feudalism.
- germandiago 5y agoTrue.
- mtberatwork 5y agoEh, this argument often crops up in some variation. It's essentially the "No true Scotsman" argument for the free market. The free market hasn't failed it just wasn't "free" enough! ... and so forth.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoThe whole world, not just a nation.
- ngcc_hk 5y agoMonopolistic… you miss Chiba sharp power and more net power.
- thehappypm 5y agoChibas are a huge problem. Who thought it was a good idea to breed Chihuahuas and Shiba Inus?
- dzonga 5y ago> more unicorns are becoming public. but what's not spoken about a lot is how most of these companies are running on fumes. read any tech company s-1 that's posted on hn these days, high chances the company is cash flow negative. which means if investors withdraw funds the company goes belly up in a day, leaving the regular employees i.e holoi polloi holding the bag.
- dangus 5y ago> if investors withdraw funds the company goes belly up in a day Investors can't withdraw funds from companies by design. When you sell shares in a public company it's another investor buying it from you. Runway is runway, it can be looked as a glass half empty ("running on fumes") or half full. If a company runs out of time/funding rounds it can cut costs. It's easier to make a profit when you have high revenue, brand recognition, fewer competitors. That's why growth companies run for years on losses.
- dzonga 5y agopulling funds, as in the 'cash from financing activities' yeah that can be withdrawn. shares are different, in that investors can sell the shares at a loss.
- Notanothertoo 5y agoThis is often intentional for tax reasons, see palintir and Spotify.
- jlos 5y agoFYI its "hoi polloi": - Hos is the Greek definitive article (i.e. "the") - Pollos is a Greek word, most generally, meaning "many' - They are used with the nominative plural ('oi' ending) - In Greek, the article delclines with the noun so "hos" -> "hoi"
- dzonga 5y agolet's not confuse profits with cash flow. yeah, it's okay to be running losses, if you're reinvesting the money like amazon did. however cash flows are different. will re-check if amazon was cash flow negative
- rundmc 5y agoYou mean that isn't the plan?
- GoodJokes 5y agoWho wrote this article? Can’t tell.
- phendrenad2 5y agoYes. It's impossible to do battle with an entrenched industry. Just don't. That's why every startup these days is trying to find a niche the entrenched industries missed.
- hikerclimber1 5y agoHopefully Boeing fails and hopefully the western us burns.
- silksowed 5y agocant point to anything in particular but this just seems off.
- xyzzy21 5y agoWell, duh, yes!
- orangepurple 5y ago"America Inc" properly referred to as the United States, a federal corporation https://www.law.cornell.edu/definitions/uscode.php?width=840&height=800&iframe=true&def_id=28-USC-2032517217-15940179&term_occur=2&term_src= https://www.law.cornell.edu/definitions/uscode.php?width=840...
- twofornone 5y agoI very much agree with the assertion that our economy is getting less dynamic, in the sense that everywhere you go in the US it seems like everything, and i mean everything, is being steamrolled by bigger and bigger corps and morphed into a bland, dumbed down, mass appealing corporate monoculture, designed (probably by MBAs) exclusively with profits in mind and no actual interest in developing any sort of soul or true differentiation. Random example, walk into a hardware store (everywhere you go its either lowes, home depot, or maybe ace, cross country) and tell me if there's a real difference between any of the tool manufacturers. On the one hand, the convenience of cheap and fairly durable goods is great. On the other, it seems like everyone is afraid to stray too far from what works to really innovate or compete. Most cars look pretty similar. The same restaurants exist literally from coast to coast, everywhere you go the US is starting to look more and more generic. Mostly it probably has to do with economies of scale, but at this point I'd rather spend an extra 10%+ on goods and services if it meant a return to true differentiation and a wider variety of consumer culture.
- LamdbaMamba 5y agoI'm seeing more and more discussion on a stuck mono culture, and I have to say I agree with it. This is an interesting write up on the phenomenon. https://paulskallas.substack.com/p/is-culture-stuck https://paulskallas.substack.com/p/is-culture-stuck
- twofornone 5y agoGreat writeup, really sums up a lot of the angst I've been feeling about modern american culture.
- foofoo4u 5y agoThis reflects one of the greatest dissatisfaction I have with touring the United States, which is the ubiquity of franchises. I can tour cities across the country and I always see the same companies: Starbucks, Target, 7Eleven, Panda Express, Petco, etc. It doesn't matter if I go to Salem, Austin, or Los Angeles. I see the same stores with the same shopping centers. There is a lost sense of culture. The same goes for billboards. It's always the same companies marketing: Ford, McDonalds, etc. Why do we hardly ever see small brands marketing? I'd be inclined to keep billboards if small brands utilized them to help their business, but that is rarely the case. Given this, why do we still tolerate billboards to the same mega-corporations? Everyone already knows they exist and what they sell. How much more exposure do they really need at the expense of the natural beauty of our towns and our own mental state?
- ur-whale 5y agohttps://archive.vn/I1Mq4 https://archive.vn/I1Mq4
- seaourfreed 5y ago$3.5 billion a year go to Lobbyists to corrupt congress. We have mass crony capitalism (on top of the healthy capitalism). That drags the USA down. It needs to be solved.