11 ms·
As a part-time libertarian, one of the frustrating parts of the pandemic has been discovering how many people need the nanny state to step to stop them punching
by michaelt 5y ago
As a part-time libertarian, one of the frustrating parts of the pandemic has been discovering how many people need the nanny state to step to stop them punching themselves in the face.
Near the start of the pandemic, I thought the most intrusive state powers would barely be needed. Why would you ever need to make a vaccine mandatory? What rational person would refuse a lifesaving medicine offered to them for free?
Well, I've got my answer.
- rajin444 5y ago> What rational person would refuse a lifesaving medicine offered to them for free? Somebody who has already had covid. They've already taken on risk - why expose themselves to more? Your argument of people acting rational breaks down in a lot of cases. Plenty of people have self destructive behaviors (many with externalities that affect others) that we are ok with.
- Daishiman 5y agoWhat risk? You literally expose yourself to more risk driving to work than with getting any vaccine.
- fanf2 5y agoIf you've had COVID, a vaccine can help with Long COVID symptoms, and it can reduce the risk of reinfection, so it's still better to be vaccinated than to catch COVID a second time.
- Ancapistani 5y agoThe vaccine reportedly can also trigger a more severe immune response in people who already have naturally-acquired antibodies. Try to find good statistics on the rates and severity of adverse reactions for people who have already have COVID. I've had very little success.
- herbst 5y agoThis. And generally the possibility of more severe immune responses after vaxing. (Like with dengue for example) It is obvious these are a problem, and it's obvious we do not talk a out that right now. Saying the vaccine is a perfect solution that will solve all our issues is just dellusional
- enkid 5y agoThere is no evidence of that with this vaccine, and with the number of people who have received it we would have collected that evidence by now, so stop spreading hypotheticals.
- herbst 5y agoThis is not something you usually notice until years into using it. Even the heart inflammation thing did not show in studies and only months after vaxing, and instead of more severe immune responses on infection this is something that happens immediately and not years later. This is all just loud thinking at this point. But it's something you regularly find new studies too because it seems to be a concern.
- enkid 5y agoThe reason the heart inflammation think didn't show up is because of how rare it is, not the amount of time passed. If the issue you are talking about is that rare, than my argument still stands. As to something appearing years later, that seems extremely rare and could happen without getting the vaccine, just being exposed again to the virus. Oh, and neither of us are the people that should be evaluating that because we aren't medical researchers who have closely studied the incidents of vaccines causing reactions years later. I will trust the people who have extensively studied the problem.
- acdha 5y agoBy now, the COVID vaccines have been given to an extremely large sample size so even very rare side-effects would be known by now. Similarly, because vaccines train your own immune system without staying in your body, it’s extremely unlikely for a side-effect to be delayed in time for more than weeks. Note the timeframes on the relevant historical examples: https://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/concerns/concerns-history.html https://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/concerns/concerns-history....
- UncleMeat 5y agoThe additional risk is nearly-zero and vaccination provides additional protection even in cases of prior infection.
- LatteLazy 5y agoI feel exactly the same
- threatofrain 5y agoPunching yourself in the face, or nanny state discussions, is more akin to something like a seat belt law. We have seat belt laws to stop the individual from hurting themselves, not because we're afraid they're going to launch out as a projectile and hurt others. But vaccination is a community thing more than an individual thing. If it were just about hurting yourself, then I'd agree that the discussion should be framed as paternal.
- michaelt 5y agoYou're absolutely right - getting vaccinated protects your family, your community, and your country. What I mean by punching yourself in the face is: Even if you don't have any family and you hate your neighbours, getting vaccinated is still in your own interests, because it stops you dying.
- nradov 5y agoI encourage everyone to get vaccinated if they can, but it's unclear what community protection that provides. Vaccinated people can still get infected and spread the virus. They may be contagious for a shorter period on average but the magnitude is still unknown. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02187-1 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02187-1 Since the Delta variant is so contagious there will be no significant herd immunity effect to protect the unvaccinated. The virus is now endemic and can't be eradicated so all of us can expect to be exposed multiple times throughout our lives. https://www.businessinsider.com/delta-variant-made-herd-immunity-not-possible-astrazeneca-developer-2021-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/delta-variant-made-herd-immu...
- lamontcg 5y agoVaccination almost certainly reduces transmission. https://www.timesofisrael.com/80-of-vaccinated-covid-carriers-didnt-spread-virus-in-public-spaces-report/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/80-of-vaccinated-covid-carrier... RNA levels spike to the same levels on PCR, but they decline faster, and culturable amounts of virus are lower in breakthrough infections, indicating a higher proportion of viral debris in breakthrough infections rather than virus: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.20.21262158v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.20.21262158v... Even if you take the worst numbers out there vaccines still eliminate 50% of infections. And symptomology, viral load and transmissibility are correlated -- which means the vaccines is likely to be effictatious against transmissibility just like it is against disease. The worst-case idea that breakthrough infections, even though they're much less severe, produce identical risk of transmission does not make any sense at all. I would bet money that if everyone was vaccinated that the R0 of delta would be less than 1.0 and we would not have epidemic spread and that breakthrough superspreaders are incredibly rare.
- betterunix2 5y ago...that is why I could never be a libertarian. People have repeatedly proved themselves unwilling or unable to live up to the libertarian ideal of behaving "rationally."
- amelius 5y agoEven rational actors can ruin things deeply. E.g. government intervention is necessary to have network-neutrality.
- fighterpilot 5y agoThere's nothing inherently inconsistent between right-libertarian values and a vaccine mandate. Libertarians believe that force should be applied to person A to protect person B from person A in certain circumstances. If person A wants to punch person B in the face, restricting person A by force is perfectly consistent with libertarian values. If person A threatens to infect person B with a deadly disease due to refusing a vaccine, then a vaccine mandate has some justification under the same ideals. The devil will be in the details (e.g., how deadly is the disease, etc). It's also why a carbon tax and many other measures are not inherently inconsistent with libertarian values on a first principles examination. But for some reason, libertarians in practice tend to dislike these policy proposals, even though they can follow in principle from the founding axioms. I attribute that to group-think and a general disbelief in the existence of negative externalities, not to a problem inherent in libertarianism.
- pharmakom 5y agoPeople are libertarian for different reasons. Some of them just hate government and look for an ideological framework to justify it. I would say that driving licenses are a similar case.
- simonh 5y agoExcept that you don't need a driving license to drive, only to do so on public roads. These mandates are similar, you can be as un-vaccinated as you like as long as you stay at home.
- version_five 5y agoI'm a libertarian and I think choices should be up to the individual, because it's never ok to have a political group decide for you what is good or bad. It's antithetical to western liberalism. My rant aside, I think there are better and worse ways to infringe on people's liberty when needed. And given the way the winds are blowing, it would be much better to enforce vaccination at the federal level, i.e. compel people by law to get it. There can be exemption of course, but the point is it becomes between you and the state. The current patchwork creates all kinds of disparity, invades privacy be repeatedly making you tell others about your health and identify yourself, and burdens businesses and others with enforcement. It also lets the government avoid the ire of people who don't want a mandate, by moving the front lines of enforcement elsewhere. I think business and local level mandates are more popular because they play on people's desire to punish the unvaccinated, instead of working positively to tackle covid.
- kxyvr 5y agoI think part of the difficulty with the libertarian point of view regarding the COVID vaccine is that not all parties are given a free choice either. For example, if someone refuses a vaccine, should an emergency room be free to refuse care? Currently, they can not due to EMTALA. That's not to say that it's unreasonable to question and philosophize the implications of a mandate. At the same time, barring a more effective plan, the implications of not having a mandate seem particularly horrific. All the same, I do agree with you that if there is to be a mandate, that it's best to come from the federal government to create a uniform set of guidelines. I also agree that the patchwork of rules has been a mess.
- teeray 5y ago> should an emergency room be free to refuse care? Let’s say instead of “unvaccinated” that they’re actually wildly radioactive and suffering radiation poisoning. Should we treat that person, or turn them away because they could irradiate the ER?
- KingOfCoders 5y ago"For example, if someone refuses a vaccine, should an emergency room be free to refuse care?" No we shouldn't, we don't turn people away who drove drunken with 200km/h and crashed.
- nostromo 5y agoMy takeaway is the opposite: I'm pleasantly surprised with how many people are vaccinated, and how quickly. It's hard to get 2/3rds of Americans to agree on just about anything. When you look at the hold-outs, it's largely young people who are at very low risk of serious illness. (85% of 65 and older are vaccinated, but just 57% of people 18-29.) So it makes sense to me that they are more hesitant.
- not2b 5y agoNo, it's only been hard to get 2/3 of Americans to go along quite recently. Everyone lined up for vaccines in the 1950s and 1960s, numbers well over 90%.
- Gibbon1 5y agoConsider that in 1955 one of the companies producing the Salk Vaccine shipped 120,000 doses with live virus which sickened 40,000 children and sparked a polio epidemic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cutter_Laboratories#Cutter_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cutter_Laboratories#Cutter_inc...
- adriancr 5y agoAnd yet numbers were still 90%+, so what does that say about their views on vaccine usefulness?
- herbst 5y agoOr does it just tell the story of a time without easily accessible open media?
- adriancr 5y agoFair, although I could look at that open media as propaganda/brainwashing and reach a conclusion on media's effectiveness. I can also look at the past and ask if vaccines eradicated the diseases it was meant for... and for that it was incredibly effective.
- swayvil 5y agoBut some of us see it differently. You are telling me that I am not allowed to disagree with you.
- angelzen 5y agoThere are vaccines. Everyone that wants a vaccine already got it or can easily get it. People say they are extremely good at eliminate severe covid, that's what I got one myself. But at this point taking a vaccine or not is a personal decision. People are punching themselves in the face all the time, see obesity crisis for example. Should we ban hamburgers & fries next?
- setum 5y agoyes, if obesity were contagious.
- angelzen 5y agoIf only vaccines were to prevent covid spread. 'CDC: COVID-19 Vaccines 66% Effective Against Delta Variant'. https://www.webmd.com/vaccines/covid-19-vaccine/news/20210825/cdc-covid-19-vaccines-66-percent-effective-against-delta-variant https://www.webmd.com/vaccines/covid-19-vaccine/news/2021082...
- standardUser 5y agoWhat point are you trying to make? And why do you think a link to a single study without explanation would prove any point whatsoever?
- angelzen 5y agoThat according to CDC data 1/3 of vax people are going to develop an infection. There is no way to purge covid infections from the population, not even with 100% vax rate. In a population 67% vaccinated or higher, there are going to be more vax infections than unvax infections. At which point choosing to vax oneself or not is not going to keep covid from spreading and becomes a personal choice. If you are an adult, would do you good to get vaxed. But seems strange that the OP claimed to be 'libertarian' and yet in favour of forced vax. There is a big difference between 'this is what I think would do you good, but I'm going to respect your decision regardless' and 'get vaxed or else' position so many have embraced of late.
- muttantt 5y agoIf something is free, you are the product.
- cmsj 5y agoAir is free.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoLots of stuff is free without someone being a product. I can make art for free if I really put my mind to it, and leave it in the forest for others to possibly enjoy.
- benf76 5y agoAir isn’t manufactured by a corporation.
- roenxi 5y ago(1) It is population level rational to have diversity. Sometimes acting irrationally has payoffs because something wildly unexpected happens. (2) There is an almost endless list of things people do that are to their detriment. A core part of libertarianism is that people have to be free to make their own mistakes. We don't mandate exercise, prudent spending, safe sex practices or sensible family planning. The reasons to mandate vaccination are not robust enough to justify mandating that either. Although I think it is humourous that the "my body my choice" slogan is being studiously avoided by both wings of politics at the moment.
- cmsj 5y agoavoiding exercise doesn't cause people around you to get fatter though.
- roenxi 5y agoAnd everyone is going to get coronavirus sooner or later, regardless of how vaccinated the population is. Because if the virus was stopped dead by vaccination then it wouldn't matter what other people did, and if it isn't then ... vaccines aren't going to stop you catching it eventually. Besides, there have been crazy ideas floated like making an issue out of vaccinating people who have already had & recovered from COVID. They're less likely to spread the coronavirus around than any other demographic.
- croon 5y ago> Because if the virus was stopped dead by vaccination then it wouldn't matter what other people did, and if it isn't then ... vaccines aren't going to stop you catching it eventually. I'm not sure if you chose this binary line of thinking or if it was by accident, but you present the outcomes based on a 0 or 100% efficacy when it's not the case. It matters/ed what other people do, and if more people got vaccinated (or could do so earlier) it might've stopped covid. Whether it could now is a crap-shoot, but more protection is always better than less.
- 5y ago
- bserge 5y agoWhy not let them? A lot of things can only be learned through hardship.
- cmsj 5y agoThere are two things a vaccine can do - protect you, or protect society. Their greatest benefit is when they protect society by dampening the spread/severity of a pathogen to a level low enough that society can function essentially normally. If a sizeable chunk of the population chooses not to participate in that collective action, they endanger themselves (which can be argued is their fair choice), but also those around them who are unable to take the vaccine. There is no individualist refusal to vaccinate, the effect is still collective, just in a negative direction.
- csomar 5y agoThe whole point of democracy and freedom is that you convince people with words and not with sticks. If people are refusing a vaccine, that means you (as the political class, media class, scientific class) have failed your job to educate a segment of your population. It is easy to blame people for what could be your shortcomings. But this is not 5% or 10% of your population, it seems to be around 40-50%. This is more of a crisis of faith on both public and private institutions and it certainly doesn't get fixed with sticks and by removing more rights (and thus reinforcing the believes that made these people refuse the vaccine in the first place).
- enkid 5y agoIt doesn't help that major components of the "political class" are being the biggest babies and spreading straight up disinformation. Sure, we shouldn't have to have a mandate, but we are now at the point where it makes no sense not to have one and people can't see that because they are being routinely lied to by people that have the vaccine and by organizations that have the mandate.
- csomar 5y ago> It doesn't help that major components of the "political class" are being the biggest babies and spreading straight up disinformation. Again, this is your shortcoming. It doesn't get fixed by forcing people to have something injected inside of them and have their movement restricted by sanitary passports.
- croon 5y agoWhere does personal responsibility come into the equation? You say it's someone else's fault they haven't educated someone, but that someone has to carry some responsibility on being receptive and to evaluate information, no? Being persuaded and being informed are hopefully related, but demonstrably different.
- enkid 5y agoThis is not "my" shortcoming. This is a shortcoming of the system that we have to make up for in some way, like having a vaccine mandate.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cortic 5y agoThe problem with free choice is that people often make the wrong choice. -The Chinese Communist Party and Michaelt the Libertarian.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hulitu 5y ago> What rational person would refuse a lifesaving medicine offered to them for free? Every rational person. If i gave you a free medicine (drugs for example) will you take it ? The problem was that the political class undermined all trust in vaccination: promising more liberties to vaccinated people, contradicting the responsible state agencies ( this was the worse they could do), pouring money in Pharma companies and then buying their products ( looks like corruption), lying that the vaccines have been tested but in reality they had express approval, dismissing other vaccines ( Sputnik) for political reasons and forcing the people in a so called lockdown which (except in some countries) had no effect on the pandemic because the measures were pure propaganda (for example the child must stay in quarantine but the rest of the family, not)
- Ekaros 5y agoNot to forget not standing to higher moral standard by going beyond and above in showing example.
- jaybrendansmith 5y agoFor the same reason that, in a completely libertarian society, people will not buy police insurance and fire insurance and thus provide financial support for a police force and fire company. It's too idealistic and shows the limits of the invisible hand. Governments specialize in risk externalities and black swan events, and COVID-19 falls under both of these scenarios. What's clear from all this is that pandemics and wars show the weakness in the Libertarian philosophy and yes, giving government this kind of power is both dangerous and necessary. "If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary." - Federalist 51, Alexander Hamilton.
- busymom0 5y agoList of folks who refuse it: 1. Young, healthy and fit people who don't have any prior medical conditions. I checked the stats in Canada and I have a lot more chances of dying in a car accident than COVID in my age group. 2. Minorities who have had very bad treatment by the medical community in the past. Numerous examples of blacks, Latin Americans, indigenous being used for experiments. 3. Similar to point 2, anyone who's low income and therefore had poor treatment by the medical community. 4. Everyone who's already gotten natural infection immunity. There's numerous studies of this being much stronger and longer lasting. While they also say that an extra vaccine might boost the immunity slightly more too, there's very little benefit imo, especially if you are already young and healthy. 5. Many vaccinated folks also oppose vaccine mandates because that requires disclosing personal information. Quebec's vaccine passport app already got hacked including name, date of birth, IP address and which vaccines. And the Quebec government was very dismissive of this whole thing too which didn't instil any confidence in them. Vaccine mandates are also opposed by many in the minority community as they know this is just another reason which will cause more law enforcement actions. Here's Aba & Preach, 2 of the largest black YouTubers of Canada, explaining why they oppose such vaccine mandates even though they themselves are vaccinated. They explain how historical poor and unethical treatment explains why many minorities or those from poor families are skeptic of the health care institutions: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k6yHSIqsT9g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k6yHSIqsT9g https://youtu.be/Kt1FsXdrX5I https://youtu.be/Kt1FsXdrX5I So there's many reasons of not getting the irreversible, non-long term tested, declining efficacy and short lasting vaccine. There's no guarantees of how many boosters and how often they will be required. Israel is already talking about the 4th booster shot. Also this whole mandate thing just makes the public even more accepting of more surveillance.
- kcplate 5y agoI personally know several POC who chose not to get vaccinated because the CDC suggested at one point that for “social justice” reasons that POC should be vaccinated first. A rapidly developed vaccine using new experimental tech, with an emergency use approval…and someone in our government suggests that the black folks should line up first. Talk about clueless.
- UncleMeat 5y agoThe vaccines were as close to a literal miracle as I've ever seen in my life. We got several different vaccines that worked within a year of the pandemic hitting. There was no guarantee that we'd ever get working vaccines, let alone so many so fast. Depressing that it wasn't enough.
- Markoff 5y agoBecause it's not lifesaving medicine for them? Vaccines are lifesaving for old and obese, not so much for anyone else who is pretty much at zero risk from COVID, yet most of the people are harassed with restrictions and forced vaccination if they don't wanna be discriminated for being healthy and taking care of their health unlike obese filling hospitals.
- archontes 5y agoThis and the existence of commons are the primary issues with libertarianism. If you want to build a system as large as 300,000,000 people, you need some way to control the dynamics of that system so that outliers don't cause catastrophes, and the larger the system, the more extreme the outliers you'll encounter.
- Dwelve 5y agoYes, that is a fantastic argument. Better have someone else come in that is many times stronger than you and punch you in the face. Great solution!