11 ms·
I wonder should we also start mandating yearly influenza shots from everyone? And bar those who are not tested or vaccinated from work places? It would certainl
by Ekaros 5y ago
I wonder should we also start mandating yearly influenza shots from everyone? And bar those who are not tested or vaccinated from work places? It would certainly save some lives wouldn't it?
- bserge 5y agoLet's go even further and mandate psychological and physical tests, to make sure there are fewer deaths. You never know what goes through someone's head or whether a previous injury will lead to an accident. I'm only half joking, this could actually help me :D
- merpnderp 5y agoYou know what kills more than COVID? Sugar which causes cancer, diabetes, and heart disease. If we're going to go after COVID for the havoc it causes, there's a long list of similar issues that could be tackled with the same type of mandate. I don't look forward to our health-police state we apparently decided was a great idea. Well we didn't decide, because that would have required congress to pass a law. This was just some old man skipping congress, likely knowing this will be overturned by the Supreme Court, but desperately needing to change the national debate away from Afghanistan.
- bserge 5y agoThe ultimate cause of death is life. 100% mortality rate heh
- TOMDM 5y agoIf people could take a shot or two that massively reduces the risk of sugar induced cancer, diabetes and heart disease they'd be fools not to take it.
- pbaka 5y agoIt's called insulin shots. They're not cheap your side of the Atlantic.
- aruggirello 5y agoWhy not prevent such cancers in the first place? Forbidding sales of sugar, cigarettes, and trash food would go a long way to prevent cancer, diabetes, heart disease and obesity. Sh*t happens, you can't have a vaccine for everything.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoUnfortunately you are going to have a hard time finding scientific agreement on which foods to ban. The science isn’t that good yet.
- ridgeguy 5y agoDownvoted because you assert a simplistic and erroneous equivalence between damage caused by sugar consumption and that caused by a communicable disease. If you eat sugar, you don't endanger others' health. If you don't get vaccinated, you put others at risk. See the difference?
- chickenpotpie 5y agoHeart disease kills more people than covid because heart disease is an umbrella term for thousands of conditions, while covid-19 is one disease. Same for cancer, there are hundreds of types of cancer.
- guscost 5y agoA yearly combination COVID and influenza shot will be the next mandate - at least in the fascist shitholes that are still subject to these rules.
- gizmo385 5y agoAre you implying that the US is a racist shithole? Or that the states that institute a policy like this are facist shitholes?
- psychometry 5y agoAh yes, the shithole states like Vermont and Massachusetts, which are so much unlike the paradise that is Mississippi.
- merpnderp 5y agoAt some point you have enough money, as a famous beloved man once said, and issues like agency become far more important (he didn't say that last part). Mississippi might be a poor state, but its GDP is still higher than most European countries.
- zibzab 5y agoBeats Greece per capita, but is beaten in net GDP. Tie with Greece is not an indicator of good economy :)
- merpnderp 5y agoNet GDP? Mississippi is a small state, why would you compare net? And its economy per capita is somewhere between Israel's and Slovenia's, hardly bad economies. And this from a state where more than half the kids grow up in small rural schools.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoWhen this all started and the stats for influenza deaths came out (usually as a poor attempt to downplay the seriousness of COVID) I was shocked at my own ignorance as to the effect of influenza. I'd previously tried to but been inconsistent in getting my flu shot, but now that I understand the human cost that's changed for me. It amazes me that people would be hesitant to get it and that there'd even be need to mandate it now. None of the same arguments can be made against the flu shot that can be made against the COVID vaccine (and in fact if we had yearly COVID vaccines those arguments would be moot there as well), but I'm sure we'd have a ton of vaccine deniers there, which really just proves it's ideology and feelings over any sort of real concern.
- md_ 5y agoIt would probably save lives _and_ lower the cost of healthcare. This is why many employers already offer free on-site "influence" (heh) shots for employees: it makes good business sense. I'm never sure how to take objections like yours, because there are certainly a few different things to discuss. Is your objection to the government's role in this (such that you'd be fine with private employers enforcing whatever mandates they wish)? Or are you objecting to the mandatory vaccination (in which case, what do you have against spitting into a vial once a week)? Or are you more of a technocrat, concerned that the ROI (in terms of, say, QUALYs, as economists like to put it) gained through these policies isn't worth the cost? All strike me as viable arguments, but it's always hard to tell which one is being put forward.
- tolmasky 5y agoIf we lived in a non-influenza world that suddenly experienced influenza for the first time, we would think it's crazy to not only allow, but many times encourage, sick employees to come to work and basically take out the entire office. It's like just committing to losing a week's worth of productivity across the board. One nice benefit of going more remote is that we can hopefully "personalize" the cold/flu experience vs. making it a de facto office-wide experience, and without the bizarre politics around vaccines/masks/sick-days/etc.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoOne would hope. My struggle previously with having a cold is that those can stick around for a week or two - until we set this new precedent for working from home I couldn't just disappear for a week because I didn't feel well so I'd inevitably take a day when it was especially bad, but then I'd come in and spread it around anyways.
- yourapostasy 5y agoI count myself extremely fortunate, as [knock on wood] I rarely get the flu. About once every 4 years on average, and most times when I get it, I'm through it in about 48-72 hours. And my clients are always very understanding and I'm able to still deliver while WFH, except in the very worst depths of about 12-24 hours. There has got to be some genetic component where others have it way worse than I do, and yet still others skate by even better than I do. We know far less about biology than we think we do.
- rmah 5y agoWhen I was a youth, most public schools mandated a variety of vaccinations. If you didn't get them, you couldn't go to school. Is that no longer the case?
- julianlam 5y agoThere are many exemptions that apply. Religious exemptions are one example.
- astura 5y agoSome states (including big ones like California and NY and conservative ones like Mississippi and West Virginia) have no exemptions to school vaccine requirements other than medical exemptions. https://www.ncsl.org/research/health/school-immunization-exemption-state-laws.aspx https://www.ncsl.org/research/health/school-immunization-exe...
- khuey 5y agoCalifornia used to have more exemptions and they were used heavily by new age/hippie types (i.e. not conservatives) to skirt vaccination requirements so the laws were changed recently.
- BackBlast 5y agoSince the change there have been a number of doctors willing to grant medical exemptions to any who want them. [0] It isn't as much of an impediment as it appears. [0] https://calmatters.org/health/2020/09/california-doctor-school-vaccination-exemptions/ https://calmatters.org/health/2020/09/california-doctor-scho...
- frumper 5y agoThe article you linked talks about a new law that invalidated those exemptions from that doctor because they were not supported by clinical guidelines.
- robmccoll 5y agoYeah what's next? Making other behaviors that have a small but established likelihood of endangering the lives of others or their property illegal at little to no cost to the liberty of an individual? Pretty soon I won't be able to drive my car under the influence, or without proper insurance, or while not wearing a seatbelt, or I won't be able to discharge my firearms in my 0.2 acre backyard in a suburban area. 650,000 people have died and that's with taking some pretty extreme precautions (for what we consider extreme anyway). It's not just the old or the infirm. Healthy people in their 20s and 30s. Toddlers. We have gone to war over much less. We have a ton of safety regulations that govern how we build homes and infrastructure, how we plan for fires and natural disasters, how you live your daily life, and pretty much anything else because they are effective and do save lives. This one seems reasonable (mandatory COVID vaccination - influenza vaccines are significantly less effective and in general the people that die from it society seems to be ok with).
- robmccoll 5y agoI really wish HN had a controversy upvote / downvote ratio - maybe multiplied by number of votes?
- disneygibson 5y agoYou really think those death numbers are accurate? There are a ton of incentives present (read: federal $$$) for hospitals and others to exaggerate death counts and case numbers.
- disneygibson 5y agoSo we should mandate everything that saves lives, no matter the cost to freedom or infringing of rights? This is the issue with technocratic government: zero understanding of anything deeper than “if it works, do it!”
- tomrod 5y agoIt's been a year this approach has been claimed. Time to roll up sleeves for your civic duty.
- anblp 5y agoAmerika, erwache! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturmlied https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturmlied
- boplicity 5y agoI am open to hearing a coherent description of the specific "cost to freedom" of taking one of the widely available COVID vaccines.
- disneygibson 5y agoI don’t think most people have an issue with voluntary vaccination. The problem is when nefarious actors use the situation to create a surveillance state, social credit system, and then exclude people from doing simple human things like eating at a restaurant. Australia is the future of the Western world.
- boplicity 5y ago> Surveillance state If that exists, it existed before COVID, and vaccinations against COVID certainly haven't changed that. > Social credit system Are you referring to mandates? These have been a thing, in the U.S., for many decades > exclude people from doing simple human things Vaccine mandates have excluded people from things far more important than restaurants, such as education, for many decades. This is not new to COVID. You seem to be arguing against a system that has existed for many, many years.
- jononomo 5y agoThis makes good sense and I fully support this idea. I'm also in favor of heavily taxing soda and beer.
- coin 5y agoHow is taxing soda, beer related to mandatory vaccines?
- TOMDM 5y agoReduces the likelihood of unhealthy outcomes. Excessive consumption of soda and beer have negative health consequences, and taxing them could lower consumption. It also doesn't have the contagious element that viruses do, but if you only care about the individual impact it's still a defensible position.
- rudolph9 5y agoThe flu doesn't overwhelm hospitals in recent history. Covid-19 regularly causes governors to declare state-of-emergency in order to care for the massive number of people who need medical attention due to the disease. I can't help but think like your comment is more intended provoke heated responses than encourage constructive discussion.
- oceanplexian 5y agoThe flu definitely overwhelms hospitals on a yearly basis. Try searching Google with a date filter before 2020 for hospital overcrowding and flu.
- HWR_14 5y agoThe flu definitely did something in 2017-2018 (although that was a standout year). However, that "overwhelming" was mostly dealt with by telling people to go home and take theraflu (and OTC medication). As in, literally a press at the ER/admitting, which resulted in people needing to be examined before they were turned away. And doctors/nurses had to work overtime to do that! But the ICU beds never got overwhelmed. In hospital treatment never failed. The response then was "if you have a flu, call your GP who will just prescribe you the medicine over the phone". The exact same situation that most non-COVID patients have been in for months.
- mardifoufs 5y agoHere in Quebec they were overwhelmed. Actually our hospitals were constantly at over 100% capacity, and were almost empty during most of the pandemic. Even at the peak of covid they weren't as full simply because most of the critical cases died in nursery homes or at home before reaching a hospital, thanks to the negligence of the government.
- astura 5y agoIf flu vaccines were paid for entirely by the government I'd imagine that mandating companies hold onsite influenza vaccine clinics yearly would be largely uncontroversial and fairly effective.
- Ekaros 5y agoQuestion is not availability but banning anyone without one from working.
- zxcvbn4038 5y agoSmoking kills 500,000 people per year in the US - which is only slightly less then COVID at current rates - I don't see anyone rushing to shut that down. Heart disease kills 650,000 per year, but there is still a McDonalds and Taco Bell on every corner.
- UncleMeat 5y agoThere are absolutely enormous anti-smoking adversing and education campaigns. Cigarettes are mandated by law to have very specific packaging that loudly lists the risk of death. Large taxes are placed on them. In a great many places you are not allowed to smoke in public. Smokers have higher health insurance premiums and cannot access certain kinds of medical care like various organ transplants. Selling a cigarette to a child is a crime. Exposing children to second hand smoke can be abuse. And yes, there are a large number of people who sue Cigarette manufacturers for their role in the deaths of these people with the attempt of completely destroying the industry.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lax4ever 5y agoThe difference being that people's general livelihoods are not being affected by these campaigns and requirements. The choice is still available to people even if there are restrictions on use and distribution. That is not the case with the vaccine.
- gilbetron 5y agoGo smoke where you work (assuming non-remote work!), and see if there are ramifications.
- UncleMeat 5y agoIn my state, if I work at a restaurant and I smoke indoors on the job that is against the law. A tremendous number of jobs ban indoor smoking among employees and will absolutely fire you if you don't comply.
- kuraudo 5y agoAs long as we mandate mandatory weight loss for all overweight citizens first.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoInfluenza is not shutting down the country and making us miserable. It's a much less disruptive disease. Just because you don't want to get a jab doesn't mean society should shut down for you. That's why this should be done through employers and other methods requiring you not participate if you won't participate in something to help society. If you don't want to get a jab don't work for them. Easy choice. Start your own Jab Free Lawn Service.
- halfjoking 5y agoThanks for the words of encouragement. After I lose my job I plan to be a company of 1 working on my SaaS or doing contract work... but I'm not confident that restrictions won't get harsher the more that people get vaxxed. The vaccines will work less and less, and the unvaxxed will be blamed more and more, leading to them being treated as criminals. At what point does the US government freeze my bank account? At 95%? 98% vaccinated? I'm planning to leave the country before then.