15 ms·
New details on silicon, subatomic particles and possible ‘fifth force’
- dexwiz 5y agoIf this came from almost any other group it would be an easy write off. But NIST really does have some of the best analytical chemists and physicists around.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoHeadline is misleading. The "new details" are of the sort "if there is a fifth force, you won't find it over here." > The scientists’ results improve constraints on the strength of a potential fifth force by tenfold over a length scale between 0.02 nanometers (nm, billionths of a meter) and 10 nm, giving fifth-force hunters a narrowed range over which to look. This is not surprising and it would be possible believe this sort of a thing from a variety of qualified groups.
- lilyball 5y agoI’m not sure what’s misleading about it. “If this force exists, you’ll find it in this range” seems to be a valuable detail to know when searching for this force. It feels to me like this is very similar to the trend of only caring about positive experiment results and thinking negative experiment results aren't interesting. But they are! Negative results are useful and give us information! And are often crucial contributions toward positive results from later experiments.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoIt is misleading because it suggests that they have found new signs, previously unknown, that such a force might exist, rather than new details that demote it from "possible with certain limitations" to "possible with narrower limitations". This is presumably why dexwis seemed to think that it was so remarkable and that it might easily be written off as too-fantastic.
- vagrantJin 5y ago> the trend of only caring about positive experiment results Probably starts in school. Negative results are just a loss of marks rather than a potential point of interest. Even if the lab report states that the results were unexpected and possible reasons given - it was an automatic fail. Never has it been considered, at least in my alma mata, that a negative result reasoned about might actually be interesting on its own and worth the time. Since aint nobody got time for that, said trend will probably continue for a long time.
- roywiggins 5y agoYes, technically it's not over there is a "New detail about a possible fifth force", but it's not exactly what first jumps to mind? Consider "New details about a possible Game of Thrones book release date" being a similarly unsatisfactory headline if the article content is "it's not in the next 12 months". Technically true, that is a new detail, but is it really what the headline implies?
- jcranberry 5y agoI think that's not the best example since it is assumed this book is eventually coming out. Maybe if it was "New details about a possible Game of Thrones seasons 5-8 do-over" essentially being "no plans in the next 12 months".
- roywiggins 5y agoThe consensus that WoW will ever come out has frayed substantially https://www.reddit.com/r/books/comments/k4xubh/have_we_as_a_society_given_up_completely_on/ https://www.reddit.com/r/books/comments/k4xubh/have_we_as_a_...
- sidlls 5y agoA constraint on the domain and range of values is a detail. Restricting the possible range of action for a force is certainly something physicists look for.
- roywiggins 5y agoIt absolutely is very interesting science, but the headline is arguably misleading. It's like saying "we have learned new things about where the body is buried" after searching an area and not finding the body: it's absolutely true, but misleading.
- sidlls 5y agoNo, it isn’t misleading at all. Narrowing a constraint is learning something new. It could very well have gone the other way. Or in a way completely unexpected.
- dylan604 5y agoIsn't this pretty much the description of how the Higgs Bosun was found? Fermilab kept finding where it wasn't, narrowing in on where it could be, so that the first time LHC looked it pretty much looked directly at it. Just because an expirement doesn't find the proof of, the proof of it not is also valuable.
- retbull 5y agoFrom what I read in this article they didn't prove that the force exists at all they actually showed that it wasn't present in several areas. This helps other people who are doing experiments in the area by cutting down on the range of sizes they need to look in for it but it doesn't provide evidence for its existence.
- analog31 5y agoIndeed, and in addition, their research programs focus on improving the science and technology behind making measurements. So they have the best metrologists around too.
- wolverine876 5y agoThat's impossible. I've learned that only super-wealthy capitalists can accomplish anything.
- LeegleechN 5y agoThe headline is misleading. The work tightened the range of possible strengths of a fifth force by a factor of 10. In other words it ruled out the existence of a fifth force within a wide range of parameters that were previously open.
- kibwen 5y agoNote that the original article's headline is "Groundbreaking Technique Yields Important New Details on Silicon, Subatomic Particles and Possible ‘Fifth Force’" (which is too long for HN), which makes it clear that the focus is on the technique. It's the abbreviated HN title that sort of makes it sound as though the focus is on the force.
- criticaltinker 5y agoIt seems like the title length constraint on HN is a bit too limiting and often results in these types of clarifying comments. Couldn’t we expect more accurate and higher quality titles by relaxing the length constraint? I’m sure it’s been discussed before here, but I’m struggling to think of downsides from such a change.
- nl 5y agoIt would involve a change to HN. There's still no mobile friendly stylesheet. I wouldn't hold your breath.
- Cederfjard 5y agoI mostly read HN on my phone and I think the experience is fine. So maybe there’s just not enough demand on that front.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoPeople have been clamoring for mobile friendly blockquote for a while.
- Raineer 5y agoAs a Boulderite and a huge fan of NIST, I am bummed out that the misleading headline does come from NIST itself and not an overzealous contributor. Exciting results, all the same.
- blondin 5y agowait, how is what they wrote misleading?
- redis_mlc 5y agoBecause there's no fifth force.
- prutschman 5y agoIt's not literally false, but I got an inaccurate impression based on the headline. To me it implied a positive discovery of evidence rather than a ruling-out. If they'd said "determined new constraints on a hypothetical 5th force" or something I would have gotten a correct impression.
- potatoman22 5y agoI've always wondered why there has to be a discrete number of forces, rather than it being a spectrum describing types of interactions.
- macksd 5y agoThere may not have to be, as far as we know. From the Wikipedia page[1]: Many theoretical physicists believe these fundamental forces to be related and to become unified into a single force at very high energies on a minuscule scale, the Planck scale, but particle accelerators cannot produce the enormous energies required to experimentally probe this. Devising a common theoretical framework that would explain the relation between the forces in a single theory is perhaps the greatest goal of today's theoretical physicists. The weak and electromagnetic forces have already been unified with the electroweak theory of Sheldon Glashow, Abdus Salam, and Steven Weinberg for which they received the 1979 Nobel Prize in physics. Some physicists seek to unite the electroweak and strong fields within what is called a Grand Unified Theory (GUT). An even bigger challenge is to find a way to quantize the gravitational field, resulting in a theory of quantum gravity (QG) which would unite gravity in a common theoretical framework with the other three forces. Some theories, notably string theory, seek both QG and GUT within one framework, unifying all four fundamental interactions along with mass generation within a theory of everything (ToE). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_interaction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_interaction
- akamoonknight 5y agoAnother related thing I've wondered is if, similar to how the possible electroweak force un-unified into the electromagnetic force and the weak force, is there a scenario where the electromagnetic force (or the weak force) un-unifies into some other sub force ? So I guess like the reverse of the GUT.
- _Microft 5y agoSounds like you mean electrostatics and magnetostatics.
- sroussey 5y agoActual title: Groundbreaking Technique Yields Important New Details on Silicon, Subatomic Particles and Possible ‘Fifth Force’
- sroussey 5y ago“A vastly improved understanding of the crystal structure of silicon, the ‘universal’ substrate or foundation material on which everything is built, will be crucial in understanding the nature of components operating near the point at which the accuracy of measurements is limited by quantum effects,” said NIST senior project scientist Michael Huber.
- monocasa 5y ago> Each neutron in an atomic nucleus is made up of three elementary particles called quarks. Well and tons and tons of virtual particles popping in and out of existance. Only a little over 1% the mass of a neutron is the three quarks normally listed.
- tomrod 5y agoI love that our fundamental reality is built on virtual particles. Physics rocks!
- JackFr 5y agoI love that our mental model of reality is built on virtual particles. Metaphysics rocks!
- hongsy 5y ago> Only a little over 1% the mass of a neutron is the three quarks normally listed. Do you have a source for this?
- monocasa 5y agoYou can add up the mass of one up quark (2.2MeV) and two down quarks (4.7MeV each) and compare that to the mass of a neutron (939.565MeV)
- blobster 5y agohttps://www.newscientist.com/article/dn16095-its-confirmed-matter-is-merely-vacuum-fluctuations/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn16095-its-confirmed-m...
- cwillu 5y agohttps://profmattstrassler.com/articles-and-posts/particle-physics-basics/the-structure-of-matter/protons-and-neutrons/ https://profmattstrassler.com/articles-and-posts/particle-ph... has a very good explanation.
- amerine 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rossjudson 5y agoIt's love, right? I saw the movie.
- tiborsaas 5y agoIt's a confusing force. When two particles interact via love they possess this fore which always equate to 1LUV. Tragedy is that it's unstable and one always has more than the other, 50:50 split is rarely seen. It's even possible that during an interaction one can have all the love and the other none and they still bind together in a way.
- loloquwowndueo 5y agoFifth force? So … water, fire, earth, air and what else??? :)
- aemreunal 5y ago...and love.
- Cats_In_Love 5y agoNice.
- KyleBrandt 5y agoPardon the comment noise, but I can't help but highlight that "Fifth Force of Nature" is an excellent name for a band.
- niccl 5y agoQuintessence. That's what it means: '(In Ancient and Medieval philosophy) ether, the fifth and highest essence or element after earth air, water and fire, which was thought to be the constituent matter of the heavenly bodies and latent in all things. [C15 via French from Medieval Latin 'quinta essentia' the fifth essence] From Collins English Dictionary
- kordlessagain 5y agoAether
- scotty79 5y agostupidity I always treated stupidity as a fifth element that can bring great and surprising tragedies to humanity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Cats_In_Love 5y agoI understand the interest in a fifth force is to explain the dark matter/dark energy anomaly discovered by the astronomer Vera Rubin. The orbital velocities of stars at increasing radii (radiuses?) from the center can't be accounted for by the current understanding of gravity and visible matter.
- pharke 5y ago>“Generally, if there’s a force carrier, the length scale over which it acts is inversely proportional to its mass,” How does this apply to gravity, if at all?
- svenpeter 5y agoIt’s been a while since my last physics lectures so this might be wrong, but the way i understand it: We don’t have a good model of quantum gravity yet but our best guess is that the force carrier of gravity might be a particle called graviton. This hypothetical particle has no mass and therefore the length scale of gravity would be infinite. This matches the Newtonian and the general relativity model of gravity. This is different from the source of gravity which would be the (gravitational) mass of an object (or more accurately the components of the stress energy tensor which describe the density and flux of energy but that’s also the point where I have to start with the hand waving because my knowledge becomes very fuzzy there) It’s also true for the electromagnetic interaction: the force carrier here is the photon which is also massless and the length scale is also infinite here.
- betterunix2 5y agoThat is the big question in physics today! There is the hypothetical "graviton" which, as you should expect, has zero mass. There are theoretical problems due to the poorly understood interaction of general relativity and quantum mechanics -- if you could resolve those problems you would have a "theory of everything."
- kazinator 5y agoPardon my following likely idiotic statement from a layperson, but the surprising matter of the charge distribution within the neutron suggests that the nuclear "weak force" is actually just electrostatic force. So that is to say, if the neutron is slightly negative near the surface, what if that's the entire basis of the force that makes neutrons able to bind protons in the atom nucleus. We would expect this to be a kind of dipole whose field drops off rapidly with distance.
- LegitShady 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroweak_interaction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electroweak_interaction
- thayne 5y agoFirst of all, the nucleus is held together by the strong nuclear force, not the weak nuclear force (the weak force causes certain kinds of decay, such as a neutron to decay into a proton and electron). Secondly, as soon as you have multiple protons, the repulsion from the positive charges will be much, much greater than any dipole attraction. Finally, physicists have done a lot of really precise measurements with subatomic particles, and I don't think a dipole interaction like that would match the observed results.
- kazinator 5y agoRight! The strong nuclear force is over two orders of magnitude stronger than electromagnetism, so it cannot be caused by it. It has to be, in order overcome the vehement repulsion among the protons.
- betterunix2 5y agoActually the relationship between the weak nuclear force and the electromagnetic force is well understood. It would have to be related, given that the weak interaction is the cause of beta decay, which results in a neutron becoming a proton (which has a positive electromagnetic charge) and the creation of an electron (which has a negative charge). The force carrying particles of the weak force can also have electromagnetic charge, further demonstrating the connection between the two phenomena. You can reason about all the forces being related in some way. For example, beta decay happens in free neutrons, but does not happen in a helium-4 nucleus; there should be a connection with the strong nuclear force that explains this. In some sense the fact that we can observe or measure an interaction implies that it must be related to other forces, since our ability to make an observation is itself dependent on such connections (in the end you need some electromagnetic effect that your eyes can perceive).
- Yaggo 5y agoIn school, 25 years ago, I was taught the "circling balls" atomic model and for me physics seemed kind of boring and very stable field of science, like we already knew almost everything. Nowadays, thanks to superb youtube channels[1], I've learnt that we are rather in the beginning of the journey of solving the mystery of universum, and the reality is much more exciting than those boring "circling balls"; actually there are no balls at all but just "fields" (which of course is also just a mental model). [1] E.g. https://www.youtube.com/user/TheScienceAsylum https://www.youtube.com/user/TheScienceAsylum
- hutzlibu 5y agoTo me it seemed as well, that my physics teachers mindset was unchanged and frozen to the classical deterministic physic mindset of prequantum discoveries. It was actually believed in 18xx), that theoretical physics was allmost solved. But somehow this very wrong idea prevailed and made it to my school as well.
- codeulike 5y agoIt's deliberate, you get taught different models of the atom etc the deeper you get into physics/chemistry. In that way you also learn about models and the scientific method and how the advances have been made. In the same way that Newtonian physics is still useful for a lot of stuff, the circling balls model of the atom can still be useful in some areas
- UncleSlacky 5y ago"All models are wrong, but some are useful".
- 52-6F-62 5y agoI don't think it's the process so much as the outlook that's taught to younger students that the disapproval comes from. It's presented as a much smaller frame of study than it really is. And often it's treated so mechanistically, that rather than teaching you how understanding is important and will feed into your very worldview it's presented as something you study if you want to build assembling machines or something. My and OP's gripes might be more endemic to underfunded midwestern rural schools like I attended, but I'm sure it wasn't that rare, unfortunately.
- edumucelli 5y agoIt makes me wonder that infinite things are still "hidden" from our understanding. As the silicon is widely used on our modern society we have spent enough time studying its properties. What about other materials, there is potentially an "universe" on everything and that is incredible.
- kordlessagain 5y agoSee http://ayuba.fr/mach_effect/estes_park/ssi_estes_park_proceedings_tajmar.pdf http://ayuba.fr/mach_effect/estes_park/ssi_estes_park_procee...